SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 33
Revealing the North West’s
  Creative & Media Industries –
       the hidden sector
A Methodological Approach revealed for the first time at “North West
          Creative & Media Industries plc – the first AGM”
                             Prepared by
   Dr. Ged Mirfin, Chief Data Officer, Business Link North West &
          Landes Land, Lead Data Warehouse Developer
Hedley Bull on “Definitions”

    “The art of definition is to leave
 everything in, take everything out, and
     make the definition so long and
  complicated that people don’t realise
      that you haven’t done either”
The Problem with SIC Codes
SOURCE: EVIDENCE AND ANALYSIS DOCUMENT WHICH SUPPORTS THE FINAL REPORT
OF THE CEP (CREATIVE ECONOMY PROGRAMME) ISSUED BY DCMS.
MUCH OF THE CRITICISM SEEMS TO HAVE CONCENTRATED ON THE ESTIMATED ECONOMIC CONTRIBUTION CREATIVE
INDUSTRIES MAKE TO THE UK. THESE CRITICISMS FALL INTO TWO CATEGORIES: THE DEFINITION OF CREATIVE INDUSTRIES IS
TOO WIDE OR TOO NARROW AND THEREFORE THE NUMBER IS TOO BIG OR TOO SMALL; AND THE LACK OF OFFICIAL
STANDARD STATISTICS FOR THE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES

IN PARTICULAR, PROBLEMS HAVE BEEN RAISED WITH THE IDENTIFICATION OF CREATIVE INDUSTRIES WITHIN OFFICIAL
CLASSIFICATIONS. OFFICIAL STATISTICS ARE DRAWN FROM ONS SURVEYS WHICH COVER BUSINESSES THAT ARE
REGISTERED FOR VAT AND DO NOT INCLUDE THOSE THAT ARE NOT REGISTERED OR SMALL BUSINESS WHOSE TURNOVER IS
BELOW THE VAT THRESHOLD. THIS IS PROBLEMATIC WHEN TRYING TO IDENTIFY AND MEASURE THE ACTIVITY OF THE
CREATIVE INDUSTRIES BECAUSE MANY OF THE INDUSTRIES ARE VERY SPECIFIC AND SMALL IN TERMS OF NUMBER OF
BUSINESSES, TURNOVER AND EMPLOYMENT…

THE BULLETIN USES NATIONAL STATISTICS SOURCES WHERE POSSIBLE – PRIMARILY THE ANNUAL BUSINESS INQUIRY, THE
INTER-DEPARTMENTAL BUSINESS REGISTER AND THE LABOUR FORCE SURVEY….DEFINITIONS ARE BASED ON THE UK
STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATIONS (SIC)…, HOWEVER THEY DO NOT ACCURATELY REFLECT THE STRUCTURE OF THE
CREATIVE INDUSTRIES. AS SUCH IT IS DIFFICULT TO CAPTURE THE FULL EXTENT OF… ACTIVITY.

THERE IS CONCERN THEREFORE THAT OFFICIAL STATISTICS ARE NOT TOTALLY REPRESENTATIVE OF THE WHOLE CREATIVE
INDUSTRIES SECTOR. THE ONLY WAY TO OVERCOME THIS WOULD BE TO CARRY OUT A SEPARATE SURVEY OF SMALL
CREATIVE FIRMS AND INDIVIDUALS BUT THIS WOULD BE A HUGE UNDERTAKING INVOLVING SIGNIFICANT COSTS AND
POTENTIALLY PLACING A CONSIDERABLE BURDEN ON THE FIRMS.

THE STRUCTURE OF THE OFFICIAL CLASSIFICATIONS MEANS THAT FOR SOME SICS, IDENTIFICATION OF CREATIVE INDUSTRIES
WITHIN WIDER INDUSTRIAL CODES IS REQUIRED IN ORDER TO PRODUCE THE ESTIMATES

THERE ARE MANY DIFFERENT DEFINITIONS OF THE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES IN EXISTENCE MEANING THAT COMPARABILITY
BETWEEN METHODOLOGIES IS OFTEN A PROBLEM.

DCMS ESTIMATES CONCENTRATE ON THE NATIONAL PICTURE, [THEY ARE] KEEN TO WORK CLOSELY WITH REGIONAL
REPRESENTATIVES ON METHODOLOGIES AND APPROACHES TO DATA COLLECTION AT DIFFERENT LEVELS. [THEY] WILL
CONSIDER REGIONAL APPROACHES, ALONGSIDE [THE] NATIONAL METHODOLOGY TO DETERMINE BEST PRACTICE
Successful Definition
• Sector Definition is the key to
  accessing meaningful data
• Definition needs to be intuitive
• Definition needs to utilise experience
  on the ground
• Wide range of opinions need to be
  included in definition review
• What happens to companies that “just
  don’t fit”?
It’s All in the Definition!
Build an Elaborate Definition based on an
overlapping set of Classification Systems


 Select from a
 carefully
 itemised list of         First Phase - Define
 variables
Identifying the DCI Sector Utilising
   Overlapping Classifications
                                            Flexibility
                                         The ability to utilise
                                          multiple business
                                         classifications from
                                       various sources as well
                                           as the keyword
           Yell Class     Thomson      descriptors provides a
                                      breadth of analysis that
                                         virtually eliminates
                                      businesses for which we
                                        have no classification
                          Nature of
         SIC 1992, 2003               data. The potential size
                          Business    of the pot for businesses
             or 2007
                          Keyword       BLNW misses is very
                                                 small.
It’s All in the Definition!
Access to a wide variety of classification systems
 means that it is possible to define Sectors very
   precisely and visualise gaps and overlaps
 Select

              Lessening
              dependability on SIC
              Codes improves Sector
              identification accuracy
                                         Second Phase – Refine
              Overlaps between
              different classification   your Definition
              systems increases
              reliability
It’s All in the Definition!
  High Level Validation of Data Internally by
 Sector Managers and Advisors and Externally
by Cluster Organisations & Industry Specialists
 Define    Refine
                        Ability to
                        Interrogate
                        Extremely Granular
                        Data in a Highly
                        Accessible Way
                        means contributes
                        to a much more
                        consensual way of
                        building a Sector
                        Definition


                    Third Phase – Validate
It’s All in the Definition!
Appending of specialist sub-sector definitions
 originated by Frontier Economics will reveal
          supply chain relationships
 Define    Refine   Validate
                                The ability to
                                overlay a multi-
                                tiered definitional
                                systems means that
We Are Here !                   it will be possible to
                                view the D&C
                                Supply Chain
                                hierarchy in the NW
                                for the first time



                       Fourth Phase – Append
It’s All in the Definition!
Construction of a series of Detailed Cross-Tab
Reports scoped out by Northwest Vision and
     Media and other Sector Partners &
  Stakeholders delivered via inform online
Define    Refine   Validate   Append
                                       The ability to report
                                       on the continually
                                       updated data on a
                                       regularised basis
                                       will allow the
                                       NWDA to assess
                                       the health of the
                                       EETS Sector and
                                       measure the impact
                                       of policy over time


              Fifth Phase – Analyse, Report & Share
It’s All in the Definition!
The art of the possible – a two way exchange of
 data which is continually enriched by activity
  captured in the CRM Systems of BLNW and
          Northwest Vision and Media
 Define    Refine   Validate   Append   Report
                                                 The development of
                                                 truly embedded and
                                                 reciprocal data
                                                 sharing activity
                                                 creating a fully
                                                 embedded North
                                                 West wide shared
                                                 strategic data
                                                 warehouse asset



                          Sixth Phase – Embed
Using Yell Data In Isolation


Why Use Yell?
   Improved Granularity Over Standard Industry Classification
   Doesn’t Suffer from Fixation on Manufacturing – Service Sector
   Well Represented
   Businesses Telling the World What They’re Good At
   Many SIC codes are pointless – “Not Elsewhere Classifieds
   A fast moving sector requires a quickly adaptable classification –
   companies chasing niches update their Yell adverts faster than
   their SIC codes!
What Do The Top Yell Classifications in the Digital and Creative
RES Sector Look Like?
Top Yell Classifications for NW
                                                               Digital and Creative RES Sector
 Yellow Pages Classification      Sites     %       Yellow Pages Classification     Sites   %       Yellow Pages Classification      Sites   %


Unknown                           11,282   41.89   Advertising Agencies             257     0.95   Telecommunication Consultants     107     0.40

