Comparison Charts for Social and Behavioral Learning
Assignment Instructions:
These charts provide a method to compare and contrast theories of social and behavioral learning. Each area (basic principles, stages, classroom application, and criticism) should be addressed for each theorist/theory. Just copy the chart sbelow and insert the appropriate information. Remember to provide in-text citations and references.
Submission Instructions:
Save the file as "Yourname_CCSoBeL_Assignment"
While inside the submission area click the "Browse My Computer" button below to upload your assignment as an attachment.
Once attached, click the "Submit" button.
Social (Cognitive) Learning
Theorist
Basic Principles of Theory
Stages/Components
Classroom Application
Criticism/Problems
Bandura
Vygotsky
Bowlby
(Cognitive) Behavioral Learning
Theorist
Basic Principles of Theory
Stages/Components
Classroom Application
Criticism/Problems
Skinner
Meichenbaum
Scoring Guidelines:
I. Social and Behavioral Learning
Points Available: 40
Theory
Unacceptable
Acceptable
Target
Bandura (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete; references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate, and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained; references and citations are provided (8 points)
Vygotsky (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete; references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate, and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained; references and citations are provided (8 points)
Bowlby (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete; references and some citations are provided (6points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate, and complete; key ideas are clearly staged and explained; references and citations are provided (8 points)
Skinner (Behavioral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete; references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on al ...
Comparison Charts for Social and Behavioral LearningAssignment I.docx
1. Comparison Charts for Social and Behavioral Learning
Assignment Instructions:
These charts provide a method to compare and contrast theories
of social and behavioral learning. Each area (basic principles,
stages, classroom application, and criticism) should be
addressed for each theorist/theory. Just copy the chart sbelow
and insert the appropriate information. Remember to provide
in-text citations and references.
Submission Instructions:
Save the file as "Yourname_CCSoBeL_Assignment"
While inside the submission area click the "Browse My
Computer" button below to upload your assignment as an
attachment.
Once attached, click the "Submit" button.
Social (Cognitive) Learning
Theorist
Basic Principles of Theory
Stages/Components
Classroom Application
Criticism/Problems
Bandura
Vygotsky
Bowlby
2. (Cognitive) Behavioral Learning
Theorist
Basic Principles of Theory
Stages/Components
Classroom Application
Criticism/Problems
Skinner
Meichenbaum
Scoring Guidelines:
I. Social and Behavioral Learning
Points Available: 40
Theory
Unacceptable
Acceptable
Target
Bandura (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
3. and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Vygotsky (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Bowlby (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly staged and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Skinner (Behavioral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Meichenbaum (Behavioral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
27. Steady, high response rate Slow decrease in response rate
112
Guidelines, Example Chart , and Scoring Guidelines for
Theories/Models Comparison Charts
Basic Guidelines and Objective: It can be difficult to make
distinctions between the various theoretical models studied in
this course. Some of the theories/models use the same terms
but might attach different meanings to them. Other theories use
different terms to refer to similar concepts. To help, students
are to create charts to compare major theories across several
categories. The objective of these charts is to help distinguish
the finer points between the theories with emphasis on
classroom application of the theories.
Layout Directions: Microsoft Word is the preferred program to
create your project. Suggestions for designing this project
would be to create a table for each theory in Word and use page
breaks between each theory. Choose the landscape option in
Page layout and insert a 10-column (nine dimensions plus name
of theory) by 2-row table (titles of dimensions, as illustrated
below, and then details of each dimension). Use short
statements and include definitions of terms if you are not sure
of the meaning of some of the terminology. Since using bullet
points causes information to automatically indent into your
column space, you might consider using asterisks for your major
points as shown in the Psychoanalytical example below.
Another space-saving suggestion is to highlight your cells,
choose the Layout tab, select Cell Margins, and set the default
cell margins to 0”. Doing so allows you to maximize the use of
space within the cells.
Information Sources: You can use your textbook and outside
resources such as journals or internet sources (no Wikipedia),
but you must properly cite and reference (must have a reference
28. page which corresponds to all in-text citations) APA style (6th
edition) all information you use from ALL sources used to
answer your questions. Common terms/language relative to
each theory can be used. Otherwise: PARAPHRASE AS MUCH
AS POSSIBLE--you will learn the particulars of the theories
more easily if you can explain the information in your own
words! Turnitin will be used to analyze your projects at the
discretion of the instructor.
Be Creative: Use your creativity to create the project. For
example, you can insert graphics or examples (your own) to
further explain certain points. You can use colored fonts to
differentiate between the theories/approaches/models and
include pictures of either the theorist(s) or icons representative
of each theory. Techniques like these make the project
information more memorable.
