dkNET New Investigator Pilot Program in Bioinformatics Awardee Seminar Series
Co-Hosted with Human Islet Research Network (HIRN)
Presenter: Alok V. Joglekar, Ph.D. Assistant Professor, Center for Systems Immunology and Department of Immunology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine
Abstract
T cells are key players in many autoimmune diseases including Type 1 Diabetes. T cell responses are highly antigen specific by virtue of their T cell receptors (TCRs), that recognize epitopes on target cells. The enormous diversity of TCRs in an immune response poses a challenge in studying them, particularly regarding their antigenic specificity. Several experimental approaches have been developed to identify T cell specificities, with a recent surge in cell-based assays. More recently, computational approaches to predict T cell specificity are being developed and show great promise. This webinar will provide an overview of the experimental and computational approaches to identify T cell antigens. Furthermore, we will highlight the research performed in the Joglekar lab towards applying these approaches for auto-antigen discovery in Type 1 Diabetes. Finally, we will project what the future of these approaches may be, particularly for studying autoimmune diseases.
1. T Cell Antigen Discovery:
Experimental and Computational Approaches
Alok V. Joglekar, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor, Department of Immunology | Center for Systems Immunology
University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine
HIRN/dkNET Webinar
04.27.2022
https://www.joglekarimmunolab.org/
2. Outline
• T cell antigen discovery: Scope of the challenge
• Experimental approaches to identify T cell epitopes:
• Antigen-directed
• TCR-directed
• Which method is right for you?
• Computational approaches to predict T cell specificities
• Integrating specificity data with multi-omics
• Systems analyses of T cells in Type 1 Diabetes – research updates from the Joglekar lab
3. Bacteria,
Viruses,
Parasites
Physical barriers
e.g. Skin and mucosa
Large scale non-specific
responses
e.g. Complement, Innate
immunity
Precise responses
e.g. Adaptive immunity
Immune System: Protector of the Realm
Key mediators of immunity
Defining Characteristics of adaptive immunity
Inducible effector functions – rapid scale up ‘on demand’
Immunologic memory + recall response
Multiple layers of regulation
Antigen specificity: distinguish self vs non-self
Enzo life sciences; Benioff, Weiss, Martin et al
4. Antigen Specificity is a Key Characteristic of T Cells
T cells recognize peptide epitopes
presented on MHC molecules using their surface TCR
MHC complexes sample intra- and extra-cellular proteomes
to present to T cells
T Cell Repertoire ‘sees’ an enormous and highly diverse universe of antigens
Joglekar and Li 2020; Kobayashi 2012
5. Antigen Specificity is a Key Characteristic of T Cells
TCR ‘clonotype’ is defined by Vα/Jα/Vβ/Jβ/CDR3α/CDR3β
V(D)J Recombination Generates enormous TCR
diversity from a small number of gene fragments
CDR1/2s bind MHC and CDR3s bind epitope and MHC
>1020 Possible TCRs
~ 106-109 unique TCR clones
1011-1012 T cells
Joglekar and Li 2020; Hennecke 2001; Laydon 2015
T Cell Repertoire itself is enormous and highly diverse
6. Facets of T Cell Function
How to integrate T cell function at a single cell and repertoire level?
Antigen Discovery
scRNAseq
Bulk Vβ seq
Phosphoproteomics
ChIP, ATAC-seq, CUT&RUN
sc/Bulk RNAseq
Flow cytometry, CyTOF,
ELISA, Luminex, MSD
7. TCR Sequencing: Bulk and Single Cell Methods
Rosati 2017
How do we get from TCR sequence antigen specificity?
Bulk:
Adaptive biotechnologies
immunoSEQ
Takara SMARTeR-RACE
Single cell:
10x Genomics 5’ with VDJ
enrichment
Takara SMARTeR-RACE
8. T Cell Antigen Discovery
TCR Directed
Antigen Directed
Can we identify T cell recognizing antigens of interest?
