SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 32
Download to read offline
October 2011
Asad Siddiqui
asad@investcapital.com
9221-111 111 097 (ext 8636)
• EnVen production comes into picture
• Product price on the rise, margins getting strong
• Sector Outlook - Brighter ahead
• FFC - Royal flushing peers’ moves - Buy with total return expected
of 59% with Jun-12 TP of Rs251/share
• FFBL - The little ‘giant’ - ~33% return expected along with Jun-12
TP of Rs72/share
• ENGRO - The price king! - 90% return expected with Jun-12 TP of
Rs265/share
Fertilizer Sector Update
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR CY11
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
www.investcapital.com
Invest Capital Markets Limited
Urea turns into Gold!
Fertilizer Sec, Mkt. Cap. Rs258.42bn
Top Pick (s) FFC, ENGRO, FFBL
Sector Outlook Positive
Fertilizer Univ. PE (2011E) 6.26x
Fertilizer Univ. Div Yld (2011E) 10.8%
Fertilizer Univ. Ear Gro (2011E) 63.8%
Fertilizer Univ. Return in CY10 22.5%
Contents
Fertilizer Sector Update 3
Sector Outlook 8
Fauji Fertilizer Company Limited 10
Outlook & Recommendation 12
Financials Highlights 13
Key Ratios 14
Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited 16
Outlook & Recommendation 17
Financials Highlights 18
Key Ratios 19
Engro Corporation Limited 21
Outlook & Recommendation 24
Financials Highlights 25
Key Ratios 26
Notes 27
Date of completion: October 05, 2011
Prices are as of October 04, 2011
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR CY11
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
1InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
The page has been left blank intentionally
2InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Fertilizer Sector
3InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
N P
NFC / PAK
ARAB, 65%
ENGRO,
22% FATIM A,
13%
C A N
NFC / PAK
ARAB, 49%
FATIM A,
51%
Fertilizer Sector
SSP
Suraj fert,
31%
AGRITECH
(PAFL),
31%
NFC -LCFL
(alhamd),
38%
N P K
ENGRO,
99%
IM PORTED,
1%
UR EA
DAWH, 5%
FATIM A,
8%
ENGRO,
22%
FFC, 51%
PAK
ARAB, 1%
AGRITECH,
2%
IMPORTED,
11%
D A P
IMPORTED,
32%
FFBL (FFC
SONA), 68%
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
4InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Fertilizer Sector Update
Pakistan being an agrarian economy stands with rigorous demand for
everything that ranges from tractors to seeds, from pesticides to fertilizers.
Historically, agriculture has contributed ~22% towards Pakistan's GDP, and
has helped in employing more than 45% of country's labor force directly and
indirectly. Moreover, country's agriculture sector has constantly helped in
providing different industries with raw materials (example textiles).
This gives fertilizer sector immense importance in Pakistan. Currently, country’s
fertilizer sector is equipped with total production capacity of 6.7mn tons of
Urea and 669k tons of Di Ammonium Phosphate (DAP). There are a total of 9
companies, each manufacturing different fertilizer products. As far as
capacity break-up goes, Engro Corp (ENGRO) is now the leading company,
equipped with 34% of the total country's Urea manufacturing capacity. Fauji
Fertilizer Company (FFC) is only second to ENGRO with 31% share of the Urea
installed capacity in the country. Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited (FFBL) and
Dawood Hercules have a 10% share each. Fatima Fertilizers Limited (FATIMA)
and AgriTech (AGL) complete the list of Urea manufacturing companies,
having capacity share of 8% and 7% respectively. Meanwhile, FFBL is the sole
producer of DAP in the country.
EnVen production comes into picture
Keeping the country's ever-growing Urea demand in view, fertilizer
manufacturers have constantly increased product capacity during 2006 to
2011, growing at a CAGR of 7% till 2012, when ENGRO's new capacity is
34%
31%
10%
10%
8%
7%
ENGRO FFC FFBL DAWH FATIM A AGL
Industry capacity share
UREA, DAP - PRODUCTION SNAPSHOT
Production CY06A CY07A CY08A CY09A CY10A CAGR CY11E CY12F CY13F CAGR
Urea 4,804 4,755 4,978 5,046 5,151 2% 4,925 5,371 5,630 2%
Growth 2% -1% 5% 1% 2% - -4% 9% 5% -
Cap. Utilization 114% 110% 109% 107% 91% - 79% 80% 84% -
DAP 450 357 471 540 647 9% 650 657 663 1%
Growth 0% -21% 32% 15% 20% - 1% 1% 1% -
Cap. Utilization 101% 80% 70% 81% 97% - 97% 98% 99% -
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Fertilizer Sec, Mkt. Cap. Rs258.42bn
Top Pick (s) FFC, ENGRO, FFBL
Sector Outlook Positive
Fertilizer Univ. PE (2011E) 6.26x
Fertilizer Univ. Div Yld (2011E) 10.8%
Fertilizer Univ. Ear Gro (2011E) 63.8%
Fertilizer Univ. Return in CY10 22.5%
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
Source: KSE, InvestCap Research
60%
80%
100%
120%
140%
160%
180%
200%
Oct-10
Jan-11
Apr-11
Jul-11
Oct-11
Fetilizer Sector
KSE-100
5InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
expected to be in full swing. However, urea production has failed to take off
in similar fashion as compared to the capacity, and is expected to grow by a
mere 0.4% by the end of CY11. However, we do expect production to increase
going forward owing to better and continuous supply of gas. We estimate
urea production to increase by an average ~9% in CY12 and by 5% in CY13.
Following the Urea trend, FFBL also escalated the capacity of it's DAP
manufacturing unit over the period of time, where it grew by a 6-year CAGR
of 7% (CY06-CY11). Going forward, we also expect DAP production to
continue grow at a similar rate i.e. 7%. Unlike Urea, DAP is less dependent on
gas, hence its production remains much more efficient as compared to Urea’s.
Increasing demand to make more room for imports
During the past 5 years, Urea offtake in the country has increased at a CAGR
of only 3.2%. For CY11, we expect countrywide Urea offtake to clock in at
6.23mn tons (up 1% YoY), 80% of which is expected to be produced locally.
Going forward, we expect Urea offtake to grow at 2% for CY12, and 2.5% for
CY13. DAP offtake, on the other hand, has experienced a minor contraction
of 2.2% (5-year CAGR). For CY11, we expect DAP offtake to appreciate by a
decent 12% YoY on the back of low base-effect (DAP offtake was low during
CY10 due to massive flood facing the country). We expect DAP offtake to
grow by 5% and 3% in CY12 and CY13 respectively.
Low gas availability => lower production => Higher price
Fertilizer sector is equipped with an enviable pricing power and this is what
makes the sector highly attractive for making investments. For instance,
during CY11YTD, average Urea prices have gone up by a massive ~60% YoY.
The main reason behind price increase by such massive rate is the acute
supply shortage of gas (basic raw material). While the menace of gas
curtailment continues to sting and hamper country’s economic activity,
fertilizer manufactures are forced to increase their prices in order to curtail
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011YTD
DAP Urea
Local urea DAP historical prices(P KR / bag)
UREA, DAP - OFFTAKE SNAPSHOT
Offtake CY06A CY07A CY08A CY09A CY10A CAGR CY11E CY12F CY13F CAGR
UREA 5,235 4,917 5,532 6,478 6,123 4% 6,246 6,371 6,530 2%
Growth 2% -6% 13% 17% -5% - 1% 2% 2% -
Local Portion 90% 95% 92% 78% 84% -2% 80% 81% 83% 0%
DAP 1,508 1,390 775 1,691 1,322 -3% 1,483 1,557 1,612 7%
Growth 0% -8% -44% 118% -22% - 12% 5% 3% -
Local Portion 31% 25% 40% 42% 50% 12% 45% 42% 41% -6%
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
6InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
their losses. This increase in price on an already low production is proving to
be tough on the farmer. However, this price increase has also aided the
gov’t in a way, as now it has to provide lower subsidy on imported Urea. We
expect Urea imports to be around 1.25mn tons in CY11, and as per our
calculations, every Rs50/bag increase in product price brings gov't subsidy
down by a massive Rs1.25bn. However, we expect the total subsidy on
imported Urea to stand around Rs21.5bn for CY11.
As for DAP, rising price of Phos-acid is forcing FFBL to raise prices so that the
company can maintain its already high margins.
International and local prices converging
If we look at the graph, we see both local and international prices of Urea
move in the same direction. However, YTDCY11 Urea prices have
experienced expansion albeit with a smaller gap between local and int’l
prices. Therefore, any hike in the int’l prices of urea can provide local
manufacturers with further room to increase their prices in the future. At
current levels, Urea’s global price is hovering at a premium of ~46%.
Urea prices rise sharply than input prices
Ever since gas curtailment came into the picture, Urea manufactures were
forced to increase prices by a higher magnitude. As the graph below reveals,
during YTDCY11, Urea price has gone up by more than 40% whereas cost of
the input (gas) has gone up by a mere 3%, suggesting that it has been gas
curtailment instead of any increase in the per mmbtu cost of gas that left
Urea manufacturers with no other option but to increase product price to
maintain their margins.
-
100
200
300
400
500
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011YTD
Local Urea Imported Urea
Avg annual int'l and local urea prices(USD / to n)
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011YTD
Cumilativ e gas price
increase
Urea price increase
(% change)
Urea price and gas price
Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
7InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
DAP prices on the march
DAP prices, on the other hand, have escalated at a 24% CAGR (as the graph
reveals), where much of the increase was witnessed post 4MCY11 and
imposition of Sales Tax on fertilizers. However, during the same period DAP’s
primery raw material (Phos-acid)’s prices escalated at 13% CAGR with import
price of DAP increasing by the same quantum. Keeping up with current trend,
we expect Phos-acid prices to rise in the coming quarter, and expect it to
hover around USD1,120/ton, thus we expect local prices of DAP to rise as
well. As far as international prices are concerned, new supply from Ma'aden
is expected to bring the prices of DAP down in the international market.
Rain cum flood impact not significant
The following graph shows provincewise Urea and DAP offtake numbers. The
figure shows the province of Punjab enjoys the lion's share in both Urea and
DAP offtake, keeping in view this trend, we do not expect rain-cum-flood
situation in Sindh to hurt the cumulative offtake of fertilizer in the country,
and expect the offtake levels to stay closer to their annual averages.
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
CY06A
CY07A
CY08A
CY09A
CY10A
YTDCY11A
Local DAP International DAP
Phos-acid
Avg annual int'l, local DAP and Phos-acid
prices(USD/ton)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
2006A
2007A
2008A
2009A
2010A
7MCY11
2006A
2007A
2008A
2009A
2010A
7MCY11
Punjab Sindh KP Balouchistan
Province wise DAP and urea offtake
DAP Urea
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
8InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Sector Outlook - Brighter ahead
Additional gas flows form Qadirpur field and Kunal Pasaki, are expected to
