SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
IRC 2010 POLICY DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION PROJECTS  M.Kapsali,
Outline  - Policy design 	- Implementation instruments 		- Projects 			- Results 				- Systems Thinking  Questions?
Policy design = goals + implementation  boundary  Problematization, 	Instruments 	Implementation 		Target goals and plans 			agent- project 	Other stakeholders  boundary  boundary  Causality- problematization Evaluation systems  Implementation agents- projects and targets
Policy design  Planning – designers and psychologists- managerialistsReflexive design emergent- bottom up Systemic design both    4 Top- down implementation instruments Bottom- up  implementation  Synthesis, network  Holistic (How?)
17 multiple case studies Antimicrobial Resistance policy  Information Society eHealth- developing technologies for health 3 national EARSS projects- cases  4 IST projects- research and development  9 eTEN projects- market validation or marketization of a service
Results  4 types of tension, goal-goal, goal- instrument, instrument- instrument and evaluation- other components   Change management in problematization Focus on the boundary  Different types of pressures on the policy- project boundary with different effects  Functional instruments and operational specifications- provision of flexibility  Attention diverted from the target boundary and management tasks do not deal with change
Systems Thinking constructs     1. Boundary tensions 2. Boundary management (managing relations between actors within an institutional space)3. Equifinality (achieving a goal through multiple paths)- management of operational change
Application of Systems Thinking constructs  Boundary tensions  Boundary management  Equifinality    Goal- goal, goal- instruments  and other tensions 2 types of instruments  Spanning, buffering, bringing up team identity Flexibility to manage change vs the other operational criteria
Questions

More Related Content

What's hot

12 ipt 0104 making decisions
12 ipt 0104   making decisions12 ipt 0104   making decisions
12 ipt 0104 making decisionsctedds
 
System Analysis and Design
System Analysis and DesignSystem Analysis and Design
System Analysis and DesignZakaria Hossain
 
INTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERINGINTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERINGmuhammadusman0909
 
Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)
Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)
Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)Ajeng Savitri
 
Platinum 5th sem project
Platinum 5th sem project Platinum 5th sem project
Platinum 5th sem project Pramesh_Devkota
 
Project Gestalt Program Success
Project Gestalt Program SuccessProject Gestalt Program Success
Project Gestalt Program Successslideshareneilj
 
Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...
Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...
Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...Sandun Dasanayake
 
System Analysis and Design (SAD)
System Analysis and Design (SAD)System Analysis and Design (SAD)
System Analysis and Design (SAD)Sachith Perera
 
SYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment help
SYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment helpSYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment help
SYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment helpjohn mayer
 
Complete Introduction to Business Data Analysis
Complete Introduction to Business Data AnalysisComplete Introduction to Business Data Analysis
Complete Introduction to Business Data AnalysisSam Dias
 
System analysis and design
System analysis and design System analysis and design
System analysis and design Razan Al Ryalat
 

What's hot (11)

12 ipt 0104 making decisions
12 ipt 0104   making decisions12 ipt 0104   making decisions
12 ipt 0104 making decisions
 
System Analysis and Design
System Analysis and DesignSystem Analysis and Design
System Analysis and Design
 
INTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERINGINTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERING
INTRODUCTION TO SOFTWARE ENGINEERING
 
Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)
Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)
Systems Analyst and Its Roles (2)
 
Platinum 5th sem project
Platinum 5th sem project Platinum 5th sem project
Platinum 5th sem project
 
Project Gestalt Program Success
Project Gestalt Program SuccessProject Gestalt Program Success
Project Gestalt Program Success
 
Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...
Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...
Software Architecture Decision-Making Practices and Challenges: An Industrial...
 
