Aiann Oishi shares her learning outcomes and development behind her capstone project at the 10th Annual Accessibility Conference at the University of Guelph. Her capstone, The Web ABC Toolkit focuses on building a better business case for web accessibility and can be visited at http://aianndesign.com/web-abc.
What the WCAG? A Student Journey in Web Accessibility
1. What the WCAG?
A Student Journey in Web Accessibility
Aiann Oishi | May 29, 2018
2. This presentation is available as a Word document:
https://bit.ly/2JfI9E8
Accessible Format Available
3. About Aiann
Graduate Certificate, Accessible Media Production
Mohawk College (2018)
Bachelor of Design
York University & Sheridan College (2011)
Internships
• Henderson Bas Kohn
• Chatelaine Magazine
• Pearson Canada
Employment
• Alzheimer Society of Toronto
• MMM Group Limited
• Women’s College Hospital
5. Capstone Idea #1:
Toolkit to help the disability community
resolve accommodation issues with
businesses and services.
6. Idea #1 Fails
• Made the mistake many designers make – jumping to solutions
without thinking of its impact and effectiveness
• Assumptions:
• I would be a disability messiah with the masses using my toolkit
• Barriers are easily resolved with a one-size-fits-all solution
Made assumptions and leaped to conclusions
7. As Boromir in Lord of the Rings would tell us…
“One does not simply enforce the AODA”
10. What is a toolkit?
• A "toolkit" is a collection of related information, resources, or tools that
together can guide users to implement evidence-based practices
Sources:
Section 6: Toolkit Guidance. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
http://www.ahrq.gov/research/publications/pubcomguide/pcguide6.html
Implementation Toolkits. UC Berkley. California Social Work Education Center.
https://calswec.berkeley.edu/toolkits/implementation-toolkits
11. What goes in a toolkit?
• Resources such as:
• Articles
• Checklists
• Guides
• Multimedia such as:
• Audio recordings
• Infographics
• Slides
• Videos and webinars
• Presented online or as a document
13. Infographic Barriers
• Distracting visual elements
• Little or no supporting text to describe the actual image
• Resolution becomes blurry for users who zoom in
• Not always search engine friendly
• Larger files affect users with slower internet connection
16. Option 2: Too much contrast, illegible font, lots of text
17. Option 3: Final
• Good colour contrast
• Legible font choice
• Larger font size
• Plain language
• Clear layout
18. Presenting an Accessible Infographic
1. Provide long alternative text or a transcript with the image AND/OR
2. Build the infographic using semantic HTML and CSS so that
screen readers can access the content
Option #2 is the preferred approach
20. Requirements – What did I want to build?
• Single webpage: keep the scale of the project manageable
• Prototype: get started quickly and meet project deadlines
• Responsive design: maximize access across multiple devices/users
• Customizable: design control
• Lightweight: avoid extra hosting costs
21. The Approach – WordPress or Static HTML?
WordPress
• 30% of websites are built using
WordPress
• SEO friendly with trackbacks,
pingbacks and plugins
• Quick initial setup
Static HTML
• Highly customizable with
unlimited design control
• Loads fast
• Requires minimal hosting
requirements
23. Accessibility Testing
• WAVE Evaluation Tool (WebAIM)
• A-Checker (Inclusive Design Institute)
• Colour Contrast Analyser (Paciello Group)
• Screen reader testing
• NVDA on Windows PC with Firefox
• VoiceOver on iPhone with Safari
• Microsoft’s built-in testing tool for linked Word document
24. Further Learning – What’s next?
• UX & Web Development
• Learning CSS Grid
• Testing with end-users
• Awareness
• Promoting the toolkit
• Feedback & Analytics
• Measure toolkit visits with Google Analytics
• Setting up a survey to collect user feedback
25. Check out the Web ABC Toolkit
Scan the QR code or
access the toolkit at:
http://aianndesign.com/web-abc
26. Thank you.
If you’re interested in getting in touch,
please email aiann.design@yahoo.ca
Editor's Notes
Who am I?
