full SEI 3, 2022.pdf

Science, Education and Innovations in the context of modern problems. Vol. 5. 2022, Issue 3, Mohan Selvareju
p. 1 IMCRA, June, Baku, Azerbaijan
NO PLASTIC BAGS POLICY REVIVES A
DISSATISFACTION BEHAVIOUR AND
CULTURE CHANGE AMONG THE
MALASIYAN RETAIL CUSTOMER1
Mohan Selvaraju
1
, and Charles Ramendran SPR
2
, Vimala Kadiresan
3
,
Ooi Cheau Pian4, Khairul Rizuan Sudiman
5
1, 2, 4 and 5
Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman
3
Help University, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Abstract. Governments frequently sanction approaches to boost shoppers from practices with negative
externalities to the detriment of purchaser comfort. Understanding the nonmonetary costs, shoppers face
suggestions for social welfare assessment and strategy structure; nevertheless, measuring these costs is not
possible. The objective of this investigation is to analyse the customer’s expectation and social changes towards
no plastic bag policy. In this research, the researcher has taken an approach to the disappointment level among
the consumers because of no plastics sack policy. A quantitative methodology being utilises to get the
information through review from 400 retail customers who visit the retail outlets. The outcome uncovered that
all the factors in this investigation show a tremendous relationship towards the client disappointment towards no
plastic pack policy. These expands the estimation of the findings and is exceptionally applicable to overcoming
any barrier in the process of developing Malaysian retail business.
Keywords: Customer Dissatisfaction, Inconvenience, Customers Behavior Change, Extra cost, deprived the
Rights of the Customer.
1.0 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
In the past decade, the world has seen a significant increase in plastic bag policies aimed at reducing plastic bag
consumption, specifically through bans and pricing mechanisms. Amidst the range of responses towards the
global plastic bag problem, more than half of the global policies are bans, while the remainders are primarily
pricing mechanisms together with an ad hoc collection of voluntary agreements and information campaigns
(Nielsen et al. 2019). As a consequence, over the last ten years, a remarkable shift in policies associated with
plastic carrier bags has taken place in different countries across the world. Many governments have started to
ban or to put restrictions on the sale or free distribution of plastic carrier bags in countries all over the world
(Dikgang, Lieman & Visser, 2012). When first invented, plastic carryout bags were considered quite the
engineering feat: “a waterproof, durable, featherweight packet capable of holding more than a thousand times its
weight” (Freinkel, 2011). However, the characteristics that make plastic bags convenient also make them costly
to the environment and to municipalities trying to keep their streets and waterways clean.
Customers are the significant players for every business such as the retail store, and hypermarket. During the
‘No Plastics Bags’ campaign, customers are obliged to bring their recyclable plastic bags, but reportedly people
who in Malaysia lack such a practice in daily life (Kuppusamy & Gharleghi, 2015). Therefore, whether
consumers are dissatisfied with the merchants because they find plastic bags are not provided when they pay the
bill for many groceries at the counter. This study also aims to examine no plastics bags policy could revive a
dissatisfaction behaviour and culture change among the Malaysian retail customer. Malaysia produces an
average of 19,000 solid wastes each year, with plastic waste accounting for 24% of the total solid waste
1
Received: FEB 26,2022 / Accepted: APR 12, 2022 / Published: MAY 18: 2022

(Shahariah, Mhd., Bashirah & Mohd, 2018). In the year 2011, the government of Malaysia had started to
implement no plastic bags policy to discourage and stop people using plastic bags for carrying items purchased
from retail or shopping places, to make the policies more severe, the government had set another policy saying
that customers must be charged a levy of RM0.20 when requesting a new plastic bag, it was directly adding the
extra cost to retail customers. The latter want to own plastic bags after purchasing from local places (Shahariah,
Mhd. Bashirah & Mohd, 2018).
So that the government of Malaysia wishes to set the policy to awake those people in the country can also
understanding the damage and harm that brought by the pollution made by plastic bags (Kuppusamy &
Gharleghi, 2015). Plastic bags are indispensable companions for many consumers due to their low cost,
durability, and versatility (Nielsen, Holmberg & Stripple, 2019). Many retailer businesses use plastics bags
regularly since it is cheap, light but able to carry many items and clean as a first time use them (Shahariah,
Mhd., Bashirah & Mohd, 2018). Most of the consumer may think to have free plastics bags is their right as well
as shopping convenience and reused as the purpose of trash bags or storage (Irina, Ahamad, & Omar, 2013;
Kamaruddin & Yusuf, 2012),
TABLE 1.1: Waste Estimates for 2010: For the Top 20 Countries ranked by Mass of Mismanaged Plastic
Waste (in units of millions of metric tons per year)
Source: Jambeck et al. 2015
According to Jambeck, Geyer, Wilcox, Siegler, Perryman and Andrady (2015), Malaysia has the eighth-worst
plastic waste in the world. Based on table 1.1, it showed that between 140,000 and 370,000 tons of plastic waste
might be washed into the ocean in Malaysia in 2010 (Jambeck et al. 2015). As we have known, the materials for
marking plastics bag is polyethylene or polyethene film. However, polyethene is hard and complicated for
degradation (Kamaruddin & Yusuf, 2010). Massively used plastic bags without proper disposal, it could lead to
the ecosystem and the natural environment suffers long-term damage.

TABLE 1.2: Per Capita Plastic Waste by Country
From table 1.2, it displayed that the third country to rank as plastic waste in Malaysia, where the average person
uses 0.198 kg of plastic per day (Hofmann, 2019). After the plastics bags have been used, they end up in
landfills and bring a heavy-duty to the other resources where plastics bags need about 400 to 1000 years to
decompose when it was put into landfills (Musa, Hayes, Bradley, Clayson, & Gillibrand, 2013). People are
using plastic bags as a purpose of carrying goods after making purchases from local places already being a
culture in Malaysia. In the mind of customers, suppose that having plastic bags for them to carry their purchases
items is including in the charges of buying products from the market. According to Asmuni (2018), even that
some of the retailers had tried to provide paper bags to replace plastic bags for customers, it did not help too
much to let consumers raising their acceptance toward the no plastic bag policy.
The reason is that the acceptance of plastic bags from Malaysian retail customers are still massive due to the
costing low and also easy to get from the market compare with the paper bags. Also, Malaysian still unable to
accept the policy of plastic bags because they do not understand the importance of the implementation of this
policy (Richards & Zen, 2016). The restricted policy implemented by the government was reviving the
dissatisfaction of retail customers due to they had faced the problem of inconvenience and purchasing behaviour
are forcing them to be changed. The government of Malaysia was mostly focusing on the ways to reduce the
using of plastic bags. Still, they did not provide an efficient solution to solving the replacement problem of
plastic bags (Hashim, Abdullah & Takeshi, 2019). Therefore, the primary purpose of this study is to understand
the consumer's perspective on the "no plastic bags" policy and how it affects consumer buying behaviour.
Besides that, some of the research showed that the policy affected different demographics of consumers’
purchasing behaviour in terms of gender, age and others (Shahariah, Mhd. Bashirah & Mohd, 2018). In this
situation, we can say that the primary purpose of this study is to understand the consumer's perspective on the
"no plastic bags" policy and how it affects consumer buying behaviour. Moreover, find solutions to maintain
good customer relationships and achieve their maximum satisfaction. The government of Malaysia was mostly
focusing on the ways to reduce the using of plastic bags. Still, they did not provide an efficient solution to
solving the replacement problem of plastic bags (Hashim, Abdullah & Takeshi, 2019), it was also one of the
problems that reviving the dissatisfaction of retail customers toward no plastic bags policy.
Therefore, the dissatisfaction of retail customers had been revived due to the government did not provide any
efficient solution on the replacement of plastic bags, it will directly causing inconvenience of customers, they
even had to carry extra cost when preparing their eco-bags or requesting plastic bags from the local places
(Mortimer & Russell-Bennett, 2018). Various research studies relate more towards the environmental issue and
plastics usage and fails to deliberate the customers’ dissatisfaction towards the instance policy changes. Along
these lines, this study incorporates some particular targets to assist the exploration results and suggestion.
Initially, it distinguishes the resuscitating factors that trigger the dissatisfaction disposition practices. Next, it
grasps the effect level because of the no plastic strategy. Lastly, it examinations the effect results with this
policy implementation.
2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW
There have some articles that had investigated the topic of how no plastic bags policy was affecting customers
on their satisfaction and buying behaviour. The purchase behaviour changed of customers is one of the reasons