                                                   Photographers-Commercial &
Computer Services                 1,106    4.11                                     242     0.90   Theatres & Concert Halls          107     0.40
                                                   Industrial

Photographers-General             1,070    3.97    Secretarial Services             232     0.86   Closed Circuit TV Installers       99     0.37

                                                   TV, Film & Video Production
Internet Web Design                987     3.66                                     232     0.86   Musicians                          98     0.36
                                                   Services

Discos - Mobile                    684     2.54    Translators & Interpreters       230     0.85   Drama Schools                      92     0.34

Designers-Advertising & Graphic    579     2.15    Telecommunication Services       218     0.81   Payroll Services                   91     0.34

Computer Software Development      504     1.87    Newspapers & Magazines           214     0.79   Computer Training                  87     0.32

Mobile Phones & Accessories        474     1.76    Entertainment Agencies           186     0.69   Museums                            84     0.31

Computer Consultancy               447     1.66    Telecommunication Eqpt           164     0.61   Jewellery Mfrs                     81     0.30

Libraries                          442     1.64    Printers' Services               154     0.57   Art Galleries-Public               80     0.30

Marketing & Advertising
                                   425     1.58    Corporate Entertainment          152     0.56   Broadcasting Services              80     0.30
Consultants

Dancing Schools                    350     1.30    Computer Systems                 149     0.55   Piano Tuning & Repair              73     0.27

Internet Services                  340     1.26    Art Galleries & Dealers          138     0.51   Audio-Visual Services              72     0.27

Printers & Lithographers           329     1.22    Public Relations Consultants     138     0.51   Trophies, Medals & Rosettes        72     0.27

Jewellers                          316     1.17    Bathroom Design & Installation   126     0.47   Computer Networking & Cabling      69     0.26

Entertainers                       308     1.14    Monumental Masons & Memorials    118     0.44   Computer Consumables               67     0.25

Artists                            304     1.13    Recording Services-Sound         118     0.44   Video & DVD Services               67     0.25

Computer Maintenance               296     1.10    Accessories - Fashion            114     0.42   Arts Organisations                 66     0.25

Publishers & Publications          283     1.05    Computer Software Sales          107     0.40   Mobile Phone Repairs & Services    63     0.23
“Internet Web Design &
                                  Development”
•Web hosting: If you want a website for your customers to visit, this
is a vital internet service. A good web hosting service will ensure the
pages of your web site appear quickly and reliably.
•Domain name: The part of an email address after the @ sign. Many
internet service providers enable you to buy your own domain name,
so you can have an email (and website) address personalised with
your own or your company's name.
•Software development: This is where a computer service company
writes software for you to meet a specific requirement.
Some computer service companies will write whole
programs, while others just write tools to get one
program talking to, or sharing data with, another.
•e-commerce: Doing business on the internet. Supply
of an e-commerce enabled web site, which allows
visitors to pay for goods and services.
“Internet Web Design &
     Development”
“Designers-Advertising &
                                             Graphic”
•The term graphic design refers to a number of artistic and professional disciplines which
focus on visual communication and presentation. A graphic designer may use typography,
visual arts and page layout techniques to produce the final result. Graphic design often
refers to both the process (designing) by which the communication is created and the
products (designs) which are generated.
•Common uses of graphic design include magazines, advertisements, product packaging
and web design. For example, a product package might include a logo or other artwork,
organized text and pure design elements such as shapes and colour. From road signs to
technical schematics, from interoffice memorandums to reference manuals. Design can also
aid in selling a product or idea through effective visual communication. It is applied to
products and elements of company identity like logos, colours, and text.
•Graphic design is applied in the entertainment industry in decoration, scenery, and visual
story telling. With the advent of the web, information designers with experience in
interactive tools such as Adobe Flash are increasingly being used to illustrate the
background to news stories.
•A graphic design project may involve the stylization and presentation of
  existing text and either pre-existing imagery or images developed by
      the graphic designer.
• Graphic designers are often involved in interface design, such as web
design and software design when end-user interactivity is a design
consideration of the layout or interface. Combining visual communication skills
                     with the interactive communication skills of user interaction and online
                          branding, graphic designers often work with software developers
and                       web developers to create both the look and feel of a web site or
software                              application and enhance the interactive experience of the
user or web site                            visitors.
“Designers-Advertising &
       Graphic”
Digital and Creative Design

                                      Designers-Advertising &
                Age                                             Internet Web Design    Sum:                                Designers-
                                                                                                                                            Internet Web
                                             Graphic                                               Employees              Advertising &
                                                                                                                                               Design
                                                                                                                                                            Sum:
                                                                                                                            Graphic
B: 1 Month - 11 Months                          11                      33               44
C: 1 Year - 1 Year 11 Months                    19                      35               54        0-4                        488               814         1,302
D: 2 Years - 2 Years 11 Months                  12                      39               51                                                                 167
                                                                                                   5-9                         60               107
E: 3 Years - 4 Years 11 Months                  47                     100              147
F: 5 Years - 6 Years 11 Months                                                           93        10-49                       29               57           86
                                                29                      64
G: 7 Years - 9 Years 11 Months                  41                      71              112        50-99                       1                   6         7
H: 10 Years - 13 Years 11 Months                23                      50               73
                                                                                                   100-249                                         1         1
I: 14 Years - 19 Years 11 Months                17                      10               27
J: 20 Years - 30 Years 11 Months                11                      6                17        250+                        1                             1
K: 31 Years+                                     1                      1                2                                                                   2
                                                                                                   Unknown                                         2
Unknown                                        368                     578              946
                               Sum:            579                     987             1,566                 Sum:             579               987         1,566



                      Designers-Advertising                                                                    Designers-
  Turnover                 & Graphic
                                              Internet Web Design     Sum:
                                                                                      Sub-Region                                      Internet Web Design    Sum:
                                                                                                           Advertising & Graphic
 1: Unclassified                                       1                1
                                                                                      Cheshire &
 2: 1 to <90k                 313                     883
                                                                                                                    103                      160             263
                                                                      1,196           Warrington
 3: 90k to <400k              204                      76              280
                                                                                      Cumbria                       36                        87             123
 4: 400k to <1m                44                      14               58
                                                                                      Greater
 5: 1m to <2.5m                12                      10               22                                          234                      365             599
                                                                                      Manchester
 6: 2.5m to <5m                2                       2                4
                                                                                      Greater
 7: 5m to <10m                 1                                        1                                           105                      163             268
 8: 10m to                                                                            Merseyside
 <40m                          1                                        1
                                                                                      Lancashire                    101                      212             313
 Unknown                       2                       1                3

           Sum:               579                     987             1,566                        Sum:             579                      987            1,566
Top Yell Classifications for Digital
                                                                and Creative RES Sector
 Yellow Pages Classification      Sites     %       Yellow Pages Classification     Sites   %       Yellow Pages Classification      Sites   %


Unknown                           11,282   41.89   Advertising Agencies             257     0.95   Telecommunication Consultants     107     0.40

                                                   Photographers-Commercial &
Computer Services                 1,106    4.11                                     242     0.90   Theatres & Concert Halls          107     0.40
                                                   Industrial

Photographers-General             1,070    3.97    Secretarial Services             232     0.86   Closed Circuit TV Installers       99     0.37

                                                   TV, Film & Video Production
Internet Web Design                987     3.66                                     232     0.86   Musicians                          98     0.36
                                                   Services

Discos - Mobile                    684     2.54    Translators & Interpreters       230     0.85   Drama Schools                      92     0.34

Designers-Advertising & Graphic    579     2.15    Telecommunication Services       218     0.81   Payroll Services                   91     0.34

Computer Software Development      504     1.87    Newspapers & Magazines           214     0.79   Computer Training                  87     0.32

Mobile Phones & Accessories        474     1.76    Entertainment Agencies           186     0.69   Museums                            84     0.31

Computer Consultancy               447     1.66    Telecommunication Eqpt           164     0.61   Jewellery Mfrs                     81     0.30

Libraries                          442     1.64    Printers' Services               154     0.57   Art Galleries-Public               80     0.30

Marketing & Advertising
                                   425     1.58    Corporate Entertainment          152     0.56   Broadcasting Services              80     0.30
Consultants

Dancing Schools                    350     1.30    Computer Systems                 149     0.55   Piano Tuning & Repair              73     0.27

Internet Services                  340     1.26    Art Galleries & Dealers          138     0.51   Audio-Visual Services              72     0.27

