4. Primary Bone Healing
• Occurs when there has been
Anatomical Reduction and
interfragmentary compression,
leading to Absolute Stability
• New blood vessels grow into any
small gaps that exist (gap
healing)
• mesenchymal cells differentiate
into osteoblasts, laying down
lamellar bone in small gaps and
woven bone in large gaps
5. Primary Bone Healing
• Osteoclasts form Cutting Cones
that tunnel across the fracture site
wherever there is contact between
the bone ends or a minute gap.
• Blood vessels and osteoblasts follow,
laying down lamellar bone in the
form of new osteons
• This process of newly formed
osteons bridging the gap may take
many months and may be difficult
to see on an X-ray
• This is the same process as the
remodelling phase (stage IV) of
secondary bone healing
7. Secondary Bone Healing
With Relative Stability, strain or
movement at the fracture site
stimulates secondary healing by two
discrete processes:
1. Periosteal Bony Callus
(Intramembranous
Ossification):
• Periosteal multipotent cells
differentiate into osteoprogenitor
cells, producing bone directly without
first forming cartilage.
• Early hard callus at the fracture site
periphery, if no extensive periosteal
stripping.
8. Secondary Bone Healing
With Relative Stability, strain or movement
at the fracture site stimulates secondary
healing by two discrete processes:
2. Fibrocartilaginous Bridging Callus
(Endochondral Ossification):
• occurs simultaneously between adjacent
bone ends, and within the surrounding soft
tissued, involving the formation of
fibrocartilage, becomes calcified then
replaced by osteoid or woven bone.
• dependent on some movement occurring
at the fracture site (strain).
• Rigid fixation inhibits the differentiation
of cells and the formation of callus.
10. Perren’s Strain Theory
• After any form of fixation or immobilization, a
fracture that is loaded will undergo some
degree of movement or strain.
• This may be compressive, tensile, bending or
torsional.
• Strain at fracture site decreased with
increased fracture gap or greater surface area
• metaphyseal fractures (larger bone diameter)
• multifragmentary or segmental fractures (overall
strain shared among the individual fragments)
• Fracture callus becomes increasingly stiff with
time
• gelatinous granulation tissue -> soft callus ->
hard bony callus.
11. Perren’s Strain Theory
• Each of these tissues is able to
tolerate a different amount of
strain:
• Granulation tissue: up to 100 per
cent.
• Fibrous connective tissue: up to 17
per cent.
• Fibrocartilage: 2–10 per cent.
• Lamellar bone: <2 per cent.
12. Perren’s Strain Theory
• High Interfragmentary Strain = Granulation tissue
formation
• as strain decreases with time cartilage and bone form
• If with absolute stability = strain low
• inhibits callus formation
• allows direct (primary) Haversian remodelling
• If fragments fixed rigidly but with a gap
• primary bone healing (cutting cones) may Not be able
to bridge the gap
• Lack of strain = inhibits callus formation and
secondary healing
• May predispose to non-union.
• If with relative stability
• more strain-tolerant cartilaginous callus required to
stiffen the fracture site before hard woven bony callus
forms and replaces it (secondary healing).
• A larger strain produces a bigger callus
Absolute Stability means no motion between fracture surfaces under functional load
The process is very intolerant of strain (movement) at the fracture site.
Absolute Stability means no motion between fracture surfaces under functional load
The process is very intolerant of strain (movement) at the fracture site.
Relative Stability (some controlled motion between fracture surfaces under functional load)
Relative Stability (some controlled motion between fracture surfaces under functional load)
Haematoma from ruptured blood vessels forms fibrin clot. Damaged
tissue and degranulated platelets release signalling molecules, growth
factors and cytokines.
Migration of inflammatory cells into the haematoma occurs, responding to
local growth factors and cytokines (IL-1, IL-6, TGF-β super-family including
BMPs, PDGF, FGF, IGF).
Proliferation, differentiation and matrix synthesis as haematoma is replaced
by granulation tissue. Capillary in-growth (angiogenesis) and recruitment of
fibroblasts, mesenchymal cells and osteoprogenitor cells. The periosteum
plays an important role in this process.
Cell types involved include PMNs, macrophages and then fibroblasts.
At necrotic bone ends, bone resorption is mediated by osteoclasts and
removal of tissue debris by macrophages.
