Range of threshold identification for traffic flow parameters using fuzzy logic

1. BAYERO UNIVERSITY KANO
FACULTY OF ENGINEERING
Identification of the Range of Threshold for Fuzzy Input in Traffic Flow
By
Yusuf Musa Yerima
SPS/21/MCE/00027
Submitted To
Engr. Prof. H.M. Alhassan
November, 2023
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
CIV8331: Advance Traffic Engineering
Assignment On:

2. WHAT IS FUZZY LOGIC AND INPUT?
• Fuzzy logic is a mathematical framework that deals with reasoning and
decision-making under uncertainty. Unlike traditional binary logic (true or
false), fuzzy logic allows for degrees of truth between 0 and 1. It's often used
in control systems, artificial intelligence, and various applications where
imprecise or ambiguous information needs to be considered.
• Fuzzy input refers to input data or information that is imprecise or has
uncertainty associated with it. In fuzzy logic systems, input variables can take
on a range of values with degrees of membership in different fuzzy sets. This
allows the system to handle and process information that may not have clear-
cut boundaries, enabling a more flexible and realistic representation of certain
types of data.

3. HOW DOES FUZZY LOGIC WORKS?

4. INTRODUCTION
• Since 1965 when the fuzzy logic and fuzzy algebra were introduced
by Lotfi Zadeh, the fuzzy theory successfully found its applications
in the wide range of subject fields. This is mainly due to its ability to
process various data, including vague or uncertain data, and provide
results that are suitable for the decision making.
• The increasing complexity of urban traffic systems demands
intelligent and adaptive control mechanisms to optimize traffic flow.
Fuzzy logic has emerged as a promising approach for setting
thresholds in traffic management, offering the flexibility to capture
the uncertainty inherent in real-world traffic conditions(Al-Jarrah,
O,2017)

5. INTRODUCTION (CONT.)
• Many research aimed to contribute to the evolving landscape of intelligent
traffic control by investigating the range of thresholds using fuzzy logic
through an exploration of dynamic adaptation strategies, threshold range
selection methodologies, and the integration of human behavior models.
• In a fuzzy logic system for traffic flow parameters, the range of thresholds
is defined using linguistic variables and fuzzy sets. Here are some
examples of the driver car-following behavior when entering a u-turn,
1. Distance to the Lead Vehicle:
v Fuzzy sets: Far, Medium, Close
v Linguistic rules: If the distance to the lead vehicle is "Close" then
decrease speed.

6. INTRODUCTION (CONT.)
2. Speed of the Lead Vehicle:
vFuzzy sets: Slow, Moderate, Fast
vLinguistic rules: If the lead vehicle is moving "Slow,"
then maintain a safe following distance.
3. Driver Comfort Level:
vFuzzy sets: Uncomfortable, Neutral, Comfortable
vLinguistic rules: If the driver feels "Uncomfortable" due
to the u-turn, then adjust speed and following distance.

7. INTRODUCTION (CONT.)
• These fuzzy logic examples help create a system
that can make decisions based on imprecise and
uncertain inputs. By incorporating fuzzy sets and
rules, the model can emulate human-like reasoning,
making the car-following behavior more adaptable to
varying conditions during a making u-turn.
• In summary, it’s important to note that the range of
thresholds in fuzzy logic is not fixed and can be
adjusted based on the specific needs and objectives of
the traffic flow analysis or control system.

8. PROBLEM STATEMENT
• The increasing complexity of urban traffic systems demands
intelligent and adaptive control mechanisms to optimize traffic
flow. Fuzzy logic has emerged as a promising approach for
setting thresholds in traffic management, offering the flexibility to
capture the uncertainty inherent in real-time traffic conditions by
enabling more accurate and robust analysis and decision-making
in transportation systems.

9. AIM AND OBJECTIVES
• The aim is to determine the thresholds range using fuzzy logic for traffic
flow parameters such as traffic speed, traffic density, traffic congestion and
driver behaviors in order to enhance the adaptability of traffic control
systems by incorporating a more flexible approach.
• The objective of this study is to determine using fuzzy logic models that
can handle the uncertainty and imprecision associated with traffic flow
parameters especially the fundamental traffic stream parameters (flow,
density and speed) and the driver’s behavior such as aggressiveness or
cautiousness and how such behavior can influence factors like following
distances, lane changing patterns, and reaction times.