add ~200mmcfd to the sui network grid, which going forward should improve
the supply situation to the fertilizer plants on Sui Network, enabling them with
better flow of gas. However, this is a short term measure, in the long term,
unless any sizable discovery is made gas, outages are expected to occur
regularly with increasing durations. Thus, in the long run fertilizer price rise is
highly likely. Being an agrarian economy we expect demand for Urea to be
ever present.
Regional Attractiveness
Not only on the local front, Pakistan fertilizers stand highly attractive in a
regional contest as well. Following graphs show key ratios and profitability
growth measures on which Pakistan fertilizers (mainly FFC, FFBL and ENGRO)
stand out. The three major companies show higher Earnings Growth, Dividend
Yields and Return on Earnings with lower Price to Earnings, as depicted by the
following charts.
Regional ROE
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
FFCPA
FFBLPA
ANHUICH
YIWUCH
RESPIN
RALIIN
SHINDOOCH
ENGROPA
GSFCIN
TPBTB
Regional Earning Growth
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
TPBTB
FFBLPA
ENGROPA
FFCPA
GSFCIN
SHINDOOCH
YIWUCH
ANHUICH
RALIIN
RESPIN
Regional PE
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
RESPIN
RALIIN
ANHUICH
YIWUCH
SHINDOOCH
GSFCIN
FFCPA
ENGROPA
FFBLPA
TPBTB
Regional Dividend Yield
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
16%
FFBLPA
FFCPA
TPBTB
ENGROPA
GSFCIN
RALIIN
SHINDOOCH
RESPIN
ANHUICH
YIWUCH
Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
9InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Fauji Fertilizer
Company Limited
10InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
FFC - Royal flushing peers’ moves
Rising Urea prices proved to be most fruitful for FFC, as the company receives
its gas supply from the Mari network. During 1HCY11, company’s topline grew
by a decent 21% YoY on the back of ~37% YoY increase in the price of Urea.
However, had production levels not fallen by 5% YoY during the said period,
topline could have witnessed further growth. Gross margins experienced a
colossal growth of 12.3pps, owning to above-mentioned price increase
coupled with decrease in the cost of production (amid gas curtailment),
while the input charges per unit remained the same. Distribution charges
also rose by 16% YoY mainly due to the rise in the price of diesel (up 20% YoY).
Increase of 89% YoY in other income (higher dividends from FFBL) contributed
heavily in bolstering the bottomline (35% EPS contribution). This increase at
such massive level aided in offsetting 78% YoY increase in other charges of
the company, leading to a bottomline growth of 61% YoY.
FFBL's dividends to keep providing support
FFC has ~51% stake in FFBL, which entitles FFC to enjoy 51% of all the dividends
that FFBL declares (FFBL’s dividend contribution to FFC earnings has
substantially increased to 36% against 20% during CY05-10). During CY11,
FFBL’s contribution to FFC’s earnings is expected to increase to 40%, on the
back of massive increase of 50% in FFBL’s earnings this year. Thus, going forward,
FFC1HCY11 RESULT REVIEW
(Rs mn) 1HCY11 YoY 2QCY11 QoQ
Net Sales 24,221 21% 13,120 18%
Gross Profit 13,693 55% 7,783 32%
Gross Margin 56.5% 12.25pps 59.3% 6pps
Selling and Distribution Cost 2,165 16% 1,148 13%
Finance Cost 471 -5% 242 6%
Other Expenses 1,121 78% 615 21%
Other Income 2,882 89% 919 -53%
Profit after Tax 8,189 61% 4,080 -1%
EPS @ 848mn shares 9.65 4.81
DPS @ 848mn shares 9.25 4.75
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Company Discripation
Fauji Fertilizer Company Limited is the
largest urea producer in Pakistan; the
company also enjoys the biggest
market share of the urea market. FFC
was incorporated in 1978 as a
private limited company. This was a
joint venture between Fauji
Foundation (a leading charitable
trust in Pakistan) and Haldor Topsoe
A/S of Denmark. Today the company
has assest bass of ~Rs45bn, making it
one of the leading and most
profitable companies in Pakistan.
-
5.00
10.00
15.00
20.00
25.00
30.00
CY11F
CY12F
CY13F
CY14F
CY15F
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
FFC EPS
FFBL's contribution
Percentage participation by FFBL(EPS Rs)
FFBL EPS participation in FFC
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
FFC Gross Margins
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
55%
60%
65%
CY05A
CY07A
CY09A
CY11E
CY13F
CY15F
Bloomberg Code FFC PK
No. of Shares 848.16mn
Avg Daily Vol (1-Yr) 1.86mn Sh
Last Closing Rs170.62
Target Price (Jun-11) Rs251.00
Upside Potential 47.10%
Dividend Yield (CY12) 15.35%
Total Return (CY12) 62.45%
Return in CY10 22.28%
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
11InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
FFC’S WIND POWER PROJECT
Project cost USD140mn
Capacity 50mw
Debt financing 70%
Equity financing 30%
Source: Company Reports
UREA PRICE SENSITIVITY WITH EPS
Price/bag (Rs) CY12F CY13F T. Price
Base-case 29.11 29.30 251
20 29.75 29.97 257
40 30.40 30.64 263
60 31.04 31.31 269
80 31.69 31.98 275
100 32.34 32.65 280
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
2,000
2,100
2,200
2,300
2,400
2,500
2,600
2009A
2010A
2011E
2012F
2013F
112%
114%
116%
118%
120%
122%
Urea Production
Urea Sales
Capacity Utilization
FFC production and sales
(000 tons)
stable income from FFBL is going to boost earnings of FFC, in addtion to core
income increase. Currently, FFBL's participation in FFC's EPS is expected to be
at ~40%, which is expected to stabilize at ~30% during CY12 and CY13.
FFC the biggest gainer of any urea price hike
FFC receives gas supply from Mari-gas fields; hence the company is not facing
as much of a dire situation on gas supply front as players on the SNGP network.
Therefore, any increase in the price of urea coming from ENGRO (over and
above our price assumption, which is same as for ENGRO) is going to be
beneficial for FFC. We have given below a sensitivity that showcases the
impact of Urea price change on expected earnings of FFC.
Company embarking on new ventures
FFC successfully had a financial close of its venture in the wind power project.
As per our discussion with the company’s management, the cost of the project
is expected to be around USD140mn, with debt to equity ratio being at
70:30. The project is expected to come online during early CY13.
This project is going to be beneficial for the company due to virtually non-
extent operating cost. Guarantee of the wind speed insured by the gov’t of
Sindh also makes this project an attractive investment for FFC. From a
valuation standpoint, keeping timeline of the project we have not yet
incorporated the earnings impact of this project, which would have only
made FFC’s already compelling valuations more attractive.
12InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Outlook and Recommendation
As discussed earlier, the company is not as much plagued as its peers on the
Sui network. Thus, as gas curtailment increases on other fertilizer players in
the sector i.e. Engro, it is going to benefit FFC in form of increased margins
with every increase in Urea price that Engro passes on to consumer in order
to make up for the production loss.
FFC is currently trading at forward PE of 5.86x and 5.8x for CY12 and CY13
respectively, coupled with CY12 and CY13 massive dividend yield of ~15.4%
15.6%. Like FFBL, the company’s main investing trigger is its handsome payout
(90% for CY11E,CY12F and CY13F). We have 'Buy' call on the scrip with Jun-12
Target Price of Rs251/share, which provide a solid 47% upside from current
levels.
FFC VALUATION BREAK UP
Rs mn CY11E CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15F Terminal
FCFE 23,060 26,510 23,302 22,823 23,997 144,732
Cost of equity 21% 21% 21% 21% 21% 21%
Discounted FCFE 26,489 24,433 19,384 17,746 17,741 107,001
Accumulated FCFE 212,795
Number of shares 848
FCFE per share 251
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
VALUATION CRITERIA
Cost of Equity 21%
Risk Premium 6.5%
Terminal growth 3%
-1
49
99
149
199
249
299
Jan-
06
Sep-
06
May-
07
Jan-
08
Sep-
08
May-
09
Jan-
10
Sep-
10
May-
11
FFC PE Bands
3x
5x
8x
10x
15x
(Rs bn)
13InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
FFC’S INCOME STATEMENTS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Sales 36,163 44,874 57,936 64,037 66,599
Cost of Sales 20,515 25,310 24,171 24,200 26,114
Gross Profit 15,648 19,564 33,766 39,838 40,485
Selling and Distribution 3,175 3,944 6,144 5,302 5,539
EBIT 12,474 15,619 27,622 34,536 34,945
Financial charges 945 1,087 1,106 1,117 754
Other income 2,801 3,153 5,247 5,625 5,344
Other charges 1,272 1,376 2,334 1,796 1,868
Net Profit before Tax 13,057 16,310 29,428 37,248 37,668
Tax 4,233 5,281 9,656 12,560 12,814
Profit after tax 8,824 11,029 19,772 24,689 24,853
EPS (Rs) @ 848mn shares 10.40 13.00 23.31 29.11 29.30
DPS (Rs) @ 848mn shares 13.15 16.00 20.98 26.20 26.37
FFC'S BALANCE SHEETS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Equity
Issued and Paidup 6,785 6,785 8,482 8,482 8,482
Share Capital 13,083 15,448 24,745 34,125 46,256
Liabilities
Long term Liabilities 7,615 7,035 7,857 6,155 4,697
Current Liabilities 17,855 20,578 23,922 26,993 27,258
Total Liabilities 25,469 27,613 31,221 33,148 31,955
Equity  Liabilities 38,552 43,061 56,524 67,273 78,211
Assets
Current Assets 14,917 17,224 30,435 41,484 52,604
Fixed Assets 23,634 25,837 26,089 25,789 25,607
Total Assets 38,552 43,061 56,524 67,273 78,211
FFC'S CASH FLOWS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Cashflow from Operations 13,519 15,917 20,545 30,167 26,548
Cashflow from Investments (5,758) (8,657) 614 (878) (1,044)
Cashflow from Financing (4,842) (9,920) (10,561) (17,160) (14,924)
Net Inflow / Outflow 2,918 (2,660) 10,598 12,129 10,580
Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Financial Highlights
14InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
FFC’S KEY RATIOS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Liquidity ratios
Current Ratio 0.84 0.84 1.24 1.4 1.68
Quick Ratio 0.61 0.66 1.01 1.19 1.45
Captial structure
Times interest earned 14 15 25 27 41
Int bearing debt to equity 0.35 0.25 0.19 0.1 0.04
Total debt to equit 1.95 1.79 1.3 1.05 0.79
Returns ratios
Return on assets (RoA) 23% 26% 34% 34% 31%
Return on Equity (RoE) 67% 71% 79% 71% 56%
Return on Cap. employed 55% 62% 95% 101% 103%
Profitablity margins
Gross margin 43% 44% 57% 58% 57%
EBITDA Margin 37% 37% 45% 56% 54%
Net profit margins 24% 25% 34% 35% 34%
Growth
Sales 18% 24% 25% 6% 4%
EBITDA growth 28% 24% 63% 11% 1%
Net profit growth 35% 25% 72% 10% 1%
General ratios
PBV 11.06 9.37 5.84 4.24 3.26
Payout ratio 126% 123% 90% 90% 90%
Dividend Yield 7.7% 9.4% 12.3% 15.2% 15.4%
PE 16.40 13.12 7.31 5.86 5.82
Source:Company reports, InvestCap Research
Key Ratios
15InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Fauji Fertilizer Bin
QasimLimited
16InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
FFBL - The little ‘giant’
Following the trend of sector profitability, 1HCY11 proved to be exceptionally
good for FFBL. Company's topline grew by a massive 51% YoY, primarily owing
