SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Download to read offline
313
heme 4
INDIVIDUAL TREATMENT
OF DEVELOPMENTAL DIFFICULTIES
AND DISABILITIES
529
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN
WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
Angelka Velkoska1
, Goran Ajdinski1
and Milena Milicevic2
1
Institute of Special Education and Rehabilitation, Faculty of Philosophy,
ā€œSs Cyril and Methodiusā€ University, Skopje, Republic of Macedonia
2Medical College of Professional Studies ā€œMilutin Milankovicā€,
Belgrade, Serbia
Summary
The general aim of this study was to explore the emotional ties
between child with disability and its attachment ļ¬gure (mother)
and pathology that can occur in this emotional bond. For this pro-
pose we study two children with disability (child with autism and
child with Down syndrome) and to access the results we used ver-
sion 3 of the Q-sort test, which consists of 90 items. Here we pre-
sented characteristics of a ā€œsecure attachmentā€ with the primer
care giver, also characteristics of ā€œunsecure attachmentā€, classiļ¬-
cations, causes of insecure attachment and methods that can help
us to recover emotional ties. We gave special explanation of disor-
ganization / disorientation, as most frequent insecure attachment
of the child with disabilities. Throughout analysis, we determined
that both examined children have insecure attachment. According
to the results of the Person coefļ¬cient of correlation child with
Down syndrome has 0.23 ratios of attachment, and child with au-
tism has coefļ¬cient of ā€“ 0.35. The results from the analysis were
compared with standardized coefļ¬cients that are considered as a
characteristic of the safest child ā€“ criterion sort.
Angelka Velkoska et al.
530
KEY WORDS: attachment theory, insecure attachment, emotional
ties, Down Syndrome, autism.
I. OVERVIEW OF THE ATTACHMENT THEORY
Attachment theory was ļ¬rst conceptualized in the 1950ā€™s by John
Bowlby. It was ļ¬rst a clinical theory based upon the observation that
the delinquent boys he was working with all suffered severe traumatic
losses. His inquiry led him to explore the effects of early separation,
evolutionary biology, ethology, cognitive neuroscience and information
processing theory.
An attachment may be deļ¬ned as an affection tie that one person or
animal forms between himself and another speciļ¬c one ā€“ a tie that binds
them together in space and endures over time. (Vaughn et al, 1992)
The emphasis on attachment to the mother has shifted to an em-
phasis on the primary caregiver (which may not be the mother) and it is
now recognized that children can form multiple attachments. An impor-
tant development in challenging the assumption that mothers needed to
be at home full-time was the discovery that quality was more important
than quantity in forming secure attachments between caregivers and
their children. Both the primary caregiver and the infant are active par-
ticipants in this process. The key factor for the caregiver is sensitive
responsiveness ā€“ the ability to attune to the child and respond to their
signals. The child's responsiveness is also an important contributor to
the process. When the parent and the child are in sync with each other,
then the child develops a secure attachment. The child feels safe, know-
ing that mom or dad will be there when needed.
The success or failure of the parent-children attachment bond has
a life-long effect on the way your child feels about him or herself and
about others. Individuals who experience confusing, frightening, or
broken emotional communications during their infancy often grow into
adults who have difļ¬culty understanding their own emotions and the
feelings of others. This limits their ability to build or maintain success-
ful relationships.
Secure attachment helps the child: (Fahlberg et al., 1988)
- attain full intellectual potential;
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
531
- sort out what he or she perceives;
- think logically;
- develop a conscience;
- become self-reliant;
- cope with stress and frustration;
- handle fear and worry;
- develop future relationships;
- reduce jealousy.
With secure attachment there is a fertile environment for the capac-
ity for ļ¬ve kinds of love: maternal love, paternal love, peer love, sexual
love, and parental love. Early affective ties have a big inļ¬‚uence in so-
cial activities of the child, accomplishing higher degree of socialization,
conļ¬dent and good about themselves and enjoying being with others.
1.1. Attachment and psychopathology
Infants are helpless from birth, and need consistent, loving re-
sponses to their needs for food, sleep and comfort. As the infant grows,
so does the bond of trust with the primary caregiver. Secure attachment
has a lifelong effect on growth, development, trust and relationships. If
a child is not provided this consistent, loving care, he will develop an
insecure attachments form. Children with insecure attachments have
learned that the world is not a safe place. They donā€™t have the expe-
riences they need to feel conļ¬dent in themselves and trust in others.
Because attachment is a fundamental part of childrenā€™s development
that affects the growing brain, insecure attachment shows itself in many
different ways.
Signs of attachment problems: (Fletcher, 2008)
- Inappropriately clinging and demanding;
- Little exploration of environment;
- Reckless self-endangerment (failure to use secure base in times
of risk);
- Role reversal ā€“ excessive concern for attachment ļ¬gure;
- Hyper vigilance leading to withdrawal and ambivalence;
- Indiscriminate friendliness;
- Superļ¬cially engaging and charming behavior;
Angelka Velkoska et al.
532
- Avoidance of eye contact;
- Extreme independence;
- Lack of affection on carerā€™s terms;
- Destructiveness to self, others, and material things;
- Difļ¬culty using others for emotional comfort;
- Learning delays -more than expected for intellectual abilities;
- Extreme sensitivity to change or rejection;
- Abnormal eating patterns;
- Poor peer relationships;
- Persistent questioning or chatter;
- Sleep disturbances, in particular not being able to sleep alone.
In this list we can see that signs, symptoms for attachment prob-
lems can be manifested as an emotional, physical, social problems and
problems in educational process. Different patterns of attachment have
been identiļ¬ed by Ainsworth using the 'Strange Situation'. This was a
laboratory experiment in which the interaction between mothers and
infants was observed prior to, during and after a brief separation. Three
categories have been identiļ¬ed by Ainsworth: (Ainsworth, 1978)
Secure attachment ā€“ child protested when mother left, sought her
out while she was gone, greeted her with delight when she returned,
explored more when mother present (Category B).
Secure children explore freely in the presence of their caregiver,
check on him or her periodically, and restrict exploration during the
caregiverā€™s absence. Children who are securely attached show varying
levels of distress in the absence of their caregiver but respond positively
to the caregiverā€™s return. They will seek contact with their parent when
distressed and will settle down once contact is made and comfort is
provided.
Anxious attachment ā€“ distressed when mother left, little relief
when reunited, highly anxious before, during and after separation, loathe
to explore even when mother present (Category C). In addition, they ļ¬nd
little comfort in contact and are often angered if mother tries to comfort
them with a toy. They are sometimes termed ā€œambivalentā€ in reference
to the fact that they mix weak contact maintaining with strong protest if
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
533
mother puts them on the ļ¬‚oor. Exploratory behavior rarely recovers to
preseparation levels during the reunion episodes. (Solomon, 1999)
Avoidant attachment ā€“ relatively indifferent to mother, rarely
cried when she left, little positive response on return, curiosity unaf-
fected by mother's presence (Category A). Avoidant children seem not
to care whether a parent is present or absent. In the presence of the care-
giver, avoidant children will explore their environment without inter-
est in the parentā€™s whereabouts. Upon departure avoidant children are
minimally distressed. At reunion avoidant children do not move toward
the parent or try to initiate contact. In fact, they often ignore or avoid
the parent. Despite this apparent lack of concern, infants with an avoid-
ant attachment style show as much, if not more, physiological arousal
than other infants, suggesting that they have learned to contain their
distress.
There is a group of children who do not ļ¬t into Ainsworthā€™s origi-
nal three-category scheme. Mary Main, another inļ¬‚uential attachment
researcher, added a fourth category to include these children.
Disorganized attachment ā€“ children either lack an organized pat-
tern to their behavior or have strategies that repeatedly break down.
When stressed, in the presence of their caregiver, these children appear
disorganized or disoriented displaying unusual behaviors such as ap-
proaching the caregiver with their head averted, trance-like freezing, or
strange postures. These behaviors have been interpreted as evidence of
fear or confusion with respect to the caregiver. Disorganization is con-
sidered an extreme form of insecurity. (Main, 1981).
Causes of Insecure Attachment and Attachment Disorders
- The caregiver is unable to provide for the child. Sometimes,
parents may love and intend the best for their children, but not
know themselves how to provide the care the children need.
They may have a history of abuse, depression, trauma or be
overwhelmed by work and childcare responsibilities. A medical
emergency may have occurred in the parent, making care very
difļ¬cult. A death or trauma in the family can also have enormous
impact.
Angelka Velkoska et al.
534
- Abuse and neglect. If the primary caregiver is a source of pain
and terror, as in physical or emotional abuse, a secure attach-
ment cannot form. Parents who abuse alcohol and drugs may
have a lowered threshold for violence and are at increased risk
for neglecting their children.
- Constantly changing caregivers. Insecure attachment can also
occur if the child has very little interaction with a primary care-
giver, but instead has a succession of childcare providers that are
not attuned to the child and do not stay in the childā€™s life.
- Children in institutional care. Children in institutional care
have not only lost their primary caregiver but may have lived in
conditions where they cannot form a secure bond. Children in a
succession of foster or group homes, or children adopted from
overseas who have lived in orphanages, are at risk.
- Child illness or disability. Infants with long hospital stays,
where they have been isolated and alone, are also at risk. Parents
may also feel overwhelmed with an infantā€™s needs if the infant
is constantly sick and in pain, withdrawing or lashing out at the
child because they donā€™t know what to do. (Kemp et al., 2009)
If we look at the previous division, we can see that people with dis-
abilities have a higher risk to develop insecure attachment. But often in
our country as in many others, these people are unnecessarily exposed
to other factors, and we make even higher risk for insecure attachment.
One of those factors was institutional care that we provide for children
with disabilities. One of the ļ¬rst measures for primary prevention is the
prevention against separation of child from the mother during the ļ¬rst
year of life. The risk exists until the 4th or 5th year of the childā€™s life.
For mentally retarded children, when the case is child's separation from
the mother, we should be lead by the mental age and not the calendar
age of the youngster.
Assessment of emotional connection between mother and child
can estimate by using the test called "Strange situation" and "Q-sort"
methods.
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
535
The "strange situation" is a laboratory procedure used to assess
infant attachment style. The procedure consists of the following eight
episodes: (Connell & Goldsmith, 1982)
1. Parent and infant are introduced to the experimental room.
2. Parent and infant are alone. Parent does not participate while
infant explores.
3. Stranger enters, converses with parent, then approaches infant.
