The health system had a split in spending between two suppliers for endomechanical staplers. This prevented them from accessing premium contract tiers and resulted in $1M in additional spending. After negotiations, the health system was able to reduce additional spending to $250K but lost revenue share benefits. The underlying issue was surgeon preference for the staplers they were trained on. The author worked with the value analysis team for months on presentations, but surgeons refused to consolidate usage due to concerns over patient outcomes. Eventually, the C-suite prioritized $10M in budget savings and pressured surgeons to comply given the potential savings from consolidating stapler usage.