Printers & Lithographers           329     1.22    Public Relations Consultants     138     0.51   Trophies, Medals & Rosettes        72     0.27

Jewellers                          316     1.17    Bathroom Design & Installation   126     0.47   Computer Networking & Cabling      69     0.26

Entertainers                       308     1.14    Monumental Masons & Memorials    118     0.44   Computer Consumables               67     0.25

Artists                            304     1.13    Recording Services-Sound         118     0.44   Video & DVD Services               67     0.25

Computer Maintenance               296     1.10    Accessories - Fashion            114     0.42   Arts Organisations                 66     0.25

Publishers & Publications          283     1.05    Computer Software Sales          107     0.40   Mobile Phone Repairs & Services    63     0.23
“Computer Software
                                 Development”
•   Software development: This is where a computer service company
    writes software for you to meet a specific requirement. Some
    computer service companies will write whole programs, while
    others just write tools to get one program talking to, or sharing
    data with, another.
•   Software configuration: This means making a program work as
    you want it to—including getting it to "talk" with other programs.
    It's usually best to leave business software configuration to a
    specialist computer services expert.
•   CRM: Short for customer relationship management,
     CRM software helps you keep track of the contact
    you've had with customers, and can be a useful tool
          for increasing sales. It can be complicated to set up
            without the help of a specialist IT company.
“Computer Software
  Development”
Computer Software Development

                                       Computer Software                                  Computer Software
                  Age                    Development
                                                             Sum:        Employees          Development
                                                                                                              Sum:

B: 1 Month - 11 Months                         4              4
                                                                        0-4                      221          221
C: 1 Year - 1 Year 11 Months                  15              15
D: 2 Years - 2 Years 11 Months                14              14        5-9                      102          102
E: 3 Years - 4 Years 11 Months                30              30
                                                                        50-99                    18            18
F: 5 Years - 6 Years 11 Months                28              28
G: 7 Years - 9 Years 11 Months                80              80        100-249                  11            11
H: 10 Years - 13 Years 11 Months              84              84
                                                                        250+                     3             3
I: 14 Years - 19 Years 11 Months              85              85
J: 20 Years - 30 Years 11 Months              58              58        Unknown                  1             1
K: 31 Years+                                  22              22
                                                                                  Sum:           504          504
Unknown                                       84              84
                             Sum:             504            504


                          Computer Software                                          Computer Software
       Turnover             Development
                                               Sum:
                                                           Sub-Region                                         Sum:
                                                                                       Development
1: Unclassified                  2              2
                                                           Cheshire &
2: 1 to <90k                    297            297                                         130                 130
                                                           Warrington
3: 90k to <400k                  93             93
4: 400k to <1m                   28             28         Cumbria                          29                 29
5: 1m to <2.5m                   25             25         Greater
                                                                                           191                 191
6: 2.5m to <5m                   13             13         Manchester
7: 5m to <10m                    13             13
                                                           Greater Merseyside               70                 70
8: 10m to <40m                   16             16
9: 40m+                          14             14
                                                           Lancashire                       84                 84
Unknown                          3              3

                   Sum:         504            504                      Sum:               504                 504
Using Yell Data With SIC




Using Yell to Fill the Gaps in SIC
   Expands the “Not Elsewhere Classifieds”
   Adds granularity to the “Other… …Activities”
   Shows the way the business describes itself to its customers
   rather than how the accountant registers the business


Examples of adding value with Yell
Using Yell Data With SIC –
                                                Printing Not Elsewhere Classified


SIC 2003
SIC 2003 Description                Locations

Printing not elsewhere classified     1,044




                                                SIC 2003 to Yell
                                                SIC 2003 Description                 Yellow Pages Classification               Locations

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Unknown                                      342

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printers & Lithographers                     329

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printers' Services                           89

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Screen Printers                              57

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Label Printers                               56

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printers' Supplies                           56
                                                                                     Greeting Card / Post Card Mfrs &
                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Wh'salers                                    34

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printing-Colour                              31

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Copying & Duplicating Services               23

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Directories                                  17

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Maps & Charts                                 5

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Identification Cards                          3

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Calendar Mfrs                                 1

                                                 Printing not elsewhere classified   Screen Printing Supplies                      1

                                                                                                                        Sum:     1,044
Using Yell Data With SIC –
                                              Telecommunications


SIC 2003
SIC 2003 Description   Locations

Telecommunications       1,671




                                   SIC 2003 to Yell
                                                                                                        Locatio
                                   SIC 2003 Description   Yellow Pages Classification                   ns

                                   Telecommunications     Unknown                                        550

                                   Telecommunications     Mobile Phones & Accessories                    474

                                   Telecommunications     Telecommunication Services                     218

                                   Telecommunications     Telecommunication Eqpt                         132

                                   Telecommunications     Telecommunication Consultants                  107

                                   Telecommunications     Closed Circuit TV Installers                    99

                                   Telecommunications     Mobile Phone Repairs & Services                 63

                                   Telecommunications     Internet Services                               11
                                                          Telephone Answering & Messaging
                                   Telecommunications     Services                                         8

                                   Telecommunications     Data Communication Systems                       3

                                   Telecommunications     Directory Enquiries                              2

                                   Telecommunications     Intercom Systems                                 2

                                   Telecommunications     Mobile Phone - Ringtone, Logo & Text             1

                                   Telecommunications     Telephone Service                                1

                                                                                                 Sum:    1,671
Using Yell Data With SIC –
                                                Other Computer Related Activities


SIC 2003
SIC 2003 Description                Locations

Other computer related activities      4,531


                                                  SIC 2003 to Yell
                                                                                                                               Locatio
                                                  SIC 2003 Description                 Yellow Pages Classification             ns

                                                   Other computer related activities   Unknown                                  3,032

                                                   Other computer related activities   Computer Services                        933

                                                   Other computer related activities   Internet Web Design                      207

                                                   Other computer related activities   Computer Training                         87

                                                   Other computer related activities   Internet Services                         75

                                                   Other computer related activities   Computer Networking & Cabling             69

                                                   Other computer related activities   Computer Aided Design Services            58

                                                   Other computer related activities   Telecommunication Eqpt                    32

                                                   Other computer related activities   Data Recovery                             10

                                                   Other computer related activities   Document & Data Destruction                8

                                                   Other computer related activities   Computer Security                          7

                                                   Other computer related activities   Multimedia Services                        5

                                                   Other computer related activities   Videoconferencing                          4

                                                   Other computer related activities   Publishers & Publications                  2

                                                   Other computer related activities   Information Services                       1

                                                   Other computer related activities   Secretarial Services                       1

                                                                                                                        Sum:    4,531
Nature of Business Fails…
                           When Yell




What about all those “Unknown” Yells?
   Not all businesses advertise in Yell….
   ….so we use other tools in the warehouse to illuminate…


Examples of adding value with Nature of Business Attributes
Nature of Business – Printing Fails…
                                When Yell N.E.C.



                                                                                   Yell to Nature
                                                                                   of Business
SIC 2003 to Yell
                                                                                   Yellow Pages
SIC 2003 Description                 Yellow Pages Classification       Locations
                                                                                   Classification   Nature of Business
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Unknown                              342
                                                                                   Unknown          4 & 6 colour printers
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printers & Lithographers             329
                                                                                   Unknown          Braille, large print & audio transcriptions
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printers' Services                    89
                                                                                   Unknown          Casting of light metals.
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Screen Printers                       57
                                                                                   Unknown          Colour leaflets, brochures and booklets
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Label Printers                        56
                                                                                   Unknown          Colour Printers
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printers' Supplies                    56
                                                                                   Unknown          Commercial and colour printing.
                                     Greeting Card / Post Card
                                                                                   Unknown          Commercial Lithographic Printers
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Mfrs & Wh'salers                      34
                                                                                   Unknown          Commercial printers.
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Printing-Colour                       31
                                                                                   Unknown          Commercial Printers
                                     Copying & Duplicating
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Services                              23                       Commercial printers and merchants of office
                                                                                   Unknown          stationery and supplies.
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Directories                           17
                                                                                   Unknown          Commercial printing.
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Maps & Charts                         5
                                                                                   Unknown          Commercial printing machines and labels.
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Identification Cards                  3
                                                                                   Unknown          Computer Stationery Printers
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Calendar Mfrs                         1
                                                                                   Unknown          Consultant
 Printing not elsewhere classified   Screen Printing Supplies              1
                                                                                   Unknown          Copying & Duplicating Services
                                                                Sum:     1,044
                                                                                   Unknown          Designers - Graphic

