SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
2212-8271 © 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle
Engineering in the person of the Conference Chair Prof. Terje K. Lien
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2014.06.012
ScienceDirect
21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering
Effects of climate change on factory life cycle
U. Dombrowskia
, S. Ernsta
*
a
Technische Universität Braunschweig, Institute for Advanced Industrial Management, Langer Kamp 19, 38106 Braunschweig, Germany
* Corresponding author. Tel.: 0049-531-391-2703; fax: 0049-531-391-2703. E-mail address: stefan.ernst@tu-bs.de
Abstract
Climate change and global warming have negative consequences for humans and nature. While many research activities analyze the effects of
industrial production on global warming and aim to develop actions using rare resources more efficiently and reducing CO2-emission, the
effects of climate change on industrial production is rarely discussed. Hence, manufacturing companies are considered in research as cause of
climate change and not as affected by climate change. Thus, there is no systematic consideration of effects of climate change in factory
planning. This leads to expensive adaptions within factory life cycle. For this reason the paper identifies ecological, economical and social
changes caused by the climate change. These changes are analyzed on their effects on factories and prioritized according to their risk for the
company. Subsequently, the identified changes are matched to different functions of factory planning. The matching allows developing
planning-related and preventive strategy to cope with changes during factory life cycle.
© 2014 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 21st CIRP Conference on Life
Cycle Engineering in the person of the Conference Chair Prof. Terje K. Lien.
Keywords: Factory Life Cycle; Climate Change; Global Warming; Factory Planning; Advanced Industrial Management
1. Introduction
According to the climate policy of the United Nations,
global warming should be limited up to two degrees compared
to the level before the industrialization. The consequences of
this are intensive changes in conditions of living. Several
research studies forecast that this target can be only achieved
by drastic reduction of CO2 emission within a small time
frame [1]. Most research activities try to analyze the effects of
industrial production on global warming and aim to develop
actions using rare resources more efficiently and reducing
CO2 emission (e.g. Kyoto Protocol, EU Emissions Trading
Scheme). However, the reversion of this argument how
climate change will affect industrial production is rarely
discussed.
For this reason, the paper introduces ecologic, economic as
well as social changes caused by the climate change. This
paper describes a solution how to deal with these impacts by
using a 6-step-approach. The approach is a systematic way to
derive specific risk out of the impacts of the climate change.
The changes are analyzed concerning to their effects on
factory elements and factory life cycle phases. These effects
are evaluated by the probability of occurrence and the damage
level. Subsequently, the identified probability and damage
level are determining risk levels, which are prioritizing the
risk of effects on different factory life cycle elements.
According to the risk type, a strategy can be developed that
considers targeted measures for specific risks.
2. Factory Planning
2.1. Factory Planning and Factory Life Cycle
Factory planning is defined as a systematic, object-oriented
process to design a factory. It is structured into a sequence of
seven phases with its own methods and tools (see figure 1)
[2]. There are different factory planning processes, e.g. VDI
planning process or the IFU reference model for the factory
life cycle. The IFU approach has a wider scope than the VDI
planning process, because it concludes the factory life cycle
phases. The factory planning starts with the enterprise
analysis and ends with the shutdown, which is the end of
© 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle
Engineering in the person of the Conference Chair Prof. Terje K. Lien
338 U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342
production. It is often necessary to adapt and to tune the
factory to improve performance of the factory. These
iterations are also included in the reference model [3].
In phase 1 enterprise analysis, the objectives in factory
planning are deduced from the enterprise objectives and are
specified according to the specific requirements of the factory
planning project. The project team has to gather all required
information during the as-is-analysis and adapt the
information for the following phases. The goal is a definition
of all tasks in the project of factory planning. At the end of the
first phase, the project is evaluated and the management
makes the decision whether the factory planning will
continue. The general planning can be seen as the core task
of the factory planning process, because the whole factory is
designed (phase 2). It starts with the location finding. After
the structure planning and dimensioning, an ideal layout is
prepared. Based on this ideal layout different layout variants
are generated which are considering restrictions. Also, the
material flow and the material handling are planned. These
variants are evaluated according to the defined objectives. The
best variant is the input for the next phase, detailed planning
(phase 3). Within the detailed planning, the selected variant is
developed to a level of maturity for the implementation. The
results are a detailed description and the visualization of all
factory elements. The following phase is the implementation
(phase 4) and the results of previous phases are put into action
the first time. This phase also includes implementation
controlling (monitoring, coordination and documentation of
the realization process) and the production ramp up. The
planning activities are performed in teamwork that is
controlled by project management methods. The entire
planning process is supported by project management [2,3].
Operation (phase 5) has the longest duration of all life cycle
phases. The task of the factory planner does not end with the
implementation because there are still smaller improvements
steps or ramp ups of new products. The task is to assure the
capability and efficiency of the factory. Tuning enables the
provision of the facilities with the required resources at the
designated place of installation. Adjustment is the
displacement or expansion of the factory. The shutdown of
the factory is the end of factory life. The factory becomes
industrial wasteland or it may be re-utilized or revitalized for
future users’ needs [4]. Due to revitalization, the planning
process starts again [3].
The IFU reference model is focusing on life cycle phases.
Another focus on factory life cycle is present utilization value
of the different levels of factories as shown in figure 2.
According to the different lifetime of technological products,
processes, building and land use, the life cycle and the present
utilization value differs. The value of the land use is almost
constant in the long-term. Only pollution like oil pollution of
the ground has a negative influence on the value. The
connections between the elements of the factory life cycle are
based on following [5]:
• Product: According to customers demand, the product life
cycle is getting shorter.
• Process: This element is influencing the production
system. The process life cycle is planned for one or more
product life cycles. It is adapted to the product life cycle.
• Building: The building equipment is based on product,
process and production system life cycles. It needs to be
adapted to changes in production system life cycles.
• Land use: The land use life cycle is oriented on the reuse
of redeveloped areas with existing infrastructure (area
recycling)
Fig. 1. Reference model for factory life cycle
Enterprise
analysis
• Target planning
• As-is analysis
• Evaluation and
decision
General
planning
• Location finding
• Master layout
planning
• Premises structure
planning
• Organisation of
production
• Material flow and
materials handling
• Factory layout
Detailed
planning
• Detailed planning
of production
• Warehouse and
transport planning
• Office-area layout
Implementation
Shutdown
Operation
Industrial
wasteland
Re-utilisation
and
revitalisation
1
2
3
4 5
6
B
Tuning and
adaption
A
Environmentally
compatible
factory planning
Computersupportin
factoryplanning
Versatile design of
production systems
to planning stages1 6
339U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342
Fig. 2. Utility value of different life cycles. [5]
2.2. Research gap
The factory life cycle is determined by the product and
process life cycle and requires changeability of the factory as
well as a synchronization of the different life cycles. The
solutions are changeability and the improvement of the
flexibility of life cycles (to synchronize them) [5]. This is a
field of past and present research in factory planning. But
there is a lack of research about climate change and factory
planning. Some of the conventional factory planning
approaches in research are supposing the climate for a factory
location as static, so that they consider climate for
dimensioning the air conditioning [5-7]. Others try to reduce
the negative impact of the factories on the climate change by
reducing CO2 emissions [8,9]. The duration of the factory life
cycle shows a need for the consideration of long-term trends
like climate change. Greenfield factory planning projects
should take changing climate conditions into account.
Nevertheless the majority of factories were build-up years or
decades ago. Hence, the effects of climate change were not as
