SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Malcolm Gladwell vs Duncan Watts
Who is Duncan Watts?
Duncan Watts is a professor of sociology at Columbia University.
He argues that Malcolm Gladwell’s theory of “social epidemics”•,
discussed in The Tipping Point sounds intuitively correct, but is
wrong.
Gladwell states that social influence stems from a two-step flow
of communication; from the media to influentials (a tiny minority
of well-connected, persuasive people), and from them to
everyone else. If correct, this theory means that marketers
should search out and influence the influentials.
However, Gladwell can only offer anecdotal evidence to
support his theory. What Watts has found, however, is that
with the exception of celebrities (like Oprah Winfrey), even
key influentials don’t interact with enough people to have
the impact Gladwell states that they have.
Watts has run computer simulations of the dynamics of social
contagion. What he has discovered is that – because of the
number of people who need to be”touched”•– in nearly all
circumstances, these influentials don’t have the significant
impact we “hoped” they would to make our marketing job
easier.
The key finding in their research (supported by other research as
well), is that the key way to create social contagion is to reach
“easily influenced” individuals and get them to influence others
just like them. These findings mean that, for us marketers, we
should not focus on a few influentials, but rather on leveraging
Web-based social networking tools to reach large numbers of
ordinary people.
Source: http://crimsonmarketing.com/malcolm-gladwell-was-
wrong-a-better-theory-of-social-networks/

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Marketing für Changemaker
Marketing für ChangemakerMarketing für Changemaker
Marketing für ChangemakerEva Hieninger
 
זוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסט
זוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסטזוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסט
זוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסטEyal Boers
 
Silabo evaluacion educativa pato tobar
Silabo evaluacion educativa pato tobarSilabo evaluacion educativa pato tobar
Silabo evaluacion educativa pato tobarverito velasquez
 
Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...
Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...
Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...B&T Magazine
 
Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26
Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26
Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26hemaycortes
 
WOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWN
WOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWNWOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWN
WOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWNLavanya's Trendzs
 
A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1
A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1
A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1Poliana Bellan
 

Viewers also liked (14)

CliftonScottResume
CliftonScottResumeCliftonScottResume
CliftonScottResume
 
Flyer
FlyerFlyer
Flyer
 
Marketing für Changemaker
Marketing für ChangemakerMarketing für Changemaker
Marketing für Changemaker
 
זוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסט
זוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסטזוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסט
זוויות גיליון 1 יולי-אוגוסט
 
PROYECTOS INFORMATICOS
PROYECTOS INFORMATICOSPROYECTOS INFORMATICOS
PROYECTOS INFORMATICOS
 
Diseño estructura madera_norma_e010
Diseño estructura madera_norma_e010Diseño estructura madera_norma_e010
Diseño estructura madera_norma_e010
 
Mision vision
Mision  visionMision  vision
Mision vision
 
Silabo evaluacion educativa pato tobar
Silabo evaluacion educativa pato tobarSilabo evaluacion educativa pato tobar
Silabo evaluacion educativa pato tobar
 
Introducción inv
Introducción invIntroducción inv
Introducción inv
 
Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...
Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...
Sam Hannah-Rankin, Public Sector Innovation Director, Dept of Premier & Cabin...
 
Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26
Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26
Guiademindstorms pagina 5-26
 
WOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWN
WOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWNWOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWN
WOMEN'S SLEEP WEAR NIGHT GOWN
 
A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1
A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1
A1. MEP 1 - Mod 1 - Tema1
 
El estudio de casos
El estudio de casosEl estudio de casos
El estudio de casos
 

Similar to Criticisms of malcolm gladwell's tipping point

T ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk reviewT ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk reviewarunakenyi
 
T ipping point book review
T ipping point book reviewT ipping point book review
T ipping point book reviewarunakenyi
 
Influence in Online Media
Influence in Online MediaInfluence in Online Media
Influence in Online Mediaaliciahouselog
 
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communicationBjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communicationRai University
 
Media effects
Media effectsMedia effects
Media effectsAHJoshy
 
10 things wrong with the effects model
10 things wrong with the effects model10 things wrong with the effects model
10 things wrong with the effects modelnctcmedia12
 