                                                                                   Unknown          Design/print & finish corporate literature
Nature of Business – Telecommunications
                            When Yell Fails…



                                                                            Yell to Nature
                                                                            of Business
SIC 2003 to Yell
                                                                            Yellow Pages
SIC 2003 Description   Yellow Pages Classification              Locations
                                                                            Classification   Nature of Business
Telecommunications     Unknown                                     550
                                                                            Unknown          Burglar & Intruder Alarm Systems
Telecommunications     Mobile Phones & Accessories                 474
                                                                            Unknown          Business Services
Telecommunications     Telecommunication Services                  218
                                                                            Unknown          Call centre activities.
Telecommunications     Telecommunication Eqpt                      132
                                                                            Unknown          charitable service
Telecommunications     Telecommunication Consultants               107
                                                                            Unknown          Charities & Voluntary Organisations
Telecommunications     Closed Circuit TV Installers                99
                                                                            Unknown          Charity.
Telecommunications     Mobile Phone Repairs & Services             63
                                                                            Unknown          Communication products.
Telecommunications     Internet Services                           11
                                                                            Unknown          Communications
                       Telephone Answering & Messaging
                                                                            Unknown          Communications consultancy and outsourcing.
Telecommunications     Services                                     8
                                                                            Unknown          Communications & Networking
Telecommunications     Data Communication Systems                   3
                                                                            Unknown          Communications Solutions & Installations
Telecommunications     Directory Enquiries                          2
                                                                                             Community based out patient day care and
Telecommunications     Intercom Systems                             2
                                                                            Unknown          diagnostic services.
                                                                                             Computer programming and consultancy
Telecommunications     Mobile Phone - Ringtone, Logo & Text         1
                                                                            Unknown          services.
Telecommunications     Telephone Service                            1
                                                                                             Computer related, storage and warehousing,
                                                         Sum:     1,671     Unknown          courierthan national post.
                                                                            Unknown          Conference Services

                                                                            Unknown          Consultancy services.

                                                                            Unknown          Consultants
Nature of Business – Other Computer Related
                          When Yell Fails…
                 Activities

                                                                                       Yell to Nature
                                                                                       of Business
SIC 2003 to Yell
SIC 2003 Description                Yellow Pages Classification        Locations   Yellow Pages
                                                                                   Classification   Nature of Business
Other computer related activities   Unknown                              3,032
                                                                                   Unknown          00Bespoke Application Development
Other computer related activities   Computer Services                     933
                                                                                   Unknown          3d and 2d animation for the broadcast tv industry.
Other computer related activities   Internet Web Design                   207
                                                                                   Unknown          3D Visual Design
Other computer related activities   Computer Training                      87
                                                                                                    3D visualising, animation and branding for architectural
Other computer related activities   Internet Services                      75      Unknown          and construction industries
Other computer related activities   Computer Networking & Cabling          69      Unknown          Accountancy and web-site design services.
                                    Computer Aided Design                          Unknown          Accountancy support.
Other computer related activities   Services                               58
                                                                                   Unknown          Accounting, auditing, tax consult.
Other computer related activities   Telecommunication Eqpt                 32
                                                                                   Unknown          Adult Education Centres
Other computer related activities   Data Recovery                          10
                                                                                   Unknown          Advanced Sensor & Control Technologies
Other computer related activities   Document & Data Destruction            8
                                                                                   Unknown          Advertising.
Other computer related activities   Computer Security                      7
                                                                                   Unknown          Architectural and design services
Other computer related activities   Multimedia Services                    5
                                                                                   Unknown          Architectural, technical consultancy.
Other computer related activities   Videoconferencing                      4
                                                                                                    Assett/Process tracking services for businesses serving
Other computer related activities   Publishers & Publications              2       Unknown          Pharmaceutical, logistics, aviation & Manufacturing sectors
Other computer related activities   Information Services                   1                        Audio visual installation engineers, commenced on 1 june
Other computer related activities   Secretarial Services                   1       Unknown          2007.

                                                                                   Unknown          Audio-Visual Production & Presentation Services
                                                                Sum:     4,531
                                                                                   Unknown          Automation and control design, installation and service.

                                                                                   Unknown          Automotive service engineers.
What Else Is Possible? Fails…
                           When Yell




What if we combine different classification systems?
   Hard to find Sectors and Sub-Sectors can be focused on
   Best of all worlds
   We know something about the vast majority of businesses – there
   are very few for which we don’t have at least one form of
   classification
   Classification can be scored for reliability


Real World Example – The Gaming Sector
Real World: Identifying the Gaming Sector
                           When Yell Fails…




Yell Classification                     Appropriate Natures of Business

Toy & Game Mfrs & Importers             Games Manufacturer

Computer Games                          Leading designer, developer and

Gaming Eqpt
                              Gaming    manufacturer of gaming
                                        Animation, design and production
Games Shops
Computer Software
                              Sector    services
Development
                              Profile   Animation studio
                                        Digital artist and Second Life Gallery
                                        Manufacture of Games
                                        Manufacture of professional and arcade
                                        games and toys
  Avoiding
                                        Computer Games design & developers
  Toys
                                        Games development. Video & computer.
  Amusement                             NOT retail
                                        Computer games software development.
                                        computer games
Real World: Identifying the Gaming Sector
                          When Yell Fails…

More Related Content

Similar to Revealing The North Wests Creative &amp; Media Industries The Hi

Big Data Is Here - Now What?
Big Data Is Here - Now What?Big Data Is Here - Now What?
Big Data Is Here - Now What?Chris Selland
 
Kognitio TiVo
Kognitio TiVoKognitio TiVo
Kognitio TiVoKognitio
 
Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...
Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...
Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...Cloudera, Inc.
 
The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution
The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution
The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution Ian Beckett
 
Ci may june 03 liv watson
Ci may june 03 liv watsonCi may june 03 liv watson
Ci may june 03 liv watsonWorkiva
 
Visual Fusion 4.5 Overview
Visual Fusion 4.5 OverviewVisual Fusion 4.5 Overview
Visual Fusion 4.5 OverviewIDV Solutions
 
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013Michael Hiskey
 
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013Kognitio
 
12.08.09 Event Mike Perdue Presentation
12.08.09 Event   Mike Perdue Presentation12.08.09 Event   Mike Perdue Presentation
12.08.09 Event Mike Perdue Presentationmcini
 
Advanced Topics In Business Intelligence
Advanced Topics In Business IntelligenceAdvanced Topics In Business Intelligence
Advanced Topics In Business Intelligenceguest1a9ef2
 
Reflections on knowledge management practice case study
Reflections on knowledge management practice    case studyReflections on knowledge management practice    case study
Reflections on knowledge management practice case studyRichard Vines
 
Business Intelligence Maturity
Business Intelligence MaturityBusiness Intelligence Maturity
Business Intelligence MaturityLouis Fernandes
 
Analytics big data ibm
Analytics big data ibmAnalytics big data ibm
Analytics big data ibmAccenture
 
IBM-Infoworld Big Data deep dive
IBM-Infoworld Big Data deep diveIBM-Infoworld Big Data deep dive
IBM-Infoworld Big Data deep diveKun Le
 
How Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking Sector
How Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking SectorHow Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking Sector
How Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking SectorCognizant
 
IBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel Sabbah
IBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel SabbahIBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel Sabbah
IBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel SabbahKathy (Kat) Mandelstein
 
Business analytics for the CIO
Business analytics for the CIOBusiness analytics for the CIO
Business analytics for the CIOManish Nair
 
Eye4Insights: Ritu Abrol
Eye4Insights: Ritu AbrolEye4Insights: Ritu Abrol
Eye4Insights: Ritu AbrolRitu Abrol
 

Similar to Revealing The North Wests Creative &amp; Media Industries The Hi (20)

Big Data Is Here - Now What?
Big Data Is Here - Now What?Big Data Is Here - Now What?
Big Data Is Here - Now What?
 
Kognitio TiVo
Kognitio TiVoKognitio TiVo
Kognitio TiVo
 
Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...
Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...
Modernizing Your IT Infrastructure with Hadoop - Cloudera Summer Webinar Seri...
 
