Submit Search
Upload
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
•
0 likes
•
468 views
RregullatIslame
Follow
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Read less
Read more
Education
Report
Share
Report
Share
1 of 54
Download now
Download to read offline
Recommended
Sq Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Sq Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Fatos
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
1490-ONDERZOEK HISTORISCHE SPANTEN-smallprint
1490-ONDERZOEK HISTORISCHE SPANTEN-smallprint
Tektor interieur & architectuur
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
zakir2012
The Subtle art of Mental toughness by Author Devanssh Mehta
The Subtle art of Mental toughness by Author Devanssh Mehta
DevansshMehta
Linux assembly language programming
Linux assembly language programming
Protim Debnath
Apostila sisvarmanual
Apostila sisvarmanual
Yrlânia Guerra
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
PublicLeaker
Recommended
Sq Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Sq Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Fatos
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
1490-ONDERZOEK HISTORISCHE SPANTEN-smallprint
1490-ONDERZOEK HISTORISCHE SPANTEN-smallprint
Tektor interieur & architectuur
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
Material On The Authenticity Of The Quran
zakir2012
The Subtle art of Mental toughness by Author Devanssh Mehta
The Subtle art of Mental toughness by Author Devanssh Mehta
DevansshMehta
Linux assembly language programming
Linux assembly language programming
Protim Debnath
Apostila sisvarmanual
Apostila sisvarmanual
Yrlânia Guerra
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
Other tongues other flesh - by george hunt williamson
PublicLeaker
After Your Heart Attack
After Your Heart Attack
TmbMedical
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
zakir2012
Concentration distribution in turbulent flow corrosion equation
Concentration distribution in turbulent flow corrosion equation
Nithya M
Les cabanes de volta a juneda
Les cabanes de volta a juneda
Antoni Aixalà
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Goswami Mahirpari
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
FAROUQ
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
FAROUQ
The Book Of Miscellany
The Book Of Miscellany
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
Loveofpeople
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
FAROUQ
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
FAROUQ
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
FAROUQ
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
FAROUQ
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
P6P
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Connor T. MacIVOR
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
Suzy
Suzy
Ahmet Türkan
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Lexo dhe Mëso
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the muslim
E verteta vjen nga Zoti
Fortress of the Muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Zaffer Khan
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
The Chosen One
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
The Choice
More Related Content
What's hot
After Your Heart Attack
After Your Heart Attack
TmbMedical
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
zakir2012
Concentration distribution in turbulent flow corrosion equation
Concentration distribution in turbulent flow corrosion equation
Nithya M
Les cabanes de volta a juneda
Les cabanes de volta a juneda
Antoni Aixalà
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Goswami Mahirpari
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
FAROUQ
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
FAROUQ
The Book Of Miscellany
The Book Of Miscellany
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
Loveofpeople
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
FAROUQ
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
FAROUQ
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
FAROUQ
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
FAROUQ
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
P6P
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Connor T. MacIVOR
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
Suzy
Suzy
Ahmet Türkan
What's hot
(17)
After Your Heart Attack
After Your Heart Attack
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Concentration distribution in turbulent flow corrosion equation
Concentration distribution in turbulent flow corrosion equation
Les cabanes de volta a juneda
Les cabanes de volta a juneda
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
The Book Of Miscellany
The Book Of Miscellany
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Suzy
Suzy
Similar to Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Lexo dhe Mëso
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the muslim
E verteta vjen nga Zoti
Fortress of the Muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Zaffer Khan
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
The Chosen One
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
The Choice
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
The Choice
Fortress of a_muslim
Fortress of a_muslim
Mohammad Ali
Fortress of the_muslim
Fortress of the_muslim
Sonali Jannat
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
ayshaayyoob2003
9146art9
9146art9
PT Carbon Indonesia
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Islamic Homeschooling
CSR and Global Citizenship in the global business
CSR and Global Citizenship in the global business
Dr. Rakesh Ainapur
Wa clubs and activities explanations
Wa clubs and activities explanations
walibrarian2012
RESUME
RESUME
YOGESH GEHLOT
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Loveofpeople
Contemporary Issues
Contemporary Issues
Islamic Library
Twitter Traffic
Twitter Traffic
Michael Mayhew
Fiqh us-sunnah
Fiqh us-sunnah
Noor Al Islam
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Chemtrails Spoter
Similar to Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
(20)
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of a_muslim
Fortress of a_muslim
Fortress of the_muslim
Fortress of the_muslim
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
9146art9
9146art9
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
CSR and Global Citizenship in the global business
CSR and Global Citizenship in the global business
Wa clubs and activities explanations
Wa clubs and activities explanations
RESUME
RESUME
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Contemporary Issues
Contemporary Issues
Twitter Traffic
Twitter Traffic
Fiqh us-sunnah
Fiqh us-sunnah
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
More from RregullatIslame
Dielli i Allahut shkëlqen mbi perëndimin
Dielli i Allahut shkëlqen mbi perëndimin
RregullatIslame
Studime rreth fesë Krishtere
Studime rreth fesë Krishtere
RregullatIslame
30. Mësim besimi fuqizon dhe avancon qytetërimin
30. Mësim besimi fuqizon dhe avancon qytetërimin
RregullatIslame
24. Bëhu çelës për të mirën
24. Bëhu çelës për të mirën
RregullatIslame
20. Kaloi edhe një vit
20. Kaloi edhe një vit
RregullatIslame
22. Hytbet e xhumasë dhe hatibët e sotshëm
22. Hytbet e xhumasë dhe hatibët e sotshëm
RregullatIslame
21. Vlera e të qarët nga frika e Allahut
21. Vlera e të qarët nga frika e Allahut
RregullatIslame
18. A është kush që djeg Biblën
18. A është kush që djeg Biblën
RregullatIslame
16. Xhelozia për shenjat e fe
16. Xhelozia për shenjat e fe
RregullatIslame
29. Kënaqësia e të jetuarit me fenë e Allahut
29. Kënaqësia e të jetuarit me fenë e Allahut
RregullatIslame
27. Si të shfrytëzojmë pushimet verore
27. Si të shfrytëzojmë pushimet verore
RregullatIslame
26. Kush po e cenon tolerancën mes qytetërimeve
26. Kush po e cenon tolerancën mes qytetërimeve
RregullatIslame
25. Mos u dëshpëro
25. Mos u dëshpëro
RregullatIslame
23. Turpi është nga degët e imanit
23. Turpi është nga degët e imanit
RregullatIslame
28. Xhamia, institucion edukimi dhe adhurimi
28. Xhamia, institucion edukimi dhe adhurimi
RregullatIslame
10. A është kush që përvjel krahët
10. A është kush që përvjel krahët
RregullatIslame
19. Haxhi dhe uniteti i muslimanëve
19. Haxhi dhe uniteti i muslimanëve
RregullatIslame
17. Shkollimi në institucionet publike sot
17. Shkollimi në institucionet publike sot
RregullatIslame
15. Devotshmëria, sprovat, ballafaqimi
15. Devotshmëria, sprovat, ballafaqimi
RregullatIslame
14. A ekzistojnë fantazmat
14. A ekzistojnë fantazmat
RregullatIslame
More from RregullatIslame
(20)
Dielli i Allahut shkëlqen mbi perëndimin
Dielli i Allahut shkëlqen mbi perëndimin
Studime rreth fesë Krishtere
Studime rreth fesë Krishtere
30. Mësim besimi fuqizon dhe avancon qytetërimin
30. Mësim besimi fuqizon dhe avancon qytetërimin
24. Bëhu çelës për të mirën
24. Bëhu çelës për të mirën
20. Kaloi edhe një vit
20. Kaloi edhe një vit
22. Hytbet e xhumasë dhe hatibët e sotshëm
22. Hytbet e xhumasë dhe hatibët e sotshëm
21. Vlera e të qarët nga frika e Allahut
21. Vlera e të qarët nga frika e Allahut
18. A është kush që djeg Biblën
18. A është kush që djeg Biblën
16. Xhelozia për shenjat e fe
16. Xhelozia për shenjat e fe
29. Kënaqësia e të jetuarit me fenë e Allahut
29. Kënaqësia e të jetuarit me fenë e Allahut
27. Si të shfrytëzojmë pushimet verore
27. Si të shfrytëzojmë pushimet verore
26. Kush po e cenon tolerancën mes qytetërimeve
26. Kush po e cenon tolerancën mes qytetërimeve
25. Mos u dëshpëro
25. Mos u dëshpëro
23. Turpi është nga degët e imanit
23. Turpi është nga degët e imanit
28. Xhamia, institucion edukimi dhe adhurimi
28. Xhamia, institucion edukimi dhe adhurimi
10. A është kush që përvjel krahët
10. A është kush që përvjel krahët
19. Haxhi dhe uniteti i muslimanëve
19. Haxhi dhe uniteti i muslimanëve
17. Shkollimi në institucionet publike sot
17. Shkollimi në institucionet publike sot
15. Devotshmëria, sprovat, ballafaqimi
15. Devotshmëria, sprovat, ballafaqimi
14. A ekzistojnë fantazmat
14. A ekzistojnë fantazmat
Recently uploaded
taibif_開放資料流程-清理資料01-通則_20240509_20240509.pdf
taibif_開放資料流程-清理資料01-通則_20240509_20240509.pdf
jhujyunjhang
啟思中國語文 - 中二 單元一 - 孟嘗君列傳 - 記敍的方法和人稱1.pptx
啟思中國語文 - 中二 單元一 - 孟嘗君列傳 - 記敍的方法和人稱1.pptx
businesshealthwise
1.🎉“黑客”如何修改成绩?🤔🎉 在这个信息爆炸的时代,我们经常会看到各种作弊手段。但是你知道吗?有一种作弊方式可能比你想象中更巧妙:它就是——黑客![单...
1.🎉“黑客”如何修改成绩?🤔🎉 在这个信息爆炸的时代,我们经常会看到各种作弊手段。但是你知道吗?有一种作弊方式可能比你想象中更巧妙:它就是——黑客![单...
微信 tytyqqww业务接单
法国蒙彼利埃国家高等建筑学院毕业证制作/德语歌德B1证书/加拿大新斯科舍省农业学院文凭加急制作一个
法国蒙彼利埃国家高等建筑学院毕业证制作/德语歌德B1证书/加拿大新斯科舍省农业学院文凭加急制作一个
michaelell902
taibif_資料標準概念介紹_20240509_20240509_20340509.pdf
taibif_資料標準概念介紹_20240509_20240509_20340509.pdf
jhujyunjhang
10.2.1 马来西亚各州名称的由来六年级历史单元练习马来西亚各州名称的由来练习
10.2.1 马来西亚各州名称的由来六年级历史单元练习马来西亚各州名称的由来练习
PUAXINYEEMoe
Recently uploaded
(6)
taibif_開放資料流程-清理資料01-通則_20240509_20240509.pdf
taibif_開放資料流程-清理資料01-通則_20240509_20240509.pdf
啟思中國語文 - 中二 單元一 - 孟嘗君列傳 - 記敍的方法和人稱1.pptx
啟思中國語文 - 中二 單元一 - 孟嘗君列傳 - 記敍的方法和人稱1.pptx
1.🎉“黑客”如何修改成绩?🤔🎉 在这个信息爆炸的时代,我们经常会看到各种作弊手段。但是你知道吗?有一种作弊方式可能比你想象中更巧妙:它就是——黑客![单...
1.🎉“黑客”如何修改成绩?🤔🎉 在这个信息爆炸的时代,我们经常会看到各种作弊手段。但是你知道吗?有一种作弊方式可能比你想象中更巧妙:它就是——黑客![单...
法国蒙彼利埃国家高等建筑学院毕业证制作/德语歌德B1证书/加拿大新斯科舍省农业学院文凭加急制作一个
法国蒙彼利埃国家高等建筑学院毕业证制作/德语歌德B1证书/加拿大新斯科舍省农业学院文凭加急制作一个
taibif_資料標準概念介紹_20240509_20240509_20340509.pdf
taibif_資料標準概念介紹_20240509_20240509_20340509.pdf
10.2.1 马来西亚各州名称的由来六年级历史单元练习马来西亚各州名称的由来练习
10.2.1 马来西亚各州名称的由来六年级历史单元练习马来西亚各州名称的由来练习
Xhumaja - Dita më e zgjedhur e javës
1.
Xhumaja – Dita
më e zgjedhur e javës ﴿ اجمعة – اأسبوع أيام أفضل ﴾ ] Shqip – Albanian – أباي [ Salih El Kurdi Përktheu : Selim Sylejmani Redaktoi : Redaksia pranë shtëpisë botuese NUN 2011 - 1432
2.
﴿ اجمعة – اأسبوع أيام أفضل ﴾ « اأبانية
نغة با » كردي ا صامح ترمة : سنيماي سنيه راجعة : دار دى اتحرير هيئة " نون " نطباعة 2011 - 1432
3.
6$/,+(/.85', ;+80$-$ ',7$0É(=*-('+85(-$9É6 6+.83
4.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 7sUs IDOsQGHULPL L WDNRQ $OOOODKXW $Ws H IDOsQGHURMPs QJD $L QGLKPs GKH IDOMH NsUNRMPs(OXVLP$OODKXQTsWsQDPEURMsQJDHNHTMDGKHQJDYHSULPLLYHSUDYHMR WsPLUD$WsTs$OODKXHXGKs]RQQsUUXJsWsGUHMWsQXNNDNXVKTsPXQGWDVKSLHQs KXPEMHHNXVKVKNRQQsKXPEMHDVNXVKSsUYHo7LMQXNPXQGWDQ[MHUUsQJDKXPEMD 'sVKPRMTsQXNNDWsDGKXUXDUWMHWsUSsUYHo$OODKXW[KVKGKHVH0XKDPPHGLDV sVKWs URE GKH L 'sUJXDU L 7LM 2EOLJLP L QMHULXW sVKWs Ws KXOXPWRMs SsU QMRKMHQ H QDWUsVGKHWsJMLWKDNULMHVDYHUUHWKWLMQsNXDGsUWsDUULWMHVVsNsWUHQMRKXULYHWs ILOORMsWsPHQGRMsHGKHSsUQMRKMHQH.ULMXHVLWWs0DGKsULVKsPLFLOLQs.XU DQLQH ODUWs WKRWs$$WsKHUs GLMH VH QXN ND Ws DGKXUXDUWMHWsUSRV$OOOODKXW# .XU DQ 0XKDPPHG
5.
$OOOODKX L /DUWsVXDU
QXN H NULMRL QMHULXQ GKH QXN H YHQGRVL Qs WRNs SD NXUUQMsIDUsTsOOLPLSRUHNULMRLGKHLYXULGHWUDGKHREOLJLPHTsWDVSURYRMsDsVKWs IDOsQGHUXHVQGDM PLUsVLYHWs$OODKXW[KVKDSRPRKXHVLPLUsVLYHWs7LM 'HULVDHN]LVWHQFDMHWDGKHNULMHVDMRWHsVKWsH=RWLW[KVKLFLOLWsNULMRLGKHWs SsUVRVL DWsKHUs SDWMHWsU GXKHW WD QMRKsVK $Ws Qs GXDUW H FLOLW JMHQGHWosVKWMD GKH HN]LVWHQFDMRWH 3sUNsWsDUVH$OOOODKXLDEsULWsREOLJXHVKPHQMRKMHQH7LM $8QsQXNLNULMRYDH[KLQsWGKHQMHUs]LWSsUYHoVHWsPsDGKXURMQsWsPsQMRKLQ GKHW LNUHMQsDGKXULPHWTsXDREOLJRL
6.
# .XU DQ
7.
/H[XHVWsQGHUXDUQsNsWsOLEsUGRWsQMLKHQLQsSLNDWsVKNXUWsUDPH REOLJLPHW OLGKXU PH
IDOMHQ H QDPD]LW Ws [KXPDVs Ws FLODW $OOOODKX [KVK LD EsUL REOLJLP EHVLPWDUsYHGXNHNsUNXDUSUHMWUHTsWDDGKXURMQsGKHPDGKsURMQs$Ws
8.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 'LVSR]LWDWHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs QsED]sWs.XU¶DQLWGKHVXQQHWLW 3DVKL[KUHVQJD0HNNDQs 0HGLQH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP Q[LWRL W XD PsVRMs PXVOLPDQsYH IHQs H UH GKH WX VTDURQWH SsUSDUUHJXOOVLQs H GLVD YHSULPHYHWsWUHWsFLOsWDWD]DNRQLVKWLSUDNWLNRQLQQs[KDKLOLMHWHWsFLOsWLVKLQQs NXQGsUVKWLP PH EHVLPLQ LVODP 'XNH DVJMsVXDU YOHUsQ H YHSULPHYH Ws [KDKLOLMHWLW LVODPL PXVOLPDQsYH X RIURL ]sYHQGsVLPPHGLVSR]LWDWGKHIHVWDWLVODPH6KHPEXOO WLSLN SsU NsWs MDQs EDMUDPL L 5DPD]DQLW ILWsU %DMUDPL
9.
