Presentation given online by Professor Rebecca Ferguson at the 4th Annual International Conference on Research and Innovation In Education held at the University of Nairobi, Kenya, on 26 October 2022.
1. 1
Professor Rebecca Ferguson
The Open University, UK
AICRIE: 26 October 2022
Innovative
Pedagogies
appropriate for emerging and
low IT-resourced contexts
2. 2
Institute of Educational Technology, The Open University, UK
iet.open.ac.uk/projects/skills-for-prosperity-kenya
7. 7
A critical perspective
Digital inequality
Using artificial
intelligence (AI)
to write essays
Remote
surveillance and
proctoring
8. 8
Extending learning possibilities
• From learner to earner Skills for employment and career development
• Taking our place in society Developing responsible citizens
• Building our community Changing perspectives, opening opportunities
• Healthy mind, healthy body Developing the whole person
• Questioning and learning Building minds
• Developing global citizens Creating a better world
10. 10
Innovating Pedagogy
We propose a long list of new
educational terms, theories, and
practices.
We then pare these down to ten
that have the potential to provoke
major shifts in educational practice.
Lastly, we draw on published and
unpublished writings to compile ten
sketches of pedagogies that might
transform education.
12. 12
Computational thinking
Each area of the curriculum is
associated with a set of skills that
can be applied throughout our
life, giving us new ways to
understand the world. In the case
of computing, as we learn its
principles and languages, we also
acquire a set of problem-solving
skills. Together, these are known
as Computational Thinking.
Using techniques from computing to solve problems in many areas
13. 13
Computational thinking
Decomposition Breaking a large problem
down into smaller ones
Pattern recognition Recognising how these
smaller problems relate to ones that have
been solved in the past
Abstraction Identifying and setting aside
unimportant details
Algorithm design Identifying and refining
the steps necessary to reach a solution
Debugging Refining those steps
Presenting a solution in a usable form
Researchers who have
investigated how children
engage with the
programming environment
Scratch have identified skills
and shifts in perspective
related to computational
thinking: experimenting &
iterating, testing &
debugging, reusing &
remixing, abstracting &
modularising, expressing,
connecting and questioning.
https://scratch.mit.edu/
14. 14
Seeking the truth
Epistemic Aims and Value Goals and values that
drive cognition and action.These include wanting to
know, seeking the truth, and avoiding error.
Epistemic Ideals Criteria people use to decide
whether they have achieved their epistemic aims.
These can also be used to evaluate other people’s
epistemic products, such as arguments and websites.
Reliable Epistemic Processes Strategies that
enable the achievement of epistemic aims. Even
though truth is hard to achieve, a reliable process is
more likely than other processes to get to the truth.
Epistemic = Relating to knowledge or to the degree of its validation
15. 15
Seeking the truth
• Expose learners to the diversity of
knowledge
• Help them to develop epistemic criteria
• Support development of reliable
strategies for making sense of the
world
• Encourage learners to reflect on their
assumptions
• Motivate learners to care about truth
and knowledge
Resources
available on
BBC Bitesize
16. 16
Threshold concepts
Concepts that learners struggle to understand.
They may be
• transformative: they shift a learner’s perceptions of
a subject
• irreversible: once learned, they are hard to unlearn
• integrative: they expose the inter-relatedness of
some things
• bounded: they border with other threshold concepts
to define a disciplinary area
• troublesome: they appear difficult and unintuitive
An example is
inertia. An object
in motion will
continue in
motion unless an
external force
acts on it. This
goes against the
‘common sense’
notion that it will
stop when it runs
out of energy.
18. 18
Making thinking visible
Response systems enable
• Students to ask questions
• Educators to collect answers
Software enables
• Creation of models, videos, or
texts that bring together audio,
images and video
• Dialogue and interaction
Augmented reality enables
• Creation of holograms, or objects
that can be used in a virtual space
When thinking is visible, it
can be used by teachers to
adapt teaching and provide
feedback and by learners to
make more informed
decisions about their study.