The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution
The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution
The rise of the digital supply network - IIOT Industry40 distribution
 
Ci may june 03 liv watson
Ci may june 03 liv watsonCi may june 03 liv watson
Ci may june 03 liv watson
 
Visual Fusion 4.5 Overview
Visual Fusion 4.5 OverviewVisual Fusion 4.5 Overview
Visual Fusion 4.5 Overview
 
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
 
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
Big data and the bi wild west kognitio hiskey mar 2013
 
12.08.09 Event Mike Perdue Presentation
12.08.09 Event   Mike Perdue Presentation12.08.09 Event   Mike Perdue Presentation
12.08.09 Event Mike Perdue Presentation
 
Advanced Topics In Business Intelligence
Advanced Topics In Business IntelligenceAdvanced Topics In Business Intelligence
Advanced Topics In Business Intelligence
 
Reflections on knowledge management practice case study
Reflections on knowledge management practice    case studyReflections on knowledge management practice    case study
Reflections on knowledge management practice case study
 
Business Intelligence Maturity
Business Intelligence MaturityBusiness Intelligence Maturity
Business Intelligence Maturity
 
Analytics big data ibm
Analytics big data ibmAnalytics big data ibm
Analytics big data ibm
 
IBM-Infoworld Big Data deep dive
IBM-Infoworld Big Data deep diveIBM-Infoworld Big Data deep dive
IBM-Infoworld Big Data deep dive
 
How Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking Sector
How Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking SectorHow Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking Sector
How Analytics Can Transform the U.S. Retail Banking Sector
 
IBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel Sabbah
IBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel SabbahIBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel Sabbah
IBM Rational Software Conference 2009 Day 1 Keynote: Dr Daniel Sabbah
 
Business analytics for the CIO
Business analytics for the CIOBusiness analytics for the CIO
Business analytics for the CIO
 
AT&T
AT&TAT&T
AT&T
 
Eye4Insights: Ritu Abrol
Eye4Insights: Ritu AbrolEye4Insights: Ritu Abrol
Eye4Insights: Ritu Abrol
 
EETS Write Up
EETS Write UpEETS Write Up
EETS Write Up
 

More from Ged Mirfin

Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...
Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...
Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...Ged Mirfin
 
The labour party has a rural problem
The labour party has a rural problemThe labour party has a rural problem
The labour party has a rural problemGed Mirfin
 
The back to the future virus
The back to the future virusThe back to the future virus
The back to the future virusGed Mirfin
 
Ged mirfin poitical cv
Ged mirfin poitical cvGed mirfin poitical cv
Ged mirfin poitical cvGed Mirfin
 
North West Blue Collar Conservatism
North West Blue Collar ConservatismNorth West Blue Collar Conservatism
North West Blue Collar ConservatismGed Mirfin
 
Political hypocrisy
Political hypocrisyPolitical hypocrisy
Political hypocrisyGed Mirfin
 
Political inertia
Political inertiaPolitical inertia
Political inertiaGed Mirfin
 
Political arrogance
Political arrogancePolitical arrogance
Political arroganceGed Mirfin
 
Ged mirfinprofile
Ged mirfinprofileGed mirfinprofile
Ged mirfinprofileGed Mirfin
 
Political authenticity villains or the virtuous
Political authenticity   villains or the virtuousPolitical authenticity   villains or the virtuous
Political authenticity villains or the virtuousGed Mirfin
 
Pet Role Trust Flyer
Pet Role Trust FlyerPet Role Trust Flyer
Pet Role Trust FlyerGed Mirfin
 
The death of aspiration the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...
The death of aspiration   the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...The death of aspiration   the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...
The death of aspiration the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...Ged Mirfin
 
Oldham by-election demography
Oldham   by-election demographyOldham   by-election demography
Oldham by-election demographyGed Mirfin
 
Horkin_BallotPoster
Horkin_BallotPosterHorkin_BallotPoster
Horkin_BallotPosterGed Mirfin
 
LEPs: A Primer
LEPs: A PrimerLEPs: A Primer
LEPs: A PrimerGed Mirfin
 
Data stewardship a primer
Data stewardship   a primerData stewardship   a primer
Data stewardship a primerGed Mirfin
 
My role as chief data officer
My role as chief data officerMy role as chief data officer
My role as chief data officerGed Mirfin
 
A high wire balancing act conservative voice paper
A high wire balancing act conservative voice paperA high wire balancing act conservative voice paper
A high wire balancing act conservative voice paperGed Mirfin
 
Behind the headlines ged mirfin
Behind the headlines   ged mirfinBehind the headlines   ged mirfin
Behind the headlines ged mirfinGed Mirfin
 
Church revampphotos
Church revampphotosChurch revampphotos
Church revampphotosGed Mirfin
 

More from Ged Mirfin (20)

Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...
Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...
Dont Be Blown Away by All The Hot Air - Ribble Valley Councillors Call for Au...
 
The labour party has a rural problem
The labour party has a rural problemThe labour party has a rural problem
The labour party has a rural problem
 
The back to the future virus
The back to the future virusThe back to the future virus
The back to the future virus
 
Ged mirfin poitical cv
Ged mirfin poitical cvGed mirfin poitical cv
Ged mirfin poitical cv
 
North West Blue Collar Conservatism
North West Blue Collar ConservatismNorth West Blue Collar Conservatism
North West Blue Collar Conservatism
 
Political hypocrisy
Political hypocrisyPolitical hypocrisy
Political hypocrisy
 
Political inertia
Political inertiaPolitical inertia
Political inertia
 
Political arrogance
Political arrogancePolitical arrogance
Political arrogance
 
Ged mirfinprofile
Ged mirfinprofileGed mirfinprofile
Ged mirfinprofile
 
Political authenticity villains or the virtuous
Political authenticity   villains or the virtuousPolitical authenticity   villains or the virtuous
Political authenticity villains or the virtuous
 
Pet Role Trust Flyer
Pet Role Trust FlyerPet Role Trust Flyer
Pet Role Trust Flyer
 
The death of aspiration the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...
The death of aspiration   the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...The death of aspiration   the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...
The death of aspiration the end of work and the emergent culture of middle ...
 
Oldham by-election demography
Oldham   by-election demographyOldham   by-election demography
Oldham by-election demography
 
Horkin_BallotPoster
Horkin_BallotPosterHorkin_BallotPoster
Horkin_BallotPoster
 
LEPs: A Primer
LEPs: A PrimerLEPs: A Primer
LEPs: A Primer
 
Data stewardship a primer
Data stewardship   a primerData stewardship   a primer
Data stewardship a primer
 
My role as chief data officer
My role as chief data officerMy role as chief data officer
My role as chief data officer
 
A high wire balancing act conservative voice paper
A high wire balancing act conservative voice paperA high wire balancing act conservative voice paper
A high wire balancing act conservative voice paper
 
Behind the headlines ged mirfin
Behind the headlines   ged mirfinBehind the headlines   ged mirfin
Behind the headlines ged mirfin
 
