In this ever-changing revenue cycle space, it’s important for organizations to remain agile. That said, it’s time to break the mold when it comes to denial prevention efforts. During this presentation, we will review trends and traditional methods used over the years and talk about what works and what methods tend to fall short of the goal. We’ll then talk about taking denial prevention to a higher level using a three-pronged approach: reporting, accountability and training. For reporting, we’ll review the importance of defining a claim denial versus a delay in payment and how this distinction impacts prevention focus areas. Accountability is reinforced using a robust action plan that accomplishes cross departmental buy-in. We’ll focus on what should be included in your action plan, what are realistic timeframes, who should be involved and how to keep ideas fresh.
1. Click to edit Master title style
Payer Denials:
A Discussion on Prevention
hrgpros.com
Developed by Megan Smith
Executive Director, Quality and Training
msmith@hrgpros.com
509.789.6656
3. hrgpros.com
Average cost to re-work a claim $25.00
Denial rate up 2% in 2020 compared to 2016
86% of denials are avoidable
1 in 4 denied claims cannot be recovered
Source: Becker’s Hospital Review, “86% of denials are potentially avoidable: Strategies to better prevent, manage denials”, November 2020; https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/86-of-denials-are-potentially-avoidable-
strategies-to-better-prevent-manage-denials.html
4. Traditional Methods
Department Prevention Meetings
• May encourage silos
• Not as productive as cross-
departmental collaboration
Monthly Denial Reports
• Seem generic and may not resonate
• Expectation may be unclear
hrgpros.com
5. Traditional Methods
Real-time Tools or Automation
• Requires training and consistent
upkeep
• Lack of IT resources
• Required Fields or Rules
• Edit fatigue
• Creative workarounds
hrgpros.com
6. Review Denial Codes Often
• 835 reason and remark (CARC/RARC)
mapping
• Cash poster using current crosswalk
• Payer use of codes
• Automated workflows in informatics
system
hrgpros.com
7. hrgpros.com
Denial of Payment
Payer indicates no payment will be made
after review of claim
Includes reasons that can be appealed
Avoidable
Examples: Medical Necessity, No
Eligibility, No Auth, Untimely
Delay of Payment
Final decision pending additional
information
Typically no appeal needed
Unavoidable
Examples: Additional Information Needed,
Coordination of Benefits, Accident/Incident
questionnaire
8. Refine What is Reported
• Remove replicates or “roll up”
multiple denials to most pertinent
• Both volume & dollar amount
• Minimum 3 month trending – 6
months is best
• Capture avoidable/unavoidable
• Concise - include graphs, status
indicators
hrgpros.com
9. Department Reports Should be Relatable
• Make sure departments understand what they’re looking at
• Correlate denied dollars as cost of CT machine, # of FTEs
• Denial percentages should be tied to
department revenue and overall
revenue
• Explain any delays in results
hrgpros.com
10. Consider an Event or All-Day
Workshop
• Understand the impact
• Walk in each others’ shoes
• Creates synergy
• Increase long term buy-in
• All in it together
hrgpros.com
11. Prepare for the Workshop
• Establish denial reporting
• Survey departments to gauge level of
understanding & enthusiasm
• Prepare action plan template/handouts
• Determine 1 or 2 top denials for
each department involved
• Limit workshop to <12 people
hrgpros.com
12. Workshop Agenda Should Include
• Round table opinion /association with denials
• Walk through of PFS operational workflow
• Review pre-workshop survey
• Discuss financial impact – keep it relative to audience
• Develop action plan & assign roles/responsibilities
hrgpros.com
Goal: Department Education and Buy-in
13. During the Workshop
• Bring in lunch/snacks
• Check phones at the door
• Dry erase boards / sticky notes
• 100% participation
• Break often -10 mins
• Plan activities that get people
moving
hrgpros.com
14. Action Plan
hrgpros.com
• Description of action
• Responsible party
• Priority level (multiple actions)
• Due dates
• Status indicators
• Resources needed
• Barriers
15. hrgpros.com
Do’s
• Include stakeholders
• Executive sponsor(s)
• Take your time
• Assign roles & responsibilities
• Keep plan updated & visible
Don’ts
• Develop plan in a silo
• Assume acceptance is
understanding
• Expect to tackle everything in
first 30 days
16. Keeping the Plan Fresh
• Be mindful of daily responsibilities and factor in “fires”
• Encourage staff level “cheerleaders”
• Schedule Reoccurring Meetings
• Keep action plan visible in shared location (SharePoint)
• Celebrate wins – not matter how small
• All in this together!
hrgpros.com
17. Action Plan Ideas
• Reduce insurance plan choices based on plan ID
• Create infographics displayed at registration stations
• Cross-departmental committee for changes to payer/plan combinations
• Committee for denial reason and remark code actions
• Develop quality and training program for billing and registration
• Implement SharePoint site for resource documents
hrgpros.com
18. Root Cause Analysis
Monthly cross department review of monthly write-offs
• CFO, HIM, Patient Access, Billing Directors, Managers & Supervisors
• Walk through accounts in informatics system
Review monthly bad debt assignment
• Accounts with viable insurance, no payment and no PR reason code
Complete case studies
• High dollar write off
• Aged accounts
• Unsuccessful appeals
hrgpros.com
Validate denial codes often – make sure you don’t have contractual adjustment codes in there – such as a CO 97 or CO 45. Is your code mapping the most up to date? Chances are if you’re using an 835, you will have to have the reason code available to post the 835, but are codes correctly mapping as denials?
Also for 835 processing, you’ll want to regularly check that the payers are using ANSI codes appropriately
If you’re posting manually, are cash posters manually choosing denial codes? Are they using an up to date reason code crosswalk when posting proprietary codes to the ANSI standard?
To maximize your message, make sure each department you’re meeting with fully understands the meaning of the report. Schedule a meeting with department stakeholders to review the reports together. Keeping in mind what’s important to that department, your kick off meeting should include data that will resonate with that particular department. For example, if addressing pre service authorization denials with your advanced imaging department, don’t just show up with an excel report full of numbers