1
ADVANCED NEGOTIATION
The Harvard Method
7 Elements of Negotiation
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 2
 Introduction
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 3
What is TO NEGOTIATE ?
“Negotiation is a process of potentially opportunistic
interaction by wich two or more parties, with some
apparent conflict, seek to do bettel through jointly
decided action than they could otherwise”
David Lax & Jim Sebenius
Harvard Business School
"Negotiation is a basic means of getting what you
want from others.
It is back-and-forth communication designed to
reach agreement when you and the other side
have some interests that are shared and others
that are opposed."
Roger Fisher
Harvard Business School
“Sex apart, negotiation is the most common and
problematic involvement of one person with another,
and the two activities are not unrelated”
J.K Galbraith
Harvard Business School
“Negotiation is a process in
wich interested parties try to
reach a mutually satisfactory
agreement…”
Howard Raiffa
Kennedy School of
Government
Harvard University
“Negotiatio is a basic means of getting what you want from others. It is
back-and-forth communication designed to reach agreement when you
and the other side have some interests that are shared and others that are
oppsed…”
William Ury
Harvard Law School
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
Uncertain (simple)
Complicated Complex
Chaotic
Realities?
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
I have only one objective
my target
5
COMPLICATED
Problem
COMPLEX
Problem
NEGOTIATION
The negotiation round itself can be seen as a
complex or complicated problem.
Expand my vision of the
objectives at stake
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com 6
THE FACT TO NEGOTIATE
A
B
H
E
D
I
M
C F
L
A
B
E
C
A
B
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
Synthesis: Complicated versus Complex
COMPLICATED COMPLEX
Closed system Open system
Space limits / Set times Space limits / Indefinite time
Costs / Clear benefits Costs / Hidden benefits
7
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 8
SPHERE OF INFLUENCE OF THE
NEGOTIATOR
Sphere of
influence
Sphere of
involvement
(results zone)
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 9
Minimum impact on the results
Sphere of
influence
Sphere of
involvement
REAGENT NEGOTIATOR
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 10
PROACTIVE NEGOTIATOR
Sphere of
influence
Sphere of
involvement
Maximum impact on the results
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 11
Vision of the problem and
the sphere of influenceSPHERE OF
INVOLVEMENT
Simple
reading
Complex
reading
SPHERE OF
INVOLVEMENT
VISION
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 12
Negotiation style?
•Is one whose target is victory at any cost. Doesn't mind the
claims of the other party or the future consequences of their
actions. Braves negotiations from the perspective of short
term.
Tough
Negotiator
•Belive that with a good relationship it is possible negotiations
in wich everyone benefits. Bases its negotiating strategy in
using a friendly communication as the main weapon.
Soft or relational
Negotiator
•Faces the negotiation from a objective postulates, knows
how to adapt his natural tendency depending on the
particular characteristics of the negotiation. It focuses on the
interests separating people from the problem.
Principled
Negotiator
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 13
Characteristics of a Good Negotiator
Be
Impersonal
Think Fast
and Clear
Easily and
good
expressed Capacity
Analysis
and
Synthesis
Be PatientFocussed on
objectives
Great
Empathy
Have Good
Humor
Know how
to control
himself
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 14
Strategy Types
Distributive
strategies
Cooperative
strategies
Positional
strategies
Método
Harvard
Winning at
all costs
Win to Win
Anchored
to the
starting
points
Create value
Claim value
Manage the Dilemma
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 15
Negotiation process Phases
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
ContentRelationship
Negotiation preparation
and bargaining process
analysis techniques
Communication skills
development techniques
Negotiation: Two skills in wich we operate
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 17
 The Harvard Program 7 Elements of
Negotiation
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
Communication
BATNA
Relationship
Positions
Differences
Commons
InterestsAims
Stakeholders
Short term
Medium term
Long term
Sections
The 7 Elements of Harvard.
Rules of
legitimacy
Commitment
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 19
1. BATNA. Best Alternative to a
Negotiation Agreement
BATNA (Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement)
They are the resources available to each part if no
agreement is reached. E.g. “We reserve the right to
take legal actions”
Aim.- Identify and develop the best alternatives that each
part has if ther is no agreement. My BATNA will tell me if
I should continue with the negotiation or not.
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 20
Enumerate possible alternatives
WE + - THEY + -
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
Best BATNA
WE THEY
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 21
• Our best BATNA
– 1.
– 2.
– 3.
– 4.
– 5
• Get worse their BATNA
– 1.
– 2.
– 3.
– 4.