GKH .XUEDQEDMUDPL 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPLNLVKWHKDVXUEDQRUsWH0HGLQHVVHVLQs GGLWsWHFDNWXDUDLIHVWRQLQQJDGKQMLPHWHWUHWsKHUVKPH[KDKLOLNHGXNHLHYRNXDU DWR 0H
Ws SDUsNsWs3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YH VHOOHPGHNODURL$$OODKX NsWRGGLWsXDND]sYHQGsVXDUPHPsWsPLUs VHNsWRDWRMDQsEDMUDPLL5DPD]DQLW GKH.XUEDQEDMUDPL# (EX'DYXGL
10.
1sNsWsPsQUs$OODKX[KHOHVKDQXKXGLWsWHDUJsWLPLWWsVKIUHQXDUWsVKHMWDQLW PXVOLPDQsYH XD ]sYHQGsVRL
PH GLWsW Qs Ws FLODW DWD Ws OXPWXU SsU VKNDN Ws SsUPEXVKMHVVsSsUXOsVLVs VsWUHQGDM7LMHPDGKsURMQsHIDOsQGHURMQsGKHNsUNRMQs IDOMHSUHM7LM 3UDQGDMQDPXVOLPDQsWLNHPLWULIHVWDWsFLODWLIHVWRMPs'SUHMWUHLIHVWRMPs YHWsPQMsKHUsQsYLWQGsUVDLWUHWLSsUVsULWHWoGRMDYs.MRsVKWsGLWDH[KXPDVsGLWs WsFLOsQQDPXVOLPDQsWHIHVWRMPsoGRMDYs$OODKX[KHOHVKDQXKXPXVOLPDQsYHXD NDSsUFDNWXDUNUHUMHQHSHVsQDPD]HYHJMDWs GLWsVGKHQDWsV1sIXQGWsMDYsVQD
11.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT PXVOLPDQsW WXERKHPL Ts Ws JMLWKs Vs EDVKNX Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVs WD NXURUs]RMPs SsUXOsVLQsQGDM$OODKXW[KHOHVKDQXKXNXUHNUHMPsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsVsEDVKNX GKHNMRsVKWsDUVHWHMHWPHUsQGsVLTsNMRGLWsSsUQHWsMHWsIHVWsMDYRUH'LWsQH [KXPDVs$OODKXVXEKDQHKXZHWH DODHNDSsUVRVXUNULMLPLQHoGRJMsMHWsJMDOOs1s NDSWLQsQ.DI$OODKX L0DGKsUXDUWKRWs$1HNULMXDPTLHMWHWRNsQGKHJMLWKoNDND QGsUPMHWWUHEUHQGDJMDVKWsGLWHVKGKH1XNQGLHPORGKMH#
12.
'XNH NRPHWXDU NsWs
DMHW XOHPkMD LVODPH WKRQs VH $OODKX [KHOOH VKDQXKX NULMLPLQHNDILOOXDUWsGLHOsQGKHHNDSsUIXQGXDUWsSUHPWsQGLWsQH[KXPDVsNXUH NULMRL$GHPLQVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP1sGLWsQH[KXPDVs$GHPLsVKWsIXWXU Qs ;KHQQHW Ws SUHPWHQ sVKWs Q[MHUUXU SUHM WLM GKH Ws SUHPWHQ GR Ws VKNDWsUURKHW GQMDOOsNXGKHoDVWLLSUHPWXDUGRWsILOORMsNsWsGLWs 'LWDH[KXPDVssVKWsVSHFLILNHSsUVKNDNVHQsWsNUKHWQDPD]LL[KXPDVsGKH VH PXVOLPDQsW WXERKHQ Ts QMs KHUs Qs MDYs Ws JMLWKs Vs EDVKNX GXNH PDGKsUXDU $OODKXQ [KHOH VKDQXKX WD GsJMRMQs KWEHQ H [KXPDVs Qs Ws FLOsQ LPDPL L FHNs SUREOHPHW Ps Ws WKHNVXDUD Ws VKRTsULVs LVODPH GKH L NsVKLOORQ QMHUs]LW VH GXNH QGMHNXUVXQQHWLQH3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPWsJMHMQs]JMLGKMHSsU SUREOHPHWH WUHGKHTsUXDQD=RW WsPRVNsUNRMQs]JMLGKMHMDVKWsGLVSR]LWDYHWs $OODKXW3UDQGDMsVKWsHQGDOXDUTsGLWDH[KXPDVsWsNDORKHWQsDJMsULPVLosVKWsH QGDOXDUWsDJMsURKHWQsGLWsWHEDMUDPLWWs5DPD]DQLWRVH.XUEDQEDMUDPLWPHTsDWR MDQsIHVWDLVODPH $OODKX [KHOOH VKDQXKX PXVOLPDQsYH XD ND FDNWXDU IHVWDW SDV SsUIXQGLPLW Ws LEDGHWHYHQGDM7LM3DVDJMsULPLWQMsPXMRUYLH%DMUDPLGPWKIHVWDQsWsFLOsQQDH
13.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT IHVWRMPs SsUPEXVKMHQ H LEDGHWLW WRQs QGDM $WLM /DYGLSORWLW 3DV FHUHPRQLYH Ws PXQGLPVKPHWsKD[KLWYLHIHVWDH.XUEDQEDMUDPLWPHWsFLOLQNXURUs]RKHWLEDGHWL QsPXDMLQGKXOKL[K[KH5DVWLLQMHMWssVKWsHGKHPHGLWsQH[KXPDVsNXUQsIXQGWs oGR MDYH H IHVWRMPs ELQGMHQ WRQs QGDM $OODKXW Ws 0DGKsUXDU JMDWs MDYsV YLMXHVH 3UH]HQWLPL Qs QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs ND QJMDVKPsUL Ws PsGKD PH SUH]HQWLPLQ H KD[KLQMYH Qs KD[K 6H LG E 0XVHMHEL UDKLPHKXOODK WKRW $0s VKXPs GsVKLURM Ws SUH]HQWRM Qs QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs VH Qs NUHUMHQ YXOOQHWDUH Ws KD[KLW# *MLWKDVKWX NXVK QJXWHW PH VKNXUMHQ H WLM Qs QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs sVKWs VLNXU Ws NHWs WKHUUXU NXUEDQ SsU KLU Ws $OODKXW [KHOH VKDQXKX YDUsVLVKW QJD NRKD NXU sVKWs QLVXU Qs NUHUMHQHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs1JD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHW Ts3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$.XVKSDVWURKHWWsSUHPWHQ DVKWX VLo SDVWURKHW SDV DNWLW VHNVXDO H SDVWDM QLVHW Qs [KDPL Qs RUsQ H SDUs Ws PsQJMHVLWLOORJDULWHWVKSsUEOLPVLNXUWsNLVKWHWKHUUXUNXUEDQQMsGHYHNXVKQLVHWQs RUsQHGWsVLNXUWsNLVKWHIOLMXDUQMsORSsNXVKQLVHWQsRUsQHWUHWsVLNXUWsNLVKWH IOLMXDUQMsGDVKPHEULUsNXVKQLVHWQsRUsQHNDWsUWVLNXU WsNLVKWHIOLMXDUQMsSXOsH NXVKQLVHWQsRUsQHSHVWsLOORJDULWHWVLNXUNDIOLMXDUQMsYH]s# %XKDULX
14.
3UH]HQWLPLLUUHJXOOWQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsWsUKHTSDVYHWHIVKLUMHQHPsNDWHYH JMDWsMDYsVVsNDOXDUPHNXVKWTsWsPRVEsKHQPsNDWHWsPsGKD3HMJDPEHULVDO ODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH
VHOOHP ND WKsQs $3HVs QDPD]HW GLWRUH SUHM [KXPDVs GHUL Qs [KXPD SUHM UDPD]DQLW Qs UDPD]DQ L VKOHMQs PsNDWHW QsVH QMHULX L ODUJRKHW PsNDWHYHWsPsGKD# 0XVOLPL
15.
16.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 1s PXVQHGLQ H LPDP $KPHGLW UDKLPHKXOODK sVKWs QMs KDGLWK Qs Ws FLOLQ 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPOLGKXUPHGLWsQH[KXPDVsGHNODURQ$$MR WH$OODKXsVKWsPsHoPXHVKPHVHEDMUDPLL5DPD]DQLWGKH.XUEDQEDMUDPL# 0X PLQsWHGKHQs;KHQQHWGRW LNHQsIHVWDWHYHWD.sWRMDQsGLWsWNXUDWD GRWD YL]LWRMQs=RWLHYHW.MRsVKWsGLWDH[KXPDVs$WsKHUs$OODKX[KHOHVKDQXKXGRW L QGHURMsGKHGRW XVKIDTHWGKHDWDGRWDVKLNRMQsIWUsQH7LMILVQLNH.MRGRWsMHWs VKSsUEOLPLPsLPLUsSsUWDQs;KHQQHWGKHQXNPXQGW XQGRGKsDVJMsPsHPLUs7s VKLNXDULWHIWUsVVs7LMsVKWsSsUPHQGXUQs.XU DQVLVKSsUEOLPLPsLPLUs$$WUH TsEsMQsYHSUDWsPLUDXWDNRQHPLUD[KHQHWL
17.
HHGKHPsWHSsUHVKRKLQ$OODKXQ
18.
)WUDWHWUHQXNLPEXORQSOXKXULL]LDVQsQoPLPLDWDMDQsEDQXHVWs[KHQQHWLW DWMDQsSsUJMLWKPRQs#
19.
1JD6XKHMELUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$.XU[KHQHWOLQMWsWsKMQsQs;KHQQHW$OODKX D]]HZH[KHOH GRW XWKRW$$GsVKLURQLW XDVKWRMVKSsUEOLPLQ
20.
# $WDGRWsSsUJMLJMHQ$9DOOs QXN QD
NH QGULWXU IWUDW YDOOs QXN QD IXWH Qs ;KHQQHW YDOOs QXN QD NH UXDMWXU QJD ;KHKHQHPL# $WsKHUs$OODKXWGRWDQJULWsSHUGHQSUHM7LMGKH[KHQHWOLQMYHQXNGRW X MHSHWDVJMsPsHEXNXUVHWsVKLNXDULWH)WUsVVs7LM# 3DVWDM3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPUHFLWRL$$WDWsFLOsWEsMQsYHSUDWsPLUDLSUHWVKSsUEOLPLGKH PsVKXPsVHNMR# 0XVOLPL
21.
$WRGLWsWsFLOsWLVKLQIHVWDSsUPX PLQsWQsGQMDOOsNSRDWRGLWsGRWsMHQsIHVWD HGKHQs;KHQQHW $WDNsWRGLWDGRWsWXERKHQNXULVKIDTHW=RWLWLWUH3UDQGDMGLWDH
22.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT [KXPDVssVKWsTXDMWXUHGKHPsVKXPsVHNMR GPWKGLWsQsWsFLOsQ$LGRW XVKIDTHW EDQRUsYHWs;KHQQHWLW$UDEsWMRLVODPLNJMLWKDVKWXHTXDQLQHGKHGLWsWsDUDEL]PLW LOsVLWsHGLWsVVs[KXPDVs 1JD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$'LWDPsHPLUsQsWsFLOsQNDOLQGXU'LHOOLsVKWsGLWDH [KXPDVsDWsGLWssVKWsNULMXDU$GHPLDWsGLWssVKWsIXWXUQs;KHQQHWGKHDWsGLWsND GDOXUSUHMWLM#0XVOLPL
23.
*MLWKDVKWX QJD (EX
+XUHMUH UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRKHW HGKH VH 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND GHNODUXDU $1s GLWsQ H [KXPDVs PHOHNsWTsQGURMQsQsGHUWHoGR[KDPLHGKHLUHJMLVWURMQsQMsQJDQMsHPUDWHDWUH TsVKNRMQsQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs
24.
.XULPDPLWsQJMLWHWQsPLQEHUDWDLPEOOLQ OLEUDWGKHVKNRMQsWsPDUULQSMHVsQsWsSsUPHQGXULWH$OODKXW$LLFLOLVKNRQPs KHUsWQs[KXPDsVKWsVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUXUUQMsGHYHSDVWDMDLSDVWLM VLNXUWsNHWs WKHUUXUQMsORSsSDVWDMDLSDVWLMVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsGHOHSDVWDMDLSDVWLMVLNXU WDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsSXOsQGsUVDDLLIXQGLWVLNXUW LMHWsIDOXUQMsYH]s#
%XKDULXGKH 0XVOLPL
25.
/LGKXUPHVKNXDUMHQQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs$EDEHE5LID LUUsIHQ$'HULVDSR VKNRMD Qs
QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs Ps DUULW (EX $EEDVL GKH WKD $( ND GsJMXDU 3HMJDPEHULQVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPGXNHGHNODUXDU$.XVKLSOXKURVsNsPEsW
26.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT QsUUXJsQH$OODKXW PHQGRKHWQsVKNXDUMHQQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs
27.
$OODKX GRWD UXDMQJD]MDUULL;KHKHQHPLW# %XKDULX
28.
1JD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$1sGLWsQH[KXPDVsPHOHNsWTsQGURMQsQsGHUWHoGR [KDPLHGKHHUHJMLVWURMQsQMsSDVQMsHPUDWHDWUHTsVKNRMQsSsUWDIDOXUQDPD]LQH [KXPDVs
29.
.XULPDPLWsQJMLWHWQsPLQEHUDWDHPEOOLQOLEULQGKHVKNRMQsWsPDUULQ SMHVs Qs Ws
SsUPHQGXULW H $OODKXW $L L FLOL QJXWHW Qs [KXPD sVKWs VLNXU Ws NHWs WKHUUXUQMsGHYHSDVWDMDLSDVWLMVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsORSsSDVWDMDLSDVWLM VLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsGHOHSDVWDMDLSDVWLMVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsSXOsQGsUVDDL LIXQGLWVLNXUW LMHWsIDOXUQMsYH]s# ;KHPD WLSRV,EQL0D[KHV
30.
ÉVKWs WKsQs VH
PRPHQWL L VKNXDUMHV Vs KHUVKPH Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVs ILOORQ PHQMsKHUs SDV ]HQLWLW Ws 'LHOOLW NRKD H ILOOLPLW Ws QDPD]LW Ws GUHNsV
31.
QGsUVD SsUIXQGRQ PH TsQGULPLQ
H LPDPLW Qs PLQEHU 0RPHQWL VDKDW
32.
SsU Ws FLOLQ
NsWX PHQGRKHW QXN NXIL]RKHW YHWsP Qs VDKDWLQ Ws FLOLQ QD H QMRKLP SRUVH PH NsWs GsVKLURKHW Ws WUHJRKHW SsU QMs SHULRGs Ws FDNWXDU NRKRUH . KDGLWK QD WUHJRQ SsU YOHUsQHSDVWULPLWQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsGKHVKNXDUMHVVsKHUVKPHQs[KXPDQDPD] 1JD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQIMDOsWH3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPLFLOLNDWKsQs$1sGLWsQH[KXPDVsNDQMsVDKDWWsFLOLQQsVH PXVOLPDQsWHNDORMQsQsQDPD]GKHLOXWHQ$OODKXWSsUQHYRMDWHWUH$OODKXPHWs YsUWHWs GR W XD MDSLQ DWs# DWsKHUs 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP WUHJRLPHJLVKWULQMVHNVDKDWQGRGKHWQsQMsSHULRGsWHMHWWsVKNXUWsU# %XKDULXGKH 0XVOLPL
33.
1sWUDQVPHWLPLQQJD0XVOLPLWKXKHW$NVDKDWsVKWsYsUWHWsLVKNXUWsU#
34.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 1s NRPHQWLQ H FDNWLPLW Ws NRKsV Vs NsWLM VDKDWL Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVs QJD (EX %XUGHHNQJDEDEDLLYHWWUDQVPHWRKHWVHHNLVKWHGsJMXDU3HMJDPEHULQVDOODOO OODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP GXNH WKsQs $. VDKDW sVKWs Qs PHV Ws TsQGULPLW XOXU Ws LPDPLW SDVKWEHVVsSDUs
35.
HGHULPHSsUIXQGLPLQHQDPD]LW# 0XVOLPL
36.
,EQL 0D[KH(EX'DYXGLGKH1HVD LXNRQVLGHURMQsVHDLVDKDWsVKWsQsPHVWs QDPD]LW
Ws LTLQGLVs H GHUL PH SHUsQGLPLQ H 'LHOOLW 1s QMs WUDQVPHWLP WMHWsU QJD 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPOLGKXUPHVDKDWLQHSsUPEXVKMHVVsGXDVs WKXKHW$.sVKWsVDKDWLLIXQGLWLGLWsV SDUDSHUsQGLPLWWs'LHOOLW
37.
# ,EQL0D[KH
38.
