Incorrect pH readings from buffer solutions can be caused by several factors related to the buffer or pH probe. Old or improperly stored buffer solutions may be past their shelf life or exposed to heat, affecting the pH. Used buffer solutions should not be returned to their bottle. It is also important to check the performance of the pH probe through visual inspection, cleaning, and ensuring proper storage and handling. Inaccurate pH readings could be due to issues with either the buffer solution or the pH probe, so both should be evaluated when calibration does not provide the expected results.