– 5
► If my BATNA is BETTER than the
expected result than I can obtain with
the negotiation, the most appropiate is
to break the negotiation and execute
my BATNA.
► If the BATNA of the other party is
WORSE than the results that may be
expected in the negotiation, they will
make every effort to reach an
agreement .
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 22
• Interests vs. Positions
• Positions:
– Starting poit, first motivations
– They must be become in interests
• Interests:
– Real motivations
Pragmatic
Internal
2. INTERESTS - POSITIONS
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
Negotiation is a conflict of interests
Sometimes we sacrify an important interest
because we are not willing to give in another
with less importance
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 24
“Interests are the raw material of the negotiation. The game of the
negotiation is based on their exchange”.
Roger Fisher.
Harvard Business School
• Different
• Common
List
• For me
• For the other
part
Prioritization
• Give in one
interest in
exchange of
another
Exchange
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 25
Focus on INTERESTS forgetting the positions makes easier VALUE
CREATION and achieving AGREEMENTS
Subtle Interests: reputation, justice, strategy, precedents
Worst and best result in each case before I offer as exchange
Get away from the points of conflict
EMPATHY. Opposite role
All interests are not opposed
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com
26
Different interests
We They
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
Shared interests
We They
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com
27
3. OPTIONS
a) Definition
► Points on which agreement might be possible.
► Different ways to satisfy the interests of both parties
► They are the physical translation of the interests
b) Premises to generate options
► It is always possible to enlarge the pie
► The pursued values are in the differences
► Separate the process of generating ideas from the making of decisions.
► Adapt the appeared ideas to the chosen strategy.
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 28
CAMP DAVID AGREEMENTS
Egypt interests Possible options Israel interests
1.Maximum interest:
SOVEREIGNTY
1. Differences
interchangeable:
- Egypt desmilitarize the
area
- Israel transfer the
sovereignty.
1. Maximum interest:
SECURITY
2. Medium interest:
- Obtein Peace
- Prestige of the leaders
2. Differences
interchangeable:

2. Medium interest:
-- Obtein Peace
- Prestige of the leaders
3. Minimum interest:
Having armed forces in
Sinai
3. Differences
interchangeable:
3. Minimum interest:
Sovereignty in Sinai
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 29
4. RULES OF LEGITIMACY
It is necessary to
pursue the LEGITIMACY
of the agreement.
Each part shall have the
FEELING of having
achieved their
expectations
The agreement must be
FAIR
External and IMPARTIAL
models: law,
precedents,
international treaties,
habits.
Write the Victory
Speech
Treaty of Versailles
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 30
5. RELATIONSHIP
The State borns when
political organization
ceases to be based on
personal relationships
and based on
territorial and
institutional
relationships.
An agreement last in
time when it is based
on the object and not
on the subjects.
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com
Elements of a good relationship
Reason
Converse
Convince
Confidence
Influence
Acceptance
Emotion
Preach
Impose
Mistrust
Pressure
Negation
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 32
• The efficient negotiation requires effective bilateral
communication
• Define a communication system dominated by both
parts.
• Consider cultural differences
• No hurry. Deliberate and clear messages.
• Form and substance.
6. COMMUNICATION
33
METHODOLOGY
My suppositions
What could
understand them
New approach
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 34
Verbal or written approaches which specify what is going
to do or not each part.
APPROACH
STRUCTURE
EXECUTION
COMMITMENT
7. COMMITMENT
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com
35
METHODOLOGY
1. Last commitment draft
2. Last commitment
A. Previous steps: ¿Authority?, ¿Who and
what will do everyone?, ¿Incentives for
compliance?
B. Documentary and reliable composition of
the responsabilities of each part.
Negociación Avanzada. Reclamar Valor.
www.eficax.com
36
NEGOTIATION STRATEGY
• 1. OBJECTIVES OF THE PARTS
– SHORT, MEDIUM AND LONG TERM
– VISIBLE AND HIDDEN
– STAKEHOLDERS
• 2. THE PROCESS. THE SEVEN ELEMENTS
• 3. TO MANAGE THE DILEMMA OF THE NEGOTIATOR
– THE SECTIONS
INTEREST
OPTIONS
GUIDELINE
RELATIONSHIP AND COMMUNICATION
BATNACOMMITMENT
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com
“The good negotiator is one
who knows CREATE
VALUE without becoming
vulnerable to those who
CLAIM and identify the right
time TO CLAIM”
Negociación Avanzada.
www.eficax.com 38
Executive Education Plan
C/ Calendula 93. Miniparc III. Edificio E.
El Soto de la Moraleja.
28109- Alcobendas (Madrid).