*MLWKDVKWX WUDQVPHWRKHW VH
3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND GHNODUXDU $Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVs ND QMs oDVW GKH QsVH PXVOLPDQL EUHQGD WLM L OXWHW $OODKXWSsUQGRQMsWsPLUs$OODKXGRW LDMDSs.oDVWsVKWsSDVLTLQGLVs# $KPHGL
39.
$'LWDH[KXPDVsLNDGPEsGKMHWsVDKDWQMsVDKDWsVKWsQsWsFLOLQQsVHPXVOLPDQLL OXWHW$OODKXWPHVLJXULGRW LSORWsVRKHW.sUNRMHQLDWsVDKDWQsWsPEDUXDUWsYDNWLW WsLTLQGLVs# 1HVD
LXGKH+DNLPL
40.
1JD6HOHPHWE $EGXUUDKPDQL UDGL
$OOOODKXDQKX WUDQVPHWRKHWTsDV KDEsWH 3HMJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP LVKLQ XQDQLP Ts VDKDWL L SORWsVLPLW Ws GXDVs sVKWs SLNsULVKW DL oDVWL SDUDSsUIXQGLPLW Ws YDNWLW Ws LTLQGLVs$)HW KXO%DUL# ,EQL +D[KHU HO$VNDODQL
41.
1JD (EX 0XVDL
UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRKHW Ts 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND WKsQs $. VDKDW sVKWs Qs PHV Ws TsQGULPLWWsLPDPLWQsPLQEHUGPWKQsPHVGKXWEHYHHGHULQsSsUIXQGLPLQH QDPD]LW
42.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 3DVRMDWHUsQGDWsOsVKLPLWWs QDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs 1JD ,EQL 2PHUL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRKHW VH H NLVKWH GsJMXDU 3HMJDPEHULQ VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP GXNH GHNODUXDU QJD PLQEHUL $2VH QMHUs]LWGRWsKHTLQGRUsQJDOsVKLPLLQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsRVH$OODKXGRW LPEOOs ]HPUDWH WUHGPWK$OODKXGRWsYHQGRVsQMsSHUGHQsPHVWUHGKHXGKs]LPLWWs 7LM
43.
DQGDMGRWsEsKHQQHJOLJMHQWs WsSDNXMGHVKsPGKHLQGLIHUHQWs
44.
# 0XVOLPL
45.
2EOLJLPLLODUMHVGKHSRURVLDH SDUIXPRVMHVGKHSsUGRULPLL PLVYDNXWSsUQGHUWsQDPD]LWWs [KXPDVs 7UDQVPHWRKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$/DUMDWs SUHPWHYHsVKWsREOLJLPLoGRSHUVRQLWsPRVKsVPDGKRUHVLSDVWULPLLGKsPEsYHPH PLVYDNGKHOHUMDPHSDUIXPQsVHND# %XKDULX
46.
*MLWKDVKWXPXVOLPDQLsVKWsLREOLJXDUTsQs GLWsQH[KXPDVsWsYHVKsUUREDWPs WsPLUDSsUVKNDNWsKDGLWKLWWs3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPWsFLOLQH WUDQVPHWRQ (EX
6HLGL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX H Qs Ws FLOLQ WKXKHW $Ws SDVWUXDULW Ws
47.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT SUHPWHYHsVKWsREOLJLPLoGRPXVOLPDQLGKHDWs GLWsGXKHWYHVKXUUUREDWPsWsPLUD Ts L ND VL GKH GXKHWSDUIXPRVXU QsVH ND PXQGsVL# $KPHGLGKH6KHMKDQLGPWK %XKDULXGKH0XVOLPL
48.
7DEHUDQLHWUDQVPHWRQQJD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKX Ts 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX
DOHMKL YH VHOOHP NLVKWH WKsQs $2 MX PXVOLPDQs NMR sVKWsGLWDHIHVWsVVXDMSUDQGDMSDVWURKXQLGKHSsUGRUQLPLVYDNXQ# 7sSsUFMHOOXULWHVKSHVKWsWs VDODYDWHYH3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQsGLWsQH [KXPDVs (EX'DYXGLGKH1HVD LXWUDQVPHWRMQsVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHO OHPNDGHNODUXDU$'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsVsVKWsHSUHPWMD3sUSLTXQLTsNsWsGLWs WsPsSsUFLOOQLVDPsVKXPsVDODYDWHPXDQJDVHDWRVDODYDWHGRW PsSUH]HQWRKHQ# 7s SUDQLVKLPLW H SHWsQ $6L GR Ws SUH]HQWRKHQ NXUVH WUXSL W DWsKHUs GR Ws MHWs VKSsUEsUsGKHLVKQGsUUXDUQsSOXKXUR3HMJDPEHUL$OODKXW# $$OODKXLDNDQGDOXDU WRNsVW LGsPWRMsWUXSDWHSHMJDPEHUsYHWs$OODKXW# XSsUJMHJM3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP#
49.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 7sOH[XDULWHNDSWLQsV³HO.HKI´ QsGLWsQH[KXPDVs (EX6H LGHO+XGDULXUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWKRWTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$.XVKGLWsQH[KXPDVsHOH[RQNDSWLQsQ(O.HKIGRWDQGULoRMs GULWDQXUL
50.
PLGLVG[KXPDYH# +DNLPL
51.
2EOLJLPLLIDOMHVVsQDPD]LWWs [KXPDVs 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL
YH VHOOHP GHNODURQ $ÉVKWs GHWUs H oGR PXVOLPDQL Ts QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs WD NUHMs Qs [KHPDW SRV NDWsUYH URELW JUXDV IsPLMsVGKHWsVsPXULW# (EX'DYXGLGKH+DNLPL
52.
8OHPkMD LVODPH SDMWRKHW
Ts NUHUMD H QDPD]LW Ws [KXPDVs sVKWs IDU]LDMQ REOLJLPLSUHUsLoGRPDVKNXOOLQRUPDOWsPRVKsVPDGKRUH$OODKXL0DGKsUXDUWKRW $2MXTsEHVXDWNXUEsKHWWKLUUMDSsUQDPD]GLWsQH[KXPDVsHFQLVKSHMWSsU DWNXSsUPHQGHW$OODKX GsJMRMHQLKXWEHQIDOQLHQDPD]LQ
53.
HOLQLVKLWEOHUMHQNMR sVKWsVKXPsPsHGRELVKPHSsUMXQsVHMHQLTsHGLQL#
54.
(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND
WKsQs $1D MHPL VLSDV SUDQLPLW GKH NRKsV Vs 6KSDOOMHV
55.
Ws SDUsW QGRQsVH DWUH
X sVKWs GKsQs /LEULSDUD QHVK 3DVWDM NMR sVKWs GLWs H FLODXsVKWs
56.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT FDNWXDUVLGLWsSsUIHVWsSRUDWDXSsUoDQsGKH$OODKXQDXGKs]RLQHYHQsNsWsGKH ERWDWMHWsUQDSDVRQQsNsWs+HEUHQMWsHIHVWRMQsGLWsQHDUGKVKPHWsVKWXQGHQ
57.
QGsUVDNULVKWHUsW WsSDVQHVsUPHQ WsGLHOsQ
58.
# 0XVOLPL
59.
$.XVKLOsVKRQTsOOLPLVKWWUL [KXPD$OODKXGRW LDYXORVs]HPUsQ# 7UDQVPHWRMQsWs3HVWLW$HOKDPVH#
60.
1DPD]LL[KXPDVssVKWsIDU]LDMQWsFLOLQGXKHWWDNUHMsoGRPXVOLPDQLOLUsL PRVKsVPDGKRUHGKHQRUPDOHFLOLQXNQGRGKHWQsUUXJsGKHQXNNDDUVHWLPSsU OsVKLPLQH[KXPDVs 3UDQGDM[KXPDQsQXNMDQsWsREOLJXDUWDIDOLQIsPLMDURELXGKsWDULERU[KOLXL FLOL IULNRKHW QJD
DUUHVWLPL DV DL Ts ND QGRQMs SHQJHVs SsU VKNDNWs FLOsVL OHMRKHW PXQJHVDQJD[KHPDWL 0LUsSRWsJMLWKsMDQsWsREOLJXDUWDIDOLQQDPD]LQHGUHNsV7sIDOXULWHQDPD]LW WsGUHNsVSDV[KXPDVsQXNsVKWsREOLJLPSsUDWDTsHNDQsIDOXUQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs $OODKX[KHOHVKDQXKXQDNDSsUFDNWXDUSHVsHMRJMDVKWsQDPD]HQsGLWs .RKDHQDPD]LW Ws[KXPDVssVKWs NRKDHQDPD]LWWsGUHNsV ,PDP$KPHGL%XKDULX(EX'DYXGLGKH%HMKHNLXWUDQVPHWRMQsQJD(QHVLUDGL $OOOODKX DQKX VH 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP H IDOWH QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVsNXUGLHOOLHNDORQWH]HQLWLQ
61.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT ;KHPDWLsVKWsNXVKWLYOHUsVVsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs1XNNDNXUUIDUsDUJXPHQWL NXUsVKWsIMDODSsUQXPULQHQMHUs]YHTsMDQsWsGRPRVGRVKsPSsUYOHUsQHQDPD]LWWs [KXPDVsSsUVKNDNWsKDGLWKLWWs7DULNE6KLKDELWLFLOLWUDQVPHWRQVH3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNLVKWHWKsQs$1DPD]LQH[KXPDVsMDQsWsREOLJXDUWD NUHMQsWsJMLWKsPXVOLPDQsWQs[KHPDW# 'LVDPDGMHNDQsGHNODUXDUVHsVKWsHGUHMWs TsPHGYHWsWsIDOHWQDPD]LL[KXPDVs 1JDKDGLWKLLVLSsUVKsQXDUPXQGWsNXSWRKHWTsNXVKWHWSsUNUHUMHQH QDPD]LWWs [KXPDVsMDQsVLYLMRQ WsMHWsPDVKNXOO LOLUsWsPRVMHWsURERVHGLoHQJMDVKPH
62.
LVKsQGRVKs WsPRVQGRGKHWQsUUXJs QXNNDDUVHWLPSsUOsVKLPLQH[KXPDVsGKH
[KHPDWLsVKWsNXVKWSsUYOHUsQHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs 6DLSsUNHWNXVKWHYH WsWMHUDSRVNsWUHTsLSDUDVKWURMQsGLVDXOHPkMDQXNND NXUUIDUsED]HQsWsFLOsQPXQGWsWKLUUHQ $XWRULLYHSUsV(UUHYGDWXQQHGLMMH6LGGLN+DQLUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$;KXPDMD sVKWs QDPD] VL QDPD]HW WMHUsGKHQXNNDDVJMsTsPXQGWsGsVKPRMsVHNQDPD] sVKWsPHQDWUsWMHWsU1sNsWsPsQUsQDXSsUJMLJMHPLDWUHWsFLOsWSsUNUHUMHQH NsWLMQDPD]LVLNXVKWSDUDVKWURMQsHN]LVWLPLQHVKWHWLWLVODPGKHNDOLILWLFLOLGRWD XGKsKHTWHNsWsQDPD]
63.
SRUHGKHDWUHTsGHNODURMQsTsNQDPD]PXQGWsNUKHW
64.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT YHWsPQs[KDPLQsHPDGKHWsTWHWLWSRUMRHGKHQsIVKDWVLGKHDWUHTsVLNXVKWH WKHNVRMQsQXPULQHFDNWXDUWsIDOsVYH1XNNDNXUUIDUsDUJXPHQWHVKVHNsWRNXVKWH PXQG Ws MHQs PXVWHKDE H OH Ps Ws MHQs YD[KLE 3sUNXQGUD]L QsVH Qs QMs YHQG G QMHUs] H IDOLQ QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs GKH SRV WUH QXN DVQMs QMHUL WMHWsU DWD MDQs Ws REOLJXDUWDNUHMQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsQsWsUsVL# 8OHPkMD NRQVLGHURMQs Ts SDUD QDPD]LW Ws [KXPDVs sVKWs H REOLJXDU KWEHMD QJDVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPJMLWKsQMsPEDQWHKWEHSRUHGKH SsUVKNDNWsIMDOsYHWs$OODKXW[KHOHVKDQXKX$2EHVLPWDUsNXUWsSUHPWHYHWKLUU H]DQL Qs OXWMH OHUQL VKLWEOHUMHW GKH VKNRQL SsU WD NUHU OXWMHQ# 8OHPkMD NRQVLGHURQVHNsWXPHQGRKHWQsKWEHQPHTssVKWsHQJMDVKPHPHQDPD]LQ *MDWs [KXPDVs sVKWs REOLJLP Ws PEDKHQ G KWEH .XU LPDPL Ws QJMLWHW Qs PLQEHU SUHIHURKHW Ts W L SsUVKsQGHW Ws SUDQLVKPLW H SDVWDM Ws NWKHKHW NDK [KHPDWOLQMWs GKH GsJMRKHM H]DQL ;KDELUL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRQ VH 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPXGUHMWRKHMPHVHODPVDKHUsTsQJMLWHMQs PLQEHU,EQL0D[KH
65.
%LODOLUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXHWKLUUWHH]DQLQVDKHUsTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP
QJMLWHM Qs PLQEHU GKH EsQWH LNDPHW NXU 3HMJDPEHUL ]EULVWH QJD PLQEHUL$KPHGL
66.
.XU 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX
DOHMKL YH VHOOHP QJMLWHM Qs PLQEHU DV KDEsW L NWKHQLQIWUDWHWUHGUHMWWLM,EQL0D[KH
67.
.XVKW sVKWs Ts
KWEMD Ws MHWs H TDUWs HORNXHQWH GKH SD IMDOs Ws UsQGD ,PDP 1HYHYL UDKLPHKXOODK GHNODURQ $+WEMD GXKHW Ws MHWs H TDUWs HORNXHQWH GKH PH
68.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT UUMHGKs ORJMLNH 1XN JX[RQ Ws MHWs H NRPSOLNXDU QXN JX[RQ Ws SsUPEDMs IMDOs Ws SDNXSWXHVKPH GKH QXN GXKHW Ws MHWs H DVKSsU# +DWLEL GXKHW WD ]JMHGKs QMs WHPs DNWXDOHSsUKWEHQHWLMQsWsFLOsQGRWsIODVsPELSUREOHPHWPHWsFLOsWVRWSsUEDOOHQ PXVOLPDQsW PLUsSR SDUD Vs JMLWKDVK KWEMD GXKHW Ws MHWs NsVKLOOs H FLOD GR W XD SsUNXMWRMsDKLUHWLQGKHQMsNRKsVLVKWWHPXVOLPDQsWWs]JMRMsQGMHQMsWsXQLWHWLWGKH VROLGDULWHWLW LVODP PLGLV PXVOLPDQsYH $XWRUL L YHSUsV (UUHYGDWXQQHGLMMH 6LGGLN +DQL UDKLPHKXOODK WKRW $+WEH VLSDV 6KHULDWLW sVKWs DMR Ws FLOsQ H ND PEDMWXU 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQsWsNDSDVXUSUDODMPsULPHSsU]MDUULQ H ;KHKHQHPLW GKH Q[LWMH Ws YHSUDYH SsUDUULWMHQH EHJDWLYH Ws ;KHQQHWLW .MRHGKH sVKWsHVHQFDHKWEHVGKHSsUNsWsDMRsVKWsSsUFDNWXDU# 1JD,EQL0HV XGLUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPKWEHWHWLM]DNRQLVKWLILOORQWHPHNsWRIMDOs$)DOsQGHULPLLSsUNHW YHWsP$OODKXWPHWHQGLKPRKHPLQJD$LIDOMHNsUNRMPsGKH$WLMLPEsVKWHWHPLQJD SUDSsVLDHYHWYHWHVGKHQJDYHSUDWWRQDWsNsTLDLOLQHXGKs]RQ$OODKXDVNXVKQXN GRWDODUJRMsQJDUUXJDHFLOLQ$OODKXHOsQsGHYLMLPDVNXVKQXNPXQGWDXGKs]RMs QsUUXJsWsGUHMWs'sVKPRMVHQXNND]RWSRV$OODKXWGKHGsVKPRMVH0XKDPPHGL VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPsVKWsUREL7LMGKH3HMJDPEHUL7LMÉVKWsGsUJXDUPH WsYsUWHWsQTsQMHUs]LWW LJs]RMsSDUDGLWsVVs*MNLPLWNXVKLELQGHW$OODKXWGKH 3HMJDPEHULWWs7LMDLsVKWsQsUUXJsWsGUHMWsHNXVKEsQPsNDWQGDM$OODKXWGKH 3HMJDPEHULWWs7LMYHWYHWHVLVKNDNWRQGsPQGsUVD$OODKXL0DGKsUXDUQXNPXQGWs GsPWRKHWQsDVJMs# (EX'DYXGL
69.
70.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 3DVWDMYD]KGRKHWPHFLWLPLQHDMHWHYHYLMXHV $2MXTsEHVXDWNLQLHIULNs$OODKXQPHQMsVLQTHULWHWWsYsUWHWsGKHPRVYGLVQL SRVYHWsPGXNHTHQsPXVOLPDQs EHVLPWDUs
71.