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul HannanActual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul HannanDr. Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
 
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for ScientistsThe Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for ScientistsCraig McClain
 
Hypodermic needle theory.pptx
Hypodermic needle theory.pptxHypodermic needle theory.pptx
Hypodermic needle theory.pptxUmer Ikram
 
O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)
O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)
O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)#ogilvychange
 
Social media for influence operations
Social media for influence operationsSocial media for influence operations
Social media for influence operationsRick van der Kleij
 
Dissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations studentsDissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations studentsStephen Waddington
 

Similar to Criticisms of malcolm gladwell's tipping point (20)

T ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk reviewT ipping point bookk review
T ipping point bookk review
 
T ipping point book review
T ipping point book reviewT ipping point book review
T ipping point book review
 
Influence in Online Media
Influence in Online MediaInfluence in Online Media
Influence in Online Media
 
iCitizen 2008: Duncan Watts
iCitizen 2008: Duncan WattsiCitizen 2008: Duncan Watts
iCitizen 2008: Duncan Watts
 
Three Types of People
Three Types of PeopleThree Types of People
Three Types of People
 
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communicationBjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
Bjmc i, cp, unit-iii,theories of mass communication
 
Media effects
Media effectsMedia effects
Media effects
 
10 things wrong with the effects model
10 things wrong with the effects model10 things wrong with the effects model
10 things wrong with the effects model
 
The tipping point - Book review
The tipping point - Book reviewThe tipping point - Book review
The tipping point - Book review
 
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul HannanActual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
Actual Power: Engaging the Disengaged - by Fiza Zia Ul Hannan
 
Hypodermic needle theory
Hypodermic needle theoryHypodermic needle theory
Hypodermic needle theory
 
Media Effects
Media EffectsMedia Effects
Media Effects
 
The theory of tipping points
The theory of tipping pointsThe theory of tipping points
The theory of tipping points
 
The theory of tipping points
The theory of tipping pointsThe theory of tipping points
The theory of tipping points
 
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for ScientistsThe Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
The Benefits and Barriers for Social Media for Scientists
 
Hypodermic needle theory.pptx
Hypodermic needle theory.pptxHypodermic needle theory.pptx
Hypodermic needle theory.pptx
 
O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)
O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)
O Behave! Issue 7 (October Edition)
 
Social media for influence operations
Social media for influence operationsSocial media for influence operations
Social media for influence operations
 
Mctheories
MctheoriesMctheories
Mctheories
 
Dissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations studentsDissertation topics for media and public relations students
Dissertation topics for media and public relations students
 

Criticisms of malcolm gladwell's tipping point

  • 1.
  • 2. Malcolm Gladwell vs Duncan Watts
  • 3. Who is Duncan Watts? Duncan Watts is a professor of sociology at Columbia University. He argues that Malcolm Gladwell’s theory of “social epidemics”•, discussed in The Tipping Point sounds intuitively correct, but is wrong.
  • 4. Gladwell states that social influence stems from a two-step flow of communication; from the media to influentials (a tiny minority of well-connected, persuasive people), and from them to everyone else. If correct, this theory means that marketers should search out and influence the influentials.
  • 5. However, Gladwell can only offer anecdotal evidence to support his theory. What Watts has found, however, is that with the exception of celebrities (like Oprah Winfrey), even key influentials don’t interact with enough people to have the impact Gladwell states that they have.
  • 6. Watts has run computer simulations of the dynamics of social contagion. What he has discovered is that – because of the number of people who need to be”touched”•– in nearly all circumstances, these influentials don’t have the significant impact we “hoped” they would to make our marketing job easier.
  • 7. The key finding in their research (supported by other research as well), is that the key way to create social contagion is to reach “easily influenced” individuals and get them to influence others just like them. These findings mean that, for us marketers, we should not focus on a few influentials, but rather on leveraging Web-based social networking tools to reach large numbers of ordinary people. Source: http://crimsonmarketing.com/malcolm-gladwell-was- wrong-a-better-theory-of-social-networks/