SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 99
DIAGNOSTICS
FOR OBSERVATION and DAMPING
of E-P INSTABILITY
Vadim Dudnikov
FERMILAB, December 2005
Motivation
 For observation and damping of e-p and
ion-beam instability it is important to use
adequate diagnostics
 For verification of computer codes for instability
simulation it is important to have a reliable experimental
date in simple conditions.
 Experiments in small scale low energy rings can be used
for quantitative verification of simulation codes and for
development of methods for instability damping .
 Informative diagnostics is important for collection of
necessary information.
Outline
 e-p instability: historical remarks and references
 Small scale Proton Storage Rings
 Diagnostics
 Observations
 Damping of e-p instability
 Production of a stable space charge compensated
circulating beam with high intensity
Abstract
 Diagnostics for observation, identification and damping of instabilities driven
by interaction with secondary plasma in storage rings and synchrotrons will
be considered.
 Clearing electrodes, fast gauges, fast valves, fast extractors, repulsing
electrodes, electron and ion collectors with retarding grids, particle
spectrometers used for the detection of secondary particle generation and
secondary particle identification will be discussed.
 Features of electrostatic and magnetic dipole and quadrupole pickups will
be presented.
 The influence of nonlinear generation of secondary plasma in driving and
stabilization of e-p instability will be discussed.
 Observations of anomaly in secondary particle generation will be presented.
 Conditions for accumulation of proton beam with intensity greater than
space charge limit will be discussed.
Two-stream instability, historical remarks
 Beam instability due to compensating particles were
first observed with coasting proton beam and long proton
bunches at the Novosibirsk INP(1965), the CERN
ISR(1971), and the Los Alamos PSR(1986)…
 Recently two-stream instability was observed in almost
all storage rings with high beam intensity.
 Observation of two-stream instability in different
conditions will be reviewed.
 Diagnostics and damping of two-stream instability will be
discussed.
Two-stream instability
 Beam interaction with elements of accelerator and secondary
plasma can be the reason for instabilities, causing limited beam
performance.
 Improving of vacuum chamber design and reducing of impedance by
orders of magnitude relative with earlier accelerators increases
threshold intensity for impedance instability.
 Two-stream effects (beam interaction with a secondary plasma)
become a new limitation on the beam intensity and brightness.
Electron and Antiproton beams are perturbed by accumulated
positive ions.
 Proton and positron beams may be affected by electrons or negative
ions generated by the beam. These secondary particles can induce
very fast and strong instabilities.
 These instabilities become more severe in accelerators and storage
rings operating with high current and small bunch spacing.
This instability is a problem for heavy ion inertial fusion,
but ion beam with higher current density can be more
stable.
Instability can be a reason of fast pressure rise include electron
stimulated gas desorbtion, ion desorbtion, and beam loss/halo
scraping. Beam induced pressure rise had limited beam
intensity in CERN ISR and LEAR. Currently, it is a limiting
factor in RHIC, AGS Booster, and GSI SIS. It is a relevant
issue at SPS, LANL PSR, and B-factories. For projects under
construction and planning, such as SNS, LHC, LEIR, GSI
upgrade, and heavy ion inertial fusion, it is also of concern.
Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics
www.inp.nsk.su
First project of proton/antiproton collider VAPP, in
the Novosibirsk INP (BINP), 1960
 Development of charge-exchange injection (and
negative ion sources) for high brightness proton beam
production. First observation of e-p instability.
 Development of Proton/ Antiproton converter.
 Development of electron cooling for high brightness
antiproton beam production.
 Production of space charge neutralized proton beam
with intensity above space charge limit. Inductance
Linac, Inertial Fusion, Neutron Generators.
History of Charge Exchange Injection
(Graham Rees, ISIS , ICFA Workshop)
1. 1951 Alvarez, LBL (H-) ;
1956 Moon, Birmingham Un. (H+2)
2. 1962-66 Budker, Dimov, Dudnikov, Novosibirsk ;
first achievements; discovery of e-p instability.IPM
3. 1968-70 Ron Martin, ANL ; 50 MeV injection at ZGS
4. 1972 Jim Simpson, ANL ; 50-200 MeV, 30 Hz booster
5. 1975-76 Ron Martin et al, ANL ; 6 1012 ppp
6. 1977 Rauchas et al, ANL ; IPNS 50-500 MeV, 30 Hz
7. 1978 Hojvat et al, FNAL ; 0.2-8 GeV, 15 Hz booster
8. 1982 Barton et al, BNL ; 0.2-29 GeV, AGS
9. 1984 First very high intensity rings ; PSR and ISIS
10. 1980,85,88 IHEP, KEK booster, DESY III (HERA)
11. 1985-90 EHF, AHF and KAON design studies. SSC
12. 1992 AGS 1.2 GeV booster injector
13. 1990's ESS, JHF and SNS 4-5 MW sources
History of
Surface Plasma Sources
Development
BDD, G.Budker, G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov
Charge-Exchange Injection
INP Novosibirsk, 1965, bunched beam
first observation of an e- driven instability?
coherent betatron oscillations & beam loss
with bunched proton beam; threshold ~1-1.5x1010,
circumference 2.5 m, stabilized by feedback
(G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, 1965).
F. Zimmermann
Other INP PSR 1967:
coasting
beam instability
suppressed by
increasing beam
current;
fast accumulation of
secondary plasma
is essential for
stabilization;
1.8x1012 in 6 m
V. Dudnikov, PAC2001,
PAC2005
• Damped by extensive system of electrostatic clearing electrodes
ISR, coasting proton beam, ~1972
(R. Calder, E. Fischer, O. Grobner, E. Jones)
excitation of nonlinear
resonances; gradual
beam blow up similar
to multiple scattering
beam induced signal
from a pick up showing
coupled e-p oscillation;
beam current is 12 A and
beam energy 26 GeV
2x10-11 Torr,
3.5% neutralization,
DQ=0.015
PSR instability, 1988
(D. Neuffer et al, R. Macek et al.)
beam loss on time scale
of 10-100 ms above
threshold bunch charge
of 1.5x1013,
circumference 90 m,
transverse oscillations
at 100 MHz frequency
beam current and vertical oscillations;
hor. scale is 200 ms/div.
AGS Booster, 1998/99 (M.Blaskiewicz)
coasting beam
vertical instability
growth time ~3 ms
~100 MHz
downward shift as
instability progresses
beam current [A]
500 ms
-500 ms
5
y power density
0.2 GHz
time
KEKB e+ beam blow up, 2000 (H. Fukuma, et al.)
threshold of fast
vertical blow up
slow growth
below threshold?
beam current, mA
IP spot size
half of solenoids on
all solenoids off
all solenoids on
Vacuum pressure read-
out vs. total current as
recorded in four straight
section locations for the
electron (blue dots) and
positron (red dots) rings.
Evidence of electron cloud build-up in
DAFNE (PAC05, FPAP001,002)
Vacuum pressure
read-out vs. total
current as
recorded in 2
straight section of
the positron ring
where a
50 G solenoid field
was turned on (red
dots) and off
(blue dots).
Evidence of electron cloud build-up in
DAFNE (PAC05, FPAP001)
Electron cloud build-up
along two bunch trains
for the drift downstream
of the arc: a) simple drift,
b) drift with residual
magnetic field of By≈ .1 T,
c) drift with a 50
G solenoid. (Primary
electron rate dλe/ds=
0.26)
Simulation of electron cloud build-up in DAFNE
(PAC05, FPAP001)
Why no e-p Instability in the ISIS?
Exotic vacuum chamber? Defocusing,
scattering of secondary electrons? Collect
electrons as black body?
ISIS has much larger a and b, and low particle density. Bounce
frequency is low . Only low modes of betatron oscillations are
unstable. This lead to removing of electrons without beam loss.
References
www.google.com two-stream transverse instability…
http://wwwslap.cern.ch/collective/electron-cloud/.
Historical remark
V.Dudnikov.Ph.D.thesis,1966
References for first observation of e-p instability
 V.Dudnikov, “The intense proton beam accumulation in storage ring by charge-
exchange injection method”, Ph.D.Thesis, Novosibirsk INP,1966.
 G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experiments on production of intense proton
beam by charge exchange injection method” in Proceedings of International
Symposium on Electron and Positron Storage Ring, France,Sakley,1966, rep. VIII,
6.1 (1966).
 G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experimental investigation of the intense proton
beam accumulation in storage ring by charge- exchange injection method”, Soviet
Atomic Energy, 22, 384 (1967).
 G.Budker, G.Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Experiments on electron
compensation of proton beam in ring accelerator”, Proc.VI Intern. Conf. On High