EFICAX
www.eficax.com
info@eficax.com
Tel. 91 116 58 16
Fax. 91 829 84 39

The Harvard Negotiation Method

  • 1.
    1 ADVANCED NEGOTIATION The HarvardMethod 7 Elements of Negotiation
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 3 Whatis TO NEGOTIATE ? “Negotiation is a process of potentially opportunistic interaction by wich two or more parties, with some apparent conflict, seek to do bettel through jointly decided action than they could otherwise” David Lax & Jim Sebenius Harvard Business School "Negotiation is a basic means of getting what you want from others. It is back-and-forth communication designed to reach agreement when you and the other side have some interests that are shared and others that are opposed." Roger Fisher Harvard Business School “Sex apart, negotiation is the most common and problematic involvement of one person with another, and the two activities are not unrelated” J.K Galbraith Harvard Business School “Negotiation is a process in wich interested parties try to reach a mutually satisfactory agreement…” Howard Raiffa Kennedy School of Government Harvard University “Negotiatio is a basic means of getting what you want from others. It is back-and-forth communication designed to reach agreement when you and the other side have some interests that are shared and others that are oppsed…” William Ury Harvard Law School
  • 4.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com Uncertain (simple) Complicated Complex Chaotic Realities?
  • 5.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com I have only one objective my target 5 COMPLICATED Problem COMPLEX Problem NEGOTIATION The negotiation round itself can be seen as a complex or complicated problem. Expand my vision of the objectives at stake
  • 6.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com 6 THE FACT TO NEGOTIATE A B H E D I M C F L A B E C A B
  • 7.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com Synthesis: Complicated versus Complex COMPLICATED COMPLEX Closed system Open system Space limits / Set times Space limits / Indefinite time Costs / Clear benefits Costs / Hidden benefits 7
  • 8.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 8 SPHEREOF INFLUENCE OF THE NEGOTIATOR Sphere of influence Sphere of involvement (results zone)
  • 9.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 9 Minimumimpact on the results Sphere of influence Sphere of involvement REAGENT NEGOTIATOR
  • 10.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 10 PROACTIVENEGOTIATOR Sphere of influence Sphere of involvement Maximum impact on the results
  • 11.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 11 Visionof the problem and the sphere of influenceSPHERE OF INVOLVEMENT Simple reading Complex reading SPHERE OF INVOLVEMENT VISION
  • 12.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 12 Negotiationstyle? •Is one whose target is victory at any cost. Doesn't mind the claims of the other party or the future consequences of their actions. Braves negotiations from the perspective of short term. Tough Negotiator •Belive that with a good relationship it is possible negotiations in wich everyone benefits. Bases its negotiating strategy in using a friendly communication as the main weapon. Soft or relational Negotiator •Faces the negotiation from a objective postulates, knows how to adapt his natural tendency depending on the particular characteristics of the negotiation. It focuses on the interests separating people from the problem. Principled Negotiator
  • 13.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 13 Characteristicsof a Good Negotiator Be Impersonal Think Fast and Clear Easily and good expressed Capacity Analysis and Synthesis Be PatientFocussed on objectives Great Empathy Have Good Humor Know how to control himself
  • 14.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 14 StrategyTypes Distributive strategies Cooperative strategies Positional strategies Método Harvard Winning at all costs Win to Win Anchored to the starting points Create value Claim value Manage the Dilemma
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com ContentRelationship Negotiation preparation and bargaining process analysis techniques Communication skills development techniques Negotiation: Two skills in wich we operate
  • 17.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 17 The Harvard Program 7 Elements of Negotiation
  • 18.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com Communication BATNA Relationship Positions Differences Commons InterestsAims Stakeholders Short term Medium term Long term Sections The 7 Elements of Harvard. Rules of legitimacy Commitment
  • 19.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 19 1.BATNA. Best Alternative to a Negotiation Agreement BATNA (Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement) They are the resources available to each part if no agreement is reached. E.g. “We reserve the right to take legal actions” Aim.- Identify and develop the best alternatives that each part has if ther is no agreement. My BATNA will tell me if I should continue with the negotiation or not.
  • 20.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 20 Enumeratepossible alternatives WE + - THEY + - 1. 2. 3. 1. 2. 3. Best BATNA WE THEY
  • 21.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 21 •Our best BATNA – 1. – 2. – 3. – 4. – 5 • Get worse their BATNA – 1. – 2. – 3. – 4. – 5 ► If my BATNA is BETTER than the expected result than I can obtain with the negotiation, the most appropiate is to break the negotiation and execute my BATNA. ► If the BATNA of the other party is WORSE than the results that may be expected in the negotiation, they will make every effort to reach an agreement .