Church revampphotos
Church revampphotosChurch revampphotos
Church revampphotos
 

Revealing The North Wests Creative &amp; Media Industries The Hi

  • 1. Revealing the North West’s Creative & Media Industries – the hidden sector A Methodological Approach revealed for the first time at “North West Creative & Media Industries plc – the first AGM” Prepared by Dr. Ged Mirfin, Chief Data Officer, Business Link North West & Landes Land, Lead Data Warehouse Developer
  • 2. Hedley Bull on “Definitions” “The art of definition is to leave everything in, take everything out, and make the definition so long and complicated that people don’t realise that you haven’t done either”
  • 3. The Problem with SIC Codes SOURCE: EVIDENCE AND ANALYSIS DOCUMENT WHICH SUPPORTS THE FINAL REPORT OF THE CEP (CREATIVE ECONOMY PROGRAMME) ISSUED BY DCMS. MUCH OF THE CRITICISM SEEMS TO HAVE CONCENTRATED ON THE ESTIMATED ECONOMIC CONTRIBUTION CREATIVE INDUSTRIES MAKE TO THE UK. THESE CRITICISMS FALL INTO TWO CATEGORIES: THE DEFINITION OF CREATIVE INDUSTRIES IS TOO WIDE OR TOO NARROW AND THEREFORE THE NUMBER IS TOO BIG OR TOO SMALL; AND THE LACK OF OFFICIAL STANDARD STATISTICS FOR THE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES IN PARTICULAR, PROBLEMS HAVE BEEN RAISED WITH THE IDENTIFICATION OF CREATIVE INDUSTRIES WITHIN OFFICIAL CLASSIFICATIONS. OFFICIAL STATISTICS ARE DRAWN FROM ONS SURVEYS WHICH COVER BUSINESSES THAT ARE REGISTERED FOR VAT AND DO NOT INCLUDE THOSE THAT ARE NOT REGISTERED OR SMALL BUSINESS WHOSE TURNOVER IS BELOW THE VAT THRESHOLD. THIS IS PROBLEMATIC WHEN TRYING TO IDENTIFY AND MEASURE THE ACTIVITY OF THE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES BECAUSE MANY OF THE INDUSTRIES ARE VERY SPECIFIC AND SMALL IN TERMS OF NUMBER OF BUSINESSES, TURNOVER AND EMPLOYMENT… THE BULLETIN USES NATIONAL STATISTICS SOURCES WHERE POSSIBLE – PRIMARILY THE ANNUAL BUSINESS INQUIRY, THE INTER-DEPARTMENTAL BUSINESS REGISTER AND THE LABOUR FORCE SURVEY….DEFINITIONS ARE BASED ON THE UK STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATIONS (SIC)…, HOWEVER THEY DO NOT ACCURATELY REFLECT THE STRUCTURE OF THE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES. AS SUCH IT IS DIFFICULT TO CAPTURE THE FULL EXTENT OF… ACTIVITY. THERE IS CONCERN THEREFORE THAT OFFICIAL STATISTICS ARE NOT TOTALLY REPRESENTATIVE OF THE WHOLE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES SECTOR. THE ONLY WAY TO OVERCOME THIS WOULD BE TO CARRY OUT A SEPARATE SURVEY OF SMALL CREATIVE FIRMS AND INDIVIDUALS BUT THIS WOULD BE A HUGE UNDERTAKING INVOLVING SIGNIFICANT COSTS AND POTENTIALLY PLACING A CONSIDERABLE BURDEN ON THE FIRMS. THE STRUCTURE OF THE OFFICIAL CLASSIFICATIONS MEANS THAT FOR SOME SICS, IDENTIFICATION OF CREATIVE INDUSTRIES WITHIN WIDER INDUSTRIAL CODES IS REQUIRED IN ORDER TO PRODUCE THE ESTIMATES THERE ARE MANY DIFFERENT DEFINITIONS OF THE CREATIVE INDUSTRIES IN EXISTENCE MEANING THAT COMPARABILITY BETWEEN METHODOLOGIES IS OFTEN A PROBLEM. DCMS ESTIMATES CONCENTRATE ON THE NATIONAL PICTURE, [THEY ARE] KEEN TO WORK CLOSELY WITH REGIONAL REPRESENTATIVES ON METHODOLOGIES AND APPROACHES TO DATA COLLECTION AT DIFFERENT LEVELS. [THEY] WILL CONSIDER REGIONAL APPROACHES, ALONGSIDE [THE] NATIONAL METHODOLOGY TO DETERMINE BEST PRACTICE
  • 4. Successful Definition • Sector Definition is the key to accessing meaningful data • Definition needs to be intuitive • Definition needs to utilise experience on the ground • Wide range of opinions need to be included in definition review • What happens to companies that “just don’t fit”?
  • 5. It’s All in the Definition! Build an Elaborate Definition based on an overlapping set of Classification Systems Select from a carefully itemised list of First Phase - Define variables
  • 6. Identifying the DCI Sector Utilising Overlapping Classifications Flexibility The ability to utilise multiple business classifications from various sources as well as the keyword Yell Class Thomson descriptors provides a breadth of analysis that virtually eliminates businesses for which we have no classification Nature of SIC 1992, 2003 data. The potential size Business of the pot for businesses or 2007 Keyword BLNW misses is very small.
  • 7. It’s All in the Definition! Access to a wide variety of classification systems means that it is possible to define Sectors very precisely and visualise gaps and overlaps Select Lessening dependability on SIC Codes improves Sector identification accuracy Second Phase – Refine Overlaps between different classification your Definition systems increases reliability
  • 8. It’s All in the Definition! High Level Validation of Data Internally by Sector Managers and Advisors and Externally by Cluster Organisations & Industry Specialists Define Refine Ability to Interrogate Extremely Granular Data in a Highly Accessible Way means contributes to a much more consensual way of building a Sector Definition Third Phase – Validate
  • 9. It’s All in the Definition! Appending of specialist sub-sector definitions originated by Frontier Economics will reveal supply chain relationships Define Refine Validate The ability to overlay a multi- tiered definitional systems means that We Are Here ! it will be possible to view the D&C Supply Chain hierarchy in the NW for the first time Fourth Phase – Append
  • 10. It’s All in the Definition! Construction of a series of Detailed Cross-Tab Reports scoped out by Northwest Vision and Media and other Sector Partners & Stakeholders delivered via inform online Define Refine Validate Append The ability to report on the continually updated data on a regularised basis will allow the NWDA to assess the health of the EETS Sector and measure the impact of policy over time Fifth Phase – Analyse, Report & Share
  • 11. It’s All in the Definition! The art of the possible – a two way exchange of data which is continually enriched by activity captured in the CRM Systems of BLNW and Northwest Vision and Media Define Refine Validate Append Report The development of truly embedded and reciprocal data sharing activity creating a fully embedded North West wide shared strategic data warehouse asset Sixth Phase – Embed
  • 12. Using Yell Data In Isolation Why Use Yell? Improved Granularity Over Standard Industry Classification Doesn’t Suffer from Fixation on Manufacturing – Service Sector Well Represented Businesses Telling the World What They’re Good At Many SIC codes are pointless – “Not Elsewhere Classifieds A fast moving sector requires a quickly adaptable classification – companies chasing niches update their Yell adverts faster than their SIC codes! What Do The Top Yell Classifications in the Digital and Creative RES Sector Look Like?
  • 13. Top Yell Classifications for NW Digital and Creative RES Sector Yellow Pages Classification Sites % Yellow Pages Classification Sites % Yellow Pages Classification Sites % Unknown 11,282 41.89 Advertising Agencies 257 0.95 Telecommunication Consultants 107 0.40 Photographers-Commercial & Computer Services 1,106 4.11 242 0.90 Theatres & Concert Halls 107 0.40 Industrial Photographers-General 1,070 3.97 Secretarial Services 232 0.86 Closed Circuit TV Installers 99 0.37 TV, Film & Video Production Internet Web Design 987 3.66 232 0.86 Musicians 98 0.36 Services Discos - Mobile 684 2.54 Translators & Interpreters 230 0.85 Drama Schools 92 0.34 Designers-Advertising & Graphic 579 2.15 Telecommunication Services 218 0.81 Payroll Services 91 0.34 Computer Software Development 504 1.87 Newspapers & Magazines 214 0.79 Computer Training 87 0.32 Mobile Phones & Accessories 474 1.76 Entertainment Agencies 186 0.69 Museums 84 0.31 Computer Consultancy 447 1.66 Telecommunication Eqpt 164 0.61 Jewellery Mfrs 81 0.30 Libraries 442 1.64 Printers' Services 154 0.57 Art Galleries-Public 80 0.30 Marketing & Advertising 425 1.58 Corporate Entertainment 152 0.56 Broadcasting Services 80 0.30 Consultants Dancing Schools 350 1.30 Computer Systems 149 0.55 Piano Tuning & Repair 73 0.27 Internet Services 340 1.26 Art Galleries & Dealers 138 0.51 Audio-Visual Services 72 0.27 Printers & Lithographers 329 1.22 Public Relations Consultants 138 0.51 Trophies, Medals & Rosettes 72 0.27 Jewellers 316 1.17 Bathroom Design & Installation 126 0.47 Computer Networking & Cabling 69 0.26 Entertainers 308 1.14 Monumental Masons & Memorials 118 0.44 Computer Consumables 67 0.25 Artists 304 1.13 Recording Services-Sound 118 0.44 Video & DVD Services 67 0.25 Computer Maintenance 296 1.10 Accessories - Fashion 114 0.42 Arts Organisations 66 0.25 Publishers & Publications 283 1.05 Computer Software Sales 107 0.40 Mobile Phone Repairs & Services 63 0.23