Graphic designer with 6+ years of experience
Currently freelancing, completed a Graduate Certificate in the Accessible Media Production program at Mohawk College
Why Accessibility
Working as an in-house designer in the public sector has exposed me to many challenges
Fear of change – ex: We’ve always done [blank] this way
Fear of not knowing – ex: We want to be accessible, but we don’t know how
Design has the power to change perspectives, make a positive impact!
Define capstone:
Demonstrates understanding of what we’ve learned in the Accessible Media Production program
Current legislation, attitudes and barriers
Is in an accessible format (i.e. document, website, video) to showcase skills gained
Learning about the AODA legislation not having teeth led me my first idea…
Why did it fail?
Made assumptions and leaped to conclusions – same mistake many designers make.
Jumping to solutions without thinking of its impact and effectiveness
’Disability Messiah’
Reality Check
I’m not a lawyer. I have limited knowledge and training in the Canadian legal system
Compared to the United States, there hasn’t been enough lawsuits challenging accessibility barriers to provide me context
AODA is only provincial, no federal legislation yet…
The idea was too broad and large to take on as a student project!
Having worked in in-house marketing teams, I remembered some past challenges in getting people on board with accessibility.
I asked myself…
How do you make a case for someone to sign off on a new initiative?
How do you persuade someone to be on your side?
How do you justify spending resources to support your project?
Answer: You build a business case…
W3C (World Wide Web Consortium) lists four main factors in making a business case: financial, social, legal and technical.
Examples
Financial – reduce potential retrofitting costs
Legal – meeting standards like the AODA
Social – promoting inclusion
Technical – opportunity to invest in assistive technology and increase access to services
Every organization is unique. You get asked – which factor is most relevant to me? If I need to make a case, what factors should I focus on and which benefits should I highlight?
NOTE: all of these factors are important!
First learning outcome - figure out what a toolkit is.
The official definition: A "toolkit" is a collection of related information, resources, or tools that together can guide users to implement evidence-based practices.
Simply put: they provide a blueprint for what to do, when to do it, and how to do it
Being a graphic designer, decided to focus on producing an infographic to map the four factors in making a business case
Infographics have benefits:
Information is concise and in smaller chunks
Visually shows the relationships between data and information
Popular on social media
Infographics have barriers:
Distracting visual element
Little or no supporting text to describe the actual image
Becomes blurry for users who zoom in
Not always search engine friendly
Larger files affect users with slow, internet connection speeds
I believe the best work comes from starting on paper, I drew…icons, lines, mapped out the information I wanted to convey
Now that I had an infographic, I realized it wasn’t fully accessible.
It was still presented as a flat JPG or printed piece. For example, if you had vision loss or couldn’t understand the flow of information presented.
That’s how I came to my third and final learning outcome.
In terms of approach, I could go with either WordPress or a static HTML site.
With WordPress, I would learn…
how to apply WCAG 2.0 to edit an existing WordPress theme to be accessible as possible
With a static HTML site, I would learn…
how to apply WCAG 2.0 to build an accessible HTML webpage using semantic markup
Clean, simple layout
Appropriate use of contrast and colours
Semantic HTML
Keyboard operable – expand/collapse sections with TAB, UP/DOWN arrows, navigate by headings with a screen reader
Responsive design
Content is available in alternate formats – Word document, text-only version
Creating a website = I could have additional resources online.
Toolkit can be downloaded as a:
Postcard*
Poster*
Word Document
Text-only HTML
*Both the postcard and poster come with a text transcript
Understand that meeting a checklist doesn’t = accessibility.
To follow a QA (quality assurance) process, I tested the website’s structure and colour contrast with tools like WAVE, A-Checker, Colour Contrast Analyser.
Screen reader testing
Microsoft testing for Word document
More user testing!
Connected the toolkit to Analytics – can see where and how it’s being accessed
Learned about CSS Grid from both Sandi, professor and developer colleagues at Pearson
I welcome feedback from all of you (and anyone I present the toolkit to). When I presented to
Visit the toolkit online – I have postcards with the QR code if you prefer accessing it on your mobile device.
Get in touch with me.
Business cards on the table.