Cheetah Development Summary of Approach with Investment Management
Cheetah Development Summary of Approach with Investment Management
1.
2. Contents
A. Understand Causes
of Rural Poverty
• 4 Halves of Have-
Nots
• Farmers lack access
to finance and
markets
• Value chains are
weak
• Needed solutions
are businesses
B. Solve Poverty by
Creating Livelihoods
• Mission: Turn crops
into cash
• Strategy 1: Solve
finance for higher
crop yields
• Strategy 2: Invest in
value chains to
create markets
• Strategy 3: Achieve
scale
C. Shift Charity to
Impact Investment
• Not enough aid
money to end
poverty
• Underlying
nonprofit
foundation
• Africa Farmers
Collateral Fund
• Africa Agriculture
Equity Fund
3. SECTION A: Understand Causes of Rural Poverty
• Rural poverty is profound.
• Subsistence farmers are
majority of poor on earth.
• While aid has helped with
healthcare and education,
rural poverty is often
getting worse.
• There is not enough money
in aid to end poverty.
4. Subsistence
Farming & Food, Rough
Statistics for Most
African Nations
Half of people
are chronically
malnourished
Half of year
famine:
wet/dry cycle
becomes
feast/famine
Half of food
imported, esp.
by value: local
markets are
huge
Half of
farmer’s
production
never
consumed
4 Halves
of the
Have-Nots
4
Most of a farmer’s
production from
the wet season is
lost: the lack of
processing,
preservation, and
logistics businesses
causes hunger and
poverty. There is no
model to invest in
them. Aid competes
with them.
Underlying
Problems
5. Farmers Lack
Access to Crop
Input Finance
Underlying
Problems
• With careful manual
application, it costs $200-
$1000 per acre for seeds,
fertilizer and treatments
• There is not enough money in aid to lift farmers out
of poverty. BIG LOANS are needed;
(more than microfinance offers farmers.)
• Microfinance limits people to subsistence.
6. • What is a market? -List of buyers to negotiate terms (a
business function)
• Distribution systems lacking so need market building
(rather than ‘market linkages’)
• Access paradox: market is BIG but farmer is SMALL (too
small to connect)
Farmers Lack Access
to Markets
Underlying
Problems
7. Farmers
produce little
for sale
• So no
commercial
loans
• So no reliable
market causing
much waste
Food
businesses lack
crop inputs
• So limited
growth and
investment
• So they import
needed volume
competing with
nearby farmers
Underlying
Problems
Dysfunction in the
Food Value Chain
Cheetah must
work on both
halves because
the problems are
linked in a
vicious
cycle
Underlying
Problems
Markets Solutions
are Needed Too
that damage
investments
9. STRATEGY – Farmer Partnership:
New ways to finance farmers
New businesses for small farmers
Make farmers investable
STRATEGY – Solve Industry Gaps:
New businesses in value chain
closely serving farmers
10. Is a last mile problem/opportunity:
connecting backbone industry
to small suppliers/users
at the end of the line.
11. SECTION B: Solve Poverty by Creating Livelihoods
• Mission Summary
• Strategy 1: Increase crop
yields with new kind of
finance to commercialize
farmers.
• Strategy 2: Make
investments in value-chain
to create markets and
serve farmer needs.
• Strategy 3: Achieve scale.
13. Strategy 1: Commercialize Farmers
Beyond subsistence:
Maize fields planted
on the same day.
(Cheetah supported
farmer on left.)
It’s not giving gifts, it’s growing gifts
14. 4 Steps to Leave Subsistence Poverty
1.
Organizing
in
Registered
Groups
2.
Technical
Farming
(Agronomy
and Inputs)
3.
Large
Commercial
Loans
4.
Guaranteed
Markets
Farmer
Commercialization
Prefer to partner with NGOs for
training, organizing and data
collection
Pearl’s focus
and income
Partner w/ local
banks
(metafinance)
15. Africa
Farmers
Collateral
Fund
Healthy
Commercial
Loan – 3 Legs
Business
(Farmer’s
Group)
Economic
Benefit
(Markets)
Lending
Bank
Receive no cash, only
inputs, pay with crops,
loans guaranteed
between members
Guarantee
markets and
first 10% of loan
Kept in USD
accounts
Spreading the risk
unlocks the deadlock
Investment
Solution
16. From MIT group that
made the first major
review of microfinance:
“… the structure of
[microfinance’s] success
in lending to the poor is
such that we cannot
count on it to be a
stepping-stone for
larger businesses to be
created and financed.