System Analysis and Design (SAD)
System Analysis and Design (SAD)System Analysis and Design (SAD)
System Analysis and Design (SAD)
 
SYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment help
SYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment helpSYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment help
SYSTEM ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Assignment help
 
Complete Introduction to Business Data Analysis
Complete Introduction to Business Data AnalysisComplete Introduction to Business Data Analysis
Complete Introduction to Business Data Analysis
 
System analysis and design
System analysis and design System analysis and design
System analysis and design
 

Viewers also liked

Siklus Kebijakan Publik Implementasi
Siklus Kebijakan Publik ImplementasiSiklus Kebijakan Publik Implementasi
Siklus Kebijakan Publik Implementasikuliaaah
 
Growing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry Dowell
Growing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry DowellGrowing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry Dowell
Growing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry DowellDowell Management
 
The Top 5 CRM Implementation Mistakes
The Top 5 CRM Implementation MistakesThe Top 5 CRM Implementation Mistakes
The Top 5 CRM Implementation MistakesRedspire Ltd
 
EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...
EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...
EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...EY
 
Formulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In Nigeria
Formulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In NigeriaFormulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In Nigeria
Formulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In NigeriaROCARE / ERNWACA
 
POLICY MAKING PROCESS
POLICY MAKING PROCESSPOLICY MAKING PROCESS
POLICY MAKING PROCESSYammie Daud
 
The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017
The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017
The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017LinkedIn
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Siklus Kebijakan Publik Implementasi
Siklus Kebijakan Publik ImplementasiSiklus Kebijakan Publik Implementasi
Siklus Kebijakan Publik Implementasi
 
Growing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry Dowell
Growing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry DowellGrowing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry Dowell
Growing Your Public Policy Toolbox by Larry Dowell
 
Wildavsky
WildavskyWildavsky
Wildavsky
 
The Top 5 CRM Implementation Mistakes
The Top 5 CRM Implementation MistakesThe Top 5 CRM Implementation Mistakes
The Top 5 CRM Implementation Mistakes
 
EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...
EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...
EY Human Capital Conference 2012: Building a global mobility policy from the ...
 
Formulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In Nigeria
Formulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In NigeriaFormulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In Nigeria
Formulation And Implementation Of Educational Policies In Nigeria
 
POLICY MAKING PROCESS
POLICY MAKING PROCESSPOLICY MAKING PROCESS
POLICY MAKING PROCESS
 
The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017
The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017
The Top Skills That Can Get You Hired in 2017
 

Similar to Policy Design@IRC 2010

Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...
Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...
Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...ILRI
 
Introduction to Data4Impact
Introduction to Data4ImpactIntroduction to Data4Impact
Introduction to Data4ImpactData4Impact
 
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference  Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference Maria Kapsali
 
Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.
  Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.  Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.
Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.pasicUganda
 
Dream It 09[1].06.11 Batpurev
Dream It 09[1].06.11 BatpurevDream It 09[1].06.11 Batpurev
Dream It 09[1].06.11 Batpurevpanall2009
 
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)Data4Impact
 
20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...
20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...
20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...OpenAIRE
 
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...Data4Impact
 
eCF - Competenties Michel Noordzij
eCF - Competenties Michel NoordzijeCF - Competenties Michel Noordzij
eCF - Competenties Michel NoordzijMichel Noordzij
 
Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07
Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07
Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07Wolfgang_Polt
 
Images of Information Systems
Images of Information SystemsImages of Information Systems
Images of Information Systemsguestead93f3
 
Pp slide set 13 workforce planning
Pp slide set 13   workforce planningPp slide set 13   workforce planning
Pp slide set 13 workforce planningTricordant
 
project evaluation of Business Subject1.docx
project evaluation of Business Subject1.docxproject evaluation of Business Subject1.docx
project evaluation of Business Subject1.docxvenkatasivakumar6
 
Insights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulations
Insights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulationsInsights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulations
Insights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulationsNick Hart, Ph.D.
 

Similar to Policy Design@IRC 2010 (20)

Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...
Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...
Enhancing quality of research 4 development: Initial ideas for design and imp...
 
