SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Malcolm Gladwell vs Duncan Watts
Who is Duncan Watts?
Duncan Watts is a professor of sociology at Columbia University.
He argues that “Influentials” do not have any special role in
trends, especially for marketing.
Gladwell states that, “social influence stems from a two-step
flow of communication; from the media to influentials (a tiny
minority of well-connected, persuasive people), and from them
to everyone else. If correct, this theory means that marketers
should search out and influence the influentials” (Gow, 2007).
However, in his research, Watts, “analyzed email patterns and
found that highly connected people are not, in fact, crucial social
hubs” (Thompson, 2008). Instead, he predicts your average
couch potato has just as high of a chance to start a new trend!
The only exception Watts found were influential celebrities
such as Oprah Winfrey because of how wide an audience
they are able to reach (Gow, 2007).
Watt’s findings suggest that marketers should, “not focus on a
few influentials but rather on leveraging Web-based social
networking tools to reach large numbers of ordinary people”
(Gow, 2007 ).

More Related Content

What's hot

Social media for research impact
Social media for research impactSocial media for research impact
Social media for research impactAberdeen CES
 
Media 01 2015 incomplete
Media 01 2015 incompleteMedia 01 2015 incomplete
Media 01 2015 incompleteEric Strayer
 
Whistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the Messenger
Whistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the MessengerWhistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the Messenger
Whistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the MessengerAniisu K Verghese
 
Film slideshare
Film slideshareFilm slideshare
Film slideshareJulia Chew
 
Audience theories
Audience theoriesAudience theories
Audience theorieskieranlukas
 
Intro to new and digital media 2017
Intro to new and digital media 2017Intro to new and digital media 2017
Intro to new and digital media 2017CHSGmedia
 
Impact of Social Media
Impact of Social MediaImpact of Social Media
Impact of Social Mediawhite paper
 
Thesis i presentation(10.14)
Thesis i presentation(10.14)Thesis i presentation(10.14)
Thesis i presentation(10.14)Hannah Li
 
Flipbook- Taryn Cates
Flipbook- Taryn CatesFlipbook- Taryn Cates
Flipbook- Taryn CatesTaryn Cates
 
Understanding influence in social media
Understanding influence in social media Understanding influence in social media
Understanding influence in social media Pulsar Platform
 
Soc101 - Collective Behavior & Social Movements
Soc101 - Collective Behavior & Social MovementsSoc101 - Collective Behavior & Social Movements
Soc101 - Collective Behavior & Social MovementsJessie Daniels
 
CLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for Good
CLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for GoodCLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for Good
CLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for GoodCharlie Gray
 
Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02
Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02
Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02Geo Alega
 
The Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-Representation
The Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-RepresentationThe Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-Representation
The Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-RepresentationPamela Rutledge
 

What's hot (16)

Social media for research impact
Social media for research impactSocial media for research impact
Social media for research impact
 
Media 01 2015 incomplete
Media 01 2015 incompleteMedia 01 2015 incomplete
Media 01 2015 incomplete
 
Whistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the Messenger
Whistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the MessengerWhistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the Messenger
Whistle Blowing, Media, Manipulation - Don't Shoot the Messenger
 
Flipbook
FlipbookFlipbook
Flipbook
 
Film slideshare
Film slideshareFilm slideshare
Film slideshare
 
Audience theories
Audience theoriesAudience theories
Audience theories
 
Intro to new and digital media 2017
Intro to new and digital media 2017Intro to new and digital media 2017
Intro to new and digital media 2017
 
Impact of Social Media
Impact of Social MediaImpact of Social Media
Impact of Social Media
 
Thesis i presentation(10.14)
Thesis i presentation(10.14)Thesis i presentation(10.14)
Thesis i presentation(10.14)
 
Flipbook- Taryn Cates
Flipbook- Taryn CatesFlipbook- Taryn Cates
Flipbook- Taryn Cates
 
Understanding influence in social media
Understanding influence in social media Understanding influence in social media
Understanding influence in social media
 
