Rhetorical Critique Essay

Rhetorical Critique Essay
Kimberly Huerta Frey English 102–167 January 25, 2012 A Rhetorical Critique of David Brooks "People Like Us" In David Brooks' "People Like
Us" passage on the issue of diversity, Brooks takes a personally emotional perspective of the way in which Americans don't appreciate how diverse
our nation is while "relatively homogeneous" (Brooks 136). His argument is weakened, however, through a bias and hypocrisy that his diction
conveys. He claims that grouping ourselves with those who we are most alike is in our nature to, and in doing so, we separate ourselves from those
who are different. Using certain statistics as evidence, Brooks points out that the social segmentation created by society will always exist. He argues
that no matter...show more content...
As he provides the statistic that 90 percent of professors in some universities that are "in the arts and sciences who had registered with a political
party had registered Democratic" (Brooks 135), he gives the reader opportunity of debate. However they are connected with very specific subjects, in
this case education, which does not include the amount of neighborhoods he is considering. On the other hand, supporting Brooks' main point, the
detail he provides explains to what level of diversity is not as widespread as we think it is. In Brooks' statement, "many of us are so narrow–minded
that we can't tolerate a few people with ideas significantly different from our own" (Brooks 136), he sounds very passionate about what he is
saying. I believe that when a writer becomes emotional about their argument, it is more engaging and gives the reader a reason to be convinced.
Brooks begins this fundamental paragraph comparing our wish for diversity to our dream of equality. He says that both of these are "based on ideals
we celebrate even as we undermine them daily" (Brooks 135). In this 21st century, one would think that equality exists everywhere, however similarly,
women still get paid less than men for the same job, and discrimination by race occurs plenty to this day. The same unawareness occurs with diversity,
which we see, but by nature, we prevent it. Brooks continuously tells how terrible the situation is,
Get more content on HelpWriting.net

A Critique Of Mr. Banks's Speech
Speech Critique
The event that I was attending was an NHS Induction, that I was a part of. The person hosting this event was my AP World History teacher, Mr.
Banks. It was an honor to receive this invitation for having a GPA higher than a ninety and being a leader in my community. In Mr. Banks
introduction, he did a very good job on getting everyone's attention by having a strong voice. To add on , he did introduce the topic clearly, not only
that but he preview what he was going to talk about before he started. The topic was related to the audience, because everyone that took part of this
event was somehow related to the event.
Secondly, the body of Mr. Banksspeech, when he was presenting his point he made sure to not not briefly talk about them, but also explained them in
a very sensible way for everyone. All his point were fully supported because they were relating to the actions and things we accomplished in order to
be in the event. Furthermore, the organization was well planned, he started of my explaining it, but then he broke it down and gave a few examples to
make it easier to understand. The language he used in his speech was excellent, the language was accurate, appropriate, and not only that but the
connections he made with all...show more content...
Banks speech was his voice, it was loud, clear, and it showed enthusiasm. The power of his voice kept everyone hooked on his speech which is what
everyone wants when they are presenting a speech. In the other hand, one of his weakness was his eye contact, he looked to the left side more and
didn't pay much attention to the right side. This can be a problem because you can lose part of your audience by not paying attention to them, but not
only that, they might not be able to hear you as well. Overall, I would give his speech an excellent score. Mr. Banks met his assignment to inform
everyone about NHS, the specific purpose was well chosen, and most importantly the message adapted to the audience