Finding ways to finance
medium scale
enterprise is the next
big challenge for
finance in developing
countries.”
Microfinance
Small loans averaging
$300 filling microfinance
space
Less successful and
smaller in rural areas
and for agriculture
Best suited to micro
enterprises with no
usage control
Credit often based upon
peer pressure or
average risk factors
Cheetah’s
Metafinance
Innovation
Loans (and equity)
$5000-$500,000 filling
“Missing Middle” gap
Designed for
communities or midsized
businesses
Requires strict structural
control, which is built in
Credit based on
production capability
17. Strategy 2: Invest in Value Chain Businesses
Solve value chain
problems holding
farmers back:
Example: Solar
food dryer
preserves food, is
affordable to
farmers, opens
new markets and
recovers harvest
losses.
It’s not giving gifts, it’s growing gifts
18. Target Investment Criteria
Profitable
High impact –
change livelihoods
significantly
Ag or ag value
chain
Replicable – can be
replayed and cross
cultures
Scalable and able
to grow quickly
meeting the needs
of many
High need, fills a
critical gap, ‘last
mile’ to farmers
High leverage – few
employees or low
investment
changes many lives
Cluster – fit with
other investments
to multiply effect
Red: priority
preference
Green:
important
preference
19. Cheetah
Innovation:
• Franchise approach replays business successes
• Pilot concepts tested before investments
• Shared back office resources between investments
Africa
Agriculture
Equity Fund
Investable
Micro Venture
Capital
20. InvestmentExamples
Pearl Foods – opening
markets and finance to
farmers
Reservoir – ending the
feast/famine cycle, now
with solar food dryers
Kabisa – creating rural
transport, especially for
transporting crops
Sunborn – dried food
marketing
Prototyped
InitialOperationsOperating
Operating
21. Strategy 3: Achieve Scale
The problem is
massive – 2
billion people.
The solution
must be
scalable:
It must employ
strategies that
are replicable
and can be
widely adopted.
It’s not giving gifts, it’s growing gifts
22. We have a
moral
obligation
to scale it.
That is
different…
Because there
is a solution
that works…
Our Operating Thesis
Poverty is intrinsically offensive and a major contributor to many of
the most serious problems on earth (war, disease, climate change).
24. Directly impact a 1
million+ people
and indirectly far
more
Operate in 2-3
regions/continents,
more than 12
nations
Open more than 20
locations(a
common test of
franchising skills)
Found more than
10 new companies
Cheetah Five Year Objectives
25. Investment Steps
• Identify opportunities
• SelectIdeate
• Prototype
• Validation requirementsPilot
• Demonstrate business model
• Verify validation requirements metActivate
• Invest
• Grow in origination and new locationsPropagate
Board approval required to
advance to each new step.
26. Avoiding the
Gartner Hype Cycle
By piloting
companies,
Cheetah is able
to provide
much more
realistic
expectations of
performance in
advance of
significant
investment.
Supporting
pilots is part of
the reason the
investor fees
are front
loaded.
27. SECTION C: Shift Charity to Impact Investment
• Leverage current farmer
assets – first let them
succeed where they are.
• Increase crop yields with
new kind of finance.
• Make investments in value-
chain to create markets and
serve farmer needs.
• Go to scale.
28. The solution to poverty isn’t charity; it is
investment: what’s needed is wealth
creation not redistribution.
It must attract donors AND investors;
it’s the only way to fund the scale of the
problem.
Cheetah offers a fundamentally new way
to capitalize wealth creation for
smallholder farmers.
Gives impact investors a financial and
social return: double and even triple
bottom lines.
Financing a revolution in rural
economic development
29. "...investments made into companies, organizations,
and funds with the intention to generate measurable
social and environmental impact alongside a financial
return.
Impact investments can be made in both emerging and
developed markets, and target a range of returns from
below market to market rate, depending upon the
circumstances."
- Global Impact Investing Network
Impact Investing:
Aligning Investments with Values
30. Three Pillars: Success to Significance
Philanthropy
Impact focus
Kick-start
businesses
Business
Profits for
sustainability
Accountability
Capital Markets
Debt and
Equity
Needed for
Scale
31. Training on the use of
solar food dryers
often attracts crowds
of women in villages.
65% of world’s
uncultivated arable
land. Uses less than 2%
of renewable water.