Parent leaves inconspicuously.
4. First separation episode: Stranger's behavior is geared to that of
infant.
5. First reunion episode: Parent greets and comforts infant, then
leaves again.
6. Second separation episode: Infant is alone.
7. Continuation of second separation episode: Stranger enters and
gears behavior to that of infant.
8. Second reunion episode: Parent enters, greets infant, and picks
up infant; stranger leaves inconspicuously.
The Attachment Q-Set was developed for three reasons:
- to provide an economical methodology for further examining re-
lations between secure base behavior at home and Strange Situ-
ation classiļ¬cations,
- to better deļ¬ne (via a Q-set) the behavioral referents of the se-
cure base concept, and
- to stimulate interesting normative secure base behavior and indi-
vidual differences in attachment security beyond infancy.
In our research we used Q-set methods, version 3.0. It was written
in 1987 and consists 90 items.
This illustrates a method that can be used to test the validity of
Strange Situation classiļ¬cations across age, across cultures, and in clin-
ical populations. (Waters, 1987)
1.2 Neurological aspects of the
disorganized / disoriented attachment
When a child has developmental delays, the emotional tie between
parent and child may not be as easy to achieve. For example, a prema-
Angelka Velkoska et al.
536
ture infant who has developmental delays may not smile at the typical
four to six weeks, she may not be able to coo, clap her hands, or even sit
on the ļ¬‚oor and play with mom and dad as other child can. She may not
give clear messages as to when she is hungry, tired, or over-stimulated.
If the parent has a difļ¬cult time understanding the babyā€™s cues, or the
baby does not respond as expected, the ā€œemotional playā€ is interrupted
and the synchrony between them can be broken. Also, when a child is
dependent on her mother for needs beyond the routine feeding, holding,
playing each day, the dynamics of love between them can change. The
mom may have to switch back and forth between the roles of being a
nurse and mother, which can confuse both her and the child.
There were a number of studies designed to answer whether a be-
havior that is considered to disorganize and disorient may be associated
with neurological abnormalities. Studies have shown that the percent-
age of children with disoriented / disorientated attachment was signiļ¬-
cantly higher in those who had neurological abnormalities, compared
to the children who donā€™t have abnormalities. The percentage of D at-
tachment was increased in children with autism and Down syndrome
(35%), among children born prematurely (24%) and children whose
mother was an alcoholic or drug addict (43%). (Main, 1990).
Main and Solomon described several speciļ¬c behaviors in chil-
dren with D attachment to the mother. They gave seven key behaviors
that can deļ¬ne this attachment:
1. Periodically access contradictory behavior of parents.
2. Ex. When a parent would seek to embrace the child (to spread
hands) it moves towards the wall or standing in the middle of the
room with the frozen, silly expression on his face.
3. Simultaneous display of contradictory behavior of parents.
4. Ex. The child sits in the lap of parents, but it is stiff or childā€™s
smile towards the parent has elements of fear.
5. Wrong, incomplete movements or expressions,
6. Ex. When a child is frightened, it doesnā€™t goes to his parents to
seek comfort.
7. Stereotyped, unsymmetrical movements and improper posture.
8. Ex. Swaying, pulling his ear, bending the hair and other rhyth-
mic repetitions of certain movements.
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
537
9. Cold, static and slow movements and expressions.
10. Direct display of misunderstanding by the parent.
11. Immediate indicators, indicators of D attachment
A number of syndromes, diseases and health disorders may be ac-
companied by neurological disorders, such as autism, cerebral palsy,
Down syndrome, epilepsy, Tay ā€“ Sachs disease and many others. It is
important to emphasize that the behaviors points to the D attachment
are very rare in the general population, which is not the case when it
comes to children with disabilities. Main and Solomon described spe-
ciļ¬c behaviors of the child, but when observed, we should not look
exactly for these behaviors, but behaviors that are similar or close to
them and who has shown the presence of D attachment between parent
and child.
Children with Down syndrome
in Strange Situation
Bowlby used the term "secure attachment" as a system of childā€™s
behavior, when the child uses his/her mother as a secure base to explore
the environment and after each survey returns to her to receive the nec-
essary physical and emotional contact.
He establishes two types of mad behavior, i.e.:
ā€“ Secure behavior, which serves the child to call her mother. Such
behaviors are: crying, laughing and gesture like the spread of
arms.
ā€“ Accessible behavior: when the child goes to the mother or lo-
cated in its vicinity. These include walking and running.
This research examines these behaviors in children with Down
syndrome. Behaviors such as their reaction when they are alone only in
the presence of the mother, only in the presence of unknown or in the
presence of both, actually the behavior in Strange Situation.
This research examined 12 children with Down syndrome and 12 chil-
dren without disabilities (a control group). The experimental and the
control group were homogeneous in terms of sex, age and social status.
(Bowlby, 1983)
Angelka Velkoska et al.
538
1.1. Emotional ties ā€“ children with autism and Down syndrome
Parents and families who have child with disabilities are in the
front of the big test. However, in contrary the child suffers from the
repercussions of the unfulļ¬lled parental expectations.
Parents go through several stages: (Kopachev, 2008)
- Stage of shock ā€“ crying, irrational behavior and helplessness;
- Stage of negation ā€“ followed by the words: ā€œThis is not pos-
sibleā€ or ā€œThis is not happening to usā€;
- Stage of anger ā€“ often to the child with disabilities, anxiety etc;
- Stage of reorganization ā€“ parents accept the reality and begin to
act constructively.
Mother suffers from depression and sorrow for a long time. For
that period the child grows aside a mother that resembles "dead mother"
and she is unable to serve as a reļ¬‚ection of her image of life and exis-
tence to the child. Relations with objects that are very important for the
development of the child will be affected across all the life stages.
Children with autism show difļ¬culties not only in the creation of
emotional ties, but in expressing their emotions. When they were com-
pared to mentally healthy children, they showed greater lack of emo-
tion and a lot less need for sharing emotions and interactions with other
people.
Autism has been found to disrupt mother-child interaction gen-
erally and speciļ¬cally maternal responsibility. (van IJzendoorn et al,
2007).
During free play, children with autism compared to other children
from the same age-group, played with a fewer toys and were less fo-
cused on entering the game and rarely interacted with their peers. When
the game was more structural, children with autism had more contact
with their teammates and they were not distinguishable from their peers.
Based on this fact, we can conclude that children with autism do not
miss the ability to express their emotions, but have reduced social skills
that affect their opportunity for emotional expression.
The aim of one survey was to make a comparison of the emotional
statements of children with autism and children with Down syndrome.
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
539
Children with autism showed greater capacity for emotional expression
than is expected of them, in terms of their mental abilities.
Children with autism showed less positive emotions toward their
mothers during the game than children with Down syndrome. These
children showed negative effects in their feedback of emotional re-
quests by their mother and existence of hostility and fast irritability.
The biggest difference between these two groups was in the ļ¬eld of
self-regulation (self-control). Self-control includes the emotional reac-
tions during the game, the attention of the child, the child exploring
experience, focusing on toys, this includes the possibility of the child to
solve a problem and to determine the function of toys.
II CASE STUDY
In the further section of the text, we will present two case studies.
With Q-set we analyzed two children with disabilities, in order to deter-
mine whether they have secure or insecure attachment. In the same time
we will make comparison between emotional ties which those children
had develop with their mothers. These girls were at the age of ļ¬ve. One
of them has Down syndrome (DS), and the other has autism with intel-
lectual disability.
The results of the child with DS showed that she has developed
insecure attachment, and according to the results of the Person coef-
ļ¬cient of correlation she had 0.23 ratios of attachment. Through analy-
sis we determined that the child with autism has extremely insecure
attachment, with a coefļ¬cient of ā€“ 0.35. The results from the analysis
were compared against standardized coefļ¬cients that are considered as
a characteristic of the safest child ā€“ criterion sort.
In the study we used version 3.0 of the Q-sort test consisting 90
items. Below are presented the results of some of the items that are
especially important for determining the emotional ties between child
and his/her mother ā€“ care giver. Items are grouped in several groups:
affective sharing, secure base, enjoyment of physical contacts, compli-
ance and fussy/difļ¬cult.
Angelka Velkoska et al.
540
Table 1. Scores in items for affective sharing and differences between
scores of the child with DS and the child with autism
Aļ¬€ecļæ½ve sharing
Auļæ½sm
Down
Syndrome
secure
child
ā€“
criterion
sort
diļ¬€erences
between
secure
child
and
au-
ļæ½sm
child
diļ¬€erences
between
secure
child
and
DS
child
1. When child ļ¬nds something new
to play with, he carries it to mother or
shows it to her from across the room.
1 1 7.6 6.6 6.6
2. Child quickly greets his mother with
a big smile when she enters the room.
(Shows her a toy, gestures, or says "Hi,
Mommy").
7 9 8.6 1.6 0.4
3. Child tries to get mother to imitate
him, or quickly noļæ½ces and enjoys it
when mom imitates him on her own.
1 9 7.2 6.2 1.8
From this table we can see that the child with autism and the child
with Down syndrome achieved lower scores on the items related to
affective sharing. We observed big differences in the ļ¬rst item (6.6),
from which we can see that these children do not feel their mother as a
secure base for research. The child with autism had the lowest score for
3 items, so we can conclude that she cannot recognize the signs which
her mother sends to her, like it is imitation.
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
541
Table 2. Scores in secure base items and differences between scores
of the child with DS and the child with autism.
Secure base items
Auļæ½sm
Down
Syndrome
secure
child
defenses
between
se-
cure
child
and
auļæ½sm
child
defenses
between
secure
child
and
DS
child
1. When he is upset or injured, child will accept
comforļæ½ng from adults other than mother.
6 6 5.5 0.5 0.5
2. Child is willing to talk to new people, show them
toys, or show them what he can do, if mother asks
him to.
3 5 6.6 3.6 1.6
3. Child keeps track of motherā€™s locaļæ½on when he
plays around the house.
4 1 5.6 1.6 4.6
4. Child is easy for mother to lose track of when he
is playing out of her sight.
6 6 2.9 3.1 3.1
5. Child someļæ½mes signals mother (or gives the im-
pression) that he wants to be put down, and then
fusses or wants to be picked right back up.
4 6 2 2 4
6. When child is upset about mother leaving him,
he sits right where he is and cries. Doesnā€™t go aļæ½er
her.
8 6 1.4 6.6 4.6
7. Child clearly shows a paļæ½ern of using mother as
a base from which to explore.
3 3 8.9 5.9 5.9
8. Child will accept and enjoy loud sounds or be-
ing bounced around in play, if mother smiles and
shows that it is supposed to be fun.
6 9 5.4 0.6 3.6
9. If mother reassures him by saying "Itā€™s OKā€™ or "It
wonā€™t hurt you", child will approach or play with
things that iniļæ½ally made him cauļæ½ous or afraid.
