1. CURRICULUM VITAE
Name: Ghulam Mustafa
Father’s Name: Sardar Khan
NIC No. 61101-3552879-7
Domicile: Sialkot, Punjab, Pakistan
Date of Birth: March 8, 1957
Date of Joining Govt Service: September 17, 1980
Qualification: IPDET (Carleton Univ, Canada), M.Phil. (Reprod. Physiol.), D.V.M.
Postal Address: House No. 73, Street 42, G-10/4, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Ph: 92-51-2302247
Office Address: Deputy Chief, Food and Agriculture Section, M/o Planning,
Development & Reform, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad.
Phone: 92-51-9245084, E-mail: mustafa_47@yahoo.com
Mobile: 92-321-5861081
II. MEMBERSHIP: i) Representing Developing Countries, served on the Steering Committee of the Network of
Networks on Impact Evaluation (NONIE)
ii) International Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS), Johannesburg, South
Africa
iii) European Evaluation Society, CZECH-IN, Prague Congress Centre, 5. kvetna 65,
140 21 Prague 4, Czech Republic
iv) Remained Board Member of International Organization for Collaborative Outcome
Management (IOCOM) for four years
v) Pakistan Evaluation Network (PEN)
vi) Community of Evaluators (CoE) Pakistan
vii) Represented Developing Countries on the Nominating Committee of the International
Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie) in 2012 for appointment of Board Commissioners.
III. PROFESSIONAL TRAINING, CERTIFICATION, ETC.
Course/Diploma/Certificate Duration Institution
Poultry Extension Course
Micro Computer Programming Course
Promotion Course
Planning Tools
Financial Management of Projects
Leadership Development
Project Analysis and Management
Sustainable Agriculture
Good Governance
Use of CPM/PERT in Project Management
Andrology/Assisted Reproduction (Embryo
Transfer Technology)
International Program for Development
Evaluation Training (IPDET) 2009
7-26 February 1981
26 July to 4 September 1999
27 March to 6 April 2002
25-27 July 2002
3-6 February 2003
22-24 December 2003
8-13 March 2004
21-26 June 2004
30 Aug. to 12 Sep., 2004
26-28 May 2005
14 Nov. to 3 Dec., 2005
8 June to 3 July 2009
Poultry Research Institute, Karachi,
Pakistan.
Pakistan Computer Bureau, Islamabad.
Pakistan Planning and Management
Institute (PPMI), Islamabad, Pakistan.
-do-
-do-
-do-
-do-
APO Japan at Colombo, Sri Lanka.
SAARC HRDC, Islamabad, Pakistan.
PPMI, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Institute of Reproductive Medicine,
Münster, Germany.
Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada.
IV. DETAILS OF EXPERIENCE

2. NAME AND
ADDRESS OF
ORGANIZATION
POST HELD
WITH BASIC
PAY SCALE
PERIOD
FROM TO
NATURE OF WORK
M/o Planning,
Development &
Reform (Food &
Agriculture
Section), Islamabad.
Deputy Chief,
BPS 19
Oct 2015 to date i ) Preparation of Annual and Long-Term
Plans for development of agriculture
including livestock and fisheries.
ii) Appraisal of projects for agricultural
development, particularly the development
projects involving Livestock and Fisheries.
iii) Allocation of funds on annual basis for the
projects for development of agriculture
including livestock and fisheries.
iv) Rendering advice to the Government of
Pakistan on policy issues in development of
agriculture including livestock and fisheries.
v) Evaluation of research proposals for studies
on agriculture, livestock and fisheries.
vi) Monitoring and evaluation of development
projects of Agri, Livestock and Fisheries.
vi) Supervision of the work of one Assistant
Chief.
M/o Planning,
Development &
Reform (Public
Investment
Authorization
Section), Islamabad.