that making dissatisfaction happened since customers are forced to change their normal purchase behaviour, and
it is not their desire (Kuppusamy & Gharleghi, 2015). Besides, inconvenience during purchase is another reason
that is making dissatisfaction happened because the retail stores, hypermarkets, shopping centres and other
merchandise places had stopped providing the plastic bags for carrying goods (Saleh, Farzana & Jihad, 2019).
The extra cost that customers need to afford for the plastic bags also requests the other reason that revives the
dissatisfaction of customers toward the no plastic bags policy (Irina, Ahamad & Omar, 2013). Otherwise,
customers will also be feeling their rights had been deprived due to stop providing plastic bags from the
(Mortimer & Russell-Bennett, 2018). Customers expect full service when they shop because they have already
paid for things at the merchandise places (Lee, Hsu & Fu, 2014).
At the previous time, customers can get the service they want like getting plastic bags after paying the charges
of purchase. Still, after implemented the no plastic bags policy, the merchandise places stop providing plastic
bags to customers. Plastic bags are the most convenience carrying method of customers due to it is weightless to
carry but strong enough to carry bought items, clean when first use and customers no need to worry how to get
it. Customers’ dissatisfaction happened due to no plastics bag announcement by the retailers with immediate
effects and without any other alternatives. Furthermore, customers also felt that they have lost the customer’s
rights (Shahariah et al. 2018). These circumstances had made them getting inconvenience and more trouble
(Saidan, Ansour & Saidan, 2016). The circumstances of inconvenience are more likely to happen on those
customers who would like to buy a large number of groceries or other goods to store at home for a week or even
a month.
The inconvenience caused by the no plastic bag policy means that some of these customers prefer not to buy
plastic bags where they are no longer available. Because customers are not prepared to carry their materials, and
it isn't easy to carry them if they buy large quantities of goods (Shahariah, Mhd., Bashirah & Mohd, 2018). The
confirmation of a successful policy or program implemented by the government does not only depend on the
operations and management of government, but it must also get the cooperation of people of the country. By
implementing the no plastic bags policy in those years, there is part of the Malaysian accepting the policy and
change their purchasing behaviour by preparing their eco-bags when doing purchase at retail or shopping places
(Kamaruddin & Yusuf, 2010). Besides that, another part of Malaysian still has a lot of complaints and grumbles
towards the no plastic bags policy (Richards & Zen, 2016). With immediate implementation of no plastic bags,
customers perceived that it is customer’s rights to complaint and reject the retailer’s ideas. Moreover, it is
difficult to find alternative mechanism to replace the normal behaviour where the problem awareness is high,
behaviour change does not follow automatically, mainly because of the following obstacles: 1) perceived
practicability and convenience in the consumption context, 2) lack of knowledge on how to implement
alternatives or lack of opportunities, 3) strong habits, and 4) shift of responsibility (Heidbreder, Bablok, Drews
& Menzel, 2019).
One of the purchasing behaviour changes of the customers is those customers who choose to do purchasing at
merchandise places on the weekend must preparing their eco-bags or other ways that can help to carry the things
they bought from the merchandise places after the policy had been implemented (Saleh, Farzana & Jihad, 2019).
The reason is that the behaviour of the customer to prepare the carrier material by himself makes them more
inconvenient, and the critical point of the customer's dissatisfaction from this perspective is that they are not
ready to accept the policy (Gupta & Somanathan, 2011). According to Irina et al. (2013), there are some of the
Malaysians trying to choose other weekdays to do purchasing due to avoid the no plastic bags policy that
implemented on the weekend. This behaviour reflects that the "no plastic bag day" campaign has a significant
influence on customers' purchasing behaviour. Consumption is a part of the daily life of all people with needs
and desires, although it may occur without notice (Avallone, Giraldi & Oliveira, 2012).
Plastic bags have become a necessity, and in Malaysia, it is no exception. People are consuming more; the more
plastics bags are needed. Besides, this policy has supported by environmental activists and groups, but it also
caused many complaints from the everyday consumer (Malaysia Kini, 2018). According to the article by Saleh
et al, (2019), charging 20 cents for a plastic bag has an unfortunate effect on preventing people from using
plastic bags, which has also caused many complaints from the public. However, the implementation of the
policy of no plastic bag will cause inconvenience to them and require extra costs to buy plastic bags to put in the
items they buy. As a result, some of the customers think they pay for plastic bags, but it does not make them less
troublesome. Some of the customers think they need to pay extra for more plastic bags to separate items and
reduce the damage caused by the weight of the items. However, the cost of this type of bag will be relatively
high, and the retail price will not be cheaper than ordinary plastic bags. It will lead to customer dissatisfaction
because customers did not expect to have to pay more for a bag to fill the purchased items.

There are many environment-friendly bags on the market such as paper bags, reusable bags, bio-degradable bags
and jute bags (Jalil, Mian & Rahman, 2013) however, customers need to pay extra cost to buy a bag in order to
place and bring those items were purchased by them. These compostable grocery bags are usually sold at
retailer’s premises. The purpose of charging for this product is to discourage the use of disposable bags, even if
they are compostable, to promote the use of reusable bags that last longer and are not discarded into the
environment in the short term (Santos, Sousa, Oliveira Sampaio & Fagundes, 2013). Disposable plastic bags are
used to carry goods and are usually offered to customers at the point of sale (United Nations, 2018). However,
the government has launched no plastic bag policy through Malaysia, which is expect to reduce the usage of the
plastic bag consequences reduces the pollution of the environment. From the perspective of consumers, the free
use of plastic bags when shopping is regarded as the right of consumers and an essential factor of shopping
convenience (Irina, Ahamad & Omar, 2013).
According to the (Mortimer & Russell-Bennett, 2018), they stated that customer dissatisfaction is due to
supermarkets breaking their “psychological contract” with customers. Srisuwan Janya, an activist, accuses
retailers of violating consumers’ rights by stopping the distribution of disposable plastic bags without offering
suitable alternatives (Wipatayotin, 2020). When customers are shopping, it is their right to have plastic bags to
carry their purchases. Some customers think that after implementing the no plastic bag policy, retailers should
prepare other bags such as paper bag, degradable bag and so on, to replace plastic bags. Instead, retailers are
telling customers to pay extra for buy a plastic bag or carry their own bags. Therefore, consumers feel that the
policy of no plastic bags violates their rights, leading them to be dissatisfied with the policy. On the other hand,
some people are not satisfied that they are deprived the rights of plastic bags. Customers’ satisfaction is very
critical to every business. It needs to be considered as a vital component of any business because it will provide
those business owners and marketers with a metric that can be used to improve and measure business
performance from a customer perspective, it had also decided the loyalty of customers towards the brand they
bought (Khadka & Maharjan, 2017).
The implementation of no plastic bags policy had successfully aroused the dissatisfaction of customers who
already been relying on using plastic bags as their carrying material (Gupta & Somanathan, 2011). The reason
that making customers’ dissatisfaction with those who rely on using plastic bags happened is the no plastic bags
policy had forcing the customer behaviour changed and making them feel inconvenience. In contrast, purchase
at the merchandise places with no plastic bags provide. Customers feel their rights are being taken away and the
additional cost burden is another reason for dissatisfaction with the policy. No plastic bags policy had led to the
dissatisfaction of customers that happened since their normal purchase behaviour had been a force to change, it
is not their desire, and they had not ready to face it yet (Cho, 2012). The policy had to force them to change their
normal purchasing behaviour on stop providing plastic bags to them, so that they have to prepare their carrying
materials like eco-bags, backpack or others to carry their purchasing goods (Saleh, Farzana & Jihad, 2019).
In this regard, the present study intends to investigate the perspective and critical situation adjoining the four
primary determinants (Inconvenience, Customers Behavior Change, Extra cost, Deprived the Rights of the
Customer) towards customer dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag policy. These leads to the development of
below hypotheses:
H1: There is a significant relationship between inconvenience and customer dissatisfaction towards no plastic
bag policy.
H2: There is a significant relationship between customers’ behavior change and customer dissatisfaction
towards no plastic bag policy.
H3: There is a significant relationship between extra cost and customer dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag
policy.
H4: There is a significant relationship between supply deprived the rights of customer and customer
dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag policy.
3.0 METHODOLOGY
Quantitative research was used to achieve the objectives of the study by using a questionnaire survey. Data
collection was conducted face-to-face in six hypermarkets located in Klang Valley, namely Tesco, Giant, 99
Speedmart, Econsave, Jaya Grocer, and AEON Big. The target sample size in this study is 400, with a margin of

error of ±5% at 95% confidence level, by assuming 50% of the respondents with a good knowledge of plastic
bag policy (Xubin Pan. 2019). The questionnaires consist of 3 core components: 1) demographic information,
which consisted of gender, age, race, the visited hypermarket, and the frequency of visiting the selected
hypermarket; 2) factors against the plastic bag policy; 3) attitude toward plastic bag policy. There were four
sub-components to measure the factors against the plastic bag policy: inconvenient, behaviour changes, extra
cost, and deprivation of the right of the customer. Customers’ dissatisfaction was used to measure the attitude
toward plastic bag policy. A 5-point Likert scale questionnaire was offered in the English language.
In the study, IBM SPSS Software version 23 was used to analyse the collected data. The reliability test was
performed to check the validity of the items under factor measure. The results showed that the Cronbach’s alpha
for the factor measure was 0.740, indicating the items used to measure the factor against the plastic bag policy
were acceptable (Tavakol & Dennick, 2011). In this study, the descriptive statistics focused on frequencies and
percentages of the demographic variables. At the same time, Pearson Correlation test and Multiple Linear
Regression (MLR) analysis were performed to determine the correlation between the variables of factors
measure and the attitude toward the plastic bag policy. The range of Pearson correlation coefficient, r , falls
from -1.0 to +1.0 where -1.0 indicates a negative linear correlation while +1.0 indicates a positive linear
correlation (Samuels & Gilchrist, 2014). The formula of the MLR in this study, as shown below:
4
4
3
3
2
2
2
1
0 x
x
x
x
y 



 




Where 
y customer dissatisfaction toward no plastic bag policy

1
x Inconvenience

2
x Behaviour changes

3
x Extra cost

4
x Deprivation of the right of the customer
The significance level of 0.05 was adopted in this study.
4.0 RESULTS
4.1Pearson Correlation Analysis
In order to test the hypothesis, the sodality of variables has been assessed using a Pearson correlation analysis.
At this moment, the focus is to ensure the consistencies between variables is exist. The positive correlation
coefficient, r, represents the direct association between variables, whereas a negative value indicates that the
variables are inversely associated. When the r-value is zero, variables are not associated with one another.
According to Cohen (2010), the strength of correlations is categorized as low (r = 0.10 to o.29), medium (r =
0.30 to 0.49) and high (r = 0.50 to 1.00). Table 1.3 present the summary of two-tailed Pearson’s correlation
between independent variables and dependent variables.
TABLE1.3: Linear Regression Analysis (Dependent Variable: Dissatisfaction among Retail Customer
towards No Plastic Policy)
Variable r Sig.
Inconvenience .832** .000

Behaviour Change .824** .000
Extra Cost .520** .000
Deprived of Right .811** .000
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.001 level (2-tailed).
Dependent variable: Dissatisfaction among Retail Customer No Plastic Policy
Following Cohen’s (1988) approach, there are in highly positive correlation between customer dissatisfaction
and no plastic bag policy of retailing and inconvenience (r = 0.832, p < .001), behaviour change (r = 0.824, p <
.001), a moderate correlation of extra cost (r = 0.520, p < .001) and deprived of right (r = 0.811, p < .001). The
statistics data indicates the most of the variables are correlated. Results of the correlation test imply an
association between variables but do not necessarily indicate a causation relationship (Zikmund, 1991). For the
hypothesis testing, correlation analysis points out possible causal relations, and linear regression will analyze the
predictive power between the variables in the following sections.
4.2 Linear Regression Analysis
The linear regression method is an evaluation of impact for both independent variables and dependent variable.
It has led to which each independent variable is particularly significant predictors of one dependent variable. As
shown in table 1.4, it summarises the analysis of independent variables of inconvenience, behaviour change,
extra cost and deprived of right with the dependent variable of customer dissatisfaction among the Malaysia
retail customers concerning to no plastic bag policy.
TABLE 1.4 Linear Regression Analysis
Hypothesis Variables R2
Beta t Sig.
H1 Inconvenience .832** .338 6.598 .000
H2 Behaviour Change .824** .274 5.339 .000
H3 Extra Cost .520** .073 2.531 .012
H4 Deprived of Right .811** .272 5.794 .000
***. Correlation is significant at the 0.001 level (2-tailed)
Note. Significant levels: ***p < 0.001; **p < 0.01; *p < 0.05
Concerning to table 1.4, the estimation for H1 was computed to evaluate dissatisfaction of customer in retail
business and no plastic bag policy based on inconvenience. A significant in regression method was R2
of .832
with p < .001. It indicates that 83.2% of the variation in dissatisfaction of retailing among customer towards no
plastic bag policy was estimated by inconvenience. Portrays that inconvenience is significantly influenced the
dissatisfaction in retailing business when no plastic policy being implemented. In fact, among the other
independent variables, inconvenience is the curial factor in ensuring the satisfaction level for the customer.