to price appreciation experienced in DAP, where it grew by ~33%YoY.
Furthermore, product offtake supported this increase as volumes grew by a
solid 29% YoY. The company's gross margins also bolstered by massive 627bps
in 1HCY11, which was mainly due to magnitude of price increase, appreciating
by greater than the increase in raw material cost (Phos-acid, DAP's prime
raw material) that grew by 26% YoY.
An astounding 81% YoY in gross profit coupled with 4% YoY decrease distribution
charges led to a bolstered EBIT margins, rising by stupendous 900bps to .
Financial charges of the company remained almost at the same level as
previous year’s. As a result net profit of the company grew by mammoth
104% YoY.
Margins expected to remain robust
We have seen Phos-acid prices going up by 13% QoQ in 3QCY11, which is
expected to normalize going forward. In immediate terms, we foresee Phos-
acid prices reacting USD1,20-1,150/ton during 4QCY11. On international front,
we foresee supply to be on the rise as Saudi Arabian mining company, Ma'aden,
is expected to come online in 4QCY11. This additional supply is expected to
bring down the price of DAP to an extent in the international market, while at
current point in time, Pakistan is importing DAP at CFR price of USD695/ton.
Though in the short term, increasing cost of Phos-acid is expected to pull
down FFBL’s margins where the company enjoys primary margin of USD310/
ton currently. On the other hand, FFBL’s YTD primary margins have averaged
at ~USD325/ton. This rising cost of Phos-acid in the short term is expected to
be easily passed on to the consumer, as FFBL enjoys exclusive pricing power
being sole producer of DAP in Pakistan.
FFBL1HCY11 RESULT REVIEW
(Rs mn) 1HCY11 YoY 2QCY11 QoQ
Net Sales 18,017 51% 9,963 124%
Gross Profit 6,929 81% 4,182 152%
Gross Margin 38.4% 621bps 41.9% 780bps
Admin Cost 296 42% 182 159%
Selling and Distribution Cost 1,048 -4% 683 187%
Other Operating Income 741 50% 409 123%
Other Operating Charges 406 116% 235 137%
EBIT 5,921 108% 3,491 144%
Finance Cost 373 13% 266 248%
Profit After Tax 3,514 104% 1,956 126%
EPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 3.76 2.09
EPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 3.50 2.25
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Company Discripation
Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited is a
subsidiary of Fauji Fertilizer Company
(51% stake), the company Limited is
the sole manufacturer of DAP in
Pakistan. FFBL previously was known
as FFC-Jordan because of 10% stake
held by Jordan Phospate Mines Co.
However, in 2003 Jordan Phosphate
Mines Co. sold its share, hence the
company was renamed as Fauji
Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited (FFBL).
FFBL Gross Margins
25%
27%
29%
31%
33%
35%
37%
39%
41%
CY05A
CY07A
CY09A
CY11E
CY13F
CY15F
Bloomberg Code FFBL PK
No. of Shares 934.11mn
Avg Daily Vol (1-Yr) 4.21mn Sh
Last Closing Rs61.77
Target Price (Jun-11) Rs72.00
Upside Potential 16.56%
Dividend Yield (CY12) 15.17%
Total Return (CY12) 31.73%
Return in CY10 36.74%
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
17InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Depreciating PKR to impact FFBL’s margins a bit
Since FFBL's prime raw material (Phos-acid) is imported and it is denominated
in USD terms, it stands prone to depreciation in PKR. We have done a
sensitivity that showcases impact of PKR depreciation on FFBL’s earnings
outlook. Phos-acid price has been on the rise off late due to global demand
of the commodity, which coupled with PKR depreciation may put pressure
on copmany’s primary margin, while its pricing power may provide partial
relief.
Outlook and Recommendation
Being country's sole DAP producer, FFBL's DAP offtake is not expected to go
down despite price expansions. However, DAP margins are at their record
high (primary margin at average USD311/ton) at the moment, and going
forward are expected to normalize to the level of around USD250/ton.
Strong dividends are the major investing trigger for the stock. We have 'Buy'
call on FFBL with Jun-12 Target Price of Rs72/share. The scrip currently offers
an upside of a decent ~17%, alongwith a shining CY12F and CY13F dividend
yield of an average ~15%. At current levels, FFBL is trading at PE of 6.11x and
6.49x for CY12 and CY13 respectively.
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
PKR DEPRECIATION IMPACT ON FFBL EARNINGS
Rupee Depreciation Change in earnings
5% -3%
6% -6%
7% -8%
8% -10%
9% -12%
10% -15%
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
FFBL VALUATION BREAK UP
Rs mn CY11E CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15F Terminal
FCFE 6,179 7,924 9,367 8,775 10,673 65,881
Cost of equity 20% 20% 20% 20% 20%
Discounted FCFE 6,758 7,241 7,152 5,598 5,689 35,115
Accumulated FCFE 67,553
Number of shares (mn) 934
FCFE/share (Rs) (Jun-12 TP) 72
Source: Company Reports,, InvestCap Rsearch
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
2009A
2010A
2011E
2012F
2013F
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Urea Production
Urea Sales
Capacity Utilization
FFBL urea production and sales
snapshot
(000 tons)
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
2009A
2010A
2011E
2012F
2013F
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
DAP Production
DAP Sales
Capacity Utilization
FFBL DAP production and sales
snapshot
(000 tons)
VALUATION CRITERIA
Risk free 14.5%
Risk Premium 6.5%
Terminal growth 5%
-1
49
99
149
199
Jan-06
Sep-06
May-07
Jan-08
Sep-08
May-09
Jan-10
Sep-10
May-11
FFBL PE Bands
3x
5x
10x
15x
18x
(Rs bn)
18InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
FFBL’S INCOME STATEMENTS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Net sales 36,725 43,257 56,180 59,784 59,482
Cost of Sales 27,060 29,794 37,198 41,213 41,312
Gross Profit 9,665 13,463 18,982 18,571 18,170
Distribution Expense 2,236 2,585 3,009 2,950 3,100
Administrative Expense 401 700 1,045 1,141 1,163
Operating profit 7,028 10,178 14,927 14,480 13,906
Financial Cost 1,460 934 905 269 287
Other Operating Expense 443 713 1,015 1,116 1,132
Other Income 998 1,033 1,495 1,098 930
Share of Associate's profit / (loss) (315) 121 186 219 243
Compensation from GOP - - - - -
Profit Before Tax 5,808 9,686 14,688 14,412 13,660
Taxation 2,024 3,171 4,908 4,974 4,767
Profit After Tax 3,784 6,514 9,781 9,438 8,893
EPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 4.05 6.97 10.47 10.10 9.52
DPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 4.00 6.55 9.70 9.37 8.57
FFBL'S BALANCE SHEETS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Equity
Issued and Paid up 9,341 9,341 9,341 9,341 9,341
Share Holder Equity 10,660 12,210 16,921 16,439 18,039
Liabilities
Current Liabilities 16,747 15,389 12,465 12,117 12,865
Non Current Liabilities 8,818 7,737 7,089 6,441 5,792
Equity and Liability 36,225 35,336 36,474 34,997 36,697
Assets
Current Assets 18,444 18,318 19,816 18,778 21,001
Non-Current Assets 17,781 17,018 16,658 16,220 15,695
Total Assets 36,225 35,336 36,474 34,997 36,697
FFBL'S CASH FLOWS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Cashflow from Operations 22,953 8,520 11,747 9,208 10,091
Cashflow from Investments (5,378) 2,858 (1,413) (617) (558)
Cashflow from Financing (15,869) (8,305) (9,939) (10,568) (7,442)
Net Cash Inflow/Outflow 1,707 3,072 394 (1,977) 2,091
Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Financial Highlights
19InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
FFBL’S KEY RATIO
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Liquidity ratios
Current Ratio 1.10 1.19 1.59 1.55 1.63
Quick Ratio 1.14 1.22 1.48 1.70 -
Captial structure
Times interest earned 5.65 12.30 17.90 58.72 53.08
Int bearing debt to equity 1.29 0.87 0.34 0.31 0.27
Total debt to equit 2.40 1.89 1.16 1.13 1.03
Returns ratios
Return on assets (RoA) 10% 18% 27% 27% 24%
Return on Equity (RoE) 36% 53% 58% 57% 49%
Return on Cap. employed 31% 49% 105% 102% 90%
Profitablity margins
Gross margin 26% 31% 34% 31% 31%
EBITDA margins 22% 27% 29% 26% 26%
Net profit margins 10% 15% 17% 16% 15%
Growth
Sales 37% 18% 30% 6% -1%
EBITDA growth 11% 39% 41% -3% -3%
Net profit growth 31% 72% 50% -3% -6%
General ratios
PBV 5.41 4.73 3.41 3.80 3.47
Payout ratio 99% 94% 93% 93% 90%
Dividend Yield 6.5% 10.6% 15.7% 15.2% 13.9%
PE 15.25 8.86 5.90 6.11 6.49
Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Key Ratios
20InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Engro Corporation
Limited
21InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
ENGRO - The price king!
Engro Corp's core profitability was bolstered by a solid 49% YoY. However,
after inclusion of one-time accounting change corp’s profiability slid well
below market’s expectation.
Topline of the company grew by an impressive 37% YoY during 1HCY11.
However, cost of sales also grew by almost the same proportion, as a result
gross margins of the conglomerate were up by mere 77bps YoY. Engro Foods
was the top participant in the topline expansion of Engro Corp. Despite
expanding admin (up 36% YoY) and distribution cost (up 17% YoY), company’s
operating margins were up 153bps YoY, mainly because operating income
grew by a larger magnitude (up 49% YoY).
Earnings were expected in the bracket of Rs10-11/share during 1HCY11.
However, the company incorporated a one time accounting change, that
allowed them to incorporate financial charges from May-11 (2 months prior
to commissioning of the new plant) instead of capitalizing them along with
other expenses, which raised financial charges of Engro Corp, rocketed
upwards by 96% YoY. As a result the earnings of Engro Corp's prime bread
earner (Engro Fertilizer) was below expectations (EFert EPS at Rs1.9).
The above-mentioned one-off dampened Engro Corp's earnings for the said
period, however, the company remained glued to its history by offering DPS
of Rs2/sh.
Tweaking assumptions to have value fine-tuned
Keeping in view the recent gas curtailment scenario and lower than
contracted level of supply to EnVen, we have done few changes in the
price assumption of Urea, gas levels that we expect EnVen to enjoy, Urea
production figures and offtake numbers. Currently, ENGRO’s USD1.2bn plant
is receiving 80mmcfd gas supply from SNGP, while another 20 mmcfd
additional supply is being provided by the Mari network. As a result, the plant
is producing 3,500 tons of urea per day, against name-plate capacity of
3,850 tons (~91% capacity utilization).
ENGRO CROP 1HCY11 RESULT REVIEW
(Rs mn) 1HCY11 YoY 2QCY11 QoQ
Net Sales 46,084 37% 24,236 44%
Gross Profit 13,041 40% 6,916 50%
Gross Margin 28.3% 140bps 28.5% 50bps
Admin Cost 1,359 36% 744 31%
Selling and Distribution Cost 3,184 17% 1,636 19%
Other Operating Income 599 -3% 255 -47%
Other Operating Charges 734 29% 456 0%
EBIT 8,363 49% 4,333 61%
Finance Cost 3,674 96% 2,501 131%
Share of Income from JV 239 -8% 120 -6%
Profit After Tax 3,316 4% 1,274 -8%
EPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 8.43 3.24
DPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 2.00 2.00
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Engro Gross Margins
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
55%
60%
65%
CY05A