#
72.
$ $2MXQMHUs].LQLIULNs=RWLQWXDMTsMXNDNULMXDUSUHMQMsYHWHMHQMHULX
73.
GKH QJDDMRNULMRLSDOsQVKRTsQ
74.
HVDMHSUHMDWUHGYHXVKWXDQEXUUDVKXPsHJUD 'KH NLQL IULNs
$OODKXQ Ts PH HPULQ H 7LM SsUEHWRKHQL UXDMHQL IDUHILVLQ DNUDEDOOsNXQ
75.
VH$OODKXsVKWsPELNsTUsVPELMX#
76.
$2 EHVLPWDUs SsUPEDMXQL
PsVLPHYH Ws $OODKXW GKH WKXDQL IMDOs Ws GUHMWD$ $
77.
$L$OODKX
78.
LXPXQGsVRQWsEsQLYHSUDWsPLUDMXVKOHQMXYHPsNDWHWWXDMDH NXVKUHVSHNWRQ$OODKXQGKHWsGsUJXDULQH7LMDLNDDUULWXUQMsVXNVHVWsPDGK#
79.
3UHIHURKHW Ts SDV
NsWUH DMHWHYH GKH KDGLWKsYH Qs ILOOLP Ws KWEHV Ws GUHMWRKHW HGKHVDODYDWH3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP *MLWKDVKWX0XVOLPLQsSsUPEOHGKMHQHWLMWUDQVPHWRQVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$3DVNsVDMTsXWKDIMDODPsHPLUssVKWs/LEULL$OODKXW QGsUVDXGKsL]PLPsLPLUssVKWsYHSUDH0XKDPPHGLW VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHO OHP*MsUDWPsWsGsPVKPHMDQsULVLWsQsIrQGsUVDoGRULVLsVKWsGHYLMLP# 3DVNsWLMIMDOLPLWsVKNXUWsULPDPLGRWDILOORMsWHPsQHKWEHVVsWLMQsWsFLOsQ GXKHWWsSsUPHQGDMHWHNXU DQRUHWsNXMWRMs$OODKXQ[KHOHVKDQXKXGKHGRWsEsMs GXD SsU PX PLQsW GKH PX PLQHW 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP L ND PEDMWXU G KWEH GKH ND QGHMXU XOXU QMs NRKs Ws VKNXUWsUPLGLVWUH8OHPkMD ND
80.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT JMNXU VH NMR QGHMWMH H VKNXUWsU XOXU sVKWs EDUD] PH OH[LPLQ H NDSWLQsV (O,KODV JMHUVDGLVDXOHPkWsWMHUsVXSR]RMQsVHNSXVKLPsVKWsVDQGHMWMDXOXUQsPHVUHNDWLW WsSDUsGKHWsGWsGKHPLGLVUHNDWLWWsWUHWsGKHWsNDWsUHTsTXKHW[KHOVHWXOLVWLUDKD NLVKWHYHSULPL3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPWsFLOLQHSUDNWLNRQWH VKXPsVKSHVK
81.
(EX'DYXGLUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$.XUQJMLWHM3HMJDPEHUL
82.
QsPLQEHUUULQWHXOXU GHULVDPXMH]LQLWsSsUIXQGRQWHH]DQLQSDVNsVDMQJULWHMGKHILOORQWHKWEHQPDQGHM XOHMGKHQXNIOLVWHSDVNsVDMVsULVKQJULWHMGKHIOLVWH# +DIL],EQL +D[KHULUDKLPHKXOODKQsYHSUsQHWLM)HW KXO%DULILVKHULIVDKLKLO %XKDUL
GHNODURQ $7UDQVPHWLPL L (EX 'DYXGLW OLGKXU PH osVKWMHQ H XOMHV Vs 3HMJDPEHULWPLGLVGKWEHYHGKHDMRTsQXNIOLVWHJMDWsNRKsVNXUUULQWHXOXUQXNGR WsWKRWTs3HMJDPEHULQXNHNDSsUPHQGXU$OODKXQGKHQXNLsVKWsOXWXU$WLMQsYHWH# .XVKW sVKWs Ts KWEMD Ws MHWs H TDUWs HORNXHQWH GKH SD IMDOs Ws UsQGD ,PDP 1HYHYLUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$+WEMDGXKHWWsMHWsHTDUWsHORNXHQWHGKHPHUUMHGKs ORJMLNH $MR QXN JX[RQ Ws MHWs H NRPSOLNXDU QXN JX[RQ Ws SsUPEDMs IMDOs Ws SDNXSWXHVKPH GKH QXN GXKHW Ws MHWs H YUD]KGs# +DWLEL GXKHW WD ]JMHGKs QMs WHPs DNWXDOHSsUKWEHQHWLMQsWsFLOsQGRWsIODVsOLGKXUPHSUREOHPHWPHWsFLOsWVRW EDOODIDTRKHQPXVOLPDQsWPLUsSRSDUDVsJMLWKDVKKWEMDGXKHWWsMHWsNsVKLOOsHFLOD GRW XDNXMWRMsDKLUHWLQHTsQMsNRKsVLVKWWHNPXVOLPDQsWWs]JMRMsQGMHQMsQHXQLWHWLW Ws VROLGDULWHWLW LVODP PLGLV PXVOLPDQsYH ,EQL .DMMLP HO;KH]YLMMH UDKLPHKXOODK WKRW $+WEMD H 3HMJDPHEULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND THQs VSMHJLP L SDULPHYHWsEHVLPLWQs$OODKXQPHOHNsWOLEUDWSHMJDPEHUsWGKHWDNLPLQPH7H(ND
83.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT SsUPHQGXU;KHQQHWLQGKH;KHKHQHPLQ.DIROXUOLGKXUPHDWsoNDX NDSsUJDGLWXU $OODKXGDVKDPLUsYHWs7LMVLGKHSsUDWsoNDXNDSsUJDGLWXUDUPLTsYHWs7LM.sWR KWEHWsWLMLPEXVKQLQ]HPUDWHQMHUs]YHPHLPDQGKHYHWsGLMHSsU$OODKXQ[KHOH VKDQXKX# 9HKEL =XKDMOL Qs YHSUsQ H WLM )LNKXOLVODPL YH HGLOOHWXKX WKRW $+WEMD GLWsQ H [KXPDVs GXKHW Ws SsUPEDMs PLUsQMRKMH $OODKXW VDODYDWH 3HMJDPEHULW VDO ODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPGKHQDVLKDWSsUIHQsGKHGQMDOOsNXQ# )DNLKsWHVKNROOsVMXULGLNHGHNODURMQsTsKWEMDGXKHWWsILOORMsPHIDOsQGHULPLQ QGDM$OODKXWGKHWsSsUPHQGXULWHVKHKDGHWLWGsUJLPLQHVHODYDWHYH3HMJDPEHULWVDO ODOOOODKXDOHMKL YH VHOOHP NsVKLOODNXMWLPH SsUDKLUHW GKH FLWLPH Ws.XU DQLW3DV KWEHV Vs SDUs LPDPL GXKHW Ws UULMs XOXU 1s KWEHQ H GWs GR Ws ILOORMs PH PLUsQMRKMHQ$OODKXWGsUJLPLQHVHODYDWHYHSsU3HMJDPEHULQVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYH VHOOHP GKH GXD SsU PX PLQs H PX PLQH Ts $OODKX W XD IDOs PsNDWHW GKH W L PsVKLURMsTsSUHMWUHW LHOLPLQRMsYXDMWMHWW XGKXURMsILWRUHQGDMDUPLNXWW LUXDM QJD oGR VsPXUMH GKH NUHMNMR sVKWs QJDVXQQHWLQs VKNROOsQMXULGLNH Ws KDQHILMYH 0LUsSR NsWRQXNMDQsVKDUWHWHKWEHVQJDVHYHWsLPDP(EX+DQLIHUDKLPHKXOODK WKRW VH SsU Ws THQs KWEMD H YOHIVKPH PMDIWRQ Ts LPDPL YHWsP WD UHFLWRMs 6XEKDQHOODKRVH%LVPLOODKRVH $OODKX(NEHU)DNLKsWHVKNROOsVMXULGLNHPDOLNLMH GHNODURMQsVHNRPSRQHQWHWHSsUPHQGXUDWsKWEHVQXNMDQsNXVKWSsUYOHUsQHKWEHV QJDVH YHWsP PHQGXE SUHIHURKHW
84.
)DNLKsW H VKNROOsV
MXULGLNH VKDILMH PHQGRMQs VH NRPSRQHQWHWHWKHNVXDUDWsKWEHVQMsNRKsVLVKWMDQsHGKHSMHVsWHVDMSDWsFLOsWDMR QXNsVKWsHSORWs)DNLKsWHVKNROOsVMXULGLNHKDQEHOLMHNRQVLGHURMQsVHNRPSRQHQWHW H VLSsUVKsQXDUD SDUDTHVLQ NXVKW SsU YOHUsQ H KWEHV SRV GXDVs ,EQL .XGDPH
85.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT UDKLPHKXOODKLFLOLNDTHQsLVKNROOsVKDQEHOLMHQsYHSUsQHWLMIHQRPHQDOH(O0XJQL GHNODURQ$.XULPDPLJMDWsKWEHVILOORQPHGXDDLOHMRKHWWsSUDQLVKsPYHWsIODVLQ RVHMR/LGKXUPHNsWsosVKWMHHN]LVWRMQsGPHQGLPH /HMRKHWWsELVHGRKHWJMDWsNRKsVVsGXDVsPHTsNMRsVKWsVKHQMsTsLPDPLHND SsUIXQGXDUKWEHQGKHNMRsVKWsQMsVRMVLNXULPDPL]EUHWQJDPLQEHUL %XNOHMRKHWWsELVHGRKHWQJDVHGXDMDsVKWsSMHVsHKWEHVQGsUVDJMDWsNRKsVVs KWEHVQXNOHMRKHWWsIROXULWVLoNRQVLGHURMQsIDNLKsWHVKNROOsVMXULGLNHKDQEHOLMH 8OHPkMD LVODPH sVKWs XQDQLPH VH sVKWs H QGDOXDU Ws ELVHGRKHW JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHVSDPDUUsSDUDVVKSsUPEDMWMHQHVDM*MDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVGXKHWWsKHVKWLQ HGKHDWDTsQXNMDQsQsJMHQGMHWDGsJMRMQsLPDPLQ*MLWKDVKWXNRQVLGHURMQsHGKHVH JMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVQXNGRWsXUGKsURKHWSsUPLUsGKHQXNGRWsQGDORKHWQJDH NHTMD1JD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNLVKWHWKsQs$1sVHQMHULXVKRNXWDIsULWKRW$KHVKW#GRWs JDERQWHGKHGRWDKXPEWHVKSsUEOLPLQH[KXPDVs
86.
# %XKDULX
87.
ÉVKWs H QGDOXDU
Ts JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHV QMHUs]LW Ws PHUUHQ PH oIDUsGR DNWLYLWHWHVKQJDVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPGHNODURQ$.XVKOXDQ PH JXUDOHFs H ND KXPEXU VKSsUEOLPLQ H GLWsV Vs [KXPDVs# 0XVOLPL
88.
7LUPLGKLX JMLWKDVKWX WKRW VH
N sVKWs KDGLWK L VDNWs .XU QMHULX OXDQ PH GLo JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHVDMRLDWsUKHTYsPHQGMHQGKHHODUJRQQJDSsUNXVKWLPLÉVKWsHQGDOXDUTsWs SLKHWGLoJMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVVsLPDPLWÉVKWsREOLJLPSsUWsSUDQLVKPLWTsKWEHQ WD SsUFMHOOLQ Qs KHVKWMH Ts QJD PRPHQWL NXU LPDPL WD ILOORMs KWEHQ GKH N sVKWs PHQGLPLMXULVWsYHWsVKNROOsVPDOLNLMHGKHKDQEHOLMH,PDP(EX+DQLIHNRQVLGHURQ
89.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT VH GXKHW QGsUSUHUs Ws JMLWKD ELVHGDW PHQMsKHUs SDV QJMLWMHV Vs LPDPLW Qs PLQEHU ,PDP6KDILXNRQVLGHURQVHJMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVQXNsVKWsHQGDOXDUWsELVHGRKHW PLUsSRsVKWsPsPLUsWsKHVKWHW6DLSsUNHWLPDPLWQsPLQEHUDWLMLOHMRKHWWsIODVs GKHLOHMRKHWW XDWsUKHTsYsPsQGMHQDWUHTsQXNHSsUFMHOOLQKWEHQRVHEsMQsGLoTs sVKWs Qs NXQGsUVKWLP PH VXQQHWLQ H 3HMJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ,PDPLPXQGWsGHNODURMs $+HVKWPRVIROPRVLQGDMsVDIDWPLGLVQMHUs]YH# % GKH GLo Ws QJMDVKPH 7s SUDQLVKPLW PXQG W L SsUJMLJMHQ LPDPLW QsVH L SHWs GLo JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHV QJDVH 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP 6HOLNXQ L FLOL NLVKWHKUsQD[KDPLJMDWsKWEHVVs3HMJDPEHULWHNLVKWHSHWXU$$MHIDOXU# $-R# XSsUJMHJM6HOLNX$dRKXGKHIDOX# % LNLVKWHWKsQs3HMJDPEHUL# 1JD,EQL 2PHULWUDQVPHWRKHWVHQMsQMHULNLVKWHKUsQsPHV[KLGJMHUVD2PHUL PEDQWH KWEHQ H NXU 2PHUL H YsUHMWL H SHWL $3sUVH MH YRQXDU# . LX SsUJMHJM $.DPTHQs L ]sQsQXN MDP VKNXDUDVQsVKWsSLGKHYHWsPDUULWDWsPDUUDEGHVW# $WsKHUs2PHULLWKD$9DOOsYHWsPDEGHVWLQ$QXNNHGsJMXDUVH3HMJDPEHULVDO ODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND XUGKsUXDU SDVWULPLQ H WUXSLW GLWsQ H [KXPDVs
90.
# %XKDULX GKH 0XVOLPL
91.
.RKD H SDVWULPLW
ILOORQ PHQMsKHUs SDV DJLPLW Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVs H GHUL Qs ]HQLWLQ H GLHOOLW NRKsQ H QDPD]LW Ws GUHNsV
92.
'LVD XOHPk NRQVLGHURMQsVHYRQLPLLSDVWULPLWSDNSDUDVKNXDUMHVQs[KXPDsVKWsPsLPLUs 'LVD XOHPk
LVODP NRQVLGHURMQs VH Ts JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHV sVKWs H QGDOXDU SsUVKsQGHWMD VL GKH SsUJMLJMD QGDM VDM $WD REOLJLPLQ H GsJMLPLW Ws KWEHV H NDQs SsUFDNWXDUDQDORJPHQDPD]LQQsWsFLOLQsVKWsQGDOXDUWsELVHGXDULW.sWXEsQSMHVs HGKH IDOsQGHULPL $OODKXW SDV WsVKWLPLW JMDWs KWEHV HGKH GHNODULPL $$OODKX Ws
93.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT PsVKLURIWs# *MLWKDVKWXNsWDXOHPkVKWRMQsVHJMDWsKWEHVsVKWsHOHMXDUWsELVHGRKHW YHWsPQsUDVWWsQGLKPsVQGRQMsWsYsUEsULSsUWsFLOLQEHVRKHWVHPXQGWsEMHUsQs SXVRVHSDUDODMPsULPLLGLNXMWTsLsVKWsDIUXDUDNUHSLGKHHN]LVWRQIULNDVHPXQGWD KHOPRMs H NsVKWX PH UDGKs )MDOsW H 3HMJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP $1sVHQMHULXVKRNXWWsYHWLWKRW$+HVKW#GRWsJDERMs# QXNQsQNXSWRMQsTsQMHULX NDPEHWXUSDQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsSRUVHQsQNXSWRQVHDWLMLsVKWsQGDOXUVHYDSLLGLWsV Vs[KXPDVsSsUNXQGUD]LGLVDXOHPkNRQVLGHURMQsVHPXQJHVDHVHYDSLWQsNsWsGLWs QsQNXSWRQ VH DL ND EsUs PsNDW ,EQL$EGXUUDKLPL UDKLPHKXOODK GHNODURQ $.RQFHQVXVLL[KPD D
94.
PLGLVXOHPkYHsVKWsTsKHVKWMDJMDWsKWEHVsVKWsYD[KLESsU WsSUDQLVKPLWWsFLOsWMDQsQsJMHQGMHWDGsJMRMQsIMDOLPLQHLPDPLW3sUJMLWKsVLVKW QGDOLPL L ELVHGsV
JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHV ND Ws EsMs PH Ws JMLWKs 1XN JX[RQ Ws SsUVKsQGHWHWPDGMHDVDLTsWsVKWLQ# 0HQGLPLLXOHPDVsLVODPHOLGKXU PHosVKWMHQHREOLJLPLWWs SUDQLVKsPYHJMDWsNRKsVVs KWEHV ,PDP 1HYHYLXUDKLPHKXOODKGLMHWDULVKTXDULVKNROOsVVKDILMHQsYHSUsQHWLM 0H[KPX DEOHQL,9
95.