Deputy Chief,
BPS 19
Oct 2014 to Oct 2015 i) Initial scrutiny of project documents for
deciding on their circulation among CDWP
members or return to sponsors.
iii) Coordination with Federal Ministries and
Provincial Government for holding of
meetings of Central Development
Working Party (CDWP).
iii)Coordination with other Sections and
Wings of M/o PD&R for preparation of
working papers for the CDWP and
Summaries for the Executive Committees of
National Economic Council (ECNEC).
iv)Coordination with the Cabinet Division for
holding of meetings of the ECNEC.
v) Assisting the Chief on policy decisions
regarding powers of different fora for
approval of projects.
vi) Preparation of Annual Progress Report of
the CDWP and ECNEC.
vii) Supervision of the work of four Assistant
Chiefs.
Earthquake
Reconstruction and
Rehabilitation
Authority (ERRA),
Prime Minister’s
Secretariat (Public),
Islamabad.
Director, BPS
19, Project
Evaluation Cell
Oct 2009 to Oct 2014 i) Evaluation of projects for reconstruction
and rehabilitation related to education, health,
communication, power, government
buildings, social protection, livelihoods,
environment, etc.
ii) Allocation of funds for the reconstruction
projects.
iii) Revision of Operational Manual of ERRA.
iv) Supervision of the work of 1-2 Deputy
Directors.
-do- Deputy
Director, BPS
18
May 2008 to Oct. 2009 i) Preparation of Rules for project preparation
and approval.
ii) Evaluation of projects for reconstruction
and rehabilitation of education, health,
communication, power, government
buildings, social protection, livelihoods,
environment, etc.
iii) Monitoring of implementation progress of
projects.
Earthquake
Reconstruction and
Rehabilitation
Authority (ERRA),
Director, BPS
19, Project
Evaluation Cell
(Current
9-12-2006 to May 2008 i) Evaluation of projects for reconstruction
and rehabilitation related to education, health,
communication, power, government
buildings, social protection, livelihoods,
environment, etc.
ii) Allocation of funds for the reconstruction

3. NAME AND
ADDRESS OF
ORGANIZATION
POST HELD
WITH BASIC
PAY SCALE
PERIOD
FROM TO
NATURE OF WORK
Prime Minister’s
Secretariat (Public),
Islamabad.
Charge) projects.
iii) Revision of Operational Manual of ERRA.
iv) Supervision of the work of 1-2 Deputy
Directors.
Earthquake
Reconstruction and
Rehabilitation
Authority (ERRA),
Prime Minister’s
Secretariat (Public),
Islamabad.
Deputy
Director, BPS
18
19-6-2006 to 8-12-2006 i) Preparation of Rules for project preparation
and approval.
ii) Evaluation of projects for reconstruction
and rehabilitation of education, health,
communication, power, government
buildings, social protection, livelihoods,
environment, etc.
iii) Monitoring of implementation progress of
projects.
-do- Deputy Chief,
BPS 19,
(Current
Charge)
9-5-2006 to18-6-2006 1). Preparation of Annual and Long-Term
Plans for development of livestock and
fisheries.
2). Appraisal of projects for agricultural
development, particularly the development
projects involving Livestock and Fisheries.
3). Allocation of funds on annual basis for the
projects for development of livestock and
fisheries.
4). Rendering advice to the Government of
Pakistan on policy issues in development
of livestock and fisheries.
5). Evaluation of research proposals for
studies on livestock and fisheries.
6). Monitoring and evaluation of development
projects.
Government of
Pakistan, Planning
and Development
Division
(Agriculture &
Food Section),
Islamabad.
Assistant Chief,
BPS 18
November 2001 to 8
May 2006
1). Preparation of Annual and Long-
Term Plans for development of
agriculture.
2). Appraisal of projects for agricultural
development, particularly the
development projects involving
Agricultural Extension, Research,
Oilseeds, Marketing, Livestock and
Fisheries.
3). Allocation of funds on annual basis
for the projects for development of
agriculture.
4). Rendering advice to the Government
of Pakistan on policy issues in
development of agriculture.
5). Evaluation of research proposals for
studies on agriculture.
6) Impact evaluation of projects.