6 5 8.9 2.9 3.9
10. If held in motherā€™s arms, child stops crying and
quickly recovers aļæ½er being frightened or upset.
2 9 9 7 0
11. At home, child gets upset or cries when moth-
er walks out of the room. (May or may not follow
her.)
3 4 1.8 1.2 2.2
12. Child uses motherā€™s facial expressions as good
source of informaļæ½on when something looks risky
or threatening.
1 2 8.8 7.8 6.8
Angelka Velkoska et al.
542
This table gives us very important information about the emo-
tional ties between the mother and the child. Bout children do not
feel their mother as a secure object for making emotional connection.
There is no adequate emotional sheering, the mother did not sufļ¬-
ciently recognize the signs from her child. On the other hand, the
child cannot understand what is required from him/her and how he/
she can respond to those requests because of the intellectual difļ¬cul-
ties. We can notice this in the items with particular low scores, actu-
ally with big differences compared to the scores of a ā€œsecure childā€,
in the items number 7, 10 and 12.
Table 3. Scores in secure base items and differences between scores
of the child with DS and the child with autism.
Enjoyment of physical contact
Auļæ½sm
Down
Syndrome
Secure
child
diļ¬€erences
between
secure
child
and
au-
ļæ½sm
child
diļ¬€erences
between
secure
child
and
DS
child
1. Child oļæ½en hugs or cuddles against mother,
without her asking or inviļæ½ng him to do so.
5 3 7.4 2.4 4.4
2. Child enjoys relaxing in motherā€™s lap. 3 9 7.4 4.4 1.6
3. Child asks for and enjoys having mother hold,
hug, and cuddle him.
5 8 8.3 3.3 0.3
4. Child puts his arms around mother or puts
his hand on her shoulder when she picks him
up.
4 4 7.8 3.8 3.8
5. Child enjoys climbing all over mother when
they play.
5 3 6.6 1.6 3.6
Itā€™s necessary to have a physical contact, so you can build adequate
emotional connection with somebody. Yet again, the scores of these
items are different to the scores of the so-called ā€œsecure childā€. The
autistic child has signiļ¬cant differences in the second item, compared
to the criterion sort. This is an aspect of secure based behavior. A child
who enjoys close physical contact is expected to ļ¬nd such a comforting
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
543
contact if distressed. During our observation we noticed that the child is
confused and stiff when she sits in her motherā€™s lap.
Table 4. Scores for compliance items and differences between scores
of the child with DS and the child with autism.
Compliance
Auļæ½sm
Down
Syndrome
secure
child
diļ¬€erences
between
secure
child
and
auļæ½sm
child
diļ¬€erences
betw-
een
secure
child
and
DS
child
1. Child readily shares with mother or lets her
hold things if she asks to. 6 7 8.3 2.3 1.3
2. Child follows motherā€™s suggesļæ½ons readily,
even when they are clearly suggesļæ½ons rather
than orders.
4 7 6.7 2.7 1.7
3. When mother tells child to bring or give her
something, he obeys. 2 7 7 5 0
4. When mother says "No" or punishes him,
child stops misbehaving (at least at that ļæ½me).
Doesnā€™t have to be told twice.
2 4 6.1 4.1 2.1
5. When mother says to follow her, child does
so.
1 8 6.8 5.8 1.2
6. Child is easily upset when mother makes him
change from one acļæ½vity to another. 7 1 2.7 4.3 1.7
In these items we can see signiļ¬cant differences between the child
with autism and the child with Down syndrome. According to this, au-
tistic child has lower compliance with her mother. She does not react
on verbal instructions from her mother and in the most cases the child
didnā€™t understand those instructions.
The biggest score differences is in the item 5. This item says more
about mother's intuitive understanding of good behavior modiļ¬cation
principles than with any trait of the child. There is also a signiļ¬cant
difference in item 3. This behavior reļ¬‚ects both the motherā€™s implicit
understanding of behavior modiļ¬cation principles and the child's his-
tory of harmonious or interfering interaction with her.
Angelka Velkoska et al.
544
There are no signiļ¬cant differences between the children with Down
syndrome and criterion sort.
Table 4 Scores for fussy/difļ¬cult items and differences between scores
of the child with DS and the child with autism.
Fussy/diļ¬ƒcult
Auļæ½sm
Down
Syndrome
secure
child
diļ¬€erences
between
secure
child
and
auļæ½sm
child
diļ¬€erences
between
se-
cure
child
and
DS
child
1. When child returns to mother aļæ½er playing,
he is someļæ½mes fussy for no clear reason.
2 6 3.1 1.1 2.9
2. When child cries, he cries hard. 8 3 4.1 3.9 1.1
3. Child is lighthearted and playful most of the
ļæ½me.
3 7 6.2 3.2 1.2
4. Child oļæ½en cries or resists when mother
takes him to bed for naps or at night.
4 5 2.5 1.5 2.5
5. When the child is upset by motherā€™s leaving,
he conļæ½nues to cry or even gets angry aļæ½er she
is gone.
7 6 2.4 5.4 4.4
6. Child ignores most bumps, falls, or startles. 9 8 3.3 6.3 5.3
7. Child cries when mother leaves him at home
with babysiļæ½er, father, or grandparent.
2 5 3.5 1.5 1.5
8. Child easily becomes angry with toys. 8 2 2.3 6.3 0.3
9. Child is demanding and impaļæ½ent with moth-
er. Fusses and persists unless she does what he
wants right away.
9 2 1.8 8.8 0.2
10. Plays roughly with mother. Bumps, scratch-
es, or bites during acļæ½ve play.
6 6 2 4 4
11. When child is in a happy mood, he is likely
to stay that way all day.
1 8 5.7 4.7 2.3
12. When mother doesnā€™t do what child wants
right away, child behaves as if mom were not
going to do it at all.
9 8 1.7 8.7 7.7
Yet again, the scores of the autistic child have bigger differences
from criterion sort, compared to the DS child. We have signiļ¬cant dif-
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
545
ferences in a several items, especially items number 8 and 9. Those
items are about frustration, tolerance or low threshold of tolerance.
I. The children have higher scores on item 12. This item is for
sensibility and includes a low threshold for detecting infant signals, co-
operation (vs. interference) with the infant's ongoing behavior, physical
and psychological availability and acceptance of the infant's needs and
demands.
III REPAIRING INSECURE ATTACHMENTS
AND ATTACHMENT DISORDERS
Insecure attachment can be a vicious cycle. Due to problems with
social relationships, insecurely attached children may become even
more isolated and withdrawn from their primary caregivers, family
and friends. Children with disabilities already have a lot of problems
making appropriate and quality social contacts with the environment.
These processes of socialization of those children will be more difļ¬cult
if they have insecure attachment with their primer caregiver. However,
it is never too late to work on forming secure attachments. While the
brain is most pliable in infancy and early childhood, it is responsive
to changes all of our lives. Relationships with relatives, teachers and
childcare providers can also supply an important source of connection
and strength for a childā€™s developing mind.
Secure attachment doesnā€™t happen overnight. It is an ongoing pro-
cess between the parent and baby. Early intervention has the greatest
chance of success. Appropriate models of intervention with mother-in-
fant dyads are available. The availability of support services to new
mothers is essential.
Intervention with toddlers and older children is also possible. To
understand how to do this we need to look at the way in which secure
attachment develops between caregiver and infant. While we cannot
recreate this situation it is important to remember that the basic needs of
the baby are still unmet in the child who is not securely attached.
Holding and eye contact are very important. Children with attach-
ment difļ¬culties often resist this. This is especially characteristic of
children with autism, they cannot make eye-contact with other person.
Angelka Velkoska et al.
546
In the treatment of the child we can use holding therapy, so we can im-
prove eye-contact, but from the other hand we will have big inļ¬‚uence in
improvement the emotional ties between child and his primer caregiver.
In the past it was believed that autism occurs as a result of emotional
lack of the mother ā€“ "cold mothers", today we know that inability to es-
tablish adequate emotional contacts between the child with autism and
his mother is not a cause of autism as a condition, but its consequence.
Holding therapy has been demonstrated to be effective in a wide
range of situations. This technique is based on the physical holding of
children, even while they protest. Clearly there are problems implement-
ing this with older children and children have suffered abuse. However,
holding can be achieved in other ways ā€“ sitting with children, tucking
them into bed and staying with them etc. (Welch 1988).
Building a secure attachment requires all your nonverbal commu-
nication skills, not just eyeā€“ contact, but also gentle handling, playful
movements at times, rhythmic movement, a soft soothing voice (child
maybe canā€™t understand what we are saying, but he or she can enjoy just
listening of our voice).
For making secure attachment we must also:
- Provide support for the primary caregiver. The primary care-
giver needs to be emotionally healthy, have adequate time, and the right
skills to be attuned and responsive to the childā€™s needs.
- Help the child express his or her needs. Children with attach-
ment problems will need extra help in learning to express their needs.
They may have learned not to cry if in pain or frightened, for example,
or not associate touch with being soothed. They may revert to devel-
opmentally inappropriate behaviors if stressed or scared. It might take
extra creativity and diligence on the caregiverā€™s part to help the child
express needs safely and appropriately.
- Time, consistency and predictability is key. Problems in at-
tachment result from problems with trust. By this very deļ¬nition, re-
pairing an attachment disruption takes time, consistency and patience.
It will take time for a child to realize that they can trust and rely on their
primary caregiver and other important people in their lives.
ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME
547
REFERENCES
1. Ainsworth, M. D. S., Blehar, M. C., Waters, E.,Wall, S. (1978): Patterns of attach-
ment: A psychological study of the strange situation. Hillsdale, N.J.: Erlbaum.
2. Bowlby, J. (1983): Attachment and Loss.Harmondsworth: Basic Books.
3. Connell, J., P.,Goldsmith, H. H. (1982). A structural modeling approach to the
study of attachment and strange situation behaviors. New York: Plenum
4. Fahlberg, V. (1988): Fitting the Pieces Together. London: British Agencies for
Adoption and Fostering.
5. Fletcher, H., Skelly. A. (2008): Attachment Theory and Learning Disabilities:
Connections between early beginnings and later challenges.
6. Kemp, G., Smith, M., Saisan, J., Segal, J. Symptoms. (2009): Treatment and hope
for children with insecure attachment. Available from URL: http://helpguide.org/
mental/parenting_bonding_reactive_attachment_disorder.htm
7. Kopachev, D. (2008): Mentalno zdravje na licata so mentalna retrdacija. Unpub-
lished manuscript.
8. Main, M. (1981): Avoidance in the service of attachment. New York: Cambridge
UniversityPress.
9. Main, M., Solomon, J. (1990): Procedures for identifying infants as disorganized/
disoriented during the Ainsworth Strange Situation. Chicago: University of Chi-
cago.
10. Slonims, V. Cox, A., McConachie, H. (2006): Analysis of mother-infant interac-
tions in infants with Down Syndrome and typically developing infants. American
Journal of Mental Retardation 111:273-289.
11. Solomon, J., George,S. (1999): Attachment Disorganization. New York: Guilford
Press.
12. Van Ijzendoorn, M.H., Rutgers, A.H., Bakersmans-Kranenburg, M.J. et al (2007):
Parental sensitivity and attachment in children with autism spectrum disorder:
comparison with children with mental retardation, with language delays and with
typical development. Child Development 78, 597-608.
13. Vaughn, B. E., Stevenson-Hinde, J., Waters, E., Kotsaļ¬s, A., et al. (1992): Attach-
ment security and temperament in infancy and early childhood. Developmental
Psychology.
14. Waters, E. (1987): Attachment Q-Set (V.3.0). Unpublished manuscript. SUNY at
StonyBrook.
15. Welch, M. (1988): Mother-Child Holding Therapy in the Treatment of Develop-
mental Delays. Stamford: Connecticut.
Angelka Velkoska et al.
548