Qualitative Research Critique Essay
Article Citation
Gilmartin, J. (2003). Day surgery: Patients' perceptions of a nurse–led preadmission clinic. Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 243–250.
Initial Reaction This research article is from the UK and the writer questions if the findings from this study will have heuristic relevance and
applicability to nursing and healthcare in the United States (U.S.). Primary healthcare in the UK is provided through the National Health Service
(NHS); this writer has little knowledge as to how it works and its impact on patient care and nursing. This limited knowledge may introduce bias in this
critique.
Descriptive Vividness The significance of this study is to determine if a preadmission clinic process can be developed and...show more content...
246). Twenty–two participants spoke of the provision of information giving as comprehensive and helpful in surgical preparation, in contrast eight
participants felt the information giving was deficient in its content. One individual went on to say "I personally felt that I was not given any
information once the preassessemnt nurse discovered I worked as a staff nurse on a day surgery unit in another hospital" (Gilmartin, 2003, p. 247).
Negative case studies do not weaken research findings but make the study more credible as the researcher has considered alternative views in the
analysis of data (Tappen, 2011).
As this research consisted of 30 participants, a table format listing the four themes with clustered excerpts would have provided this writer with easier
interpretation of the data collected. It would have been useful to quantitatively designate the percentage of participants in support of a theme versus
those with alternative perceptions. Narrative display of data collection findings made this research less vivid for this writer.
Methodological Congruence Documentation, procedural, and ethical rigor was established in this research study with some suggestions for
improvement to follow. This research was stated to be a hermeneutic phenomenological research using a mixed methodological approach, Colaizzi and
van Manen. This researcher made in–depth clarifying statements to support the van Manen

HIV Qualitative Research Critique Paper
HIV Qualitative Research Critique: Draft Research is relevant to nursing with a specific end goal to interpret obstructions, increment estimation of
patient care, propose new thoughts for future research, and shape the benchmarks at which we rehearse at. Studying research permits experts the
capacity to decide qualities and shortcomings in every specific piece. Evaluating is imperative to bolster or expose conclusions found by the
examination directed. Supporting or exposing research takes into consideration medical attendants to reinforce proper patient mediations and execute
them with the most extreme endorsement. It is imperative for me to understand how to properly critique research for my career as a nurse so that I can
stand by the medical...show more content...
Proper critiquing is also vital when holding a position of management to oversee interventions implemented by other nurses under my supervision.
Critiques may likewise be done as learning experiences or to help give suitable input to the creator before distribution. As for this situation, I have
critiqued 2 research articles as an instructive affair for my nursing education. Peltzer, Domian, and Teel (2015) examine the everyday impacts of having
a HIV positive status as a youthful African–American woman in a Midwestern metropolitan city. Udonkhamsuk, Fongkaew, Grimes, Viseskul, and
Kasatpibal (2014) examine the treatment adherence of Thai youth who are likewise living with an HIV/Helps status. The significance of the critique
of these research articles and evidenced based practice is to understand the strategy for thinking, for teaching, and for nursing proposals for HIV/AIDS
positive patients. Moreover will give spots for advancement in our healthcare framework

Advertising Critique Essay
Advertising Critique:
LibraTech's eLluminate – The NEW Standard for eReaders
MKTG575: Advertising Management
DeVry University, Keller Graduate School
February 4, 2013
Introduction What makes a good product? This is a question that many companies find themselves asking as they begin market research to uncover
new products for their current and potential customers. Is it the quality? The product's functionality and ease of use? Maybe it is the features and all
of the bells and whistles that distinguish a product from its competitors. Perhaps, consumers are keenly focused on unbeatable prices when looking for
new products. When companies ask, 'what makes a good product?' the answer is simple; a good...show more content...
These companies are dominating the e–reader scene, [by providing] quality, great features, and reasonable prices" (Hill, 2012). LibraTech will deliver
the same product solution, however the company must work hard and be vigilant in converting customers over to the new LibraTech technology. This
advertising critique will provide a solid approach to tackling the challenges that LibraTech will face as they introduce their new eReader to the market.
It will outline recommendations for a product name, strategies to target potential customers and a high–level recommendation for an advertising plan
that will surely help to put LibraTech's new eReader on the map as a powerhouse in the eReader industry.
Product Naming Strategy At its core, LibraTech is a company with a brand name that is strong and easily recognizable. What stands out the most
for this brand is it powerful usage of the word 'Libra'. In the zodiac world, Libra is one of the most powerful zodiac signs. The Libra represents a
since of balance, harmony and it is one of the sun signs of the zodiac. Given such a powerful foundation, the name for LibraTech's new eReader had to
embody the essence of the Libra zodiac sign. The name had to strong, and it had to marry well with the parent name of the company. The name
selected for this