intensive as they are today. For this reason, the next chapter
describes climate change and its effects on factories.
3. Climate Change and its effects
This paper will not discuss if global warming is manmade
or not, it discusses the effects of global warming on factories.
3.1. Theory of climate change
Since the industrialization began, humanity started to pollute a
large amount of CO2 into the atmosphere, which was stored in
fossil energy sources, like coal. The consequence is an
increase of CO2-amount in the air from 280 ppm in the year
1850 to 367 ppm in 2000. This is a raise of 31 percent within
110 years. The result of CO2 is that sunrays, which are
reflected by earth’s surface, are reflected again. The
consequence is a higher temperature in the atmosphere. The
so called natural greenhouse effect is strengthened due to the
higher manmade amount of CO2 (anthropogenic greenhouse
effect). According to that, the average temperature is rising.
The higher average temperature is just one effect of the
changing climate. The climate change causes health,
agriculture, forests, water resources, coastal areas or
Fig. 3. Natural disasters in Germany 1970 to 2012 [10].
biodiversity [1]. Other serious effects like the sea level rise
and the higher frequency of extreme weather. The increasing
frequency of extreme weather events can be shown by the
number of natural disasters in Germany (see figure 3). The
total number of disasters is classified in hydrological disasters
(e.g. floods, landslide), metrological disasters (e.g. storms)
and climatologically disasters (e.g. heat/cold wave, drought,
forest fire) and geophysical disasters. Compared to the 1970s,
there is a significant increase in the first three types of
disasters which are related to climate change [10]. Except the
disasters, there are other effects like rising or falling
precipitation amounts, changing average temperature, changes
in agriculture, etc [11]. Not all changes have an impact on the
factory. The relevant effects are described below.
3.2. Effects of climate change on factories
The economy of industrial nations is still based on
manufacturing companies. The building envelope of the
factory is a place for value adding activities and there are
countless factories all over the world. The changing climate
conditions are affecting these factories in different ways.
Especially extreme weather events have an effect on factories.
For example, tornados can blow away roofs or the snow load
can lead to a collapse of the factory with the likely result of
seriously injured or dead victims. These events need to be
taken into account. The effects of climate change were
identified by a literature analysis (e.g. [1,12-15]) and selected
by an expert evaluation according to their relevance for the
factory. The effects can be clustered into three groups:
ecological, economical and social effects. Ecological effects
are describing the changes in the environment and the climate
conditions. Economical effects are consequences on business
and supply chains derived from the ecological effects.
Thirdly, social effects are chances like new governmental
restrictions, immigration or customer behavior. The following
effects will be considered in further analysis:
Ecological effects
• Amount of precipitation: heavy rains, annual amount,
droughts
• Temperature curve: cold/ heat waves
• Storm
• Floods due to heavy rains and sea level rise
utilityvalue
lifetime
I. construction
period and initial
investment
II. physical and
moral
impairment
III. modernization
IV. renovation
V.Decay
and
demolition
A B
C
D
Productlifecycle
Process lifecycle
Building lifecycle
Land use cycle
A
B
C
D
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
1970
1972
1974
1976
1978
1980
1982
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
2010
2012
Numberofnaturalcatastrophes
geophysical events
(earthquake, tsunami, volcanic eruption)
meteorological events
(storm)
hydrological events
(floodings, mass movements)
climatological events
(extremes in temperature, drought, forest fire)
Trend
340 U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342
Economical effects
• Higher susceptibility of a collapse of global supply chains
due to higher frequency of extreme weather events
• Higher costs for prevention activities
• Higher prices for insurance
Social effects
• Refugees due to deteriorate climate conditions (e.g. sea life
rise is flooding coastal areas in developing countries)
• Arising awareness of customers for climate change leads to
the need for climate friendly production
• CO2-limitation
• Prohibition of materials with a negative effect on climate
(e.g. CFC ban)
Depending on local conditions and the characteristic of the
factory, the intensity of each effect is varying and additional
effects may need to be considered. For example, if water
resources get scarce the competition between industry, private
households and agriculture for water is getting harder. This is
influencing water-intensive industries, like chemical industry
or power plants. This may result in blackouts in summer
which is affecting other branches.
4. Approach
The effects of climate change need to be taken into account
within all phases of the factory planning process. Also the
approach needs to be adaptable to be applicable in practice.
Hence, the approach is a wide general approach that can be
adapted to a suitable level of detail. It consists of 6 steps
which provides a systematic development of strategies and
supports the conservation of the factory’s value. The first step
determines the field of all possible applications by defining
the level of detail and describing all factory life cycle
elements. Afterwards, the field is limited to the relevant
elements in the second step. During the third step,
probabilities of occurrence of the effects of climate change are
assessed for each factory element and life cycle phase. Then,
the level of damage is determined for each combination in the
fourth step. Step 5 contains the derivation of different risk
levels which are visualized and classified in a risk portfolio.
Finally, strategies are developed according to the risk level.
Each step is described in detail in the following.
4.1. Step 1: Determination of the field of application
The first step is the determination of all possible factory
life cycle elements that can be considered in the following
analysis. A factory life cycle element can be characterized by
the dimensions ‘factory element’ and ‘life cycle phase’.
Especially, the factory elements have a broad range of
detailing. As described in paragraph 2.1, there are the four
main factory elements product, process, building and land. If
required, these elements can be detailed to smaller pieces. The
second dimension is the ‘life cycle phase’. This dimension
can be divided according to the six life cycle phases of IFU
reference model. The result of the first step is the definition of
a matrix of the factory life cycle elements (see figure 4a). The
Fig. 4. a) Step 1: Matrix with factory life cycle elements.
b) Step 2: Selection of relevant elements.
n columns correspond with all possible factory life cycle
phases (or sub-phases). There are m rows for each factory
element.
4.2. Step 2: Selection of relevant factory life cycle elements
The further approach would get too complex, if all
elements of the matrix would be considered in further
analysis. Therefore, the relevant parts are selected by a
comprehensive analysis or by a company-specific decision of
the management. The comprehensive analysis consists of an
impact matrix and a consistency matrix. These techniques
support the systematic derivation of interrelations between
different elements that are relevant for the selection [16].
Hence, specific factory life cycle elements, whole phases or
factory elements that are not relevant can be excluded.
For example the factory element ‘product’ may be not
relevant for climate change because its life cycle time is rather
short. Also, the life cycle phase ‘enterprise analysis’ is
supposed to be not relevant for the company analysis of the
climate change. Hence, parameters of the first column and the
lowest row can be deleted from the matrix (see figure 4b).
4.3. Step 3: Occurrence of effects of climate change
The effects of climate change are analyzed in step 3. A
number of main effects are listed in paragraph 3.2. If
additional effects influence the factory life cycle elements,
they can be added. Each effect is considered in the analysis by
a third dimension. Consequently, the matrix is expanded to a
cube. Each field of the cube represents the impact of an effect
of climate change of a factory life cycle element. The impact
can be described with the probability of occurrence of an
effect within the factory life cycle for a specific factory
location. Figure 5 shows a cube whose fields contain the
probability of occurrence which is stated between 0 and 1.
From this it follows that a probability of 1 indicates that the
effect takes place every year at least once and a probability of
0.3 that it occurs in three of ten years. The probabilities of
occurrence are divided into the following six categories [17]:
• Inconceivable (probability of <0.02)
• Not likely (probability of 0.02 to <0.1)
• Conceivable (probability of 0.1 to <0.2)
a) Example: step 1 b) Example: step 2
LC phase
Factory element
Land
Bulding
Process
Product
Enterpriseanalysis
Generalplanning
Detailedplanning
Implementation
Operation
Shutdown
Factory LC element
LC phase
Factory element
Land
Bulding
Process
Product
Not relevant
Enterpriseanalysis
Generalplanning
Detailedplanning
Implementation
Operation
Shutdown
LC – life cycle
341U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342
Fig. 5. Step 3: Three dimensions of probability cube (dummy data).
• Occasionally (probability of 0.2 to <0.3)
• Likely (probability of 0.3 to <0.8)
