1. Aging, cumulative DNAAging, cumulative DNA
damage, and deficits indamage, and deficits in
genomic repair:genomic repair:
A story of micronutrients andA story of micronutrients and
lifelong neural integritylifelong neural integrity
2. The accrual of DNA damage leadsThe accrual of DNA damage leads
to progressive aging.to progressive aging.
ā¢ DNA damage is ubiquitous.DNA damage is ubiquitous.
ā¢ Our cells are well-equipped with DNA repair enzymes.Our cells are well-equipped with DNA repair enzymes.
ā¢ However, DNA damage can occur at such high levelsHowever, DNA damage can occur at such high levels
that the cellās capacity for DNA repair is overwhelmed.that the cellās capacity for DNA repair is overwhelmed.
ā¢ As DNA damage accumulates over time, our DNA repairAs DNA damage accumulates over time, our DNA repair
mechanisms become increasingly inefficient.mechanisms become increasingly inefficient.
3. Ionizing radiation and oxidative stressIonizing radiation and oxidative stress
can cause single- andcan cause single- and
double- stranded breaks in DNA.double- stranded breaks in DNA.
ā¢ Ionizing radiation kills cells by inducing double-strandedIonizing radiation kills cells by inducing double-stranded
DNA breaks. Double stranded breaks are the mostDNA breaks. Double stranded breaks are the most
lethal form of DNA damage: one unrepaired DSB islethal form of DNA damage: one unrepaired DSB is
sufficient to kill a cell.sufficient to kill a cell.
ā¢ ROS destroy DNA by creating single-stranded breaks;ROS destroy DNA by creating single-stranded breaks;
when two single-stranded breaks on opposite strandswhen two single-stranded breaks on opposite strands
are within 10 to 20 base pairs of each other, a DSBare within 10 to 20 base pairs of each other, a DSB
occurs.occurs.
4. The constitutively expressed nuclear proteinThe constitutively expressed nuclear protein
poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1 becomespoly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1 becomes
immediately activated upon DNA strandimmediately activated upon DNA strand
breakage.breakage.
PARP-1 catalyzes the cleavage of NADPARP-1 catalyzes the cleavage of NAD++
into ADP-riboseinto ADP-ribose
and nicotinamide.and nicotinamide.
5. Mechanism of action of PARP-1:Mechanism of action of PARP-1:
2 PARP-1 molecules bind to the damaged DNA at the site of the nick. ADP-2 PARP-1 molecules bind to the damaged DNA at the site of the nick. ADP-
ribose polymers (pink) are synthesized and attached to associated proteins.ribose polymers (pink) are synthesized and attached to associated proteins.
These polymers create a negative charge, purportedly changing theThese polymers create a negative charge, purportedly changing the
conformation of the DNA molecule, making it more accessible for repairconformation of the DNA molecule, making it more accessible for repair
enzymes. The negatively charged protein-(ADP-ribose) polymers dissociateenzymes. The negatively charged protein-(ADP-ribose) polymers dissociate
from the negatively-charged DNA molecule. The green molecule is afrom the negatively-charged DNA molecule. The green molecule is a
histone, which, when dissociated, gives the DNA molecule a more relaxedhistone, which, when dissociated, gives the DNA molecule a more relaxed
and accessible shape.and accessible shape.
6. Cellular response to DNA damage fluctuatesCellular response to DNA damage fluctuates
according to the severity of the insult:according to the severity of the insult:
ā¢ Under physiologicalUnder physiological
conditions, PARP-1 playsconditions, PARP-1 plays
a critical role in DNA basea critical role in DNA base
excision repairexcision repair
machinery.machinery.
ā¢ Also, degradation of theAlso, degradation of the
ADP-ribose polymer mayADP-ribose polymer may
provide a source of ATPprovide a source of ATP
for ligation of DNA nicks.for ligation of DNA nicks.
ā¢ End result: DNA repairEnd result: DNA repair
and genomic stability.and genomic stability.
ā¢ Severe DNA damage canSevere DNA damage can
activate PARP-1 500-fold:activate PARP-1 500-fold:
ā¢ Extremely high levels ofExtremely high levels of
PARP-1 activity willPARP-1 activity will
deplete the cell of NAD+deplete the cell of NAD+
and ATP.and ATP.
