SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Locating urban strategies
                   in a continuum of climate change
                   adaptation
                   T E Downing, L Downing, F Zermoglio, C Lacambra, M Hamza
                   Brainstorming on urban adaptation

                   15 November 2012




                                For internal use           15 November 2012
T Downing et al.
Abstract

Urban planning is a particular entry point for climate change adaptation. As its own
community of practice, it comes with visions and procedures, concepts and definitions,
and frameworks. In working with this community, as with any end-user, our aim is to
develop solutions that fit within their reference points.
To this end, we are developing:
•   Five entry points that correspond to different stages in a continuum of adaptation
•   Benchmarking each entry point in terms of urban planning with examples from around
    the world
•   Initial assessments of where we expect a sample of cities we are working with to be
    located in this continuum
•   A set of strategies that are appropriate to each entry point, taking the location in the
    continuum as guidance for urgent priorities and competence in moving forward




T Downing, C Lacambra
Brainstorming a continuum of adaptation

Key:
Dashed: baseline
Solid: early action
Double: vision and future strategy
                                                        Prepare for additional
                                                       climate change impacts

                   Build capacity for climate
                      change adaptation



                                         Manage               Enhance spatial
                                         current                 planning for
                                      disaster risks              future risks
           Ensure basic planning
                 services
Benchmarks


For each entry point…
•   Ensure basic planning services
•   Manage current disaster risks
•   Build capacity for climate adaptation
•   Enhance spatial planning for future risks
•   Prepare for additional climate change impacts


There are different requirements and strategies…


Moving forward from one level to the next is a choice…
Working on a template



Strategy name           [photo/graphic]
Rationale

Benchmark/use case      Good practice example/reference

[place]                 [sector]
Objective

Activities              Outcomes
*                       *
*                       *
*                       *
Illustrative example
Document incidences of local flooding

Flooding ranges from major disasters along rivers to
local hot spots of inundation during intense rainfalls.
Building up a picture of where flooding occurs helps
people to understand the many aspects of the
hazard, as well as who is vulnerable and what can be
done.




Dar es Salaam                                                Oxford developed a data base of weather-related
With very little relief, local flooding ties up traffic as   events, compiled from newspapers and interviews
well as damages key infrastructure                           with key managers. The data helped identify impacts,
                                                             but also recorded what managers felt they could do
                                                             to reduce the economic cost of short-term events. It
                                                             has been helpful in mainstreaming adaptation within
                                                             existing maintenance and infrastructure budgets.
Objective: Monitor local flood impacts and                   Lead stakeholder: City of Dar es Salaam, supported
responses by key agencies, beginning with an                 by relevant ministries and in association with the
historical baseline of events since 2000.                    University of Dar es Salaam (commissioned to
                                                             develop the reporting template and baseline)
Activities                                                   Outcomes
* Develop baseline and template for reporting                * Shared, documented data base of weather-related
* Record events as they occur over a 3 year test             flood events including estimates of impacts and
project                                                      responses
* Produce an annual review to validate the data and          * Raised awareness and initial procedures for
disseminate early lessons learned                            reducing flood damages within existing agencies and
                                                             budgets

More Related Content

Similar to Benchmarking Urban Adaptation Strategies

Development of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian Municipalities
Development of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian MunicipalitiesDevelopment of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian Municipalities
Development of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian MunicipalitiesCagney
 
Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration
Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration
Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration ENVIRONMENTALALERTEA1
 
How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...
How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...
How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...weADAPT
 
Jerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects Presentation
Jerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects PresentationJerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects Presentation
Jerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects PresentationIwl Pcu
 
Susanne Rasmussen 2013 masccc
Susanne Rasmussen 2013 mascccSusanne Rasmussen 2013 masccc
Susanne Rasmussen 2013 mascccJen Boudrie
 
Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...
Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...
Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...Robert Muir
 
Ian Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRR
Ian Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRRIan Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRR
Ian Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRRNAPExpo 2014
 
Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)
Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)
Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)Bayes Ahmed
 
Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...
Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...
Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...GWP-Mediterranean (GWP-Med)
 
NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...
NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...
NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...UNDP Climate
 
Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...
Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...
Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...Sabrina Dekker
 
UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019
UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019
UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019NAP Events
 
Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...
Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...
Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...NAP Events
 
Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015
Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015
Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015Gina Ziervogel
 
Lima me of adaptation rupa mukerji
Lima me of adaptation rupa mukerjiLima me of adaptation rupa mukerji
Lima me of adaptation rupa mukerjiASOCAM
 
Lessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP process
Lessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP processLessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP process
Lessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP processNAP Global Network
 

Similar to Benchmarking Urban Adaptation Strategies (20)

Development of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian Municipalities
Development of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian MunicipalitiesDevelopment of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian Municipalities
Development of Local Climate Action Plans in 3 Jordanian Municipalities
 
Adapting to Climate Change: Assessing World Bank Group Experienceadaptation f...
Adapting to Climate Change: Assessing World Bank Group Experienceadaptation f...Adapting to Climate Change: Assessing World Bank Group Experienceadaptation f...
Adapting to Climate Change: Assessing World Bank Group Experienceadaptation f...
 
Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration
Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration
Guidelines for mainstreaming climate change and key consideration
 
How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...
How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...
How to be a municipality that is adapting well: lessons from within the City ...
 
Hydropower Siting, Design, Operations in Changing Climate
Hydropower Siting, Design, Operations in Changing ClimateHydropower Siting, Design, Operations in Changing Climate
Hydropower Siting, Design, Operations in Changing Climate
 
Jerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects Presentation
Jerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects PresentationJerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects Presentation
Jerker Tamelander - Mainstreaming CC in IW Projects Presentation
 
Susanne Rasmussen 2013 masccc
Susanne Rasmussen 2013 mascccSusanne Rasmussen 2013 masccc
Susanne Rasmussen 2013 masccc
 
Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...
Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...
Extreme Weather Resiliency and Climate Adaptation Through Strategic Asset Man...
 
Adaptive Disaster Risk Reduction
Adaptive Disaster Risk ReductionAdaptive Disaster Risk Reduction
Adaptive Disaster Risk Reduction
 
Ian Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRR
Ian Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRRIan Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRR
Ian Noble: Lessons from the PPCR and GFDRR
 
Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)
Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)
Lecture 6: Urban & Regional Planning (Risk Mitigation Concept)
 
Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...
Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...
Workshop on Flood management in a transboundary context, 13-14.12.2011, Jacob...
 
NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...
NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...
NAP-Ag - Addressing agricultural resilience in long term climate planning ins...
 
Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...
Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...
Building Capacity by Building Bridges: Lessons from Developing the Dublin Reg...
 
UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019
UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019
UNCDF local NAP supplementary guideline April 2019
 
Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...
Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...
Session 4.5 Updating the National Climate Change Action Plan: Towards an e...
 
Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015
Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015
Ziervogel Paris #CFCC15 Co-producing an adaptation plan 2015
 
A Green Budget for Europe Cohesion Policy contributions by Patrick ten Brink ...
A Green Budget for Europe Cohesion Policy contributions by Patrick ten Brink ...A Green Budget for Europe Cohesion Policy contributions by Patrick ten Brink ...
A Green Budget for Europe Cohesion Policy contributions by Patrick ten Brink ...
 
Lima me of adaptation rupa mukerji
Lima me of adaptation rupa mukerjiLima me of adaptation rupa mukerji
Lima me of adaptation rupa mukerji
 
Lessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP process
Lessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP processLessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP process
Lessons learned from South Africa on M&E in the NAP process
 

Benchmarking Urban Adaptation Strategies

  • 1. Locating urban strategies in a continuum of climate change adaptation T E Downing, L Downing, F Zermoglio, C Lacambra, M Hamza Brainstorming on urban adaptation 15 November 2012 For internal use 15 November 2012 T Downing et al.
  • 2. Abstract Urban planning is a particular entry point for climate change adaptation. As its own community of practice, it comes with visions and procedures, concepts and definitions, and frameworks. In working with this community, as with any end-user, our aim is to develop solutions that fit within their reference points. To this end, we are developing: • Five entry points that correspond to different stages in a continuum of adaptation • Benchmarking each entry point in terms of urban planning with examples from around the world • Initial assessments of where we expect a sample of cities we are working with to be located in this continuum • A set of strategies that are appropriate to each entry point, taking the location in the continuum as guidance for urgent priorities and competence in moving forward T Downing, C Lacambra
  • 3. Brainstorming a continuum of adaptation Key: Dashed: baseline Solid: early action Double: vision and future strategy Prepare for additional climate change impacts Build capacity for climate change adaptation Manage Enhance spatial current planning for disaster risks future risks Ensure basic planning services
  • 4. Benchmarks For each entry point… • Ensure basic planning services • Manage current disaster risks • Build capacity for climate adaptation • Enhance spatial planning for future risks • Prepare for additional climate change impacts There are different requirements and strategies… Moving forward from one level to the next is a choice…
  • 5. Working on a template Strategy name [photo/graphic] Rationale Benchmark/use case Good practice example/reference [place] [sector] Objective Activities Outcomes * * * * * *
  • 6. Illustrative example Document incidences of local flooding Flooding ranges from major disasters along rivers to local hot spots of inundation during intense rainfalls. Building up a picture of where flooding occurs helps people to understand the many aspects of the hazard, as well as who is vulnerable and what can be done. Dar es Salaam Oxford developed a data base of weather-related With very little relief, local flooding ties up traffic as events, compiled from newspapers and interviews well as damages key infrastructure with key managers. The data helped identify impacts, but also recorded what managers felt they could do to reduce the economic cost of short-term events. It has been helpful in mainstreaming adaptation within existing maintenance and infrastructure budgets. Objective: Monitor local flood impacts and Lead stakeholder: City of Dar es Salaam, supported responses by key agencies, beginning with an by relevant ministries and in association with the historical baseline of events since 2000. University of Dar es Salaam (commissioned to develop the reporting template and baseline) Activities Outcomes * Develop baseline and template for reporting * Shared, documented data base of weather-related * Record events as they occur over a 3 year test flood events including estimates of impacts and project responses * Produce an annual review to validate the data and * Raised awareness and initial procedures for disseminate early lessons learned reducing flood damages within existing agencies and budgets