10. LITERATURE REVIEW
• The literature on fuzzy logic applied to traffic flow thresholds
encompasses various aspects, including dynamic adaptation, optimal
selection, and integration with smart infrastructure. Notable studies
emphasize the importance of real-time adjustments in fuzzy
thresholds based on traffic conditions (Huang et al., 2018),
• Tarhini, A, (2018), Threshold values are used to determine the
membership of an element in a fuzzy set. These thresholds can vary
based on the context and the granularity of your model. Here are some
general examples of threshold ranges for traffic flow:

11. LITERATURE REVIEW (CONT.)
1. Traffic Density:
v Low: 0 to 0.3
v Moderate: 0.2 to 0.7
v High: 0.5 to 1.0
2. Traffic Speed:
v Slow: 0 to 0.4
v Moderate: 0.3 to 0.7
v Fast: 0.6 to 1.0
3. Traffic Congestion:
v Light: 0 to 0.3
v Moderate: 0.2 to 0.6
v Heavy: 0.5 to 1.0

12. LITERATURE REVIEW (CONT.)
• Al-Jarrah, O, (2017) , The specific range and terms used can be determined based
on the characteristics of the traffic system. Some common fuzzy parameters used in
traffic flow analysis include:
1. Traffic density: Fuzzy sets can be used to describe traffic density, where
membership functions represent low, moderate, and high-density levels.
2. Traffic speed: Fuzzy logic can be used to model varying speeds, such as slow,
moderate, and fast traffic speeds.
3. Traffic congestion: Fuzzy sets can describe the degree of congestion, ranging
from light congestion to heavy congestion.
4. Driver behavior: Fuzzy parameters can be used to model driver behavior, such as
aggressive, cautious, or normal driving.
5. Weather conditions: Fuzzy logic can represent weather conditions like light rain,
heavy rain, snow, and their impact on traffic flow.

13. LITERATURE REVIEW (CONT.)
• Human behavior modeling is identified as a critical factor, with
efforts directed towards integrating realistic driver reactions into
fuzzy thresholds (Chien et al., 2017).
• In summary, the literature on fuzzy logic on thresholds range for
traffic flow underscores the significance of dynamic adaptation,
optimal selection, uncertainty handling, human behavior integration,
multi-criteria decision-making, mixed traffic scenarios, smart
infrastructure integration, sensitivity analysis, and scalability.

14. CURRENT RESEARCH ON THE STUDY AREA
1. "Adaptive Threshold Determination for Fuzzy Traffic Flow Classification" by M.
Pradhan et al. (2021): The authors use a combination of fuzzy logic and
evolutionary optimization algorithms to dynamically adjust the threshold values
based on real-time traffic data. The effectiveness of the proposed approach is
evaluated using a case study in urban road networks.
2. "Fuzzy Logic-Based Traffic Flow Assessment Using Real-Time Data" by K.
Kumar et al. (2020): The study recommends a range of threshold values based on
fuzzy logic-based classification of traffic conditions. The proposed approach is
validated using traffic data collected from multiple urban areas.

15. CURRENT RESEARCH ON THE STUDY AREA (CONT.)
3. "Fuzzy Model for Traffic Flow Classification" by P. D. Ponnaganti et al.
(2019): The study focuses on determining the range of threshold values for traffic
variables, such as traffic volume, speed, and occupancy. The proposed model is
applied to real-time traffic data, and its performance is compared against
traditional traffic flow classification methods.
4. "Fuzzy Logic-Based Inference System for Traffic Flow Classification" by S.
Patra et al. (2018): The authors determine the range of thresholds for traffic
variables by considering the linguistic terms and membership functions.
• In summary, these recent studies provide insights into the use of fuzzy logic
for determining the range of thresholds in traffic flow classification. They apply
innovative approaches to dynamically adjust the thresholds based on real-time
traffic data, enhancing the accuracy and adaptability of the fuzzy logic models.

16. PROBLEMS WITH THE CURRENT RESEARCH
v Lack of consensus on threshold determination
v Subjectivity in defining membership functions
v Data availability and quality
v Limited validation and benchmarking
v Interpretation challenges
• Despite these challenges, fuzzy logic still offers valuable insights into
understanding traffic flow patterns and has been successfully applied in
various transportation systems worldwide. Researchers continue to work
on addressing these problems through advancements in methodology and
standardization efforts within the field.

17. FUTURE DIRECTIONS IN THE SUBJECT AREA
v Integration with emerging technologies
v Dynamic threshold adjustment
v Multi-modal traffic systems
v Human Behavior Integration
v Cybersecurity Concerns
• These potential future researches aim to advance the understanding
and application of fuzzy logic in addressing the complex challenges
associated with traffic flow in evolving urban environments and
real-world situations.