  • 14. “Internet Web Design & Development” •Web hosting: If you want a website for your customers to visit, this is a vital internet service. A good web hosting service will ensure the pages of your web site appear quickly and reliably. •Domain name: The part of an email address after the @ sign. Many internet service providers enable you to buy your own domain name, so you can have an email (and website) address personalised with your own or your company's name. •Software development: This is where a computer service company writes software for you to meet a specific requirement. Some computer service companies will write whole programs, while others just write tools to get one program talking to, or sharing data with, another. •e-commerce: Doing business on the internet. Supply of an e-commerce enabled web site, which allows visitors to pay for goods and services.
  • 15. “Internet Web Design & Development”
  • 16. “Designers-Advertising & Graphic” •The term graphic design refers to a number of artistic and professional disciplines which focus on visual communication and presentation. A graphic designer may use typography, visual arts and page layout techniques to produce the final result. Graphic design often refers to both the process (designing) by which the communication is created and the products (designs) which are generated. •Common uses of graphic design include magazines, advertisements, product packaging and web design. For example, a product package might include a logo or other artwork, organized text and pure design elements such as shapes and colour. From road signs to technical schematics, from interoffice memorandums to reference manuals. Design can also aid in selling a product or idea through effective visual communication. It is applied to products and elements of company identity like logos, colours, and text. •Graphic design is applied in the entertainment industry in decoration, scenery, and visual story telling. With the advent of the web, information designers with experience in interactive tools such as Adobe Flash are increasingly being used to illustrate the background to news stories. •A graphic design project may involve the stylization and presentation of existing text and either pre-existing imagery or images developed by the graphic designer. • Graphic designers are often involved in interface design, such as web design and software design when end-user interactivity is a design consideration of the layout or interface. Combining visual communication skills with the interactive communication skills of user interaction and online branding, graphic designers often work with software developers and web developers to create both the look and feel of a web site or software application and enhance the interactive experience of the user or web site visitors.
  • 18. Digital and Creative Design Designers-Advertising & Age Internet Web Design Sum: Designers- Internet Web Graphic Employees Advertising & Design Sum: Graphic B: 1 Month - 11 Months 11 33 44 C: 1 Year - 1 Year 11 Months 19 35 54 0-4 488 814 1,302 D: 2 Years - 2 Years 11 Months 12 39 51 167 5-9 60 107 E: 3 Years - 4 Years 11 Months 47 100 147 F: 5 Years - 6 Years 11 Months 93 10-49 29 57 86 29 64 G: 7 Years - 9 Years 11 Months 41 71 112 50-99 1 6 7 H: 10 Years - 13 Years 11 Months 23 50 73 100-249 1 1 I: 14 Years - 19 Years 11 Months 17 10 27 J: 20 Years - 30 Years 11 Months 11 6 17 250+ 1 1 K: 31 Years+ 1 1 2 2 Unknown 2 Unknown 368 578 946 Sum: 579 987 1,566 Sum: 579 987 1,566 Designers-Advertising Designers- Turnover & Graphic Internet Web Design Sum: Sub-Region Internet Web Design Sum: Advertising & Graphic 1: Unclassified 1 1 Cheshire & 2: 1 to <90k 313 883 103 160 263 1,196 Warrington 3: 90k to <400k 204 76 280 Cumbria 36 87 123 4: 400k to <1m 44 14 58 Greater 5: 1m to <2.5m 12 10 22 234 365 599 Manchester 6: 2.5m to <5m 2 2 4 Greater 7: 5m to <10m 1 1 105 163 268 8: 10m to Merseyside <40m 1 1 Lancashire 101 212 313 Unknown 2 1 3 Sum: 579 987 1,566 Sum: 579 987 1,566
  • 19. Top Yell Classifications for Digital and Creative RES Sector Yellow Pages Classification Sites % Yellow Pages Classification Sites % Yellow Pages Classification Sites % Unknown 11,282 41.89 Advertising Agencies 257 0.95 Telecommunication Consultants 107 0.40 Photographers-Commercial & Computer Services 1,106 4.11 242 0.90 Theatres & Concert Halls 107 0.40 Industrial Photographers-General 1,070 3.97 Secretarial Services 232 0.86 Closed Circuit TV Installers 99 0.37 TV, Film & Video Production Internet Web Design 987 3.66 232 0.86 Musicians 98 0.36 Services Discos - Mobile 684 2.54 Translators & Interpreters 230 0.85 Drama Schools 92 0.34 Designers-Advertising & Graphic 579 2.15 Telecommunication Services 218 0.81 Payroll Services 91 0.34 Computer Software Development 504 1.87 Newspapers & Magazines 214 0.79 Computer Training 87 0.32 Mobile Phones & Accessories 474 1.76 Entertainment Agencies 186 0.69 Museums 84 0.31 Computer Consultancy 447 1.66 Telecommunication Eqpt 164 0.61 Jewellery Mfrs 81 0.30 Libraries 442 1.64 Printers' Services 154 0.57 Art Galleries-Public 80 0.30 Marketing & Advertising 425 1.58 Corporate Entertainment 152 0.56 Broadcasting Services 80 0.30 Consultants Dancing Schools 350 1.30 Computer Systems 149 0.55 Piano Tuning & Repair 73 0.27 Internet Services 340 1.26 Art Galleries & Dealers 138 0.51 Audio-Visual Services 72 0.27 Printers & Lithographers 329 1.22 Public Relations Consultants 138 0.51 Trophies, Medals & Rosettes 72 0.27 Jewellers 316 1.17 Bathroom Design & Installation 126 0.47 Computer Networking & Cabling 69 0.26 Entertainers 308 1.14 Monumental Masons & Memorials 118 0.44 Computer Consumables 67 0.25 Artists 304 1.13 Recording Services-Sound 118 0.44 Video & DVD Services 67 0.25 Computer Maintenance 296 1.10 Accessories - Fashion 114 0.42 Arts Organisations 66 0.25 Publishers & Publications 283 1.05 Computer Software Sales 107 0.40 Mobile Phone Repairs & Services 63 0.23
  • 20. “Computer Software Development” • Software development: This is where a computer service company writes software for you to meet a specific requirement. Some computer service companies will write whole programs, while others just write tools to get one program talking to, or sharing data with, another. • Software configuration: This means making a program work as you want it to—including getting it to "talk" with other programs. It's usually best to leave business software configuration to a specialist computer services expert. • CRM: Short for customer relationship management, CRM software helps you keep track of the contact you've had with customers, and can be a useful tool for increasing sales. It can be complicated to set up without the help of a specialist IT company.
  • 21. “Computer Software Development”
  • 22. Computer Software Development Computer Software Computer Software Age Development Sum: Employees Development Sum: B: 1 Month - 11 Months 4 4 0-4 221 221 C: 1 Year - 1 Year 11 Months 15 15 D: 2 Years - 2 Years 11 Months 14 14 5-9 102 102 E: 3 Years - 4 Years 11 Months 30 30 50-99 18 18 F: 5 Years - 6 Years 11 Months 28 28 G: 7 Years - 9 Years 11 Months 80 80 100-249 11 11 H: 10 Years - 13 Years 11 Months 84 84 250+ 3 3 I: 14 Years - 19 Years 11 Months 85 85 J: 20 Years - 30 Years 11 Months 58 58 Unknown 1 1 K: 31 Years+ 22 22 Sum: 504 504 Unknown 84 84 Sum: 504 504 Computer Software Computer Software Turnover Development Sum: Sub-Region Sum: Development 1: Unclassified 2 2 Cheshire & 2: 1 to <90k 297 297 130 130 Warrington 3: 90k to <400k 93 93 4: 400k to <1m 28 28 Cumbria 29 29 5: 1m to <2.5m 25 25 Greater 191 191 6: 2.5m to <5m 13 13 Manchester 7: 5m to <10m 13 13 Greater Merseyside 70 70 8: 10m to <40m 16 16 9: 40m+ 14 14 Lancashire 84 84 Unknown 3 3 Sum: 504 504 Sum: 504 504
  • 23. Using Yell Data With SIC Using Yell to Fill the Gaps in SIC Expands the “Not Elsewhere Classifieds” Adds granularity to the “Other… …Activities” Shows the way the business describes itself to its customers rather than how the accountant registers the business Examples of adding value with Yell
  • 24. Using Yell Data With SIC – Printing Not Elsewhere Classified SIC 2003 SIC 2003 Description Locations Printing not elsewhere classified 1,044 SIC 2003 to Yell SIC 2003 Description Yellow Pages Classification Locations Printing not elsewhere classified Unknown 342 Printing not elsewhere classified Printers & Lithographers 329 Printing not elsewhere classified Printers' Services 89 Printing not elsewhere classified Screen Printers 57 Printing not elsewhere classified Label Printers 56 Printing not elsewhere classified Printers' Supplies 56 Greeting Card / Post Card Mfrs & Printing not elsewhere classified Wh'salers 34 Printing not elsewhere classified Printing-Colour 31 Printing not elsewhere classified Copying & Duplicating Services 23 Printing not elsewhere classified Directories 17 Printing not elsewhere classified Maps & Charts 5 Printing not elsewhere classified Identification Cards 3 Printing not elsewhere classified Calendar Mfrs 1 Printing not elsewhere classified Screen Printing Supplies 1 Sum: 1,044