WKRW$ÉVKWsREOLJLPWsKHVKWHWJMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVPLUsSRQD QXN H NRQVLGHURMPs
Ws QGDOXDU ELVHGsQ JMDWs NRKsV Vs VDM# . sVKWs PHQGLPL L
96.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 8UYHWLWL,EQL =XEHMULW6HLGE;KXEHMULW1HKDLXW6HYULXWGKH(EX'DYXGLW,PDP 0DOLNX(O(Y]DLLPDP(EX+DQLIHGKHLPDP$KPHGLMDQsWsPHQGLPLWVHELVHGD JMDWs KWEHV sVKWs H QGDOXDU $WD SRKLPLQ H WUH H DUJXPHQWRMQs PH IMDOsW H /DYGLORWLW $.XU OH[RKHW .XU DQL MX GsJMRQLH DWs PH YsPHQGMH
97.
GKH KHVKWQL Qs PsQUsTsWsILWRQLPsVKLUs#
98.
*MLWKDVKWXHGKHPHKDGLWKLQH0XKDPPHGLW VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQsWsFLOLQWKXKHW$1sVHQMHULXVKRNXWWsYHWVNDMWLML WKRW$+HVKW#GRWsJDERQWH GKHGRWDKXPEVKSsUEOLPLQH[KXPDVs
99.
# %XKDULXGKH 0XVOLPL
100.
1MsVRMHGKHKDGLWKLWsFLOLQHWUDQVPHWRQ(EX'HUGDUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXQs WsFLOLQWKXKHW$'LWsQH[KXPDVsNDPKUsQsPHV[KLGWs3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPGKHDLQsKWEHHILOORLNDSWLQsQ(W7HYEHGKHXQsHSHWD(EHMME .D ELQ $.XU
sVKWs VKSDOOXU NMR VXUH# 8EHMML QXN P X SsUJMLJM Qs SHWMH .XU SsUIXQGXDPQDPD]LQ HSHWDSsUVHQXNP XSsUJMLJMHDLPsWKD$7LVRWLNHKXPEXU VHYDSHW H QDPD]LW WsQG# 8Qs OLGKXU PH NsWs H SHWD 3HMJDPEHULQ VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPLFLOLPsWKD$8EEHMLWDNDWKsQsWsYsUWHWsQ# %HMKHNL
101.
0LUsSR MXULVWsW H VKNROOsV
VKDILMH H DUJXPHQWRMQs PHQGLPLQ H WUH SRDVKWX PH KDGLWKH Ws VDNWs Qs Ws FLOsW SsUPHQGHW VH SHMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP H ND QGsUSUHUs KWEHQ SsU W LX SsUJMHJMXU QMHUs]YH Qs SHWMHW H WUH 6KHPEXOO SsU NsWs sVKWsKDGLWKLWsFLOLQHWUDQVPHWRQ (QHVLUDGL$OOOODKXDQKX$*MHUVD3HMJDPEHULH PEDQWHKWEHQQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsKULQMsQMHULGKHHSHWL# 3HMJDPEHUL$OODKXW NXUGRWsSDVRMsGLWDH*MNLPLW# 1MHUs]LWILOOXDQW LEsMQsPHVKHQMsWsKHVKWsPLUSR DLLVKWHNsPEsQJXOsVGKHNsWsHSsUVsULWLWULKHUsGKHQMHUs]LWJMDWsWsUsNRKsVLEsQLQ
102.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT VKHQMsWsKHVKWs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPDWsKHUsLXSsUJMHJM$, PMHULWLo NsSsUJDGLWXUSsUGLWsQH*MNLPLW# %HMKHNL
103.
%XKDULXGKH0XVOLPLWUDQVPHWRMQsQJD(QHVL$*MHUVD3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPWsSUHPWHQPEDQWHKWEHXQJULWQMsQMHULGKHWKD$3HMJDPEHUL $OODKXWVKNXDQSRVKWNXDMWSRUVKNRLSRVKWHGKHoGRJMsWMHWsUDQGDMOXWH$OODKXQ W QDVKXDMHWMHQ# 3HMJDPEHULLVKWULXGXDUWGKHUHFLWRLQMs
OXWMH# 0LUsSRGLVDXOHPk VXSR]RMQsVHQJULWMDHGXDUYHNDWsEsMsYHWsPPHQDPD]LQLVWLVNDQDPD]LSsUVKL
104.
# 0H[KPX XVKHUKXOPHKH]]HEEOHQL,9I
105.
*MLWKDVKWXMXULVWsWHVKNROOsVVKDILMHGHNODURMQsTsREOLJLPLLKHVKMWHVNDWsEsMs YHWsPPHOH[LPLQH.XU DQLWGKHVHIMDOLPLSDQHYRMVKsPLFLOLHDVJMsVRQVHYDSLQH [KXPDVssVKWsDLIMDOLPQJDLFLOLQXNNDNXUUIDUsGRELH3UDQGDMMXULVWsWVKDILMHQXNH NRQVLGHURMQsWsGUHMWsDQDORJMLQsHFLODOLGKsQDPD]LQGKHKWEHQQJDVHHN]LVWRMQs KDGLWKHWsVDNWsTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDIROXUJMDWsNRKsVVs KWEHV ,EQL +D]PL
$QGDOXVL UDKLPHKXOODK Qs OLGKMH PH REOLJLPLQ H KHVKWMHV JMDWs KWEHV WKRW $ÉVKWs REOLJLP Ts Ws JMLWKs SUH]HQWRMQs Qs KWEH Ws PRV H VKTLSWRMQs DVQMs IMDOs JMDWs NRKsV Vs VDM SRV SsUVKsQGHWMHV PH VHODP NXU QMHULX Ws KMs Qs PHV[KLG GKH SsUJs]LPLW Ws DWLM Ts WsVKWLQ GKH IDOsQGHULPLW$OODKXW [KHOH VKDQXKX GKHGHNODULPLLVDODYDWHYHSsU3HMJDPEHULQVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQsVHNsWs HXUGKsURQLPDPLQJDPLQEHULSsUJMLJMDHLPDPLWQJDPLQEHULQsVHGLNXVKHSHW GLoNDRVHNsUNRQQGRQMsVTDULPQJDDL1sNsVDUDVWHDVNXVKQXNJX[RQWDKHVKWsDWs TsSHWPLUsSRPHLVKDUHWGRW LDEsMsPHGLMHWsPRVIODVs.XVKIOHWJMDWsNRKsVVs
106.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT KWEHVGLoWMHWsUSRVNsVDMTsHSsUPHQGsPQGsUVDHGLQVHsVKWsHQGDOXDUoGRIMDOs WMHWsUSRVNsWLMNDPEHWXUSDVHYDS
107.
[KXPD0LUsSRQsVHLPDPLKDWLEQGsUIXWsQs KWEHIMDOLPTsQXNSsUPEDMQsKDGLWKHGKHGXDWDQLPsIOHWSsUGLoWMHWsUDWsKHUs sVKWsHOHMXDUWsELVHGRKHWVLosVKWsOHMXDUWsELVHGRKHWHGKHJMDWsNRKsVVsTsQGULPLW WsWLMXOXUPLGLVGKWEHYH*MDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVWsSUDQLVKPLWQXNJX[RMQsWsVMHOOLQ QsSsUJLVKWULQMJXUDOHFs# ,EQL+D]PLQsOLGKMHPHosVKWMHQHVHODPLWGKHSsUJMLJMHVQGDMWLMGHNODURQ$$L SsUNHWHODPLW GKH SsUJMLJMHVQGDMWLMWUDQVPHWRKHWQJD(EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKX DQKXVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$1sVHGLNXVKSUHMMXVK XOHWQsPHVLQHQMHUs]YHOHW
LSsUVKsQGHWsPHVHODPHNXUWsODUJRKHWQJDQGHMDOHW L SsUVKsQGHWsVsULVKQJDVHVHODPLLSDUssVKWsQMsVRMVLHGKHLGWL# (EX'DYXGL
108.
$OODKX [KHOH VKDQXKX
WKRW $.XU SsUVKsQGHWHQL PH QGRQMs SsUVKsQGHWMH MX NWKHQL SsUVKsQGHWMH HGKH Ps Ws PLUsRVH NWKHQLHDVKWX $OODKXOORJDULW SsUoGR VHQG
109.
*MLWKDVKWXHGKHWsIDOsQGHUXDULW$OODKXWSDVWsVKWLPLWGKHSsUJs]LPLQSsU NsWs QsVH DL
Ts WsVKWLQ H IDOsQGHURQ $OODKXQ [KHOH VKDQXKX 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPGHNODURQ WDUDE
110.
$.XUGLNXVKSUHMMXVKWsVKWLQOHWDIDOsQGHURMs $OODKXQHDWDTsHGsJMRMQsOHWD SsUJs]RMQsPH#$OODKXWsPsVKLURIWs#GKHDLOHW XSsUJMLJMHW$$OODKXQDPsVKLURIWs HGKHMXYHHGKHQHYH#
(EX'DYXGL
111.
WDUDE
112.
113.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPJMLWKDVKWXWKRW$.XUGLNXVKSUHMMXVK WsVKWLQWsGHNODURMs$)DOHPQGHURM$OODKXQ#NXUVHDLTsHGsJMRQOHW LWKRW$$OODKX WsPsVKLURIWs#HNOHW LSsUJMLJMHW$$OODKXMXXGKs]RIWsGKHHSsUPLUVRIWsJMHQGMHQ WXDM# (EX'DYXGL
114.
1sVHGLNXVKQDGHNODURQVHsVKWsPsGUHMWTsJMDWsNRKsVVsKXWEHVWsKHVKWLP DWsKHUs sVKWs H
GUHMWs HGKH DMR Ts VHODPL GKH SsUJMLJMD QGDM WLM JMLWKDVKXW sVKWs YD[KLEQGsUVDHGKHIDOsQGHULPL$OODKXWSDVWsVKWLPsVGKHSsUJs]LPLsVKWsYD[KLE 'LVD NRQVLGHURMQs VH VHODPL GKH SsUJs]LPL SDV WsVKWLPsV QXN YOHQ JMDW NRKsV Vs KWEHVGPWKKWEMDGXKHWWsSsUFLOOHWSDIMDOsPHQGLPLQsOLGKXUPsNsWsosVKWMH sVKWsVLPsSRVKWs 7UDQVPHWRKHWTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPND WKsQsOLGKXUPHQDPD]LQ $*MDWsWLMQXNJX[RQWsELVHGRKHW# 'RWsWKRWsVKWsJDELP Ts KWEHQWD SsUFDNWRMPs DQDORJ PHQDPD]LQQJDVHKHVKWMDJMDWs NRKsVVsKWEHV QXNsVKWsXUGKsUXDUPH.XU DQDVPHVXQQHWGKHDVPHNRQFHQVXVWsXOHPkYH8Qs HNDPVWXGMXDUWsUsosVKWMHQGKHNDPKDVXUVHsVKWsHOHMXDUTsLPDPLW LSsUJMLJMHW SHWMHYH Ws QMHUs]YH Ws SUDQLVKsP GHULVD QGRGKHW Qs PLQEHU JMDWs KWEHV GKH NMR ELVHGsQsPHVWsLPDPLWGKH[KHPDWLWQXNsVKWsIDU]SRUPXKDELOHMXDUQsVLWXDWDWs MDVKWs]DNRQVKPHSUHMWsFLODYHGLVDGRW LSsUPHQGLPPsSRVKWs QsVHNsWsHNHPL SDUDVVK VLPXQGSUDWsQGDORKHWTsJMDWsKWEHVWsMDSLPVHODPGKHWsSsUJMLJMHPL Qs Ws VL GKH WD SsUJs]RMPs DWH Ts WsVKWLQ H Ts QMsNRKsVLVKW H NRQVLGHURMPs Ws OHMXHVKsP ELVHGsQ H FLOD QXN sVKWs H XUGKsUXDU PH .XU DQ DV VXQQHW (QHV E 0DOLNXUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXUUsIHQ $*MHUVDSHMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHO OHPPEDQWHKWEHQH[KXDPVsXQJULWQMsEHGXLQGKHWKD$3HMJDPEHUL$OODKXWQD
115.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT VKNXDQSRVKWNXDMWQDVKNRLSRVKWoGRJMsDQGDMOXWH$OODKXQW QDVKXDMHWMHQ#GKH DLLVKWULXGXDUWGKHH EsULQsMGXD# %XKDULX
116.
(EX5LID DUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWKRW $(UGKDWHSHMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPJMHUVDDLSRPEDQWHKWEHQGKHLWKDVK$3HMJDPEHUL$OODKXWHUGKDWs SHVOLGKXUPHIHQsPHTsXQsQXNHGLFLODsVKWsIHMDLPH#
$WsKHUs3HMJDPEHULVDO ODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP H QGsUSUHMWL KWEHQ GKH P X DIUXD GKH X XO Qs QMs NDUULJH Ps GXNHW VH LVKWH H PHWDOLW GKH ILOORL Ws Ps NsVKLOORMs JMsUD Ts LD NLVKWH PsVXDU$OODKXL0DGKsULVKsP3DVNsVDMYD]KGRLPHKWEHQGHULQsIXQG# 0XVOLPL
117.
+DVDQ%DVULXUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$*MDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVPXQGWsSsUVKsQGHWHW PH VHODP GKH
W L NWKHKHW SsUJMLJMH DWLM VL GKH Ws SsUJs]RKHW DL Ts WsVKWLQ GKH L IDOsQGHURQ$OODKXW# 7DEL LQLLQMRKXU$WDUDKLPHKXOODKGHNODURQ$1sVHQMHULXWsVKWLQJMDWsNRKsVVs KWEHVVsLPDPLWGKHLIDOsQGHURQ$OODKXWRVHSsUVKHQGHWHWLHGsJMRQDWsKHUsQs YHWHSsUJs]RMHGKHQsYHWHNWKHMDSsUVKsQGHWMHQHQsVHQXNHGsJMRQKWEHQDWsKHUs SsUJs]RMHGKHNWKHMDSsUVKsQGHWMHQPH]sTsGsJMRKHW# 6KNXUWLPLVKWOLGKXUPHELVHGsQ JMDWsKWEHV 1GDORKHWELVHGDNXULPDPLsVKWsQsPLQEHUQGsUVDDLTsOXDQPHJXUsRVHGLo WMHWsUHNDKXPEXUYOHUsQHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs
118.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT .XVKKQQsPHV[KLGGHULVDLPDPLPEDQKWEH QXNLOHMRKHWWsMDSsVHODP 0LUsSR QsVH GLNVXK HGKH SsUNXQGsU NsVDM MHS VHODP sVKWs OsQs ]JMLGKMD Ts W L SsUJMLJMHWPHLVKDUHWWsPRVLSsUJMLJMHWIDUHRVHW LSsUJMLJMHWPHVHODPQsYHWHHMR PH]s .XUKDWLELWDSsUPHQGsHPULQ3HMJDPEHULWWs$OODKXWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYH VHOOHPLOHMRKHWGsJMXHVLWTsQsYHWHWsEsMsVHODYDWHQGDMWLM .XU WsVKWLQ JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHV IDOsVLW L OHMRKHW Ts Qs YHWH WD IDOHQGHURMs $OODKXQ[KHOHVKDQXKX .XUKDWLELWsSsUPHQGsDMHWHWsFLOsWEsMQsIMDOsPEL;KHKHQHPLQGsJMXHVLWL OHMRKHWTsWsNsUNRMs PEURMWMHQJD]MDUULHSRNMRUUHJXOOYOHQHGKHSsULVWLJIDULQ 1sVHKDWLELEsQGXDJMDWsKWEHVVsSDUsRVHWsGWsGsJMXHVLWLOHMRKHWTsQs YHWH Ws GHNODURMs $$PLQ# 1sVH KDWLEL ILOORQ Ws VKTLSWRMs GXD SDV KWEHV Vs GWs GsJMXHVLWLOHMRKHWWsGHNODURMs$$PLQ#QJDVHKDWLELHNDSsUIXQGXDUKWEHQ ÉVKWs H OHMXDUELVHGD JMsWs NRKsV Vs KWEHVQsUDWVWsVKSsWLPLWWsQMHULXWWs YHUEsU WsUKHTMHV Vs YsUHWMHV SsU JMDUSsU DNUHS ]MDUU RVH GLo WMHWsU Qs PHV[KLG Qs PsQUsTsWsHOLPLQRKHWGsPL#
119.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 9OHUD HYHSULPLWWsDWUHTsH SsUFMHOOLQKWEHQQsKHVKWMH 1JD (EX +XUHMUH UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WKRW $.XVK Ws SUHPWHQ SDVWURKHW GKH VKNRQQsQDPD]Ws[KXPDVsSDVWDMIDOsDWsTsLsVKWsSsUFDNWXDUSDVWDMQsKHVKWMHH SsUFMHOOKWEHQHLPDPLWGKHSDVNsVDMIDOHWPHWHLMDQIODNXUPsNDWHWQsPHVDVDM GKH[KXPDVsVsDUGKVKPHVLGKHWULGLWsSDVNsVDM# 0XVOLPL
120.
