Current damage predictors in high-valued systems are based on strain measurements and crack detection, thus, estimating the remaining useful life difficult. The US Army Research Laboratory developed damage precursor detection technique to outsmart fatigue prior to crack initiation. Our successful approach track the evolution in the materials microstructure, electrical inductance or capacitance, or thermal response.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of membrane structures.pptx
Damage precursor detection to outsmarting fatigue
1. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land ForcesUNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
UNCLASSIFIED
Damage Precursor Index Methodology for
Aviation Structures
Ed Habtour1, Daniel Cole1, Christopher Kube1, Adam Svensken1, Mark Robeson2, and Abhijit Dasgupta3
1 U. S. Army Research Laboratory, APG, MD 21005 USA
2US Army Aviation and Missile Research, Development, and Engineering Center, Ft. Eustis, VA 23604 USA
3Center for Advanced Life Cycle Engineering, University of Maryland, MD 20742 USA
Ed Habtour, Ph.D., P.E., Team Lead
Prognostics & Diagnostics, Vehicle Technology Directorate at ARL
ed.m.habtour.civ@mail.mil
2. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Objective
1) Understand materials evolution
2) Incorporate precursors into models
3) Track changes in nonlinear dynamics
Damage Precursor: Aviation
Challenges
1) Characterize Precursors:
i. classes of materials
ii. loading profiles
iii. environmental Conditions
2) Nonlinearity:
i. manifestation of health
ii. parameters sensitivity
iii. multiaxial loading
Army Impact
1) Prolong the life of critical components
to achieve “Fatigue-Free”
2) Provide fast, relevant health
information
3. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
The Why: FY16 Army Budget
1 FY2016 Army Budget Overview, Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Army (DASA) for Budget , 2015
2 Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Outlook Handbook, 2014-15 Edition, Military Career
Operations and
Maintenance
$45B, 36%
Military
Personnel
$56B, 44%
Other, $2B, 2%
Procurement &
RDTE,
$23B, 18%
Battle Damage Assessment
and Repair is not a driving
maintenance factor
OCO Request1
O&M $12B (55%)
FY16 Army Request1
Base: $126B
OCO: $ 22B
~ 27% of Army personnel2 are
in sustainment functions
4. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Current State: Data Collection
Materiel
Instrumentation Data Collection Systemic
Issues Root Causes Mi1ga1ng
Correc1ve
Measures
Deploy field analysts
Increase number of field
data collectors world wide
Analyze field data
Utilize Physics of
Failure capabilities
Increase LSS
Green & Black Belt
Update training, manuals
and requirements and
integrate solutions
“… none are connected and provide a coherent description of what failed and why,…. Hence, there
is no realistic, formal way to track successes, analyze failures… from past acquisition programs.”
Final Report of the 2011 Army Acquisition Review
5. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Shigley, Mechanical Engineering Design (2001)
Fatigue Loading in Shafts and Axles:
!!!
32
= !
!!
!!
+
!!!!
!!
!
+
!!
!!
+
!!"!!
!!
!
!
!
d = diameter !! = alternating moment !! = mean moment
!!= alternating torque !! = mean torque !! = yield strength
! = safety factor
!! = fatigue strength reduction factor
!!" = fatigue strength reduction factor for shear
!! = fatigue limit !! = !!!!!!!!!!!!
!
!! = Surface Factor !! = ! !!"
!
!! = Load Factor (Bending, Torsion, …)
!! = Size Factor
!! = Temperature Factor
!! = Miscellaneous Effects Factor
Current State: Design
6. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Detect Precursors
Structural
Mechanics
Micro-
mechanics
Nonlinear
Dynamics
Damage Sensors Repair
Open-loop Monitoring
Integrated State Awareness & Control
Current State of the Art ARL
ARL: Future State of the Art
7. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Approach
Project 1:
Metal Alloys
• Steel 1095
• Al 7075
Project 2:
Composite
• Glass/epoxy
• IM7/8552
• IM10
Project 3:
Composite
Constituents
• Individual IM7
• 8552
• Fiber/Matrix
Future Materials
• 3-D Printed
• Hybrid Alloys
Select Aviation
Materials
Local Materials Characterization
(e.g. SEM, AFM, EBSD, Nanoindentation)
Identify Precursors
Create State
Awareness Models
Global Sensing
(e.g. UT, Electrical, Optic, IR, EMI)
Detect Precursors –
COTS sensors
Conventional & Multifunctional
Sensors:
Performance, Sustainment &
Survivability
Engineering
Models
• Connect Micro to
Macro-Mechanics
• Apply Nonlinear
Dynamics