• Often (probability of 0.8 to 1)
According to the example, there is a probability of 1 that
the amount of precipitation has a negative impact on building
during implementation phase. The probability within the life
cycle phase operation is between 0.2 and 0.3, because it is less
likely that negative impacts occur. Finally, all fields in the
cube have to be evaluated.
4.4. Step 4: Estimation of the damage level
The forth step contains the estimation of the level of
damage if the effect of climate change occurs. Each factory
life cycle element gets assigned a level of damage for every
effect. The following four levels are distinguished [18]:
• Negligible: if the effect occurs, there will be no negative
impact on the factory life cycle element.
• Moderate: if the effect occurs, it has an impact on the
factory life cycle element. Nevertheless, there is just a
minor damage.
• Critical: if the effect occurs, it will hurt the company very
much so that it has a huge damage. But the effect will not
be existence-threatening for the factory.
• Catastrophic: A catastrophic damage has a big negative
impact on the factory element; it is seriously existence-
threatening for the factory.
For example, the damage of a higher amount of
precipitation has a very high damage on the factory operation,
because the factory’s roof is leaky. Also the factory’s location
is in a flooding area of a river with the result that flooding of
the building is getting more likely. Hence, the level of damage
is critical to catastrophic.
4.5. Step 5: Derivation of risk level
The probability of occurrence and the level of damage can
be combined to a risk portfolio that shows a specific risk for
certain combinations. A reasonable tool for visualization this
context is the risk portfolio shown in figure 6. One dimension
of the matrix is the level of damage with the four categories of
step 4. The other dimension is the probability of occurrence
Fig. 6. Step 5: Risk portfolio with risk types.
from step 3 which are clustered into six categories. Hence, the
matrix has 24 fields which have a different importance for the
factory. The field in the bottom left is representing low risk.
On the very top right, there are the combinations with high
risk. The risk portfolio with the example of precipitation is
shown in figure 6.
4.6. Step 6: Strategy development
If all potential risks are indentified and classified, the
factory management should develop strategies to handle the
risk. The risk types are [19]:
1. Unacceptable risk
2. “as low as reasonably practicable” risk
3. Acceptable risk
Generally, all risks should be avoided. However, this is
often impossible due to financial restrictions and conflicting
goals. One the one hand, factories should not be located close
to rivers in order to avoid floods. On the other hand, a river
might be necessary for transportation or to avoid high costs
for cooling water. In green field projects, unacceptable risks
need to be avoided during planning. Practicable risks should
be managed by appropriate risk strategies. Acceptable risks do
not require special strategies but should be covered by
insurance policies. In brown field planning, strategy
development is more challenging. If unacceptable but
avoidable risks exist, green flied strategies are applicable.
Nevertheless, in brown field planning identified risks are
often hard to avoid. This results from the limited degrees of
freedom in such cases. Factories have to cope with
unacceptable risks by adapting their factory elements.
5. Industrial application
In the years 2002 and 2013 there were 2 “flood of the
century” in middle Europe with huge destructions in the
German federal state of Saxony. Many companies were
affected within a short period of time. If the approach were
taken into account, companies would have strategies to handle
the second flood or they would have relocated their factories
to safer places. Nevertheless the approach is not a
methodology to predict occurrence of effects of climate
change. It is developed to identify and categorize risk in
LC phase
Factory element Effect
Land
Bulding
Process
…
Generalplanning
Detailedplanning
Implementation
Operation
Shutdown
Precipitation
Temperature wave
Floods
Probability of occurrence
0.01 0.01 0.05 0.01
0.25 0.7 1 0.25
0.1 0.15 0.1 1
0.01
0.25
1
Damage
negligible
critical
moderate
catastrophic
Probability
Often
Likely
Occasionally
Conceivable
Not likely
Inconceivable
Risk
Precipitation
Impact on factory LC element
Unacceptable risk
ALARP risk
Acceptable risk
342 U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342
structured way. The goal is the definition of robust strategies
to manage negative effects of the climate change.
A conceivable case study is a medium-sized company of
the metal processing industry is located in flooding area of a
river. The approach can be utilized to identify and evaluated
the risk for the factory. For example the flooding (estimated
probability of 0.1) would destroy power supply (factory life
cycle element operation/building) that has high cost for
rebuilding (unacceptable risk). A measure of the strategy is
usage of waterproofed equipment and the emergency
shutdown. Another possible strategy is the cooperation with
local government and other companies to build a dam.
6. Conclusion
The approach shows that the consideration of the effects of
the climate chance is very complex. The approach is a method
that takes all relevant factory elements and life cycle phases
into account in a very systematic way. Within the six steps of
the approach, the analysis is getting more and more detailed
and focused on relevant aspects. It starts with a
comprehensive view on the total factory life cycle and its
elements. Afterwards, the probability of occurrence and the
level of damage for all elements and all effects allow a
classification of risks. All elements are evaluated and an
assignment to three risk classes gives a prioritization. For the
high risk strategies need to be developed by using factory
planning. Finally, the value of the factory life cycle can be
preserved, because planning activities can be evaluated.
Hence, the approach still requires managers and factory
planning engineers that have the awareness and knowledge
about the effects of climate change as well as competences to
develop measures according to the strategies. Therefore, the
qualification and education of engineers needs to be adapted
to the described situation.
Actual, the implementation of the approach is prepared for
application in companies.
References
[1] Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Climate Change
2007: Synthesis Report. Valencia 2007.
[2] Richtlinie Verein Deutscher Ingenieure V. D. I. 5200. Fabrikplanung.
Planungsvorgehen. Factory planning. Planning procedure. Düsseldorf:
Verein Deutscher Ingenieure VDI; 2009. In German.
[3] Dombrowski U, Quack, S, Schulze S, 2008. Development of a
Continuous Factory Improvement Process for a Sustainable Production.
Proceedings of International Conference on Sustainable Product
Development and Life Cycle Engineering 2008, Basan, Korea.
[4] Dombrowski U, Quack S, Schulze S. Nachnutzung und Revitalisierung
von Fabriken. Re-utilisation and revitalisation of factories. In: ZWF Vol.
7/8, Munich: Carl Hanser; 2006. p. 444-447. In German.
[5] Schenk M, Wirth S. Fabrikplanung und Fabrikbetrieb: Methoden für die
wandlungsfähige und vernetzte Fabrik. Factory planning and factory
management: Methods for an adaptable and networked factory. Berlin-
Heidelberg: Springer; 2006. In German.
[6] Wiendahl HP, Reichardt J, Nyhuis P. Handbuch Fabrikplanung. Manual
for factory planning. München: Hanser; 2009. In German.
[7] Grundig, CG. Fabrikplanung. Factory planning. 3rd ed. Munich: Carl
Hanser; 2009. In German.
[8] Dombrowski U, Ernst S, Evers M. Employee Participation for Increasing
Energy Efficiency in Factory Operations. In: Zaeh M, editor. Enabling
Manufacturing Competitiveness and Economic Sustainability.
Heidelberg: Springer; 2014. p. 279-284.
[9] Müller E, Engelmann J, Löffler T, Strauch J. Energieeffiziente Fabriken
planen und betreiben. Planning and operating of energy-efficient
factories. Berlin: Springer; 2009. In German.
[10] Re Munich; Rück Münchener. Topics Geo–Jahresrückblick
Naturkatastrophen 2012. Topics Geo Natural Catastrophes 2012. Edition
Wissen. Munich; 2013. In German.
[11] Ding Y, Griggs DJ, et al. Climate change 2001: the scientific basis.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2001.
[12] Alcamo J, Olesen, JE. Life in Europe under climate change. Malden.
Wiley-Blackwell 2012.
[13] Mastrandrea, M. D.; Schneider, Stephen H.: Preparing for climate
change. Cambridge. Boston Review 2010
[14] Archer, D.: Global warming - Understanding the forecast. Malden:
Wiley-Blackwell; 2012.
[15] Günther E. Klimawandel und Resilience Management - Interdisziplinäre
Konzeption eines entscheidungsorientierten Ansatzes. Climate change and
resilience management - interdisciplinary conception of a decision-
oriented approach. Wiesbaden: Gabler Verlag; 2009. In German.
[16] Gausemeier J, Fink A, Schlake O. Szenario-Management – Planen und
Führen mit Szenarien. Scenario management – scenario planning and
guiding. 2. Ed. Munich: Carl Hanser; 1996. In German.
[17] Schubert K. Risk matrix. Safety Management. Hamburg: VBG; 2009.
[18] Igor Linkov I, Bridges TS. Climate. Global Change and Local
Adaptation. Dordrecht: Springer; 2011.
[19] Cameron IT, Raman R. Process Systems Risk Management. Amsterdam:
Elesevier; 2005.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Strategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning Resilience
Strategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning ResilienceStrategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning Resilience
Strategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning ResilienceRavenskirk Llp
 
