This document discusses the diagnostic criteria and challenges of schizoaffective disorder. It notes that schizoaffective disorder involves a combination of schizophrenia and mood disorder symptoms. However, the diagnostic criteria have varied between classifications and the disorder has very low inter-rater reliability. Differential diagnosis is also difficult given similarities to other psychotic and mood disorders. In summary, schizoaffective disorder remains a controversial and diagnostically complex condition.
2. Kraepelinian
dichotomy
Emil Kraepelin (1896): divided psychosis into two groups,
i.e. Dementia Praecox & Manic-Depressive Insanity.
Dementia Praecox → Schizophrenia
(Eugen Bleuler; 1857 – 1939)
Manic-Depressive Insanity → Affective disorder
overarching category for mood disorders
(Henry Maudsley;1835-1918)
3. The Acute Schizoaffective Psychoses
Jacob Kasanin (1897-1946) a Russian-born,
American-trained psychiatrist who introduced the
term ‘schizoaffective psychoses’. In 1933 in The
American Journal of Psychiatry, he published a
paper entitled '"The Acute Schizoaffective
Psychoses" In his article Kasanin described 9 case
studies who had both schizophrenic symptoms
comorbid with affective symptoms.
4. Inclusion in the classification system
• DSM-I (1952): Schizophrenic reaction, schizoaffective type.
• DSM-II (1968):Schizophrenia, schizoaffective type. (excited / depressed)
• DSM-III (1980):schizoaffective disorder (a separate diagnosisunder the
heading:Psychotic Disorders not Elsewhere Classified)
• DSM III-R (1987): introduced the first operationalised diagnostic criteria
for schizoaffective disorder.
• DSM-IV (1994): schizoaffective disorder; bipolar & depressive types (in the
chapter: schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders)
• DSM-5 (2013): schizoaffective disorder; bipolar & depressive types (in the
chapter: SchizophreniaSpectrum and Other Psychotic Disorders)
❖ ICD-9 (1977):the first appearance of schizoaffective in ICD; as a subtype
of schizophrenia.
5. What is schizoaffective
disorder?
• Since its original description, over 24
different definitions have been
generated (Winokur et al 1996).
• Schizoaffective disorder is a mental
disorder that is marked by a
combination of schizophrenia and a
mood disorder.
6. Diagnostic
Criteria:
DSM-5
• A. An uninterrupted period of illness during which there is a major
mood episode (major depressive or manic) concurrent with Criterion A
of schizophrenia. Note: The major depressive episode mustinclude
Criterion A1: Depressed mood.
• B. Delusions or hallucinations for 2 or more weeks in the absence
of a major mood episode (depressive or manic) during the lifetime
duration of the illness.
• C. Symptoms that meet criteria for a major mood episode are
present for the majority of the total duration of the active and residual
portions of the illness.
• D. The disturbance is not attributable to the effects of a substance
(e.g., a drug of abuse, a medication) or another medical condition.
❑ Specify whether:
o Bipolartype
o Depressive type
7. Diagnostic
Criteria:
DSM-5
A. An uninterruptedperiod of illnessduring which there is a major mood
episode (major depressive or manic) concurrent with Criterion A of schizophrenia.
Note: The major depressive episode must include Criterion A1: Depressed mood.
• Criterion A Schizophrenia:Two (or more) of the following, each present for a
significant portion of time during a 1-month period (or less if successfully
treated). At least one of these must be (1), (2), or (3):
1. Delusions.
2. Hallucinations.
3. Disorganized speech (e.g., frequent derailment or incoherence).
4. Grossly disorganised or catatonicbehaviour.
5. Negativesymptoms (i.e., diminished emotionalexpression or avolition).
❖ICD-11: All diagnosticrequirements for Schizophreniashould be met
concurrently with the full diagnostic requirementsof a Mood Episode.
8. Diagnostic
Criteria:
DSM-5
B. Delusions or hallucinations for 2 or more weeks
in the absence of a major mood episode (depressive or
manic) during the lifetime duration of the illness.
o This differentiates schizoaffectivedisorder from
mood disorders.
o Reliability of self-reports?
o A meta-analysisof 53 studies showed a 28.6%
prevalence of comorbid depressive symptoms in
schizophrenia (Wen Li 2020).
❖ ICD-11:does not require a period of psychotic
symptoms without affectivesymptoms
9. Diagnostic
Criteria:
DSM-5
C. Symptomsthat meet criteria for a major mood
episode are present for the majority of the total duration of
the active and residual portions of the illness.
o DSM IV: a substantialportion of the total duration
➢ Majority: > 50% of the total duration of the illness!
➢ Diagnostic Fluctuation!
10. Diagnostic
Criteria:
DSM-5
D. The disturbance is not attributable to the
effects of a substance (e.g., a drug of abuse, a
medication) or another medical condition.
❖ Substance misuse can alter the picture of the
original mental disorder:
o Precipitating incongruent psychotic symptomsin people
with a mood disorder.
o Precipitating mood symptoms in people with
schizophrenia.
11. DSM 5 versus ICD-11
• People who meet the DSM
5 criteria for schizoaffective
disorder most probably will be
diagnosed with schizophrenia
under ICD 11.
• People who meet the ICD-
11 criteria for schizoaffective
disorder most probably will be
diagnosed with a primary mood
disorder under DSM 5.
12. Demographics
❖Vague of diagnostic criteria → No large-scale studies
on the epidemiology, incidence, or prevalence.
❖Overall, the clinical and demographic characteristics
are in-between those of bipolar disorder and of
schizophrenia but more similar to schizophrenia.
o Prognosis: Bipolar Disorder > Schizoaffective >
Schizophrenia
o 30% of cases occur between the ages of 25 and 35
o Lifetime prevalence appears to be around 0.3%
o Gender prevalence: Females > Males
13. Diagnostic Reliability
Since its inception, Schizoaffective Disorder diagnosis has been
controversial in terms of its diagnostic necessity, validity and
reliability. (Hung et al., 2018).
"schizoaffective disorder is a nosological nuisance but a clinical
reality" Marneros 2003.
15. Diagnostic
Reliability
(JE Schwartz · 2000)
➢Data from the Israeli National Psychiatric Registry
on 16,341 adults diagnosed with schizophrenia or
schizoaffective, hospitalised at least twice in 1963–
2017, were analysed: Reliability between the last
and first diagnosis was 60 % for schizoaffective
disorder and 94 % for Schizophrenia (Florentin,
2023).
Percentof patients retaining diagnosis over 24 months
schizophrenia 92%
Bipolar disorder 83%
Major depression 74%
Psychosis not otherwise specified 44%
Schizoaffective disorder 36%
Brief psychosis 27%
17. Take Home Messages
SCHIZOAFFECTIVE DISORDER SHOULD NOT
BE A COMMON DIAGNOSIS.
WHENEVER YOU SEE THE DIAGNOSIS OF
SCHIZOAFFECTIVE DISORDER TRY TO BE A
SCHIZODETECTIVE.
PLEASE THINK TWICE BEFORE INITIATING
THE DIAGNOSIS OF SCHIZOAFFECTIVE
DISORDER.