CY07A
CY09A
CY11E
CY13F
CY15F
Company Discripation
Engro Corporation is one of the
leading Pakistani business
conglomerates. Having had
undergone an employee led buyout
in 1992. Currently Dawood Hercules
holds 32% stake in the company.
Engro has expanded its businesses
phenomenally in the past two
decades. As a holding company its
subsidiaries include:
Subsidiary Stake
*Engro Fertilizers Ltd 100%
*Engro Foods Ltd 90%
*Engro Eximp Pvt Ltd 100%
*Avanceon Ltd 100%
*Engro PowerGen Ltd 100%
*Engro Polymers  Chem Ltd 56%
*Engro Vopak Ltd 50%
Bloomberg Code ENGRO PK
No. of Shares 339.28mn
Avg Daily Vol (1-Yr) 2.09mn Sh
Last Closing Rs142.42
Target Price (Dec-11) Rs251.00
Upside Potential 86.1%
Dividend Yield (CY12) 5.61%
Total Return (CY12) 91.71%
Return in CY10 5.75%
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
22InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
We expect EnVen's capacity utilization to be at 77.5% for CY12 (down because
we expect capacity utilization to be at 65% during 1QCY12 and 4QCY12),
owing to gas outages during winter season. We assume the production and
offtake to be at ~1070k tons form new plant, total offtake is expected to be
at 1.9mn tons. This is our long term production assumption as well. On cost
front, we expect fuel gas cost per mmbtu to increase by 2.5% and feed gas
cost per mmbtu to increase by 5.25% ( on old plant), both increasing biannually.
In order to fight this increase in costs, we have assumed ENGRO to raise price
of its Urea by 4% annually.
Fertilizer business stability very important for Engro Corp
Engro Fertilizer is currently the bread and butter for the whole Engro Corp
(bottomline contribution of average 70%), and is going to be so in future as
well due to the attractive margins the company earns on its fertilizer (Urea)
sales. However, with acute gas supply shortages, production of Engro Fertilizer
has painted a different picture from what was expected prior to new
capacity coming online. Going forward, we expect gas supply situation to
gradually improve (as Kunal Pasaki field is expected to add 50-100mmcfd to
Sui network). This expected better supply with current level of product prices
makes Engro Fertilizer an attractive subsidiary of the conglomerate.
Ferlizer business holds largest share in Corp’s value
Engro Corp’s profitability and value share break up graph shows 5-year
average forecasted profitability of Corp’s existing subsidiaries coupled with
their individual value contribution to conglomerate’s target price. In this
regard, Engro Fertilizer leads the way in both the profitability and valuation
departments with average 70% and 63% share respectively.
Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
CY11F
CY12F
CY13F
CY14F
CY15F
CY16F
CY17F
CY18F
CY19F
CY20F
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Total Offtake
EnVen Production
Capacity Utilization EnVen(000 tons)
Long term offtake and EnVen production
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2009A
2010A
2011E
2012F
2013F
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
Urea Production
Urea Sales
Capacity Utilization
Engro production and sales
(000 tons)
Eximp
7%
Polymer
2%
Power
4%
Vopak
9%
Avanceon
1%
Food
14%
Fertilizer
70%
Profit Contributors
`
Fertilizer
63%
Food
14%
Avanceon
1%
Vopak
6%
Power
4%
Polymer
3%
Eximp
11%
Value Contributors
`
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
23InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
As far as profitability and value contribution by other subsidiaries are
concerned:
• 3% is contributed by Engro Foods towards valuation and 7% towards
profitability
• Plagued Engro Polymer has 4% share in valuation, while contributes
2% in corp’s profit
• Engro Power enjoys valuation share of 11% and its profitability
participation is at 4%.
• Trading concern, Eximp has participation of 14% and 7% is towards
profitability
• Vopak and Avanceon have contribution of 6% and 1% respectively.
Their contribution towards profitability is at 9% and 1% respectively.
Decreasing interest rates to benefit Engro the most
With expected cut in the discount rate in up coming monitory policies of the
central bank, ENGRO's PKR denominated debt servicing should experience
contraction due to falling KIBOR, as a result of discount rate cut. We have run
a sensitivity, providing different scenarios at different interest levels and
their impact on ENGRO’s Target Price.
The table above highlights the relativity of financial leverage of Engro Corp
with interest rate volatility. In this regard, 50bps rate cut would increase the
target price of the company by 6%. In CY12 we expect policy rate to shed
100-150bps, which should lead to increase in the target price of ENGRO by
10-15%.
IMPACT OF INTEREST RATE CHANGE ON ENGRO
Interest rate decline Target Price Change
Base case (Rs/sh) 265 -
50bps 281 6%
100bps 291 10%
150bps 306 15%
200bps 322 22%
Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
24InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Outlook and Recommendation
Better expected profits from the Engro subsidiaries such as Engro Fertilizer,
Engro PowerGen, Engro Foods, and Engro Eximp (though not as much as
previous year’s), are expected to do their bit to offset the expected
profitability loss of the much plagued subsidiary, Engro Polymer and Chemicals
Limited.
We expect Engro Corp to turn the tide and once again prove as to why it has
been and still continues to be Pakistan's premier company as far as profitability
growth is concerned. We iterate a 'Buy on the scrip with Jun-12 Target Price
of Rs265/share, which offers a massive upside potential of ~92%. At current
levels, the company is trading at CY12F and CY13F PE of 2.70x and 2.51x
respectively.
ENGRO VALUATION BREAK UP
(Rs mn) CY11E CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15-20F Terminal
Fertilier (20,304) 16,283 9,049 4,331 127,914 142,605
Foods (4,172) (1,256) 460 1,083 24,646 79,818
Polymer (1,415) (805) (211) 52 13,833 23,378
Power (Div) 674 735 762 812 4,339 1,130
Eximp (Div) 959 1,689 2,041 1,781 11,286 13,956
Avanceon - 10 77 99 949 1224
Vopak (Div) 505 602 686 765 6,923 9,280
Engro Corp
Aggregate FCFF* (SoTP) (26,101) 15,564 9,553 5,522 189,890 271,287
WACC 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% 14.2%
Discounted FCFF (SoTP) (24,965) 16,011 9,593 5,438 56,401 56,425
Total Firm Value* 104,262
Number of shares 393mn
Jun-12 Target Price (SoTP) (Rs) 265
*Adjusted cashflows for Corp’s shares in the subsidiaries as well as for their leverage and cash balances
VALUATION CRITERIA
Risk free 14.5%
Risk Premium 7%
Terminal growth 5%
-1
49
99
149
199
249
Jan-
06
Sep-
06
May-
07
Jan-
08
Sep-
08
May-
09
Jan-
10
Sep-
10
May-
11
ENGRO PE Bands
3x
5x
10x
15x
20x
(Rs bn)
25InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
ENGRO’S INCOME STATEMENTS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Net Sales 58,152 79,976 97,950 129,253 142,713
Cost of Sales 44,658 59,702 65,606 80,469 91,044
Gross Profit 13,494 20,274 32,344 48,783 51,668
Selling  Distribution 6,215 8,290 7,410 8,319 8,870
Other Income 390 897 728 914 1,035
Other Operating Charges 844 958 1,323 2,004 2,232
Finance Cost 2,222 4,201 6,409 10,273 8,532
Share of Income from JV 459 555 555 662 754
Profit before Tax 5,062 8,277 18,485 29,763 33,824
Taxation 1,343 1,836 6,470 8,917 11,308
Profit after tax 3,719 6,441 12,015 20,846 22,516
Attributable to Equity Holders 3,807 6,790 12,071 20,754 22,275
Attributable to Minority Interest -88 -349 -56 92 241
3,719 6,441 12,015 20,846 22,516
EPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 9.7 17.26 30.69 52.77 56.64
DPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 6.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 8.0
ENGRO FERTILIZER CASH FLOWS
(Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Cashflow from Operations 9,244 (14,611) 14,544 18,598 21,765
Cashflow from Investments (38,840) (14,695) (23,427) 9,354 (1,678)
Cashflow from Financing 28,274 24,280 (9,813) (13,064) (12,789)
Net Cash Inflow/Outflow (1,322) (5,026) (18,696) 14,888 7,298
Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Financial Highlights
26InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
ENGRO KEY RATIOS
CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F
Liquidity ratios
Current Ratio 1.07 2.06 0.46 1.05 1.05
Quick Ratio 0.34 1.73 0.05 0.56 0.58
Coverage ratios
Time Interest Earned 3.28 2.85 3.89 3.94 5.02
Profitablity margins
Gross margin 23% 25% 33% 38% 36%
EBITDA margins 12% 13% 25% 33% 30%
Net profit margins 6% 8% 12% 16% 16%
Growth
Sales 42% 38% 22% 32% 10%
EBITDA growth 0% 48% 139% 74% 1%
Net profit growth -12% 73% 87% 73% 8%
General ratios
PBV 1.45 1.37 1.37 0.95 0.72
Payout ratio 21% 12% 7% 4% 4%
Dividend Yield 1% 1% 1% 1% 1%
PE 14.71 8.25 4.64 2.70 2.51
Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research
Key Ratios
27InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
Notes:
28InvestCap Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
October 2011
FERTILIZER SECTOR CY11
A Publication of InvestCap Research
Pakistan Research
MONEY MARKET DESK
(92-21) 3520 8751, 3520 8757, 3520 8767
Naeem Ul Hassan
Nadeem Dar
Mehmood Qureshi
Asif Hussain
Nasir Suria
EQUITY SALES DESK
(92-21) 3520 8727, 3520 8735, 3520 8730-31
Shahrukh Naqvi
Noureen Moin Khan
Nabeel Jafar
Owais Imam
Abdul Samad Tariq
Irfan Ali Muhammad
RESEARCH (92-21) 111 111 097 (8634)
Khurram Schehzad Economy, Strategy and Oil
Farhan Bashir Khan Economy, EP, Refineries and Telecom
Asad Siddiqui Fertilizers, Chemicals, Banks and Construction
Abdul Azeem Automobile, Gas Distribution, Power and Textiles
Mazhar A. Sabir Mutual Funds and Insurance
Yawar uz Zaman FMCGs, Paper  Board and Construction
Rao Aamir Ali Database Manager
Asim Abbas Research Distribution
FOREIGN EXCHANGE DESK
(92-21)3520 8778-87
Raheel Abbass
Atif Ali
Naheed Fatima
Qazi Owais
Zain Jafri
Zeeshan Atique
Hammad Rasheed
COMMODITY SALES DESK
(92-21)3521 35226-28
Ali Kazmi
Shoaib Memon
Shoaib Machiara
CORPORATE FINANCE
(92-21)3521 35226-28
AsherSaeed
Salman Shahab
Kiran Javed
This report is for information purposes only and we are not soliciting any action based upon it. The material is
based on information we believe to be reliable but we do not guarantee that it is accurate and complete.
Invest Capital Markets Limited will not be responsible for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or
statement herein or for any omission. This report or any part of it may not be reproduced or published without
prior permission.
www.investcapital.com
InvestCapital Markets Limited
Karachi Head Office
C3C, 12th Lane, Ittehad Commercial Area,
Khayaban-e-Ittehad,
Phase- II Ext, DHA,
Karachi,
Telephone + 92 (21) 111 111 097
Fax + 92 (21) 3531 3885
Email info@investcapital.com
Islamabad Office
301, Muhammad Gulistan Khan House
82E, Blue Area, Fazal-e-Haq Road,
Islamabad
Telephone + 92 (51) 3282 5904
Fax: +92 (51) 3227 5202
Peshawar Office
1st Floor, State Life Building 34 - The Mall,
Peshawar Cantt.
Telephone +92 (91) 3527 6025-28
Fax +92 (91) 3527 3683
Lahore Office
16A, Main Gulberg ,Near MCB Tower,
Lahore
Telephone +92 (42) 35776701-08
Fax +92 (42) 3577 6710