,PDP 6KDILXUDKLPHKXOODKQs0XVQHGLQ HWLMQJD6D
OHEHWEHEL0DOLNXUDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRQ Ws NHWs WKsQs $1MHUs]LW ELVHGRQLQ Qs PHV WUH JMHUVD 2PHULLVKWHQsPLQEHU.XUPXMH]LQLHSsUIXQGRQWHH]DQLQ2PHULQJULWHMQsNsPEs GKH Ws JMLWKs H QGsUSUHQLQ ELVHGsQ GKH QXN ELVHGRQLQ IDUH SsUGHULVD QXN H SsUIXQGRQWHKWEHQHGWs3DVLNDPHWLWGKH]EULWMHVVs2PHULWQJDPLQEHULDV KDEsW ILOORQLQWsELVHGRQLQ# ,PDP6KDILXJMLWKDVKWXQsYHSUsQHWLM(O8PPWUDQVPHWRQQJD6D OHEHWL$.XU LPDPLQJMLWHMQsPLQEHUWsSUDQLVKPLWGRWDQGsUSUHVLQWsSsUPHQGXULWH$OODKXWGKH IMDOLPLLLPDPLWQGsUSUHQoGRELVHGsPLGLVQMHUs]YHdGRELVHGsSDVKWEHVsVKWsH OHMXDU#
121.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT ,PDPLQXNGXKHWW¶LQJULWsGXDUW SsUGXDNXUsVKWsQsPLQEHU 3DUDQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsLPDPLQsPLQEHUJMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHVQXNGXKHWW L QJULWs GXDUW VLo EsQ Qs GXD QJDVH N YHSULP sVKWs Qs NXQGsUVKWLP PH VXQQHWLQ H 3MHJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP+XVHMQLUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQ VHVL8PDUHE5XHMEHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXHNLVKWHSDUs%LVKUDE0HUYDQLQVHVLQs PLQEHUGXNHEsUsGXDLQJULWsGXDUW.YHSULPLWLM5XMHEHHNDDNX]XDUUUHSWsPH IMDOsW$$OODKXL ]KGXNWsNsWRGGXDUPHWsYsUWHWsHNDPSDUs3HMJDPEHULQVDOODOO OODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP VH VL Qs PLQEHU
122.
PH GRUs Ws
GMDWKWs NLVKWH EsUs NsVKWX $WsKHUs5XHMEHILOORLWDOsYL]sJLVKWLQWUHJXHVWsGRUsVVsWLMWsGMDWKWs# 0XVOLPL
123.
2EOLJLPLLIDOMHVVsWHKLMMHWXO PHV[KLGLWHGKHSsUNXQGsUIDNWLW TsLPDPLQGRGKHWQsPLQEHU *MDWNRKsVVsKWEHVJMHUVDLPDPLQGRGKHWQsPLQEHUIDOsVLWWsFLOsWWHNDWsKHUs KMQs Qs PHV[KLG
MDQs Ws REOLJXDU W L IDOLQ G UHNDWH SDUD Vs Ws XOHQ ;KDELU E $GXOODKXUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQ$'HULVD3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPHPEDQWHKXWEHQH[KXPDVsHUGKLQMsQMHULGKHDLLWKD$2ILODQHMH
124.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT IDOXU# $-R# XSsUJMHJMN$dRKXGKHIDOX# % LWKD3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHP# %XKDULXGKH0XVOLPL
125.
*DELPHWTsLEsMQsPXVOLPDQsW GLWsQH[KXPDVsGKHWsFLOsW VKNDNWRMQsKXPEMHQHVHYDSLWWs NsVDMGLWHPXEDUHN 1JD (EX
+XUHMUH UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRKHW Ts 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs#1sGLWsQH[KXPDVsPHOHNsWTsQGURMQsQsGHUWH oGR[KDPLHGKHLVKsQRMQsQMsSDVQMsHPUDWHDWUHTsVKNRMQsSsUWDIDOXUQDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs
126.
.XU LPDPL Ws
QJMLWHW Qs PLQEHU DWD L PEOOLQ OLEUDW GKH VKNRMQs Ws SUH]HQWRMQsQsWsSsUPHQGXULWH$OODKXW$LTsVKNRQKHUsWQs[KXPDVLNXUWDNHWs WKHUUXUNXUEDQQMsGHYHSDVWDMDLTsSDVWLMVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsORSsSDVWDMDL SDVWLMVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsGHOHSDVWDMDLSDVWLMVLNXUWDNHWsWKHUUXUQMsSXOs QGsUVDDLLIXQGLWVLNXUW MHWsGKXUXDUQMsYH]s# %XKDULXGKH0XVOLPL
127.
1JD (YV E
(YVL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRKHW Ws NHWs WKsQs $( NDP GsJMXDU3HMJDPEHULQH$OODKXWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPGXNHWKsQs$.XVKWs SUHPWHQSDVWURKHWGKHUUHJXOORKHWVDPsPLUsTssVKWsHPXQGXUGKHVKSHMWRQVDPs KHUsWTssVKWsHPXQGXUGKHVKNRQQsNsPEsGKHMRNDOXDUSDVWDMLDIURKHWLPDPLW GKHHSsUFMHOOKWEHQ
128.
GXNHGsJMXDUSDNXUUIDUsDNWLYLWHWLWsSDOHMXDUPHWUXSGKH
129.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT PHJRMs
130.
GRWsNHWsVKSsUEOLPVLNXUWsMHWsIDOXUGKHDJMsUXDUWsUsYLWLQ$KPHGLGKH (EX'DYXGL
131.
6HOPDQ)DULVLXUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXUUsIHQVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPNDGHNODUXDU$.XVKWsSUHPWHQODKHWSDVWURKHWVDPsPLUsTssVKWsH PXQGXUOKHWIORNsW
132.
PHYDMRVHSDUIXPRVHWPHDURPsWsVKWsSLVsSDVWDMVKNRQGKH QXNQGDQsGYHWsQsVDII
133.
SDVWDMIDOsDWsTsLsVKWsSsUFDNWXDUSDVWDMKHVKWsGHULVD LPDPLHPEDQKWEHQLIDOHWDMRTsHNDEsUsPLGLVNsVDMGKH[KXPDVsVsNDOXDU# %XKDULX
134.
1JD(EX+XUHMUMHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$1sVHQMHULXVKRNXWDIsUWLMLWKRW$+HVKW#GRWs JDERQWH GRWDKXPEWHVKSsUEOLPLQH[KXPDVs
135.
# %XKDULXGKH0XVOLPL
136.
1JDKDGLWKsWHVLSsUVKsQXDUPXQGWsNRQNOXGRKHWTsVHYDSLLQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs sVKWsVKXPsLPDGK.XVKHSUDNWLNRQDWsTsHNDSUDNWLNXDU3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsNDNsWRVHYDSH 1Ms% PsoGRKDSGHULQsPHV[KLGPX PLQLNDVKSsUEOLPVLNXUWsMHWsIDOXUGKH DJMsUXDUWsUsYLWLQ '%
.XVKVKNRQPsKHUsWQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsNDVKSsUEOLPVLNXU$OODKXWW L NHWsWKHUUXU.XUEDQPDGKsVLDHFLOLWYDUHWQJDVKSHMWLPLLWLMQsPHV[KLG 7UH% 0sNDWHWIVKLKHQGKHIDOHQQJD[KXPDMDGHULQs[KXPD .DWsU% 0HOHNsWXDVKsQRMQsIDOsVYHVHYDSHWSsUVKNDNWsNUHUMHVVsQDPD]LWWs [KXPDVs
137.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT )DWNHTsVLVKWVRWNDSDNPXVOLPDQsWsFLOsWLNXVKWRMQsYsPHQGMHNsWUHosVKWMHYH WHMHWWsUsQGsVLVKPHQsGLWsQH[KXPDVs1JDQMsKHUsNMREsKHWQJDSDGLWXULDPLUsSR JOREDOLVKW NMR EsKHW QJDSsUWDFLD GKH QHJOLJMHQFD GKH ODUJsVLD H WUHQJDVXQQHWL L 3HMJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP /DUJLPL L WUH QJD VXQQHWL Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVsPXQGWsSsUNXIL]RKHWQsSLNDWYLMXHVH 0RVSsUILOOMDHVKNXDUMHVVsKHUVKPHQs[KXPD 0RVSsUILOOMDHODUMHVVsREOLJXHVKPHSDUIXPRVMHVGKHSsUGRULPLWWsPLVYDNXW QsGLWsQH[KXPDVs %LVHGLPLUHFLSURNPLGLVQMHUs]YHJMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHV 7sNWKHULWHVKSLQsVGKHNUDKXWQJDLPDPLJMHUVDNQGRGKHWQsPLQEHUQGsUVD KWEMDsVKWsGXNHX]KYLOOXDU 7sOXDMWXULWHSDQHYRMVKsPPHWHSLKGKHNsUFLWMHWsJLVKWULQMYH 1GsUKUMDQsVDIIHGKHVKTHWsVLPLLIDOsVYHWsUHQGXDUQsVDIIH *DELPHWHLPDPLWQsPLQEHUSDUD JMDWsGKHSDVKWEHV =JMDWMDHKWEHVGKHWsVKNXUWXDULWHQDPD]LWVXQQHWsVKWsSLNsULVKWHNXQGsUWD
138.
'XDMDHLPDPLWPHQMsKHUsSDVQJMLWMHVVsWLMQsPLQEHUPHGXDUNDKNLEODGKHWs NWKHULWHVKSLQsVIDOsVYHWsFLOsWQXNLSsUVKsQGHWsPHVHODPTssVKWsQJDVXQQHWL
139.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT ,EQL7HMPLMMHUDKLPHKXOODKGHNODURQ$'XDMDHLPDPLWSDVQJMLWMHVQsPLQEHUQXNND NXUUIDUsED]HQsVXQQHW# $(W,KWLMDUDWXOLOPLMMH#
140.
3sUVKsQGHWMDPHVHODPHWsSUDQLVKsPYHSDVQJMLWMHVQsPLQEHU 0RVSsUILOOMDGKHOsQMDDQDVKHKWEHVVs3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHO OHPPsWsFLOsQDL]DNRQLVKWHILOORQWHKWEHQGKHHFLODILOORQPH$,QQHOKDPGH OLOODKLQDKPHGXKXYHQHVWH LQXKXYHQDVWDJILUXKX
NsWsKWEHQsSsUNWKLPHNHPL VKsQXDUPsVLSsU
141.
3sUIXQGLPLLVKSHMWsLKWEHVVsGWs .XIL]LPLLKWEHVVsGWsYHWsPQsOH[LPWsWKMHVKWsWsWHNVWLWDUDESDNXUUIDUs NsVKLOODVKGKHLQNXUDMLPHVKSsUGHYRFLRQGKHSUDNWLNLPWsGLVSR]LWDYHLVODPH SsUIXQGLPLQHSsUKHUVKsPWsKWEHVHIMDOsWH/DYGLSORWLW$,QQHOODKXMH
PXUX ELO! !DGOLYHOLKVDQL# 1JMLWMDHQJDGDVKPHHLPDPLWQsPLQEHUGKH]EULWMDQJDPLQEHULQGsUVDGLVD SUHMLPDPsYHQsoGRVKNDOOsOH[RMQsGXDWsSRVDoPHWsFLODWQXNWUDQVPHWRKHQQJD 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPGKHWsNWKHULWHLPDPLWNDKNLEOMDPH GXDUWsQJULWXUDSDUDKLSMHVQsPLQEHU 1JULWMDHGXDUYHWsLPDPLWJMDWsGXDVs,EQL7HMPLMMHUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$ÉVKWs H QGDOXDU Ts LPDPL W L QJULWs GXDUW JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHVJMHUVD sVKWs Qs PLQEHU QJDVH 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP JMDWs GXDVs H ND OsYL]XU YHWsP JLVKWLQWUHJXHVWsGRUsVVsGMDWKWs#
142.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 1JULWMDHGXDUYHWsIDOsVYHJMDWsGXDVsVsLPDPLW,EQL$ELGLQLUDKLPHKXOODK MXULVW L VKNROOsV KDQHILMH WKRW $1sVH H EsMQs NsWs DWsKHUs NDQs JDEXDU# $+DVKLMHWX,EQL$ELGLQ#OLEUL,I
143.
1JULWMD H GXDUYH
Qs GXD JMDWs NRKsV Vs TsQGULPLW XOXU Ws LPDPLW PLGLV G KWEHYH5HVKLG5LGDUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$1JULWMDHGXDUYHQsGXDJMDWsNRKsVVs TsQGULPLW Ws LPDPLW XOXU PLGLV G KWEHYH QXN ND NXUUIDUs ED]H Qs VXQQHWLQ H 3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP'XKHWWsKHVKWHWJMDWsWsUsKWEHVSUD HGKHJMDWsTsQGULPLWWsLPDPLWXOXUPLGLVGKWEHYH
144.
7sSUDQLVKPLWGXKHWWsEsMQs GXDQsYHWHGKHWsPRVLSHQJRMQsWsWMHUsWJMDWsNRKsVVsTsQGULPLWWsLPDPLWXOXU PLGLVGKWEHYH
145.
GKHQXNGXKHWW LQJULWLQGXDUW.XVKYHSURQQGUVKHQXNYHSURQ VLSDV VXQQHWLW
Ws 3HMJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYH VHOOHP3sUNXQGUD]L DWDPH YHSULPLQHWUHHNXQGsUVKWRMQsVXQQHWLQQJDVHLPDPLQGRVKWDWDQLPssVKWsQJULWXU SsUKWEHQHGWsQGsUVDDWDHQGHEsMQsGXDPHGXDUWsQJULWXUD0sPLUssVKWsTs JMDWsKWEHVWsGsJMRMQsGKHPHQGRMQsSsUSsUPEDMWMHQHVDM.YHSULPLJDEXDUL PXVOLPDQsYHsVKWsULVLH]DNRQVKPH# $)HWDYD# 0XKDPPHG5HVKLG5LGDOLEUL,I
146.
)DOMDHQDPD]LWWsGUHNsVSDVLTssVKWsIDOXUQDPD]LL[KXPDVsQGsUVDPsH GUHMWssVKWsTsQDPD]LLGUHNsVWs PRVIDOHWSDVNUHUMHVVsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs
147.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 6XQQHWHWHKWEHV 1JDVXQQHWHWH3HMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPsVKWsTsKWEMDWs PEDKHWQsPLQEHUQsPsQUsTsQMHUs]LWWsPXQGWDVKLNRMQs%XKDULXGKH0XVOLPLH WUDQVPHWRMQsQMsKDGLWKQs WsFLOLQWKXKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHO OHP NLVKWH PEDMWXU KWEH Qs PLQEHU 1JD 6DLE E -H]LGL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRKHWWsNHWsWKsQs$QsNRKsQHSHMJDPEHULWVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP (EX%HNULWGKH2PHULWH]DQLSDVRQWHPsQMsKHUsSDVQJMLWMHVVsLPDPLWQsPLQEHU# %XKDULX
148.
.XULPDPLWsQJMLWHWQsPLQEHUGXKHWW LSsUVKHQGHVsWsUSDQLVKPLWPHVHODP QJDVHNsVKWXNDYHSUXDU5HVXOXOODKXVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP,PDPLGXKHWW L SsUVKHQGHVsWsSUDQLVKPLWG
KHUs *MDWsKUMHVQsPHV[KLG 'KHNXUWsQJMLWHWQsPLQEHU 0LQEHULGXKHWW LNHWsYHWsPWULVKNDOOsGKHLPDPLJMDWsKWEHVGRWsTsQGURMs QsVKNDOOsQHGWsQsPsQUsTsSDVKWEHVVsSDUsWsPXQGWsXOHWGKHWsSXVKRMsQs VKNDOOsQHWUHWs ,PDPLGXKHWWsQJMLWHWQsPLQEHUSDUDH]DQLWGKHYHWsPDWsKHUsPXMH]LQLPXQG WDWKLUUsH]DQLQ1DPD]LL[KXPDVsHNDYHWsPQMsH]DQ +WEMDGXKHWWsMHWsHVKNXUWsUHTDUWsGKHHORNXHQWH 7sSUDQLVKPLWGXKHWWsGUHMWRKHQNDKLPDPLGKHGXKHWW LNXVKWRMQsYsPHQGMH KWEHVHQsVHNsWsQXNHEsMQsNDQsPEHWXUSDVHYDSLQH[KXPDVs'KHNXVKOXDQ
149.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT PHJXUDOHFsJMsTsHNHPLWKHNVXDUQsKDGLWKLQVDKLK
150.