Photo by Oscar Omondi on Unsplash
19. 19
Making thinking visible
Five phases
1. Ensuring learners understand the
purpose of the approach.
2. Creating purposeful questions or
tasks.
3. Setting a deadline for responses.
4. Analysing responses.
5. Presenting responses to learners
and adapting learning activities to
take responses into account.
Just-in-time teaching
Using digital tools to make
student thinking visible before
class, so activities can meet
their learning need.
Questions and assignments
are given before class.
21. 21
Innovating Pedagogy 2022
Combining
movement and
conversation to
enhance learning
Walk and talk
Maximising
learning
opportunities and
flexibility
Hybrid models
Promoting
wellbeing in all
areas of teaching
and learning
Wellbeing
education
Accredited short
courses to
develop
workplace skills
Microcredentials
Title page. Title is ‘Innovative Pedagogies appropriate for emerging and low IT-resourced contexts. Talk give n by Rebecca Ferguson of The Open University UC to AICRIE on 26 October 2022. Images of a lightbulb and the logo of the University of Nairpbi
Image of the Institute of Educational Technology, The Open University, UK, where the speaker is based. It is a colourful modern building surrounded by flowers.
Covers of nine Innovating Pedagogy reports. They all have a band of color with the title, the year and the authors, logo of The Open University and any collaborating institutions, and a picture of people learning, usually using technology.
Divider slide: Why look for the next big ideas?
Slide is headed ‘Preparing for the Future’ and includes titles and images of jobs that might exist in 2020. The jobs are from careers2030.cst.org/jobs
Jobs are: healthcare navigator, wearable technology therapist, robot counsellor, garbage designer, agile supply chain worker, rewilder, digital currency provider, digital memorialist and urban farmer.
The pictures are generic, for example the one for robot counsellor shows a robot’s head.
Heading is rapid change. Examples given here are Siri in 2011, the year of the MOOC in 2012, Alexa in 2013, Sudtainable Development Goals in 2016 and COVID in 2019/
Pictures for each of these add interest but no new information. For example, the Alexa logo illustrates the Alexa date.
Heading is ‘A critical perspective’. Three examples given are using artificial intelligence (AI) to write essays, digital inequality, and remote surveillance and proctoring. Digital inequality is illustrated witth the cover of a report from the University of Bristol on digital inequalities across higher education in the global South and global North since the start of COVID-19. AI is illustrated with a story from vice.com on students using AI to write their papers. Remote surveillance is illustrated with a story from Teen Vogue on students fighting remote exam surveillance
Extended learning possibilities
From learner to earner Skills for employment and career development
Taking our place in society Developing responsible citizens
Building our community Changing perspectives, opening opportunities
Healthy mind, healthy body Developing the whole person
Questioning and learning Building minds
Developing global citizens Creating a better world
Divider slide: looking to the future
Innovating pedagogy
We propose a long list of new educational terms, theories, and practices.
We then pare these down to ten that have the potential to provoke major shifts in educational practice.
Lastly, we draw on published and unpublished writings to compile ten sketches of pedagogies that might transform education.
Images of the two most recent reports, one showing a teenager using virtual reality and another showing two young women in a lab.
Divider slide: four pedagogies
Computational thinking
Using techniques from computing to solve problems in many areas
Each area of the curriculum is associated with a set of skills that can be applied throughout our life, giving us new ways to understand the world. In the case of computing, as we learn its principles and languages, we also acquire a set of problem-solving skills. Together, these are known as Computational Thinking.