ā¢ This activates p53,This activates p53,
triggering a cascade oftriggering a cascade of
cellular events leading tocellular events leading to
apoptosis.apoptosis.
ā¢ End result: The cell dies.End result: The cell dies.
7. Severe DNA damageSevere DNA damage
presents a huge problempresents a huge problem
for non-proliferating cellsfor non-proliferating cells
such as neurons:such as neurons:
It makes sense that a lifetime ofIt makes sense that a lifetime of
unrepaired DNA damage can leadunrepaired DNA damage can lead
to neurodegeneration.to neurodegeneration.
8. Is there anything we can do toIs there anything we can do to
assist our cells in repairing DNAassist our cells in repairing DNA
damage?damage?
9. Folic Acid Deficiency andFolic Acid Deficiency and
Homocysteine Impair DNA Repair inHomocysteine Impair DNA Repair in
Hippocampal Neurons and SensitizeHippocampal Neurons and Sensitize
Them to Amyloid Toxicity inThem to Amyloid Toxicity in
Experimental Models of AlzheimerāsExperimental Models of Alzheimerās
DiseaseDisease
Inna I. Kruman, T.S. Kumaravel, Althaf Lohani, Ward A.Inna I. Kruman, T.S. Kumaravel, Althaf Lohani, Ward A.
Pedersen, Roy G. Cutler, Yuri Kruman, Norman Haughey,Pedersen, Roy G. Cutler, Yuri Kruman, Norman Haughey,
Jaewon Lee, Michele Evans, and Mark P. MattsonJaewon Lee, Michele Evans, and Mark P. Mattson
The Journal of Neuroscience, March 1, 2002, 22(5): 1752-The Journal of Neuroscience, March 1, 2002, 22(5): 1752-
17621762
10. Overexpression of PARP-1 hasOverexpression of PARP-1 has
been detected in the brains ofbeen detected in the brains of
Alzheimerās disease patients.Alzheimerās disease patients.
This suggests that the overactivation ofThis suggests that the overactivation of
PARP and the associated exhaustion ofPARP and the associated exhaustion of
cellular energy sources due to thecellular energy sources due to the
depletion of NADdepletion of NAD++
lead to the extensivelead to the extensive
neuron death seen in AD.neuron death seen in AD.
11. The chief risk factor for AD is advanced age.The chief risk factor for AD is advanced age.
Top left: healthy 20-year old; middle: normal 80-Top left: healthy 20-year old; middle: normal 80-
year-old; right: AD patient.year-old; right: AD patient.
12. Folic acid deficiency induces DNAFolic acid deficiency induces DNA
damage in cells via several pathways:damage in cells via several pathways:
1. The promotion of uracil misincorporation: folate is a co-1. The promotion of uracil misincorporation: folate is a co-
factor in the synthesis of dTMP. Low dTMP yields thefactor in the synthesis of dTMP. Low dTMP yields the
DNA polymerase-mediated dUTP misincorporation intoDNA polymerase-mediated dUTP misincorporation into
DNA.DNA.
2. DNA hypomethylation: folate deficiency translates into2. DNA hypomethylation: folate deficiency translates into
fewer methyl groups available to covalently attach tofewer methyl groups available to covalently attach to
DNA for gene regulation.DNA for gene regulation.
3. Impairment of DNA repair: uracil is excised from DNA3. Impairment of DNA repair: uracil is excised from DNA
through base excision repair, resulting in nicks. Thethrough base excision repair, resulting in nicks. The
formation of two opposing nicks leads to deletions,formation of two opposing nicks leads to deletions,
duplications, chromosome breaks.duplications, chromosome breaks.
13. Folate coenzymes are critical forFolate coenzymes are critical for
DNA integrity:DNA integrity:
14. Hypothesis: Folic acid deficiencyHypothesis: Folic acid deficiency
and homocysteine sensitizeand homocysteine sensitize
neurons to Aneurons to AĪ²Ī²-induced death.-induced death.
