Professional Practices
 Failure of Subhiksha
Objectives


To analyse Subhiksha as a failed venture

 To list down the factors that led to its
                 failure

To give suggestions that would lead the
failed venture to a sustainable position
Failed Venture
Subhiksha : Company Profile
        Type         • Discount department store

      Industry       • Retail

      Founder        • R Subramaniam (IIM Ahmedabad)

Date of Commencement • March, 1997

     First store     • Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai, India (1997)

  Number of Stores   • 1000 stores(defunt)

     Employees       • 25,000(NA)

      Website        • www.subhiksha.in(defunct)

  Date of Shutdown   • 2007
Subhiksha : About the Company


Subhiksha means "One that gives all good things in Life".

 Chennai based supermarket and pharmacy retail chain

                USP: Discount Strategies

     Market Focus: Middle class income consumers

                     Company Logo
Subhiksha : Product Portfolio
               Super
               market




                         Fruits and
    Telecom   Products
                         Vegetable




              Pharmacy
Subhiksha : Growth Portfolio

• Entered Indian      • Opened First         • 10 Stores in        • 50 stores in
  Retail Market         Store in Chennai       Chennai               Chennai. ICICI
                                                                     joins venture.


                      March                  March
1997                                                               June 2000
                      1997                   1998


           • 120-130 stores      • Retail Stores in      • Subhiksha
             in Tamil Nadu         Gujrat,                 Mobile Shops
                                   Karnataka, Delhi,
                                   Mumbai, Andhra
                                   Pradesh

           2002                  2004-05                 2006
Subhiksha : Crash Timeline

October                       December
                                                            April 2008                         April 2008
 2007                           2007
                                                                         Plans foray                        Plans Private
            Mulls Rs                      Shelves the
                                                                         into East                          Wholesale
            350crore IPO                  Plan
                                                                         market                             Marker




                              September                       October                            January
June 2008
                                 2009     Hints at large       2009                                2009
                                                                          Problems in cash
            Wants Funds for               format consumer
                                                                          flow, Supplies cut                 Bankruptcy Filed
            Expansion                     durables and IT
                                                                          off, Stores go dry
                                          stores
Subhiksha : Failure Factors

       Un-mindful expansion spree
              IPO problem
       Poor inventory management
             Lack of Focus
          Vendor Management
Subhiksha : Failure Factors

          Balance Sheets: Cash Flows

      Quality of ground level management

               Discounts as USP

          Mastering the supply chain
Subhiksha : Suggestions
Measured Expansion


Employees Approach


Promoting Ethics


IPO Benefits


Attractive Visual Merchandising


Thoughtful Inventory Management
Subhiksha : Suggestions
Reasonable Profit Margins


Consolidated Expansion of Product Variety


Audit and Survey Teams


Promotion Strategies


Above the Line Promotion


Vendor Management
Thank You

Professional practices

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Objectives To analyse Subhikshaas a failed venture To list down the factors that led to its failure To give suggestions that would lead the failed venture to a sustainable position
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Subhiksha : CompanyProfile Type • Discount department store Industry • Retail Founder • R Subramaniam (IIM Ahmedabad) Date of Commencement • March, 1997 First store • Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai, India (1997) Number of Stores • 1000 stores(defunt) Employees • 25,000(NA) Website • www.subhiksha.in(defunct) Date of Shutdown • 2007
  • 5.
    Subhiksha : Aboutthe Company Subhiksha means "One that gives all good things in Life". Chennai based supermarket and pharmacy retail chain USP: Discount Strategies Market Focus: Middle class income consumers Company Logo
  • 6.
    Subhiksha : ProductPortfolio Super market Fruits and Telecom Products Vegetable Pharmacy
  • 7.
    Subhiksha : GrowthPortfolio • Entered Indian • Opened First • 10 Stores in • 50 stores in Retail Market Store in Chennai Chennai Chennai. ICICI joins venture. March March 1997 June 2000 1997 1998 • 120-130 stores • Retail Stores in • Subhiksha in Tamil Nadu Gujrat, Mobile Shops Karnataka, Delhi, Mumbai, Andhra Pradesh 2002 2004-05 2006
  • 8.
    Subhiksha : CrashTimeline October December April 2008 April 2008 2007 2007 Plans foray Plans Private Mulls Rs Shelves the into East Wholesale 350crore IPO Plan market Marker September October January June 2008 2009 Hints at large 2009 2009 Problems in cash Wants Funds for format consumer flow, Supplies cut Bankruptcy Filed Expansion durables and IT off, Stores go dry stores
  • 9.
    Subhiksha : FailureFactors Un-mindful expansion spree IPO problem Poor inventory management Lack of Focus Vendor Management
  • 10.
    Subhiksha : FailureFactors Balance Sheets: Cash Flows Quality of ground level management Discounts as USP Mastering the supply chain
  • 11.
    Subhiksha : Suggestions MeasuredExpansion Employees Approach Promoting Ethics IPO Benefits Attractive Visual Merchandising Thoughtful Inventory Management
  • 12.
    Subhiksha : Suggestions ReasonableProfit Margins Consolidated Expansion of Product Variety Audit and Survey Teams Promotion Strategies Above the Line Promotion Vendor Management
  • 13.