energy accelerators, 1967, MIT & HU,A-104, CEAL-2000, (1967).
 G.I.Dimov, V.G.Dudnikov,V.G.Shamovsky, ” Transverse instability of a proton beam
due to coherent interaction with a plasma in a circular accelerator” Soviet
Conference on Charge- particle accelerators”,Moscow,1968, translation from
Russian, 1 1973 108565 8.
 G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Investigation of the secondary charged
particles influence on the proton beam dynamic in betatron mode ”, Soviet Atomic
Energy, 29,353 (1969).
 Yu.Belchenko, G.Budker, G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov, et al. X PAC,1977.
 O.Grobner, X PAC,1977.
 E. Colton, D. Nuffer, G. Swain, R.Macek, et al., Particle Accelerators, 23,133
(1988).
Models of two-stream instability
 The beam- induces electron cloud buildup and development of
two-stream e-p instability is one of major concern for all projects
with high beam intensity and brightness [1,2].
 In the discussing models of e-p instability, transverse beam
oscillations is excited by relative coherent oscillation of beam
particles (protons, ions, electrons) and compensating particles
(electrons,ions) [3,4,5].
 For instability a bounce frequency of electron’s oscillation in
potential of proton’s beam should be close to any mode of
betatron frequency of beam in the laboratory frame.
1. http://wwwslap.cern.ch/collective/electron-cloud/.
2. http://conference.kek.jp/two-stream/.
3. G.I.Budker, Sov.Atomic Energy, 5,9,(1956).
4. B.V. Chirikov, Sov.Atomic.Energy,19(3),239,(1965).
5. Koshkarev, Zenkevich, Particle Accelerators, (1971).
6. M.Giovannozzi, E.Metral, G.Metral, G.Rumolo,and F. Zimmerman , Phys.Rev.
ST-Accel. Beams,6,010101,(2003).
Memo from: Bruno Zotter
www.aps.anl.gov/conferences/icfa/twoo-stream/
 Subject: Summary of my own conclusions of the
workshop
 1) Go on with your plans to coat the most sensitive
locations in the PSR (Al stripper chamber, sections with
ceramics and with high losses) with Ti nitride - make
sure that the deposition technique avoids rapid flaking
off;
 2) If this is not sufficiently successful, install a transverse
feedback system based on the wide-band split cylinder
pickups - Dudnikov showed an example where a simple
feedback seemed to work fine on e-p. If the oscillations
are kept sufficiently small by it, there may be no need for
high power;
Development of Charge Exchange Injection and Production of
Circulating Beam with Intensity Greater than Space Charge Limit
V.Dudnikov. “Production of an intense proton beam in storage ring by a charge- exchange injection method”,
Novosibirsk, Ph.D.Thesis,INP, 1966.
Development of a Charge- Exchange Injection; Accumulation of proton beam up to space charge limit; Observation and damping of
synchrotron oscillation; Observation and damping of the coherent transverse instability of the bunched beam. Observation of the e-p
instability of coasting beam in storage ring.
G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experiments on production of intense proton beam by charge exchange injection method” in
Proceedings of International Symposium on Electron and Positron Storage Ring, France,Sakley,1966, rep. VIII, 6.1 (1966).
G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experimental investigation of the intense proton beam accumulation in storage ring by charge-
exchange injection method”, Soviet Atomic Energy, 22, 384 (1967).
G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov, “Determination of circulating proton current and current density distribution (residual gas ionization profile
monotor)”, Instrum. Experimental Techniques, 5, 15 (1967).
Dimov. “Charge- exchange injection of protons into accelerators and storage rings”, Novosibirsk, INP, 1968.
Development of a Charge- Exchange Injection; Accumulation of a proton beam up to the space charge limit; Observation and
damping of synchrotron oscillations; Observation and damping of the coherent transverse instability of the bunched beam;.
Shamovsky. “Investigation of the Interaction of the circulating proton beam with a residual gas”, Novosibirsk, INP, 1972.
Observation of transverse e-p coherent instability of the coasting beam in the storage ring, Observation of a transverse Herward’s
instability, Damping of instabilities, Accumulation of a proton beam with a space charge limit.
G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Transverse instability of the proton beam induced by coherent interaction with plasma in
cyclic accelerators”, Trudy Vsesousnogo soveschaniya po uskoritelyam, Moskva, 1968, v. 2, 258 (1969).
G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Investigation of the secondary charged particles influence on the proton beam dynamic in
betatron mode ”, Soviet Atomic Energy, 29,353 (1969).
G.Budker, G.Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Experiments on electron compensation of proton beam in ring accelerator”,
Proc.VI Intern. Conf. On High energy accelerators, 1967, MIT & HU,A-104, CEAL-2000, (1967).
Chupriyanov. “Production of intense compensated proton beam in an accelerating ring”, Novosibirsk, INP, 1982.
Observation and damping transverse coherent e-p instability of coasting proton beam and production of the proton beam with an
intensity up to 9.2 time above a space charge limit.
G.Dimov, V.Chupriyanov, “Compensated proton beam production in an accelerating ring at a current above the space charge limit”,
Particle accelerators, 14, 155- 184 (1984). Yu.Belchenko, G.Budker, G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov, et al.X PAC,1977.
General view of INP PSR
with charge exchange injection 1965
1. Magnet
2. Vacuum chamber
3. Beam line
5. First stripping target
6. Second stripping target
INP PSR for bunched beam accumulation by
charge exchange injection
1- fist stripper;
2- main stripper Pulsed
supersonic jet;
3- gas pumping;
4- pickup integral;
5- accelerating drift tube;
6- gas luminescent profile
Monitor;
7- Residual gas current
monitor;
8- residual gas IPM;
9- BPM;
10- transformer Current
monitor;
11- FC;
12- deflector for Suppression
transverse instability by
negative Feedback.
Small Radius- High beam density. Revolution 5.3 MHz. 1MeV, 0.5 mA, 1 ms.
PSR for Circulating p-Beam Production
1-striping gas target;
2-gas pulser;
3-FC;
4-Q screen;
5,6-moving targets;
7-ion collectors;
8-current monitor;
9-BPM;
10-Q pick ups;
11-magnetic BPM;
12-beam loss monitor;
13-detector of secondary particles
density;
14-inductor core;
15-gas pulsers;
16-gas leaks.
Proton Energy -1 MeV; injection-up to 8 mA; bending radius-42 cm; magnetic field-3.5 kG;index-
n=0.2-0.7; St. sections-106 cm;aperture-4x6 cm; revolution-1.86 MHz; circulating current up to
300mA is up to 9 time greater than a space charge limit.
Vacuum control
 Stripping target- high dense supersonic hydrogen
jet (density up to e19 mol/cm3, target e17 mol/cm2 , ~1ms)
 Vacuum e-5 Torr
 Fast, open ion gauges
 Fast compact gas valves, opening of 0.1 ms.
Fast, compact gas valve, 0.1ms, 0.8 kHz,
tested for >109Pulses, operate 12 Years in BNL H- magnetron SPS
1 -current feedthrough;
2- housing; 3-clamping
screw; 4-coil; 5- magnet
core; 6-shield; 7-screw;
8-copper insert; 9-yoke;
10-rubber washer-
returning springs;
11-ferromagnetic plate-
armature; 12-viton stop;
13-viton seal; 14-sealing
ring; 15-aperture;
16-base; 17-nut.
Photograph of a fast, compact gas valve
Proton beam accumulation for different injection
current (0.1-0.5 mA)
Injected beam
Circulating beam,
Low injection current
Start saturation
Strong saturation
Residual gas ionization beam current & profile
monitors (ICM,IPM),1965
Residual gas luminescent beam profile monitor,
INP,1965
1- magnetic pole;
2- proton beam;
3- moving collimator
4- light guide;
5-photomultiplier;
6-vacuum chamber
Beam profiles evolution during accumulation
F.Zimmermann
F.Zimmermann
Modern IPM (DESY)
Fermilab IPM
 Mark-II details
Secondary Screen Grid
RF Shield Over MCP
J.Zagel
Internal Structure, FNAL IPM
 Main Injector
 Electrostatic Unit
J.Zagel
Signal and Timing
 Typical Amplified Strip Signal
 Relative to Beam Sync Clock
(Captured in Recycler)
J.Zagel
Interesting Observations
 Plate Discoloration from
long term exposure to beam
 Diamondlike film deposition
CERN Luminescence Profile Monitor
 It works with N2 injection
1 light channel is going to a PM for
gas-luminescence studies (decay
time etc.)
 2 channels are used for profile
measurements:
 The H channel is in air: it showed
high background with LHC
beam, due to beam losses
 The V channel is in vacuum
 The MCP has a pre-programmed
variable gain over cycle
(it showed some problems to log on
timing events)
Beam
H & V Reference Screens
PM Tube
V profile MCP & CCD
H profile MCP & CCD
N2
injection
Filters
CERN IPM inside
CERN Beam profile. The Fitting Strategies
Sigma=1.750 mm --
Sigma=1.852 mm --
%
2
.
11
%
6
.
5
sigma 
D