ā¢ Increased DNA damage has been foundIncreased DNA damage has been found
in the neurons of AD patientsin the neurons of AD patients
ā¢ Non-neuronal cells from AD patientsNon-neuronal cells from AD patients
display defective DNA repairdisplay defective DNA repair
ā¢ Folic acid deficiency and high cellularFolic acid deficiency and high cellular
levels of homocysteine impair DNA repairlevels of homocysteine impair DNA repair
in non-neuronal cellsin non-neuronal cells
15. MethodsMethods
ā¢ Hippocampal andHippocampal and
cortical cell culturescortical cell cultures
ā¢ Included neurons andIncluded neurons and
gliaglia
ā¢ Control: completeControl: complete
mediummedium
ā¢ Methyl-donor deficientMethyl-donor deficient
medium lacked folicmedium lacked folic
acid and methionineacid and methionine
ā¢ APP transgenicAPP transgenic
mouse models aremouse models are
homozygous for thehomozygous for the
āSwedish mutationā.āSwedish mutationā.
Cells that express thisCells that express this
mutant sequencemutant sequence
secrete approximatelysecrete approximately
6-8 times more A6-8 times more AĪ²Ī²
peptide than wild-typepeptide than wild-type
cells.cells.
16. Hippocampal neurons subjected to folateHippocampal neurons subjected to folate
deficiency and homocysteine exhibitdeficiency and homocysteine exhibit
increased vulnerability to Aincreased vulnerability to AĪ²Ī²-induced death.-induced death.
ļ 80% of the neurons maintained in methyl-donor80% of the neurons maintained in methyl-donor
deficient medium died within 72 hours.deficient medium died within 72 hours.
ļ Only 10% of the neurons in complete mediumOnly 10% of the neurons in complete medium
died within 72 hours.died within 72 hours.
17. Folic acid deficiency increasesFolic acid deficiency increases
homocysteine levels and sensitizeshomocysteine levels and sensitizes
hippocampal neurons to death in APPhippocampal neurons to death in APP
mutant transgenic mice.mutant transgenic mice.
18. ļ AmyloidAmyloid Ī²Ī²--
peptide levelspeptide levels
are unchangedare unchanged
in APP mutantin APP mutant
mice maintainedmice maintained
on a folic acid-on a folic acid-
deficient dietdeficient diet
19. Folic acid deficiency and homocysteineFolic acid deficiency and homocysteine
enhance Aenhance AĪ²Ī²-induced DNA damage in-induced DNA damage in
cultured hippocampal neurons andcultured hippocampal neurons and
APP mutant miceAPP mutant mice
20. The Olive Tail Moment is aThe Olive Tail Moment is a
measure of DNA damage inmeasure of DNA damage in
a cell.a cell.
OTM = (amount of DNA in tail) xOTM = (amount of DNA in tail) x
(distance between head and tail(distance between head and tail
regions)regions)
21. Folic acid deficiency promotes uracilFolic acid deficiency promotes uracil
misincorporation and impairs DNA repairmisincorporation and impairs DNA repair
under conditions of exposure to Aunder conditions of exposure to AĪ²Ī²
ā¢ Neurons incubated inNeurons incubated in
methyl-donor deficientmethyl-donor deficient
medium experiencedmedium experienced
a significant increasea significant increase
in uracilin uracil
misincorporationmisincorporation
(p<0.01).(p<0.01).
22. DiscussionDiscussion
ā¢ The combination of low folic acid intake and theThe combination of low folic acid intake and the
consequent hyperhomocysteinemia might put agingconsequent hyperhomocysteinemia might put aging
individuals at increased risk for developing Alzheimerāsindividuals at increased risk for developing Alzheimerās
disease.disease.
ā¢ The CA3 neurons of the hippocampus may beThe CA3 neurons of the hippocampus may be
selectively vulnerable to DNA damage, since noselectively vulnerable to DNA damage, since no
significant damage was seen in the CA1 region.significant damage was seen in the CA1 region.
ā¢ Folic acid deficiency and hyperhomocysteinemiaFolic acid deficiency and hyperhomocysteinemia
accelerate the accumulation of DNA damage that isaccelerate the accumulation of DNA damage that is
promoted by age-related increases in oxidative stresspromoted by age-related increases in oxidative stress
and Aand AĪ²Ī²..
ā¢ Dietary supplementation may reduce the risk of AD.Dietary supplementation may reduce the risk of AD.
