SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 38
Identification and
assessment of the
multilingual dyslexia
      individual
     Dr Ian Smythe




                 © Ian Smythe, 2013
Cognitive predictors of reading in different languages


 Visual                      Phonological awareness               Phonological access

 Sound discrimination        Phonological memory                  Phonological decoding



75%



50%



25%



0%
              Arabic    Chinese       English         Hungarian   Portuguese



Diszlexiaveszélyeztetettség
Who is Dr Ian Smythe?
Resources
Languages and dyslexia
Resources
www.doitprofiler.info
‘Around two-thirds of
Mancunian school
children are bilingual – a
huge figure which
indicates just how
precious its linguistic
culture is. As immigration
and the arrival of
overseas students to the
city continues, it’s fair to
say that this already large
list is set to grow.’
What is dyslexia?


Dyslexia is a difficulty in the acquisition of fluent
and accurate reading and writing skills.

The manifestation of dyslexia in any individual
depends not only upon the cognitive profile but also
the language in question.



Question: Why label?
South Africa
An international
model of reading



An international
model of
assessment



An international
model of support
Reading non-words




     gat
     rop
     shug
     hild
     narge

14
Reading non-words




gat          anacampersote
rop          mithradatism
shug         qualtagh
hild         ucalegon
narge        groak
Spelling non-words
Spelling non-words




cug            driggle
yoll           plicant
brin            stronk
moid          cladition
rilt           trabnag
Chinese multilinguals –
                         Spelling words


Target     Hank        Denis      Lucy        Kevin
trousers   chies       throuses   trouserse   slother
thread     friyed      thried     throught    frish
sword      sond        solt       thoad       sloid
passage    passage      passage   passage     pastsh
quarter    qualter     coult      quater      quart
heart      heart       hart       heart       heart
biscuit    bisate      bisket     biscuit     bictar
parcel     paccel      passoue    passle      pichie
Chinese multilinguals –
                          Spelling non-words


Target      Hank          Denis         Lucy        Kevin
cug         cup           car           cag         cother
yoll        yo            young         yotch       yo
brin        bun           bring         brein       bring
moid        meild         mored         moid        moid
rilt        wilt          rult          realt       roat
driggle     chelle        grout         choger      groot
plicant     clikcan       playcant      plicant     prkarm
stronk      strong        strong        strung      strong
cladition   condition     praettation   clidition   learmeather
trabnag     traveleg      travnige      trapnegk    charparint
Sound discrimination

              shelled   shield
Test items
              halt      hall
              tilt      tilt
              ship      sheep
              raw       war
              nib       nip
              fish      fish
              end       and
              fan       van
              lap       rap
Understanding ESL and Sound
                           Discrimination

Some language groups have difficulties distinguishing certain sounds.
Below is an example of a typical sound discrimination task, and examples
of language groups that have problems with specific items.


        shelled        shield
        halt           hall
        ship           sheep             Russian
        raw            war
        nib            nip               Spanish
        end            and               Many languages
        fan            van               Indian languages
        lap            rap               Chinese, Japanese
Auditory Memory
Sound discrimination




36195              791

136792             4982

5127394            15428

93782615           613752

148376925
Analysis    Phonological
               units


Storage     Phonological
               tasks


Synthesis   Phonological
            manipulation
               skills
Analysis     Phonological
                units

             Word      Syllable
Storage




            Phoneme   Morphemic
Synthesis
                         unit
Analysis      Phonological
                 tasks

            Alliteration
Storage




Synthesis
But what can I do on Monday?




27
Analysis      Phonological
                 tasks

            Alliteration   Rhyme
Storage




Synthesis
Which ends with the same sound as bread?
           Cow – Bus - Head
Analysis       Phonological
                  tasks

            Alliteration      Rhyme
Storage




            Syllabification
Synthesis
Syllabification




31
Analysis       Phonological
                  tasks

            Alliteration       Rhyme
Storage




            Syllabification     Phoneme
Synthesis
                              identification
First sound in strawberry