Photo shows a man and a boy working together at a computer workshop
Computational thinking
Decomposition Breaking a large problem down into smaller ones
Pattern recognition Recognising how these smaller problems relate to ones that have been solved in the past
Abstraction Identifying and setting aside unimportant details
Algorithm design Identifying and refining the steps necessary to reach a solution
Debugging Refining those stepsPresenting a solution in a usable form
Researchers who have investigated how children engage with the programming environment Scratch have identified skills and shifts in perspective related to computational thinking: experimenting & iterating, testing & debugging, reusing & remixing, abstracting & modularising, expressing, connecting and questioning.
https://scratch.mit.edu/
Slide includes the Scratch logo – a cartoon cat with a broad smile striding forward
Seeking the truth
Epistemic Aims and Value Goals and values that drive cognition and action.These include wanting to know, seeking the truth, and avoiding error.
Epistemic Ideals Criteria people use to decide whether they have achieved their epistemic aims. These can also be used to evaluate other people’s epistemic products, such as arguments and websites.
Reliable Epistemic Processes Strategies that enable the achievement of epistemic aims. Even though truth is hard to achieve, a reliable process is more likely than other processes to get to the truth.
Epistemic = Relating to knowledge or to the degree of its validation
Two images ofclaims fact-checked by the Full Fact organisation. One is that in the UK women earn less than men. Full Fact notes this is true overall and goes into more detail. The other claim is that the UK can’t attract junior doctors from around the workd because they won’t earn enough to meet minimum income requirements. Full Fact provides the figures – a second-year junior doctor would earn just enough to meet the current threshold.
Seeking the truth
Expose learners to the diversity of knowledge
Help them to develop epistemic criteria
Support development of reliable strategies for making sense of the world
Encourage learners to reflect on their assumptions
Motivate learners to care about truth and knowledge
Images of three relevant images available at BBC Bitesize.
One is of ttwo people swapping phones to see if they can break out of their echo chambers, one resource is to help learners to spot fake news and listen to every side of a story, the third offers five ways to spot misleading images online.
Threshold concepts
Concepts that learners struggle to understand. They may be
transformative: they shift a learner’s perceptions of a subject
irreversible: once learned, they are hard to unlearn
integrative: they expose the inter-relatedness of some things
bounded: they border with other threshold concepts to define a disciplinary area
troublesome: they appear difficult and unintuitive
An example is inertia. An object in motion will continue in motion unless an external force acts on it. This goes against the ‘common sense’ notion that it will stop when it runs out of energy.
Tricky topics
Ten steps to teaching tricky topics
Bring educators together
Brainstorm activity
Produce mind maps
Identify stumbling blocks
Caputre problems
Develop quiz
Construct intervention
In-class activities
Analyse success.
Two small pictures show teachers working together to do this, and an example of a mind map connecting different ideas with lines and different colours
Making thinking visible
Response systems enable
Students to ask questions
Educators to collect answers
Software enables
Creation of models, videos, or texts that bring together audio, images and video
Dialogue and interaction
Augmented reality enables
Creation of holograms, or objects that can be used in a virtual space
When thinking is visible, it can be used by teachers to adapt teaching and provide feedback and by learners to make more informed decisions about their study.
Photo by Oscar Omondi of three children in a Kenyan clasrrom. One has their eyes on their desk, one is giving a thumbs-up, and one has a sheet of paper behind their head.
Making thinking visible
Just-in-time teaching
Using digital tools to make student thinking visible before class, so activities can meet their learning need. Questions and assignments are given before class.
Five phases
Ensuring learners understand the purpose of the approach.
Creating purposeful questions or tasks.
Setting a deadline for responses.
Analysing responses.
Presenting responses to learners and adapting learning activities to take responses into account.
Divider slide: on the horizon
Innovating Pedagogy 2022
Walk and talk: Combining movement and conversation to enhance learning
Hybrid models: Maximising learning opportunities and flexibility
Wellbeing education: Promoting wellbeing in all areas of teaching and learning
Microcredentials: Accredited short courses to develop workplace skills
Ways of contacting the speaker or accessing her slides
slideshare.net/R3becca
r3beccaf.wordpress.com/
twitter.com/R3beccaF
Website for the Innovating Pedagogy reports
www.open.ac.uk/blogs/innovating/
Image of the current report, showing two young women in a lab.