23. Folic Acid deficiency is quiteFolic Acid deficiency is quite
common in humans.common in humans.
ā¢ Approximately 10% of the U.S. populationApproximately 10% of the U.S. population
is folate-deficient.is folate-deficient.
ā¢ Folate deficiency is much more prevalentFolate deficiency is much more prevalent
in developing countries. Worldwide, therein developing countries. Worldwide, there
are about 200,000 severe birth defects perare about 200,000 severe birth defects per
year resulting from folate-deficient diets.year resulting from folate-deficient diets.
ā¢ Reduced intestinal absorption of folic acidReduced intestinal absorption of folic acid
in the elderly increases folate-deficiency inin the elderly increases folate-deficiency in
this population to almost 50%.this population to almost 50%.
24. Sources of folic acidSources of folic acid
ā¢ Most cereals and breads are fortified withMost cereals and breads are fortified with
200 Āµg of folic acid per serving.200 Āµg of folic acid per serving.
ā¢ Natural sources of folic acid include leafyNatural sources of folic acid include leafy
greens and citrus.greens and citrus.
ā¢ Most supplements contain 400 Āµg of folicMost supplements contain 400 Āµg of folic
acid.acid.
ā¢ Less than one gram per day of folic acid isLess than one gram per day of folic acid is
considered non-toxic.considered non-toxic.
25. ReferencesReferences
Ames, B. et. al. 1993. Oxidants, antioxidants, and the degenerative diseases of aging. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90:Ames, B. et. al. 1993. Oxidants, antioxidants, and the degenerative diseases of aging. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90:
7915-7922.7915-7922.
Ames, B. et. al. 1995. The causes and prevention of cancer. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 92: 5258-5265.Ames, B. et. al. 1995. The causes and prevention of cancer. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 92: 5258-5265.
Ames, B., and Wakimoto, P. 2002. Are Vitamin and mineral deficiencies a major cancer risk? Nat Rev Cancer 2: 694-Ames, B., and Wakimoto, P. 2002. Are Vitamin and mineral deficiencies a major cancer risk? Nat Rev Cancer 2: 694-
704.704.
Atamma, H. 1999. A method for detecting abasic sites in living cells: age-dependent changes in base excision repair.Atamma, H. 1999. A method for detecting abasic sites in living cells: age-dependent changes in base excision repair.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 97: 686-691.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 97: 686-691.
Blount, B., et. al. 1997. Folate deficiency causes uracil misincorporation into human DNA and chromosome breakage:Blount, B., et. al. 1997. Folate deficiency causes uracil misincorporation into human DNA and chromosome breakage:
implications for cancer and neuronal damage. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94: 3290-3295.implications for cancer and neuronal damage. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94: 3290-3295.
Curtin, N. 2002. PARP-1: A new target for cancer treatment.Curtin, N. 2002. PARP-1: A new target for cancer treatment.
http://www.cancerresearchuk.org/aboutus/publications/scientificyearbook/Parp_cancerhttp://www.cancerresearchuk.org/aboutus/publications/scientificyearbook/Parp_cancer..
Ingram M. 2003. Alzheimerās disease: the molecular origins of the disease are coming to light, suggesting severalIngram M. 2003. Alzheimerās disease: the molecular origins of the disease are coming to light, suggesting several
novel therapies.novel therapies. http://www.americanscientist.org/template/AssetDetail/assetid/21886/page/1http://www.americanscientist.org/template/AssetDetail/assetid/21886/page/1..
Kruman, I. et. al. 2000. Homocysteine elicits a DNA damage response in neurons that promotes apoptosis andKruman, I. et. al. 2000. Homocysteine elicits a DNA damage response in neurons that promotes apoptosis and
hypersensitivity to excitotoxicity. J. Neurosci. 20(18):6920-6926.hypersensitivity to excitotoxicity. J. Neurosci. 20(18):6920-6926.
IMandelbaum-Schmid, J. 2004. Vitamin and mineral deficiency harm one-third of the worldās population, says newIMandelbaum-Schmid, J. 2004. Vitamin and mineral deficiency harm one-third of the worldās population, says new
report. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 82(3): 230-231.report. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 82(3): 230-231.