Start with a limited set of putative antigens
Measure pMHC binding/functional output
Can we identify antigens recognized by T cells de novo?
Start with TCR sequences/T cell clones
Screen libraries of epitopes
Computational
Can we predict antigens-specificity of T cells?
Start with TCR sequences +/- putative antigen data
Computational prediction of epitope presentation and recognition
9. T Cell Antigen Discovery
Antigen Directed
Can we identify T cell recognizing antigens of interest?
Start with a limited set of putative antigens
Measure pMHC binding/functional output
10. Antigen Directed Methods – Functional Readouts
Advantages
Highly sensitive
Ease of implementation
HLA typing not required
Rapid
Quantitative / semi-quantitative
Disadvantages
Small # of peptides/proteins at once
No other information than reactivity
Kawakami 1994; van der Bruggen 1991; McCutcheon 1997; Joglekar and Li 2020
11. Antigen Directed Methods – pMHC Multimers
Advantages
Cell isolation
Multiplexing with immune phenotyping
Direct quantification of cells
Disadvantages
Small # of peptides (up to 100s)
Expensive
High affinity HLA binders only
Class II tetramers are often unstable
Altman 1996; Klenerman 2002; Wooldrige 2009; Hadrup 2009; Newell 2009, 2012, 2013; Ma 2021; Peng 2021; Bentzen 2016; Zhang 2016
12. T Cell Antigen Discovery
TCR Directed
Can we identify antigens recognized by T cells de novo?
Start with TCR sequences/T cell clones
Screen libraries of epitopes
13. TCR Directed – Truly Degenerate/Combinatorial
Advantages
Truly degenerate starting libraries
Very high scale (>108) of epitopes
No a priori information needed
Can start with TCR sequences
Disadvantages
Labor and cost intensive
Yields mimotopes
Soluble TCR production is non-robust
Non-physiological pMHC presentation
Less robust for class II
Gavin 1994; Pinilla 2001; Wilson 1999; Hiemstra 1997; Ernst 1998; Wen 2008, 2011, 2013; Birnbaum 2012; Brophy 2013; Boder 1997;
14. TCR Directed – Cell-based
Advantages
Physiological pMHC presentation
Flexible scale (102-106) of epitopes
Actual epitopes identified
Customizable design of libraries
Class I and Class II
Can start with TCR sequences
Disadvantages
Labor and cost intensive
Some a priori information needed
Affinity may impact sensitivity
Joglekar 2019; Li 2019; Kisielow 2019; Kula 2019; Sharma 2019; Dobson 2022
15. T Cell Antigen Discovery
Computational
Can we predict antigens-specificity of T cells?
Start with TCR sequences +/- putative antigen data
Computational prediction of epitope presentation and recognition
16. Computational Approaches – Predicting Specificity
TCRs sharing Ag-specificity often have similar CDR3 sequences TCRs with similar CDR3 sequences may share Ag-specificity
Can NOT predict Ag-specificity de novo (i.e. in absence of known Ag-specific TCRs in the dataset)
Glanville 2017; Dash 2017; Zhang 2020, 2021; Valkiers 2021
17. Computational Approaches – Predicting Repertoire Bias
TCR repertoire features can distinguish disease states
Can distinguish disease states even without the knowledge of Ag-specificity
Xkcd.com; Zhang 2021; Davidsen 2019; Sidhom 2021; Dvorkin 2021
18. T Cell Antigen Discovery
TCR Directed
Antigen Directed
Can we identify T cell recognizing antigens of interest?
Functional readouts
pMHC multimers
Can we identify antigens recognized by T cells de novo?
Combinatorial/degenerate
Cell-based
Computational
Can we predict antigens-specificity of T cells?
Predict specificity
TCR feature based classfiers
19. Which Antigen Discovery Method is Right for You?
Absolutely no ab initio idea
e.g. auto/allo-reactive TCRs
Some idea
e.g. TCRs with
known tissue
targets
Narrow range of potential Ag
e.g. pathogen-specific TCRs
What is known
about potential Ag?