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
46.4 46.6 46.8 47 47.2 47.4 47.6 47.8 48
Response(mm)
Freq. (Hz)
Translation Base Excitation 0.3g, Ramp up 30s, Dwell 20s, 5in beam,
AR=8
Test 1
Test 2
Test 3
Test 4
Test 5
Model 1
Model 2
Model 3
Model 4
Model 5
Dynamic Loading
• Structural
• Rotating
• Tension-Tension
• 3- Point Bend
Environmental
Loading
• Thermal Cycling
Excite Structure –
Laboratory testing
Mechanical
Properties
• Tension
• Bending
• Shear
Control
Loads
20 µm
8. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Damage Precursor in Alloys: Identification
Research Results
E. Habtour, D. Cole, M. Robeson et al., Str Ctrl &
Health Monitoring, 2016
E. Habtour, D. Cole., Int. J. of Nonlinear
Mechanics, 2016
𝑚𝑦̈ + 𝑐𝑦̇ + 𝑘𝑦 = 𝐹
𝑚 = inertia, 𝑐 = Damping, 𝑘 = Structural stiffness
Nonlinear system:
𝑚 𝑒𝑓𝑓 𝑦̈ + 𝑐𝑦̇ + 𝑘 𝑒𝑓𝑓 𝑦 + 𝑁𝑖(𝑦2
𝑦̈ + 𝑦𝑦̇ 𝟐) + 𝑁𝑔 𝑦3
= 𝐹
𝑁𝑖 = Nonlinear inertia, 𝑁𝑔 = Nonlinear stiffness, 𝐹 = Base excitation
• Detected precursors with COTS sensors
• Nonlinear detection models for transverse rotational Vibration
Accomplishments
a)
b) c)
After
20 µm
Fatigued Beam Free Surface
Alloy Cantilever under Harmonic Oscillation
9. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Damage Precursor in Alloys: Verification
Research Results
Control 75K cycles 150K cycles
BCC
Ferrite
Fe3C
Cementite D. Cole, E. Habtour, et al., to be
submitted to Experimental
Mechanics, 2016
• Changes in local micro-mechanical properties prior to
crack initiation
• Confirmed precursors using novel techniques
• Nano-indentation
• AFM, EBSD
Accomplishments/Advancements
10. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Damage Precursor: Global Model
Equation of motion for nonlinear system is:
!!""! + 2!!!""!!! + !!""! + !!"#$ !!
! + !!!
+ !!"#$!!
= !!!!
Nonlinear inertial coefficient including tip rotary inertia is:
!!"#$ = ! !!"!"
!
!
!
!"
!
!
+ ! !!"!"
!
!
!
!!!
+ !!!"
!!!
Effective stiffness and nonlinear geometric stiffness coefficients:
!!"" = !" !!!"
!"
!
!
!!"#$ = 2 !" !!
!!! !
!"
!
!
!! =
1 +
3!!
4
!!"#$
!!""
1 +
!!
2
!!"#$
!!""
Equation of motion for linear system is:
!!""! + 2!!!""!!! + !!""! = !!!!
E. Habtour, et al., to be submitted to Mech Sys & Sig Pro, 2016
11. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Damage Precursor: Micromechanics Model
ρ
∂2
ui
∂t2
=
∂2
uk
∂xj
∂xl
Cijkl
+
∂um
∂xn
Cijklmn
+δkm
Cijnl
+δik
Cjlmn
+δim
Cjknl( )
⎡
⎣
⎢
⎤
⎦
⎥
Quadratic Nonlinearity Term
u a( )= u1
cos ka −ωt( )−u2
sin2 ka −ωt( )+...
where ( )
22
2 1
8
a
ku uβ= →
β ≡ Quadratic Nonlinearity Parameter
( )
2
2
1
8u
a ku
β =
Second-harmonic amplitude gives an experimental
parameter
measured lattice damage
β β β+=
C. Kube and J. Turner, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 2015
C. Kube and J. Turner, J. of Elasticity, 2015
Damage Quantification from
Harmonic Generation
12. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Damage Precursor: bridging the
scales
Example of 3-Dimensional Distribution of Material Nonlinearity for Titanium Single
Crystals
• Nonlinearity is directionally dependent
• Nonlinear response depends on dilational or shear wave displacement
13. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
C. Kube and J. Turner, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 2015
C. Kube and J. Turner, J. of Elasticity, 2015
Effective elastic moduli needed to define requires averaging over all orientations of
the grains
β
( )
2 1
0 1
1
, d d
4
ijkl ijklC Cw
π
χ φ χ φ
π −
〈 〉 = ∫ ∫
( )
2 1
0 1
1
, d d
4
ijklmn ijklmnC Cw
π
χ φ χ φ
π −
〈 〉 = ∫ ∫
( )0
ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ
ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ
ijklmn ijnl jlmn jkm ik im j l n i k m
j l i
knl
j ki kl
n n n u uC C u
n n u
C C
C u
δ δ δ
β
〈 〉 + + +〈 〉 〈 〉 〈 〉
〈 〉
= −
2z 3z
4z
5z
4x
5x
2x
3x1z
1x 1y
4y 5y
2y
3y1z
1x 1y
Single Grain Elastic Modulus
Aggregate Elastic Modulus
ijklC
〈Cijkl
〉
Damage Precursor: bridging the
scales
14. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Characterizing: Induce Damage
Precursors in Composites
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
5.5
6
x 10
-5
N/Nf
compliance,s
Bulk Composite – Compliance Effect Measured
during 3-pt Bend Test
Microtensile Testing for Individual Microfibers
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
50 100 150 200
FailureStress,MPa
FailureStrain,%
Failure Displacement, µm
28 mm
12.5mm
gage length
adhesivefiber
gripped region
load
(mm/N)
Elastic Modulus Map Conductivity Map
15. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Habtour, et al. Shock and Vibration (In Preparation)
Damage Precursor: Nonlinearity vs.