Mistry, S., et. al. 2002. Cultured rat hippocampal neural progenitors generate spontaneously active neural networks.Mistry, S., et. al. 2002. Cultured rat hippocampal neural progenitors generate spontaneously active neural networks.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99: 1621-1626.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99: 1621-1626.
Strosznajder, J.B., et. al. 2000. Effect of amyloid beta peptide on poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity in adult andStrosznajder, J.B., et. al. 2000. Effect of amyloid beta peptide on poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity in adult and
aged rat hippocampus. Acta Biochimica Polonica 47(3): 847-854.aged rat hippocampus. Acta Biochimica Polonica 47(3): 847-854.
Editor's Notes
Good afternoon, everyone! Since our topic of discussion today is aging as a failure in genomic repair, Iād like to start off by telling a story of micronutrients and lifelong neural integrity.
As our geriatric population continues to grow, it becomes apparent that long life is an attainable goal for many of us.
Clearly, neither society nor the individual benefits from achieving long life if poor health is an unpreventable consequence. It appears that in reducing mortality in our aging population, we have increased morbidity.
Therefore, one of the principal goals of the study of aging should be to diminish the human suffering that many believe is inevitable with advanced age.
DNA is constantly being damaged by both endogenous and exogenous factors. For example, extensive DNA damage is caused by endogenous oxidants that are by-products of normal energy metabolism. Also, we are often subjected to outside sources of damage, such as ionizing radiation, second-hand cigarette smoke, UV radiation, and a host of chemical mutagens.
2. If the everyday, steady-state level of DNA damage remains relatively low, then DNA repair is highly efficient and is very effective in counteracting the aging process.
For example, itās been estimated that the number of oxidative hits to DNA per cell per day is approximately 10,000 in humans. The vast majority of these hits are repaired, but, as we know, nothing is perfect, and this includes our DNA repair mechanisms. This means that the amount of DNA damage incurred in each of our cells very slowly accumulates as we age.
4. As an example, a decline in the activity of base excision repair has been shown in aged cells.
A human cell undergoes around 50,000 single-stranded DNA breaks per day, and only about 10 double-stranded breaks per day.
An unrepaired DSB is so deadly because it can cause deletions or duplications of a relatively large chunk of a chromosome arm, which can potentially lead to the uncontrolled cell proliferation that we call cancer in mitotic cells, or to cell death in non-proliferating cells.
Even single-stranded breaks, if they occur too often, or if DNA mechanisms are impaired, can be quite dangerous because two opposing single-stranded breaks can create one double-stranded break.
Itās postulated that PARP-1 may either act to signal to DNA repair enzymes that damage is present
O
Or
To dislodge histone cores from DNA, relaxing its shape so that the repair enzymes are better able to do their work.
And here, you can see that PARP-1 catalyzes the cleavage of NAD into ADP-ribose and nicotinamide, and in so doing, expends a lot of energy.
Now this slide gives a nice visual of how PARP might work its magic. Once associated with the DNA, PARP synthesizes the ADP-ribose polymers, which, with their overall negative charges, relax the conformation of the DNA molecule, making it more receptive to DNA repair. You can see that the ADP-ribose polymers are covalently attached to the associated proteins, including PARP-1 itself.
PARP-1 contributes to genomic stability by aiding in base excision repair, which Meenaās going to talk about in much more detail in her presentation.
Now this suicide effect is seen in the non-proliferative cells of the body.
Depending on the severity of the DNA damage, NAD+ depletion can occur in minutes.
So, the big question that comes to mind is:
Well, weāre going to address that question in the paper Iām presenting, entitled
And Iāll start by briefly relating the significance of PARP-1 to this paper:
In previous studies, itās been found that overexpression of PARP-1 has been detected in the brains of Alzheimerās disease patients.
Now according to the authors of this paper, this suggests that it is the exhaustion of the cellās energy sources from the overactivation of PARP that leads to neurodegeneration.