Education Article Critique Essay example
Amanda Tatarek
9/29/10
Article Review #1
The article begins by the author explaining that men have privilege over women. "Denials which amount to taboos surround the subject of advantages
which men gain from women's disadvantages. These denials protect male privilege from being fully acknowledged, lessened or ended," (McIntosh,
1998. P. 1). Then the article proceeds to discuss how whites, whether they realize it or not, have a considerable advantage over other races. She lists
twenty–six ways that whites have the upper hand. McIntosh explains that as a white person she had been sheltered from the privileges that she had. "I
think whites are taught not to recognize white privilege, as males are taught not to recognize male...show more content...
There is a black Ms. America and a Black Ms. America, yet the former Ms. America was black. There are sororities that are specifically for particular
races yet regular sororities cannot discriminate on race but the race specific ones can. I feel that no matter what race you are you experience
discrimination in your lifetime. Coming to Temple and living around Temple, I feel like the minority when I walk on the streets. I feel that it doesn't
matter what color skin you are, sometimes you will have the upper hand and sometimes you will have the lower hand. That is just how life is.
As a teacher I am going to make sure all my children, no matter what race they are, receive equal amount of attention, knowledge, and opportunities
within my classroom. I will do this by shaping the curriculum around a multicultural perspective. "Multicultural education, on the other hand,
encourages a culturally responsive curriculum in which diversity is integrated throughout the courses activities and interactions in the
classroom,"(Gollnick & Chinn, 2009, p. 72). I will not let my race overpower the way I write and deliver my lessons. I will use Race and
Ethnicity within my curriculum to teach my students to be aware of all cultures and races so they aren't blinded by the dominant culture of America.
Any child can succeed and do well no matter where they come from.

Research Critique Essay example
Table of contents Page Quantitative Article Critique of Nursing Research1 Problem Statement/Purpose1 Literature Review2 Limitations of the Study2
Hypothesis/Research Question3 Operational Definitions/Definition of Terms4 Research Design5 Setting, Population and Sample5 Data Collection
Methods/Instruments6 Data Analysis, Findings, Implications, & Recommendations 7 References8 Quantitative Article Critique of Nursing Research
The article selected for review in this investigation is entitled "Perioperative outcomes of coronary artery bypass grafting: Effects of metabolic
syndrome and patient's sex." The...show more content...
The presence of acute coronary syndrome in some patients served to increase lipid output, making it difficult to clearly determine lipid disorders in
some patients. This is an issue of concern because high lipid levels are a hallmark for the diagnosis of metabolic syndrome. Hypothesis/Research
Question A careful review of the information provided by the authors demonstrates that a definitive hypothesis or research question is not directly
stated in the investigation. Rather, at the conclusion of the introduction/literature review, the authors note that "For these reasons, this study was
conducted to examine the incidence of metabolic syndrome in CABG patients and to determine if metabolic syndrome and/or the patient's sex affect
clinical outcomes in the perioperative setting" (p. 469). Based on the direction of the literature review and previous studies reviewed by the authors, the
reader can imply that the research questions seek to determine the impact of CABG on patients with metabolic syndrome and the hypothesis is that
gender will have some impact on the specific outcomes which result for patients in this particular group. Operational Definitions/Definition of Terms
Operational definitions used in the study include: metabolic syndrome, coronary artery bypass graft surgery and gender. Data for the investigation was
reviewed by patient gender–i.e. male or female. In addition, all patients included in the study had undergone coronary

Apa Critique Examples
At this point, you should now be able to summarize your evaluations and connect it to your research report. Do not forget to emphasize its
contribution to the field, as well. Again, avoid subjective assessments that you cannot justify. End your critique with an APA formatted reference list.
Remember to use the heading "References," not "Bibliography," or "Works Cited." Also, do not put the font in bold. Center the word at the top of the
page, like what you will see on the next page. Also recheck your parenthetical and in–text citations and make sure they match with your references list
to avoid unintended plagiarism. Make sure your reference list is alphabetized and properly indented. Word count of this dummy critique: 458 words
excluding

