Here are the key points about Christian and Muslim views on IVF:Christian views:- Some Christians believe IVF is acceptable if it helps infertile couples have children, as God gave us medical knowledge. - Others argue IVF is wrong as it involves destroying unused embryos.- Some see it as interfering with God's plan or "playing God".- Others argue the money could be better spent helping poor/hungry children.Muslim views: - Most Islamic scholars permit IVF as long as the sperm and egg come from a married couple.- IVF is seen as acceptable to overcome infertility issues and have children, which is encouraged in Islam. - Destroying or discard
Similar to Here are the key points about Christian and Muslim views on IVF:Christian views:- Some Christians believe IVF is acceptable if it helps infertile couples have children, as God gave us medical knowledge. - Others argue IVF is wrong as it involves destroying unused embryos.- Some see it as interfering with God's plan or "playing God".- Others argue the money could be better spent helping poor/hungry children.Muslim views: - Most Islamic scholars permit IVF as long as the sperm and egg come from a married couple.- IVF is seen as acceptable to overcome infertility issues and have children, which is encouraged in Islam. - Destroying or discard
Baby-making : what the new reproductive treatments mean for families & society V Somasundram
Similar to Here are the key points about Christian and Muslim views on IVF:Christian views:- Some Christians believe IVF is acceptable if it helps infertile couples have children, as God gave us medical knowledge. - Others argue IVF is wrong as it involves destroying unused embryos.- Some see it as interfering with God's plan or "playing God".- Others argue the money could be better spent helping poor/hungry children.Muslim views: - Most Islamic scholars permit IVF as long as the sperm and egg come from a married couple.- IVF is seen as acceptable to overcome infertility issues and have children, which is encouraged in Islam. - Destroying or discard (6)
Here are the key points about Christian and Muslim views on IVF:Christian views:- Some Christians believe IVF is acceptable if it helps infertile couples have children, as God gave us medical knowledge. - Others argue IVF is wrong as it involves destroying unused embryos.- Some see it as interfering with God's plan or "playing God".- Others argue the money could be better spent helping poor/hungry children.Muslim views: - Most Islamic scholars permit IVF as long as the sperm and egg come from a married couple.- IVF is seen as acceptable to overcome infertility issues and have children, which is encouraged in Islam. - Destroying or discard
3. Why do some people believe
that Euthanasia is acceptable?
Which religious teaching can
you use to argue against
abortion
Why is the Hippocratic
oath important?
Why might some religious
people not agree with IVF?
Under what circumstances
might people agree a women
having an abortion?
Sanctity of life
Quality of life
To preserve life
‘thou shall not kill’
The lesser of two evils
4.
5.
6. We are learning to know
and understand what In
vitro fertlisation is
To understand why some
people may need IVF
Success Criteria
By the end of the lesson I
will be able to:
Explain what IVF is
Explain why some
people think it is
important
7. Many people choose to have
children
Some couples have fertility
problems and need help to
conceive a child
Many religious people believe
that God decides who can and
can’t have children
Others believe that fertility
treatment provided by
medical science means that
couples can choose for
themselves
8. 1. Write down 3 reasons
why people might
want to have
children?
2. Do you think
everyone has the
right to have
children, even if they
are infertile? Give
reasons for your
answer
9. 1. This is when an egg is taken
from a woman’s ovaries and
in a glass tube it is fertilised
with a man’s sperm
2. It is then placed in a special
solution designed to
nurture the egg as it begins
to divide.
3. Then the fertilised egg or
embryo is implanted into
the woman’s uterus and
hopefully she becomes
pregnant.
4. This is also known as a
test-tube baby
10. Louise Brown was the first
test- tube baby conceived
outside her mother’s womb
in 1978.
IVF is a scientific method of
making a woman pregnant,
which does not involve sex.
Conception occurs by the
sperm and egg being
fertilised in a test tube
Do you think IVF is
a good thing? Why?
11.
12. IVF is now very common and
has helped many couples who
were infertile to have a child
IVF is very expensive in the
UK it costs between 4 and 8
thousand pounds
The NHS allow infertile
couples to have 3 attempts at
IVF without paying if;
The mother is between 23
and 39, one partner is
infertile or has been
diagnosed with a fertility
problem.
13. Elizabeth Adeney became the
oldest woman in Britain to have
a baby. She was 66.
In 2009 she paid for IVF
treatment in the Ukraine using a
donor egg and donor sperm.
No British clinic was prepared to
treat her because of her age
She runs her own business so
hired a nanny when she returned
to England to look after her
baby.
Why is this story
controversial?
14. FOR
Everyone should have the
right to be a parent
I’ve earned the money, so I
can spend it however I
choose
I have been married for 5
years and we desperately
want a baby. The chance of
IVF treatment on the NHS
is a lifeline to us.
AGAINST
A child is a gift from God
not a right. If you cannot
have that gift you cannot
buy it!
There are enough people in
the world anyway. Why
should we waste money
artificially creating more?
Think what 4000 pounds
could do to help starving in
the developing world.
15. Spend 5 mins preparing an argument either for or
against IVF
Spend 2 mins thinking of a question to ask somebody
who thinks differently to you
Be prepared to present your case and answer
questions
16. Think and answer
What have you learnt
today?
How have you learnt it?
What will you do now to
make sure you remember
it?
17.
18. Group 1:IVF Group 2: Euthanasia
Group 3: Pro-life
Group 4: abortion
Group 5: quality
of life
Group 6: sanctity
of life
19. Reconciliation conflict Qur’an Jihad
moral evil natural evil innocent Jesus
sin freewill Allah war killing protest
activist Quakers obligation peace
forgiveness Desmond Tutu Bible
Muslim Christian
23. We are learning to
Know and understand
the Christian and
Muslim views on IVF
Know my own thoughts
on IVF
By the end of the lesson I
will
Be able to explain these
by answering an exam
question
24.
25. Christians believe that God
gave us the medical
knowledge to help infertile
couples and we should use it.
Some accept IVF if the sperm
and the egg belong to the
biological parents
Some accept IVF as they
believe it is the most
compassionate thing to do for
Infertile couples
In the Bible God brings
happiness to infertile couples
by giving them a child.
26. However some Christians
are against IVF
Christians believe that a
child is a gift from God and
is part of His plan
Some do not think the cost
of IVF is justified when so
many children are starving
Some do not accept IVF
because unused fertilised
embryos are destroyed
Some see Doctors as
playing God
27. Christians believe that a child is a G---- from God.
They believe that IVF is very e-------- and the money
could be spent on feeding children who are starving.
Christians also believe IVF is wrong because spare e----
-- are d-------- and this goes against the Sanctity of life.
The view that all life is s------.
However other Christians believe that IVF is
acceptable. They say if God gave us the m------
knowledge and ability to help i-------- couples we
should use it. Some Christians say as long as the egg
and the sperm belong to the b--------- parents it is a
kind and c------------ thing to do.
28.
29. ‘Money spent on IVF would be better spent saving life’ 8
marks.
Do you agree? Give reasons and evidence for your
answer showing that you have thought about more
than one point of view. You must include reference to
religious beliefs in your answer
30.
31. Think?????
What do Christians
believe about IVF?
What do Muslims believe
about IVF?
What is the Sanctity of
life?
What do you think about
this issues?