D 
Secondary Particles detector with repeller,
INP,1967
Mass Spectrum of Ions from the Beam
Integral Signal (bottom), Differential Signal (top)
Ion Detection System for High Vacuum Storage Rings.
ANL Fast collector with repeller
Electron Sweep detector for Quadrupoles. ( R. Macek, LA NL)
Inductive BPM, INP,1967
Signals and spectrum from inductive BPM
Inductive BPM (DESY)
Transverse instability in the INP PSR,
bunched beam (1965)
Transverse instability of bunched beam in
INP PSR (1965)
Transverse instability of bunched beam with a high
RF voltage
1-ring pickup, peak bunch
intensity ;
2-radial loss monitor.
 Beam was deflected
after Instability loss.
 Two peaks structure
of beam after
instability loss.
 Only central part of
the beam was lost
Evolution of bunches profiles in INP PSR
1- 0.05 ms(100 turns);
2- 0.4 ms(1000 turns);
3- 0.8 ms (3000 turns);
4- 2.8 ms, before start
transverse instability.
Bunches period 188 ns
coasting beam injection
Transverse instability in Los Alamos PSR, bunched
beam (1986)
e-p instability in LA PSR, bunched beam
Macek, LANL
Pickup signals and electron current in LA PSR
R.Macek, LANL
Electron signal and proton loss in LA PSR
R.Macek, LANL
PSR for beam accumulation with inductive
acceleration
1-first stripper;
2-magnet pole n=0.6;
3-hollow copper torus
with inductance current;
4-main stripper;
5-accelerating gap;
6-ring pickup;
7-BPMs;
8-Res.gas IPM;
9-vacuum chamber.
FC; quartz screens;
Retarding electron and
ion collectors/
spectrometers .
e-p instability with a low threshold in INP PSR
1-beam current, N>7e9p
2-beam potential, slow
Accumulation of electrons
10mcs, and fast loss 1mcs.
3-retarding electron
collector;
4,5-ion collector, ionizing
Current Monitor;
6,7-ion Collectors Beam
potential monitor;
8,9- negative mass
Instability.
Injection:
Coasting beam, 1MeV,
0.1mA
R=42 cm.
Instability of coasting beam in AG PSR, 1967
1- beam current
monitor;
2- vertical proton
loss monitor;
3- radial proton loss;
4- detected signal of
vertical BPM.
20 mcs/div.
e-p instability of coasting beam in the INP PSR
(1967)
e-p instability of coasting beam in LA PSR,1986
INP PSR for beam above space charge limit
Small Scale Proton Storage Ring for Accumulation of
Proton Beam with Intensity Greater than
Space Charge Limit
Beam accumulation with clearing voltage
 Secondary plasma
accumulation
suppressed by strong
transverse electric field.
 Vertical instability with
zero mode oscillation
was observed
(Herward instability).
Threshold intensity N (left) and growth rate J (right) of
instability as function of gas density n
a- hydrogen; b- helium; c- air.
Spectrums of coasting beam instability in BINP
PSR (magnetic BPM)
Spectrums transverse beam instability in LA PSR
R.Macek, LANL
Beam accumulation with space charge
neutralization
Ionization cross sections for H
Proton beam accumulation with intensity above
space charge limit
Proton beam accumulation with intensity grater
than space charge limit.
Dependence of injection current.
Beam accumulation with a plasma generator
on
off
Basic parameters and threshold of the neutralization factor
for e-p instability of the proton rings (coasting beams)
Threshold of neutralization factor for
coasting beam
JPARC-MR PSR ISIS AGS FNAL-MI KEK-PS
L(m) 1567.5 90 163 202 3319 339
g 50.9 1.85 1.07 1.2 128 12.8
Np(x1013) 33 3 3 1.8 3 0.3
lp (x1011/m) 2.1 3.3 1.8 0.89 0.09 0.089
sr(cm) 0.35 1 3.8 1 0.17 0.5
 -0.0013 -0.187 -0.83 -0.65 0.002 0.022
Dp/p(%) 0.25 0.4 0.5 0.5 0.03 0.3
weL/c 7739 195 69 226 6970 246
fth 0.0015 0.025 0.45 0.15 0.00055 0.05
Build-up time due to ionization for the
instability
 Ionization (2x10-7 Pa)
Y1,i=8x10-9e-/(m.p)
t= fth/cY1,i =0.4 fth
 JPARC-MR 0.6ms
 PSR 10 ms instability is observed
 ISIS 180 ms no instability
 AGS booster 60 ms instability
 AGS 10 ms no instability
 FNAL-MI 0.2 ms
 KEK-PS 20 ms no instability
Fast Ion-beam instability of H- beam in FNAL Linac
BPM
signals
after
preinjector
0.75 MeV
50mA
Transverse instability in FNAL Booster, DC B,
Coasting beam. Injection 400MeV, 45 mA.
E-p instabilty in Fermilab booster
BPM signal
Beam intensity
Secondary electron generation in the FERMILAB
booster, normal acceleration
Observation of anomaly in secondary electron
generation in the FERMILAB Booster
 Observation of secondary particles in the booster proton beam are presented in the
Booster E-Log at 04/06/01 .
 Reflecting plate of the Vertical Ionization Profile Monitor (VIPM) was connected to the
1 MOhm input of oscilloscope (Channel 2).
 To channel 1 is connected a signal of proton beam Charge monitor Qb, with
calibration of 2 E12 p/V.
 Oscilloscope tracks of the proton beam intensity Qb (uper track) and current of
secondary particles (electrons) Qe (bottom track) are shown in Fig. 1 in time scale 5
ms/div (left) and 0.25 ms/ div (right).
 The voltage on MCP plate is Vmcp=-200 V.
 It was observed strong RF signal induced by proton beam with a gap ( one long
bunch). For intensity of proton beam Qb< 4E12 p electron current to the VIPM plate
is low ( Qe< 0.1 V~ 1E-7 A) as corresponded to electron production by residual gas
ionization by proton beam.
 For higher proton beam intensity (Qb> 4E12p) the electron current to the VIPM plate
increase significantly up to Qe=15 V~ 15 E-6 A as shown in the bottom
oscillogramms. This current is much greater of electron current produced by simple
residual gas ionization. This observation present an evidence of formation of high
density of secondary particles in high intense proton beam in the booster, as in Los
Alamos PSR and other high intense rings.
 Intense formation of secondary particles is important for the beam behavior and
should be taken into account in the computer simulation.
Instability in the Tevatron
Instability in Tevatron
Instability in RHIC, from PAC03
Cold emission of electrons from electrodes with dielectric films
CATHODE DEPOSITS INDUCE DISCHARGES: cold emission
POSITIVE IONS ACCUMULATION
CREATES HIGH DIPOLE FIELD, INDUCING
ELECTRON EXTRACTION (MALTER
EFFECT) or sparks
+ ++++++ +
- -
DEPOSITS
Instrumentation for observation and damping of
e-p instability
 1. Observation of plasma (electrons) generation and correlation with an instability
development. Any insulated clearing electrodes could be used for detection of
sufficient increase of the electron density. More sophisticated diagnostics (from ANL)
is used for this application in the LANL PSR. These electrodes in different location
could be used for observation of distribution of the electron generation.
 2. For determination an importance compensating particles it is possible to use a
controlled triggering a surface breakdown by high voltage pulse on the beam pipe
wall or initiation unipolar arc. Any high voltage feedthrough could be used for
triggering of controlled discharge. Could this break down initiate an instability?
 3. For suppression of plasma production could be used an improving of surface
properties around the proton beam. Cleaning of the surface from a dust and
insulating films for decrease a probability of the arc discharge triggering. Deposition
of the films with a low secondary emission as TiN, NEG. Transparent mesh near the
wall could be used for decrease an efficient secondary electron emission and
suppression of the multipactor discharge. Biased electrodes could be used for
suppressing of the multipactor discharge, as in a high voltage RF cavity.
 4. Diagnostics of the circulating beam oscillation by fast (magnetic) beam position
monitors (BPM).
 5. Local beam loss monitor with fast time resolution. Fast scintillator, pin diodes.
 6. Transverse beam instability is sensitive to the RF voltage. Increase of the RF
voltage is increase a delay time for instability development and smaller part of the
beam is involved in the unstable oscillation development.
 7. Instability sensitive to sextuple and octupole component of magnetic field,
chromaticity (Landau Damping), …
Electron generation and suppression
 Gas ionization by beam and by secondary electrons.
 Photoemission excited by SR.
 Secondary emission, RF multipactor,ion-electron emiss.
 Cold emission; Malter effect; Unipolar arc discharge
(explosion emission). Artificial triggering of arc.
 Suppression:
 1-clearind electrodes; Ultra high vacuum.
 Gaps between bunches.
 Low SEY coating: TiN, NEG.
 Transverse magnetic field.
 Arc resistant material
Conclusion
 Experimental dates from small scale rings can
be used for verification of computer simulation.
 Stabilization of space charge compensated
proton beam with a high intensity has been
observed.
 It is useful to use low energy proton ring for
investigation e-p instability.