Critique Essay Examples
Critique Essay of Process and Learning
Out of all the projects for this course, I think the critique paper was the hardest because it challenged how I thought about scientific journals when it
came to identifying weak parts of a study and how to critique the strengths and weaknesses within those articles in a scientific manner. As a result, my
writing process was affected by this in depth look into each of the three articles I chose on stroke rehabilitation with a focus on virtual reality, and my
understanding of science writing grew with this paper.
With the critique paper, my writing process consisted of using the critique planning worksheet provided on Blackboard, and meeting with you, the
professor, outside the classroom during your office...show more content...
For the proposal between my partner, Alicia Buettner, and I, we decided to find something that related to each of our health profession majors.
Our research for the proposal revealed the importance of occupational and physical therapists working together in the field and the changing
technology in prostheses within rehabilitation treatment. With both topics in mind, we chose to have our proposal addressing the need for
occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) students working together in a class at the University of Findlay that also focused on
prostheses. After deciding on a topic for our proposal, the next step in the writing process was following the break down for each section of the
proposal that you, the professor, provided our peers and us in the classroom. By discussing the content required for each of the sections in the
proposal and the correct formats we were to be using during class time, my partner and I were able to gain a grasp on what you were requiring
from our proposal. For example, Alicia and I spent a great deal of time looking over the notes we wrote down from the board to make sure we were
following the correct guidelines for each section. The mini assignments also helped in reassuring that Alicia and I were on the correct path for the
proposal. With each

Example Of A Critical Review Essay
The study consisted of 395 students from the Australian National University studying a first–year psychology course of which 247 were female, 143
male, 4 as other gender, and 1 one was missing. The age of the participants ranged from 17 to 56 years of age (Вµ=19.7, Пѓ=4.6). Participants were
recruited through participation in a lab activity, however, all participation was voluntary without the use of incentives. Data was collected with the
awareness and informed consent of the participants. This study followed a between–subjects design, and the study itself was quasi–experimental. The
variable which was manipulated – the independent variable – was the presence of a childhood imaginary companion. The variables which were
measured – the dependent variables – were fantasy proneness and the frequency of self–talk....show more content...
The study was completed over the duration of a week by nine classes, each with approximately 30 students and was conducted online. Firstly, the
participants read an information sheet which briefly highlighted the study and its procedure. Following this, the participants completed a Creative
Experiences Questionnaire (CEQ), designed by Merckelbach, Horselenberg, & Muris (2001). This questionnaire aimed to measure the fantasy
proneness of the individual and involved choosing either 'yes' or 'no' to the given 25 questions. Then, the participants completed the Self–Talk Scale
developed by Brinthaupt, Hein, & Kramer (2009). This involved 16 questions with the selection of answers 1 (never) to 5 (very often), and was used
to assess the frequency of self–talk. The last task to complete was the Imaginary Companion (IC) questionnaire, of which the first part collected
demographic information such as age and gender. Proceeding this, a definition of imaginary companion was provided followed by questions relative to
imaginary

Essay on Criticism
Criticism
Criticism can be negative or positive; the way it is said may be good or bad. Why do most of us want to avoid giving or receiving criticism? The
purpose of criticism is to encourage positive outcomes (what the giver wants). Ideally, it brings balance into our lives, provides us with a basis of
comparison, and brings truth, honesty, and intimacy. Hopefully, it gives us honest feedback–a balance of praise and criticism. Do most of us want to
know how we are doing?
Why do successful business people actually seek out criticism from people they respect? Why do people feel they are unfairly criticized? Are tone of
voice, choice of words important? What communication skills...show more content...
Know ones skill and weaknesses; ones successes and failures. How does one know when one is doing a good job? Need to have a "feel" so we are not
caught off guard. Need to learn to take criticism on the job professionally, and emotion (breathe deeply and slowly). Try to remain impartial. Ask
yourself is the criticism is valid. What can we learn?
Other factors that color criticism: 1) relationship with the giver of criticism (friends give advice). Why do we resent criticism from in–laws, parents
and spouses more than bosses do? 2) Choice of words–how it is given. "I can't believe you would do such a stupid thing." What words make you angry,
loud, etc? 3) Style of delivery, sacristy, fast and angry, loud, etc. 4) Timing, and public or private. 5) Other types: beyond your control, aimed at your
gender, size, heritage, appearance, etc
QUESTIONS: How good are you at staying cool under criticism? (Knots in stomach, anger, etc). How well do you listen when you are criticized?
(Rephrase so that you really understand what he/she is saying). How effectively can you organize your thoughts to answer (if you think you should)?
How well do we put the criticism in perspective (not life threatening)? Do we brood on it for weeks, months?
GIVER OF CRITICISM
In many societies a giver of bad news was killed. Is it more difficult to give

Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: "A Communication
Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU" and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The
abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention, measurement
method, findings, and conclusion were all mentioned in the abstract.
Statement of the Problem
The problem explored in the article was stated as a problem statement. In this article, the authors explain about the stressful situations of families having
loved ones...show more content...
A prospective, randomized, controlled trial was conducted during the study. One family member per patient was assessed over the telephone 90 days
after the patient's death. The measurements collected include the symptoms related to Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and other significant
symptoms of depression and anxiety.
Study Variables For this study patient families were randomly assigned to the intervention or control group. In the control group the interactions
between the family and ICU staff, including the end–of–life conference, occurred according to the usual practices and policies in the hospital; whereas
in the intervention group, the research study was conducted according to specific guidelines. A bereavement information leaflet was given to each
surrogate decision maker. In this research, the independent variable can be the type of family conference received by the surrogates and the dependent
variables were the level of stress, anxiety, and depression levels indicated in the 90–day follow–up interview.
Conceptual Model / Theoretical framework In this research study, authors chose to relate the research article to Sister Callista Roy's Adaptation Model.
Roy's adaptation model can be applied in this study because of the family member's opportunity

Concert Critique
MUS 110CL Concert Critique Guidelines and Rubric After either attending a live concert or watching a full length concert online, write a critique
of the performance following the format below. Here are a few examples of full length concerts you can find online (by conducting a web search
using the criteria below) that could be used for this assignment: п‚· п‚· п‚· п‚· п‚· п‚· п‚· п‚· Coldplay Live In Boston 2012 (Full Concert DVD)
Sting: If on a winters night–Live from Durham Cathedral 2009 (watch all 14 songs on concert) Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck, Jimmy Page, Ron Wood, Bill
Wyman, Jan Hammer, Charlie Duke Ellington The Great Paris Concert Richard Galliano/Winton Marsalis– Billie Holiday meets Edith PIAF Wynton
Marsalis and the Lincoln Jazz Center...show more content...
Sometimes the music in a concert will be only one genre. Sometimes there will be several genres performed. Attach the program to your critique,
and then refer to the titles in the program. For example: "Autumn Leaves" was performed by a small instrumental ensemble (guitar, bass, and
percussion). It is a standard contemporary tune. The tempo was a moderately slow ballad. It had a very mellow sound... 4. Tell how well you think
the performers interpreted the music that was on the concert. Were the singers in tune? Did the piano player play musically and rhythmically? Do
you think the performers communicated the music as it was meant to be communicated by the composer? 5. Tell which pieces or part of the concert
was most moving or enjoyable for you. If you didn't enjoy the concert very much, tell why you didn't enjoy it. What could have been better? Be as
specific as you can when expressing your opinion of the performance – don't just write generalities like "It was nice" or "it made me feel like dancing".
Tell why the music made you feel like dancing. Write about why you particularly enjoyed that part of the concert. 6. Conclude your critique by
summing up the performance and telling us if you would go to hear these performers again – or would invite your friends or family to hear this
performance/performers.
Submit the Concert Critique to the Dropbox no later than Sunday 11:59 PM EST/EDT of Module 5. (This Dropbox basket is linked to Turnitin.)
Critique must be