Soc101 - Collective Behavior & Social Movements
Soc101 - Collective Behavior & Social MovementsSoc101 - Collective Behavior & Social Movements
Soc101 - Collective Behavior & Social Movements
 
CLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for Good
CLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for GoodCLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for Good
CLICKTIVISM: A (Flawed) Force for Good
 
Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02
Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02
Somepres 110213174050-phpapp02
 
The Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-Representation
The Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-RepresentationThe Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-Representation
The Impact of Social Media on Women's Self-Image and Self-Representation
 
Film 240 Flipbook
Film 240 Flipbook Film 240 Flipbook
Film 240 Flipbook
 

Viewers also liked

ingenieria comercial
ingenieria comercialingenieria comercial
ingenieria comercialKaren Robayo
 
Lunabotics_PresentationFINAL
Lunabotics_PresentationFINALLunabotics_PresentationFINAL
Lunabotics_PresentationFINALAustin Cote
 
Herbalpelangsingperut
HerbalpelangsingperutHerbalpelangsingperut
Herbalpelangsingperutsuplemen
 
Najnowsze osiągnięcia robotyki
Najnowsze osiągnięcia robotykiNajnowsze osiągnięcia robotyki
Najnowsze osiągnięcia robotykigrzesiekAAAAA
 
Восприятие окружающего мира
Восприятие окружающего мираВосприятие окружающего мира
Восприятие окружающего мираgogzez
 
приезжева
приезжеваприезжева
приезжеваnastya230896
 
Структура Вселенной
Структура ВселеннойСтруктура Вселенной
Структура Вселеннойgogzez
 
Brian Watson Resume 2015
Brian Watson Resume 2015Brian Watson Resume 2015
Brian Watson Resume 2015Brian Watson
 
Жизнь во Вселенной
Жизнь во ВселеннойЖизнь во Вселенной
Жизнь во Вселеннойgogzez
 

Viewers also liked (13)

ingenieria comercial
ingenieria comercialingenieria comercial
ingenieria comercial
 
Lunabotics_PresentationFINAL
Lunabotics_PresentationFINALLunabotics_PresentationFINAL
Lunabotics_PresentationFINAL
 
Herbalpelangsingperut
HerbalpelangsingperutHerbalpelangsingperut
Herbalpelangsingperut
 
Yourprezi
YourpreziYourprezi
Yourprezi
 
Najnowsze osiągnięcia robotyki
Najnowsze osiągnięcia robotykiNajnowsze osiągnięcia robotyki
Najnowsze osiągnięcia robotyki
 
Восприятие окружающего мира
Восприятие окружающего мираВосприятие окружающего мира
Восприятие окружающего мира
 
приезжева
приезжеваприезжева
приезжева
 
Customer Feedback
Customer FeedbackCustomer Feedback
Customer Feedback
 
Sosiantopologi Pendididikan
Sosiantopologi PendididikanSosiantopologi Pendididikan
Sosiantopologi Pendididikan
 
It services
It servicesIt services
It services
 
Структура Вселенной
Структура ВселеннойСтруктура Вселенной
Структура Вселенной
 
Brian Watson Resume 2015
Brian Watson Resume 2015Brian Watson Resume 2015
Brian Watson Resume 2015
 
Жизнь во Вселенной
Жизнь во ВселеннойЖизнь во Вселенной
Жизнь во Вселенной
 

Similar to Criticisms of malcolm gladwell's tipping point

Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communicationBjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communicationRai University
 
Influence in Online Media
Influence in Online MediaInfluence in Online Media
Influence in Online Mediaaliciahouselog
 
Slideshare Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth Marketing
Slideshare   Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth MarketingSlideshare   Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth Marketing
Slideshare Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth MarketingiQ Student Accommodation
 
Two step flow
Two step flow Two step flow
Two step flow kerry17
 
T ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk reviewT ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk reviewarunakenyi
 
An Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdf
An Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdfAn Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdf
An Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdfSara Parker
 
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul HannanActual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul HannanDr. Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
 
The Two-Step Flow Of Communication
The Two-Step Flow Of CommunicationThe Two-Step Flow Of Communication
The Two-Step Flow Of CommunicationAiyana Cruz
 