More Related Content

Similar to 2DIAGNOSTICSe-p.ppt

Highly mismatched alloys for optoelectronics
Highly mismatched alloys for optoelectronicsHighly mismatched alloys for optoelectronics
Highly mismatched alloys for optoelectronicsMohammadreza Nematollahi
 
Ion beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TEST
Ion beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TESTIon beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TEST
Ion beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TESTMircea Chipara
 
Nuclear chemistry and Radioactivity
Nuclear chemistry and RadioactivityNuclear chemistry and Radioactivity
Nuclear chemistry and RadioactivityVarinderKhepar
 
A pn junction can be used as a.pdf
A pn junction can be used as a.pdfA pn junction can be used as a.pdf
A pn junction can be used as a.pdfbkbk37
 
poster2016 final ver. archie & wae
poster2016 final ver. archie & waeposter2016 final ver. archie & wae
poster2016 final ver. archie & waeAchbold Jugdersuren
 
Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018
Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018
Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018Toma Susi
 
Atomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular Dichroism
Atomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular DichroismAtomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular Dichroism
Atomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular DichroismRiccardo Di Stefano
 
Nuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawat
Nuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawatNuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawat
Nuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawatAyush Kumawat
 
Modeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and Radiation
Modeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and RadiationModeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and Radiation
Modeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and RadiationIJPEDS-IAES
 
Swift Heavy Ion Irradiation
Swift Heavy Ion IrradiationSwift Heavy Ion Irradiation
Swift Heavy Ion Irradiationkrishslide
 
Analysis of Pseudogap in Superconductors
Analysis of Pseudogap in SuperconductorsAnalysis of Pseudogap in Superconductors
Analysis of Pseudogap in SuperconductorsIOSR Journals
 

Similar to 2DIAGNOSTICSe-p.ppt (20)

Highly mismatched alloys for optoelectronics
Highly mismatched alloys for optoelectronicsHighly mismatched alloys for optoelectronics
Highly mismatched alloys for optoelectronics
 
SNBoseTalk06
SNBoseTalk06SNBoseTalk06
SNBoseTalk06
 
Ion beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TEST
Ion beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TESTIon beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TEST
Ion beam irradiation of polycarbonate_TEST
 
nbigagli_00393293223155
nbigagli_00393293223155nbigagli_00393293223155
nbigagli_00393293223155
 
Nuclear chemistry and Radioactivity
Nuclear chemistry and RadioactivityNuclear chemistry and Radioactivity
Nuclear chemistry and Radioactivity
 
A pn junction can be used as a.pdf
A pn junction can be used as a.pdfA pn junction can be used as a.pdf
A pn junction can be used as a.pdf
 
Search for Neutron Electric Dipole Moment
Search for Neutron Electric Dipole MomentSearch for Neutron Electric Dipole Moment
Search for Neutron Electric Dipole Moment
 
poster2016 final ver. archie & wae
poster2016 final ver. archie & waeposter2016 final ver. archie & wae
poster2016 final ver. archie & wae
 
Birkan - Space Propulsion and Power - Spring Review 2013
Birkan - Space Propulsion and Power - Spring Review 2013Birkan - Space Propulsion and Power - Spring Review 2013
Birkan - Space Propulsion and Power - Spring Review 2013
 
s41566-021-00813-y.pdf
s41566-021-00813-y.pdfs41566-021-00813-y.pdf
s41566-021-00813-y.pdf
 
Peizolelectric Sensors Explained
Peizolelectric Sensors ExplainedPeizolelectric Sensors Explained
Peizolelectric Sensors Explained
 
Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018
Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018
Toma Susi – Atom manipulation @ MRS2018
 
Serena barbanotti INFN milano
Serena barbanotti INFN milanoSerena barbanotti INFN milano
Serena barbanotti INFN milano
 
thesis
thesisthesis
thesis
 
Poster
PosterPoster
Poster
 
Atomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular Dichroism
Atomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular DichroismAtomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular Dichroism
Atomic Plane Resolution Electron Magnetic Circular Dichroism
 
Nuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawat
Nuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawatNuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawat
Nuclear magnetic resonance by ayush kumawat
 
Modeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and Radiation
Modeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and RadiationModeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and Radiation
Modeling the Dependence of Power Diode on Temperature and Radiation
 
Swift Heavy Ion Irradiation
Swift Heavy Ion IrradiationSwift Heavy Ion Irradiation
Swift Heavy Ion Irradiation
 
Analysis of Pseudogap in Superconductors
Analysis of Pseudogap in SuperconductorsAnalysis of Pseudogap in Superconductors
Analysis of Pseudogap in Superconductors
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.
Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.
Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.aasikanpl
 
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...Sérgio Sacani
 
Behavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdf
Behavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdfBehavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdf
Behavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdfSELF-EXPLANATORY
 
Luciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptx
Luciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptxLuciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptx
Luciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptxAleenaTreesaSaji
 
Boyles law module in the grade 10 science
Boyles law module in the grade 10 scienceBoyles law module in the grade 10 science
Boyles law module in the grade 10 sciencefloriejanemacaya1
 
Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST
Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOSTDisentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST
Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOSTSérgio Sacani
 
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...RohitNehra6
 
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptxGFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptxAleenaTreesaSaji
 
Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?
Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?
Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?Patrick Diehl
 
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43bNightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43bSérgio Sacani
 
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptxPhysiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptxAArockiyaNisha
 
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​kaibalyasahoo82800
 
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdfA relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdfnehabiju2046
 
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCESTERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCEPRINCE C P
 
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docxScheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docxyaramohamed343013
 
Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...
Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...
Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...jana861314
 
Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)
Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)
Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)PraveenaKalaiselvan1
 
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroidsHubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroidsSérgio Sacani
 
NAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdf
NAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdfNAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdf
NAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdfWadeK3
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.
Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.
Call Girls in Mayapuri Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝9953322196🔝 💯Escort.
 
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
PossibleEoarcheanRecordsoftheGeomagneticFieldPreservedintheIsuaSupracrustalBe...
 
Behavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdf
Behavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdfBehavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdf
Behavioral Disorder: Schizophrenia & it's Case Study.pdf
 
Luciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptx
Luciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptxLuciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptx
Luciferase in rDNA technology (biotechnology).pptx
 
Boyles law module in the grade 10 science
Boyles law module in the grade 10 scienceBoyles law module in the grade 10 science
Boyles law module in the grade 10 science
 
Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST
Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOSTDisentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST
Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST
 
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
 
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptxGFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
 
Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?
Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?
Is RISC-V ready for HPC workload? Maybe?
 
Engler and Prantl system of classification in plant taxonomy
Engler and Prantl system of classification in plant taxonomyEngler and Prantl system of classification in plant taxonomy
Engler and Prantl system of classification in plant taxonomy
 
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43bNightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
 
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptxPhysiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
 
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​
 
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdfA relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
 
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCESTERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
 
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docxScheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
Scheme-of-Work-Science-Stage-4 cambridge science.docx
 
Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...
Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...
Traditional Agroforestry System in India- Shifting Cultivation, Taungya, Home...
 
Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)
Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)
Recombinant DNA technology (Immunological screening)
 
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroidsHubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
 
NAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdf
NAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdfNAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdf
NAVSEA PEO USC - Unmanned & Small Combatants 26Oct23.pdf
 