Now I know that weāre all familiar with the pathology of Alzheimerās disease, but Iād like to show this slide just to illustrate the extent of neuron death that characterizes this disease. If you compare the coronal sections of the postmortem brains, you can see the normal morphology on the left and the dramatic shrinkage characteristic of advanced AD on the right. The top pictures are PET scans of , from left to right, a normal 20-year-old, a normal 80-year-old, and an AD patient. This shows the reduced blood volume in the AD brain, which indicates a decline in cognitive function.
Folate is required for transferring one carbon units in the synthesis of nucleotides. Folate deficiency decreases the synthesis of thymidylate, which is essentially 5-methyl uracil. DNA polymerases are not terribly discriminating and readily incorporate uracil into newly synthesized DNA strands.
Methylation of cytosine residues is a major epigenetic mechanism for controlling gene expression and silencing. It is absolutely essential for maintaining genomic integrity.
3. Now after uracil is incorporated into the cellās DNA, two repair enzymes, uracil-DNA glycosylase and apyrimidinic endonuclease, generate transient nicks that could result in a less repairable and much more hazardous double-strand break if two opposing nicks are formed.
This is a little schematic diagram of folateās multiple biochemical effects on genomic integrity. Basically, you can see that methylene THF is required for the methylation of deoxyuridylate to thymidylate, and that without sufficient folate, uracil gets incorporated into a nascent DNA strand. Whatās also important in this diagram is that without adequate levels of methyl-THF, there is little synthesis of methionine and homocysteine levels rise in the cell. Homocysteine is toxic to cultured neurons, inducing further DNA damage and leading to apoptosis.
For this study, both cell cultures and mouse models were used.
Primary hippocampal cell cultures from embryonic day 18 rat embryos were used. These hippocampal progenitor cells can differentiate into neuronal networks that display spontaneously generated action potentials. In other words, these cells exhibit all the characteristics of functional neurons. Their networks form spontaneously firing synapses within 7 days.
The cell cultures included neurons and glia, because the authors wanted to determine the effects of methyl-donor deficiency on proliferating cells.
In this first experiment, the authors of this study wanted to answer the question, āWhat are the effects of methyl donor deficiency on neuron survival?ā
The neurons that were exposed to the methyl-donor deficient medium showed a dramatic death rate. Approximately 80% of the neurons died within 72 hours.
And whatās interesting about this experiment is that folate and methionine deficiency was not toxic to the astrocyte but itās proliferation rate was significantly decreased by approximately 65% compared with controls.
Now in this experiment, 7-month-old APP mutant and wild-type mice were put on either the control diet or the folate deficient and homocysteine excessive diet. After 3 months on the diets, the mice were killed, brain slices were prepared and stained with cresyl violet. Upon examination, you can see that both mutant and wild-type mice on the methyl-donor deficient diets exhibit damage to the hippocampal CA3 neurons. Stereology-based counts to determine the numerical densities of neurons in this region were performed, and it was found that the mutant mice on the methyl-donor deficient diet experienced a 20% loss in neurons. Although the wild type mice on the methyl-donor deficient diet did sustain damage to this region, neuron loss was not significant. This suggests that neuronal death may only be triggered when the DNA damage reaches a critical threshold, which is lowered by the combination of a folate-deficient diet and age-related increases in age-related a-beta accumulation.
Thus, the data from this experiment suggest that folate deficiency renders hippocampal CA3 neurons in APP mutants vulnerable to death by a mechanism that doesnāt involve increased a-beta production or deposition.
In this experiment, comet assay analysis was employed to assess the extent of DNA damage in each individual neuron in the cell cultures. Nuclei with damaged DNA have the appearance of a comet with a bright head and a tail, while intact nuclei appear round with no tail. And you can see in the photos on the left that there was a significant increase in DNA damage in the neurons within 8 hours of incubation in the methyl-donor deficient medium. The āolive tail momentā is used to quantify the DNA damage. This the product of the amount of DNA in the tail times the distance between the head and the tail regions. In the graph on the right, DNA damage in tissue samples from both the mutant and wild-type mice is quantified. You can see that there was a significant increase in DNA damage to mutant mice fed a methyl-donor deficient diet for three months. (p&lt;0.01)
To determine the effects of folic acid deficiency on uracil misincorporation, neurons were incubated in UDG, an enzyme that removes misincorporated uracil. This results in DNA strand breaks that can then be detected by comet assay and analyzed by olive tail moment.