  • 25. Using Yell Data With SIC – Telecommunications SIC 2003 SIC 2003 Description Locations Telecommunications 1,671 SIC 2003 to Yell Locatio SIC 2003 Description Yellow Pages Classification ns Telecommunications Unknown 550 Telecommunications Mobile Phones & Accessories 474 Telecommunications Telecommunication Services 218 Telecommunications Telecommunication Eqpt 132 Telecommunications Telecommunication Consultants 107 Telecommunications Closed Circuit TV Installers 99 Telecommunications Mobile Phone Repairs & Services 63 Telecommunications Internet Services 11 Telephone Answering & Messaging Telecommunications Services 8 Telecommunications Data Communication Systems 3 Telecommunications Directory Enquiries 2 Telecommunications Intercom Systems 2 Telecommunications Mobile Phone - Ringtone, Logo & Text 1 Telecommunications Telephone Service 1 Sum: 1,671
  • 26. Using Yell Data With SIC – Other Computer Related Activities SIC 2003 SIC 2003 Description Locations Other computer related activities 4,531 SIC 2003 to Yell Locatio SIC 2003 Description Yellow Pages Classification ns Other computer related activities Unknown 3,032 Other computer related activities Computer Services 933 Other computer related activities Internet Web Design 207 Other computer related activities Computer Training 87 Other computer related activities Internet Services 75 Other computer related activities Computer Networking & Cabling 69 Other computer related activities Computer Aided Design Services 58 Other computer related activities Telecommunication Eqpt 32 Other computer related activities Data Recovery 10 Other computer related activities Document & Data Destruction 8 Other computer related activities Computer Security 7 Other computer related activities Multimedia Services 5 Other computer related activities Videoconferencing 4 Other computer related activities Publishers & Publications 2 Other computer related activities Information Services 1 Other computer related activities Secretarial Services 1 Sum: 4,531
  • 27. Nature of Business Fails… When Yell What about all those “Unknown” Yells? Not all businesses advertise in Yell…. ….so we use other tools in the warehouse to illuminate… Examples of adding value with Nature of Business Attributes
  • 28. Nature of Business – Printing Fails… When Yell N.E.C. Yell to Nature of Business SIC 2003 to Yell Yellow Pages SIC 2003 Description Yellow Pages Classification Locations Classification Nature of Business Printing not elsewhere classified Unknown 342 Unknown 4 & 6 colour printers Printing not elsewhere classified Printers & Lithographers 329 Unknown Braille, large print & audio transcriptions Printing not elsewhere classified Printers' Services 89 Unknown Casting of light metals. Printing not elsewhere classified Screen Printers 57 Unknown Colour leaflets, brochures and booklets Printing not elsewhere classified Label Printers 56 Unknown Colour Printers Printing not elsewhere classified Printers' Supplies 56 Unknown Commercial and colour printing. Greeting Card / Post Card Unknown Commercial Lithographic Printers Printing not elsewhere classified Mfrs & Wh'salers 34 Unknown Commercial printers. Printing not elsewhere classified Printing-Colour 31 Unknown Commercial Printers Copying & Duplicating Printing not elsewhere classified Services 23 Commercial printers and merchants of office Unknown stationery and supplies. Printing not elsewhere classified Directories 17 Unknown Commercial printing. Printing not elsewhere classified Maps & Charts 5 Unknown Commercial printing machines and labels. Printing not elsewhere classified Identification Cards 3 Unknown Computer Stationery Printers Printing not elsewhere classified Calendar Mfrs 1 Unknown Consultant Printing not elsewhere classified Screen Printing Supplies 1 Unknown Copying & Duplicating Services Sum: 1,044 Unknown Designers - Graphic Unknown Design/print & finish corporate literature
  • 29. Nature of Business – Telecommunications When Yell Fails… Yell to Nature of Business SIC 2003 to Yell Yellow Pages SIC 2003 Description Yellow Pages Classification Locations Classification Nature of Business Telecommunications Unknown 550 Unknown Burglar & Intruder Alarm Systems Telecommunications Mobile Phones & Accessories 474 Unknown Business Services Telecommunications Telecommunication Services 218 Unknown Call centre activities. Telecommunications Telecommunication Eqpt 132 Unknown charitable service Telecommunications Telecommunication Consultants 107 Unknown Charities & Voluntary Organisations Telecommunications Closed Circuit TV Installers 99 Unknown Charity. Telecommunications Mobile Phone Repairs & Services 63 Unknown Communication products. Telecommunications Internet Services 11 Unknown Communications Telephone Answering & Messaging Unknown Communications consultancy and outsourcing. Telecommunications Services 8 Unknown Communications & Networking Telecommunications Data Communication Systems 3 Unknown Communications Solutions & Installations Telecommunications Directory Enquiries 2 Community based out patient day care and Telecommunications Intercom Systems 2 Unknown diagnostic services. Computer programming and consultancy Telecommunications Mobile Phone - Ringtone, Logo & Text 1 Unknown services. Telecommunications Telephone Service 1 Computer related, storage and warehousing, Sum: 1,671 Unknown courierthan national post. Unknown Conference Services Unknown Consultancy services. Unknown Consultants
  • 30. Nature of Business – Other Computer Related When Yell Fails… Activities Yell to Nature of Business SIC 2003 to Yell SIC 2003 Description Yellow Pages Classification Locations Yellow Pages Classification Nature of Business Other computer related activities Unknown 3,032 Unknown 00Bespoke Application Development Other computer related activities Computer Services 933 Unknown 3d and 2d animation for the broadcast tv industry. Other computer related activities Internet Web Design 207 Unknown 3D Visual Design Other computer related activities Computer Training 87 3D visualising, animation and branding for architectural Other computer related activities Internet Services 75 Unknown and construction industries Other computer related activities Computer Networking & Cabling 69 Unknown Accountancy and web-site design services. Computer Aided Design Unknown Accountancy support. Other computer related activities Services 58 Unknown Accounting, auditing, tax consult. Other computer related activities Telecommunication Eqpt 32 Unknown Adult Education Centres Other computer related activities Data Recovery 10 Unknown Advanced Sensor & Control Technologies Other computer related activities Document & Data Destruction 8 Unknown Advertising. Other computer related activities Computer Security 7 Unknown Architectural and design services Other computer related activities Multimedia Services 5 Unknown Architectural, technical consultancy. Other computer related activities Videoconferencing 4 Assett/Process tracking services for businesses serving Other computer related activities Publishers & Publications 2 Unknown Pharmaceutical, logistics, aviation & Manufacturing sectors Other computer related activities Information Services 1 Audio visual installation engineers, commenced on 1 june Other computer related activities Secretarial Services 1 Unknown 2007. Unknown Audio-Visual Production & Presentation Services Sum: 4,531 Unknown Automation and control design, installation and service. Unknown Automotive service engineers.
  • 31. What Else Is Possible? Fails… When Yell What if we combine different classification systems? Hard to find Sectors and Sub-Sectors can be focused on Best of all worlds We know something about the vast majority of businesses – there are very few for which we don’t have at least one form of classification Classification can be scored for reliability Real World Example – The Gaming Sector
  • 32. Real World: Identifying the Gaming Sector When Yell Fails… Yell Classification Appropriate Natures of Business Toy & Game Mfrs & Importers Games Manufacturer Computer Games Leading designer, developer and Gaming Eqpt Gaming manufacturer of gaming Animation, design and production Games Shops Computer Software Sector services Development Profile Animation studio Digital artist and Second Life Gallery Manufacture of Games Manufacture of professional and arcade games and toys Avoiding Computer Games design & developers Toys Games development. Video & computer. Amusement NOT retail Computer games software development. computer games
  • 33. Real World: Identifying the Gaming Sector When Yell Fails…