2DIAGNOSTICSe-p.ppt

  • 1. DIAGNOSTICS FOR OBSERVATION and DAMPING of E-P INSTABILITY Vadim Dudnikov FERMILAB, December 2005
  • 2. Motivation  For observation and damping of e-p and ion-beam instability it is important to use adequate diagnostics  For verification of computer codes for instability simulation it is important to have a reliable experimental date in simple conditions.  Experiments in small scale low energy rings can be used for quantitative verification of simulation codes and for development of methods for instability damping .  Informative diagnostics is important for collection of necessary information.
  • 3. Outline  e-p instability: historical remarks and references  Small scale Proton Storage Rings  Diagnostics  Observations  Damping of e-p instability  Production of a stable space charge compensated circulating beam with high intensity
  • 4. Abstract  Diagnostics for observation, identification and damping of instabilities driven by interaction with secondary plasma in storage rings and synchrotrons will be considered.  Clearing electrodes, fast gauges, fast valves, fast extractors, repulsing electrodes, electron and ion collectors with retarding grids, particle spectrometers used for the detection of secondary particle generation and secondary particle identification will be discussed.  Features of electrostatic and magnetic dipole and quadrupole pickups will be presented.  The influence of nonlinear generation of secondary plasma in driving and stabilization of e-p instability will be discussed.  Observations of anomaly in secondary particle generation will be presented.  Conditions for accumulation of proton beam with intensity greater than space charge limit will be discussed.
  • 5. Two-stream instability, historical remarks  Beam instability due to compensating particles were first observed with coasting proton beam and long proton bunches at the Novosibirsk INP(1965), the CERN ISR(1971), and the Los Alamos PSR(1986)…  Recently two-stream instability was observed in almost all storage rings with high beam intensity.  Observation of two-stream instability in different conditions will be reviewed.  Diagnostics and damping of two-stream instability will be discussed.
  • 6. Two-stream instability  Beam interaction with elements of accelerator and secondary plasma can be the reason for instabilities, causing limited beam performance.  Improving of vacuum chamber design and reducing of impedance by orders of magnitude relative with earlier accelerators increases threshold intensity for impedance instability.  Two-stream effects (beam interaction with a secondary plasma) become a new limitation on the beam intensity and brightness. Electron and Antiproton beams are perturbed by accumulated positive ions.  Proton and positron beams may be affected by electrons or negative ions generated by the beam. These secondary particles can induce very fast and strong instabilities.  These instabilities become more severe in accelerators and storage rings operating with high current and small bunch spacing.
  • 7. This instability is a problem for heavy ion inertial fusion, but ion beam with higher current density can be more stable. Instability can be a reason of fast pressure rise include electron stimulated gas desorbtion, ion desorbtion, and beam loss/halo scraping. Beam induced pressure rise had limited beam intensity in CERN ISR and LEAR. Currently, it is a limiting factor in RHIC, AGS Booster, and GSI SIS. It is a relevant issue at SPS, LANL PSR, and B-factories. For projects under construction and planning, such as SNS, LHC, LEIR, GSI upgrade, and heavy ion inertial fusion, it is also of concern.
  • 8. Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics www.inp.nsk.su
  • 9. First project of proton/antiproton collider VAPP, in the Novosibirsk INP (BINP), 1960  Development of charge-exchange injection (and negative ion sources) for high brightness proton beam production. First observation of e-p instability.  Development of Proton/ Antiproton converter.  Development of electron cooling for high brightness antiproton beam production.  Production of space charge neutralized proton beam with intensity above space charge limit. Inductance Linac, Inertial Fusion, Neutron Generators.
  • 10. History of Charge Exchange Injection (Graham Rees, ISIS , ICFA Workshop) 1. 1951 Alvarez, LBL (H-) ; 1956 Moon, Birmingham Un. (H+2) 2. 1962-66 Budker, Dimov, Dudnikov, Novosibirsk ; first achievements; discovery of e-p instability.IPM 3. 1968-70 Ron Martin, ANL ; 50 MeV injection at ZGS 4. 1972 Jim Simpson, ANL ; 50-200 MeV, 30 Hz booster 5. 1975-76 Ron Martin et al, ANL ; 6 1012 ppp 6. 1977 Rauchas et al, ANL ; IPNS 50-500 MeV, 30 Hz 7. 1978 Hojvat et al, FNAL ; 0.2-8 GeV, 15 Hz booster 8. 1982 Barton et al, BNL ; 0.2-29 GeV, AGS 9. 1984 First very high intensity rings ; PSR and ISIS 10. 1980,85,88 IHEP, KEK booster, DESY III (HERA) 11. 1985-90 EHF, AHF and KAON design studies. SSC 12. 1992 AGS 1.2 GeV booster injector 13. 1990's ESS, JHF and SNS 4-5 MW sources
  • 11. History of Surface Plasma Sources Development BDD, G.Budker, G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov Charge-Exchange Injection
  • 12. INP Novosibirsk, 1965, bunched beam first observation of an e- driven instability? coherent betatron oscillations & beam loss with bunched proton beam; threshold ~1-1.5x1010, circumference 2.5 m, stabilized by feedback (G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, 1965). F. Zimmermann Other INP PSR 1967: coasting beam instability suppressed by increasing beam current; fast accumulation of secondary plasma is essential for stabilization; 1.8x1012 in 6 m V. Dudnikov, PAC2001, PAC2005
  • 13. • Damped by extensive system of electrostatic clearing electrodes ISR, coasting proton beam, ~1972 (R. Calder, E. Fischer, O. Grobner, E. Jones) excitation of nonlinear resonances; gradual beam blow up similar to multiple scattering beam induced signal from a pick up showing coupled e-p oscillation; beam current is 12 A and beam energy 26 GeV 2x10-11 Torr, 3.5% neutralization, DQ=0.015
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18. PSR instability, 1988 (D. Neuffer et al, R. Macek et al.) beam loss on time scale of 10-100 ms above threshold bunch charge of 1.5x1013, circumference 90 m, transverse oscillations at 100 MHz frequency beam current and vertical oscillations; hor. scale is 200 ms/div.
  • 19. AGS Booster, 1998/99 (M.Blaskiewicz) coasting beam vertical instability growth time ~3 ms ~100 MHz downward shift as instability progresses beam current [A] 500 ms -500 ms 5 y power density 0.2 GHz time
  • 20. KEKB e+ beam blow up, 2000 (H. Fukuma, et al.) threshold of fast vertical blow up slow growth below threshold? beam current, mA IP spot size half of solenoids on all solenoids off all solenoids on
  • 21. Vacuum pressure read- out vs. total current as recorded in four straight section locations for the electron (blue dots) and positron (red dots) rings. Evidence of electron cloud build-up in DAFNE (PAC05, FPAP001,002)
  • 22. Vacuum pressure read-out vs. total current as recorded in 2 straight section of the positron ring where a 50 G solenoid field was turned on (red dots) and off (blue dots). Evidence of electron cloud build-up in DAFNE (PAC05, FPAP001)
  • 23. Electron cloud build-up along two bunch trains for the drift downstream of the arc: a) simple drift, b) drift with residual magnetic field of By≈ .1 T, c) drift with a 50 G solenoid. (Primary electron rate dλe/ds= 0.26) Simulation of electron cloud build-up in DAFNE (PAC05, FPAP001)
  • 24. Why no e-p Instability in the ISIS? Exotic vacuum chamber? Defocusing, scattering of secondary electrons? Collect electrons as black body?
  • 25. ISIS has much larger a and b, and low particle density. Bounce frequency is low . Only low modes of betatron oscillations are unstable. This lead to removing of electrons without beam loss.
  • 26. References www.google.com two-stream transverse instability… http://wwwslap.cern.ch/collective/electron-cloud/.
  • 28. References for first observation of e-p instability  V.Dudnikov, “The intense proton beam accumulation in storage ring by charge- exchange injection method”, Ph.D.Thesis, Novosibirsk INP,1966.  G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experiments on production of intense proton beam by charge exchange injection method” in Proceedings of International Symposium on Electron and Positron Storage Ring, France,Sakley,1966, rep. VIII, 6.1 (1966).  G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experimental investigation of the intense proton beam accumulation in storage ring by charge- exchange injection method”, Soviet Atomic Energy, 22, 384 (1967).  G.Budker, G.Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Experiments on electron compensation of proton beam in ring accelerator”, Proc.VI Intern. Conf. On High energy accelerators, 1967, MIT & HU,A-104, CEAL-2000, (1967).  G.I.Dimov, V.G.Dudnikov,V.G.Shamovsky, ” Transverse instability of a proton beam due to coherent interaction with a plasma in a circular accelerator” Soviet Conference on Charge- particle accelerators”,Moscow,1968, translation from Russian, 1 1973 108565 8.  G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Investigation of the secondary charged particles influence on the proton beam dynamic in betatron mode ”, Soviet Atomic Energy, 29,353 (1969).  Yu.Belchenko, G.Budker, G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov, et al. X PAC,1977.  O.Grobner, X PAC,1977.  E. Colton, D. Nuffer, G. Swain, R.Macek, et al., Particle Accelerators, 23,133 (1988).
