1. MR Morphology of Intracranial Tuberculomas
Dr. H. S. Das, Dr. N. Medhi, Dr. B. Saharia, Dr. S. K. Handique
Introduction:
Tuberculomas represent a common neurological disorder in developing
countries, forming 12-30% of all intracranial masses – (1,2). Furthermore the
incidence of intracranial TB in patients with AIDS is also increasing, the highest
incidence recorded being 2.3% - (3,4) in one study to 18% in another – (5). Prompt
diagnosis is mandatory since any delay in increased morbidity and mortality.
Unfortunately the diagnosis is not always possible on the basis of clinical and
epidemiological data, since clinical manifestations are nonspecific – (7,8) and
objective evidence of systemic tuberculosis or exposure to the disease may be
absent in upto 70% of the cases – (9). The role of CT in diagnosis of CNS
tuberculomas in well established, nevertheless CT findings should be interpreted
with caution since neoplastic, fungal or parasitic diseases may cause similar
changes on CT – (10). Recently Magnetic Resonance (MR) Imaging has shown
advantage over CT in the detection of intracranial pathology – (11) and its value
in the diagnosis of infections diseases of the central nervous system (CNS) has
been reported – (12,13). Although tubercular meningitis can not be differentiated
from other meningitides on the basis of MR findings; but intraparenchymal
tuberculomas show characteristic T2 shortening not found in most other space
occupying lesions – (14). Thus in the appropiate clinical setting tuberculomas
should be considered. Here, we report our experience in using MR for the
evaluation of patients with intracranial tuberculoma.
2. Patients and Methods:
10 Patients with intracranial tuberculomas were evaluated with MR in our
institution between August ’95 to August’ 99. 8 males and 2 females between
5-45 years (Mean 22.9 years) were included in this study. MRI was performed on
a 1-tesla super conductive magnet. Standard spin echo techniques were used to
obtain multiplanar T1 and T2 weighted images. Contrast was used in 6 patients.
The diagnosis of CNS tuberculosis was made after proper integration of data
from the surgical and medical findings. Data included positive biopsy in 2
patients; analysis of blood and CSF (elevation in 2 cases); positive response to
anti tubercular drugs in 6 patients and MR findings. Initial CT was done upon
admission to the hospital in all ten cases. MR was done to visualize the full
extent of the lesion, to differentiate these lesions from other diseases affecting the
brain and to delineate the contents (necrotic centre, capsule and surrounding
edema). None of the patients tested positive for HIV.
Results:
Tuberculomas were supratentorial in 9 patients and infratentorial in 1. All but
one patient had single lesions, which were located at the cortico-subcortical
junction of the cerebral hemispheres and in the brainstem in 2 patients. 1 patient
had a cerebellar tuberculoma. On MR intracranial tuberculoma caused
prolongation of the T1 relaxation time which was most marked at the centre of
the lesion. 5 patients had lesions hypointense to normal brain; 4 patients had
lesions isointense and 1 patient had a mixed signal with hypointensity
predominating on T1 weighted images. On the T2 weighted sequences the MR
appearance varied. In six patients the centre of the lesion gave hypointense
(dark) signal while the periphery gave a hyperintense (bright) signal relative to
the brain parenchyma due to surrounding oedema. In 2 patients the centre of the
lesion was hyperintense with a hypointense rim surrounded again by diffuse
hyperintensity due to edema.
Follow up CT in 6 patients during the course of antituberculous drugs showed
reduction in the six of the lesion as well as the oedema as a result of therapy. 2
patients positive biopsy while 2 patients were lost to follow up. Following
contrast infusion in 6 patients ring enhancing lesions were observed in 4 patients,
disc enhancing lesion size of less than 1 cm, 3 patients had lesion size of more
then 2 cms while the lesion size varied between 1-2 cms in the rest of the 6
patients. 2 out of the 10 patients presented with meningitis, which shows diffuse
thick meningeal contrast enhancement presumably due to granulation tissue.
These 2 patients also had different degrees of hydrocephalus.
3. Discussion:
Tuberculomas develop in the brain when the initial Rich’s focus does not rupture
into the meninges but expands locally within the parenchyma due to greater
resistance of host tissues to the infecting organism (5). Meningitis can cause
borderline encephalitis resulting in direct infiltration of the brain parenchyma
and multiple small tuberculomas which coalesce to form mature tuberculomas –
(16).
Tuberculomas have different appearances on T2 weighted images depending on
their stage of evolution. At an early stage of formation of tuberculomas, an
inflammatory reaction occurs; the mass has an abundance of giant cells and a
capsule poor in collagen. At this stage the mass is isointense on T1 and T2
weighted images. At a later stage, the capsule becomes rich in collagen. When
small tuberculomas coalesce to become larger lesions they give low signal on T2
weighted images because of fibrosis, scar tissue and free radicals produced by
macrophages during active phagocytosis – (17).
22 of the 27 cases (84%) of NCS tuberculoma in the literature clearly showed low
signal on T2 weighted images – (8, 18, 19, 20). 5 (16%) had lesions with central
high signal thought to represent caseating pathologic examination revealed
tuberculoma with dense reactive fibrosis.