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (14)

The Fertilizer sector in Pakistan- Mubarak Ali
The Fertilizer sector in Pakistan- Mubarak AliThe Fertilizer sector in Pakistan- Mubarak Ali
The Fertilizer sector in Pakistan- Mubarak Ali
 
ANALYSIS OF PAKISTAN'S HORTICULTURE EXPORTS
ANALYSIS OF PAKISTAN'S HORTICULTURE EXPORTSANALYSIS OF PAKISTAN'S HORTICULTURE EXPORTS
ANALYSIS OF PAKISTAN'S HORTICULTURE EXPORTS
 
#116D
#116D#116D
#116D
 
Global lng are the dynamicschanging
Global lng are the dynamicschangingGlobal lng are the dynamicschanging
Global lng are the dynamicschanging
 
Enhancing Energy Security for India
Enhancing Energy Security for India Enhancing Energy Security for India
Enhancing Energy Security for India
 
Corporate Presentation November 2017
Corporate Presentation November 2017Corporate Presentation November 2017
Corporate Presentation November 2017
 
Trends of key agriculture and rural development indicators feb 6 2013
Trends of key agriculture and rural development indicators feb 6 2013Trends of key agriculture and rural development indicators feb 6 2013
Trends of key agriculture and rural development indicators feb 6 2013
 
Sqm corp pres 4q17_long final
Sqm corp pres 4q17_long finalSqm corp pres 4q17_long final
Sqm corp pres 4q17_long final
 
#116C
#116C#116C
#116C
 
SQM Fourth Quarter 2017 Earnings Conference Call
SQM Fourth Quarter 2017 Earnings Conference CallSQM Fourth Quarter 2017 Earnings Conference Call
SQM Fourth Quarter 2017 Earnings Conference Call
 
Amara Raja Batteries Q2FY15: Buy for a target of Rs790
Amara Raja Batteries Q2FY15: Buy for a target of Rs790Amara Raja Batteries Q2FY15: Buy for a target of Rs790
Amara Raja Batteries Q2FY15: Buy for a target of Rs790
 
Nmdc 2 qfy2011-291010
Nmdc 2 qfy2011-291010Nmdc 2 qfy2011-291010
Nmdc 2 qfy2011-291010
 
GLOBAL DAIRY PRODUCTION STATUS, TRENDS, AND OUTLOOK
GLOBAL DAIRY PRODUCTION  STATUS, TRENDS, AND OUTLOOKGLOBAL DAIRY PRODUCTION  STATUS, TRENDS, AND OUTLOOK
GLOBAL DAIRY PRODUCTION STATUS, TRENDS, AND OUTLOOK
 
Sustaining CAADP Momentum: Growth and Investment Analysis
Sustaining CAADP Momentum: Growth and Investment Analysis Sustaining CAADP Momentum: Growth and Investment Analysis
Sustaining CAADP Momentum: Growth and Investment Analysis
 

Viewers also liked

Selvan CM Technician CV
Selvan CM Technician CVSelvan CM Technician CV
Selvan CM Technician CVkalki selvan
 
Mohamad Rizal resume
Mohamad Rizal resumeMohamad Rizal resume
Mohamad Rizal resumeRizal Misbah
 
CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)
CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)
CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)Armando Malasan
 
Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1
Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1
Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1Muhammad Afzal
 
Curriculum vitae
Curriculum vitaeCurriculum vitae
Curriculum vitaeapshihab791
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Nishit Resume
Nishit ResumeNishit Resume
Nishit Resume
 
Selvan CM Technician CV
Selvan CM Technician CVSelvan CM Technician CV
Selvan CM Technician CV
 
romel resume
romel resumeromel resume
romel resume
 
Mohamad Rizal resume
Mohamad Rizal resumeMohamad Rizal resume
Mohamad Rizal resume
 
CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)
CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)
CV as Maintenance Technician (Armando Malasan)
 
Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1
Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1
Afzal Chief Mechanic Cv 1
 
Curriculum vitae
Curriculum vitaeCurriculum vitae
Curriculum vitae
 

Similar to Fertilizer Sector October 2011

Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...
Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...
Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...IndiaNotes.com
 
Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010
Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010
Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010Angel Broking
 
Demand & Supply of fertilizer in India
Demand & Supply of fertilizer in IndiaDemand & Supply of fertilizer in India
Demand & Supply of fertilizer in IndiaSoumyashree Panigrahi
 
Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...
Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...
Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...SlideTeam
 
ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)
ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)
ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)Ali Afifi
 
18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan
18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan
18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistanMaah Noor Malik
 
Engro Chemicals
Engro ChemicalsEngro Chemicals
Engro ChemicalsQasim Raza
 
Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016
Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016
Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016Aijaz Siddique
 
China energy 110929
China energy 110929China energy 110929
China energy 110929Ahmad Halim
 
Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011
Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011
Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011Mahmood Elahi
 
Tereos apresentacao 3_t13_eng
Tereos apresentacao 3_t13_engTereos apresentacao 3_t13_eng
Tereos apresentacao 3_t13_engTereosri
 
Dorian lpg october 2016
Dorian lpg october 2016Dorian lpg october 2016
Dorian lpg october 2016DorianLPG2016
 
Engro Fertilizer limited cost analsis
Engro Fertilizer limited cost analsisEngro Fertilizer limited cost analsis
Engro Fertilizer limited cost analsisAmna javed
 
Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey
Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey
Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey FMC Group
 

Similar to Fertilizer Sector October 2011 (20)

Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...
Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...
Coal India Q1FY15: Revenues stable on steady volumes and healthy realizations...
 
Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010
Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010
Upl ru2 qfy2011-261010
 
Demand & Supply of fertilizer in India
Demand & Supply of fertilizer in IndiaDemand & Supply of fertilizer in India
Demand & Supply of fertilizer in India
 
OVERVIEW OF INDIAN CHEMICAL INDUSTRY
OVERVIEW OF INDIAN CHEMICAL INDUSTRYOVERVIEW OF INDIAN CHEMICAL INDUSTRY
OVERVIEW OF INDIAN CHEMICAL INDUSTRY
 
Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...
Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...
Stock Pitch For Pipes And Walves Distribution PowerPoint Presentation Ppt Sli...
 
ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)
ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)
ABUK Model Update Re-initiation of Coverage - October 2016 (2)
 
18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan
18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan
18279504 fertilizer-sector-of-pakistan
 
Engro Chemicals
Engro ChemicalsEngro Chemicals
Engro Chemicals
 
Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016
Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016
Pakistan fertilizers 24-10-2016
 
China energy 110929
China energy 110929China energy 110929
China energy 110929
 
Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011
Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011
Engro Security Analyst Briefing 1st Quarter 2011
 
Energy 120503
Energy 120503Energy 120503
Energy 120503
 
fertilizer
fertilizerfertilizer
fertilizer
 
Weekly report may 05, 2017
Weekly report may 05, 2017Weekly report may 05, 2017
Weekly report may 05, 2017
 
2014 06-18 2Q web report
2014 06-18 2Q web report2014 06-18 2Q web report
2014 06-18 2Q web report
 
Tereos apresentacao 3_t13_eng
Tereos apresentacao 3_t13_engTereos apresentacao 3_t13_eng
Tereos apresentacao 3_t13_eng
 
Dorian lpg october 2016
Dorian lpg october 2016Dorian lpg october 2016
Dorian lpg october 2016
 
Assignment
AssignmentAssignment
Assignment
 
Engro Fertilizer limited cost analsis
Engro Fertilizer limited cost analsisEngro Fertilizer limited cost analsis
Engro Fertilizer limited cost analsis
 
Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey
Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey
Agriculture, Livestock, Fishery and Food Industry in Turkey
 