More Related Content

Similar to Attachment Theory Of The Children With Autism And Down Syndrome

Chapter6 PP HDEV MJC
Chapter6 PP HDEV MJCChapter6 PP HDEV MJC
Chapter6 PP HDEV MJCemmanuelviking
Ā 
Attachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docx
Attachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docxAttachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docx
Attachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docxcelenarouzie
Ā 
How children cope with stress
How children cope with stressHow children cope with stress
How children cope with stresskumar mahi
Ā 
Attachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and ParentingAttachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and ParentingEmilia Kardzhilova
Ā 
Attachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and ParentingAttachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and ParentingEmilia Kardzhilova
Ā 
ATTACHMENT THEORY.pptx
ATTACHMENT THEORY.pptxATTACHMENT THEORY.pptx
ATTACHMENT THEORY.pptxBeenishShahzad2
Ā 
How do genetic and environmental factors work together to influe
How do genetic and environmental factors work together to influeHow do genetic and environmental factors work together to influe
How do genetic and environmental factors work together to influemeagantobias
Ā 
Attachment AQA A Level Psychology
Attachment AQA A Level PsychologyAttachment AQA A Level Psychology
Attachment AQA A Level PsychologyElla Warwick
Ā 
Theories of Child Physical Abuse
Theories of Child Physical AbuseTheories of Child Physical Abuse
Theories of Child Physical Abusekimberlykeith
Ā 
Chap 6 life span development.pptx
Chap 6   life span development.pptxChap 6   life span development.pptx
Chap 6 life span development.pptxwindleh
Ā 
Chap 6 life span development.pptx
Chap 6   life span development.pptxChap 6   life span development.pptx
Chap 6 life span development.pptxwindleh
Ā 
Occupational Therapy Attachment Theory
Occupational Therapy Attachment TheoryOccupational Therapy Attachment Theory
Occupational Therapy Attachment TheoryStephan Van Breenen
Ā 
Group F Presentation Final B
Group F Presentation Final BGroup F Presentation Final B
Group F Presentation Final Bagrush2011
Ā 
Group F Presentation Final A
Group F Presentation Final AGroup F Presentation Final A
Group F Presentation Final Aagrush2011
Ā 
Attachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEW
Attachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEWAttachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEW
Attachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEWmind29x
Ā 
seek social which they develop with one or.docx
seek social which they develop with one or.docxseek social which they develop with one or.docx
seek social which they develop with one or.docxbkbk37
Ā 
U9A1_PSYC3500_Final_Copy
U9A1_PSYC3500_Final_CopyU9A1_PSYC3500_Final_Copy
U9A1_PSYC3500_Final_CopyCarrie Carstens
Ā 
Developmental psychology continued
Developmental psychology continuedDevelopmental psychology continued
Developmental psychology continuedSeemi Jamil
Ā 

Similar to Attachment Theory Of The Children With Autism And Down Syndrome (20)

