SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Role of Monitoring

Mayada El-Zoghbi, CGAP
 Blaine Stephens, MIX
Monitoring and Evaluations


How is my program      Are my clients doing
doing vis-à-vis the    better because of the
    set goals?               program?

MONITORING AND               IMPACT
   PROJECT                 ASSESMENT
  EVALUATION


    Improve               Prove impact
  performance
M&E Framework


   Activities           Outputs           Outcomes            Impact



        Performance monitoring

• Indicators for measuring change
• Systems for supporting monitoring

                           Project evaluation


                                                Impact assessment
Evolution of indicators in financial inclusion

Market
                                                              Financial
                                                              inclusion
                                                             (FAS, AFI)




                                               Responsible
                                                 finance
                                                 (Smart
                                               Campaign,
                                                   PIIF)
                                                                Branchless
                                                                banking / e-
             Financial                                            money
           performance,            Social performance
         Outreach , Credit               (SPTF)
          (CGAP, SEEP)                                          SME
                             Savings
Retail
         <2000                 2005                 2010                       2015
                                  Tool development
Example: Financial capability project


          Activities                   Outputs                 Outcomes                 Impact

 Example on financial literacy:
   Create financial literacy     Delivery channels       Other service providers   Improved client welfare
          materials            developed by providers       enter the market
                                                                                   Reduced vulnerability to
   Select and train trainers      Clients trained on     Clients improve use of           shocks
                                  financial literacy        financial services
   Train service providers


 Examples of assumptions:
                               Training delivery model    Scalable business
                                  adapted to client      model is developed for
                                     environment                training


Tracking progress and testing assumptions in the monitoring framework
Think about a recent financial inclusion project. What does the results chain (or one piece of it)
look like? How do you track progress? What assumptions are key to that chain and your
monitoring? Write down and be ready to discuss with the group.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

CGAP Slides
CGAP SlidesCGAP Slides
CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1
CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1
CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1
CGAP
 
The Challenge of Inactive Customers
The Challenge of Inactive CustomersThe Challenge of Inactive Customers
The Challenge of Inactive Customers
CGAP
 
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer Segmentation
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer SegmentationCGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer Segmentation
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer Segmentation
CGAP
 
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2
CGAP
 
CGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreach
CGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreachCGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreach
CGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreach
Microfinance Hub
 

Viewers also liked (6)

CGAP Slides
CGAP SlidesCGAP Slides
CGAP Slides
 
CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1
CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1
CGAP & Grameen Foundation AppLab Case Study Part 1
 
The Challenge of Inactive Customers
The Challenge of Inactive CustomersThe Challenge of Inactive Customers
The Challenge of Inactive Customers
 
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer Segmentation
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer SegmentationCGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer Segmentation
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab: Customer Segmentation
 
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2
CGAP and Grameen Foundation AppLab Money Incubator: Case Study Part 2
 
CGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreach
CGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreachCGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreach
CGAP Technology Program - Agents marketreach
 

Similar to Blaine Stephens and Mayada El-Zoghbi - Role of Monitoring

IBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapare
IBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapareIBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapare
IBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapare
IBM Sverige
 
Performance based grants
Performance based grantsPerformance based grants
Lean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer Service
Lean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer ServiceLean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer Service
Lean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer Service
cathylums
 
Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...
Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...
Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...
OECD CFE
 
Host Analytics Overview
Host Analytics OverviewHost Analytics Overview
Host Analytics Overview
Matt Foster
 
Resume-Harish_Veligandla
Resume-Harish_VeligandlaResume-Harish_Veligandla
Resume-Harish_Veligandla
Harish Baba Veligandla
 
User Experience Balanced Scorecard
User Experience Balanced ScorecardUser Experience Balanced Scorecard
User Experience Balanced Scorecard
Sean Tyne
 
Why bsf!
Why bsf!Why bsf!
Why bsf!
BSF
 
Institutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in Mexico
Institutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in MexicoInstitutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in Mexico
Institutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in Mexico
UnicefMaroc
 