Introduction to Data4Impact
Introduction to Data4ImpactIntroduction to Data4Impact
Introduction to Data4Impact
 
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference  Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Hague conference
 
Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.
  Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.  Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.
Introducing Policy Implementation and Evaluation.
 
SDLC_Intro.ppt
SDLC_Intro.pptSDLC_Intro.ppt
SDLC_Intro.ppt
 
Dream It 09[1].06.11 Batpurev
Dream It 09[1].06.11 BatpurevDream It 09[1].06.11 Batpurev
Dream It 09[1].06.11 Batpurev
 
M&E.ppt
M&E.pptM&E.ppt
M&E.ppt
 
Logical framework analysis
Logical framework analysisLogical framework analysis
Logical framework analysis
 
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology and results (Workshop in Brussels)
 
20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...
20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...
20190528_Data4Impact_Open Science and Big data in support of measuring R&I In...
 
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...
Presentation on Data4Impact methodology & results in the workshop on the use ...
 
Ippm01 day 04
Ippm01 day 04Ippm01 day 04
Ippm01 day 04
 
eCF - Competenties Michel Noordzij
eCF - Competenties Michel NoordzijeCF - Competenties Michel Noordzij
eCF - Competenties Michel Noordzij
 
02_Ch2a.pptx
02_Ch2a.pptx02_Ch2a.pptx
02_Ch2a.pptx
 
Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07
Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07
Wp.Priority Setting, Paris 29 30 Oct. 07
 
Images of Information Systems
Images of Information SystemsImages of Information Systems
Images of Information Systems
 
Pp slide set 13 workforce planning
Pp slide set 13   workforce planningPp slide set 13   workforce planning
Pp slide set 13 workforce planning
 
project evaluation of Business Subject1.docx
project evaluation of Business Subject1.docxproject evaluation of Business Subject1.docx
project evaluation of Business Subject1.docx
 
Ms4 lfa
Ms4 lfaMs4 lfa
Ms4 lfa
 
Insights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulations
Insights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulationsInsights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulations
Insights from Program Evaluation for Retrospective Reviews of regulations
 

More from Maria Kapsali

Prouska and kapsali_book_presentation
Prouska and kapsali_book_presentationProuska and kapsali_book_presentation
Prouska and kapsali_book_presentationMaria Kapsali
 
Mixing Methods Tutorial
Mixing Methods Tutorial Mixing Methods Tutorial
Mixing Methods Tutorial Maria Kapsali
 
Design London DOME poster
Design London DOME posterDesign London DOME poster
Design London DOME posterMaria Kapsali
 
POMS improving patient care through modularity
POMS  improving patient care through modularity POMS  improving patient care through modularity
POMS improving patient care through modularity Maria Kapsali
 
Network organisations and cross organisational learning
Network organisations and cross organisational learningNetwork organisations and cross organisational learning
Network organisations and cross organisational learningMaria Kapsali
 
Simulation design london
Simulation design londonSimulation design london
Simulation design londonMaria Kapsali
 
Systems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project managementSystems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project managementMaria Kapsali
 
Systemic relations as dynamic capabilities
Systemic relations as dynamic capabilitiesSystemic relations as dynamic capabilities
Systemic relations as dynamic capabilitiesMaria Kapsali
 
Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton
Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton
Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton Maria Kapsali
 
Poster druid maria kapsali 3
Poster druid maria kapsali 3Poster druid maria kapsali 3
Poster druid maria kapsali 3Maria Kapsali
 
Systems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project managementSystems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project managementMaria Kapsali
 
Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh
Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference EdinburghSystems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh
Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference EdinburghMaria Kapsali
 
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the Hague
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the HaguePolicy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the Hague
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the HagueMaria Kapsali
 
Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009
Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009
Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009Maria Kapsali
 
Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...
Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...
Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...Maria Kapsali
 
Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009 presentation
Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009  presentation Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009  presentation
Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009 presentation Maria Kapsali
 
Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...
Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...
Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...Maria Kapsali
 

More from Maria Kapsali (20)

Prouska and kapsali_book_presentation
Prouska and kapsali_book_presentationProuska and kapsali_book_presentation
Prouska and kapsali_book_presentation
 
Mixing Methods Tutorial
Mixing Methods Tutorial Mixing Methods Tutorial
Mixing Methods Tutorial
 
Design London DOME poster
Design London DOME posterDesign London DOME poster
Design London DOME poster
 
POMS improving patient care through modularity
POMS  improving patient care through modularity POMS  improving patient care through modularity
POMS improving patient care through modularity
 
Network organisations and cross organisational learning
Network organisations and cross organisational learningNetwork organisations and cross organisational learning
Network organisations and cross organisational learning
 
Simulation design london
Simulation design londonSimulation design london
Simulation design london
 
Poster systems
Poster systemsPoster systems
Poster systems
 
Systems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project managementSystems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project management
 
Systemic relations as dynamic capabilities
Systemic relations as dynamic capabilitiesSystemic relations as dynamic capabilities
Systemic relations as dynamic capabilities
 
Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton
Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton
Policy- Project Relationality @ HaCIRIC 2009 Brighton
 
Poster druid maria kapsali 3
Poster druid maria kapsali 3Poster druid maria kapsali 3
Poster druid maria kapsali 3
 
Systems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project managementSystems thinking in innovation project management
Systems thinking in innovation project management
 
Dc
DcDc
Dc
 
Ha ciric 2010
Ha ciric 2010Ha ciric 2010
Ha ciric 2010
 
Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh
Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference EdinburghSystems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh
Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh
 
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the Hague
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the HaguePolicy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the Hague
Policy Design @ HSREPP 2010 Conference the Hague
 
Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009
Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009
Open- Closed Systems in innovation projects@ UK Systems Society Conference 2009
 
Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...
Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...
Systems Thinking in Innovation Project Management @ EURAM 2010: Systems Think...
 
Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009 presentation
Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009  presentation Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009  presentation
Relationality presentation @ HaCIRIC 2009 presentation
 
Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...
Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...
Project relations as a Dynamic Capability @ EURAM 2010: Systemic Relations As...
 

Policy Design@IRC 2010

  • 1. IRC 2010 POLICY DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION PROJECTS M.Kapsali,
  • 2. Outline - Policy design - Implementation instruments - Projects - Results - Systems Thinking Questions?
  • 3. Policy design = goals + implementation boundary Problematization, Instruments Implementation Target goals and plans agent- project Other stakeholders boundary boundary Causality- problematization Evaluation systems Implementation agents- projects and targets
  • 4. Policy design Planning – designers and psychologists- managerialistsReflexive design emergent- bottom up Systemic design both 4 Top- down implementation instruments Bottom- up implementation Synthesis, network Holistic (How?)
  • 5. 17 multiple case studies Antimicrobial Resistance policy Information Society eHealth- developing technologies for health 3 national EARSS projects- cases 4 IST projects- research and development 9 eTEN projects- market validation or marketization of a service
  • 6. Results 4 types of tension, goal-goal, goal- instrument, instrument- instrument and evaluation- other components Change management in problematization Focus on the boundary Different types of pressures on the policy- project boundary with different effects Functional instruments and operational specifications- provision of flexibility Attention diverted from the target boundary and management tasks do not deal with change
  • 7.
  • 8. Systems Thinking constructs 1. Boundary tensions 2. Boundary management (managing relations between actors within an institutional space)3. Equifinality (achieving a goal through multiple paths)- management of operational change
  • 9. Application of Systems Thinking constructs Boundary tensions Boundary management Equifinality Goal- goal, goal- instruments and other tensions 2 types of instruments Spanning, buffering, bringing up team identity Flexibility to manage change vs the other operational criteria