  • 22.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 22 •Interests vs. Positions • Positions: – Starting poit, first motivations – They must be become in interests • Interests: – Real motivations Pragmatic Internal 2. INTERESTS - POSITIONS
  • 23.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com Negotiation is a conflict of interests Sometimes we sacrify an important interest because we are not willing to give in another with less importance
  • 24.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 24 “Interestsare the raw material of the negotiation. The game of the negotiation is based on their exchange”. Roger Fisher. Harvard Business School • Different • Common List • For me • For the other part Prioritization • Give in one interest in exchange of another Exchange
  • 25.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 25 Focuson INTERESTS forgetting the positions makes easier VALUE CREATION and achieving AGREEMENTS Subtle Interests: reputation, justice, strategy, precedents Worst and best result in each case before I offer as exchange Get away from the points of conflict EMPATHY. Opposite role All interests are not opposed
  • 26.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 26 Different interests WeThey 1. 2. 3. 1. 2. 3. Shared interests We They 1. 2. 3. 1. 2. 3.
  • 27.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 27 3. OPTIONS a)Definition ► Points on which agreement might be possible. ► Different ways to satisfy the interests of both parties ► They are the physical translation of the interests b) Premises to generate options ► It is always possible to enlarge the pie ► The pursued values are in the differences ► Separate the process of generating ideas from the making of decisions. ► Adapt the appeared ideas to the chosen strategy.
  • 28.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 28 CAMPDAVID AGREEMENTS Egypt interests Possible options Israel interests 1.Maximum interest: SOVEREIGNTY 1. Differences interchangeable: - Egypt desmilitarize the area - Israel transfer the sovereignty. 1. Maximum interest: SECURITY 2. Medium interest: - Obtein Peace - Prestige of the leaders 2. Differences interchangeable:  2. Medium interest: -- Obtein Peace - Prestige of the leaders 3. Minimum interest: Having armed forces in Sinai 3. Differences interchangeable: 3. Minimum interest: Sovereignty in Sinai
  • 29.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 29 4.RULES OF LEGITIMACY It is necessary to pursue the LEGITIMACY of the agreement. Each part shall have the FEELING of having achieved their expectations The agreement must be FAIR External and IMPARTIAL models: law, precedents, international treaties, habits. Write the Victory Speech Treaty of Versailles
  • 30.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 30 5.RELATIONSHIP The State borns when political organization ceases to be based on personal relationships and based on territorial and institutional relationships. An agreement last in time when it is based on the object and not on the subjects.
  • 31.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com Elements ofa good relationship Reason Converse Convince Confidence Influence Acceptance Emotion Preach Impose Mistrust Pressure Negation
  • 32.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 32 •The efficient negotiation requires effective bilateral communication • Define a communication system dominated by both parts. • Consider cultural differences • No hurry. Deliberate and clear messages. • Form and substance. 6. COMMUNICATION
  • 33.
    33 METHODOLOGY My suppositions What could understandthem New approach 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
  • 34.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 34 Verbalor written approaches which specify what is going to do or not each part. APPROACH STRUCTURE EXECUTION COMMITMENT 7. COMMITMENT
  • 35.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 35 METHODOLOGY 1. Lastcommitment draft 2. Last commitment A. Previous steps: ¿Authority?, ¿Who and what will do everyone?, ¿Incentives for compliance? B. Documentary and reliable composition of the responsabilities of each part.
  • 36.
    Negociación Avanzada. ReclamarValor. www.eficax.com 36 NEGOTIATION STRATEGY • 1. OBJECTIVES OF THE PARTS – SHORT, MEDIUM AND LONG TERM – VISIBLE AND HIDDEN – STAKEHOLDERS • 2. THE PROCESS. THE SEVEN ELEMENTS • 3. TO MANAGE THE DILEMMA OF THE NEGOTIATOR – THE SECTIONS INTEREST OPTIONS GUIDELINE RELATIONSHIP AND COMMUNICATION BATNACOMMITMENT
  • 37.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com “The goodnegotiator is one who knows CREATE VALUE without becoming vulnerable to those who CLAIM and identify the right time TO CLAIM”
  • 38.
    Negociación Avanzada. www.eficax.com 38 ExecutiveEducation Plan C/ Calendula 93. Miniparc III. Edificio E. El Soto de la Moraleja. 28109- Alcobendas (Madrid). EFICAX www.eficax.com info@eficax.com Tel. 91 116 58 16 Fax. 91 829 84 39