Fertilizer Sector October 2011

  • 1. October 2011 Asad Siddiqui asad@investcapital.com 9221-111 111 097 (ext 8636) • EnVen production comes into picture • Product price on the rise, margins getting strong • Sector Outlook - Brighter ahead • FFC - Royal flushing peers’ moves - Buy with total return expected of 59% with Jun-12 TP of Rs251/share • FFBL - The little ‘giant’ - ~33% return expected along with Jun-12 TP of Rs72/share • ENGRO - The price king! - 90% return expected with Jun-12 TP of Rs265/share Fertilizer Sector Update October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR CY11 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research www.investcapital.com Invest Capital Markets Limited Urea turns into Gold! Fertilizer Sec, Mkt. Cap. Rs258.42bn Top Pick (s) FFC, ENGRO, FFBL Sector Outlook Positive Fertilizer Univ. PE (2011E) 6.26x Fertilizer Univ. Div Yld (2011E) 10.8% Fertilizer Univ. Ear Gro (2011E) 63.8% Fertilizer Univ. Return in CY10 22.5%
  • 2. Contents Fertilizer Sector Update 3 Sector Outlook 8 Fauji Fertilizer Company Limited 10 Outlook & Recommendation 12 Financials Highlights 13 Key Ratios 14 Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited 16 Outlook & Recommendation 17 Financials Highlights 18 Key Ratios 19 Engro Corporation Limited 21 Outlook & Recommendation 24 Financials Highlights 25 Key Ratios 26 Notes 27 Date of completion: October 05, 2011 Prices are as of October 04, 2011 October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR CY11 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research
  • 3. 1InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research The page has been left blank intentionally
  • 4. 2InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Fertilizer Sector
  • 5. 3InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research N P NFC / PAK ARAB, 65% ENGRO, 22% FATIM A, 13% C A N NFC / PAK ARAB, 49% FATIM A, 51% Fertilizer Sector SSP Suraj fert, 31% AGRITECH (PAFL), 31% NFC -LCFL (alhamd), 38% N P K ENGRO, 99% IM PORTED, 1% UR EA DAWH, 5% FATIM A, 8% ENGRO, 22% FFC, 51% PAK ARAB, 1% AGRITECH, 2% IMPORTED, 11% D A P IMPORTED, 32% FFBL (FFC SONA), 68% Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
  • 6. 4InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Fertilizer Sector Update Pakistan being an agrarian economy stands with rigorous demand for everything that ranges from tractors to seeds, from pesticides to fertilizers. Historically, agriculture has contributed ~22% towards Pakistan's GDP, and has helped in employing more than 45% of country's labor force directly and indirectly. Moreover, country's agriculture sector has constantly helped in providing different industries with raw materials (example textiles). This gives fertilizer sector immense importance in Pakistan. Currently, country’s fertilizer sector is equipped with total production capacity of 6.7mn tons of Urea and 669k tons of Di Ammonium Phosphate (DAP). There are a total of 9 companies, each manufacturing different fertilizer products. As far as capacity break-up goes, Engro Corp (ENGRO) is now the leading company, equipped with 34% of the total country's Urea manufacturing capacity. Fauji Fertilizer Company (FFC) is only second to ENGRO with 31% share of the Urea installed capacity in the country. Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited (FFBL) and Dawood Hercules have a 10% share each. Fatima Fertilizers Limited (FATIMA) and AgriTech (AGL) complete the list of Urea manufacturing companies, having capacity share of 8% and 7% respectively. Meanwhile, FFBL is the sole producer of DAP in the country. EnVen production comes into picture Keeping the country's ever-growing Urea demand in view, fertilizer manufacturers have constantly increased product capacity during 2006 to 2011, growing at a CAGR of 7% till 2012, when ENGRO's new capacity is 34% 31% 10% 10% 8% 7% ENGRO FFC FFBL DAWH FATIM A AGL Industry capacity share UREA, DAP - PRODUCTION SNAPSHOT Production CY06A CY07A CY08A CY09A CY10A CAGR CY11E CY12F CY13F CAGR Urea 4,804 4,755 4,978 5,046 5,151 2% 4,925 5,371 5,630 2% Growth 2% -1% 5% 1% 2% - -4% 9% 5% - Cap. Utilization 114% 110% 109% 107% 91% - 79% 80% 84% - DAP 450 357 471 540 647 9% 650 657 663 1% Growth 0% -21% 32% 15% 20% - 1% 1% 1% - Cap. Utilization 101% 80% 70% 81% 97% - 97% 98% 99% - Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research Fertilizer Sec, Mkt. Cap. Rs258.42bn Top Pick (s) FFC, ENGRO, FFBL Sector Outlook Positive Fertilizer Univ. PE (2011E) 6.26x Fertilizer Univ. Div Yld (2011E) 10.8% Fertilizer Univ. Ear Gro (2011E) 63.8% Fertilizer Univ. Return in CY10 22.5% Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research Source: KSE, InvestCap Research 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% 180% 200% Oct-10 Jan-11 Apr-11 Jul-11 Oct-11 Fetilizer Sector KSE-100
  • 7. 5InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research expected to be in full swing. However, urea production has failed to take off in similar fashion as compared to the capacity, and is expected to grow by a mere 0.4% by the end of CY11. However, we do expect production to increase going forward owing to better and continuous supply of gas. We estimate urea production to increase by an average ~9% in CY12 and by 5% in CY13. Following the Urea trend, FFBL also escalated the capacity of it's DAP manufacturing unit over the period of time, where it grew by a 6-year CAGR of 7% (CY06-CY11). Going forward, we also expect DAP production to continue grow at a similar rate i.e. 7%. Unlike Urea, DAP is less dependent on gas, hence its production remains much more efficient as compared to Urea’s. Increasing demand to make more room for imports During the past 5 years, Urea offtake in the country has increased at a CAGR of only 3.2%. For CY11, we expect countrywide Urea offtake to clock in at 6.23mn tons (up 1% YoY), 80% of which is expected to be produced locally. Going forward, we expect Urea offtake to grow at 2% for CY12, and 2.5% for CY13. DAP offtake, on the other hand, has experienced a minor contraction of 2.2% (5-year CAGR). For CY11, we expect DAP offtake to appreciate by a decent 12% YoY on the back of low base-effect (DAP offtake was low during CY10 due to massive flood facing the country). We expect DAP offtake to grow by 5% and 3% in CY12 and CY13 respectively. Low gas availability => lower production => Higher price Fertilizer sector is equipped with an enviable pricing power and this is what makes the sector highly attractive for making investments. For instance, during CY11YTD, average Urea prices have gone up by a massive ~60% YoY. The main reason behind price increase by such massive rate is the acute supply shortage of gas (basic raw material). While the menace of gas curtailment continues to sting and hamper country’s economic activity, fertilizer manufactures are forced to increase their prices in order to curtail 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011YTD DAP Urea Local urea DAP historical prices(P KR / bag) UREA, DAP - OFFTAKE SNAPSHOT Offtake CY06A CY07A CY08A CY09A CY10A CAGR CY11E CY12F CY13F CAGR UREA 5,235 4,917 5,532 6,478 6,123 4% 6,246 6,371 6,530 2% Growth 2% -6% 13% 17% -5% - 1% 2% 2% - Local Portion 90% 95% 92% 78% 84% -2% 80% 81% 83% 0% DAP 1,508 1,390 775 1,691 1,322 -3% 1,483 1,557 1,612 7% Growth 0% -8% -44% 118% -22% - 12% 5% 3% - Local Portion 31% 25% 40% 42% 50% 12% 45% 42% 41% -6% Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research
  • 8. 6InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research their losses. This increase in price on an already low production is proving to be tough on the farmer. However, this price increase has also aided the gov’t in a way, as now it has to provide lower subsidy on imported Urea. We expect Urea imports to be around 1.25mn tons in CY11, and as per our calculations, every Rs50/bag increase in product price brings gov't subsidy down by a massive Rs1.25bn. However, we expect the total subsidy on imported Urea to stand around Rs21.5bn for CY11. As for DAP, rising price of Phos-acid is forcing FFBL to raise prices so that the company can maintain its already high margins. International and local prices converging If we look at the graph, we see both local and international prices of Urea move in the same direction. However, YTDCY11 Urea prices have experienced expansion albeit with a smaller gap between local and int’l prices. Therefore, any hike in the int’l prices of urea can provide local manufacturers with further room to increase their prices in the future. At current levels, Urea’s global price is hovering at a premium of ~46%. Urea prices rise sharply than input prices Ever since gas curtailment came into the picture, Urea manufactures were forced to increase prices by a higher magnitude. As the graph below reveals, during YTDCY11, Urea price has gone up by more than 40% whereas cost of the input (gas) has gone up by a mere 3%, suggesting that it has been gas curtailment instead of any increase in the per mmbtu cost of gas that left Urea manufacturers with no other option but to increase product price to maintain their margins. - 100 200 300 400 500 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011YTD Local Urea Imported Urea Avg annual int'l and local urea prices(USD / to n) -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011YTD Cumilativ e gas price increase Urea price increase (% change) Urea price and gas price Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
  • 9. 7InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research DAP prices on the march DAP prices, on the other hand, have escalated at a 24% CAGR (as the graph reveals), where much of the increase was witnessed post 4MCY11 and imposition of Sales Tax on fertilizers. However, during the same period DAP’s primery raw material (Phos-acid)’s prices escalated at 13% CAGR with import price of DAP increasing by the same quantum. Keeping up with current trend, we expect Phos-acid prices to rise in the coming quarter, and expect it to hover around USD1,120/ton, thus we expect local prices of DAP to rise as well. As far as international prices are concerned, new supply from Ma'aden is expected to bring the prices of DAP down in the international market. Rain cum flood impact not significant The following graph shows provincewise Urea and DAP offtake numbers. The figure shows the province of Punjab enjoys the lion's share in both Urea and DAP offtake, keeping in view this trend, we do not expect rain-cum-flood situation in Sindh to hurt the cumulative offtake of fertilizer in the country, and expect the offtake levels to stay closer to their annual averages. 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 CY06A CY07A CY08A CY09A CY10A YTDCY11A Local DAP International DAP Phos-acid Avg annual int'l, local DAP and Phos-acid prices(USD/ton) 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 2006A 2007A 2008A 2009A 2010A 7MCY11 2006A 2007A 2008A 2009A 2010A 7MCY11 Punjab Sindh KP Balouchistan Province wise DAP and urea offtake DAP Urea Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
  • 10. 8InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Sector Outlook - Brighter ahead Additional gas flows form Qadirpur field and Kunal Pasaki, are expected to add ~200mmcfd to the sui network grid, which going forward should improve the supply situation to the fertilizer plants on Sui Network, enabling them with better flow of gas. However, this is a short term measure, in the long term, unless any sizable discovery is made gas, outages are expected to occur regularly with increasing durations. Thus, in the long run fertilizer price rise is highly likely. Being an agrarian economy we expect demand for Urea to be ever present. Regional Attractiveness Not only on the local front, Pakistan fertilizers stand highly attractive in a regional contest as well. Following graphs show key ratios and profitability growth measures on which Pakistan fertilizers (mainly FFC, FFBL and ENGRO) stand out. The three major companies show higher Earnings Growth, Dividend Yields and Return on Earnings with lower Price to Earnings, as depicted by the following charts. Regional ROE 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% FFCPA FFBLPA ANHUICH YIWUCH RESPIN RALIIN SHINDOOCH ENGROPA GSFCIN TPBTB Regional Earning Growth 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% TPBTB FFBLPA ENGROPA FFCPA GSFCIN SHINDOOCH YIWUCH ANHUICH RALIIN RESPIN Regional PE - 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 RESPIN RALIIN ANHUICH YIWUCH SHINDOOCH GSFCIN FFCPA ENGROPA FFBLPA TPBTB Regional Dividend Yield 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% FFBLPA FFCPA TPBTB ENGROPA GSFCIN RALIIN SHINDOOCH RESPIN ANHUICH YIWUCH Source: Bloomberg, InvestCap Research
  • 11. 9InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Fauji Fertilizer Company Limited
  • 12. 10InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research FFC - Royal flushing peers’ moves Rising Urea prices proved to be most fruitful for FFC, as the company receives its gas supply from the Mari network. During 1HCY11, company’s topline grew by a decent 21% YoY on the back of ~37% YoY increase in the price of Urea. However, had production levels not fallen by 5% YoY during the said period, topline could have witnessed further growth. Gross margins experienced a colossal growth of 12.3pps, owning to above-mentioned price increase coupled with decrease in the cost of production (amid gas curtailment), while the input charges per unit remained the same. Distribution charges also rose by 16% YoY mainly due to the rise in the price of diesel (up 20% YoY). Increase of 89% YoY in other income (higher dividends from FFBL) contributed heavily in bolstering the bottomline (35% EPS contribution). This increase at such massive level aided in offsetting 78% YoY increase in other charges of the company, leading to a bottomline growth of 61% YoY. FFBL's dividends to keep providing support FFC has ~51% stake in FFBL, which entitles FFC to enjoy 51% of all the dividends that FFBL declares (FFBL’s dividend contribution to FFC earnings has substantially increased to 36% against 20% during CY05-10). During CY11, FFBL’s contribution to FFC’s earnings is expected to increase to 40%, on the back of massive increase of 50% in FFBL’s earnings this year. Thus, going forward, FFC1HCY11 RESULT REVIEW (Rs mn) 1HCY11 YoY 2QCY11 QoQ Net Sales 24,221 21% 13,120 18% Gross Profit 13,693 55% 7,783 32% Gross Margin 56.5% 12.25pps 59.3% 6pps Selling and Distribution Cost 2,165 16% 1,148 13% Finance Cost 471 -5% 242 6% Other Expenses 1,121 78% 615 21% Other Income 2,882 89% 919 -53% Profit after Tax 8,189 61% 4,080 -1% EPS @ 848mn shares 9.65 4.81 DPS @ 848mn shares 9.25 4.75 Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research Company Discripation Fauji Fertilizer Company Limited is the largest urea producer in Pakistan; the company also enjoys the biggest market share of the urea market. FFC was incorporated in 1978 as a private limited company. This was a joint venture between Fauji Foundation (a leading charitable trust in Pakistan) and Haldor Topsoe A/S of Denmark. Today the company has assest bass of ~Rs45bn, making it one of the leading and most profitable companies in Pakistan. - 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 CY11F CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15F 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% FFC EPS FFBL's contribution Percentage participation by FFBL(EPS Rs) FFBL EPS participation in FFC Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research FFC Gross Margins 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% 55% 60% 65% CY05A CY07A CY09A CY11E CY13F CY15F Bloomberg Code FFC PK No. of Shares 848.16mn Avg Daily Vol (1-Yr) 1.86mn Sh Last Closing Rs170.62 Target Price (Jun-11) Rs251.00 Upside Potential 47.10% Dividend Yield (CY12) 15.35% Total Return (CY12) 62.45% Return in CY10 22.28% Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