GKHDQDORJPHNsWsKDGLWK NXVKOXDQPHWHSLKRVHGLoWsJQMDVKPHPHNsWsHNDKXPEXUVHYDSLQH[KXPDVs 4RUWLPLLJsUVKHWLPLWWs JLVKWULQMYHJMDWsVKNXDUMHVQs PHV[KLG 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPHNDQGDOXDUJsUVKHWLPLQHJLVKWULQMYH JMDWsVKNXDUMHVQsPHV[KLGVLGKHJMDWsTsQGULPLWQsPHV[KLG(EX6HLGLUDGL$OO OODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$.XU QGRQMsUL SUHM MXVK
QGRGKHW Qs PHV[KLG PRV W L QJDWsUURMs JLVKWULQMWs QJDVH Ws QJDWsUUXDULWHJLVKWULQMYHsVKWsQJDVKHMWDQL-XMHQLQsQDPD]SsUGHULVDQGRGKHQLQs PHV[KLGGKHGHULVDWDEUDNWLVQLPHV[KLGLQ# $KPHGL
151.
6DLSsUNHWQGDOLPLWWsQJDWsUULPLWWsJLVKWULQMYHJMDWsVKNXDUMHVQsPHV[KLGNMR PXQGWsVKLKHWHGKHQJDKDGLWKLL.D EE8[KUHWLWLFLOLWKRWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKX DOHMKL
YH VHOOHP ND WKsQs $.XU GLNXVK SUHM MXVK Ws PDUUs DEGHVW OH WD ]EXNXURMs DEGHVWLQ H YHW H QsVH SDVWDM VKNRQ Qs PHV[KLG OH Ws PRV L QJDWsUURMs JLVKWULQMWsQJDVHWDQLPsJMHQGHWQsQDPD]# (EX'DYXGL
152.
1JDNsWDKDGLWKHPXQGWsSsUIXQGRKHWVHQJDWsUULPLLJLVKWULQMYHsVKWsLQGDOXDU SRUMRQsQLYHOWsKDUDPLWJMDWsVKNXUMHVQsPHV[KLGQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsGKHGLWsW WMHUDSsUGHULVDQMHULXJMHQGHWQsSULWMHWsQDPD]LW
153.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 'XNH NRPHQWXDU NsWD KDGLWKH (O+DWWDEL UDKLPHKXOODK WKRW $'LVD QMHUs] L JsUVKHWRMQsJLVKWULQMWsYHWsPSsUGMHUUDNRKsGKHDUJsWLP.DWsWLOOsTsJMDWsQGHMsV LJsUVKHWRMQsJLVKWULQMWsHGGXDUYHLNDSLQJMXQMWsHTsQ[LWsGUHPLWMHWHNDWD.MR JMHGQMHQsWsVKXPWsQHUDVWHYHXDSULVKsDEGHVWLQ# 1sVH GLNXVK QJD Ws SUDQLVKPLW NRWHW JMDWs NRKsV Vs KWEHV SD QJDWsUULPLQ H JLVKWULQMYHGKHNDSMHQHJMXQMYHDWsKHUsGXKHWWsNWKHKHWQsDQsQHNXQGsUWQJDDMR TsJMHQGHWPHNXVKWTsWsPRVLSHQJRMsWsWMHUsWJMDWsOsYL]MHVVsYHW,EQL2PHUL UDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPNLVKWH WKsQs$1sVHGLNXVKSUHMMXVKQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsNRWHWQsYHQGLQQsWsFLOLQQGRGKHW QsPHV[KLG
154.
OHWsGUHMWRKHWQsDQsQWMHWsU# +DNLPL
155.
LOsVLWsHGLWsVVs[KXPDVs 'LWDH[KXPDVsOORJDULWHWVLGLWDPsHPLUsHMDYsV 8OHPkMD QXN sVKWs
XQDQLPH OLGKXUPH DWs VH D sVKWs DMR Ps H PLUsVH GLWD H $UHIDWLW 'LWDH[KXPDVssVKWs%DMUDPQLMDYRU 'LWsQ H [KXPDVs GKH Qs QHWsW H VDM sVKWs PLUs Ws EsKHQ VDODYDWH SsU 3HMJDPEHULQ H $OODKXW QJDVH QJD UHVXOXOODKX VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP WUDQVPHWRKHWWsNHWsWKsQs$%sQLVKXPsVDODYDWHSsUPXDQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsGKHQs QHWsWH[KXPDVs# (OEHMKHNL
156.
157.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 8UGKsULLSDVWULPLWDWsGLWssVKWsYD[KLEGHULQsDWsVKNDOOsVDsVKWsPsLIRUWs VHXUGKsULSsUILWsUQDPD] ÉVKWs PLUs Ts Qs GLWsQ H [KXPDVs Ws SsUGRUHW PLVYDNX GKH Ws SDUIXPRVHW QGsUVDSsUGRULPLLPLVYDNXWsVKWsPsLGRELVKsPVHSsUGRULPLLWLMGLWsYHWsWMHUDVL GKHSDUIXPRVMD 3DUDSsOTHKHWTsDWsGLWsWsNUKHQVDPsVKXPsQDPD]HWsEsKHWGKLNsUGKHWs OH[RKHW.XU DQGHULPHQJMLWMHQHLPDPLWQsPLQEHU0HGDOMHQHLPDPLWQGDORKHW NUHUMDHQDPD]LWQGsUVDPHILOOLPLQHKWEHVQGDORKHWoGRELVHGs ÉVKWsREOLJLPTsWsKHVKWHWQsNRKsQHKWEHVHNXVKELVHGRQJMDWsNRKsVVs KWEHVDLWDOOHWPHQDPD]GKHHKXPEYOHUsQHQDPD]LWWs[KXDPVs 3UHIHURKHW OH[LPL L VXUHV(O.HKI Qs GLWsQH [KXPDVsQGsUNDTWUDQVPHWRKHW QJD5HVXOXOODKXVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPWsNHWsWKsQs$.XVKHOH[RQVXUHQ (O.HKIGLWsQH[KXPDVsHPEXORQGULWDSUHMNsPEsYHHGHULQsNXSsQTLHOORUHHFLOD GRWDQGULoRMsQsGLWsQH *MNLPLWQGsUVDLIDOHQWsJMLWKsPsNDWHWHYRJOD
158.
PLGLVG [KXPDYH# (O+DNLPL
159.
1sGLWsQH[KXPDVsSUHIHURKHWWsYHVKHQUUREDWPsWsPLUD7UDQVPHWRKHWQJD (EL(MMXELUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWsNHWsWKsQs$(NDPGsJMXDU5HVXOXOODKXQVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPWsNHWsWKsQs$.XVKSDVWURKHWQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsSDUIXPRVHW QsVH ND SDUIXP
YHVKs UUREDW Ps Ws PLUD GKH GHO PH THWsVL GHULVD Ws DUULMs WH PHV[KLGL H SDVWDM IDOHW QsVH GR SD H EUHQJRVXU DVQMsULQ H SDVWDM NXU LPDPL Ws QJMLWHWQsPLQEHU GRWsKHVKWsGHULVDWsPRVILOORMsQDPD]LGRW LIDOHQPsNDWHWPLGLV G[KXPDYH# $KPHGL
160.
161.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 3UHIHURKHWTsQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsWsSDUIXPRVHWPHV[KLGLNXUVHNDOLILLGWs 2PHUL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX NXU YLQWH JMVPD H GLWsV XUGKsURQWH Ws SDUIXPRVHW PHV[KLGLQs0HGLQH $WLMTssVKWsLREOLJXHVKsPWDIDOsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsQXNLOHMRKHWWsPDUUs UUXJsQsNRKsQHILOOLPLWWsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsSRUVHsVKWsLREOLJXHVKsPWsVKNRMs QsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsHSDVWDMWsPDUUsUUXJs $LTsQLVHWQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsSsUoGRKDSNDVKSsUEOLPVDQMsYLWDJMsULP GKHQDPD]QGsUVDWUDQVPHWRKHWQJD5HVXOXOODKXVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPWs NHWsWKsQs$.XVKSDVWURKHWQsGLWsQH[KXPDVsGKHVKNRQPsKHUsWQsPHV[KLGL DIURKHWLPDPLWGKHKHVKWsSsUoGRKDSWsEsUsNDVKSsUEOLPQMsYMHWDJMsULPGKH QDPD]HNMRsVKWsJMsHOHKWsSsU$OODKXQ# $KPHGL,EQL+X]HMPH(W7LUPLGKLGKH (EX'DYXGL
162.
1s GLWsQ H
[KXPDVs IDOHQ PsNDWHW QGsUVD Qs Ws sVKWs QMs VDKDW Qs Ws FLOLQ SUDQRKHQGXDWsGKHNXUURELQsWsLOXWHW=RWLWWsYHW$OODKXLDSUDQRQGXDQs/LGKXU PHVDKDWLQQsGLWsQH[KXPDVssVKWsWKsQsVHQsWsNDSHVsPRPHQWHWsGRELVKPHWs FLOsW PX PLQL GXKHW W L VKIUWs]RMs PRPHQWL L SDUs sVKWs ]HQLWL L 'LHOOLW QGsUVD L IXQGLWsVKWsWsXOXULWHLPDPLWQsPLQEHU
163.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 3UHIHULPLLIDOMHVVsQDILOHVSDUD H]DQLWWs[KXPDQDPD]LWGKH PRVHN]LVWLPLLIDOMHVVsVXQQHWLW Ws[KXPDVsSDVH]DQLWSsU QDPD]LQH[KXPDVs ,PDP6KHYNDQLUDKLPHKXOODKNRQVLGHURQVHPXQGWsIDOHWQDILOHSDUDQDPD]LWWs [KXPDVsSDUDH]DQLWSsUQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs
164.
.PHQGLPHNRQILUPRQHGKHIHWYDW HLPDPLW(EX+DQLIHGKH6KDILXWWsFLOLJMLWKDVKWXNRQVLGHURMQsVHsVKWsHOHMXHVKPH WsNUKHWQDILOHSDUDH]DQLWSsUQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPWKRW$.XVKWsSUHPWHYHODKHW SDVWURKHWVDPsPLUsTssVKWsHPXQGXU OKHWIORNsW
165.
PHYDMRVHSDUIXPRVHWPHSDUIXPLQHVKWsSLVsHSDVWDMQLVHWGKHQXNL QGsUIXWHWPLGLVGYHWsYHQsVDII
166.
SDVWDMIDOsDWsTsLsVKWsFDNWXDUDQGDMKHVKWs GKH GsJMRQ JMHUVD
LPDPL H PED KWEHQ L IDOHW DMR Ts ND EsUs PLGLV NsVDM GKH [KXDPVs Vs NDOXDU# 0XVOLPL
167.
0H NsWs KDGLWK
DUJXPHQWRKHW VH sVKWs H OHMXDU Ws NUKHW QDILOH SDUD H]DQLW SsU [KXPDQDPD] ,PDP 6DQ DQL UDKLPHKXOODK DXWRUL L YHSUsV$6XEXOXVVHODP#WKRW$+DGLWKLLFLOLEsQIMDOsSsU[KXPDQsXGKs]RQVHGXKHW Ws IDOHW QDILOH QsVH QMHULX sVKWs Qs JMHQGMH WD NUHM GKH QXN ND NXUUIDUs NXILUL Ws FDNWXDUVDLSsUNHWNsVDMQDILOHÉVKWsPHUsQGsVLWsILWRKHWVHYDSLL[KXPDVsPDGMH HGKHPHGUHNDWHWsWHKLMMHWXOPHV[KLGLW# ,PDP,EQL.DMMLPHO;KHY]LQsYHSUsQHWLM$=DGXO0L DG# WKRW$1DPD]LSsUWs FLOLQEsKHWIMDOsQsNsWsKDGLWKHWsFLOLQHWUDQVPHWRQ0XVOLPLQsWsFLOLQWKXKHW
168.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT $SDVWDMIDOHWDMRTsLsVKWsFDNWXDU#sVKWsQDPD]QDILOHLFLOLSUHIHURKHWWsNUKHW HQsYHoDQWLSsUDWDWsFLOsWVKNRMQsPsKHUsWQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsHGKHDWsSDUD NRKsVVsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsGKH'LHOOLHQGHQXNsVKWsQs]HQLWNXUILOORQNRKDH QDPD]LW Ws [KXPDVs
169.
# . sVKWs
VKHPEXOOL oXSLV L FLOL YLH QMs RUs SDUD NRKsV Vs QDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsGKHVsSDULHIDOsWHKLMMHWXOPHV[KLGLQHSDVNsVDMQDILOHQWsFLOsQ GXKHWQGsUSUHUsDIsUVLVKWJMVPsRUHSDUD]HQLWLWQJDVHHN]LVWRQQMDKDGLWKLVDNWsQs WsFLOLQ3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPHNDQGDOXDUNUHUMHQHQDPD]LW JMHUVD'LHOOLWsMHWs Qs]HQLW(NXULPDPLWsQJMLWHWQsPLQEHUGRWsGUHMWRKHWNDKWs SUDQLVKPLWGKHGRW LSsUVKsQGHWsPHVHODPSDVWDMGRWsXOHWGKHSDVNsVDMPXMH]LQL PXQGWDWKLUUsH]DQLQYHWsPQMsKHUsVLosVKWsSUDNWLNDH3HMJDPEHULWDOHMKLVVHODP 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPSDVH]DQLW]DNRQLVKWQJULWHMGKHILOORQWH KWEHQNXUVHDV KDEsWHSsUFMHOOQLQPHKHVKWMHIMDOLPLQHWLMGHULVDQXNPEDURQWHPH WsGKWEHW$V3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPDVGLNXVKQJDDV KDEsW QXN H IDOWH VXQQHWLQ PLGLV H]DQLW GKH KWEHV QJDVH VLo NHPL WKHNVXDU H]DQL SsU QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs sVKWs WKLUUXU YHWsP QMs KHUs GKH NMR sVKWs H YHWPMD Ts sVKWs WUDQVPHWXDU Qs PsQUs EHVQLNH QJD SHMJDPEHUL DOHMKLVVHODP GKH NMR sVKWs DUJXPHQWVHQDPQD]LL[KXPDVssVKWsVLGKHQDPD]LL%DMUDPLWSDUDFLOLWJMLWKDVKWX QXN HN]LVWRQ VXQQHWTs GXKHW Ws IDOHW ;KDELUL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX WUDQVPHWRQ VH 3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPMHSWHVHODPNXUQJMLWHMQsPLQEHU,EQL 0D[KH
170.
%LODOOLUDGL$OOOODKXDQKX HWKLUUWHH]DQLQNXU3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYH VHOOHPXOHMQs
PLQEHU QGsUVD EsQWH LNDPHWNXU3HMJDPEHUL]EULVWHQJD PLQEHUL $KPHGL GKH 1HV LX
171.
.XU 3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX
DOHMKL YH VHOOHP
172.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT QJMLWHM Qs PLQEHU DV KDEsW L GUHMWRQLQ IWUDW H WUH NDK DL ,EQL 0D[KH
173.
(EX 'DYXGLUDKLPHKXOODKQsSsUPEOHGKMHQHWLMWUDQVPHWRQVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP
XOHM Qs PLQEHU GHULVD PXMH]LQL QXN H WKLUUWH H]DQLQ SDV NsVDM QJULWHMGKHHPEDQWHKWEHQSDVNsVDMXOHMGKHQXNIOLVWHJMsSDVNsVDMQJULWHMGKHH PEDQWHKWEHQHGWs# ,PDPL,EQ7HMPLMMHUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$3HMJDPEHULVDOODOO OODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQXNLIDOWHVXQQHWHWSDUDQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsSDVH]DQLWGKH DVNXVK QXN WUDQVPHWRQ WD NHWs EsUs NsWs 1s NRKsQ H WLM H]DQL WKLUUHM YHWsP SDV QJMLWMHV Vs WLM Qs PLQEHU %LODOOL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX H WKLUUWH H]DQLQ SDVWDM 3HMJDPEHULLPEDQWHGKWEHSDVoND%LODOOLEsQWHLNDPHWGKH3HMJDPEHULXSULQWH QMHUs]YHQsQDPD]3UDQGDMWKHPLVHQXNNDTHQsHPXQGXUTsDVDLDVGLNVXKQJD DV KDEsWHWLMWsNHWsIDOXUVXQQHWHSDVH]DQLWGKHDVNXQGQXNSsUPHQGHWTsPDGMHQs VKWsSLQsHWLMW LNHWsIDOXUVXQQHWHSDUDGDOMHVQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs# 6DLSsUNHWILOOLPLWWsNRKsVVsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsHWUDQVHWRMPsHGKHPHQGLPLQ HGUHMWsWsXOHPkYHWsFLOsWVXSR]RMQsVHNRKDHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsILOORQQsNRKsQ HNRKsVVsGUHNsVJMHUVDLPDP0DOLNXUDKLPHKXOODKNRQVLGHURQVHsVKWsHOHMXDUTs KWEMDWsPEDKHWSDUD]HQLWLWPLUsSRPHNXVKWTsDWsKHUsWsPRVNUKHWQDPD]SRV QsNRKsQNXUWsYLMsNRKDHQDPD]LWWsGUHNsV
174.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT .XVKDUULQQsUHNDWLHGWsWs QDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsQXNGXKHWWD IDOsQDPD]LQHGUHNsV .XVKDUULQQsQMsUHNDWWsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs% DLNDDUULWXUQs[KXPDHNXVK DUULQQsPsSDNVHQMsUHNDWDLGXKHWW LIDOsNDWsUUHNDWHWsIDU]LWWsGUHNsV
175.