The estimation H2 of dissatisfaction among the customer in retail business and no plastic policy are based on
behaviour change. The table 1.4 indicate the R2
of .824 p > .005. It shows the high positive relationship between
behaviour change and customer dissatisfaction towards no plastic policy in the retailing business. Similar to H1,
the p-value for H2 for regression coefficient is equal to .000 which is less than 0.05 that means the variable is a
significant factor in influencing the dissatisfaction of customer in no plastic policy for retailing. By comparing
this independent variable with others, it is the second important factor in influencing the dependent variable.
The result of H3 in table 1.4 showed that R2
of .520 with p > .005 approximately 52% of the variations
dissatisfaction among the customer in retail business and no plastic policy was estimated by extra cost portrays
that there is a moderate positive relationship between extra costs with the dependent variable.
Meanwhile, for H4 the computation to evaluate dissatisfaction of customer in retail business and no plastic bag
policy based on deprived of the right. The R2
of .811 with p < 05 means that deprived of right is a significant
factor to affect the dependent variable of customer dissatisfaction in retail business in Malaysia towards no
plastic policy.
5.0 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
The study found that inconvenience, behaviour change, extra cost and depriving the right of customer have a
significant relationship with customer dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag policy. It is supported by Shahariah,
Jamalia, Bashirah and Zahariah (2018); Valarmathy (2014); Irina, Ahamad & Omar (2013) which indicates
customers’ satisfaction level might be influenced by the implementation of no plastic bag policy as they feel
inconvenient preparing and carrying their own plastic bags for the things they purchase at retail stores.
Kuppusamy and Gharleghi (2015) expressed that no plastic bag policy executed by the government has mixed
some disappointment among customers whereby changing their buying conduct. The constrained changed in
buying conduct has inspired customer' disappointment as they have to set up their self-conveying implies (Saleh,
Farzana and Jihad, 2019). Besides, some Malaysian customers have opted to purchase on days where they do
not need to comply with the policy due to the prohibition of plastic bags usage on certain days (Irina, Ahamad
and Omar (2013).
From the social point of view, the restriction of plastic bag can be delegated as a anti-utilization which is
characterize as a safe against the way of life and the showcasing of mass creation (Penaloza and Price 1993). It
results from the excessive utilization of plastic bag in a current society constrained by the wealthier countries or
classes that rise up out of the counter utilization characters (Iyer and Muncy 2009).Regardless of what might be
expected, against the conduct that has another significance where it alludes to the contribution of customer
feelings, for example, disdain toward the restriction on usage (Zavestoski, 2002). Hostile to utilization conduct
was named as purchaser defiance, opposition, blacklist, non-conformist development, moral and non-usage
(Cherrier, 2006). It will add to the current study that breaks down the shopper's conduct of plastic bag
banishment on a national basis (Sharp et al. 2010; Cherrier 2006; Convery et al. 2007; Hasson et al. 2007).
These is clearly indicating that the resentment of consumers’ purchasing behaviour. The no-plastic bag policy
has also incurred extra cost for those who purchase more as they need to pay extra for the plastic bags causing
dissatisfaction among customers. Customers opined that, charging for every piece of plastic bag is annoying,
especially when it used to be free. Jalil et al. (2013) stated that there are many environment-friendly bags in the
market such as paper bags, reusable bags, bio-degradable bags and jute bags, but these types of shopping bags
are considered expensive compared to normal plastic bags. According to this study, not every customer is
willing to pay extra for these kinds of bags as it is relatively expensive for customers to buy new shopping bags
every visit especially when they forget to bring their bags. Moreover, with reusable bags, it incurs additional
costs because it requires extra time to clean the shopping bags (Kuppusamy and Gharleghi, 2015)
Besides, this line of research can be extended by adding a mediating or moderating effect on the relationship
between the variables and customer dissatisfaction which could be a potential effect. As for the practical
implications in this context of the study, it appears that satisfaction of customers does not only depend on the
products itself but also the extra services rendered by the retailers such as providing plastic bags to customers
for carrying their purchased items. Thus, there is a need for retailers to understand the importance of customers’
perspective that causes their dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag policy in curbing the above problems by
addressing customers’ concerns and desires hence achieving a win-win situation for both. Failure in providing
plastic bags could lead customers to leave the place without purchasing or with minimum purchase. Therefore,
the retailers can offer some discounts for customers that bring their plastic bags. On the other hand, the

government can demonstrate support by reviewing the policy again after knowing the perspective of customers
and retailers.
High coordination between government and customers can help to improve and implement no plastic bag policy
more successfully which can benefit everyone in the long run. With this limitation, the future studies can be
carried out by concealing with more states in Malaysia, and other retails such as micro and personal grocery
store for better visibility. Hence, this study should be further explored across a broader geographical area
coverage and in the substantially different cultural context. Besides this, our results cannot be readily simplified
to the overall working population. A longitudinal study can be employed when this study was cross-sectional.
This research has portrayed a clearer picture on the factors of customers’ dissatisfaction towards the ‘No Plastics
Bags’ policy which are an inconvenience, customers’ purchasing behaviour forced to change, extra cost and
deprived the rights of customers (Asmuni, Khalili, Hussin & Zain, 2018; Chitotombe, 2014; Irina, Ahamad &
Omar, 2013; Kuppusamy; Saleh, Farzana & Jihad, 2019).
The data analysis results pointed out the implementation of no plastic bag policy will cause dissatisfaction of
customers since customers are yet to adopt the policy wholeheartedly. The dissatisfaction of customers will
adversely affect the relationship between customers and retailers in the long run. Retailers may lose their
customers as some may start to purchase at different places that provide plastic bags. Thus, the government
should improvise the implementation of the policy which can benefit the environment and retailers, thus
creating a good relationship with customers.
Finally, the results of this study suggest that the no plastic bag policy has resulted in customers’ dissatisfaction
because they are deprived of their rights. According to Mortimer, G. Russell- Bennett (2018), customers’
“psychological contract” has been violated by the retailers, thus creating dissatisfaction. Customers believe that
they deserve free plastic bags when they make their purchase with the retailers. On the other hand, customers
believe that retailers have no right to deny their claims on plastic bags as they view their relationship as a
“power relationship”. The results of this study suggest inconvenience, customers’ behaviour change, extra cost
and deprived rights of customers are essential factors in customers’ dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag policy.
In conclusion, from the above study and analysis, showed that all the independent variables are significant with
the customer dissatisfaction towards no plastic bag policy. However, other variables might be important to
customers’ dissatisfaction. Future research could try to consider and include the perspective of sellers for a
better picture on the effects and level of satisfaction in terms of ‘No Plastic Bag’ policy as this study only
focused from the buyer’s side.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to thank everyone who has contributed directly and indirectly in this paper and also taking this
moment to thank Centre for Learning and Teaching (CLT, UTAR) for their support.
REFERENCES
1. Asmuni, S., Khalili, J. M., Zain, Z. m., & Hussin, N. B. (2018). Consumer Participation and Effectiveness
of the No Plastic Bag Day Program in Malaysia. 33-41. – Asian Journal of Behavioural Studies
2. Avallone, Giraldi & Oliveira, (2012). Conscious Consumption: A Study on Plastic Bags’ Consumers in
Brazil, International Journal of Psychological Studies, Vol 4, No 1. 122-134.
3. Cherrier, H. (2006). Consumer identity and moral obligations in non-plastic bag consumption: A dialectical
perspective. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 30, 515–523
4. Chitotombe, J. W. (2014). The plastic bag ‘ban’ controversy in Zimbabwe: An analysis of policy issues and
local responses. International Journal of Development and Sustainability, 1000-1012.
5. Cho, Y. C. (2012, October). The Effects of Customer Dissatisfaction on Switching Behavioural the Service
Sector. 579-592
6. Cohen, J. (2010). Set Correlation as a General Multivariate Data- Analytic Method. Hillsdale, 301-341