Financial Management Challenges
Financial Management ChallengesFinancial Management Challenges
Financial Management Challenges
Mohamad Al Shami
 
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
Dubai Quality Group
 
Strategy Map Templates
Strategy Map TemplatesStrategy Map Templates
Strategy Map Templates
Clive Keyte
 
I gcdp department output
I gcdp department outputI gcdp department output
I gcdp department output
AIESECKolkata
 
Performance audit management for results
Performance audit management for resultsPerformance audit management for results
Performance audit management for results
icgfmconference
 
Mobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and Microstrategy
Mobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and MicrostrategyMobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and Microstrategy
Mobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and Microstrategy
Jean-Michel Franco
 
Magne retail deck
Magne retail deckMagne retail deck
Magne retail deck
Kaushik Ghosh
 
Social Performance Program
Social Performance ProgramSocial Performance Program
Social Performance Program
MABSIV
 
2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk
2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk
2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk
flogarnier
 
Achieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del Monte
Achieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del MonteAchieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del Monte
Achieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del Monte
Perficient, Inc.
 
Risk management competency dictionary0
Risk management competency dictionary0Risk management competency dictionary0
Risk management competency dictionary0
Confidential
 

Similar to Blaine Stephens and Mayada El-Zoghbi - Role of Monitoring (20)

IBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapare
IBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapareIBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapare
IBM Cognos - Hälsokontroll på ekonomiavdelningen med mål att bli värdeskapare
 
Performance based grants
Performance based grantsPerformance based grants
Performance based grants
 
Lean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer Service
Lean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer ServiceLean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer Service
Lean Six Sigma and the Three "Rs" of Customer Service
 
Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...
Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...
Evaluation of business start-up policies by Jonathan Potter, Senior Economist...
 
Host Analytics Overview
Host Analytics OverviewHost Analytics Overview
Host Analytics Overview
 
Resume-Harish_Veligandla
Resume-Harish_VeligandlaResume-Harish_Veligandla
Resume-Harish_Veligandla
 
User Experience Balanced Scorecard
User Experience Balanced ScorecardUser Experience Balanced Scorecard
User Experience Balanced Scorecard
 
Why bsf!
Why bsf!Why bsf!
Why bsf!
 
Institutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in Mexico
Institutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in MexicoInstitutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in Mexico
Institutionalizing the Use of Evidence for Public Policy: A long path in Mexico
 
Financial Management Challenges
Financial Management ChallengesFinancial Management Challenges
Financial Management Challenges
 
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
 
Strategy Map Templates
Strategy Map TemplatesStrategy Map Templates
Strategy Map Templates
 
I gcdp department output
I gcdp department outputI gcdp department output
I gcdp department output
 
Performance audit management for results
Performance audit management for resultsPerformance audit management for results
Performance audit management for results
 
Mobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and Microstrategy
Mobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and MicrostrategyMobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and Microstrategy
Mobile SRM offering by Business & Decision and Microstrategy
 
Magne retail deck
Magne retail deckMagne retail deck
Magne retail deck
 
Social Performance Program
Social Performance ProgramSocial Performance Program
Social Performance Program
 
2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk
2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk
2012 05 16 Marketing Efficiency Presentation Uk
 
Achieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del Monte
Achieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del MonteAchieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del Monte
Achieving Operational Visibility and Financial Gain at Del Monte
 
Risk management competency dictionary0
Risk management competency dictionary0Risk management competency dictionary0
Risk management competency dictionary0
 

More from Microfinance Gateway

Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...
Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...
Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...
Microfinance Gateway
 
Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors?
Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors? Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors?
Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors?
Microfinance Gateway
 
Jake Kendall - hot issues session mobile banking
Jake Kendall -  hot issues session mobile banking Jake Kendall -  hot issues session mobile banking
Jake Kendall - hot issues session mobile banking
Microfinance Gateway
 
Stefan Dercon - acting on evidence
Stefan Dercon  - acting on evidenceStefan Dercon  - acting on evidence
Stefan Dercon - acting on evidence
Microfinance Gateway
 