Modelos toyota hilux 2016
Modelos toyota hilux 2016Modelos toyota hilux 2016
Modelos toyota hilux 2016gonzalezmaria21
 
Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...
Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...
Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...Наталья Валишева
 
Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...
Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...
Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...Stanleylucas
 
Slow news 75 - Buona informazione - Demo
Slow news 75 - Buona informazione - DemoSlow news 75 - Buona informazione - Demo
Slow news 75 - Buona informazione - DemoAlberto Puliafito
 
Analysis of 10 album covers
Analysis of 10 album coversAnalysis of 10 album covers
Analysis of 10 album coversTomspratley
 
Hack4dk presentation
Hack4dk presentationHack4dk presentation
Hack4dk presentationKevin Simper
 
Fit bit flex (sales)
Fit bit flex (sales)Fit bit flex (sales)
Fit bit flex (sales)hazelkrc
 
El proceso de búsqueda
El proceso de búsquedaEl proceso de búsqueda
El proceso de búsquedathekes salud
 
R065 0312 Hob Limburg Zuid
R065 0312 Hob Limburg ZuidR065 0312 Hob Limburg Zuid
R065 0312 Hob Limburg Zuidmanagerbob
 
Lean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир Канин
Lean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир КанинLean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир Канин
Lean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир КанинLPgenerator
 
Grammar plural of nouns
Grammar  plural of nounsGrammar  plural of nouns
Grammar plural of nounsmarcilliorules
 
Estructura del primer informe
Estructura del primer informeEstructura del primer informe
Estructura del primer informeLismirabal
 
Waar open je winkels?
Waar open je winkels?Waar open je winkels?
Waar open je winkels?louwris
 
Informació per als pares i mares
Informació per als pares i maresInformació per als pares i mares
Informació per als pares i maresceipelspins
 
Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...
Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...
Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...Jerónimo Trebucq
 
Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...
Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...
Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...Cristina GAONA
 
Step by step andrea warzel
Step by step  andrea warzelStep by step  andrea warzel
Step by step andrea warzelandreawarzel
 

Viewers also liked (19)

Strategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning Resilience
Strategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning ResilienceStrategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning Resilience
Strategy 2015 - Human Capital - Legacy and Planning Resilience
 
Modelos toyota hilux 2016
Modelos toyota hilux 2016Modelos toyota hilux 2016
Modelos toyota hilux 2016
 
Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...
Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...
Новые социокультурные практики муниципальных библиотек г. Ижевска в работе с ...
 
Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...
Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...
Haiti: Résultats de l'election du secteur Droits humains pour élire leur délè...
 
Slow news 75 - Buona informazione - Demo
Slow news 75 - Buona informazione - DemoSlow news 75 - Buona informazione - Demo
Slow news 75 - Buona informazione - Demo
 
Analysis of 10 album covers
Analysis of 10 album coversAnalysis of 10 album covers
Analysis of 10 album covers
 
Hack4dk presentation
Hack4dk presentationHack4dk presentation
Hack4dk presentation
 
Fit bit flex (sales)
Fit bit flex (sales)Fit bit flex (sales)
Fit bit flex (sales)
 
El proceso de búsqueda
El proceso de búsquedaEl proceso de búsqueda
El proceso de búsqueda
 
R065 0312 Hob Limburg Zuid
R065 0312 Hob Limburg ZuidR065 0312 Hob Limburg Zuid
R065 0312 Hob Limburg Zuid
 
Lean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир Канин
Lean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир КанинLean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир Канин
Lean Startup Russia 2015. Владимир Канин
 
Royex_Gen2_broschure_A3_web
Royex_Gen2_broschure_A3_webRoyex_Gen2_broschure_A3_web
Royex_Gen2_broschure_A3_web
 
Grammar plural of nouns
Grammar  plural of nounsGrammar  plural of nouns
Grammar plural of nouns
 
Estructura del primer informe
Estructura del primer informeEstructura del primer informe
Estructura del primer informe
 
Waar open je winkels?
Waar open je winkels?Waar open je winkels?
Waar open je winkels?
 
Informació per als pares i mares
Informació per als pares i maresInformació per als pares i mares
Informació per als pares i mares
 
Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...
Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...
Influencia de la ampliación del requerimiento fiscal en la integración con ju...
 
Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...
Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...
Taller redes sociales: Marca Profesional YO.2.0 18 mayo Teatro Principal Burg...
 
Step by step andrea warzel
Step by step  andrea warzelStep by step  andrea warzel
Step by step andrea warzel
 

Similar to Factory and Climate Change

التصنيع الاضافي
التصنيع الاضافيالتصنيع الاضافي
التصنيع الاضافيZainab Sattar
 
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product designLife cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product designeSAT Publishing House
 
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product designLife cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product designeSAT Publishing House
 
Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...
Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...
Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...IRJET Journal
 
A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...
A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...
A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...IRJET Journal
 
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial BuildingsIRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial BuildingsIRJET Journal
 
Family mould design for quality levers
Family mould design for quality leversFamily mould design for quality levers
Family mould design for quality leverseSAT Publishing House
 
Effects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable Buildings
Effects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable BuildingsEffects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable Buildings
Effects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable BuildingsDr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Cu31420423
Cu31420423Cu31420423
Cu31420423IJMER
 
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) ConceptIRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) ConceptIRJET Journal
 
Project proposal Research.pptx
Project proposal Research.pptxProject proposal Research.pptx
Project proposal Research.pptxDorjiWangchuk67
 
Green Building and Technology Unit 3
Green Building and Technology Unit 3Green Building and Technology Unit 3
Green Building and Technology Unit 3Chaitanya Nagare
 
01 Design of chemical processes Week 1.pptx
01 Design of chemical processes  Week 1.pptx01 Design of chemical processes  Week 1.pptx
01 Design of chemical processes Week 1.pptxDr. Rashmi Walvekar
 
Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19
Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19
Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19vivatechijri
 
1347 notes ii_ppe_304
1347 notes ii_ppe_3041347 notes ii_ppe_304
1347 notes ii_ppe_304kriti201
 
Lec 1 intro to design
Lec 1  intro to designLec 1  intro to design
Lec 1 intro to designadnanali309
 
LIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGS
LIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGSLIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGS
LIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGSSharan Thampi J
 
Miniplate and screw implant
Miniplate and screw implantMiniplate and screw implant
Miniplate and screw implantlan_jut
 
Environmental impact assessment
Environmental impact assessmentEnvironmental impact assessment
Environmental impact assessmentAkashRajeswaran
 

Similar to Factory and Climate Change (20)

التصنيع الاضافي
التصنيع الاضافيالتصنيع الاضافي
التصنيع الاضافي
 
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product designLife cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
 
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product designLife cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
Life cycle assessment and simulation enablers of sustainable product design
 
Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...
Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...
Reliability Study of Punching Shear Design of Column-Slab Connection accordin...
 