1JD ,EQL2PHULUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXPDWUDQVPHWRKHWVH3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$.XVKHDUULQQMsUHNDWQs[KXPDQDPD]GKHQsQGRQMsQDPD] WMHWsU OH WD
IDOs HGKH WMHWULQ UHNDW
176.
QJDVH DWsKHUs QDPD]L
L WLM sVKWs L UUHJXOOW# 1HVD LX ,EQL 0D[KH GKH 'DUHNXWQL
177.
0H NsWs KDGLWK
GsVKPRKHW VH NXVK DUULQ Qs UHNDWLQ H GWs Ws QDPD]LW Ws [KXPDVs ND DUULWXU Qs QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVs HGKH SsUNXQGsUDVDMVHQXNNDSUH]HQWXDUQsKWEH .XVKDUULQQsPHV[KLGJMDWs KWEHVGXKHWW¶LIDOLGUHNDWH WHKLMMHWXOPHV[KLG ;KDELULUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXNDWKsQs$+ULQsPHV[KLG
178.
QMsWsSUHPWHQMsQMHUL JMHUVD3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPHPEDQWHKWEHQGKHSHMJDPEHULH SHWL$$MHIDOXU# $-R# %
XSsUJMHJMN$$WsKHUsIDOLGUHNDWH# % LWKD3HMJDPEHUL
179.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP# %XKDULXGKH0XVOLPL
180.
.KDGLWKSDUDTHWGsVKPLWs TDUWsTsNXVKYRQRKHWQsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsGKHKQQsPHV[KLGQsNRKsQHKWEHV sVKWsLREOLJXDUWsIDOsG UHNDWHHGKHSsUNXQGsUDVDMTsoGRDNWLYLWHWJMDWsKWEHV sVKWsLQGDOXDUGKHQJDKDGLWKLJMLWKDVKWXVKLKHWTsLPDPLPXQGWsELVHGRMsPHWs SUDQLVKPLWQGsUVDDWDTsMDQsXOXUQXNGXKHWWsELVHGRMQs )DOMDHVXQQHWLWSDVQDPD]LWWs [KXPDVs (EX+XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRQTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKL YHVHOOHPNDWKsQs$.XUGLNXVKSUHMMXVKHIDOsQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsSDVNsVDMHW L IDOsNDWsUUHNDWH#
0XVOLPL
181.
$EGXOODKE2PHULUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXPDSDVNUHUMHV VsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsVKNRQWHQsVKWsSLGKHDWMHLIDOWHGUHNDWHGKHGHNODURQWH $.sVKWXNDYHSUXDU3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP# 0XVOLPL
182.
1sNRPHQWLQHKDGLWKLWWsSDUsWsVLSsUVKsQXDULPDP,EQXO$UHELXUDKLPHKXOODK WKRW $3HMJDPEHUL VDOODOOOODKX
DOHMKL YH VHOOHP ND XUGKsUXDU Ts SDV [KXPVs Ws IDOHQNDWsUUHNDWHQsPsQUsTsLQMRUDQWsWWsPRVPHQGRMQsVHHGKHPHGUHNDWH PXQGW LSORWsVRMQsDWRGUHNDWHWsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs.sWDNDWsUUHNDWHGXKHWWs IDOHQGQJDGQJDVH3HMJDPEHULWKRW$1DILOMDGLWsVsVKWsGQJDG# (EX'DYXGL GKH ,EQL +LEEDQL
183.
*MLWKDVKWX NsWR UHNDWH
GXKHW Ws IDOHQ Qs NsWs PsQUs DVKWX Ts LWKWDUsWHULVLYHWsPRVPHQGRMQsVHNsVKWsQDPD]LLGUHNsV3UDQGDMGXKHWWsIDOHQ
184.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT GQJDGDVKWXTsNMRQDILOHW LJMDVRMsQDPD]LWWsGUHNsV# *MLWKDVKWXPXQGWsIDOHW HGKHQsVKWsSLSDVQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsVHSVHHGKHNMRsVKWsVXQQHWL3MHJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHP6DLSsUNHWKDGLWKLWWs,EQL2PHULWQsNRPHQWLQHWs QMHMWLW ,EQL 7HMPLMMH WKRW $1sVH QMHULX IDOHW Qs PHV[KLG DWsKHUs GR !L IDOs NDWsU UHNDWHQsVHIDOHWQsVKWsSLDWsKHUYHWsPG# 0HNsWsGHNODULP,EQL7HMPLMMHLND DIUXDU G WUDQVPHWLPHW H G KDGLWKHYH Ws VLSsUVKsQXDU GKH ND VTDUXDU VL GXKHW W L NXSWRMPsDWD8OHPkNRQVLGHURMQsTsPHJMLWKDWsPsPLUssVKWsWsIDOXULWQsVKWsSL PHTs3HMJDPEHULDOHMKLVVHODPWKRW$1DPD]LPsLPLUsoXSLVsVKWsDLQDPD]LFLOL NUKHW Qs VKWsSL SRV IDU]LW# . sVKWs PHQGLP HGKH L LPDP 6KDILXW 0DOLNXW GKH $KHGLW .XU Qs QDPD]LQH[KXPDVsWsNHWsWROORYLWsPDGKHGXKHWJMHWXUQMsYHQGSsU IDOMHQHQDPD]LWQs[KDPLGKHDLWsPRVNUKHWQsUUXJsQsVHNsWsHOHMRMQsNXVKWHW ,PDP $KPHGL GKH %HMKHNL WUDQVPHWRMQs QJD 6HMMDUL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX Ws NHWs WKsQs $( NDP GsJMXDU 2PHULQ GXNH WKsQs Qs KWEH $3HMJDPEHUL H QGsUWRL NsWs PHV[KLG QGsUVD PH WH LVKLP QD PXKD[KHUsW GKH HQVDULWsW .XU Ws NHWs WROORYL Qs PHV[KLG QMHUs]LW OH Ws EsMQs VH[KGH Qs VKSLQDW H YsOOH]sUYH Ws WUH# *MLWKDVKWX WUDQVPHWRKHWTs2PHULLNLVKWHSDUsGLVDQMHUs]GXNHXIDOXUQsUUXJsDQGDMXWKD $)DOXQLQsPHV[KLG#
185.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 6LWsYHSURKHWNXUGLWDHEDMUDPLW SsUSXWKHWPsGLWsQH[KXPDVs ,PDP6DQ DQLUDKLPHKXOODKQsYHSUsQHWLM$6XEXOXVVHODP#sIDTHQQJD ,EQL $EEDVL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKXPD WUDQVPHWRQ VH QXN GXKHW IDOXU QDPD]LQ H [KXPDVsQsVHQsWsQMHMWsQGLWsELHQDPD]LL%DMUDPLW,EQL$EEDVLOLGKXUPHNsWs osVKWMHJMLWKDVKWXWKRWTsNYHSULPsVKWsQsSsUVKWDWMHPHVXQQHWLQH3HMJDPEHULW VDOODOOOODKX DOHMKL YH VHOOHP 7UDQVPHWRKHW VH ,EQL =XEHMUL UDGL $OOOODKX DQKX LVKWHLPDPQsQDPD]LQHEDMUDPLWQsGLWsQH[KXPD!$WDUDKLPHKXOODKWKRW$1D HUGKsPQsPHV[KLGSsUWDIDOXUQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsQGsUVD,EQL=XEHMULQXNHUGKL $WsKHUsWsJMLWKsHIDOsPLQGLYLGXDOLVKWQDPD]LQHGUHNsV# .XU,EQL$EEDVLUDGL$OO OODKXDQKXHUGKLQDHODMsPUXDPSsUYHSULPLQH,EQL =XEHMULW$WsKHUsDLQDWKD $,EQL=XEHMULNDYHSUXDUGUHMW# 1JDVXQQHWLsVKWsPRVIDOMDHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsGKH GXKHWEDVKNXDUEDMUDPLQPHQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsPHYHWsPGUHNDWHGKHNQDPD] GXKHWWsIDOHWQsNRKsQHQDPD]LWWs EDMUDPLW,EQL$EEDVLHNLVKWHEDVKNXDUQDPD]LQ HEDMUDPLWPHDWsWs[KXDPVsGKHDWsGLWsQXNHIDOWHQDPD]LQHGUHNsVSRUGLUHNWH IDOWHQDPD]LQHLTLQGLVs(EX'DYXGLUDKLPHKXOODKQJD,EQL=XEHMULUDGL$OOOODKX DQKXWUDQVPHWRQWsNHWsWKsQs$'IHVWDWNLVKLQUsQsQsQMsGLWsDQGDM,EQL=XEHMULL EDVKNRLQsQMsQDPD]WsFLOLQHIDOLQsPsQJMHVQsNRKsQHQDPD]LWWsEDMUDPLW
186.
PH YHWsP G UHNDWH
SDV NsVDM QXN IDOLDVJMs GHUL Qs QDP]LQ H LTLQGLVs# 1JD=HMG E (UNDPLUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWWsNHWsWKsQs$3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKX DOHMKLYHVHOOHPHIDOLQDPD]LQHEDMUDPLWSDVNsVDMHOHMRLPRVIDOMHQHQDPD]LWWs
187.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT [KXPDVs GKH SDVWDM GHNODURL $.XVK GsVKLURQ WD IDOs [KXPDQs
188.
OH WD IDOs# %XKDULX0XVOLPL(EX'DYXGL1HVD
LXGKH,EQL0D[KH% WHUPLQRORJMLQsHKDGLWKLW SsUPHQGHWWHUPLKDPVHWsSHVWLW
189.
1JDNMRPXQGWsVKLKHWVHDWDTsGsVKLURMQsWsIDOLQQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsPXQGWD EsMQs NsWs 1JD
KDGLWKL JMLWKDVKWX PXQG Ws NRQNOXGRKHW VH Qs HVHQFs QDPD]L L [KXPDVs QXN GXKHW Ws IDOHW PLUsSR NXVK GsVKLURQ PXQG WD EsMs NsWs 1JD (EX +XUHMUHUDGL$OOOODKXDQKXWUDQVPHWRKHWTs3HMJDPEHULVDOODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHO OHPNDWKsQs$QsNsWsGLWsMDQsSsUSXWKXUGIHVWDGKHNXVKGsVKLURQPXQGWsPRVH IDOs[KXPDQsQDGR W LEDVKNRMPsEDMUDPLQGKH[KXPDQsPHYHWsPQMsQDPD]Qs NRKsQHQDPD]LWWsEDMUDPLW
190.
# +DNLPLGKH,EQL0D[KH
191.
,PDP6KHYNDQLNRQVLGHURQ VHGXKHWIDOXU[KXPDQsHGKHSsUNXQGsUDVDMVHWDQLPsHNDIDOXUEDMUDPLQPLUsSRDL JMLWKDVKWX NRQVLGHURQ VH
OHMRKHW PRVIDOMD H QDPD]LW Ws [KXPDVs DWs GLWs ,PDP 6KHYNDQL Qs YHSUsQ $1HMOXO(YWDU# I
192.
WKRW $ÉVKWs H
OHMXDU Ts Ws PRV IDOHW QDPD]LL[KXPDVsQsGLWsQH%DMUDPLW# .XVKHVKTUWRQQsPsQUsVWXGLR]HNsWsosVKWMHGRWsVKRKsVHDWDTsQXNH NDQsIDOXUQDPD]LQHEDMUDPLWMDQsWsREOLJXDUWDIDOLQQDPD]LQH[KXPDVsHQsVH NsWs QXN DUULMQs SVK SsU VKNDN Ws PRVDUGKMHV Vs LPDPLW DWsKHUs GXKHW WD IDOLQ QDPD]LQHGUHNsV6LoNHPLWKHNVXDUSsUQDPD]LQH[KXPDVssVKWsLGRPRVGRVKsP [KHPDWL QGsUVD HGKH G MDQs PMDIW GKH NMR sVKWs YsUWHWXDU PH KDGLWKH GKH PH NRQFHQVXV Ws XOHPkVs GKH QXN ND GDOOLP Qs PHV Ws [KHPDWLW Qs [KXPD GKH Qs QDPD]HWWMHUsGKHQXNsVKWsWUDQVPHWXDUDVQMsKDGLWKQsWsFLOLQSsUPHQGHWQXUPLL GXKXUL[KHPDWOLQMYHWsFLOsWGRWsPXQGWDIDOLQ[KXPDQs
193.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT /LWHUDWXUD $=DGXOPH DG# % ,EQ.DMMLPHO;KHY]LMMH%OHQLL $)LNKXVVXQQH# % 6HMMLG6DELN% %OHQLL $1HMKXOHZWDU# 0$OLHVK6KHZNDQL%OHQLL $6XEXOXVVHODQ# % (V6DQ DQL%OHQL,, $7HPDPXOPLQQH# % 0XKDPHG1D VLUXGLQHO$OEDQL $%HMDQXOPHKD[K[KHK# % ,EQ5H[KHE $.LWDEXO0D[KPX X# %,PDPQHYHYL%OHQL,9 $)HWKXO%DUL6KHUKX6DKLKLO%XKDUL# %,EQ+D[KHU $(UUHZGDWXQQHGLMMH# +DVDQ6LGGLN.KDQ%OHQL,
194.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 3sUPEDMWMD 'LVSR]LWDWHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs QsED]sWs.XU¶DQLW GKHVXQQHWLW LOsVLWsHGLWsVVs[KXPDVs 3DVRMDWHUsQGDWsOsVKLPLWWsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs 2EOLJLPLLODUMHVGKHSRURVLDHSDUIXPRVMHVGKHSsUGRULPL LPLVYDNXWSsUQGHUWsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs 7sSsUFMHOOXULWHVKSHVKWsWsVDODYDWHYH3HMJDPEHULWVDO ODOOOODKXDOHMKLYHVHOOHPQsGLWsQH[KXPDVs 7sOH[XDULWHNDSWLQsV³HO.HKI´QsGLWsQH[KXPDVs 2EOLJLPLLIDOMHVVsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs .RKDHQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVssVKWsNRKDHQDPD]LWWs GUHNsV 0HQGLPLLXOHPDVsLVODPHOLGKXUPHosVKWMHQHREOLJLPLW WsSUDQLVKsPYHJMDWsNRKsVVsKWEHV 6KNXUWLPLVKWOLGKXUPHELVHGsQJMDWsKWEHV
195.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 9OHUDHYHSULPLWWsDWUHTsHSsUFMHOOLQKWEHQQsKHVKWMH ,PDPLQXNGXKHWW¶LQJULWsGXDUWSsUGXDNXUsVKWsQs PLQEHU 2EOLJLPLLIDOMHVVsWHKLMMHWXOPHV[KLGLWHGKHSsUNXQGsU IDNWLWTsLPDPLQGRGKHWQsPLQEHU *DELPHWTsLEsMQsPXVOLPDQsWGLWsQH[KXPDVsGKHWs FLOsWVKNDNWRMQsKXPEMHQHVHYDSLWWsNsVDMGLWH PXEDUHN *DELPHWHLPDPLWQsPLQEHUSDUDJMDWsGKHSDVKWEHV 6XQQHWHWHKWEHV 4RUWLPLLJsUVKHWLPLWWsJLVKWULQMYHJMDWsVKNXDUMHVQs PHV[KLG LOsVLWsHGLWsVVs[KXPDVs 3UHIHULPLLIDOMHVVsQDILOHVSDUDH]DQLWWs[KXPDQDPD]LW GKHPRVHN]LVWLPLLIDOMHVVsVXQQHWLWWs[KXPDVsSDV H]DQLWSsUQDPD]LQH[KXPDVs .XVKDUULQQsUHNDWLHGWsWsQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVsQXN GXKHWWDIDOsQDPD]LQHGUHNsV .XVKDUULQQsPHV[KLGJMDWsKWEHVGXKHWW¶LIDOLG UHNDWHWHKLMMHWXOPHV[KLG )DOMDHVXQQHWLWSDVQDPD]LWWs[KXPDVs
196.
;KXPDMD 'LWDPsH]JMHGKXUHMDYsV
IT 6LWsYHSURKHWNXUGLWDHEDMUDPLWSsUSXWKHWPsGLWsQH [KXPDVs /LWHUDWXUD 3sUPEDMWMD
Download now