33
But what can I do on Monday?




     anbzefItkl
     gncpmqjrs
     uvhwxdo

34
Analysis      Phonological
              manipulation

            Phoneme         Phoneme
Storage      deletion      substitution




             Syllable      Spoonerisms
Synthesis
            manipulation
The end

More Related Content

Similar to Dyslang Workshop Assessments

Class 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_sounds
Class 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_soundsClass 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_sounds
Class 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_soundsLisa Lavoie
 
What English Do University Students Really Need
What English Do University Students Really NeedWhat English Do University Students Really Need
What English Do University Students Really NeedHala Nur
 
Get talking chinese
Get talking chineseGet talking chinese
Get talking chineseDT Nguyen
 
1.1 old yeller
1.1 old  yeller1.1 old  yeller
1.1 old yellerClaudia Vc
 
The importance of reading fluency
The importance of reading fluencyThe importance of reading fluency
The importance of reading fluencyDavid Didau
 
Wilson 3 2
Wilson 3 2Wilson 3 2
Wilson 3 2clynch14
 
Wiki Version Phonics For Fun And Learners Futures
Wiki Version  Phonics For Fun And Learners FuturesWiki Version  Phonics For Fun And Learners Futures
Wiki Version Phonics For Fun And Learners FuturesJo Rhys-Jones
 
Music for pronunciation
Music for pronunciation Music for pronunciation
Music for pronunciation languagenow
 
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)Marisa Constantinides
 
Gender_grammar_Schnoebelen.ppt
Gender_grammar_Schnoebelen.pptGender_grammar_Schnoebelen.ppt
Gender_grammar_Schnoebelen.pptNINASULISYOWATI
 
Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...
Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...
Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...Read Australia (Wiring Brains Education)
 
The language show 2010 less is definitely more
The language show 2010   less is definitely moreThe language show 2010   less is definitely more
The language show 2010 less is definitely moreRachel Hawkes
 
Lin101 introduction to linguistics
Lin101 introduction to linguisticsLin101 introduction to linguistics
Lin101 introduction to linguisticsDr. Russell Rodrigo
 
Resources ppt intermediate
Resources ppt intermediateResources ppt intermediate
Resources ppt intermediateCarissa Dawn
 
Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007
Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007
Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007Eulixabeth Gomez
 
Giving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing language
Giving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing languageGiving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing language
Giving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing languageFrancis Gilbert
 
Horn, meagan project proposal
Horn, meagan project proposalHorn, meagan project proposal
Horn, meagan project proposalMeag Horn
 

Similar to Dyslang Workshop Assessments (20)

Class 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_sounds
Class 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_soundsClass 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_sounds
Class 01 emerson_phonetics_fall2014_intro_spelling_bad_how_many_sounds
 
What English Do University Students Really Need
What English Do University Students Really NeedWhat English Do University Students Really Need
What English Do University Students Really Need
 
Get talking chinese
Get talking chineseGet talking chinese
Get talking chinese
 
1.1 old yeller
1.1 old  yeller1.1 old  yeller
1.1 old yeller
 
The importance of reading fluency
The importance of reading fluencyThe importance of reading fluency
The importance of reading fluency
 
Punita Singh - Language Your Mind
Punita Singh - Language Your MindPunita Singh - Language Your Mind
Punita Singh - Language Your Mind
 
Wilson 3 2
Wilson 3 2Wilson 3 2
Wilson 3 2
 
Wiki Version Phonics For Fun And Learners Futures
Wiki Version  Phonics For Fun And Learners FuturesWiki Version  Phonics For Fun And Learners Futures
Wiki Version Phonics For Fun And Learners Futures
 
Music for pronunciation
Music for pronunciation Music for pronunciation
Music for pronunciation
 
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT FOR TEACHERS (LDT)
 
Gender_grammar_Schnoebelen.ppt
Gender_grammar_Schnoebelen.pptGender_grammar_Schnoebelen.ppt
Gender_grammar_Schnoebelen.ppt
 
Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...
Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...
Speech Sound Pics (SSP) 4 or 6 Hour Teacher/ TA/ Learning Support / PD Worksh...
 