7) Monitoring and evaluation of projects
for development of agriculture. I have
been monitoring the progress of the
following projects:

4. NAME AND
ADDRESS OF
ORGANIZATION
POST HELD
WITH BASIC
PAY SCALE
PERIOD
FROM TO
NATURE OF WORK
a). Crop Maximization Project,
costing Rs. 500.00 million.
b). National Programme for
Improvement of Watercourses, costing
Rs. 66.373 billion.
c). Strengthening of Veterinary
Services for Livestock Diseases
Control in Pakistan: Eradication of
Rinderpest, costing Rs 1992.85
million.
FAO-EU IPM Program
for Cotton in Asia
(Pakistan)
(Consultancy)
National
Consultant (GCP/
RAS/164/EC)
November 2001 Preparation of a project for Integrated
Pest Management (IPM). The project
was prepared in one month time and
was approved by Government of
Pakistan at a total cost of Rs. 200.00
million. It envisages training of farmers
in IPM technology.
M/o Planning,
Development &
Reform (Public
Investment
Authorization
Section), Islamabad.
Deputy Chief,
BPS 19,
(Current
Charge)
May 2000 Nov. 2001 a). Appraisal, monitoring and evaluation
of projects for agricultural
development, particularly, the
development projects relating to Seed
Production, Soil and Water
Conservation, Plant Protection, Food
Security, etc.
b). Overall coordination of the work of
Agriculture and Food Section.
c). Allocation of funds on annual basis
for the projects for sustainable
development of agriculture.
d). Supervise the work of two Assistant
Chiefs.
Government of
Pakistan, Planning
and Development
Division
(Agriculture &
Food Section),
Islamabad.
Assistant Chief,
BPS 18
17-12-1992 May
2000
a). Preparation of Annual and Long-
Term Plans for development of
agriculture of Pakistan.
b). Appraisal of projects for sustainable
agricultural development of Pakistan,
particularly the development projects
involving training of farmers
(Agricultural Extension), Agricultural
Research, Oilseeds, Agricultural
Marketing, Livestock and Fisheries.
c). Allocation of funds on annual basis
for the projects for development of
agriculture.
d). Rendering advice to the Government
of Pakistan on policy issues in
development of agriculture.
e) Evaluation of research proposals for
studies on agriculture.
Government of
Pakistan, Planning
and Development
Division
(Agriculture &
Food Section),
Islamabad.
Research
Officer, BPS 17
1-4-1986 16-12-1992 a). Preparation of Annual and Long-
Term Plans for sustainable
development of agriculture of
Pakistan.
b). Appraisal of projects for sustainable
agricultural development of Pakistan,
particularly the development projects
involving training of farmers

5. NAME AND
ADDRESS OF
ORGANIZATION
POST HELD
WITH BASIC
PAY SCALE
PERIOD
FROM TO
NATURE OF WORK
(Agricultural Extension), Agricultural
Research, Oilseeds, Agricultural
Marketing, Livestock and Fisheries.
c). Allocation of funds on annual basis
for the projects for sustainable
development of agriculture.
Government of the
Punjab, Livestock and
Dairy Development
Department (L&DD Dept.),
Poultry Development Centre,
Punjab, Rawalpindi, Poultry
Production Gujranwala (1-10-
1984 to 30-11- 1985), and
Poultry Production Sialkot (1-
12-1985 to 31-3-1986)
Veterinary
Officer
(Health), BPS
17
17-9-1980 31-3-1986 Implementation of FAO/UNDP
funded project of establishment of
Poultry Development Centre,
Punjab, Rawalpindi, for mitigating
deficiency of protein in the
province.
SEMINARS/WORKSHOPS/SYMPOSIA:
(i) High Quality, Equity-Focused & Gender Responsive Evaluations, Joint PPMI-UNICEF workshop,
Islamabad, Pakistan, Apr 19-20, 2016.
(ii) The 4th International Conference on National Evaluation Capacities on the theme “Blending Evaluation
Principles with Development Practices to Change People’s Lives: Evaluating Sustainable Human
Development - A Global Evaluation Agenda” organized by Independent Evaluation Office of UNDP, in
partnership with the Royal Thai Government (RTG) and jointly conducted with the International
Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS) Global Assembly 2015 at Millennium Hilton Hotel,
Bangkok, Thailand, Oct 26-30, 2015.