A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...
A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...
A STUDY OF LIFE CYCLE ENERGY ASSEMENT OF A MULTI-STORIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING...
 
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial BuildingsIRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
 
Family mould design for quality levers
Family mould design for quality leversFamily mould design for quality levers
Family mould design for quality levers
 
08 damiotti vu
08   damiotti vu08   damiotti vu
08 damiotti vu
 
Effects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable Buildings
Effects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable BuildingsEffects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable Buildings
Effects of Construction Materials to Achieve Sustainable Buildings
 
Cu31420423
Cu31420423Cu31420423
Cu31420423
 
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) ConceptIRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
 
Project proposal Research.pptx
Project proposal Research.pptxProject proposal Research.pptx
Project proposal Research.pptx
 
Green Building and Technology Unit 3
Green Building and Technology Unit 3Green Building and Technology Unit 3
Green Building and Technology Unit 3
 
01 Design of chemical processes Week 1.pptx
01 Design of chemical processes  Week 1.pptx01 Design of chemical processes  Week 1.pptx
01 Design of chemical processes Week 1.pptx
 
Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19
Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19
Current Trends in Product Development during COVID-19
 
1347 notes ii_ppe_304
1347 notes ii_ppe_3041347 notes ii_ppe_304
1347 notes ii_ppe_304
 
Lec 1 intro to design
Lec 1  intro to designLec 1  intro to design
Lec 1 intro to design
 
LIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGS
LIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGSLIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGS
LIFE CYCLE COST CALCULATION MODELS FOR BUILDINGS
 
Miniplate and screw implant
Miniplate and screw implantMiniplate and screw implant
Miniplate and screw implant
 
Environmental impact assessment
Environmental impact assessmentEnvironmental impact assessment
Environmental impact assessment
 

More from Ravenskirk Llp

Electricity and Climate Change
Electricity and Climate ChangeElectricity and Climate Change
Electricity and Climate ChangeRavenskirk Llp
 
Preface University of Vienna
Preface   University of ViennaPreface   University of Vienna
Preface University of ViennaRavenskirk Llp
 
The Core of Design Thinking
The Core of Design ThinkingThe Core of Design Thinking
The Core of Design ThinkingRavenskirk Llp
 
Speech The Limits of Law
Speech The Limits of LawSpeech The Limits of Law
Speech The Limits of LawRavenskirk Llp
 
The basis of Stable State Governance
The basis of Stable State GovernanceThe basis of Stable State Governance
The basis of Stable State GovernanceRavenskirk Llp
 
London Leadership Partnership (2)
London Leadership Partnership (2)London Leadership Partnership (2)
London Leadership Partnership (2)Ravenskirk Llp
 
Association of British Insurers and Lloyds
Association of British Insurers and LloydsAssociation of British Insurers and Lloyds
Association of British Insurers and LloydsRavenskirk Llp
 

More from Ravenskirk Llp (12)

The Paris Match
The Paris MatchThe Paris Match
The Paris Match
 
Utility Policies
Utility PoliciesUtility Policies
Utility Policies
 
Electricity and Climate Change
Electricity and Climate ChangeElectricity and Climate Change
Electricity and Climate Change
 
Preface University of Vienna
Preface   University of ViennaPreface   University of Vienna
Preface University of Vienna
 
Data Swiss Re
Data Swiss ReData Swiss Re
Data Swiss Re
 
The Core of Design Thinking
The Core of Design ThinkingThe Core of Design Thinking
The Core of Design Thinking
 
Speech The Limits of Law
Speech The Limits of LawSpeech The Limits of Law
Speech The Limits of Law
 
The basis of Stable State Governance
The basis of Stable State GovernanceThe basis of Stable State Governance
The basis of Stable State Governance
 
Bar
BarBar
Bar
 
London Leadership Partnership (2)
London Leadership Partnership (2)London Leadership Partnership (2)
London Leadership Partnership (2)
 
Association of British Insurers and Lloyds
Association of British Insurers and LloydsAssociation of British Insurers and Lloyds
Association of British Insurers and Lloyds
 
czech (1)
czech (1)czech (1)
czech (1)
 

Recently uploaded

VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...Garima Khatri
 
Digamma - CertiCon Team Skills and Qualifications
Digamma - CertiCon Team Skills and QualificationsDigamma - CertiCon Team Skills and Qualifications
Digamma - CertiCon Team Skills and QualificationsMihajloManjak
 
Hauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhi
Hauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhiHauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhi
Hauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhiHot Call Girls In Sector 58 (Noida)
 
BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024AHOhOops1
 
UNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLES
UNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLESUNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLES
UNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLESDineshKumar4165
 
Vip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp Number
Vip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp NumberVip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp Number
Vip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp Numberkumarajju5765
 
Beautiful Vip Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Vip  Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /WhatsappsBeautiful Vip  Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Vip Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /Whatsappssapnasaifi408
 
꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...
꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...
꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...Hot Call Girls In Sector 58 (Noida)
 
UNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHER
UNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHERUNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHER
UNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHERunosafeads
 
UNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.ppt
UNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.pptUNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.ppt
UNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.pptDineshKumar4165
 
Dubai Call Girls Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Call Girls  Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In DubaiDubai Call Girls  Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Call Girls Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In Dubaikojalkojal131
 
John Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdf
John Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdfJohn Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdf
John Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdfExcavator
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCRsoniya singh
 
办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一
办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一
办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一mkfnjj
 
(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...
(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...
(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...Hot Call Girls In Sector 58 (Noida)
 
FULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | Noida
FULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | NoidaFULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | Noida
FULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | NoidaMalviyaNagarCallGirl
 
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
UNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptx
UNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptxUNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptx
UNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptxDineshKumar4165
 

Recently uploaded (20)

VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Thakur village Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash ...
 
Digamma - CertiCon Team Skills and Qualifications
Digamma - CertiCon Team Skills and QualificationsDigamma - CertiCon Team Skills and Qualifications
Digamma - CertiCon Team Skills and Qualifications
 
Hauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhi
Hauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhiHauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhi
Hauz Khas Call Girls ☎ 7042364481 independent Escorts Service in delhi
 
BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
BLUE VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
 
UNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLES
UNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLESUNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLES
UNIT-III-TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS REAR AXLES
 
Vip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp Number
Vip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp NumberVip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp Number
Vip Hot Call Girls 🫤 Mahipalpur ➡️ 9711199171 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Whatsapp Number
 
Beautiful Vip Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Vip  Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /WhatsappsBeautiful Vip  Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Vip Call Girls Punjabi Bagh 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
 
sauth delhi call girls in Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in  Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Servicesauth delhi call girls in  Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...
꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...
꧁ ୨⎯Call Girls In Ashok Vihar, New Delhi **✿❀7042364481❀✿**Escorts ServiCes C...
 
UNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHER
UNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHERUNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHER
UNOSAFE ELEVATOR PRIVATE LTD BANGALORE BROUCHER
 
UNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.ppt
UNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.pptUNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.ppt
UNIT-1-VEHICLE STRUCTURE AND ENGINES.ppt
 
Dubai Call Girls Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Call Girls  Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In DubaiDubai Call Girls  Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Call Girls Size E6 (O525547819) Call Girls In Dubai
 
John Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdf
John Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdfJohn Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdf
John Deere 200lc Excavator Operation And Tests Repair Manual.pdf
 
Call Girls in Shri Niwas Puri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953056974🔝
Call Girls in  Shri Niwas Puri  Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953056974🔝Call Girls in  Shri Niwas Puri  Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953056974🔝
Call Girls in Shri Niwas Puri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953056974🔝
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
 
办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一
办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一
办理埃默里大学毕业证Emory毕业证原版一比一
 
(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...
(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...
(COD) ̄Young Call Girls In Dwarka , New Delhi꧁❤ 7042364481❤꧂ Escorts Service i...
 
FULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | Noida
FULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | NoidaFULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | Noida
FULL ENJOY - 9953040155 Call Girls in Sector 61 | Noida
 
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
 
UNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptx
UNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptxUNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptx
UNIT-V-ELECTRIC AND HYBRID VEHICLES.pptx
 

Factory and Climate Change

  • 1. Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342 Available online at www.sciencedirect.com 2212-8271 © 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering in the person of the Conference Chair Prof. Terje K. Lien doi:10.1016/j.procir.2014.06.012 ScienceDirect 21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering Effects of climate change on factory life cycle U. Dombrowskia , S. Ernsta * a Technische Universität Braunschweig, Institute for Advanced Industrial Management, Langer Kamp 19, 38106 Braunschweig, Germany * Corresponding author. Tel.: 0049-531-391-2703; fax: 0049-531-391-2703. E-mail address: stefan.ernst@tu-bs.de Abstract Climate change and global warming have negative consequences for humans and nature. While many research activities analyze the effects of industrial production on global warming and aim to develop actions using rare resources more efficiently and reducing CO2-emission, the effects of climate change on industrial production is rarely discussed. Hence, manufacturing companies are considered in research as cause of climate change and not as affected by climate change. Thus, there is no systematic consideration of effects of climate change in factory planning. This leads to expensive adaptions within factory life cycle. For this reason the paper identifies ecological, economical and social changes caused by the climate change. These changes are analyzed on their effects on factories and prioritized according to their risk for the company. Subsequently, the identified changes are matched to different functions of factory planning. The matching allows developing planning-related and preventive strategy to cope with changes during factory life cycle. © 2014 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering in the person of the Conference Chair Prof. Terje K. Lien. Keywords: Factory Life Cycle; Climate Change; Global Warming; Factory Planning; Advanced Industrial Management 1. Introduction According to the climate policy of the United Nations, global warming should be limited up to two degrees compared to the level before the industrialization. The consequences of this are intensive changes in conditions of living. Several research studies forecast that this target can be only achieved by drastic reduction of CO2 emission within a small time frame [1]. Most research activities try to analyze the effects of industrial production on global warming and aim to develop actions using rare resources more efficiently and reducing CO2 emission (e.g. Kyoto Protocol, EU Emissions Trading Scheme). However, the reversion of this argument how climate change will affect industrial production is rarely discussed. For this reason, the paper introduces ecologic, economic as well as social changes caused by the climate change. This paper describes a solution how to deal with these impacts by using a 6-step-approach. The approach is a systematic way to derive specific risk out of the impacts of the climate change. The changes are analyzed concerning to their effects on factory elements and factory life cycle phases. These effects are evaluated by the probability of occurrence and the damage level. Subsequently, the identified probability and damage level are determining risk levels, which are prioritizing the risk of effects on different factory life cycle elements. According to the risk type, a strategy can be developed that considers targeted measures for specific risks. 2. Factory Planning 2.1. Factory Planning and Factory Life Cycle Factory planning is defined as a systematic, object-oriented process to design a factory. It is structured into a sequence of seven phases with its own methods and tools (see figure 1) [2]. There are different factory planning processes, e.g. VDI planning process or the IFU reference model for the factory life cycle. The IFU approach has a wider scope than the VDI planning process, because it concludes the factory life cycle phases. The factory planning starts with the enterprise analysis and ends with the shutdown, which is the end of © 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 21st CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering in the person of the Conference Chair Prof. Terje K. Lien
  • 2. 338 U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342 production. It is often necessary to adapt and to tune the factory to improve performance of the factory. These iterations are also included in the reference model [3]. In phase 1 enterprise analysis, the objectives in factory planning are deduced from the enterprise objectives and are specified according to the specific requirements of the factory planning project. The project team has to gather all required information during the as-is-analysis and adapt the information for the following phases. The goal is a definition of all tasks in the project of factory planning. At the end of the first phase, the project is evaluated and the management makes the decision whether the factory planning will continue. The general planning can be seen as the core task of the factory planning process, because the whole factory is designed (phase 2). It starts with the location finding. After the structure planning and dimensioning, an ideal layout is prepared. Based on this ideal layout different layout variants are generated which are considering restrictions. Also, the material flow and the material handling are planned. These variants are evaluated according to the defined objectives. The best variant is the input for the next phase, detailed planning (phase 3). Within the detailed planning, the selected variant is developed to a level of maturity for the implementation. The results are a detailed description and the visualization of all factory elements. The following phase is the implementation (phase 4) and the results of previous phases are put into action the first time. This phase also includes implementation controlling (monitoring, coordination and documentation of the realization process) and the production ramp up. The planning activities are performed in teamwork that is controlled by project management methods. The entire planning process is supported by project management [2,3]. Operation (phase 5) has the longest duration of all life cycle phases. The task of the factory planner does not end with the implementation because there are still smaller improvements steps or ramp ups of new products. The task is to assure the capability and efficiency of the factory. Tuning enables the provision of the facilities with the required resources at the designated place of installation. Adjustment is the displacement or expansion of the factory. The shutdown of the factory is the end of factory life. The factory becomes industrial wasteland or it may be re-utilized or revitalized for future users’ needs [4]. Due to revitalization, the planning process starts again [3]. The IFU reference model is focusing on life cycle phases. Another focus on factory life cycle is present utilization value of the different levels of factories as shown in figure 2. According to the different lifetime of technological products, processes, building and land use, the life cycle and the present utilization value differs. The value of the land use is almost constant in the long-term. Only pollution like oil pollution of the ground has a negative influence on the value. The connections between the elements of the factory life cycle are based on following [5]: • Product: According to customers demand, the product life cycle is getting shorter. • Process: This element is influencing the production system. The process life cycle is planned for one or more product life cycles. It is adapted to the product life cycle. • Building: The building equipment is based on product, process and production system life cycles. It needs to be adapted to changes in production system life cycles. • Land use: The land use life cycle is oriented on the reuse of redeveloped areas with existing infrastructure (area recycling) Fig. 1. Reference model for factory life cycle Enterprise analysis • Target planning • As-is analysis • Evaluation and decision General planning • Location finding • Master layout planning • Premises structure planning • Organisation of production • Material flow and materials handling • Factory layout Detailed planning • Detailed planning of production • Warehouse and transport planning • Office-area layout Implementation Shutdown Operation Industrial wasteland Re-utilisation and revitalisation 1 2 3 4 5 6 B Tuning and adaption A Environmentally compatible factory planning Computersupportin factoryplanning Versatile design of production systems to planning stages1 6