  • 29. Models of two-stream instability  The beam- induces electron cloud buildup and development of two-stream e-p instability is one of major concern for all projects with high beam intensity and brightness [1,2].  In the discussing models of e-p instability, transverse beam oscillations is excited by relative coherent oscillation of beam particles (protons, ions, electrons) and compensating particles (electrons,ions) [3,4,5].  For instability a bounce frequency of electron’s oscillation in potential of proton’s beam should be close to any mode of betatron frequency of beam in the laboratory frame. 1. http://wwwslap.cern.ch/collective/electron-cloud/. 2. http://conference.kek.jp/two-stream/. 3. G.I.Budker, Sov.Atomic Energy, 5,9,(1956). 4. B.V. Chirikov, Sov.Atomic.Energy,19(3),239,(1965). 5. Koshkarev, Zenkevich, Particle Accelerators, (1971). 6. M.Giovannozzi, E.Metral, G.Metral, G.Rumolo,and F. Zimmerman , Phys.Rev. ST-Accel. Beams,6,010101,(2003).
  • 30. Memo from: Bruno Zotter www.aps.anl.gov/conferences/icfa/twoo-stream/  Subject: Summary of my own conclusions of the workshop  1) Go on with your plans to coat the most sensitive locations in the PSR (Al stripper chamber, sections with ceramics and with high losses) with Ti nitride - make sure that the deposition technique avoids rapid flaking off;  2) If this is not sufficiently successful, install a transverse feedback system based on the wide-band split cylinder pickups - Dudnikov showed an example where a simple feedback seemed to work fine on e-p. If the oscillations are kept sufficiently small by it, there may be no need for high power;
  • 31.
  • 32. Development of Charge Exchange Injection and Production of Circulating Beam with Intensity Greater than Space Charge Limit V.Dudnikov. “Production of an intense proton beam in storage ring by a charge- exchange injection method”, Novosibirsk, Ph.D.Thesis,INP, 1966. Development of a Charge- Exchange Injection; Accumulation of proton beam up to space charge limit; Observation and damping of synchrotron oscillation; Observation and damping of the coherent transverse instability of the bunched beam. Observation of the e-p instability of coasting beam in storage ring. G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experiments on production of intense proton beam by charge exchange injection method” in Proceedings of International Symposium on Electron and Positron Storage Ring, France,Sakley,1966, rep. VIII, 6.1 (1966). G. Budker, G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, “Experimental investigation of the intense proton beam accumulation in storage ring by charge- exchange injection method”, Soviet Atomic Energy, 22, 384 (1967). G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov, “Determination of circulating proton current and current density distribution (residual gas ionization profile monotor)”, Instrum. Experimental Techniques, 5, 15 (1967). Dimov. “Charge- exchange injection of protons into accelerators and storage rings”, Novosibirsk, INP, 1968. Development of a Charge- Exchange Injection; Accumulation of a proton beam up to the space charge limit; Observation and damping of synchrotron oscillations; Observation and damping of the coherent transverse instability of the bunched beam;. Shamovsky. “Investigation of the Interaction of the circulating proton beam with a residual gas”, Novosibirsk, INP, 1972. Observation of transverse e-p coherent instability of the coasting beam in the storage ring, Observation of a transverse Herward’s instability, Damping of instabilities, Accumulation of a proton beam with a space charge limit. G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Transverse instability of the proton beam induced by coherent interaction with plasma in cyclic accelerators”, Trudy Vsesousnogo soveschaniya po uskoritelyam, Moskva, 1968, v. 2, 258 (1969). G. Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Investigation of the secondary charged particles influence on the proton beam dynamic in betatron mode ”, Soviet Atomic Energy, 29,353 (1969). G.Budker, G.Dimov, V. Dudnikov, V. Shamovsky, “Experiments on electron compensation of proton beam in ring accelerator”, Proc.VI Intern. Conf. On High energy accelerators, 1967, MIT & HU,A-104, CEAL-2000, (1967). Chupriyanov. “Production of intense compensated proton beam in an accelerating ring”, Novosibirsk, INP, 1982. Observation and damping transverse coherent e-p instability of coasting proton beam and production of the proton beam with an intensity up to 9.2 time above a space charge limit. G.Dimov, V.Chupriyanov, “Compensated proton beam production in an accelerating ring at a current above the space charge limit”, Particle accelerators, 14, 155- 184 (1984). Yu.Belchenko, G.Budker, G.Dimov, V.Dudnikov, et al.X PAC,1977.
  • 33. General view of INP PSR with charge exchange injection 1965 1. Magnet 2. Vacuum chamber 3. Beam line 5. First stripping target 6. Second stripping target
  • 34. INP PSR for bunched beam accumulation by charge exchange injection 1- fist stripper; 2- main stripper Pulsed supersonic jet; 3- gas pumping; 4- pickup integral; 5- accelerating drift tube; 6- gas luminescent profile Monitor; 7- Residual gas current monitor; 8- residual gas IPM; 9- BPM; 10- transformer Current monitor; 11- FC; 12- deflector for Suppression transverse instability by negative Feedback. Small Radius- High beam density. Revolution 5.3 MHz. 1MeV, 0.5 mA, 1 ms.
  • 35. PSR for Circulating p-Beam Production 1-striping gas target; 2-gas pulser; 3-FC; 4-Q screen; 5,6-moving targets; 7-ion collectors; 8-current monitor; 9-BPM; 10-Q pick ups; 11-magnetic BPM; 12-beam loss monitor; 13-detector of secondary particles density; 14-inductor core; 15-gas pulsers; 16-gas leaks. Proton Energy -1 MeV; injection-up to 8 mA; bending radius-42 cm; magnetic field-3.5 kG;index- n=0.2-0.7; St. sections-106 cm;aperture-4x6 cm; revolution-1.86 MHz; circulating current up to 300mA is up to 9 time greater than a space charge limit.
  • 36. Vacuum control  Stripping target- high dense supersonic hydrogen jet (density up to e19 mol/cm3, target e17 mol/cm2 , ~1ms)  Vacuum e-5 Torr  Fast, open ion gauges  Fast compact gas valves, opening of 0.1 ms.
  • 37. Fast, compact gas valve, 0.1ms, 0.8 kHz, tested for >109Pulses, operate 12 Years in BNL H- magnetron SPS 1 -current feedthrough; 2- housing; 3-clamping screw; 4-coil; 5- magnet core; 6-shield; 7-screw; 8-copper insert; 9-yoke; 10-rubber washer- returning springs; 11-ferromagnetic plate- armature; 12-viton stop; 13-viton seal; 14-sealing ring; 15-aperture; 16-base; 17-nut.
  • 38. Photograph of a fast, compact gas valve
  • 39. Proton beam accumulation for different injection current (0.1-0.5 mA) Injected beam Circulating beam, Low injection current Start saturation Strong saturation
  • 40. Residual gas ionization beam current & profile monitors (ICM,IPM),1965
  • 41. Residual gas luminescent beam profile monitor, INP,1965 1- magnetic pole; 2- proton beam; 3- moving collimator 4- light guide; 5-photomultiplier; 6-vacuum chamber
  • 42. Beam profiles evolution during accumulation
  • 46. Fermilab IPM  Mark-II details Secondary Screen Grid RF Shield Over MCP J.Zagel
  • 47. Internal Structure, FNAL IPM  Main Injector  Electrostatic Unit J.Zagel
  • 48. Signal and Timing  Typical Amplified Strip Signal  Relative to Beam Sync Clock (Captured in Recycler) J.Zagel
  • 49. Interesting Observations  Plate Discoloration from long term exposure to beam  Diamondlike film deposition
  • 50. CERN Luminescence Profile Monitor  It works with N2 injection 1 light channel is going to a PM for gas-luminescence studies (decay time etc.)  2 channels are used for profile measurements:  The H channel is in air: it showed high background with LHC beam, due to beam losses  The V channel is in vacuum  The MCP has a pre-programmed variable gain over cycle (it showed some problems to log on timing events) Beam H & V Reference Screens PM Tube V profile MCP & CCD H profile MCP & CCD N2 injection Filters
  • 52. CERN Beam profile. The Fitting Strategies Sigma=1.750 mm -- Sigma=1.852 mm -- % 2 . 11 % 6 . 5 sigma  D   D 