Critique of a Survey
Critique of a Survey
Starting with the introduction of the survey they seemed to be too specific in their intro of what was going to be in the survey by describing each type
of question that would be presented throughout the survey. I feel like this information isn't necessary and over excessive in an introduction. That part
of the introduction should be taken out and instead maybe include something along the lines of "Please read every question carefully and thank you for
participating" or something along those lines. Regarding the question before the first question I feel like this makes answering the first question
confusing because it makes it seem like I should be answering that question even though it is just a set up for the...show more content...
Again, the question above question 12 should be reformatted to a statement instead because of possible confusion it could cause the participant of the
survey. And for question 12 I feel like there should be another question or 2 because it seems odd that there is just one question concerning unpaid
internships, maybe they could include more questions about why they took it. Or since the next section is on internships maybe you shouldn't separate
them and include question 12 in the next section so the format doesn't look awkward. In the instructions about the next set of questions it should be
changed to "Indicate how much you agree or disagree with the following statements," this should be added so that it doesn't make it seem like you are
leaning for them to answer agree to the statements. With questions 13 and 14 I think they should add more spacing to the numbers and get rid of the
commas just to make each number distinguished and separate from the rest. For question 15 I think they should change it to "Are you trying to or
thinking about graduating early to save on

Strategic Plan Critique Paper
The following document contains the consolidated feedback that members of Team C provided to each other as the final individual assignments for
the strategic plans were completed. This was a useful tool in providing a peer review prior to the final submission of the individual assignment. This
task allowed each team member the opportunity to provide recommendations for others to enhance their own papers as well as provide some insight
on areas where our own papers could be best finalized.
K.'s Feedback for the Team
Patricia:
The background and executive summary of the paper lay a good foundation for the strategic analysis. I noticed that there were a number of grammatical
errors throughout the paper which is to be expected with a...show more content...
Good word flow, but just reword the personal pronoun of I which is not allowed in APA formatting. Good paper with greatresearch!
Suzanne:
The paper was great with a lot of research and the greatest asset of the paper was the way you did the strategy and the way it refer to the certain parts
of the internal and external. The grid will help a person be more visual with the factors that are involved with the strategy point and the long–term
objectives which will give the paper a visual of the each against each other, and see how they correlate. That was a good point and how you
brought it out. The financial could be a bit more descriptive and the short executive summary of yours will almost make me rewrite my part. Also
and this is good feedback to read other papers, then it is when we see the mistakes we made. Altogether it is a good paper, few grammatical errors,
but from your work before you do excellent writing, research, and proof reading skills. Good paper! The only thing I could complain about the
paper is that headers are needed to separate each item you are talking about. That is what I did and I wrote too much in my paper, but separation of
the headers for the topics will draw the attention to the reader when they are looking to refer to something, and if a header is there it is easy to follow.
S's Feedback for the Team
Kebreab
It looks like you have a good start on your paper

Dance Concert Critique
My overall response to the dance concert is spectacular because each dance piece was moving, remarkable, and motivational. Each dance had an
astounding affect on me and allowed to me repelled into the performance. These impressions came from me analyzing the dance pieces, "A Brief
Study of Recent History and "One Heart, Two Worlds", for the Spring 2016 Studio 115Dance Concert Series at USM's Dance and Theatre Building on
May 4th. The first performance, "A Brief Study of Recent History" was choreographed by Elizabeth Lentz–Hill and introduced by the dancers Jennifer
Alafat, Megan Bradberry, Shaquille Hayes, etc. While the second piece, "One Heart, Two Worlds", was choreographed by Dejonelle Gleeton and the
performers were Brittain Allgood,...show more content...
75). Modern dance is all about the concentration on innovation. The dance, "One heart, Two worlds" has a huge connection with the choreographers,
Doris Humphrey, and Charles Weidman, a technique of "music visualization". When it came to creating dances, Humphrey was interested in group
dynamics. She also had a strong connection with music, therefore, music visualization is "a way to see the music through the dance, sometimes
having the dances follow rhythmic patterns (pg.81). Also, the choreographer, Isadora Duncan, created dances centered on the emotion of Mother,
depicting a sorrowful and broken figure. This emotion relates to the duo dance scene, the girl connecting with the world of dreaming and the harsh
world of reality; however, in the end, she appears to be broken when separated from her dream. Also, Duncan went against the traditional form of
ballet by creating dances in ways that were more natural, like movements of the trees or ocean as well as being inspired by not restricting movement
by providing the dancers with loose costumes. The dance "One Heart, Two Worlds" also depicts movements in a more natural way such as the nature of