7. Dikgang, Lieman, & Visser, (2012). Analysis of the plastic-bag levy in South Africa. 59-65, Journal of
Resources, Conservation and Recycling.
8. Frienkel,S. (2011). A Brief history of plastic’s conquest of the world. 4-8. NBC LEARN.
9. Gupta, K., & Somanathan, R. (2011, November). Consumer Response’s to Incentives to Reduce Plastic Bag
Use: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Urban India. 4-39.
10. Hashim, U. A., Abdullah, N., & Takeshi, M. (2019). A Review on Plastic Policies in Malaysia and Japan.
1-7.
11. Heidbreder, L. M., Bablok, I., Drews, S., & Menzel, C. (2019). Tackling the plastic problem: A review on
perceptions, behaviours, and interventions. 1077-1093.
12. Hofmann, W. (2019, April 3). Top 5 Greenest Countries in Asia-Pacific. Retrieved April 3, 2019, from
https://www.valuechampion.sg/top-5- greenest-countries-asia-pacific.
13. Irina, S. Z., Ahamad, R., & Omar, W. (2013). No plastic bag campaign day in Malaysia and the policy
implication.
14. Iyer, R., & Muncy, J. A. (2009). Purpose and object of anti-consumption. Journal of Business Research, 62,
160–168
15. Jalil, M. A., Mian, M. N., & Rahman, M. K. (2013). Using Plastic Bags and Its Damaging Impact on
Environment and Agriculture: An Alternative Proposal. International Journal of Learning & Development, 1-14.
16. Jambeck, J. R., Geyer, R., Wilcox, C., Siegler, T. R., Perryman, M., Andrady, A., et al. (2015). Plastic
waste inputs from land into the ocean. Science, 768- 771.
17. Kamaruddin, R., & Yusuf, M. M. (2010, July). Selangor Government’s “No plastic Bag Day” Campaign:
Motivation and Acceptance Level. 210.
18. Khadka, K., & Maharjan, S. (2017, November). Customers Satisfaction and Customer Loyalty. 1-64.
19. Kuppusamy, M., & Gharleghi, B. (2015, June 5th). "No Plastic Bag Day” Concept and Its Role in
Malaysian’s Environmental Behaviour Development. 175.
20. Lee, K.-Y., Hsu, Y.-C., & Fu, S.-H. (2014). The Effects of Service Convenience, Satisfaction, Commitment
on Loyalty to Retail Service Brand. 43-67.
21. Mortimer, G., & Russell-Bennett, R. (2018). Why plastic bag bans triggered such a huge reaction.
22. Musa, Hayes, Bradley, Clayson, & Gillibrand, 2013. Measures aimed at reducing plastic carrier bag use: A
consumer behaviour focused study.17-23
23. Nielsen, T. D., Holmberg, K., & Stripple, J. (2019). Need a bag? A review of public policies on plastic
carrier bags - where, how and to what effect? Waste management, 428-440.
24. Penaloza, L., & Price, L. L. (1993). Consumer resistance: A conceptual overview. Advance Consumer
Research, 20, 123–128.
25. Richards, C., & Zen, I. S. (2016, July 19). From surface to deep corporate social responsibility. The
Malaysian no plastic bags campaign as both social and organizational learning, 278.
26. Saidan, M. N., Ansour, L. M., & Saidan, H. (2016, October). Management Of Plastic Bags Waste: An
Assessment Of Scenarios In Jordan. 148-154.
27. Saleh, O. B., Farzana, Q., & Jihad, M. (2019, May 30). “No Plastic Bag” Campaign of Malaysia. 116-117.

28. Samuels, P., & Gilchrist, M. (2014, April). Pearson Correlation. 1- 4
29. Santos, S. C., Sousa, C. E., Oliveira Sampaio, D. D., & Fagundes, A. A. (2013). The Impact of Using
Compostable Carrier Bags on Consumer Behaviour in the City of Belo Horizonte, Brazil. Ambiente &
Sociedade, 1-20.
30. Shahariah, A., Mhd., K. J., Bashirah, H. N., & Mohd, Z. Z. (2018, March). Consumer Participation and
Effectiveness of the No Plastic Bag Day Program in Malaysia

AUTHORS PROFILE
Mohan Selvaraju received his Bachelor degree from Chartered Institute of Logistics and
Transport (CILT, UK) specializing in Logistics in 2002. In 2010, he obtained his MSc
from UTM majoring in Urban Transport Planning. He has more than 29 years working
experience in the Logistics and Supply Chain sectors. Mr. Mohan Selvaraju also a PSMB
certified trainer since 2006. He is currently engaged as an academician, and holding the
position of lecturer with UTAR in the Faculty of Science (FSc). His current research
interests include supply chain management, operations, procurement and supply chain
risk and pursuing his PhD study and specializing in procurement area.
Dr Charles Ramendran SPR Subramaniam received his PhD in Human Resource
Management from Universiti of Sains Malaysia (USM) and Master in Human Resource
Management from Universiti Utara Malaysia (UUM). He also obtained his degree in
Bachelor of Social Work Management (Hons) from Universiti Utara Malaysia. He is
currently engaged as an academician, holding the position of Assistant Professor in the
Faculty of Business and Finance in Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman (UTAR). His areas
of expertise are employment law, psychological contract, occupational safety and health,
leadership and human resource management. He has published his articles in indexed
journals – ESCI indexed journal, Scopus Journals and conference proceedings lists. Prior to joining academia,
he began his career as an Industrial Relations Officer (IRO) in the National Union of
Plantation Workers.
Dr Vimala Kadiresan is Senior Lecturer in the Faculty of Business, Economics and
Accounting at HELP University. Her teaching and research interests include Human
Resource Management, Business Management, and Organization Behaviour. She has
been in the tertiary education industry for 14 years which has contributed to effective
teaching of business-related subjects as in experience sharing and problem solving. She
is involved actively in research collaboration and publications. Her research studies have
been published in Scopus and other international journals.
Ooi Cheau Pian is a lecturer of Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman (UTAR) with
experience in coaching, teaching, and facilitating work-related to Statistics. She
completed her Master Degree in Statistics in the year 2012 from Universiti Sains
Malaysia. Her work focuses especially on Social Network Analysis.
Khairul Rizuan bin Suliman is a lecturer of Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman (UTAR) for Logistics and
International Shipping. He received a Diploma and Bachelor Degree in Industrial
Logistics from Universiti Kuala Lumpur (UniKL) Malaysian Institute of Industrial
Technology, Malaysia and obtained his Master of Science in Transportation Planning
from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM) as well as a professional certification of
International Diploma in Supply Chain Management from International Trade Centre
(ITC), Geneva Switzerland. He is currently working on a PhD research in Supply Chain
at Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM). His research concentrates on the seaport terminal,
logistics operations and transportation sector. Apart on that, he also a chartered member
of Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport (CILT), Professional Technologists
[Transportation & Logistic Technology] from Malaysia Board of Technologists
(MBOT), member of Transportation Science Society of Malaysia (TSSM) and member of Eastern Asia Society
for Transportation Studies (EASTS).

Science, Education and Innovations in the context of modern problems. Vol. 5. 2022, Issue 3, Abdulaziz A. Bakhit A.
EXAMINING THE EFFECT OF ORGANISA-
TIONAL COMMITMENT, HUMAN RE-
SOURCE PRACTICES AND COMPETENCE
ON ORGANISATIONAL CITIZENSHIP BE-
HAVIOUR1
Abdulaziz Abdullah Bakhit Alhosni, Asia Pacific University of Technology and Innovation, Malaysia
Lua Sharmini Satanam, Asia Pacific University of Technology and Innovation, Malaysia
Thilageswary Arumugam (corresponding author, Asia Pacific University of Technology and Innovation, Ma-
laysia
Abstract
Effectiveness Nationality Behaviour is generally a phrase which includes something good which will workers
perform from their very own option, which often facilitates co-office workers in addition advantages the organi-
zation. One of the aspects that will impact on company nationality behaviour amongst staff from your financial
field will be efficiency dedication which in turn referred to as feeling related to obligation that this employee
includes a job through the business. The 2nd element is human being source methods which usually understood
to be a method of which sucks in, evolves, inspires as well as maintain personnel to ensure the particular effi-
cient execution additionally success from the organization as well as users. The next element will be skills
meaning the capability in the individual to create inside an acceptable degree at the office including the power in
the particular person in order to move plus use the talents in addition to understanding inside brand new circum-
stances and also boost decided benefits. Consequently, this particular evaluation will assess these kinds of ele-
ments that will affect typically the efficiency nationality behaviour between employees associated with bank
field. An overall total regarding 114 respondent’s reactions have been created SPSS one simply by just one to be
able to evaluation the specific data. The outcomes indicated that there was clearly a considerable partnership
among effectiveness determination, individual reference procedures and even effectiveness in the direction of
efficiency nationality conduct amongst staff with the financial industry in a single centre Japanese nation.
Keywords: Organisational Citizenship Behaviour, Organisational Commitment, Human, Resource Practices,
Competence
Introduction
Effectiveness Nationality Behavior (OCB) is recognized as probably the most important plus developing regions
of study amongst college students in the last 2 decades (Muthuraman and Alhaziazi, 2017). Because financial
field is among the crucial industries performs an important part within improving the specific economic climate
from the country, the particular specialist will probably pay a lot more focus on the actual workers of economic
industries (Riyadh in addition to Prophet, 2018). In addition, the entire quantity of this staff, inside Oman is
around 20 9, a hundred seventy five personnel inside 2018 that is regarded as typically the test in the research
(statistic yearbook, 2018). Furthermore, you will find various features that each worker offers, like age bracket,
sex, marriage standing, schooling and also duration of work (Sani, ainsi que ing., 2019). With this perception,
these kinds of market aspects effect the particular employee’s efficiency commitment, hr} manager methods and
even proficiency on efficiency nationality behavior (Uzonwanne, 2014). There was clearly an optimistic part-
nership among efficiency dedication, human being source methods, skills together with efficiency nationality
behavior between employees associated with bank field throughout Oman. As a result, this particular examine is
1
Received: FEB 17, 2022/ Accepted: 22 MAR, 2022, Published 18 APR, 2022