  • 3. 339U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342 Fig. 2. Utility value of different life cycles. [5] 2.2. Research gap The factory life cycle is determined by the product and process life cycle and requires changeability of the factory as well as a synchronization of the different life cycles. The solutions are changeability and the improvement of the flexibility of life cycles (to synchronize them) [5]. This is a field of past and present research in factory planning. But there is a lack of research about climate change and factory planning. Some of the conventional factory planning approaches in research are supposing the climate for a factory location as static, so that they consider climate for dimensioning the air conditioning [5-7]. Others try to reduce the negative impact of the factories on the climate change by reducing CO2 emissions [8,9]. The duration of the factory life cycle shows a need for the consideration of long-term trends like climate change. Greenfield factory planning projects should take changing climate conditions into account. Nevertheless the majority of factories were build-up years or decades ago. Hence, the effects of climate change were not as intensive as they are today. For this reason, the next chapter describes climate change and its effects on factories. 3. Climate Change and its effects This paper will not discuss if global warming is manmade or not, it discusses the effects of global warming on factories. 3.1. Theory of climate change Since the industrialization began, humanity started to pollute a large amount of CO2 into the atmosphere, which was stored in fossil energy sources, like coal. The consequence is an increase of CO2-amount in the air from 280 ppm in the year 1850 to 367 ppm in 2000. This is a raise of 31 percent within 110 years. The result of CO2 is that sunrays, which are reflected by earth’s surface, are reflected again. The consequence is a higher temperature in the atmosphere. The so called natural greenhouse effect is strengthened due to the higher manmade amount of CO2 (anthropogenic greenhouse effect). According to that, the average temperature is rising. The higher average temperature is just one effect of the changing climate. The climate change causes health, agriculture, forests, water resources, coastal areas or Fig. 3. Natural disasters in Germany 1970 to 2012 [10]. biodiversity [1]. Other serious effects like the sea level rise and the higher frequency of extreme weather. The increasing frequency of extreme weather events can be shown by the number of natural disasters in Germany (see figure 3). The total number of disasters is classified in hydrological disasters (e.g. floods, landslide), metrological disasters (e.g. storms) and climatologically disasters (e.g. heat/cold wave, drought, forest fire) and geophysical disasters. Compared to the 1970s, there is a significant increase in the first three types of disasters which are related to climate change [10]. Except the disasters, there are other effects like rising or falling precipitation amounts, changing average temperature, changes in agriculture, etc [11]. Not all changes have an impact on the factory. The relevant effects are described below. 3.2. Effects of climate change on factories The economy of industrial nations is still based on manufacturing companies. The building envelope of the factory is a place for value adding activities and there are countless factories all over the world. The changing climate conditions are affecting these factories in different ways. Especially extreme weather events have an effect on factories. For example, tornados can blow away roofs or the snow load can lead to a collapse of the factory with the likely result of seriously injured or dead victims. These events need to be taken into account. The effects of climate change were identified by a literature analysis (e.g. [1,12-15]) and selected by an expert evaluation according to their relevance for the factory. The effects can be clustered into three groups: ecological, economical and social effects. Ecological effects are describing the changes in the environment and the climate conditions. Economical effects are consequences on business and supply chains derived from the ecological effects. Thirdly, social effects are chances like new governmental restrictions, immigration or customer behavior. The following effects will be considered in further analysis: Ecological effects • Amount of precipitation: heavy rains, annual amount, droughts • Temperature curve: cold/ heat waves • Storm • Floods due to heavy rains and sea level rise utilityvalue lifetime I. construction period and initial investment II. physical and moral impairment III. modernization IV. renovation V.Decay and demolition A B C D Productlifecycle Process lifecycle Building lifecycle Land use cycle A B C D 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 Numberofnaturalcatastrophes geophysical events (earthquake, tsunami, volcanic eruption) meteorological events (storm) hydrological events (floodings, mass movements) climatological events (extremes in temperature, drought, forest fire) Trend
  • 4. 340 U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342 Economical effects • Higher susceptibility of a collapse of global supply chains due to higher frequency of extreme weather events • Higher costs for prevention activities • Higher prices for insurance Social effects • Refugees due to deteriorate climate conditions (e.g. sea life rise is flooding coastal areas in developing countries) • Arising awareness of customers for climate change leads to the need for climate friendly production • CO2-limitation • Prohibition of materials with a negative effect on climate (e.g. CFC ban) Depending on local conditions and the characteristic of the factory, the intensity of each effect is varying and additional effects may need to be considered. For example, if water resources get scarce the competition between industry, private households and agriculture for water is getting harder. This is influencing water-intensive industries, like chemical industry or power plants. This may result in blackouts in summer which is affecting other branches. 4. Approach The effects of climate change need to be taken into account within all phases of the factory planning process. Also the approach needs to be adaptable to be applicable in practice. Hence, the approach is a wide general approach that can be adapted to a suitable level of detail. It consists of 6 steps which provides a systematic development of strategies and supports the conservation of the factory’s value. The first step determines the field of all possible applications by defining the level of detail and describing all factory life cycle elements. Afterwards, the field is limited to the relevant elements in the second step. During the third step, probabilities of occurrence of the effects of climate change are assessed for each factory element and life cycle phase. Then, the level of damage is determined for each combination in the fourth step. Step 5 contains the derivation of different risk levels which are visualized and classified in a risk portfolio. Finally, strategies are developed according to the risk level. Each step is described in detail in the following. 4.1. Step 1: Determination of the field of application The first step is the determination of all possible factory life cycle elements that can be considered in the following analysis. A factory life cycle element can be characterized by the dimensions ‘factory element’ and ‘life cycle phase’. Especially, the factory elements have a broad range of detailing. As described in paragraph 2.1, there are the four main factory elements product, process, building and land. If required, these elements can be detailed to smaller pieces. The second dimension is the ‘life cycle phase’. This dimension can be divided according to the six life cycle phases of IFU reference model. The result of the first step is the definition of a matrix of the factory life cycle elements (see figure 4a). The Fig. 4. a) Step 1: Matrix with factory life cycle elements. b) Step 2: Selection of relevant elements. n columns correspond with all possible factory life cycle phases (or sub-phases). There are m rows for each factory element. 4.2. Step 2: Selection of relevant factory life cycle elements The further approach would get too complex, if all elements of the matrix would be considered in further analysis. Therefore, the relevant parts are selected by a comprehensive analysis or by a company-specific decision of the management. The comprehensive analysis consists of an impact matrix and a consistency matrix. These techniques support the systematic derivation of interrelations between different elements that are relevant for the selection [16]. Hence, specific factory life cycle elements, whole phases or factory elements that are not relevant can be excluded. For example the factory element ‘product’ may be not relevant for climate change because its life cycle time is rather short. Also, the life cycle phase ‘enterprise analysis’ is supposed to be not relevant for the company analysis of the climate change. Hence, parameters of the first column and the lowest row can be deleted from the matrix (see figure 4b). 4.3. Step 3: Occurrence of effects of climate change The effects of climate change are analyzed in step 3. A number of main effects are listed in paragraph 3.2. If additional effects influence the factory life cycle elements, they can be added. Each effect is considered in the analysis by a third dimension. Consequently, the matrix is expanded to a cube. Each field of the cube represents the impact of an effect of climate change of a factory life cycle element. The impact can be described with the probability of occurrence of an effect within the factory life cycle for a specific factory location. Figure 5 shows a cube whose fields contain the probability of occurrence which is stated between 0 and 1. From this it follows that a probability of 1 indicates that the effect takes place every year at least once and a probability of 0.3 that it occurs in three of ten years. The probabilities of occurrence are divided into the following six categories [17]: • Inconceivable (probability of <0.02) • Not likely (probability of 0.02 to <0.1) • Conceivable (probability of 0.1 to <0.2) a) Example: step 1 b) Example: step 2 LC phase Factory element Land Bulding Process Product Enterpriseanalysis Generalplanning Detailedplanning Implementation Operation Shutdown Factory LC element LC phase Factory element Land Bulding Process Product Not relevant Enterpriseanalysis Generalplanning Detailedplanning Implementation Operation Shutdown LC – life cycle