Chapter6 PP HDEV MJC
Chapter6 PP HDEV MJCChapter6 PP HDEV MJC
Chapter6 PP HDEV MJC
Ā 
Attachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docx
Attachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docxAttachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docx
Attachment Programs and Families Working Together Learn.docx
Ā 
How children cope with stress
How children cope with stressHow children cope with stress
How children cope with stress
Ā 
Attachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and ParentingAttachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and Parenting
Ā 
Attachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and ParentingAttachment Theory and Parenting
Attachment Theory and Parenting
Ā 
Webinar-Attachment- Mike Rechtien
Webinar-Attachment- Mike RechtienWebinar-Attachment- Mike Rechtien
Webinar-Attachment- Mike Rechtien
Ā 
ATTACHMENT THEORY.pptx
ATTACHMENT THEORY.pptxATTACHMENT THEORY.pptx
ATTACHMENT THEORY.pptx
Ā 
How do genetic and environmental factors work together to influe
How do genetic and environmental factors work together to influeHow do genetic and environmental factors work together to influe
How do genetic and environmental factors work together to influe
Ā 
Attachment AQA A Level Psychology
Attachment AQA A Level PsychologyAttachment AQA A Level Psychology
Attachment AQA A Level Psychology
Ā 
Attachment Theory.pptx
Attachment Theory.pptxAttachment Theory.pptx
Attachment Theory.pptx
Ā 
Theories of Child Physical Abuse
Theories of Child Physical AbuseTheories of Child Physical Abuse
Theories of Child Physical Abuse
Ā 
Chap 6 life span development.pptx
Chap 6   life span development.pptxChap 6   life span development.pptx
Chap 6 life span development.pptx
Ā 
Chap 6 life span development.pptx
Chap 6   life span development.pptxChap 6   life span development.pptx
Chap 6 life span development.pptx
Ā 
Occupational Therapy Attachment Theory
Occupational Therapy Attachment TheoryOccupational Therapy Attachment Theory
Occupational Therapy Attachment Theory
Ā 
Group F Presentation Final B
Group F Presentation Final BGroup F Presentation Final B
Group F Presentation Final B
Ā 
Group F Presentation Final A
Group F Presentation Final AGroup F Presentation Final A
Group F Presentation Final A
Ā 
Attachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEW
Attachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEWAttachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEW
Attachment AQA A-LEVEL PSYCHOLOGY TOPIC REVIEW
Ā 
seek social which they develop with one or.docx
seek social which they develop with one or.docxseek social which they develop with one or.docx
seek social which they develop with one or.docx
Ā 
U9A1_PSYC3500_Final_Copy
U9A1_PSYC3500_Final_CopyU9A1_PSYC3500_Final_Copy
U9A1_PSYC3500_Final_Copy
Ā 
Developmental psychology continued
Developmental psychology continuedDevelopmental psychology continued
Developmental psychology continued
Ā 

More from Darian Pruitt

5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.
2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.
2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In EnglishDarian Pruitt
Ā 
13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.
50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.
50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.
9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.
9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.
3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.
3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In IndiaDarian Pruitt
Ā 
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.Darian Pruitt
Ā 
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
Ā 

More from Darian Pruitt (20)

5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Svenska. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.
2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.
2Pac Changes Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In English
Ā 
13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.
13 Reasons Why Literary Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.
50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.
50 Essays A Portable Anthology Pdf. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.
9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.
9Th Grade Essay Format. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.
3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.
3.5 Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
15 Page Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In India
Ā 
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.
5 Paragraph Essay Outline Mla Format. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.
Ā 
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.
Ā 

Recently uploaded

MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized GroupMARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized GroupJonathanParaisoCruz
Ā 
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptxTypes of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptxEyham Joco
Ā 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxiammrhaywood
Ā 
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17Celine George
Ā 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfSumit Tiwari
Ā 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfUjwalaBharambe
Ā 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļøcall girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
Ā 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTiammrhaywood
Ā 
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerinternship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerunnathinaik
Ā 
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...jaredbarbolino94
Ā 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17Celine George
Ā 
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfBiting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfadityarao40181
Ā 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
Ā 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceSamikshaHamane
Ā 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
Ā 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
Ā 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
Ā 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxGaneshChakor2
Ā 
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course  for BeginnersFull Stack Web Development Course  for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course for BeginnersSabitha Banu
Ā 

Recently uploaded (20)

MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized GroupMARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
Ā 
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptxTypes of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Ā 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
Ā 
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
Ā 
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Computed Fields and api Depends in the Odoo 17
Ā 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Ā 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Ā 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļøcall girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
Ā 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
Ā 
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerinternship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
Ā 
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Ā 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
Ā 
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfBiting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Ā 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Ā 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Ā 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Ā 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Ā 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Ā 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
Ā 
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course  for BeginnersFull Stack Web Development Course  for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Ā 