designed to recognize efficiency nationality conduct as well as associations along with efficiency determination,
hr} manager procedures plus skills among staff members with the monetary field within Oman a good integra-
tive kind of efficiency determination, individual reference procedures in addition proficiency since the concep-
tual platform of the analysis.
Among the issues related to efficiency dedication may be the employees’ discontentment leads to low-level re-
garding employees’ determination in addition to level of00 proceeds objective (Gautam, 2017). In addition,
modifications in our Omani economic industry possess led to if you are a00 involving doubt, danger and even
function low self-esteem amongst staff. In addition, one of many common difficulties associated with human
being useful resource techniques between workers of economic market inside Oman will be salaries errors.
Whenever salaries info is created a method by hand, often there is space with regard to human being error. De-
pending on Rahmawati (2017), mentioned that certain from your typical troubles connected with inefficiencies
between personnel throughout financial industry, Within Oman will be apathy which could lead to mistakes,
lateness along with other complications. The 2nd problem regarding inefficiencies is usually bad conversation.
Therefore, typically the investigator will certainly analyze the particular effect involving skills after efficiency
passports conduct amongst staff linked to bank field within just Oman. The research objective would be to fig-
ure out the bond associated with efficiency devotion, hr} manager methods together with proficiency on effi-
ciency nationality actions between personnel through the financial industry, in Oman. Determine one zero
shows the study construction. The particular qualifying criterion on the review is definitely efficiency passports
habits.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Conceptualising the organisational commitment, competence, human resource practice and organisational citi-
zenship behaviour.
Effectiveness dedication is really a commitment associated with personnel to help accomplish the aim of the
specific company. Including personnel within recognition in addition devotion (Wolowska, 2014). Based on
Mansour (2015) described human being source methods as a group, be it natural or processed regarding in house
constant guidelines plus procedures developed in addition to applied to ensure that you can actually individual
money help the achievement from the goals from your company. Proficiency will be conceptualised when it
comes to understanding, capabilities, abilities as well as behaviour offered inside the framework of the cau-
tiously chosen group of helpful expert jobs which are of the suitable degree of generality (Sajilan, 2019). Effi-
ciency nationality behavior understood to be a casual conduct introduced simply by workers inside business
(Sargolzaei and Keshtegar, 2015).
Efficiency passports actions thought as casual habits shown by simply staff throughout enterprise (Sargolzaei as
well as Keshtegar, 2015). Efficiency dedication is generally a dedication involving employees to assist attain the
purpose of the particular organization. Including employees within recognition and even commitment
(Wolowska, 2014). Efficiency nationality behavior will be individual behavior which usually discretionary in
fact it is not really recognized straight or even obviously with the official incentive program, which allows you
to boost the efficient operating in the operation (Eyupoglu, 2016). Efficiency commitment understood to be
typically the mental preference together with faithfulness that this staff members have to their own organization
(Yousef, 2017).
In accordance with Mansour (2015), identified human being source techniques like a group of inside continuous
guidelines plus methods developed in addition to put on make sure that you’re able to send individual funds
help the specific accomplishment with the objectives on the enterprise. Human being reference routines thought
as some techniques additionally plans prepared from the man money through the group that will guide effec-
tively and even efficiently inside attaining effectiveness targets. Therefore, this may lead to the required result
of this overall performance in the establishment as well as the overall performance of your personnel and also
client satisfaction (Mazur, 2015).
Proficiency will be conceptualised with regards to understanding, capabilities, expertise together with conduct
displayed within the framework of the cautiously selected pair of practical professional duties that are belonging
to the suitable degree of generality (Sajilan, 2019). Skills may be the capability to properly execute a job, obli-
gation, or perhaps part. Common with regard to competences will be these people incorporate information,
skills, individual ideals furthermore perceptions and they create expertise plus talents and they are obtained via
job history in addition studying getting into (Kertarajasa ainsi que ing., 2019). These would be the partnership
creating for that study.

Relationship between Organisational Commitment and Organisational Citizenship Behaviour
Effectiveness dedication is among the important signals that will give rise to improving efficiency nationality
behavior (Zayas-Ortiz ainsi que ing., 2015). The specific workers that are much more dedicated plus that have
prepared to operate buy to offer the organisation's objectives are highlighting correct nationality (Tambe in addi-
tion to Shanker, 2014). Depending on Veta (2015), we have a good partnership among efficiency dedication in
addition efficiency passports. Therefore, it could be hypothesized which will; H1: There exists a considerable
connection among organization determination and even business nationality conduct among staff.
Relationship between human resource practices and organisational citizenship behaviour
The specific books recommended which will hr} manager methods which usually include payment, overall per-
formance evaluation, coaching plus advancement give rise to the particular introduction related to efficiency
nationality actions (Hassan, 2016). Human being source methods in addition efficiency passports behavior are
considerably connected with one another, that procedures will certainly result in improved amounts of effi-
ciency nationality behavior (Ahmed, 2016). Likewise, Turek in addition to Turek (2015), pointed out that will
companies might choose numerous human being reference procedures sport employees’ choices that may ad-
vantage these questions technique it will help produce efficiency nationality behaviour among all of their em-
ployees. Based on Owor (2015), there exists a good partnership among human being source techniques and even
effectiveness passports conduct. Therefore, it could be hypothesized that may; H2: There exists a considerable
partnership in between individual useful resource routines as well as company nationality conduct amongst fi-
nancial staff.
Relationship between competence and organisational citizenship behaviour
Skills is recognized as an essential element of efficiency nationality behavior (Rahmawati, 2017). Skills will be
considerably influencing upon efficiency nationality behavior (Hasanuddin&Sjahruddin, 2017). Proficiency
includes a good impact about Effectiveness Nationality Behavior (OCB); workers that have increased profi-
ciency increases the quantity of Efficiency Passports Behavior (Radosavljevic ainsi que ing., 2017). Depending
on Subramaniam and Jasmin (2017), there exists a good partnership among skills in addition efficiency pass-
ports conduct. Therefore, it could be hypothesized that will; H3: We have a substantial partnership among profi-
ciency plus effectiveness nationality conduct among financial staff.
Contribution to the theoretical gap
With this research, efficiency commitment, hr} manager methods plus proficiency will be the particular meth-
ods related to workers. Once the employees applied all those procedures nicely, in this way will be enhancing
efficiency nationality behavior within the organization, by giving the employees monetary benefits which often
encourage these two methods is to do their finest inside the company to get the specific advantages. Efficiency
nationality conduct results is the consequence of efficiency determination, hr} manager procedures in addition
to skills with this examine.
To use this specific concept with this study, interpersonal trade idea has got the greatest constructions in order to
explain effectiveness nationality actions connected with worker (Malmstrom and even Johansson, 2016). Be-
cause mentioned simply by Haifisch and Rabenu (2018), mentioned that this primary idea of sociable trade
principle will be advertise of payment. If the business provides unique incentive towards the staff, this kind of
prospects the particular performance dedication, human being source procedures together with skills associated
with staff raises since the personnel think that they ought to make up. As a result, they are doing their utmost to
be able to within associations to obtain returns. Based on Zoller as well as Muldoon (2019), cultural swap hu-
man relationships boost employee’s dependence on the companies. Controlled efficiency assistance boosts effi-
ciency consciousness and for that reason enhances emotions linked to repairing behaviors depending on effi-
ciency passions. This type of belief impacts the standard of employee’s behaviour in the direction of organiza-
tions.
METHODOLOGY
These specific studies in line with the study viewpoint associated with Positivism. Philosophical strategy related
to organic man of science will be seen in positivism since the function regarding natural man of science is
founded on noticeable interpersonal organization. The study technique will be approached based on information

choice plus speculation advancement (Aliyu ainsi que ing., 2014). The particular experts often make use of ear-
lier concept to build up rumours. Typically the speculation will likely be created in addition to analyzed to ver-
ify be it just, entire or even declined. Therefore, the particular conjecture which will be examined will certainly
result in additional idea advancement. (Sefotho, 2015).
The particular method from the studies deductive analysis that is the introduction of appropriate ideas or perhaps
supposition to resolve the issues from your study following the organization and even screening these types of
hypotheses and even speculation simply by fresh statement (Azungah, 2018). Depending on Woiceshyn together
with Daellenbach, (2018) pointed out 5 continuous actions involving deductive way of improvement. The initial
step will be deducing typically the questions make up the principle. The second stage will be conveying the par-
ticular speculation inside functional conditions in addition summarize the partnership between factors. The next
stage is usually tests typically the speculation which will developed using the appropriate design. Your fourth
stage is analyzing the outcomes in the query that may possibly take the concept or even immediate there exists a
require connected with adjusting would be the following stage. The final action is changing the theory if re-
quired when it is certainly not verified.
The study means of this particular research is utilized study which can be gathering info from the test of people
via their own reactions in order to questions that assist to learn your behaviour (Agustini, 2018). This type of
analysis enables the particular varied technique like prospecting individuals, collecting info and taking advan-
tage of other ways associated with instrumentation (Ponto, 2015 ). As a result, this specific research can be used
this kind of exploration way to discover typically the behavior regarding best management workers economic
field within Pampre, Oman.
The primary reason with regard to period collection assessment for this task will be to ensure that the profes-
sional to comprehend the actual fundamental causes are usually causing a specific pattern inside the moment
sequence details factors plus aids the particular specialist within just predicting in addition to checking the in-
formation details by simply fitted suitable variations into it.
This particular research utilized a new quantitative research that is a way of researching that will works with
figures the other which can be methodically assessed to be able to check out tendency and the associations
(Khaldi, 2017). With this homework, both main and even supplementary data selection strategies have been
regarded as. Main facts selection is going to be via disseminating typically the set of questions towards the par-
ticipants by means of search engines documents. The specific forms are usually altered through prior investi-
gate. In addition, the research includes 114 participants. Typically the potential populace was your employees
within the financial field; together with sample used has been easy arbitrary testing.
Sources and methods of data collection
Inside main information, the thought of info choice is going to be via Search engines like Google documents
that is include some queries linked to the study. The particular participants solutions the particular set of ques-
tions plus post the answer by means of search engines files to be able to check out immediately after tagging his
or her reactions. This technique associated with variety of files has been proven as period preserving plus its
very economical way of gathering the necessary info.
In addition, among the extra information that will utilized for this particular research may be the data regarding
count number from the workers which is twenty nine, 174 employees depending on record yearbook 2018.
Population and sample
Since the complete associated with greatest administration workers inside Pampre, Oman within just 2018 has
been close to twenty nine, a hundred seventy five employees which usually regarded as a big test team (statistic
yearbook, 2018). The specific trial scale the research will be 114.
DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
Demographic Profile
The specific market user profile analyzed upon sex in addition age group because authorization provided about
this two info. Therefore, this specific research is restricted on group account. The actual user profile pointed out