Source of TCRs TCR sequences and/or T cells Tissues/PBMCs
#TCRs or T cells
under investigation
Very small <10
e.g. clonally expanded TCRs
known to be of importance
Small Large
10s 100,000s
e.g. polyclonal T cell
populations
Small <100
e.g. clonally
expanded
TCRs
Joglekar and Li 2020
21. Summary – Part 1
• T cell antigen discovery: Scope of the challenge
• Fast growing universe of TCR sequence data
• Need to incorporate Ag-specificity with multi-omic measurements
• Experimental approaches to identify T cell epitopes (VERY ROUGH guide)
• Antigen-directed
• Narrow range of potential Ags + Large numbers of T cells under study
• TCR-directed
• Wide range of potential Ags + Small numbers of T cells under study
• Computational approaches to predict T cell specificities
• Nascent, but fast growing with the eye on the prize
• Integrating specificity data with multi-omics
• Nascent, but with growing capabilities + augment experimental approaches
22. T Cell Repertoires and Antigen
Discovery for Type 1 Diabetes
NIDDK New Investigator Gateway Award 1R03DK127447
dkNET New investigator Pilot Program in Bioinformatics
23. Type 1 Diabetes
Pugliese, 2017; Bettini, 2011; Katsarou 2017; Ilonen 2019
Islet infiltration by T cells is central to pathogenesis of T1D
NOD/ShiLtJ
NOD mice are a robust model of T1D
Glucagon Insulin
CD45 CD3
CD4 CD8
24. Autoantigens in Type 1 Diabetes
Shared autoantigens between NOD mice and humans
The epitope specificities of a significant fraction of islet-infiltrating T cells are not defined
Pugliese, 2017; Amdare 2021; Katsarou 2017; Ilonen 2019
25. TCR Directed Antigen Discovery in NOD Mice
Antigen discovery in mice Identifying novel autoantigens Testing for reactivity in humans
26. Summary – Part 2
• Cell based epitope discovery method: Signaling and Antigen-presenting Bifunctional Receptors
• Construction and validation of SABR screens for islet-specific CD4+ T cells
• T cell repertoire analysis in islets of NOD mice
• De novo identification of epitopes recognized by several islet-infiltrating CD4+ TCRs
• Correlation of Ag-specificity with transcriptomes
• In progress
• Continuing discovery and validation of CD4+ T cell epitopes in NOD mice
• Ag discovery of islet infiltrating CD8+ T cells in NOD mice
• SABR libraries for Ag discovery of human CD4+ and CD8+ T cells
• Computational framework to identify gene signatures associated with Ag-specific T cells
27. Core services
Novogene
Fulgent Genetics
Flow core
DLAR
Single cell core
Joglekar lab
Paul Zdinak
Rashi Ranjan
Louise Hicks
Salome Martinez
Luba Kublo
Jessica Torrey
Eduardo Zarate-Martinez
Acknowledgements
Collaborators and Advisors
Dario Vignali
Stephanie Grebinoski
Tony Cillo
Mark Anderson
Jennifer Bridge
HIRN-CMAI
HIRN-NewInv
dkNET-NewInv
Jishnu Das
Hanxi Xiao
Mark Shlomchik
Jeremy Tilstra
Alex Rowe
Harinder Singh
Anita Bansal
Paul Thomas
Shin-heng Chiou
$$$$
NIDDK New Investigator Gateway Award 1R03DK127447
dkNET New investigator Pilot Program in Bioinformatics
PACER Innovative Discovery Award
JDRF Innovative Immunotherapies Award
UPSOM start up funds
UPMC-ITTC
Mitsubishi-Tanabe Pharma
WE ARE HIRING!! joglekar@pitt.edu
Lab Alumni
Kelsey Ford
Kobie Rankin
Sanjay Rathod