Culture of Critique Essay
Americans have embraced debate since before we were a country. The idea that we would provide reasoned support for any position that we took is
what made us different from the English king. Our love of debate came from the old country, and embedded itself in our culture as a defining value.
Thus, it should not come as a surprise that the affinity for debate is still strong, and finds itself as a regular feature of the mainstream media. However,
if Deborah Tannen of the New York Times is correct, our understanding of what it means to argue may be very different from what it once was; a
"culture of critique" has developed within our media, and it relies on the exclusive opposition of two conflicting positions (Tannen). In her 1994
editorial,...show more content...
Secondly, Tannen attempts to refute the misconception, held in the "culture of critique", that "when both sides argue, thetruth will emerge" by stating
that the "truth is more likely to be found in the complex middle." However, though this argument does not stand on its own, as it is intended, her
subsequent explanation does give the refutation credibility. She reasons that the culture of critique leads reasonable people to waste effort defending
themselves from misrepresentation by unreasonable opponents, instead of being constructive; champions of unsubstantiated positions are knowingly
given credibility by the media, just so that there can be opposition.
Thirdly, after explaining why the culture of critique is predicated on false support, Tannen returns to the problem with the culture of critique itself, and
expands the discussion to how it affects journalism, politics and academia. She does so through anecdotal illustration of how a graduate student is
forced out of graduate school by its "combative" atmosphere, and presenting her own personal experience of appearing on a television talk show. The
two stories are primarily intended as an emotional appeal, encouraging the audience to relate personally, but they also help the readers identify Tannen
as a credible authority.
Additionally, Tannen, a University professor and Doctor of

Formative Critique
espond– Danielle, I really like the format of this lesson. You make it fun during the reading by asking the students questions that are silly and have no
correct response, but engage the students in the story. Your formative assessment is nice. I like the way you practice with the whole class so no one
student is singled out and feels pressured if they do not comprehend the information. Then, you travel to a more in–depth assessment of individual
students by analyzing them segmenting the words on their own. Critique– I really like the way you formatted this assessment. A critique I have is that
I am a bit confused on the coins. I do not really understand their purpose in this assessment. I am sure that you have a purpose for them, but that

Assignment 2: Article Critique
Assignment 2: Article Critique
The purpose of the research paper is to critique the article written by Arthur M.Langer (2002); which, studies the concept of reflecting on practice; and
using learning journals in higher and continuing education by non–traditional students and traditional students. The review will discuss if there is a
difference in the approach and comprehension of the non–traditional students and the traditional students as it relates to 'technical' computer class
responded to the requirement for learning journals.
The investigation will also analyze the students learning journals and identify material that contain the content, formatting style and subject matter.
This review will also concentrated on the significance points...show more content...
Did the journals assist in critical reflection?
Students had concerns about the ability to managed their electronic learning journal. They were anxiety, especially the non tradition students, they felt
insulted by the requirement of the learning journals and believed they were matched for children. Students had concerned with designing, and
presenting personal formats, less than 5% of the students hadprior experience with producing journals and only 50% of the journals were submitted on
a weekly basis, and in a timely manner. The research problems stated, there was differences in the way non–traditional students compared to that of
traditional students managed the technical' computer response in the learning journals class. The article also discussed the concept reflective learning
as it relates to the learning journals class. This section focuses on how the learning journals could be used to relate to classroom theory in situations
practiced outside the classroom. Indeed, the process of taking material learned in the classroom and understanding its application in the workplace was
signicant, but it was problems for students to successfully apply the learning journals technques to their new

Rhetorical Critique Essay

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Featured

Featured (20)

Rhetorical Critique Essay