which will man participants include fifty two. 6% while woman portion includes forty seven. 4%. As a result, it
could be acknowledged that will just about all the particular participants have been men group. It may be be-
cause of the on the internet types have been dispersed to a lot of amounts of guy individuals. 63. a couple of %
associated with participants are often older within the pattern regarding twenty three to be able to 39 many
years, 30 4. 2% from the individuals are usually among 18 in order to 22 many years, second 6% are generally
originated from participants related to 4 decades and also. Consequently, a greater factor for this study descends
from participants which are from your age bracket in between 23 to be able to 39 yrs. It may be as a result of on
the internet forms were distributed to numerous amounts of members who have been how old they are group
involving twenty-three so as to 39 yrs.
This Cronbach’s Alpha dog related to efficiency nationality behavior is zero. 835, efficiency dedication will be
zero. 867, human being source methods will be zero. 778, skills will be zero. 906. Therefore, it really is con-
firmed of which proficiency will be dependable with this study throughout dependability examine.
Table 1.0 Normality test
N
Statistic
Minimum
Statistic
Maximum
Statistic
Mean
Statistic
Std.
Deviation
Statistic
Skewness
Statistic Std.Error
Kurtosis
Statistic Std.Error
DV
IV1
IV2
IV3
114
114
114
114
5.00
9.00
8.00
5.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
18.0789
18.2982
17.8684
18.4211
4.46053
4.44221
4.01438
4.75207
-.353 .226
-.129 .226
.009 .226
-.466 .226
-.243 .449
-1.028 .449
-.607 .449
-.263 .449
The specific rating associated with effectiveness nationality behavior with regard to skewness will be -0. 353, as
well as the ranking with regard to kurtosis will be -0. 243. As well as that, the particular score regarding effi-
ciency commitment regarding skewers is usually -0. 129 along with the report intended for kurtosis is usually -
1. 028 depending on Desk one zero. In addition, the specific credit score involving human being source methods
regarding skewness is definitely absolutely no. 009, plus the ranking to get kurtosis is definitely -0. 607. Aside
from, typically the scores related to proficiency pertaining to skewness can be -0. 466, along with the ranking
intended for kurtosis is certainly -0. 263. Consequently , the consequence of almost all factors falls underneath
the suitable range meant for Skewness in addition Kurtosis catalog recommendations that is -2 to be able to +2.
Therefore, all the parameters had been normality dispersed with this study.
Table 2.0 Pearson Correlation Analysis
DV IV1 IV2 IV3
DV Pearson Correlation
Sig.(2-tailed)
N
1
114
.647**
.000
114
.657**
.000
114
.722**
.000
114
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
The specific evaluation portrayed inside Desk second . Absolutely no. The particular relationship pourcentage
among efficiency commitment plus efficiency nationality behavior that is (r sama dengan zero. 647, g ≤ no. 01)
also it means that the connection together will be solid connection. The actual relationship agent among hr}
manager methods in addition to efficiency nationality conduct which can be (r sama dengan zero. 657, l ≤ actu-
ally zero. 01) and it also signifies that the partnership together is usually sturdy connection. This relationship
ratio in between proficiency and even effectiveness nationality actions which is (r sama dengan absolutely noth-
ing. 722, s ≤ zero. 01) also it implies that the connection with each other will be robust partnership. Therefore,
almost all assessment offers demonstrated that this connection is usually approved. Probably the most strong
business along with efficiency nationality habits has been skills (r= zero. 722), accompanied by human being
source methods (r=0. 657), after that efficiency determination (r=0. 647) because represented within Determine
2 . not zero.

Discussions Hypothesis 1: Presently there a substantial partnership among efficiency dedication in addition
efficiency nationality behavior. The particular results out of this research, what this means is there exists a sub-
stantial connection in between efficiency determination as well as efficiency passports conduct amongst workers
inside Oman. In order to accept that will through an additional examine, an identical obtaining has been doing
simply by Antonieta ainsi que ing. (2017), the particular specialist distributed their own set of questions to be
able to 375 participants. The outcomes of this study offer proof there is a good romantic relationship among
effectiveness dedication plus performance nationality behavior. In addition, the previous analysis carries out by
simply Zayas ou 's. (2015) furthermore demonstrated which will efficiency passports behavior was considerably
affected simply by organisational commitment. Company determination may be the degree that employees un-
derstand responsibility from the companies. Dedicated employees often carry out advantageous actions of which
proceed beyond the task needs simply because they really feel much more devoted to their particular companies.
As a result, these types of staff turn out to be good organization residents (Nkhukhu, ainsi que approach. 2019).
In addition, useful staff frequently reciprocates along with determination via good functionality behaviours like
productivity nationality conduct (Sattar and January, 2015). Efficiency dedication is probably the important ac-
tions with a psychological relationship that may improve worker proficiency passports within benefit of typi-
cally the organisation (Flavia in addition to Poojary, 2018). Effectiveness dedication resulted in outstanding
group gamers. Given that devoted workers are often greatly committed to the company, plus it is accomplish-
ment, they may be excellent in participating together with, additionally doing work in groups. These people lead
substantially so as to improving the particular team’s productivity(Taber, 2018). Performance determination
result in strong recommends. Devoted and also dedicated personnel have confidence in their very own business,
and for that reason, work well and even good recommends of the businesses. They may be solid believers to-
gether with followers in the employer’s items, solutions, plus policies(Korkmaz, 2019). In addition, this leads to
decreased absenteeism. Typically the fully commited in addition to influenced personnel will certainly statement
a lot lower absenteeism compared to his or her co-workers. Fully commited staff members anticipate likely to
function, completing all their job, helping away tasks, furthermore adding towards business objectives (Shyti
and even Valera, 2018). Therefore, that figured we have a substantial marriage among efficiency dedication in
addition efficiency nationality actions between workers related to financial field, within just Oman.
Correlation 2: Presently there a substantial partnership among hr} manager methods plus efficiency nationality
behavior amongst employees. The particular results out of this research, shows there exists a significant partner-
ship among human being source methods in addition to effectiveness nationality conduct. The same end result
has been doing by simply Subramanian ainsi que ing. (2017), the particular professional dispersed their own set
of questions in order to 425 individuals. The consequence of that will study offers proof there exists a good
there exists a considerable connection in between human being source procedures in addition efficiency pass-
ports behavior. Some other conclusions from your examine carried out merely by Adame ou 's. (2017) pointed
out which will hr} manager procedures perform an important part within improving employees' efficiency na-
tionality actions and even company overall performance. Furthermore, some other outcomes claim that incen-
tive practises and gratification evaluation practises possess effects upon efficiency nationality actions associated
with staff, in fact it is triggered the most crucial effect (Mansour, 2015). Once the workers acquire benefits, the
employees increase their particular performance passports habits. Human being reference techniques substan-
tially affected employee's organization nationality practices like coaching together with advancement routines
(Ibraheem, 2015). An additional analyze thought the very best individual reference tactics guide the specific
staff to diminish profits purpose plus boost efficiency passports conduct (Zehir, ain ing., 2016). Workers which
are meant to remain in the actual company do work as company residents (Khoreva and Wechtler, 2018). Hr}
manager methods result in develop good associations. Delighted personnel create a lot more effective work area.
Nobody wants to operate the stressed in addition to dull environment. Businesses are generally a 2nd house to a
lot of personnel. Staff spends probably the most period in their very own place of work which is perhaps even a
lot more time period compared to these people purchase their very own homes. Consequently office associa-
tions, his or her honesty, this ideals are crucial. A house is secure, pleasant and several from it is really a section
of the safe place (Tahtali, 2019). In addition, man useful resource strategies include a good administration re-
garding discord. Discord and even disruptions are usually a part of existence. High will be two staff members
there is typically the possibility involving discord as well as the buy-ins obtain increased since the quantity of
workers raises inside a location. Nevertheless, natural human relationships possess likelihood of conflicts due to
arguments or even depending on numerous conditions. Individual useful resource methods get well-timed ac-
tions as well as solve the particular the law techniques by which a number of individuals are discussing an aver-
age route in a manner that can lead to issues. Human being resource procedures furthermore works with some-
one to 1 conflicts, that could become between company plus the employee or maybe the additional technique
close to (Bellacicco, ainsi que ing., 2019).

This may lead to enhance staff member proceeds. Individual source techniques run the specific worker yield.
Increased staff return might terribly impact the common productivity and may seriously harm typically the
standing of any kind of organization (Abdelaziz together with Ramadan, 2018). As a result, this figured we have
a substantial romantic relationship in between hr} manager procedures plus efficiency nationality response be-
tween individuals associated with financial field inside Oman.
Correlation 3: Presently there a substantial partnership among proficiency plus effectiveness nationality behav-
ior. The specific results out of this study, shows there is a considerable connection among skills in addition to
efficiency nationality conduct amongst employees. An identical obtaining is doing simply by (Fukada, 2018),
the particular specialist distributed their own set of questions to be able to two hundred participants. The conse-
quence of that will analysis provides proof there is a good romantic relationship in between effectiveness and
even efficiency nationality actions. An additional outcomes backed of which skill offers substantial partnership
in the direction of efficiency nationality habits (Spante, ainsi que ing., 2018). Skills include an impact upon effi-
ciency nationality practices, workers which are their particular degree of talents higher; they are going to boost
the amount of Efficiency Nationality Behavior (Russo, 2016). Employees possess complete determination to
exhibit typically the behaviour in addition function behaviours. The actual workers are usually carrying out their
very own functions and even jobs totally because of the understanding of the particular obligations together with
duties that this worker increases helping response contained in inside self-employee. Resulting in produce good
impact on Company Nationality Behavior (Nijhuis, ainsi que ing., 2018). In addition, the specific workers usu-
ally are including his or her understanding, capabilities, perceptions and private ideals plus creating understand-
ing in addition to abilities based on encounter and even studying result in improve performance passports per-
ceptions because the staff turn out to be noticed for that significance of productivity nationality behavior which
often resulted in create the actual company much better (Langgeng, ou 's., 2019). Proficiency results in im-
proved employee security as well as well-being. Simply by validating proficiency prior to permitting personnel
to attempt high-risk actions or even actions which have the to place individuals together with house in danger,
place of work incidents are decreased, plus people really feel much more comfortable additionally more secure
within the workplace, enhancing general well-being (Hee, ain 's., 2019). Additionally, this may lead to lowered
common organization danger. A dependable labor force makes a safer office, reducing the possibilities with
regard to injuries, home harm, penalties, in addition to legal cases (Islam, 2019). Moreover, this leads to en-
hanced making decisions. When the expertise of most users of the labor force are often examined, frontrunners
is able to see the entire abilities and failings from your staff when it comes to skills and even abilities, offering
info which can be invaluable to make tactical business choices together with impacting on typically the com-
pany’s points of interest plus path (Majid and Ibrahim, 2017). Apart from that will, this may lead to increased
support high quality. Workers which can be qualified job better in addition to efficiently, generating greater
results. As a result, top quality enhances, and thus will client satisfaction (Mon, ou approach., 2019). Therefore,
that figured we have a substantial marriage in between skills and even proficiency passports conduct among
staff members from the monetary field within Oman.
Implications of the Study
The objective of this particular study has been carried out to check into regardless of whether efficiency dedica-
tion, human being source methods in addition proficiency impacts efficiency nationality behavior amongst
workers from your financial field. In addition, this specific type of studies necessary to improving concept be-
cause you will find not many research carried out around the partnership among skills plus effectiveness pass-
ports behavior. In addition, to intensify around the significance of this kind of study results, assumptive as well
as useful ramifications will be described.
Theoretical Implications
Depending on these particular study outcomes, the assumptive factor is designed to the particular books that will
units typically the preceding with regard to some other experts around the effectiveness dedication, human being
source methods plus skills in the direction of efficiency nationality behavior amongst employees from the finan-
cial field. Appropriately, from your leads to this specific research, we have a good partnership among almost all
impartial aspects that are efficiency commitment, hr} manager methods in addition to proficiency in the direc-
tion of efficiency nationality behavior between workers through the bank field. In addition, this kind of examine
will even give a foundation understanding in order to college students in addition academicians upon perform-
ance determination, individual reference procedures and even effectiveness and exactly how they have got an
effect efficiency nationality conduct.
Practical Implications

