2. BACKGROUND
• # of materials collected: 1,284
• # of materials screened: 150
• # of materials reviewed: 82 (out of 150)
• # of materials selected: 76 (need approval for
web
portal)
3. CRITERIA FOR THE REVIEW:
Criteria Score
1 .Good design & appropriate for
smallholder farmers
20
2 .Inclusion 10
3 .Gender mainstreaming 10
4 .Climate smart agriculture (CSA) 20
5 .Hight profitability / Farm
Business
20
6. Food safety 20
Total 100
Scores Quality Selection
from > 80 to 100 Excellent
Selected
from 65 to 80 Good
from > 50 to < 65 Fair
Not
selected 50 Not good
Quality Rank:
5. Count of Thematic
areas
Animal health & production 1
Aquaculture 8
Bio-digester Plant 5
Business (business plan) 2
Cash-crop production 3
Climate Smart Agriculture 1
Forestry 3
Fruit tree production 6
Integrated Pest Management 8
Mushroom production 1
Poultry production 1
Rice production 4
Soil management 1
Vegetable growing 32
Grand Total 76
6. AVERAGE SCORES OF THE 76 REVIEWED
MATERIALS
Criteria
Max.
scores
Average scores given to
the 76 reviewed materials
Good design
20 17
Inclusion
10 10
Gender mainstreaming
10 7
Climate smart agriculture
20 14
Farm business
20 13
Food safety
20 13
Average of total score
100 73
7. Count of Authors
ASPIRE 2
Cambodia HARVEST 13
GDA/DAE 9
DCA/CA 1
East-West Seed 2
Food Facility Project 1
GIZ 3
MSME 1
NBP 5
PADEE 5
PDAFF-Kandal 4
People in Need (PIN) 1
TSSD/ TSTD 29
Grand Total 76
Count of Forms
Booklet 28
Newsletter 13
Leaflet 23
Poster 9
Video 3
Grand Total 76
Check existing cover has been used by the aspire program – it needs to be uniformed
GDA/DAE to collect more materials from MAFF and non MAFF agencies
The list of six main criteria with sub-criteria
Score for each criterion, and total score
classify by quality of the materials (good…)
Need to emphasize that selection is from 65 up
Form for the review
Category
Medium / form
Year of publication
Author
Score
Category
Medium / form
Year of publication
Author
Score
It is to note that these materials were produced from 2010 to 2016, however most of the materials published in 2012 & 2013. At the same time, there are also materials produced in 2015 -2016.
Check the vidieo