PASS Business Analytics 2015 - Most organizations lack an approach that lets them specify their requirements for BI or for analytics more broadly. Their ability to find opportunities for, and successfully use, more advanced analytics is limited. In this session, James Taylor will introduce decision modeling with DMN, a new standards-based approach to modeling decisions. He will introduce the core concepts of the approach and show how it can be used to drive more effective requirements for BI, dashboard and analytic projects. Attendees will learn how to begin with the decision in mind, defining their BI requirements in terms of the decision-making they need to improve.
1. A New Approach to
Defining BI
Requirements
April 20 - 22, 2015 | Santa Clara, CA
James Taylor
CEO
Decision Management Solutions
2. Your Presenter– James Taylor
• CEO of Decision Management Solutions
• We work with clients to improve their business by
applying analytic technology to automate & improve
decisions
• I have spent the last 12 years championing Decision Management and
developing Decision Management Systems
11. Decisions Are Made Because
A business cannot
progress any
further unless
they are made
A particular event
has occurred and
must be handled
A person must
choose between a
number of options
12. Different Kinds of Decisions
Strategic
Decisions
Tactical
Decisions
Operational
Decisions
13. Two Approaches To Decision-Making
Decision Support Systems
• Support implicit decisions
• Knowledge workers and
managers
Decision Management Systems
• Automation of explicit decisions
• Operational systems and front-line
staff
14. Today: Insight Without Impact
Beautiful visualizations
Powerful predictions
Gut decision-making
Dumb enterprise applications
15. Today: Requirements Telephone
• Decision Makers ask for data or analysis
• But the analysis does not help them make the decision
• So they ask for more data or different analysis
• But that doesn’t help either so they ask for yet another view
• And when that doesn’t help they stop using BI
and do something in Excel
• …
16. Effective BI Requirements
Clearly specify decision-
making needs
Engage the business, IT and BI
teams
Enable BI results to be
deployed
18. Decision Modeling and Notation (DMN)
• “… provide a common notation that is readily understandable by all business users...
DMN creates a standardized bridge for the gap between the business decision design
and decision implementation.”
• Use Cases
• Modeling Human Decision-making
• Modeling Requirements for automated Decision-making
• Implementing automated Decision-making
• OMG Specification – a peer to BPMN
• Decision Management Solutions, Escape Velocity, FICO, KUL, KPI, IBM, Model Systems,
Oracle, TIBCO, Visumpoint
• Approved. Finalization expected Q1 2015
20. Decision Modeling Approach
• Find Decision
• Describe Decision
• What is required to make this decision?
• Identify Information Requirements
• Identify Knowledge Requirements
• Identify Decision Requirements
22. Define Decisions
• Describe decisions with
• A question
• Possible answers
Q: Which marketing offer should be presented to
this customer during this interaction?
A: Any current, available marketing office in the
database
23. KPIs impacted by decision
Customer
Churn
Customer
Service
Calls
Service
Availability
… …
What is the best up
sell/cross-sell for this
customer?
* *
What is the price of this
service? * *
Can this customer buy this
service? * *
What retention offer should
we make this customer? *
…
Map Decisions To KPIs
24. Map Decisions To Organizations
Own
• Who specifies how the decision should be made?
• They care about the approach
Make
• Who must make these decisions day to day?
• They care about execution
Impacted by
• Who is impacted e.g. because their KPIs are impacted?
• They care about results
25. Put Decisions In Context
• Business Processes
• Business Events
• Existing Systems
• Which business processes need
decisions made?
• When will decisions be required
and in what context?
• How will you have to deploy
decision making?
28. Decisions Require Knowledge
How to make this decision
• What tells me what I must do?
• What tells me what I should do?
• What tells me what I can do?
• What tells me what I will probably do?
• What would help me do it better?
30. Decision Modeling Approach
• Find Decision
• Describe Decision
• What is required to make this decision?
• Identify Information Requirements
• Identify Knowledge Requirements
• Identify Decision Requirements
31. Decision Requirements
• Is that information available or must it be
determined by making another decision?
Where does the decision
get information?
• Can someone make part of the decision and then
stop? If so, where?
Is the decision “atomic”?
• When someone describes the decision what steps
do they describe?
How does someone make
the decision?
• Some decisions are made differently, or not made
at all, if specific circumstances are true
Do circumstances change
the decision making?
32. A Decision Requirements Diagram
Input data
Top Level
Decision
Knowledge
Sources
Specificity
Gaps Additional
Requirements
Additional
Precision
33. A Complete Decision Definition
• Definition
• Question and Allowed Answers
• Purpose and Value – KPIs impacted
• Processes, Events, Systems
• Organizations
• Decomposition
• Decisions
• Input Data
• Knowledge Sources
35. Describe Decisions
Information
• What is needed?
• Where does it come
from?
Knowledge
• How to make it
• How to improve it
Precision
• Exactly how?
• Specificity without
technical details
Context
• Application
• Organization
• Business Goals
36. Business Requirements For BI
• Decision Modeling focuses on business needs first
• Decision Models identify information, knowledge needs
• Combined with user interface design they result in a decision-centric result
User Interface
Design
Knowledge
Architecture
Implementation
Decision
Model
Information
Architecture
37. Find The Analytics That Work
Ask If Only…
• If only we knew if this customer is unhappy
• If only we knew if this piece of equipment was going to fail soon
• If only we knew where we were most likely to get a delivery this
afternoon
• If only we knew if this provider was ripping us off
• …
42. What Information Gives Us The Insight?
Data
Warehouse
What information don’t we store?
What information can’t we integrate?
What information must now be analyzed?
44. Business Case and Monitoring
Analytic
Decisions KPIs
Processes and
Systems
Organizations
Monitoring
45. A New Approach To BI Requirements
Decision Models clarify business
needs for BI
Decision Models engage the
business, IT and BI
How the result will be deployed
and used is clear
48. Effective BI Requirements
Clearly specify decision-making
needs
Engage the business, IT and BI
teams
Enable BI results to be deployed
49. Decision Modeling
Decision Models clarify business
needs for BI
Decision Models engage the
business, IT and BI
How the result will be deployed
and used is clear
50. for attending this
session and the
PASS Business
Analytics
Conference 2015
Thank
You
James Taylor, CEO
james@decisionmanagementsolutions.com