Attachment Theory Of The Children With Autism And Down Syndrome

  • 1. 313 heme 4 INDIVIDUAL TREATMENT OF DEVELOPMENTAL DIFFICULTIES AND DISABILITIES
  • 2. 529 ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME Angelka Velkoska1 , Goran Ajdinski1 and Milena Milicevic2 1 Institute of Special Education and Rehabilitation, Faculty of Philosophy, ā€œSs Cyril and Methodiusā€ University, Skopje, Republic of Macedonia 2Medical College of Professional Studies ā€œMilutin Milankovicā€, Belgrade, Serbia Summary The general aim of this study was to explore the emotional ties between child with disability and its attachment ļ¬gure (mother) and pathology that can occur in this emotional bond. For this pro- pose we study two children with disability (child with autism and child with Down syndrome) and to access the results we used ver- sion 3 of the Q-sort test, which consists of 90 items. Here we pre- sented characteristics of a ā€œsecure attachmentā€ with the primer care giver, also characteristics of ā€œunsecure attachmentā€, classiļ¬- cations, causes of insecure attachment and methods that can help us to recover emotional ties. We gave special explanation of disor- ganization / disorientation, as most frequent insecure attachment of the child with disabilities. Throughout analysis, we determined that both examined children have insecure attachment. According to the results of the Person coefļ¬cient of correlation child with Down syndrome has 0.23 ratios of attachment, and child with au- tism has coefļ¬cient of ā€“ 0.35. The results from the analysis were compared with standardized coefļ¬cients that are considered as a characteristic of the safest child ā€“ criterion sort.
  • 3. Angelka Velkoska et al. 530 KEY WORDS: attachment theory, insecure attachment, emotional ties, Down Syndrome, autism. I. OVERVIEW OF THE ATTACHMENT THEORY Attachment theory was ļ¬rst conceptualized in the 1950ā€™s by John Bowlby. It was ļ¬rst a clinical theory based upon the observation that the delinquent boys he was working with all suffered severe traumatic losses. His inquiry led him to explore the effects of early separation, evolutionary biology, ethology, cognitive neuroscience and information processing theory. An attachment may be deļ¬ned as an affection tie that one person or animal forms between himself and another speciļ¬c one ā€“ a tie that binds them together in space and endures over time. (Vaughn et al, 1992) The emphasis on attachment to the mother has shifted to an em- phasis on the primary caregiver (which may not be the mother) and it is now recognized that children can form multiple attachments. An impor- tant development in challenging the assumption that mothers needed to be at home full-time was the discovery that quality was more important than quantity in forming secure attachments between caregivers and their children. Both the primary caregiver and the infant are active par- ticipants in this process. The key factor for the caregiver is sensitive responsiveness ā€“ the ability to attune to the child and respond to their signals. The child's responsiveness is also an important contributor to the process. When the parent and the child are in sync with each other, then the child develops a secure attachment. The child feels safe, know- ing that mom or dad will be there when needed. The success or failure of the parent-children attachment bond has a life-long effect on the way your child feels about him or herself and about others. Individuals who experience confusing, frightening, or broken emotional communications during their infancy often grow into adults who have difļ¬culty understanding their own emotions and the feelings of others. This limits their ability to build or maintain success- ful relationships. Secure attachment helps the child: (Fahlberg et al., 1988) - attain full intellectual potential;
  • 4. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 531 - sort out what he or she perceives; - think logically; - develop a conscience; - become self-reliant; - cope with stress and frustration; - handle fear and worry; - develop future relationships; - reduce jealousy. With secure attachment there is a fertile environment for the capac- ity for ļ¬ve kinds of love: maternal love, paternal love, peer love, sexual love, and parental love. Early affective ties have a big inļ¬‚uence in so- cial activities of the child, accomplishing higher degree of socialization, conļ¬dent and good about themselves and enjoying being with others. 1.1. Attachment and psychopathology Infants are helpless from birth, and need consistent, loving re- sponses to their needs for food, sleep and comfort. As the infant grows, so does the bond of trust with the primary caregiver. Secure attachment has a lifelong effect on growth, development, trust and relationships. If a child is not provided this consistent, loving care, he will develop an insecure attachments form. Children with insecure attachments have learned that the world is not a safe place. They donā€™t have the expe- riences they need to feel conļ¬dent in themselves and trust in others. Because attachment is a fundamental part of childrenā€™s development that affects the growing brain, insecure attachment shows itself in many different ways. Signs of attachment problems: (Fletcher, 2008) - Inappropriately clinging and demanding; - Little exploration of environment; - Reckless self-endangerment (failure to use secure base in times of risk); - Role reversal ā€“ excessive concern for attachment ļ¬gure; - Hyper vigilance leading to withdrawal and ambivalence; - Indiscriminate friendliness; - Superļ¬cially engaging and charming behavior;
  • 5. Angelka Velkoska et al. 532 - Avoidance of eye contact; - Extreme independence; - Lack of affection on carerā€™s terms; - Destructiveness to self, others, and material things; - Difļ¬culty using others for emotional comfort; - Learning delays -more than expected for intellectual abilities; - Extreme sensitivity to change or rejection; - Abnormal eating patterns; - Poor peer relationships; - Persistent questioning or chatter; - Sleep disturbances, in particular not being able to sleep alone. In this list we can see that signs, symptoms for attachment prob- lems can be manifested as an emotional, physical, social problems and problems in educational process. Different patterns of attachment have been identiļ¬ed by Ainsworth using the 'Strange Situation'. This was a laboratory experiment in which the interaction between mothers and infants was observed prior to, during and after a brief separation. Three categories have been identiļ¬ed by Ainsworth: (Ainsworth, 1978) Secure attachment ā€“ child protested when mother left, sought her out while she was gone, greeted her with delight when she returned, explored more when mother present (Category B). Secure children explore freely in the presence of their caregiver, check on him or her periodically, and restrict exploration during the caregiverā€™s absence. Children who are securely attached show varying levels of distress in the absence of their caregiver but respond positively to the caregiverā€™s return. They will seek contact with their parent when distressed and will settle down once contact is made and comfort is provided. Anxious attachment ā€“ distressed when mother left, little relief when reunited, highly anxious before, during and after separation, loathe to explore even when mother present (Category C). In addition, they ļ¬nd little comfort in contact and are often angered if mother tries to comfort them with a toy. They are sometimes termed ā€œambivalentā€ in reference to the fact that they mix weak contact maintaining with strong protest if
  • 6. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 533 mother puts them on the ļ¬‚oor. Exploratory behavior rarely recovers to preseparation levels during the reunion episodes. (Solomon, 1999) Avoidant attachment ā€“ relatively indifferent to mother, rarely cried when she left, little positive response on return, curiosity unaf- fected by mother's presence (Category A). Avoidant children seem not to care whether a parent is present or absent. In the presence of the care- giver, avoidant children will explore their environment without inter- est in the parentā€™s whereabouts. Upon departure avoidant children are minimally distressed. At reunion avoidant children do not move toward the parent or try to initiate contact. In fact, they often ignore or avoid the parent. Despite this apparent lack of concern, infants with an avoid- ant attachment style show as much, if not more, physiological arousal than other infants, suggesting that they have learned to contain their distress. There is a group of children who do not ļ¬t into Ainsworthā€™s origi- nal three-category scheme. Mary Main, another inļ¬‚uential attachment researcher, added a fourth category to include these children. Disorganized attachment ā€“ children either lack an organized pat- tern to their behavior or have strategies that repeatedly break down. When stressed, in the presence of their caregiver, these children appear disorganized or disoriented displaying unusual behaviors such as ap- proaching the caregiver with their head averted, trance-like freezing, or strange postures. These behaviors have been interpreted as evidence of fear or confusion with respect to the caregiver. Disorganization is con- sidered an extreme form of insecurity. (Main, 1981). Causes of Insecure Attachment and Attachment Disorders - The caregiver is unable to provide for the child. Sometimes, parents may love and intend the best for their children, but not know themselves how to provide the care the children need. They may have a history of abuse, depression, trauma or be overwhelmed by work and childcare responsibilities. A medical emergency may have occurred in the parent, making care very difļ¬cult. A death or trauma in the family can also have enormous impact.
  • 7. Angelka Velkoska et al. 534 - Abuse and neglect. If the primary caregiver is a source of pain and terror, as in physical or emotional abuse, a secure attach- ment cannot form. Parents who abuse alcohol and drugs may have a lowered threshold for violence and are at increased risk for neglecting their children. - Constantly changing caregivers. Insecure attachment can also occur if the child has very little interaction with a primary care- giver, but instead has a succession of childcare providers that are not attuned to the child and do not stay in the childā€™s life. - Children in institutional care. Children in institutional care have not only lost their primary caregiver but may have lived in conditions where they cannot form a secure bond. Children in a succession of foster or group homes, or children adopted from overseas who have lived in orphanages, are at risk. - Child illness or disability. Infants with long hospital stays, where they have been isolated and alone, are also at risk. Parents may also feel overwhelmed with an infantā€™s needs if the infant is constantly sick and in pain, withdrawing or lashing out at the child because they donā€™t know what to do. (Kemp et al., 2009) If we look at the previous division, we can see that people with dis- abilities have a higher risk to develop insecure attachment. But often in our country as in many others, these people are unnecessarily exposed to other factors, and we make even higher risk for insecure attachment. One of those factors was institutional care that we provide for children with disabilities. One of the ļ¬rst measures for primary prevention is the prevention against separation of child from the mother during the ļ¬rst year of life. The risk exists until the 4th or 5th year of the childā€™s life. For mentally retarded children, when the case is child's separation from the mother, we should be lead by the mental age and not the calendar age of the youngster. Assessment of emotional connection between mother and child can estimate by using the test called "Strange situation" and "Q-sort" methods.