  • 53. Secondary Particles detector with repeller, INP,1967
  • 54. Mass Spectrum of Ions from the Beam Integral Signal (bottom), Differential Signal (top)
  • 55. Ion Detection System for High Vacuum Storage Rings.
  • 56. ANL Fast collector with repeller
  • 57. Electron Sweep detector for Quadrupoles. ( R. Macek, LA NL)
  • 59. Signals and spectrum from inductive BPM
  • 61. Transverse instability in the INP PSR, bunched beam (1965)
  • 62. Transverse instability of bunched beam in INP PSR (1965)
  • 63. Transverse instability of bunched beam with a high RF voltage 1-ring pickup, peak bunch intensity ; 2-radial loss monitor.  Beam was deflected after Instability loss.  Two peaks structure of beam after instability loss.  Only central part of the beam was lost
  • 64. Evolution of bunches profiles in INP PSR 1- 0.05 ms(100 turns); 2- 0.4 ms(1000 turns); 3- 0.8 ms (3000 turns); 4- 2.8 ms, before start transverse instability. Bunches period 188 ns coasting beam injection
  • 65. Transverse instability in Los Alamos PSR, bunched beam (1986)
  • 66. e-p instability in LA PSR, bunched beam Macek, LANL
  • 67. Pickup signals and electron current in LA PSR R.Macek, LANL
  • 68. Electron signal and proton loss in LA PSR R.Macek, LANL
  • 69. PSR for beam accumulation with inductive acceleration 1-first stripper; 2-magnet pole n=0.6; 3-hollow copper torus with inductance current; 4-main stripper; 5-accelerating gap; 6-ring pickup; 7-BPMs; 8-Res.gas IPM; 9-vacuum chamber. FC; quartz screens; Retarding electron and ion collectors/ spectrometers .
  • 70. e-p instability with a low threshold in INP PSR 1-beam current, N>7e9p 2-beam potential, slow Accumulation of electrons 10mcs, and fast loss 1mcs. 3-retarding electron collector; 4,5-ion collector, ionizing Current Monitor; 6,7-ion Collectors Beam potential monitor; 8,9- negative mass Instability. Injection: Coasting beam, 1MeV, 0.1mA R=42 cm.
  • 71. Instability of coasting beam in AG PSR, 1967 1- beam current monitor; 2- vertical proton loss monitor; 3- radial proton loss; 4- detected signal of vertical BPM. 20 mcs/div.
  • 72. e-p instability of coasting beam in the INP PSR (1967)
  • 73. e-p instability of coasting beam in LA PSR,1986
  • 74. INP PSR for beam above space charge limit
  • 75. Small Scale Proton Storage Ring for Accumulation of Proton Beam with Intensity Greater than Space Charge Limit
  • 76. Beam accumulation with clearing voltage  Secondary plasma accumulation suppressed by strong transverse electric field.  Vertical instability with zero mode oscillation was observed (Herward instability).
  • 77. Threshold intensity N (left) and growth rate J (right) of instability as function of gas density n a- hydrogen; b- helium; c- air.
  • 78. Spectrums of coasting beam instability in BINP PSR (magnetic BPM)
  • 79. Spectrums transverse beam instability in LA PSR R.Macek, LANL
  • 80. Beam accumulation with space charge neutralization
  • 82. Proton beam accumulation with intensity above space charge limit
  • 83. Proton beam accumulation with intensity grater than space charge limit. Dependence of injection current.
  • 84. Beam accumulation with a plasma generator on off
  • 85. Basic parameters and threshold of the neutralization factor for e-p instability of the proton rings (coasting beams)
  • 86. Threshold of neutralization factor for coasting beam JPARC-MR PSR ISIS AGS FNAL-MI KEK-PS L(m) 1567.5 90 163 202 3319 339 g 50.9 1.85 1.07 1.2 128 12.8 Np(x1013) 33 3 3 1.8 3 0.3 lp (x1011/m) 2.1 3.3 1.8 0.89 0.09 0.089 sr(cm) 0.35 1 3.8 1 0.17 0.5  -0.0013 -0.187 -0.83 -0.65 0.002 0.022 Dp/p(%) 0.25 0.4 0.5 0.5 0.03 0.3 weL/c 7739 195 69 226 6970 246 fth 0.0015 0.025 0.45 0.15 0.00055 0.05
  • 87. Build-up time due to ionization for the instability  Ionization (2x10-7 Pa) Y1,i=8x10-9e-/(m.p) t= fth/cY1,i =0.4 fth  JPARC-MR 0.6ms  PSR 10 ms instability is observed  ISIS 180 ms no instability  AGS booster 60 ms instability  AGS 10 ms no instability  FNAL-MI 0.2 ms  KEK-PS 20 ms no instability
  • 88. Fast Ion-beam instability of H- beam in FNAL Linac BPM signals after preinjector 0.75 MeV 50mA
  • 89. Transverse instability in FNAL Booster, DC B, Coasting beam. Injection 400MeV, 45 mA.
  • 90. E-p instabilty in Fermilab booster BPM signal Beam intensity
  • 91. Secondary electron generation in the FERMILAB booster, normal acceleration
  • 92. Observation of anomaly in secondary electron generation in the FERMILAB Booster  Observation of secondary particles in the booster proton beam are presented in the Booster E-Log at 04/06/01 .  Reflecting plate of the Vertical Ionization Profile Monitor (VIPM) was connected to the 1 MOhm input of oscilloscope (Channel 2).  To channel 1 is connected a signal of proton beam Charge monitor Qb, with calibration of 2 E12 p/V.  Oscilloscope tracks of the proton beam intensity Qb (uper track) and current of secondary particles (electrons) Qe (bottom track) are shown in Fig. 1 in time scale 5 ms/div (left) and 0.25 ms/ div (right).  The voltage on MCP plate is Vmcp=-200 V.  It was observed strong RF signal induced by proton beam with a gap ( one long bunch). For intensity of proton beam Qb< 4E12 p electron current to the VIPM plate is low ( Qe< 0.1 V~ 1E-7 A) as corresponded to electron production by residual gas ionization by proton beam.  For higher proton beam intensity (Qb> 4E12p) the electron current to the VIPM plate increase significantly up to Qe=15 V~ 15 E-6 A as shown in the bottom oscillogramms. This current is much greater of electron current produced by simple residual gas ionization. This observation present an evidence of formation of high density of secondary particles in high intense proton beam in the booster, as in Los Alamos PSR and other high intense rings.  Intense formation of secondary particles is important for the beam behavior and should be taken into account in the computer simulation.
  • 93. Instability in the Tevatron
  • 95. Instability in RHIC, from PAC03
  • 96. Cold emission of electrons from electrodes with dielectric films CATHODE DEPOSITS INDUCE DISCHARGES: cold emission POSITIVE IONS ACCUMULATION CREATES HIGH DIPOLE FIELD, INDUCING ELECTRON EXTRACTION (MALTER EFFECT) or sparks + ++++++ + - - DEPOSITS
  • 97. Instrumentation for observation and damping of e-p instability  1. Observation of plasma (electrons) generation and correlation with an instability development. Any insulated clearing electrodes could be used for detection of sufficient increase of the electron density. More sophisticated diagnostics (from ANL) is used for this application in the LANL PSR. These electrodes in different location could be used for observation of distribution of the electron generation.  2. For determination an importance compensating particles it is possible to use a controlled triggering a surface breakdown by high voltage pulse on the beam pipe wall or initiation unipolar arc. Any high voltage feedthrough could be used for triggering of controlled discharge. Could this break down initiate an instability?  3. For suppression of plasma production could be used an improving of surface properties around the proton beam. Cleaning of the surface from a dust and insulating films for decrease a probability of the arc discharge triggering. Deposition of the films with a low secondary emission as TiN, NEG. Transparent mesh near the wall could be used for decrease an efficient secondary electron emission and suppression of the multipactor discharge. Biased electrodes could be used for suppressing of the multipactor discharge, as in a high voltage RF cavity.  4. Diagnostics of the circulating beam oscillation by fast (magnetic) beam position monitors (BPM).  5. Local beam loss monitor with fast time resolution. Fast scintillator, pin diodes.  6. Transverse beam instability is sensitive to the RF voltage. Increase of the RF voltage is increase a delay time for instability development and smaller part of the beam is involved in the unstable oscillation development.  7. Instability sensitive to sextuple and octupole component of magnetic field, chromaticity (Landau Damping), …
  • 98. Electron generation and suppression  Gas ionization by beam and by secondary electrons.  Photoemission excited by SR.  Secondary emission, RF multipactor,ion-electron emiss.  Cold emission; Malter effect; Unipolar arc discharge (explosion emission). Artificial triggering of arc.  Suppression:  1-clearind electrodes; Ultra high vacuum.  Gaps between bunches.  Low SEY coating: TiN, NEG.  Transverse magnetic field.  Arc resistant material
  • 99. Conclusion  Experimental dates from small scale rings can be used for verification of computer simulation.  Stabilization of space charge compensated proton beam with a high intensity has been observed.  It is useful to use low energy proton ring for investigation e-p instability.