In another study out of 97 patients presumed to harbour cerebral tuberculomas
(of which 11 were confirmed by biopsy and 73 showed a therapeutic response to
AKT) the lesions were either homogenously hypointense or revealed a central
hyperintense nidus within the hypointense lesion on T2 weighted images (21).
Based on a histopathological grading of 7 proven tuberculomas, Gupta et al (22)
concluded that the signal intensity on T2 weighted images is variable and
dependant on the relative proportion of macrophages, cellular infiltrates and
fibrosis. Granulomas, which were frankly hyperintense on T2 weighted images,
exhibited increased cellular infiltrates, scantly macrophages and little fibrosis;
while the hypointense lesions showed grater numbers of macrophages; more
fibrosis and gliosis – (22). Large amounts of lipids were reported to contribute to
the T2 shortening in 2 of the granulomas analysed by localized proton
spectroscopy – (22). MR is of value to visualize the full extent of the lesion, in
differentiation of the lesion with other diseases of the CNS (e.g. fungal
granuloma, haemorrhagic metastases and “granulo-nodular” stage of
neurocysticercosis) and to delineate the different components of the lesion
(necrotic center, capsule and surrounding oedema), which is not always possible
with CT.
4. References:
1. Dastur HM, Desai AD (1965): A comparitive study of brain
tuberculomas and gliomas based upon 107 case records of each. Brain
88: 375-396.
2. Laitha VS, Marker FE, Dastur DK, tuberculosis of the Central Nervous
System. Neurology (India) 1980; 28: 197-201.
3. Anderson KM, MacMillan JI (1975) Intercranial Tuberculoma: an
Increasing Problem in Britain. I. Neurolo Neurosurg Pshchiatry 38:
194-201.
4. Bishburg E, Sundaram G, Reichan LB; Kapila R (1986) CNS tuberculosis
with AIDS its related complexes. Ann Intern Med 105: 210-213.
5. Intracranial tuberculosis is AIDS: CT and MRI findings. M.F.
villomoria, J Dela Torre, F. Fortea, L. Munoz, T. Hernadez and J. J.
Alarcon: (1992) Neuroradiology 34: 11-14.
6. Harder E, Al-Jawi MZ; Carney P (1983): Intracranial Tuberculoma;
Conservative management. Am J. Med 74: 570-576.
7. Lehrer H. Venkatesh B, Girolamo R, Smith A (1973): Tuberculoma of
the brain (revisited) AJR 118 : 594-600.
8. Talamas O, Del Brutto OH; Garcia Ramos G (1989): Brainstem
Tuberculoma; an analysis of 11 patients, Arch Neurol.
9. De Angelis LM (1981) Intracranial tuberculoma: Case report and review
of literature. Neurology 31: 1133-1136.
10. Wrishber L, Nice C, Karx M (1984) Cerebral computer tomography : a
text atlas, Saunders. Philadelphia.
11. Brant-Zawadzki M, Davis PL, Crooks LE (1983) : NMR demonstration
of cerebral abnormalities : Comparision with CT AJNR 4 : 120-126.
12. Davidson HD, Steiner RE (1965) MRI in infections on the CNS AJNR 6 :
120-126.
13. Schorth G; Kretzchmar K; Gawehn J, Voigt K (1987): Advantages of
MRI in the diagnosis of cerebral infection. Neuroradiology 29: 120-126.
14. Kioumehr, MR Dadsetan, SA Rooholamini, A, AU (1994): Central
Nervous System Tuberculosis: MRI. Neuroradiology 36: 93-96.
15. Dastur DK, Lalitha VS: The many facets of neurotuberculosis. An
epitome of neuropathology. In Zimmerman RA (ed). Progress in
neuropathology Vol. 2 New York. Grune and Stration 1973, 351, 108.
16. Dastur DK, (1983) Neurosurgically relevant aspects and pathognesis of
intracranial and intraspinal tuberculomas. Neurosurg Rev. 6 : 103-110.
17. Chang KH, Han MH, Roh JK et al (1990): Gd-DTPA enhanced MR
Imaging in intracranial tuberculosis. Neuroradiology 32: 19-25.
18. Gupta RK, Jena A, Sharma A, Guha DK (1988) MR imaging of
intracranial tuberculoma, J. computer Assist Tomong. 121: 280-285.
19. Salgado P, Del Brutto OH, Talamas O, Zenteno MA, Rodriguez Carbajal
J, Neuroradiology (1989) 31 : 299-302. Intracranial tuberculoma: MR
imaging.
5. 20. Dastur HM (1983) Diagnosis and neurosurgical treatment in
tuberculous diseases of the CNS. Neurosurgery 6: 11-113.
21. Desai SB, Shah VC, Tavri OJ, Rao P, MRI more specific than CT in
cranial tuverculomas. Neuroradiology (1991) : 33 (Suppl).
22. Gupta RK, Pandey B, Khan EM, Mittal P, Gujral RB, Chhabra DK. Intra
cranial tuberculomas: MRI signal intensity correlation with
histopathology and localized proton spectroscopy. Mag. Res. Imaging
(1993), 11: 443-449.