  • 8. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 535 The "strange situation" is a laboratory procedure used to assess infant attachment style. The procedure consists of the following eight episodes: (Connell & Goldsmith, 1982) 1. Parent and infant are introduced to the experimental room. 2. Parent and infant are alone. Parent does not participate while infant explores. 3. Stranger enters, converses with parent, then approaches infant. Parent leaves inconspicuously. 4. First separation episode: Stranger's behavior is geared to that of infant. 5. First reunion episode: Parent greets and comforts infant, then leaves again. 6. Second separation episode: Infant is alone. 7. Continuation of second separation episode: Stranger enters and gears behavior to that of infant. 8. Second reunion episode: Parent enters, greets infant, and picks up infant; stranger leaves inconspicuously. The Attachment Q-Set was developed for three reasons: - to provide an economical methodology for further examining re- lations between secure base behavior at home and Strange Situ- ation classiļ¬cations, - to better deļ¬ne (via a Q-set) the behavioral referents of the se- cure base concept, and - to stimulate interesting normative secure base behavior and indi- vidual differences in attachment security beyond infancy. In our research we used Q-set methods, version 3.0. It was written in 1987 and consists 90 items. This illustrates a method that can be used to test the validity of Strange Situation classiļ¬cations across age, across cultures, and in clin- ical populations. (Waters, 1987) 1.2 Neurological aspects of the disorganized / disoriented attachment When a child has developmental delays, the emotional tie between parent and child may not be as easy to achieve. For example, a prema-
  • 9. Angelka Velkoska et al. 536 ture infant who has developmental delays may not smile at the typical four to six weeks, she may not be able to coo, clap her hands, or even sit on the ļ¬‚oor and play with mom and dad as other child can. She may not give clear messages as to when she is hungry, tired, or over-stimulated. If the parent has a difļ¬cult time understanding the babyā€™s cues, or the baby does not respond as expected, the ā€œemotional playā€ is interrupted and the synchrony between them can be broken. Also, when a child is dependent on her mother for needs beyond the routine feeding, holding, playing each day, the dynamics of love between them can change. The mom may have to switch back and forth between the roles of being a nurse and mother, which can confuse both her and the child. There were a number of studies designed to answer whether a be- havior that is considered to disorganize and disorient may be associated with neurological abnormalities. Studies have shown that the percent- age of children with disoriented / disorientated attachment was signiļ¬- cantly higher in those who had neurological abnormalities, compared to the children who donā€™t have abnormalities. The percentage of D at- tachment was increased in children with autism and Down syndrome (35%), among children born prematurely (24%) and children whose mother was an alcoholic or drug addict (43%). (Main, 1990). Main and Solomon described several speciļ¬c behaviors in chil- dren with D attachment to the mother. They gave seven key behaviors that can deļ¬ne this attachment: 1. Periodically access contradictory behavior of parents. 2. Ex. When a parent would seek to embrace the child (to spread hands) it moves towards the wall or standing in the middle of the room with the frozen, silly expression on his face. 3. Simultaneous display of contradictory behavior of parents. 4. Ex. The child sits in the lap of parents, but it is stiff or childā€™s smile towards the parent has elements of fear. 5. Wrong, incomplete movements or expressions, 6. Ex. When a child is frightened, it doesnā€™t goes to his parents to seek comfort. 7. Stereotyped, unsymmetrical movements and improper posture. 8. Ex. Swaying, pulling his ear, bending the hair and other rhyth- mic repetitions of certain movements.
  • 10. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 537 9. Cold, static and slow movements and expressions. 10. Direct display of misunderstanding by the parent. 11. Immediate indicators, indicators of D attachment A number of syndromes, diseases and health disorders may be ac- companied by neurological disorders, such as autism, cerebral palsy, Down syndrome, epilepsy, Tay ā€“ Sachs disease and many others. It is important to emphasize that the behaviors points to the D attachment are very rare in the general population, which is not the case when it comes to children with disabilities. Main and Solomon described spe- ciļ¬c behaviors of the child, but when observed, we should not look exactly for these behaviors, but behaviors that are similar or close to them and who has shown the presence of D attachment between parent and child. Children with Down syndrome in Strange Situation Bowlby used the term "secure attachment" as a system of childā€™s behavior, when the child uses his/her mother as a secure base to explore the environment and after each survey returns to her to receive the nec- essary physical and emotional contact. He establishes two types of mad behavior, i.e.: ā€“ Secure behavior, which serves the child to call her mother. Such behaviors are: crying, laughing and gesture like the spread of arms. ā€“ Accessible behavior: when the child goes to the mother or lo- cated in its vicinity. These include walking and running. This research examines these behaviors in children with Down syndrome. Behaviors such as their reaction when they are alone only in the presence of the mother, only in the presence of unknown or in the presence of both, actually the behavior in Strange Situation. This research examined 12 children with Down syndrome and 12 chil- dren without disabilities (a control group). The experimental and the control group were homogeneous in terms of sex, age and social status. (Bowlby, 1983)
  • 11. Angelka Velkoska et al. 538 1.1. Emotional ties ā€“ children with autism and Down syndrome Parents and families who have child with disabilities are in the front of the big test. However, in contrary the child suffers from the repercussions of the unfulļ¬lled parental expectations. Parents go through several stages: (Kopachev, 2008) - Stage of shock ā€“ crying, irrational behavior and helplessness; - Stage of negation ā€“ followed by the words: ā€œThis is not pos- sibleā€ or ā€œThis is not happening to usā€; - Stage of anger ā€“ often to the child with disabilities, anxiety etc; - Stage of reorganization ā€“ parents accept the reality and begin to act constructively. Mother suffers from depression and sorrow for a long time. For that period the child grows aside a mother that resembles "dead mother" and she is unable to serve as a reļ¬‚ection of her image of life and exis- tence to the child. Relations with objects that are very important for the development of the child will be affected across all the life stages. Children with autism show difļ¬culties not only in the creation of emotional ties, but in expressing their emotions. When they were com- pared to mentally healthy children, they showed greater lack of emo- tion and a lot less need for sharing emotions and interactions with other people. Autism has been found to disrupt mother-child interaction gen- erally and speciļ¬cally maternal responsibility. (van IJzendoorn et al, 2007). During free play, children with autism compared to other children from the same age-group, played with a fewer toys and were less fo- cused on entering the game and rarely interacted with their peers. When the game was more structural, children with autism had more contact with their teammates and they were not distinguishable from their peers. Based on this fact, we can conclude that children with autism do not miss the ability to express their emotions, but have reduced social skills that affect their opportunity for emotional expression. The aim of one survey was to make a comparison of the emotional statements of children with autism and children with Down syndrome.
  • 12. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 539 Children with autism showed greater capacity for emotional expression than is expected of them, in terms of their mental abilities. Children with autism showed less positive emotions toward their mothers during the game than children with Down syndrome. These children showed negative effects in their feedback of emotional re- quests by their mother and existence of hostility and fast irritability. The biggest difference between these two groups was in the ļ¬eld of self-regulation (self-control). Self-control includes the emotional reac- tions during the game, the attention of the child, the child exploring experience, focusing on toys, this includes the possibility of the child to solve a problem and to determine the function of toys. II CASE STUDY In the further section of the text, we will present two case studies. With Q-set we analyzed two children with disabilities, in order to deter- mine whether they have secure or insecure attachment. In the same time we will make comparison between emotional ties which those children had develop with their mothers. These girls were at the age of ļ¬ve. One of them has Down syndrome (DS), and the other has autism with intel- lectual disability. The results of the child with DS showed that she has developed insecure attachment, and according to the results of the Person coef- ļ¬cient of correlation she had 0.23 ratios of attachment. Through analy- sis we determined that the child with autism has extremely insecure attachment, with a coefļ¬cient of ā€“ 0.35. The results from the analysis were compared against standardized coefļ¬cients that are considered as a characteristic of the safest child ā€“ criterion sort. In the study we used version 3.0 of the Q-sort test consisting 90 items. Below are presented the results of some of the items that are especially important for determining the emotional ties between child and his/her mother ā€“ care giver. Items are grouped in several groups: affective sharing, secure base, enjoyment of physical contacts, compli- ance and fussy/difļ¬cult.
  • 13. Angelka Velkoska et al. 540 Table 1. Scores in items for affective sharing and differences between scores of the child with DS and the child with autism Aļ¬€ecļæ½ve sharing Auļæ½sm Down Syndrome secure child ā€“ criterion sort diļ¬€erences between secure child and au- ļæ½sm child diļ¬€erences between secure child and DS child 1. When child ļ¬nds something new to play with, he carries it to mother or shows it to her from across the room. 1 1 7.6 6.6 6.6 2. Child quickly greets his mother with a big smile when she enters the room. (Shows her a toy, gestures, or says "Hi, Mommy"). 7 9 8.6 1.6 0.4 3. Child tries to get mother to imitate him, or quickly noļæ½ces and enjoys it when mom imitates him on her own. 1 9 7.2 6.2 1.8 From this table we can see that the child with autism and the child with Down syndrome achieved lower scores on the items related to affective sharing. We observed big differences in the ļ¬rst item (6.6), from which we can see that these children do not feel their mother as a secure base for research. The child with autism had the lowest score for 3 items, so we can conclude that she cannot recognize the signs which her mother sends to her, like it is imitation.
  • 14. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 541 Table 2. Scores in secure base items and differences between scores of the child with DS and the child with autism. Secure base items Auļæ½sm Down Syndrome secure child defenses between se- cure child and auļæ½sm child defenses between secure child and DS child 1. When he is upset or injured, child will accept comforļæ½ng from adults other than mother. 6 6 5.5 0.5 0.5 2. Child is willing to talk to new people, show them toys, or show them what he can do, if mother asks him to. 3 5 6.6 3.6 1.6 3. Child keeps track of motherā€™s locaļæ½on when he plays around the house. 4 1 5.6 1.6 4.6 4. Child is easy for mother to lose track of when he is playing out of her sight. 6 6 2.9 3.1 3.1 5. Child someļæ½mes signals mother (or gives the im- pression) that he wants to be put down, and then fusses or wants to be picked right back up. 4 6 2 2 4 6. When child is upset about mother leaving him, he sits right where he is and cries. Doesnā€™t go aļæ½er her. 8 6 1.4 6.6 4.6 7. Child clearly shows a paļæ½ern of using mother as a base from which to explore. 3 3 8.9 5.9 5.9 8. Child will accept and enjoy loud sounds or be- ing bounced around in play, if mother smiles and shows that it is supposed to be fun. 6 9 5.4 0.6 3.6 9. If mother reassures him by saying "Itā€™s OKā€™ or "It wonā€™t hurt you", child will approach or play with things that iniļæ½ally made him cauļæ½ous or afraid. 6 5 8.9 2.9 3.9 10. If held in motherā€™s arms, child stops crying and quickly recovers aļæ½er being frightened or upset. 2 9 9 7 0 11. At home, child gets upset or cries when moth- er walks out of the room. (May or may not follow her.) 3 4 1.8 1.2 2.2 12. Child uses motherā€™s facial expressions as good source of informaļæ½on when something looks risky or threatening. 1 2 8.8 7.8 6.8