(iii) International Conference on “Making Impact Evaluation Matter” held in Manila at the Asian
Development Bank HQ, 6 ADB Avenue, Mandaluyong City 1550, Metro Manila, the Philippines, Sep 1‐5,
2014.
(iv) Members Conference and Board Meeting of International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie) held in
Washington, DC, USA, at Beacon Hotel, 1615 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20036, April 7-
10,
2014.
(v) Members Conference and Board Meeting of International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie) held in
London at 36 Gordon Square, London International Development Centre, London WC1H 0PD, April 13-
15, 2013.
(vi) The 6th
NONIE conference organized by United Nations Evaluation Group (UNEG) at FAO Headquarters,
Rome, Italy, April 19-20, 2012.
(vii) International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie) Board Meeting and Members Conference, Rome, Italy,
April 16-18, 2012.
(viii) International Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS) Global Assembly,
Kempinski Hotel Amman, Abdul Hamid Shouman Street – Shmeisani, Amman, Jordan, April 11-15, 2011.
(ix) The 5th
NONIE conference organized by AFD at Centre Etoile Saint Honoré, 21/25 rue Balzac, 75008
Paris, France, March 28-29, 2011.
(x) Helped organize a two day workshop on impact evaluation by Planning Commission of Pakistan in
collaboration with International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie), at Islamabad, Pakistan, January 17-
18, 2011.
(xi) The 9th
European Evaluation Society International Conference, Prague, Czech Republic October 6-8, 2010.

6. (xii) Annual Meeting of NONIE held at Bonn, Germany March 29-30, 2010
(xiii) Represented Government of Pakistan at the Annual Members’ Conference of 3ie held at OECD, Paris,
France, February12, 2010.
(xiv) International Conference on Perspectives on Impact Evaluation: Approaches to assessing development
effectiveness, Semiramis Hotel, Cairo, Egypt, jointly organized by NONIE, AfrEA, 3ie and UNICEF,
March 29 –April 2, 2009.
(xv) Building for the future: Evaluation in governance, development and progress, EES Biennial Conference,
Lisbon, Portugal, October 1-3, 2008.
(xvi) Integrated Pest Management Policy and Planning Meeting, Lahore, Pakistan, jointly organized by FAO and
MINFAL, Government of Pakistan, November 24-25, 2000.
(xvii) Pesticide Policy Workshop, Bhurban, Pakistan, May 1-2, 2001, jointly organized by FAO and MINFAL,
Government of Pakistan.
(xviii) Prospects of Dairy Industry in Pakistan, Islamabad, Pakistan, organized by Experts Advisory Cell, Ministry
of Industries, Government of Pakistan, December 11, 2003.
(xix) Development of Livestock Policies and Action Plans, Islamabad, Pakistan, jointly organized by FAO and
MINFAL, Government of Pakistan, June 2, 2004.
SKILLS: Excellent skills in using MSDOS 6.2,Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows XP, MS Word, MS
Excel, MS PowerPoint, MSTAT C, SYSTAT, Lotus 7.0, QBASIC, FoxPro, etc. Use of internet and
E-mail is a routine.
Review: Impact of Rural Water Supply and Sanitation in Punjab, Pakistan, Independent Evaluation Department,
Asian Development Bank, 2009.
Research Publications:
1). Mustafa G, Anzar M and Arslan M. Separation of Motile Spermatozoa from Frozen Thawed Buffalo Semen: Swim-up vs
Filtration Procedures. Theriogenology 1998; 50:205-211.
2). Anzar M, Rasul Z, Ahmad N, Mustafa G and Shafique P. Effect of Stages of Cryopreservation on Motion Characteristics,
Plasma Membrane Integrity and Acrosome Morphology of Buffalo Spermatozoa (Presented at the 31st Annual Meeting of the
Society for the Study of Reproduction, August 8-11, 1998, at Texas, USA).
3). Mustafa G. In Vitro Capacitation of Buffalo Spermatozoa. M.Phil. Dissertation, Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad, 1994.
4). Mian AA, Mustafa G and Qureshi MS. Effect of Different Doses of Insemination on the Fertility of Domestic Hens. Pak. Vet.