5W1H of English Mastery
5W1H of English Mastery5W1H of English Mastery
5W1H of English Mastery
 
The language show 2010 less is definitely more
The language show 2010   less is definitely moreThe language show 2010   less is definitely more
The language show 2010 less is definitely more
 
Lin101 introduction to linguistics
Lin101 introduction to linguisticsLin101 introduction to linguistics
Lin101 introduction to linguistics
 
Resources ppt intermediate
Resources ppt intermediateResources ppt intermediate
Resources ppt intermediate
 
Phonics
PhonicsPhonics
Phonics
 
Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007
Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007
Portfolio eulixabeth gomez 2007
 
Giving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing language
Giving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing languageGiving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing language
Giving able pupils a solid theoretical framework for analysing language
 
Horn, meagan project proposal
Horn, meagan project proposalHorn, meagan project proposal
Horn, meagan project proposal
 

Dyslang Workshop Assessments

  • 1. Identification and assessment of the multilingual dyslexia individual Dr Ian Smythe © Ian Smythe, 2013
  • 2. Cognitive predictors of reading in different languages Visual Phonological awareness Phonological access Sound discrimination Phonological memory Phonological decoding 75% 50% 25% 0% Arabic Chinese English Hungarian Portuguese Diszlexiaveszélyeztetettség
  • 3. Who is Dr Ian Smythe?
  • 8.
  • 9. ‘Around two-thirds of Mancunian school children are bilingual – a huge figure which indicates just how precious its linguistic culture is. As immigration and the arrival of overseas students to the city continues, it’s fair to say that this already large list is set to grow.’
  • 10.
  • 11. What is dyslexia? Dyslexia is a difficulty in the acquisition of fluent and accurate reading and writing skills. The manifestation of dyslexia in any individual depends not only upon the cognitive profile but also the language in question. Question: Why label?
  • 13. An international model of reading An international model of assessment An international model of support
  • 14. Reading non-words gat rop shug hild narge 14
  • 15. Reading non-words gat anacampersote rop mithradatism shug qualtagh hild ucalegon narge groak
  • 17. Spelling non-words cug driggle yoll plicant brin stronk moid cladition rilt trabnag
  • 18. Chinese multilinguals – Spelling words Target Hank Denis Lucy Kevin trousers chies throuses trouserse slother thread friyed thried throught frish sword sond solt thoad sloid passage passage passage passage pastsh quarter qualter coult quater quart heart heart hart heart heart biscuit bisate bisket biscuit bictar parcel paccel passoue passle pichie
  • 19. Chinese multilinguals – Spelling non-words Target Hank Denis Lucy Kevin cug cup car cag cother yoll yo young yotch yo brin bun bring brein bring moid meild mored moid moid rilt wilt rult realt roat driggle chelle grout choger groot plicant clikcan playcant plicant prkarm stronk strong strong strung strong cladition condition praettation clidition learmeather trabnag traveleg travnige trapnegk charparint
  • 20. Sound discrimination shelled shield Test items halt hall tilt tilt ship sheep raw war nib nip fish fish end and fan van lap rap
  • 21. Understanding ESL and Sound Discrimination Some language groups have difficulties distinguishing certain sounds. Below is an example of a typical sound discrimination task, and examples of language groups that have problems with specific items. shelled shield halt hall ship sheep Russian raw war nib nip Spanish end and Many languages fan van Indian languages lap rap Chinese, Japanese
  • 23. Sound discrimination 36195 791 136792 4982 5127394 15428 93782615 613752 148376925
  • 24. Analysis Phonological units Storage Phonological tasks Synthesis Phonological manipulation skills
  • 25. Analysis Phonological units Word Syllable Storage Phoneme Morphemic Synthesis unit
  • 26. Analysis Phonological tasks Alliteration Storage Synthesis
  • 27. But what can I do on Monday? 27
  • 28. Analysis Phonological tasks Alliteration Rhyme Storage Synthesis
  • 29. Which ends with the same sound as bread? Cow – Bus - Head
  • 30. Analysis Phonological tasks Alliteration Rhyme Storage Syllabification Synthesis
  • 32. Analysis Phonological tasks Alliteration Rhyme Storage Syllabification Phoneme Synthesis identification
  • 33. First sound in strawberry 33
  • 34. But what can I do on Monday? anbzefItkl gncpmqjrs uvhwxdo 34
  • 35. Analysis Phonological manipulation Phoneme Phoneme Storage deletion substitution Syllable Spoonerisms Synthesis manipulation
  • 36.
  • 37.