Properly, from your results from the study, a good factor can also be created which will offer an understanding
towards the administration inside the company upon effectiveness dedication, exactly how employees’ discon-
tentment prospects inside low-level associated with employees’ determination plus level of00 proceeds objec-
tive. Apart from that will, altering within the financial field which usually resulted in a higher level00 doubt,
danger in addition to work lowers self-pride. A great way in order to conquer efficiency obligations issues will
be developing a strong team-work tradition which often helps a proper workplace. A business encourages the
particular lifestyle regarding group advancement, workers is going to be influenced to operate with each other in
addition accomplish a lot more. It can help increase their own commitment amounts that typically the extensive
function tradition tranquillity (Alghamdi and even Bach, 2018). As well as that, becoming obvious together with
motivate open conversation. Allowing employees become participative as to what is occurring in the business
and also how they may guide even more towards progress the business. Leading the specific workers to actually
really feel highly valued plus enhanced feeling of this fit in. Therefore, enhancing the actual overall perform-
ance involving staff via openness (Rita, 2015).
In addition, this obtaining of the study result in conquer the particular without any salaries mistakes although
making use of salaries software application that is coupled with a period presence program to ensure precise
data processing. Resulting in boost worker well-being in addition to inspiration as well as their particular career
satisfaction (Mahajan, ainsi que ing., 2015).
Additionally, the specific getting with this analysis cause get over poor connection which often lead to ineffi-
ciencies. A good way to improve typically the conversation will be simply by developing a communication-
friendly area to be able to sure that there is definitely a definite in addition continuous circulation related to in-
teraction around the team and inspiring the actual staff to convey on their own by simply making a communica-
tion-friendly atmosphere (Sieberer, 2016). In addition to of which, this locating on this study bring about defeat
the particular without any apathy which could bring about problems and even lateness. In order to triumph over
typically the without any apathy has a private talk (Xie, 2018). The initial step to consider anytime dealing with
the sluggish worker would be to just contact all of them on their very own bad behavior. Costly crucial to have
this required for personal to reduce darken these people much more simply by belittling every one of them be-
fore his or her co-office workers. Second of all, it is very important remain courteous (Kim together with White-
colored, 2018). As a result, the particular conclusions in the research might be essential for frontrunners inside
the monetary field, when it comes to informing or even increasing consciousness with regard to instant concen-
trate on be provided in the direction of issues that will go undiscovered generally. The particular collected in-
formation has been by means of participants through the personnel with the bank industry. Hence, this particular
studies essential for that organization which may be suggested as a factor to raised knows the problems con-
nected with efficiency dedication, human being source methods additionally proficiency.
Conclusion
In line with the results of the study, it could be figured effectiveness dedication, human being source methods
plus skills have an effect upon performance nationality behavior among workers from the monetary field within
Oman. First of all, hard to find related to earlier research around the partnership among effectiveness in addition
to efficiency nationality conduct. Additionally , the study experienced restrict time to gather almost all main
information, carry out the specific evaluation and even current the particular conclusions in addition restricting
this particular analysis to gather a lot more reactions for that precision from your research which usually result
in moment an issue restriction for this exploration (Sadikhov Adil Fazil, Aliev Faiq Hasan, 2022).
This suggested researching increase in order to analyzing self-concept that could impact on efficiency passports
behavior. Efficiency nationality behavior is behaviours run simply by purposes to be able to perform self-
concept (Amini, ainsi que ing, 2016). With regard to long term study, with regard to constant analysis about this
research, this specific advised that will to find much more level concerning the connection in between skill to-
gether with efficiency nationality actions to get more info. This might be carried out if you take typically the
authorization so as to access for your nearby collection associated with educational institutions in order to see
the various study which are not launched on the internet. Additionally, for any constant homework about this
examine, this recommended to utilize time that is allotted regarding conducting the investigation sensibly. Ef-
fective period administration allows experts to keep focus on their own function, contributing to investigate effi-
ciency. Time period supervision could be improved by simply planning the particular work schedule of which
details the whole groundwork.
Limitation of the Study:

The specific is designed of the study were to look at the specific effect associated with effectiveness dedication,
human being source methods plus skills upon efficiency nationality behavior.
Consequently, there have been several restrictions with this research to achieve a far more useful obtaining.
To begin with, hard to find regarding earlier research around the partnership among proficiency in addition effi-
ciency nationality behavior. Based on Lillevali in addition to Taks( 2017), there is certainly just 4 study carried
out in between these two constructs. Like a restriction, it had been hard to gather info through earlier analysis
with this exploration. In addition, the research experienced restrict time for you to collect almost all main de-
tails, carry out the particular assessment and even existing the actual results together with limiting this particular
examine to collect a lot more reactions for that precision from the analysis which usually led to in an attempt to
moment a problem restriction for this analyze.
Recommendations for future research:
With regard to long term study, for any constant analysis about this research, this recommended that will to find
a lot more level concerning the partnership among proficiency in addition efficiency nationality behavior to get
more info. This may be performed if you take the specific authorization in order to access to be able to your
local library related to educational institutions to be able to see the various studies that are not really released on
the internet. This may the actual long term specialist along with additional knowing plus analyzing from the
information acquired in addition to analyze immediately after between outcomes of the bond in between skills
as well as efficiency passports conduct. Additionally, for any continuous exploration about this researching, that
suggested to utilize time which is allotted with regard to conducting the study sensibly. Efficient time period
administration enables experts to keep concentrate on their own function, adding to study efficiency. Period
management could be enhanced by simply planning the work schedule of which addresses the entire homework.
The study diary will consider just like a regular month-to-month work schedule, and even it may use a numer-
ous file format. Therefore, improving period supervision capabilities is important in order to building and even
preserving a highly effective system associated with analysis.
References
1. Abdulazeez, S., (2017). Human resource management practices and employee retention: a
Review of literature. Journal of economics, management and trade, 18(2), pp. 1-10.
2. Agustini, M. Y. D. H., (2018). Survey by knocking the door and response rate enhancement technique
in international business research. Problems and perspectives in management, 16(2), pp. 155-163.
3. Ahmed, N. O. A., (2016). Impact of human resource management practices on organisational citizen-
ship behaviour: An Empirical investigation from banking sector of Sudan. International review of man-
agement and marketing, 6(4), pp. 964-973.
4. Alghamdi, A. & Bach, C., (2018). Developing Teamwork at Workplace. International journal of busi-
ness and management invention, 7(2), pp. 28-40.
5. Aliyu, A. A. et al., (2014). Positivist and non-positivist paradigm in social science research conflicting
paradigm or perfect partners? Journal of management and sustainability, 4(3), pp. 79-59.
6. Amini, M., Amini, M., Ghodsi, M. & Rafiee, M., (2016). Evaluation of Relationship between Social
Self Concept, Organisational Identity and Organisational Citizenship Behaviour. Asian Social Science,
12(2).
7. Antonieta, S. L., Angel, M. V. & Nascimento, S.,(2017). Organisational commitment and job satisfac-
tion: a study with municipal civil servants. Brazilian Journal of public administration, 51(6), pp. 947-
967.
8. Azungah, T. (2018). Qualitative research: deductive and inductive approaches to data analysis. Quali-
tative Research Journal, 18 (4), pp.383-400.
9. Barikova Anna, Yan Bernaziuk. (2021). Electronic educational dimension of law enforcement in a
pandemic and post-pandemic World. Science, Education and Innovations in the Context of Modern
Problems Conference, Baku, Azerbaijan, November, 2021, 4(2), 91–104. https://doi.org/10.52-
81/zenodo.6299889
10. Banahene, S., Ahudey, E. & Asamoah, A.,(2017). The measurement of organisational citizenship be-
haviour and its impact on job satisfaction and loyalty among Christian workers in Ghana. International
journal of business marketing and management (IJBMM), 2(5), pp. 20-33.
11. Bellacicco, M. et al., (2019). Quantifying the Impact of Linear Regression Model in Deriving
12. Bio-Optical Relationships: The Implications on Ocean Carbon Estimations. Sensors, 19(13), pp. 55-93.