  • 15. Angelka Velkoska et al. 542 This table gives us very important information about the emo- tional ties between the mother and the child. Bout children do not feel their mother as a secure object for making emotional connection. There is no adequate emotional sheering, the mother did not sufļ¬- ciently recognize the signs from her child. On the other hand, the child cannot understand what is required from him/her and how he/ she can respond to those requests because of the intellectual difļ¬cul- ties. We can notice this in the items with particular low scores, actu- ally with big differences compared to the scores of a ā€œsecure childā€, in the items number 7, 10 and 12. Table 3. Scores in secure base items and differences between scores of the child with DS and the child with autism. Enjoyment of physical contact Auļæ½sm Down Syndrome Secure child diļ¬€erences between secure child and au- ļæ½sm child diļ¬€erences between secure child and DS child 1. Child oļæ½en hugs or cuddles against mother, without her asking or inviļæ½ng him to do so. 5 3 7.4 2.4 4.4 2. Child enjoys relaxing in motherā€™s lap. 3 9 7.4 4.4 1.6 3. Child asks for and enjoys having mother hold, hug, and cuddle him. 5 8 8.3 3.3 0.3 4. Child puts his arms around mother or puts his hand on her shoulder when she picks him up. 4 4 7.8 3.8 3.8 5. Child enjoys climbing all over mother when they play. 5 3 6.6 1.6 3.6 Itā€™s necessary to have a physical contact, so you can build adequate emotional connection with somebody. Yet again, the scores of these items are different to the scores of the so-called ā€œsecure childā€. The autistic child has signiļ¬cant differences in the second item, compared to the criterion sort. This is an aspect of secure based behavior. A child who enjoys close physical contact is expected to ļ¬nd such a comforting
  • 16. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 543 contact if distressed. During our observation we noticed that the child is confused and stiff when she sits in her motherā€™s lap. Table 4. Scores for compliance items and differences between scores of the child with DS and the child with autism. Compliance Auļæ½sm Down Syndrome secure child diļ¬€erences between secure child and auļæ½sm child diļ¬€erences betw- een secure child and DS child 1. Child readily shares with mother or lets her hold things if she asks to. 6 7 8.3 2.3 1.3 2. Child follows motherā€™s suggesļæ½ons readily, even when they are clearly suggesļæ½ons rather than orders. 4 7 6.7 2.7 1.7 3. When mother tells child to bring or give her something, he obeys. 2 7 7 5 0 4. When mother says "No" or punishes him, child stops misbehaving (at least at that ļæ½me). Doesnā€™t have to be told twice. 2 4 6.1 4.1 2.1 5. When mother says to follow her, child does so. 1 8 6.8 5.8 1.2 6. Child is easily upset when mother makes him change from one acļæ½vity to another. 7 1 2.7 4.3 1.7 In these items we can see signiļ¬cant differences between the child with autism and the child with Down syndrome. According to this, au- tistic child has lower compliance with her mother. She does not react on verbal instructions from her mother and in the most cases the child didnā€™t understand those instructions. The biggest score differences is in the item 5. This item says more about mother's intuitive understanding of good behavior modiļ¬cation principles than with any trait of the child. There is also a signiļ¬cant difference in item 3. This behavior reļ¬‚ects both the motherā€™s implicit understanding of behavior modiļ¬cation principles and the child's his- tory of harmonious or interfering interaction with her.
  • 17. Angelka Velkoska et al. 544 There are no signiļ¬cant differences between the children with Down syndrome and criterion sort. Table 4 Scores for fussy/difļ¬cult items and differences between scores of the child with DS and the child with autism. Fussy/diļ¬ƒcult Auļæ½sm Down Syndrome secure child diļ¬€erences between secure child and auļæ½sm child diļ¬€erences between se- cure child and DS child 1. When child returns to mother aļæ½er playing, he is someļæ½mes fussy for no clear reason. 2 6 3.1 1.1 2.9 2. When child cries, he cries hard. 8 3 4.1 3.9 1.1 3. Child is lighthearted and playful most of the ļæ½me. 3 7 6.2 3.2 1.2 4. Child oļæ½en cries or resists when mother takes him to bed for naps or at night. 4 5 2.5 1.5 2.5 5. When the child is upset by motherā€™s leaving, he conļæ½nues to cry or even gets angry aļæ½er she is gone. 7 6 2.4 5.4 4.4 6. Child ignores most bumps, falls, or startles. 9 8 3.3 6.3 5.3 7. Child cries when mother leaves him at home with babysiļæ½er, father, or grandparent. 2 5 3.5 1.5 1.5 8. Child easily becomes angry with toys. 8 2 2.3 6.3 0.3 9. Child is demanding and impaļæ½ent with moth- er. Fusses and persists unless she does what he wants right away. 9 2 1.8 8.8 0.2 10. Plays roughly with mother. Bumps, scratch- es, or bites during acļæ½ve play. 6 6 2 4 4 11. When child is in a happy mood, he is likely to stay that way all day. 1 8 5.7 4.7 2.3 12. When mother doesnā€™t do what child wants right away, child behaves as if mom were not going to do it at all. 9 8 1.7 8.7 7.7 Yet again, the scores of the autistic child have bigger differences from criterion sort, compared to the DS child. We have signiļ¬cant dif-
  • 18. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 545 ferences in a several items, especially items number 8 and 9. Those items are about frustration, tolerance or low threshold of tolerance. I. The children have higher scores on item 12. This item is for sensibility and includes a low threshold for detecting infant signals, co- operation (vs. interference) with the infant's ongoing behavior, physical and psychological availability and acceptance of the infant's needs and demands. III REPAIRING INSECURE ATTACHMENTS AND ATTACHMENT DISORDERS Insecure attachment can be a vicious cycle. Due to problems with social relationships, insecurely attached children may become even more isolated and withdrawn from their primary caregivers, family and friends. Children with disabilities already have a lot of problems making appropriate and quality social contacts with the environment. These processes of socialization of those children will be more difļ¬cult if they have insecure attachment with their primer caregiver. However, it is never too late to work on forming secure attachments. While the brain is most pliable in infancy and early childhood, it is responsive to changes all of our lives. Relationships with relatives, teachers and childcare providers can also supply an important source of connection and strength for a childā€™s developing mind. Secure attachment doesnā€™t happen overnight. It is an ongoing pro- cess between the parent and baby. Early intervention has the greatest chance of success. Appropriate models of intervention with mother-in- fant dyads are available. The availability of support services to new mothers is essential. Intervention with toddlers and older children is also possible. To understand how to do this we need to look at the way in which secure attachment develops between caregiver and infant. While we cannot recreate this situation it is important to remember that the basic needs of the baby are still unmet in the child who is not securely attached. Holding and eye contact are very important. Children with attach- ment difļ¬culties often resist this. This is especially characteristic of children with autism, they cannot make eye-contact with other person.
  • 19. Angelka Velkoska et al. 546 In the treatment of the child we can use holding therapy, so we can im- prove eye-contact, but from the other hand we will have big inļ¬‚uence in improvement the emotional ties between child and his primer caregiver. In the past it was believed that autism occurs as a result of emotional lack of the mother ā€“ "cold mothers", today we know that inability to es- tablish adequate emotional contacts between the child with autism and his mother is not a cause of autism as a condition, but its consequence. Holding therapy has been demonstrated to be effective in a wide range of situations. This technique is based on the physical holding of children, even while they protest. Clearly there are problems implement- ing this with older children and children have suffered abuse. However, holding can be achieved in other ways ā€“ sitting with children, tucking them into bed and staying with them etc. (Welch 1988). Building a secure attachment requires all your nonverbal commu- nication skills, not just eyeā€“ contact, but also gentle handling, playful movements at times, rhythmic movement, a soft soothing voice (child maybe canā€™t understand what we are saying, but he or she can enjoy just listening of our voice). For making secure attachment we must also: - Provide support for the primary caregiver. The primary care- giver needs to be emotionally healthy, have adequate time, and the right skills to be attuned and responsive to the childā€™s needs. - Help the child express his or her needs. Children with attach- ment problems will need extra help in learning to express their needs. They may have learned not to cry if in pain or frightened, for example, or not associate touch with being soothed. They may revert to devel- opmentally inappropriate behaviors if stressed or scared. It might take extra creativity and diligence on the caregiverā€™s part to help the child express needs safely and appropriately. - Time, consistency and predictability is key. Problems in at- tachment result from problems with trust. By this very deļ¬nition, re- pairing an attachment disruption takes time, consistency and patience. It will take time for a child to realize that they can trust and rely on their primary caregiver and other important people in their lives.
  • 20. ATTACHMENT THEORY OF THE CHILDREN WITH AUTISM AND DOWN SYNDROME 547 REFERENCES 1. Ainsworth, M. D. S., Blehar, M. C., Waters, E.,Wall, S. (1978): Patterns of attach- ment: A psychological study of the strange situation. Hillsdale, N.J.: Erlbaum. 2. Bowlby, J. (1983): Attachment and Loss.Harmondsworth: Basic Books. 3. Connell, J., P.,Goldsmith, H. H. (1982). A structural modeling approach to the study of attachment and strange situation behaviors. New York: Plenum 4. Fahlberg, V. (1988): Fitting the Pieces Together. London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering. 5. Fletcher, H., Skelly. A. (2008): Attachment Theory and Learning Disabilities: Connections between early beginnings and later challenges. 6. Kemp, G., Smith, M., Saisan, J., Segal, J. Symptoms. (2009): Treatment and hope for children with insecure attachment. Available from URL: http://helpguide.org/ mental/parenting_bonding_reactive_attachment_disorder.htm 7. Kopachev, D. (2008): Mentalno zdravje na licata so mentalna retrdacija. Unpub- lished manuscript. 8. Main, M. (1981): Avoidance in the service of attachment. New York: Cambridge UniversityPress. 9. Main, M., Solomon, J. (1990): Procedures for identifying infants as disorganized/ disoriented during the Ainsworth Strange Situation. Chicago: University of Chi- cago. 10. Slonims, V. Cox, A., McConachie, H. (2006): Analysis of mother-infant interac- tions in infants with Down Syndrome and typically developing infants. American Journal of Mental Retardation 111:273-289. 11. Solomon, J., George,S. (1999): Attachment Disorganization. New York: Guilford Press. 12. Van Ijzendoorn, M.H., Rutgers, A.H., Bakersmans-Kranenburg, M.J. et al (2007): Parental sensitivity and attachment in children with autism spectrum disorder: comparison with children with mental retardation, with language delays and with typical development. Child Development 78, 597-608. 13. Vaughn, B. E., Stevenson-Hinde, J., Waters, E., Kotsaļ¬s, A., et al. (1992): Attach- ment security and temperament in infancy and early childhood. Developmental Psychology. 14. Waters, E. (1987): Attachment Q-Set (V.3.0). Unpublished manuscript. SUNY at StonyBrook. 15. Welch, M. (1988): Mother-Child Holding Therapy in the Treatment of Develop- mental Delays. Stamford: Connecticut.