Moving from an
extractive economy to a
value added economy
GDP grown at a 5% rate
over the last decade
High birth rates with
falling infant mortality
Growing middle class
food consumption
increasing demand –
already a net importer
Demand for food from
Middle East, India and
China
African Agriculture Holds Opportunity
32. Farmers lack access to crop
input & equipment finance
Farmers lack access
to markets & value chain
Africa Farmers
Collateral Fund
Africa Agriculture
Equity Fund
Financing Solutions with Accredited Investors
35. Risk Mitigation
Africa Farmers Collateral Fund I Africa Agriculture Equity Fund I
On-the-ground presence, active management in portfolio companies
Cheetah keeps control of accounting, reducing likelihood of corruption
Shared back office services and location reduces startup costs
Preferred share position for investors in many cases
Local village leadership for most activities bridges cultural gaps
Loans made by local commercial banks that
have rights of loan enforcement
Usually have controlling interest in
companies
Money stays in US dollars to avoid currency
exchange
Prototype many company activities before
receiving investment
Farmers cross-guarantee loans between
members of groups
Partnering when possible reduces investment
required
Farmers receive crop inputs or equipment
rather than cash; loan is paid by delivering
crops
Keeping companies small and scale achieved
through franchising reduces risks of
concentrated capital
Diverse crops and climates Franchising approach creates a higher
dedication to standardized procedures, thus
more predictable outcomes
36. Africa Farmers Collateral Fund I
• Farmers turn in crops, they are
sold, loan is paid
• If crop does poorly, crops
produced are sold, farmers
achieve no profit, loan is paid
• If farmers do not pay, other
farmers cover costs, loan is paid
• If group fails, bank enforces loan
and farmers make payments over
time
• Supplier (usually investee of AAEF
Equity Fund) of crop inputs or
equipment covers a minimum of
10% of first loan losses, including
profits from other groups, loan is
paid
• Fund investors are in tiered risks A,
B, C so losses covered in lower
tiers
Africa Agriculture Equity Fund I
• Companies are sold to outside
investor
• Fund has preferred shares, equity
is converted to debt and repaid
(this is built into the fund model
from outset – for more
information see SEAF model)
• Future fund buys out current
investors
Investor
Exit Strategies
37. Equity
Fund
Debt
Exit
Strategy
Created by
SEAF (30 yr.
proven
experience,
impact
investment
model)
Local Investors,
Employees
Common Shares
Cheetah
investment –
preferred shares
1. Cheetah raises needed investment and has board control
Common Shares
3. Loans are repaid, shares divided pro rata by others
Common Shares Cheetah shares
4. Company is revalued by pre-agreed formula
Local investors equity – common shares. However by
contract Cheetah controls accounting function to guarantee
transparency. Sale of shares is restricted by agreement.
Cheetah Preferred (15% minimum), dividing repaid
Preferred Shares with Common, (optionally, Cheetah
may be repaid while retaining equity)
6. Equity and control revert to local shareholders
Fund investment –
preferred shares A & B
Common Shares
Equity to
Debt
Round 1
Cheetah shares
2. Preferred shares divided into loan and equity
Preferred
shares
Loans
repaid
Cheetah shares
Preferred
shares
Preferred shares
Common shares
Cheetah equity subordinate to fund
debt
5. Remaining preferred shares are converted to debt and repaid (24-36 months)
Fund equity – preferred
shares, may be limited by
coupon value
7. All shareholders enjoy profit distributions pro rata with ownership
Exit Strategy:
the Process for
Fund Liquidity
38. Terms Africa Farmers Collateral Fund I LLC Africa Agriculture Equity Fund I LP
Manager or
General Partner
Cheetah Development, Inc., a 501(c)(3)
Size Up to $3.5 million by 31 Dec 2015 Up to $20 million by 31 Dec 2015
Target Return 2% 12% – 15%
Term 18 months, one 6-month extension.
Multiple series with rollovers.
7 years, 2 one year extensions.
Target investors Accredited investors, foundations, family offices and individuals. Impact
investments interested in Africa, agriculture, developing world poverty
reduction, and/or women’s economic empowerment.
Commitment Minimum 10 units or $100,000.
Fees & Expenses 1.5% per annum of total
Commitments. Fund pays its
operating expenses.
3% per annum of total commitments,
partially paid up front for incubation
and R&D. Fund pays its operating
expenses.
Legal Counsel Dorsey & Whitney LLP
Audit Firm Recognized audit firm(s) to be selected
Summary of General Fund Terms
39. Staff
• Ray Menard, founder
& CEO. Start-ups and
business development.