Increased cellularity, with proliferation, differentiation and soft callus neovascularization.
Callus is a combination of fibrous tissue, cartilage and woven bone
Intramembranous (bony/periosteal) callus = primary callus response: type I
collagen (osteoid) laid down from periosteal osteoblasts in the cambium
layer as periosteal bony callus or woven bone. This is hard callus but it does
not bridge the fracture.
Endochondral (fibrocartilaginous/bridging) callus = bridging external callus:
multipotential cells differentiate to form chondroblasts and fibroblasts within
the granulating callus, which produce the type II cartilaginous and fibrous
elements of the matrix (chondroid). Chondroblasts then calcify the chondroid
matrix they have produced, creating calcified fibrocartilage or soft callus.
Medullary callus: this is a later process and can slowly unite the fracture if
external callus fails.
Calcified soft callus is resorbed by chondroclasts and invaded by new blood vessels.
These bring with them osteoblast precursors that produce the
bony (type I) elements of the matrix (osteoid) and then mineralize it to form
woven bone.
Soft calcified chondroid callus becomes hard mineralized osteoid callus.
Bony bridging continues peripherally as subperiosteal new bone formation. At
this point the fracture is united, solid and pain-free to movement.
Once the fracture has united, the hard callus is remodelled from woven
bone to hard, dense lamellar bone by a process of osteoclastic resorption
followed by osteoblastic bone formation. The medullary canal reforms at the
end of this process.
This is the same mechanism as for direct cortical, osteonal or primary bone
healing, seen following fracture fixation with absolute stability.
Bone assumes a configuration and shape based on stresses acting upon it
(Wolff’s law). Electric fields may play a role in Wolff’s law, with osteoclastic
activity being predominant on the electropositive tension side of bone and
osteoblastic activity on the electronegative compression side.
This is defined as lack of healing of a fracture
within the expected time, which varies with
the bone involved, e.g. distal radial fractures are
expected to heal by 6 weeks, scaphoid fractures
by 8 weeks, tibial fractures by 16 ± 4 weeks and
femoral fractures by 16 ± 4 weeks. The fracture
is bridged by soft tissue, the characteristics of
which are defined by the local blood supply
and mechanical conditions (usually cartilage
and/or fibrous tissue).
Clinical union is defined by the absence of
tenderness or motion at the fracture site with no
pain on loading, while radiological union is
defined as the presence of visible bridging
trabeculae on three out of four cortices on X-rays.
Hypertrophic non-union
A good blood supply but excessive strain at the
fracture site prevents progression of the callus
to form bone. These usually require
biomechanical stabilization to allow callus
progression to bone to occur.
Atrophic non-union
A poor blood supply is caused by soft-tissue
damage, periosteal stripping and/or fracture
comminution, which may occur at the time of
injury or during the exposure for internal
fixation. A fracture fixed with rigid fixation
(zero strain) and with the fragments distracted
will also lack stimulation of callus formation.
Atrophic non-unions require stabilization and
biological enhancement in order to heal.
SYSTEMIC ENHANCEMENT
Several systemic approaches have been
hypothesized, but none is in wide usage.
Examples include IGF-1 and IGF-2, growth
hormone, parathyroid hormone, vitamin D3
and prostaglandins.
DISTANT SKELETAL INJURY
Injury to bone marrow enhances bone healing
at distant sites. Corticotomy in a long bone has
a stimulatory affect on fracture healing
elsewhere in the same bone.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS
Piezoelectric currents are produced within bone
as the collagen fibres are deformed. Streaming
potentials (electrokinetic currents) are produced
as charged constituents of extracellular matrix
flow past the mineral phase of bone as it is
deformed. The endogenous electric fields
produced from these processes are integral to
bone homeostasis, influencing normal bone
modelling and remodelling. Clinical devices use
electromagnetic induction waveforms to try to
reproduce these potentials and so speed up or
augment fracture healing.
ULTRASOUND
There is good evidence that low-intensity
ultrasound can affect gene expression, stimulate
chondroblast and osteoblast activity, enhance
blood flow, and accelerate or augment fracture
healing in animal models. Pressure waves from
ultrasound may also stimulate differentiating
bone lining cells along the edges of a fracture.
MECHANICAL METHODS
Controlled axial micromotion has been shown
to enhance the healing of tibial fractures.