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for ScientistsThe Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for ScientistsCraig McClain
 
AS and A2 Audiences Booklet
AS and A2 Audiences BookletAS and A2 Audiences Booklet
AS and A2 Audiences BookletKate McCabe
 
Running Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docx
Running Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docxRunning Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docx
Running Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docxSUBHI7
 
Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100justwatts3
 
uses and grats and dependency theory
uses and grats and dependency theoryuses and grats and dependency theory
uses and grats and dependency theoryCHSGmedia
 
dependency theory and Uuses and gratification
dependency theory and Uuses and gratificationdependency theory and Uuses and gratification
dependency theory and Uuses and gratificationCHSGmedia
 
Media A2 audiences
Media A2 audiencesMedia A2 audiences
Media A2 audiencesKate McCabe
 
Dissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations studentsDissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations studentsStephen Waddington
 
7. mass communication theory
7. mass communication theory7. mass communication theory
7. mass communication theorydeepak kulhari
 

Similar to Criticisms of malcolm gladwell's tipping point (20)

Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communicationBjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
 
Influence in Online Media
Influence in Online MediaInfluence in Online Media
Influence in Online Media
 
Slideshare Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth Marketing
Slideshare   Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth MarketingSlideshare   Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth Marketing
Slideshare Agnes Jumah, Word Of Mouth Marketing
 
Two step flow
Two step flow Two step flow
Two step flow
 
T ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk reviewT ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk review
 
An Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdf
An Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdfAn Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdf
An Overview of Agenda Setting Theory in Mass Communications.pdf
 
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul HannanActual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
 
social media trends
social media trendssocial media trends
social media trends
 
The Two-Step Flow Of Communication
The Two-Step Flow Of CommunicationThe Two-Step Flow Of Communication
The Two-Step Flow Of Communication
 
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for ScientistsThe Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
 
AS and A2 Audiences Booklet
AS and A2 Audiences BookletAS and A2 Audiences Booklet
AS and A2 Audiences Booklet
 
Running Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docx
Running Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docxRunning Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docx
Running Head ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MEDIA1ACCOUNTABILITY IN .docx
 
Effects and audiences lessons 2 and 3
Effects and audiences lessons 2 and 3Effects and audiences lessons 2 and 3
Effects and audiences lessons 2 and 3
 
Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100
 
Audience Analysis
Audience AnalysisAudience Analysis
Audience Analysis
 
uses and grats and dependency theory
uses and grats and dependency theoryuses and grats and dependency theory
uses and grats and dependency theory
 
dependency theory and Uuses and gratification
dependency theory and Uuses and gratificationdependency theory and Uuses and gratification
dependency theory and Uuses and gratification
 
Media A2 audiences
Media A2 audiencesMedia A2 audiences
Media A2 audiences
 
Dissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations studentsDissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations students
 
7. mass communication theory
7. mass communication theory7. mass communication theory
7. mass communication theory
 

Criticisms of malcolm gladwell's tipping point

  • 1.
  • 2. Malcolm Gladwell vs Duncan Watts
  • 3. Who is Duncan Watts? Duncan Watts is a professor of sociology at Columbia University. He argues that “Influentials” do not have any special role in trends, especially for marketing.
  • 4. Gladwell states that, “social influence stems from a two-step flow of communication; from the media to influentials (a tiny minority of well-connected, persuasive people), and from them to everyone else. If correct, this theory means that marketers should search out and influence the influentials” (Gow, 2007).
  • 5. However, in his research, Watts, “analyzed email patterns and found that highly connected people are not, in fact, crucial social hubs” (Thompson, 2008). Instead, he predicts your average couch potato has just as high of a chance to start a new trend!
  • 6. The only exception Watts found were influential celebrities such as Oprah Winfrey because of how wide an audience they are able to reach (Gow, 2007).
  • 7. Watt’s findings suggest that marketers should, “not focus on a few influentials but rather on leveraging Web-based social networking tools to reach large numbers of ordinary people” (Gow, 2007 ).