• Paul Larsen, VP. African
agri-business and
financing.
• Brad Brown, VP.
Impact investment and
social enterprise.
Fund Advisory Board
• Investors
• Chris Maclellan,
Trustee, The
Maclellan
Foundation
• Mark Mortenson,
Trustee, Mortenson
Foundation
Experienced Management
40. • Unique direct investment opportunity for
the “high touch” impact investment client
Set your firm
apart
• Financial and social returns, both highly
measurable
Align values of
your clients
• On-the-ground / in-the-market / culturally
attuned management
Unconventional
for success
• Not an NGO solution, a business solutionOn target
Special Offering for Values Based Investment
Clients of Registered Investment Firm Advisors
42. Proof of Concept
• Past 5 Years, Complete
Proof of Scale
• 5 Years, Starting Now
• Result: Everyone
Believes
A Movement
• 1 Billion Lives Changed
43. StartingConcepts
3 year plan to:
Use business to end poverty by
linking opportunity to the poor
Create an investment model that
can be institutionalized and
replicated
Connect philanthropy, business
and capital in a new intersection
of opportunity
ProofofConceptResults
Achieved all starting
concepts (6 years) plus:
Registered a 501(c)(3) investor
Created two innovative models
of finance (Metafinance and
Micro Venture Capital)
Set up first ever VC. in Tanzania
Focused on food and agriculture
Launched 2 new companies, 4
companies in the pilot stage
Patented a ½ ton cargo bike,
developed a new solar food
dryer, more products coming
Created new brands, “Sunborn”
for smallholder foods of quality
Have 30 employees operating in
around 50 villages directly
impacting over 10,000, indirectly
almost 250,000
Substantial livelihood impact
over 10x demonstrated
Began work in 2 more nations
Set up 2 funds and raised almost
$2 million immediately
Plumbed a deal pipeline
approaching $10 million
Joined many partners and grants
Recognized as a thought leader Next–GotoScale
5 year plan to:
Directly impact a 1 million+
people and indirectly far more
Operate in 2-3 regions or
continents, more than 12 nations
Open more than 20 locations (a
common test of franchising skills)
Found more than 10 new
companies
History:
Plan and
Results
45. Securities Disclaimer
This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an
offer or solicitation to sell shares or securities in the Company or any related
or associated company. Any such offer or solicitation will be made only by
means of the Company's confidential Offering Memorandum and in
accordance with the terms of all applicable securities and other laws. None
of the information or analyses presented are intended to form the basis for
any investment decision, and no specific recommendations are intended.
Accordingly this document does not constitute investment advice or counsel
or solicitation for investment in any security. This document does not
constitute or form part of, and should not be construed as, any offer for sale
or subscription of, or any invitation to offer to buy or subscribe for, any
securities, nor should it or any part of it form the basis of, or be relied on in
any connection with, any contract or commitment whatsoever. The Company
expressly disclaims any and all responsibility for any direct or consequential
loss or damage of any kind whatsoever arising directly or indirectly from: (i)
reliance on any information contained herein, (ii) any error, omission or
inaccuracy in any such information or (iii) any action resulting therefrom.
These numbers are approximate. Depending on the nation or district within, these numbers go up or down. Nevertheless, they represent a fair approximation of the typical life of subsistence agriculture.
Here is a typical ‘market’ for farmers: come and stand by the side of the road. Clearly that is a market that can serve only nearby farmers.
It is widely agreed that in the developing world:
Farmers lack access to markets
Middle men are largely exploitative
Export crops are best bet.
The first two are correct. However, export crops aren’t the best solution because meeting international standards is expensive, marketing internationally is expensive, and local demand, including high rates of malnutrition continue unaddressed. Export crops are favored because local markets are undeveloped.
Typically, aid organizations speak of creating ‘market linkages’ to solve the lack of access to markets. However, to speak of linkages ignores the situation on the ground. There is no healthy distribution system in the poorest nations to link farmers into.
The farmer’s biggest problem is that they are too small. They cannot meet local demands because they are too expensive to work with one-by-one and because they are not operating in a commercial fashion.
Also notice that aid orgs are by their very nature not well positioned to solve the market problem – how can they enter a negotiation? What’s needed are business to enter into this opportunity/problem.
Here is a typical ‘market’ for farmers: come and stand by the side of the road. Clearly that is a market that can serve only nearby farmers.
It is widely agreed that in the developing world:
Farmers lack access to markets
Middle men are largely exploitative
Export crops are best bet.