Use the Charts: These charts can be used as part of your notes
and will make excellent study guides when preparing for
advanced testing.
Example Chart on Related Topic
Note: This single-theory chart is provided to show the
formatting for citations followed by a reference page.. Each of
the three chart assignments must have in-text citations for ALL
information from outside sources, as well as a reference page.
Theory
Basic Principles of Theory
Stages/Components
Classroom Application
Criticism/Problems
Psychoanalytic Theory of Personality Development
* Sigmund Freud’s theory involves the belief that personality is
formed from unconscious conflicts between the components of
the mind--the id (what is immediately wanted), the ego (the
mediator between the id and superego), and the superego (what
29. is the right thing).
*Freud postulated that personality develops during childhood
and is influenced by five psychosexual stages; Freud called
these stages his psychosexual theory of development.
*During each stage, a youngster faces internal conflict between
biological drives and social expectations; if the youngster can
successfully steer through these internal conflicts, then he/she
will master each developmental stage and ultimately develop a
mature personality.
(“Psychodynamic Perspectives on Personality,” n.d.)
· Freud’s Psychosexual Stages of Development
· *Oral Stage (0-1 year) In the first stage, the libido is centered
in a baby's mouth. The id is present from birth.
· *Anal Stage (1-3 years)—In this stage the libido is centered
on the anus and the expelling or withholding of feces. The ego
develops in these first two stages.
· *Phallic Stage (3 to 5/6 years)—In this stage the libido is
focused on the sexual organs and masturbation is not
uncommon. The superego develops in this stage
· *Latency Stage (5/6 years to puberty)—In this stage the libido
is not centered on sexual motivation.
· *Genital Stage (puberty to adult)—In this stage the libido is
focused on sexual intercourse
(McLeod, 2017)
*Being aware of Freud’s psychosexual stages of development
can help a teacher understand where students are regarding
personality development and lead to a better understanding of
individual differences, especially the motivation behind certain
behaviors.
*Activities for elementary classes might involve reading stories
to children about making good choices in positive behaviors.
*Activities for middle/high school that are based on this theory
might include debates on controversial moral dilemmas such as
who to save in a lifeboat (e.g., doctor or best friend); whether
30. or not to take money/valuables found on the street; etc.
(Sass, 2012)
*Freud focused only on the sexual aspect of personality
development. He did not account for the social, emotional, or
other aspects that lead to a mature personality.
*Freud’s psychosexual stages were at fixed ages; maturation
rates were not considered.
(“Psychodynamic Perspectives on Personality,” n.d.)
References
McLeod, S. (2017). Psychosexual Stages. Retrieved from
https://www.simplypsychology.org/psychosexual.html
Psychodynamic Perspectives on Personality. (n.d.). Lumen
Learning. Retrieved from
https://courses.lumenlearning.com/boundless-
psychology/chapter/psychodynamic-perspectives-on-
personality/
Sass, E. (2012). Program Goal II: Student Learning. Knowledge
Base for Teacher Education. Retrieved from
https://www.csbsju.edu/education/our-approach/knowledge-
base/kb-ii
Scoring Guidelines for Comparison Charts
I. Cognitive, Social, Moral, and SocioEmotional Development
Points Available: 64
Theory
Unacceptable
Acceptable
Target
Piaget (Cognitive)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
31. Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and all citations are provided (8 points)
Vygotsky (Cognitive)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Bronfenbrenner (Cognitive)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Erikson (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
32. Piaget (Moral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Kohlberg (Moral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Gilligan (Moral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Erikson/Marcia (Socioemotional)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
33. references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
II. Social and Behavioral Learning
Points Available: 40
Theory
Unacceptable
Acceptable
Target
Bandura (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Vygotsky (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Bowlby (Social)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
34. accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly staged and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Skinner (Behavioral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Meichenbaum (Behavioral)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly staged and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
III. Cognitive Learning
Points Available: 32
Theory
Unacceptable
Acceptable
Target
Information Processing Model of Learning (updated Atkinson-
Shiffrin model)
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
35. inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and all citations are provided (8 points)
Levels of Processing Theory
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Schema Theory
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;
references and citations are provided (8 points)
Edward Tolman
Four Categories
Information on one or more of the four categories is missing or
inaccurate; references and citations are not provided (2 points)
Information on all four categories is provided; information is
accurate, but explanations of key ideas are vague or incomplete;
references and some citations are provided (6 points)
Information on all four categories is comprehensive, accurate,
and complete; key ideas are clearly stated and explained;