J. 1990; 10:22-24.
5). Mian AA, Mustafa G, Bhatti BM and Qureshi MS. Effect of Frequency of Insemination on Fertility and Hatchability of Eggs
in Laying Hens. Pak. J. Agric. Res. 1989; 10:163-168.
6). Aslam M and Mustafa G. Resource Gap in Economic Growth - Dependence on External Resources. Journal of the
Institute of Bankers in Pakistan, Dec., 1989.
References:
i) Dr. Shujat Ali, Special Secretary, Finance Division, Islamabad. Ph: 92-51-9201023
ii) Dr Aamer Irshad, Chief, Food and Agriculture Section, M/o Planning, Development & Reform, Islamabad. Ph: 92-51-
9245087.

7. (xii) Annual Meeting of NONIE held at Bonn, Germany March 29-30, 2010
(xiii) Represented Government of Pakistan at the Annual Members’ Conference of 3ie held at OECD, Paris,
France, February12, 2010.
(xiv) International Conference on Perspectives on Impact Evaluation: Approaches to assessing development
effectiveness, Semiramis Hotel, Cairo, Egypt, jointly organized by NONIE, AfrEA, 3ie and UNICEF,
March 29 –April 2, 2009.
(xv) Building for the future: Evaluation in governance, development and progress, EES Biennial Conference,
Lisbon, Portugal, October 1-3, 2008.
(xvi) Integrated Pest Management Policy and Planning Meeting, Lahore, Pakistan, jointly organized by FAO and
MINFAL, Government of Pakistan, November 24-25, 2000.
(xvii) Pesticide Policy Workshop, Bhurban, Pakistan, May 1-2, 2001, jointly organized by FAO and MINFAL,
Government of Pakistan.
(xviii) Prospects of Dairy Industry in Pakistan, Islamabad, Pakistan, organized by Experts Advisory Cell, Ministry
of Industries, Government of Pakistan, December 11, 2003.
(xix) Development of Livestock Policies and Action Plans, Islamabad, Pakistan, jointly organized by FAO and
MINFAL, Government of Pakistan, June 2, 2004.
SKILLS: Excellent skills in using MSDOS 6.2,Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows XP, MS Word, MS
Excel, MS PowerPoint, MSTAT C, SYSTAT, Lotus 7.0, QBASIC, FoxPro, etc. Use of internet and
E-mail is a routine.
Review: Impact of Rural Water Supply and Sanitation in Punjab, Pakistan, Independent Evaluation Department,
Asian Development Bank, 2009.
Research Publications:
1). Mustafa G, Anzar M and Arslan M. Separation of Motile Spermatozoa from Frozen Thawed Buffalo Semen: Swim-up vs
Filtration Procedures. Theriogenology 1998; 50:205-211.
2). Anzar M, Rasul Z, Ahmad N, Mustafa G and Shafique P. Effect of Stages of Cryopreservation on Motion Characteristics,
Plasma Membrane Integrity and Acrosome Morphology of Buffalo Spermatozoa (Presented at the 31st Annual Meeting of the
Society for the Study of Reproduction, August 8-11, 1998, at Texas, USA).
3). Mustafa G. In Vitro Capacitation of Buffalo Spermatozoa. M.Phil. Dissertation, Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad, 1994.
4). Mian AA, Mustafa G and Qureshi MS. Effect of Different Doses of Insemination on the Fertility of Domestic Hens. Pak. Vet.
J. 1990; 10:22-24.
5). Mian AA, Mustafa G, Bhatti BM and Qureshi MS. Effect of Frequency of Insemination on Fertility and Hatchability of Eggs
in Laying Hens. Pak. J. Agric. Res. 1989; 10:163-168.
6). Aslam M and Mustafa G. Resource Gap in Economic Growth - Dependence on External Resources. Journal of the
Institute of Bankers in Pakistan, Dec., 1989.
References:
i) Dr. Shujat Ali, Special Secretary, Finance Division, Islamabad. Ph: 92-51-9201023
ii) Dr Aamer Irshad, Chief, Food and Agriculture Section, M/o Planning, Development & Reform, Islamabad. Ph: 92-51-
9245087.