13. Eyupoglu, S. Z.,(2016). The organisational citizenship behaviour of academic staff in North Cyprus.
Procedia Economics and finance, 39(1), pp. 701-704.
14. Flavia, Z. D. & Poojary, S., (2018). Employee attitude towards organisational commitment: A literature
survey. Journal of business and management, 20(1), pp. 21-27.
15. Fukada, M.,(2018). Nursing competency: Definition, structure and development. Yonago Acta Med,
61(1), pp. 1-7.
16. Gautam, P. K., (2017). Issue of organisational commitment: Evidence from Nepalese banking industry.
Management Dynamics, 20(1), pp. 119-129.
17. Hai, L. C. & Rabenu, E.,(2018). The new era workplace relationships: Is social exchange theory still
relevant? Industrial and organisational psychology, 11(3), pp. 456-481.
18. Hasanuddin, R., & Sjahruddin, H. (2017). The Structure of Emotional Intelligence, Spiritual Intelli-
gence and Its Relationship with Work Enthusiasm and Auditor Performance. World Journal of Busi-
ness and Management, 3(1), 67.
19. Hassan, S., (2016). Impact of HRM practices on employee's performance. International journal of ac-
ademic research in Accounting, finance and management, 6(1), pp. 15-22.
20. Hee, O. C. et al.,(2019). The relationship between human resource management practices and job per-
formance in the courier service industry. International journal of academic research in business and
social sciences, 9(3), pp. 63-79.
21. Islam, T. U., (2019). Ranking of Normality Tests: An Appraisal through Skewed Alternative Space.
Symmetry, 11(1), pp. 1-14.
22. Kertarajasa, A. Y., Marwa, T. & Wahyudi, T.,(2019). The effect of competence, experience, independ-
ence, due professional care and auditor integrity on audit quality with auditor ethics as moderating var-
iable. Journal of accounting, finance and auditing studies, 5(1), pp. 80-99.
23. Khaldi, K.,(2017). Quantitative, qualitative or mixed research: which research paradigm to use. Journal
of educational and social research, 7(2), pp. 15-24.
24. Khoreva, V. & Wechtler, H., (2018). HR practices and employee performance: The mediating role of
well-being. Human resource management journal, 40(2), pp. 227-243.
25. Kim, B. & White, K., (2018). How can health professionals enhance interpersonal communication
with adolescents and young adults to improve health care outcomes?: systematic literature review. In-
ternational Journal of Adolescence and Youth, 23(2), pp. 62-119.
26. Korkmaz, M., (2019). A study over the Formulation of the Parameters 5 or Less Independent Variables
of Multiple Linear Regression. Journal of function spaces, 3(1), pp. 1-14.
27. Langgeng, S. R., Sutjahjo, G. & Adam, (2019). The contribution of competence, motivation, and crea-
tivity towards teacher’s performance through work satisfaction. International journal of engineering
and advanced technology, 8(5), pp. 145-149.
28. Mahajan, K., Shukla, S. & Soni, N., (2015). A Review of Computerized Payroll System. International
journal of advanced research in computer and communication engineering, 4(1), pp. 67-70.
29. Majid, M. & Ibrahim, A.,(2017). Measurement of organisational commitment and factors influencing
the level of commitment of employees-An empirical investigation of the higher education system. In-
ternational journal of management & business, 7(1), pp. 14-18.
30. Malmstrom, M. M. & Johansson, J.,(2016). Social exchange in collaborative innovation: maker or
beaker. Malmstrom and Johansson journal of innovation and entrepreneurship, 5(4), pp. 1-20.
31. Mansour, M.,(2015). The practice of strategic human resource management in a developing country.
European online journal of natural and social sciences, 4(3), pp. 500-517.
32. Mazur, B. (2015). Sustainable Human Resource Management. The attempt of Holistic Approach, Eco-
nomics & Management, 7(2), pp.7 -12.
33. Mena, L., (2015). Organisational commitment and organisational citizenship behaviour: Trend and re-
lationship. Intercontinental journal of human resource research review, 3(9), pp. 18-25.
34. Mon, Y. K., Myint, M. Y. & Ei, E. A., (2019). Forecasting Stock Market using Multiple Linear Re-
gression. International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development, 3(5), pp. 2174-2176.
35. Muthuraman, S. & Alhaziazi, M. (2017). Examining the factors of organisational citizenship behaviour
with reference to corporate sectors in Sultanate of Oman. International review of management and
marketing, 7(1), pp. 413-422.
36. Nijhuis, S., Vrijhoef, R. & Kessels, J., (2018). Tackling project management competence research.
Project management journal, 94(3), pp. 62-81.
37. Nkhukhu, E. O., Brown, B. & Rose, D. W., (2019). The affective commitment of academics in a uni-
versity in Botswana. International journal of educational administration and policy studies, 11(2), pp.
12-19.

38. Rahmawati, A.,(2017). Effect of competence on organisational citizenship behaviour and performance
management: The impact on organizational effectiveness. The international journal of engineering and
science, 6(11), pp. 74-85.
39. Owor, J. J.,(2015). HR practices and OCB : Mediating role of employee engagement in soft drink firms
in Uganda. International journal of business and social science, 6(9), pp. 159-170.
40. Ponto, J., (2015). Understanding and evaluating survey research. Journal of the advanced practitioner
in oncology, 6(2), pp. 168-171.
41. Radosavljevic, Z., Cilerdzic, V. & Dragic, M., (2017). Employee organisational commitment. Faculty
of business economics and entrepreneurship, 1(2), pp. 18-26.
42. Rahmawati, A.,(2017). Effect of competence on organisational citizenship behaviour and performance
management: The impact on organizational effectiveness. The international journal of engineering and
science, 6(11), pp. 74-85.
43. Riyadh, Y. M. & Mohammed, J. K.,(2018). Mediating role of stress between entrepreneurial leadership
and organisational citizenship behaviour: A case of entrepreneurial ventures in Iraq. International
Journal of Entrepreneurship, 22(1), pp. 73-117.
44. Russo, D. (2016). Competency measurement model. European conference on quality in official statis-
tic, 4(6), p. 22.
45. Sajilan, S., (2019). Network competence and firm performance: the mediating role of entrepreneurial
innovativeness among Malaysian Chinese entrepreneurs of wholesale businesses. Asian academic of
management journal, 24(1), pp. 187-201.
46. Sani, A. S., Maharani, V. E. & Masyhuri, M., (2019). The relationship among spiritual intelligence,
emotional intelligence, organisational citizenship behaviour and employee performance. Journal econ-
omy, 18(2), pp. 18-92.
47. Sadikhov Adil Fazil, Aliev Faiq Hasan (2022). Formation of the Moral needs in labor activities. Bank
and Policy, 2(2):58-65; DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.6387426
48. Sargolzaei, F. & Keshtegar, A. A.,(2015). The effect of psychological empowerment to improve em-
ployee's organisational citizenship behaviour (the study of Maskan bank branches management of
Zahedan city). Research journal of fisheries and hydrobiology, 10(9), pp. 605-611.
49. Sefotho, M. M., (2015). A researcher's Dilemma: philosophy in crafting dissertations and theses. Jour-
nal of social science, 42(1, 2), pp. 23-36.
50. Shyti, B. & Valera, D., (2018). The Regression Model for the Statistical Analysis of Albanian Econ-
omy. International journal of mathematics trends and technology, 62(2), pp. 90-94.
51. Sieberer, K. N., (2016). Effective Classroom-Management and Positive Teaching. Journal of English
language teaching, 9(1), pp. 163-172.
52. Spante, M., Sofkova, S. H., Lundin, M. & Algers, A.,(2018). Digital competence and digital literacy in
higher education research: Systematic review of concept use. Information and communication technol-
ogy in education, 5(1), pp. 1-21.
53. Statistic yearbook, (2018 ).National centre for statistics & information. [Online] Available
at:https://ncsi.gov.om/Elibrary/LibraryContentDoc/bar_Statistical%20Year%20Book%202018_a8b32d
59-cdc9-4987-ba29-1e7ce78d5cca.pdf [Accessed 18 March 2016].
54. Subramaniam, A. & Jasmin, N. N. H., (2017). Competencies, organisational citizenship behaviour, per-
son-job fit and job performance: Evidence from the narcotics control Bureau. International journal of
advanced biotechnology and research, 8(3), pp. 279-285.
55. Taber, K. S.,( 2018). The use of Cronbach's Alpha when developing and reporting research instruments
in Science education. Research in Science Education, 48(6), pp. 1273-1296.
56. Tahtali, Y., (2019). Use of factor scores in multiple regression analysis for estimation of body weight
by certain body measurements in Romanov Lambs. Peer, 2(1), pp. 1-11.
57. Tambe, S. & Shanker, M. (2014). A study of organisational citizenship behaviour (OCB) and its di-
mensions: a literature review. International Research Journal of Business and Management IRJBM, 1,
67-73.
58. Turek, D. & Turek, A. W., (2015). Do HRM practices influence organisational citizenship behaviour?
Mediating the role of person organisational fit. Technology, innovation and industrial journal , 3(1),
pp. 2219-2233.
59. Uzonwanne, F.,(2014). Organisational citizenship behaviour and demographic factors among oil work-
ers in Nigeria. Journal of humanities and social science, 19(8), pp. 87-95.
60. Wolowska, A.,(2014). Determinants of organisational commitment. Human resources management &
ergonomics, 8(1), pp. 129-146.
61. Xie, J., (2018). Research on the Performance and Governance. Open journal of social sciences,
6(1), pp. 106-118.

62. Woiceshyn, J. & Daellenbach, U., (2018). Evaluating inductive versus deductive research in manage-
ment studies: Implications for authors, editors and reviewers. Qualitative research in organizations and
management: an international journal, 13(2), pp. 183-195.
63. Yousef, D. A., (2017). Organisational commitment, job satisfaction and attitudes toward organisational
change: A study in the local government. International journal of public administration, 40(1), pp. 77-
88.
64. Zayas, M. O., Rosario, E., Marquez, E. & Colon, P. G., (2015). Relationship between organisational
commitments and organisational citizenship behaviour in a sample of private banking employees. In-
ternational Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 35(1), pp. 91-106.
65. Zehir, C., Uzmez, A. & Yildiz, H., (2016). The effect of SHRM practices on innovation performance:
The mediating role of global capabilities. Procedia social and behavioural sciences, 235(24), pp. 797-
806.
66. Zoller, Y. J. & Muldoon, J., (2019). Illuminating the principles of social exchange theory with Haw-
thorne studies. Journal of management history, 25(1), pp. 47-66.

full SEI 3, 2022.pdf

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Similar to full SEI 3, 2022.pdf

Similar to full SEI 3, 2022.pdf (20)

More from PublisherNasir

More from PublisherNasir (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

full SEI 3, 2022.pdf