The first two are correct. However, export crops aren’t the best solution because meeting international standards is expensive, marketing internationally is expensive, and local demand, including high rates of malnutrition continue unaddressed. Export crops are favored because local markets are undeveloped.
Typically, aid organizations speak of creating ‘market linkages’ to solve the lack of access to markets. However, to speak of linkages ignores the situation on the ground. There is no healthy distribution system in the poorest nations to link farmers into.
The farmer’s biggest problem is that they are too small. They cannot meet local demands because they are too expensive to work with one-by-one and because they are not operating in a commercial fashion.
Also notice that aid orgs are by their very nature not well positioned to solve the market problem – how can they enter a negotiation? What’s needed are business to enter into this opportunity/problem.
Jane Mahali Impact Story"Jane Mahali is an average Tanzanian wife and mother. Her husband, Fredy, is a subsistence farmer who produces maize and sunflower seeds on a five acre farm. She has a daughter, Miriam, age 9 and a son, Haruni, age 6. They live in Ilula Town, in a house made of clay with a thatched roof. For many years, Jane and her family were subject to the feast/famine cycle that plagues most of East Africa, depending only on income generated by their farm. This was not always enough, especially in the rainy season. Sometimes they went hungry. Sometimes Jane and Fredy were not able to pay the children’s school fees. Most times the roof leaked. Last December, Jane engaged in the Reservoir Ltd. solar drying program. She purchased a solar dryer and has used it to produce dried food products. Some products she has saved and stored for the coming rains, when it is difficult to find and expensive to purchase fresh produce. Most of her products have been sold back to Reservoir Ltd.’s guaranteed market. With the extra income the Mahali family made from solar drying, they were able to repair their roof. Both Jane’s children are in school and she is saving up for their tuition to attend the international school for their secondary education. Jane is now also able to contribute part of her income to her brother’s son, Erick who currently resides in an orphanage because his family cannot afford to care for him. With the money she has earned this year, she plans to purchase a second dryer in the next couple months to further support her family. Aside from further home improvements, all Jane’s efforts are concentrated, as a loving mother’s would be, on her children. She is saving up for their future and hopes that her daughter will become a teacher, that her son will become a policeman, and that her nephew, who sings in the local church choir, will become a Tanzanian pop star. Her community has seen her prosper and have recently formed a group to purchase their own dryers through microfinancing. With participants like these, Reservoir Ltd. in tangent with Cheetah Development can really take one billion from subsistence to substance."
* I did also learn that she herself was educated up through the 7th grade if you want to incorporate that somehow...
Work together so that aggregated production can address giant market, be registered so that banks have a legal entity to loan to, have small sub-groups (Teams) to provide peer pressure loan enforcement and planting practices
Get good training and access to high quality farm inputs to produce commercial yields per acre and quality
Get access to large loans to afford quality inputs, loans provided in kind – no cash given
Guaranteed markets (not ‘linked’) so that loans and farmer are secured, loan repaid by crop delivery, profits paid directly to farmer (usually to bank account opened in their individual name)
The Missing Middle is a gap of businesses that are largely missing in the developing world. The corresponding gap of funds was identified in a world wide study by the German Marshal fund as the predominant source of this gap. However, investing in Missing Middle is difficult because size of investment is small compared to needed vetting, accounting, mentoring, management etc. Therefore investors have avoided this space though it is the key size of investment for business development. What is needed is to make the investments extremely efficient. Cheetah uses four approaches to achieve this efficiency as depicted.
Here is a typical ‘market’ for farmers: come and stand by the side of the road. Clearly that is a market that can serve only nearby farmers.
It is widely agreed that in the developing world:
Farmers lack access to markets
Middle men are largely exploitative
Export crops are best bet.
The first two are correct. However, export crops aren’t the best solution because meeting international standards is expensive, marketing internationally is expensive, and local demand, including high rates of malnutrition continue unaddressed. Export crops are favored because local markets are undeveloped.
Typically, aid organizations speak of creating ‘market linkages’ to solve the lack of access to markets. However, to speak of linkages ignores the situation on the ground. There is no healthy distribution system in the poorest nations to link farmers into.
The farmer’s biggest problem is that they are too small. They cannot meet local demands because they are too expensive to work with one-by-one and because they are not operating in a commercial fashion.
Also notice that aid orgs are by their very nature not well positioned to solve the market problem – how can they enter a negotiation? What’s needed are business to enter into this opportunity/problem.