Control
!!""! + 2!!!""!!! + !!"" − !!!!!! − ℎ!!!
!
! + !!"#Ω!!!
!
+!!"#$ !!
! + !!!
+ !!"#$ − ℎ!!!
!
!!
= !!Ω! + !!!!
E. Habtour, et al., to be submitted to Mech Sys & Sig Pro, 2016
16. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Sense Evolution:
• Ultrasonics
• Electric Impedance
• Thermocouple
• Accelerometer
• Fiber optic
Material Evolution:
• Fibril stiffness
• Cavitation
• Deformation/Stress
• Debonding
• Compliance
• Micro-structure
Sense
Precursors
Precursors
Models
(MRC)
Uncertainty
Quantification
(ISC/CSC)
Provide
Current State
Adapt Control
• Reduce damaging
flight loads
• Maintain Capabilities
• Optimize
• Relearn
Sensor/Data
Fusion
Operational
Loads
Risk
Assessment
(ISC/CSC)
RUL Models
(ISC/CSC)
Survivability
Models
(ISC/CSC)
Forecast
Future State
Material
Degradation
Sensor
Data
Current
State
Projected
Capabilities
Proposed
Solution
Propeller System:
• Propellers
• Bearings
• Controllers
Materials System:
• Composite
• Alloys
State
Information
Integrated State-Awareness & Control
17. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Update
Health
State
Micromechanics and Structural
Testing Facilities
Adaptive Controls
ARL Computational Facilities
Reliability & State
Awareness Facilities
Integrated State-Awareness & Control
18. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
Transonic Experimental Facility
Rodman Materials
Research Laboratory
Rotorcraft Survivability
Assessment Facility
Pulse Power Facility
Access to Partner Facilities
Zahl Physical Sciences Laboratory
Shooter Performance
Facility
DSRC & Scientific
Visualization Facility
Robotics Research Facility
Vertical Impulse
Measurement
Facility
Environment for Auditory
Research
Fuel Reformation
Laboratory
Novel Energetics
Research Facility
Electromagnetic
Vulnerability Assessment
Facility
Microsystem Indoor
Testing Grounds
Specialty Electronic Materials
and Sensors Cleanroom
Vehicle Research Laboratory
ARL Technical Infrastructure
Academia Industry
19. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
C. Kube and J. Turner, J. of Aco Soc of Am, 2015
C. Kube and J. Turner, J. of Elasticity, 2015
D. Cole, E. Habtour, et al., ASME SMASIS, Colorado Springs, CO, Sept 21-23, 2015
E. Habtour, D. Cole, M. Robeson et al., Structural Control & Health Monitoring, 2016
E. Habtour, D. Cole., Int. J. of Nonlinear Mech, 2016
D. Cole, E. Habtour, et al., to be submitted to Exp Mech, 2016
E. Habtour, et al., to be submitted to Mech Sys & Sig Pro, 2016
Additional References:
FY2016 Army Budget Overview, Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Army (DASA) for Budget , 2015
Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Outlook Handbook, 2014-15 Edition,
Military Career
Shigley, Mechanical Engineering Design (2001)
Publications
E. Habtour, et al., to be submitted to Mech Sys & Sig Pro, 2016
20. UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED The Nation’s Premier Laboratory for Land Forces
US Army Research Laboratory:
• Nano- & Micromechanics Characterization: Dr. Daniel Cole, daniel.p.cole.civ@mail.mil
• Composites DP Detection: Dr. Robert Haynes, robert.a.haynes43.civ@mail.mil
• Composites Micromechanics Modeling: Dr. Todd Henry: todd.c.henry2.civ@mail.mil
• NDE & Materials Constituents Modeling: Dr. Christopher Kube, christopher.m.kube.ctr@mail.mil
• SHM-Based Adaptive Controls: Mr. Brent Mills, brent.t.mills.civ@mail.mil
• System Identification & Fault Detection: Dr. Ed Habtour: ed.m.habtour.civ@mail.mil
Collaborators:
US Army Aviation and Missile Research, Development, and Engineering Center:
Aviation Structures Durability: Mark Robeson, mark.e.robeson.civ@mail.mil
Center for Advanced Life Cycle Engineering, University of Maryland:
Experimental and Computation Mechanics: Dr. Abhijit Dasgupta, dasgupta@umd.edu
Damage Precursor: Efforts Leads