  • 5. 341U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342 Fig. 5. Step 3: Three dimensions of probability cube (dummy data). • Occasionally (probability of 0.2 to <0.3) • Likely (probability of 0.3 to <0.8) • Often (probability of 0.8 to 1) According to the example, there is a probability of 1 that the amount of precipitation has a negative impact on building during implementation phase. The probability within the life cycle phase operation is between 0.2 and 0.3, because it is less likely that negative impacts occur. Finally, all fields in the cube have to be evaluated. 4.4. Step 4: Estimation of the damage level The forth step contains the estimation of the level of damage if the effect of climate change occurs. Each factory life cycle element gets assigned a level of damage for every effect. The following four levels are distinguished [18]: • Negligible: if the effect occurs, there will be no negative impact on the factory life cycle element. • Moderate: if the effect occurs, it has an impact on the factory life cycle element. Nevertheless, there is just a minor damage. • Critical: if the effect occurs, it will hurt the company very much so that it has a huge damage. But the effect will not be existence-threatening for the factory. • Catastrophic: A catastrophic damage has a big negative impact on the factory element; it is seriously existence- threatening for the factory. For example, the damage of a higher amount of precipitation has a very high damage on the factory operation, because the factory’s roof is leaky. Also the factory’s location is in a flooding area of a river with the result that flooding of the building is getting more likely. Hence, the level of damage is critical to catastrophic. 4.5. Step 5: Derivation of risk level The probability of occurrence and the level of damage can be combined to a risk portfolio that shows a specific risk for certain combinations. A reasonable tool for visualization this context is the risk portfolio shown in figure 6. One dimension of the matrix is the level of damage with the four categories of step 4. The other dimension is the probability of occurrence Fig. 6. Step 5: Risk portfolio with risk types. from step 3 which are clustered into six categories. Hence, the matrix has 24 fields which have a different importance for the factory. The field in the bottom left is representing low risk. On the very top right, there are the combinations with high risk. The risk portfolio with the example of precipitation is shown in figure 6. 4.6. Step 6: Strategy development If all potential risks are indentified and classified, the factory management should develop strategies to handle the risk. The risk types are [19]: 1. Unacceptable risk 2. “as low as reasonably practicable” risk 3. Acceptable risk Generally, all risks should be avoided. However, this is often impossible due to financial restrictions and conflicting goals. One the one hand, factories should not be located close to rivers in order to avoid floods. On the other hand, a river might be necessary for transportation or to avoid high costs for cooling water. In green field projects, unacceptable risks need to be avoided during planning. Practicable risks should be managed by appropriate risk strategies. Acceptable risks do not require special strategies but should be covered by insurance policies. In brown field planning, strategy development is more challenging. If unacceptable but avoidable risks exist, green flied strategies are applicable. Nevertheless, in brown field planning identified risks are often hard to avoid. This results from the limited degrees of freedom in such cases. Factories have to cope with unacceptable risks by adapting their factory elements. 5. Industrial application In the years 2002 and 2013 there were 2 “flood of the century” in middle Europe with huge destructions in the German federal state of Saxony. Many companies were affected within a short period of time. If the approach were taken into account, companies would have strategies to handle the second flood or they would have relocated their factories to safer places. Nevertheless the approach is not a methodology to predict occurrence of effects of climate change. It is developed to identify and categorize risk in LC phase Factory element Effect Land Bulding Process … Generalplanning Detailedplanning Implementation Operation Shutdown Precipitation Temperature wave Floods Probability of occurrence 0.01 0.01 0.05 0.01 0.25 0.7 1 0.25 0.1 0.15 0.1 1 0.01 0.25 1 Damage negligible critical moderate catastrophic Probability Often Likely Occasionally Conceivable Not likely Inconceivable Risk Precipitation Impact on factory LC element Unacceptable risk ALARP risk Acceptable risk
  • 6. 342 U. Dombrowski and S. Ernst / Procedia CIRP 15 (2014) 337 – 342 structured way. The goal is the definition of robust strategies to manage negative effects of the climate change. A conceivable case study is a medium-sized company of the metal processing industry is located in flooding area of a river. The approach can be utilized to identify and evaluated the risk for the factory. For example the flooding (estimated probability of 0.1) would destroy power supply (factory life cycle element operation/building) that has high cost for rebuilding (unacceptable risk). A measure of the strategy is usage of waterproofed equipment and the emergency shutdown. Another possible strategy is the cooperation with local government and other companies to build a dam. 6. Conclusion The approach shows that the consideration of the effects of the climate chance is very complex. The approach is a method that takes all relevant factory elements and life cycle phases into account in a very systematic way. Within the six steps of the approach, the analysis is getting more and more detailed and focused on relevant aspects. It starts with a comprehensive view on the total factory life cycle and its elements. Afterwards, the probability of occurrence and the level of damage for all elements and all effects allow a classification of risks. All elements are evaluated and an assignment to three risk classes gives a prioritization. For the high risk strategies need to be developed by using factory planning. Finally, the value of the factory life cycle can be preserved, because planning activities can be evaluated. Hence, the approach still requires managers and factory planning engineers that have the awareness and knowledge about the effects of climate change as well as competences to develop measures according to the strategies. Therefore, the qualification and education of engineers needs to be adapted to the described situation. Actual, the implementation of the approach is prepared for application in companies. References [1] Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report. Valencia 2007. [2] Richtlinie Verein Deutscher Ingenieure V. D. I. 5200. Fabrikplanung. Planungsvorgehen. Factory planning. Planning procedure. Düsseldorf: Verein Deutscher Ingenieure VDI; 2009. In German. [3] Dombrowski U, Quack, S, Schulze S, 2008. Development of a Continuous Factory Improvement Process for a Sustainable Production. Proceedings of International Conference on Sustainable Product Development and Life Cycle Engineering 2008, Basan, Korea. [4] Dombrowski U, Quack S, Schulze S. Nachnutzung und Revitalisierung von Fabriken. Re-utilisation and revitalisation of factories. In: ZWF Vol. 7/8, Munich: Carl Hanser; 2006. p. 444-447. In German. [5] Schenk M, Wirth S. Fabrikplanung und Fabrikbetrieb: Methoden für die wandlungsfähige und vernetzte Fabrik. Factory planning and factory management: Methods for an adaptable and networked factory. Berlin- Heidelberg: Springer; 2006. In German. [6] Wiendahl HP, Reichardt J, Nyhuis P. Handbuch Fabrikplanung. Manual for factory planning. München: Hanser; 2009. In German. [7] Grundig, CG. Fabrikplanung. Factory planning. 3rd ed. Munich: Carl Hanser; 2009. In German. [8] Dombrowski U, Ernst S, Evers M. Employee Participation for Increasing Energy Efficiency in Factory Operations. In: Zaeh M, editor. Enabling Manufacturing Competitiveness and Economic Sustainability. Heidelberg: Springer; 2014. p. 279-284. [9] Müller E, Engelmann J, Löffler T, Strauch J. Energieeffiziente Fabriken planen und betreiben. Planning and operating of energy-efficient factories. Berlin: Springer; 2009. In German. [10] Re Munich; Rück Münchener. Topics Geo–Jahresrückblick Naturkatastrophen 2012. Topics Geo Natural Catastrophes 2012. Edition Wissen. Munich; 2013. In German. [11] Ding Y, Griggs DJ, et al. Climate change 2001: the scientific basis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2001. [12] Alcamo J, Olesen, JE. Life in Europe under climate change. Malden. Wiley-Blackwell 2012. [13] Mastrandrea, M. D.; Schneider, Stephen H.: Preparing for climate change. Cambridge. Boston Review 2010 [14] Archer, D.: Global warming - Understanding the forecast. Malden: Wiley-Blackwell; 2012. [15] Günther E. Klimawandel und Resilience Management - Interdisziplinäre Konzeption eines entscheidungsorientierten Ansatzes. Climate change and resilience management - interdisciplinary conception of a decision- oriented approach. Wiesbaden: Gabler Verlag; 2009. In German. [16] Gausemeier J, Fink A, Schlake O. Szenario-Management – Planen und Führen mit Szenarien. Scenario management – scenario planning and guiding. 2. Ed. Munich: Carl Hanser; 1996. In German. [17] Schubert K. Risk matrix. Safety Management. Hamburg: VBG; 2009. [18] Igor Linkov I, Bridges TS. Climate. Global Change and Local Adaptation. Dordrecht: Springer; 2011. [19] Cameron IT, Raman R. Process Systems Risk Management. Amsterdam: Elesevier; 2005.