Syed Hashemi - qualitative research
Syed Hashemi  - qualitative researchSyed Hashemi  - qualitative research
Syed Hashemi - qualitative research
Microfinance Gateway
 
Alexis Diamond - quasi experiments
Alexis Diamond  - quasi experimentsAlexis Diamond  - quasi experiments
Alexis Diamond - quasi experiments
Microfinance Gateway
 
Philip Davies - introduction to impact evaluation
Philip Davies - introduction to impact evaluationPhilip Davies - introduction to impact evaluation
Philip Davies - introduction to impact evaluation
Microfinance Gateway
 
Mark Napier - facilitating financial market development
Mark Napier - facilitating financial market developmentMark Napier - facilitating financial market development
Mark Napier - facilitating financial market development
Microfinance Gateway
 
Jim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logic
Jim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logicJim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logic
Jim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logic
Microfinance Gateway
 
Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'
Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'
Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'
Microfinance Gateway
 
Sukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market development
Sukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market developmentSukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market development
Sukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market development
Microfinance Gateway
 

More from Microfinance Gateway (11)

Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...
Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...
Kenya Financial Diaries Project: Making Ends Meet in the Land of M-PESA & Bra...
 
Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors?
Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors? Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors?
Microfinance Ratings: What use are they to investors?
 
Jake Kendall - hot issues session mobile banking
Jake Kendall -  hot issues session mobile banking Jake Kendall -  hot issues session mobile banking
Jake Kendall - hot issues session mobile banking
 
Stefan Dercon - acting on evidence
Stefan Dercon  - acting on evidenceStefan Dercon  - acting on evidence
Stefan Dercon - acting on evidence
 
Syed Hashemi - qualitative research
Syed Hashemi  - qualitative researchSyed Hashemi  - qualitative research
Syed Hashemi - qualitative research
 
Alexis Diamond - quasi experiments
Alexis Diamond  - quasi experimentsAlexis Diamond  - quasi experiments
Alexis Diamond - quasi experiments
 
Philip Davies - introduction to impact evaluation
Philip Davies - introduction to impact evaluationPhilip Davies - introduction to impact evaluation
Philip Davies - introduction to impact evaluation
 
Mark Napier - facilitating financial market development
Mark Napier - facilitating financial market developmentMark Napier - facilitating financial market development
Mark Napier - facilitating financial market development
 
Jim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logic
Jim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logicJim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logic
Jim Tanburn - how do you measure market development experiences with logic
 
Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'
Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'
Alan Gibson - market development, the 'why' and 'what'
 
Sukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market development
Sukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market developmentSukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market development
Sukhwinder Arora - measuring progress in market development
 

Blaine Stephens and Mayada El-Zoghbi - Role of Monitoring

  • 1. Role of Monitoring Mayada El-Zoghbi, CGAP Blaine Stephens, MIX
  • 2. Monitoring and Evaluations How is my program Are my clients doing doing vis-à-vis the better because of the set goals? program? MONITORING AND IMPACT PROJECT ASSESMENT EVALUATION Improve Prove impact performance
  • 3. M&E Framework Activities Outputs Outcomes Impact Performance monitoring • Indicators for measuring change • Systems for supporting monitoring Project evaluation Impact assessment
  • 4. Evolution of indicators in financial inclusion Market Financial inclusion (FAS, AFI) Responsible finance (Smart Campaign, PIIF) Branchless banking / e- Financial money performance, Social performance Outreach , Credit (SPTF) (CGAP, SEEP) SME Savings Retail <2000 2005 2010 2015 Tool development
  • 5. Example: Financial capability project Activities Outputs Outcomes Impact Example on financial literacy: Create financial literacy Delivery channels Other service providers Improved client welfare materials developed by providers enter the market Reduced vulnerability to Select and train trainers Clients trained on Clients improve use of shocks financial literacy financial services Train service providers Examples of assumptions: Training delivery model Scalable business adapted to client model is developed for environment training Tracking progress and testing assumptions in the monitoring framework Think about a recent financial inclusion project. What does the results chain (or one piece of it) look like? How do you track progress? What assumptions are key to that chain and your monitoring? Write down and be ready to discuss with the group.