18. CONCLUSIONS
• The primary aim of this work is to determine the range of threshold for
fuzzy input in traffic flow parameters. Some literature has been reviewed
that dealt with the use of fuzzy logic to determine the range of threshold
for traffic flow parameters especially fundamental traffic stream
parameters (flow, density and speed) and the driver behavior such as
aggressiveness or cautiousness and how such behavior can influence
factors like following distances, lane changing patterns, and reaction
times. The study highlights the sensitivity of traffic flow parameters to
threshold values in fuzzy logic emphasizing the need for a systematic
exploration of a range of thresholds. Through systematic analysis, optimal
parameters for fuzzy logic thresholds can be identified and contribute to
the enhancement of traffic management systems.

19. RECOMMENDATIONS
v Integration with Advanced Technologies
v Continuous Threshold Monitoring
v Collaboration with Stakeholders
v Public Awareness and Education
v Security Measures
v Pilot Programs

20. REFERENCES
1. Al-Jarrah, O., Malkawi, M., Al Khasawneh, L., & Al-Zoubi, H. (2017). Modeling traffic flow with fuzzy logic. International Journal of Scientific &
Engineering Research, 8(5), 35-41.
2. Chien, S., Ding, Y., & Wei, C. (2017). A Fuzzy Logic Model for Assessing Drivers' Behavior in Work Zone Merging Areas. Journal of Advanced
Transportation, 2017, 8795404.
3. Guney, K.; Sarikaya, N. (2009). Comparison of Mamdani and Sugeno Fuzzy Inference System Models for Resonant Frequency Calculation of
Rectangular Microstrip Antennas. Prog. Electromagn. Res. B 2009, 12, 81–104. [CrossRef]
4. Huang, J., Li, X., & Huang, G. (2018). Adaptive Traffic Signal Control Using Fuzzy Logic: A Review. IEEE Access, 6, 57962-57975.
5. Jamal, A.; Rahman, M.T.; Al-Ahmadi, H.M.; Mansoor, U. (2020). The Dilemma of Road Safety in the Eastern Province of Saudi Arabia:
Consequences and Prevention Strategies. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, 157.[CrossRef] [PubMed]
6. K. Kumar, A. Sharma, and R. V. Prasad, (2020). "Fuzzy Logic-Based Traffic Flow Assessment Using Real-Time Data," in Transportation Research
Record, vol. 2674, no. 10, pp. 560-570, 2020.
7. Li, H., Sun, D., & Shi, X. (2018). A Fuzzy Logic-Based Approach for Traffic Signal Timing Optimization Considering Environmental Impact.
Sustainability, 10(2), 431.
8. Liu, S., Ma, S., & Li, W. (2020). Scalability Analysis of a Fuzzy Logic-Based Traffic Signal Control System. Mathematical Problems in
Engineering, 2020, 4260131.
9. Li, W., Wang, D., & Yang, Z. (2020). A Fuzzy Logic-Based Adaptive Traffic Light Control System with Uncertainty Handling. Sensors, 20(10),
2932
10. M. Pradhan, A. Bhaskar, and R. Mishra, (2021)"Adaptive Threshold Determination for Fuzzy Traffic Flow Classification," Journal of Advanced
Transportation, vol. 2021, Article ID 8881687, 12 pages, 2021.
11. P. D. Ponnaganti, S. D. U. Gandham, and M. A. A. Raoof, (2019). "Fuzzy Model for Traffic Flow Classification," Journal of Advanced
Transportation, vol. 2019, Article ID 6921953, 11 pages, 2019.
12. Ross, T.J. (2005). Fuzzy Logic with Engineering Applications; John Wiley & Sons: Hoboken, NJ, USA, 2005.
13. S. Patra and R. K. Sahu,(2018). "Fuzzy Logic-Based Inference System for Traffic Flow Classification," in International Journal of Civil Engineering
and Technology, vol. 9, no. 9, pp. 787-795, 2018.
14. Tarhini, A., Vergados, D. J., & Dobre, C. (2018). Fuzzy logic-based model for predicting traffic congestion. International Journal of Computer
Networks and Applications, 5(2), 77-84.
15. Wang, J., Zhang, Y., & Cheng, R. (2022). A Fuzzy Logic-Based Intelligent Traffic Light Control System with Smart Infrastructure Integration.
Electronics, 11(8), 958.
16. Wang, Y., Qian, Y., & Chen, X. (2019). Fuzzy Logic-Based Traffic Signal Control: A Review.
17. Zhang, Y., Wang, Y., & Wang, S. (2021). Fuzzy Logic-Based Traffic Signal Control for Mixed Traffic Flow of Connected and Autonomous Vehicles.
Sensors, 21(10), 3586.
18. Zhou, Y., Li, J., & Guan, W. (2019). Sensitivity Analysis of Fuzzy Logic Controller Parameters for Traffic Signal Control. IEEE Access, 7, 176752-
176763.

21. THANK YOU FOR
LISTENING