  • 13. 11InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research FFC’S WIND POWER PROJECT Project cost USD140mn Capacity 50mw Debt financing 70% Equity financing 30% Source: Company Reports UREA PRICE SENSITIVITY WITH EPS Price/bag (Rs) CY12F CY13F T. Price Base-case 29.11 29.30 251 20 29.75 29.97 257 40 30.40 30.64 263 60 31.04 31.31 269 80 31.69 31.98 275 100 32.34 32.65 280 Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research 2,000 2,100 2,200 2,300 2,400 2,500 2,600 2009A 2010A 2011E 2012F 2013F 112% 114% 116% 118% 120% 122% Urea Production Urea Sales Capacity Utilization FFC production and sales (000 tons) stable income from FFBL is going to boost earnings of FFC, in addtion to core income increase. Currently, FFBL's participation in FFC's EPS is expected to be at ~40%, which is expected to stabilize at ~30% during CY12 and CY13. FFC the biggest gainer of any urea price hike FFC receives gas supply from Mari-gas fields; hence the company is not facing as much of a dire situation on gas supply front as players on the SNGP network. Therefore, any increase in the price of urea coming from ENGRO (over and above our price assumption, which is same as for ENGRO) is going to be beneficial for FFC. We have given below a sensitivity that showcases the impact of Urea price change on expected earnings of FFC. Company embarking on new ventures FFC successfully had a financial close of its venture in the wind power project. As per our discussion with the company’s management, the cost of the project is expected to be around USD140mn, with debt to equity ratio being at 70:30. The project is expected to come online during early CY13. This project is going to be beneficial for the company due to virtually non- extent operating cost. Guarantee of the wind speed insured by the gov’t of Sindh also makes this project an attractive investment for FFC. From a valuation standpoint, keeping timeline of the project we have not yet incorporated the earnings impact of this project, which would have only made FFC’s already compelling valuations more attractive.
  • 14. 12InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Outlook and Recommendation As discussed earlier, the company is not as much plagued as its peers on the Sui network. Thus, as gas curtailment increases on other fertilizer players in the sector i.e. Engro, it is going to benefit FFC in form of increased margins with every increase in Urea price that Engro passes on to consumer in order to make up for the production loss. FFC is currently trading at forward PE of 5.86x and 5.8x for CY12 and CY13 respectively, coupled with CY12 and CY13 massive dividend yield of ~15.4% 15.6%. Like FFBL, the company’s main investing trigger is its handsome payout (90% for CY11E,CY12F and CY13F). We have 'Buy' call on the scrip with Jun-12 Target Price of Rs251/share, which provide a solid 47% upside from current levels. FFC VALUATION BREAK UP Rs mn CY11E CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15F Terminal FCFE 23,060 26,510 23,302 22,823 23,997 144,732 Cost of equity 21% 21% 21% 21% 21% 21% Discounted FCFE 26,489 24,433 19,384 17,746 17,741 107,001 Accumulated FCFE 212,795 Number of shares 848 FCFE per share 251 Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research VALUATION CRITERIA Cost of Equity 21% Risk Premium 6.5% Terminal growth 3% -1 49 99 149 199 249 299 Jan- 06 Sep- 06 May- 07 Jan- 08 Sep- 08 May- 09 Jan- 10 Sep- 10 May- 11 FFC PE Bands 3x 5x 8x 10x 15x (Rs bn)
  • 15. 13InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research FFC’S INCOME STATEMENTS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Sales 36,163 44,874 57,936 64,037 66,599 Cost of Sales 20,515 25,310 24,171 24,200 26,114 Gross Profit 15,648 19,564 33,766 39,838 40,485 Selling and Distribution 3,175 3,944 6,144 5,302 5,539 EBIT 12,474 15,619 27,622 34,536 34,945 Financial charges 945 1,087 1,106 1,117 754 Other income 2,801 3,153 5,247 5,625 5,344 Other charges 1,272 1,376 2,334 1,796 1,868 Net Profit before Tax 13,057 16,310 29,428 37,248 37,668 Tax 4,233 5,281 9,656 12,560 12,814 Profit after tax 8,824 11,029 19,772 24,689 24,853 EPS (Rs) @ 848mn shares 10.40 13.00 23.31 29.11 29.30 DPS (Rs) @ 848mn shares 13.15 16.00 20.98 26.20 26.37 FFC'S BALANCE SHEETS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Equity Issued and Paidup 6,785 6,785 8,482 8,482 8,482 Share Capital 13,083 15,448 24,745 34,125 46,256 Liabilities Long term Liabilities 7,615 7,035 7,857 6,155 4,697 Current Liabilities 17,855 20,578 23,922 26,993 27,258 Total Liabilities 25,469 27,613 31,221 33,148 31,955 Equity Liabilities 38,552 43,061 56,524 67,273 78,211 Assets Current Assets 14,917 17,224 30,435 41,484 52,604 Fixed Assets 23,634 25,837 26,089 25,789 25,607 Total Assets 38,552 43,061 56,524 67,273 78,211 FFC'S CASH FLOWS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Cashflow from Operations 13,519 15,917 20,545 30,167 26,548 Cashflow from Investments (5,758) (8,657) 614 (878) (1,044) Cashflow from Financing (4,842) (9,920) (10,561) (17,160) (14,924) Net Inflow / Outflow 2,918 (2,660) 10,598 12,129 10,580 Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research Financial Highlights
  • 16. 14InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research FFC’S KEY RATIOS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Liquidity ratios Current Ratio 0.84 0.84 1.24 1.4 1.68 Quick Ratio 0.61 0.66 1.01 1.19 1.45 Captial structure Times interest earned 14 15 25 27 41 Int bearing debt to equity 0.35 0.25 0.19 0.1 0.04 Total debt to equit 1.95 1.79 1.3 1.05 0.79 Returns ratios Return on assets (RoA) 23% 26% 34% 34% 31% Return on Equity (RoE) 67% 71% 79% 71% 56% Return on Cap. employed 55% 62% 95% 101% 103% Profitablity margins Gross margin 43% 44% 57% 58% 57% EBITDA Margin 37% 37% 45% 56% 54% Net profit margins 24% 25% 34% 35% 34% Growth Sales 18% 24% 25% 6% 4% EBITDA growth 28% 24% 63% 11% 1% Net profit growth 35% 25% 72% 10% 1% General ratios PBV 11.06 9.37 5.84 4.24 3.26 Payout ratio 126% 123% 90% 90% 90% Dividend Yield 7.7% 9.4% 12.3% 15.2% 15.4% PE 16.40 13.12 7.31 5.86 5.82 Source:Company reports, InvestCap Research Key Ratios
  • 17. 15InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Fauji Fertilizer Bin QasimLimited
  • 18. 16InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research FFBL - The little ‘giant’ Following the trend of sector profitability, 1HCY11 proved to be exceptionally good for FFBL. Company's topline grew by a massive 51% YoY, primarily owing to price appreciation experienced in DAP, where it grew by ~33%YoY. Furthermore, product offtake supported this increase as volumes grew by a solid 29% YoY. The company's gross margins also bolstered by massive 627bps in 1HCY11, which was mainly due to magnitude of price increase, appreciating by greater than the increase in raw material cost (Phos-acid, DAP's prime raw material) that grew by 26% YoY. An astounding 81% YoY in gross profit coupled with 4% YoY decrease distribution charges led to a bolstered EBIT margins, rising by stupendous 900bps to . Financial charges of the company remained almost at the same level as previous year’s. As a result net profit of the company grew by mammoth 104% YoY. Margins expected to remain robust We have seen Phos-acid prices going up by 13% QoQ in 3QCY11, which is expected to normalize going forward. In immediate terms, we foresee Phos- acid prices reacting USD1,20-1,150/ton during 4QCY11. On international front, we foresee supply to be on the rise as Saudi Arabian mining company, Ma'aden, is expected to come online in 4QCY11. This additional supply is expected to bring down the price of DAP to an extent in the international market, while at current point in time, Pakistan is importing DAP at CFR price of USD695/ton. Though in the short term, increasing cost of Phos-acid is expected to pull down FFBL’s margins where the company enjoys primary margin of USD310/ ton currently. On the other hand, FFBL’s YTD primary margins have averaged at ~USD325/ton. This rising cost of Phos-acid in the short term is expected to be easily passed on to the consumer, as FFBL enjoys exclusive pricing power being sole producer of DAP in Pakistan. FFBL1HCY11 RESULT REVIEW (Rs mn) 1HCY11 YoY 2QCY11 QoQ Net Sales 18,017 51% 9,963 124% Gross Profit 6,929 81% 4,182 152% Gross Margin 38.4% 621bps 41.9% 780bps Admin Cost 296 42% 182 159% Selling and Distribution Cost 1,048 -4% 683 187% Other Operating Income 741 50% 409 123% Other Operating Charges 406 116% 235 137% EBIT 5,921 108% 3,491 144% Finance Cost 373 13% 266 248% Profit After Tax 3,514 104% 1,956 126% EPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 3.76 2.09 EPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 3.50 2.25 Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research Company Discripation Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited is a subsidiary of Fauji Fertilizer Company (51% stake), the company Limited is the sole manufacturer of DAP in Pakistan. FFBL previously was known as FFC-Jordan because of 10% stake held by Jordan Phospate Mines Co. However, in 2003 Jordan Phosphate Mines Co. sold its share, hence the company was renamed as Fauji Fertilizer Bin Qasim Limited (FFBL). FFBL Gross Margins 25% 27% 29% 31% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% CY05A CY07A CY09A CY11E CY13F CY15F Bloomberg Code FFBL PK No. of Shares 934.11mn Avg Daily Vol (1-Yr) 4.21mn Sh Last Closing Rs61.77 Target Price (Jun-11) Rs72.00 Upside Potential 16.56% Dividend Yield (CY12) 15.17% Total Return (CY12) 31.73% Return in CY10 36.74% Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
  • 19. 17InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Depreciating PKR to impact FFBL’s margins a bit Since FFBL's prime raw material (Phos-acid) is imported and it is denominated in USD terms, it stands prone to depreciation in PKR. We have done a sensitivity that showcases impact of PKR depreciation on FFBL’s earnings outlook. Phos-acid price has been on the rise off late due to global demand of the commodity, which coupled with PKR depreciation may put pressure on copmany’s primary margin, while its pricing power may provide partial relief. Outlook and Recommendation Being country's sole DAP producer, FFBL's DAP offtake is not expected to go down despite price expansions. However, DAP margins are at their record high (primary margin at average USD311/ton) at the moment, and going forward are expected to normalize to the level of around USD250/ton. Strong dividends are the major investing trigger for the stock. We have 'Buy' call on FFBL with Jun-12 Target Price of Rs72/share. The scrip currently offers an upside of a decent ~17%, alongwith a shining CY12F and CY13F dividend yield of an average ~15%. At current levels, FFBL is trading at PE of 6.11x and 6.49x for CY12 and CY13 respectively. Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research PKR DEPRECIATION IMPACT ON FFBL EARNINGS Rupee Depreciation Change in earnings 5% -3% 6% -6% 7% -8% 8% -10% 9% -12% 10% -15% Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research FFBL VALUATION BREAK UP Rs mn CY11E CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15F Terminal FCFE 6,179 7,924 9,367 8,775 10,673 65,881 Cost of equity 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% Discounted FCFE 6,758 7,241 7,152 5,598 5,689 35,115 Accumulated FCFE 67,553 Number of shares (mn) 934 FCFE/share (Rs) (Jun-12 TP) 72 Source: Company Reports,, InvestCap Rsearch - 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 2009A 2010A 2011E 2012F 2013F 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Urea Production Urea Sales Capacity Utilization FFBL urea production and sales snapshot (000 tons) - 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 2009A 2010A 2011E 2012F 2013F 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% DAP Production DAP Sales Capacity Utilization FFBL DAP production and sales snapshot (000 tons) VALUATION CRITERIA Risk free 14.5% Risk Premium 6.5% Terminal growth 5% -1 49 99 149 199 Jan-06 Sep-06 May-07 Jan-08 Sep-08 May-09 Jan-10 Sep-10 May-11 FFBL PE Bands 3x 5x 10x 15x 18x (Rs bn)
  • 20. 18InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research FFBL’S INCOME STATEMENTS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Net sales 36,725 43,257 56,180 59,784 59,482 Cost of Sales 27,060 29,794 37,198 41,213 41,312 Gross Profit 9,665 13,463 18,982 18,571 18,170 Distribution Expense 2,236 2,585 3,009 2,950 3,100 Administrative Expense 401 700 1,045 1,141 1,163 Operating profit 7,028 10,178 14,927 14,480 13,906 Financial Cost 1,460 934 905 269 287 Other Operating Expense 443 713 1,015 1,116 1,132 Other Income 998 1,033 1,495 1,098 930 Share of Associate's profit / (loss) (315) 121 186 219 243 Compensation from GOP - - - - - Profit Before Tax 5,808 9,686 14,688 14,412 13,660 Taxation 2,024 3,171 4,908 4,974 4,767 Profit After Tax 3,784 6,514 9,781 9,438 8,893 EPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 4.05 6.97 10.47 10.10 9.52 DPS (Rs) @ 934mn shares 4.00 6.55 9.70 9.37 8.57 FFBL'S BALANCE SHEETS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Equity Issued and Paid up 9,341 9,341 9,341 9,341 9,341 Share Holder Equity 10,660 12,210 16,921 16,439 18,039 Liabilities Current Liabilities 16,747 15,389 12,465 12,117 12,865 Non Current Liabilities 8,818 7,737 7,089 6,441 5,792 Equity and Liability 36,225 35,336 36,474 34,997 36,697 Assets Current Assets 18,444 18,318 19,816 18,778 21,001 Non-Current Assets 17,781 17,018 16,658 16,220 15,695 Total Assets 36,225 35,336 36,474 34,997 36,697 FFBL'S CASH FLOWS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Cashflow from Operations 22,953 8,520 11,747 9,208 10,091 Cashflow from Investments (5,378) 2,858 (1,413) (617) (558) Cashflow from Financing (15,869) (8,305) (9,939) (10,568) (7,442) Net Cash Inflow/Outflow 1,707 3,072 394 (1,977) 2,091 Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research Financial Highlights
  • 21. 19InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research FFBL’S KEY RATIO (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Liquidity ratios Current Ratio 1.10 1.19 1.59 1.55 1.63 Quick Ratio 1.14 1.22 1.48 1.70 - Captial structure Times interest earned 5.65 12.30 17.90 58.72 53.08 Int bearing debt to equity 1.29 0.87 0.34 0.31 0.27 Total debt to equit 2.40 1.89 1.16 1.13 1.03 Returns ratios Return on assets (RoA) 10% 18% 27% 27% 24% Return on Equity (RoE) 36% 53% 58% 57% 49% Return on Cap. employed 31% 49% 105% 102% 90% Profitablity margins Gross margin 26% 31% 34% 31% 31% EBITDA margins 22% 27% 29% 26% 26% Net profit margins 10% 15% 17% 16% 15% Growth Sales 37% 18% 30% 6% -1% EBITDA growth 11% 39% 41% -3% -3% Net profit growth 31% 72% 50% -3% -6% General ratios PBV 5.41 4.73 3.41 3.80 3.47 Payout ratio 99% 94% 93% 93% 90% Dividend Yield 6.5% 10.6% 15.7% 15.2% 13.9% PE 15.25 8.86 5.90 6.11 6.49 Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research Key Ratios
  • 22. 20InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Engro Corporation Limited
  • 23. 21InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research ENGRO - The price king! Engro Corp's core profitability was bolstered by a solid 49% YoY. However, after inclusion of one-time accounting change corp’s profiability slid well below market’s expectation. Topline of the company grew by an impressive 37% YoY during 1HCY11. However, cost of sales also grew by almost the same proportion, as a result gross margins of the conglomerate were up by mere 77bps YoY. Engro Foods was the top participant in the topline expansion of Engro Corp. Despite expanding admin (up 36% YoY) and distribution cost (up 17% YoY), company’s operating margins were up 153bps YoY, mainly because operating income grew by a larger magnitude (up 49% YoY). Earnings were expected in the bracket of Rs10-11/share during 1HCY11. However, the company incorporated a one time accounting change, that allowed them to incorporate financial charges from May-11 (2 months prior to commissioning of the new plant) instead of capitalizing them along with other expenses, which raised financial charges of Engro Corp, rocketed upwards by 96% YoY. As a result the earnings of Engro Corp's prime bread earner (Engro Fertilizer) was below expectations (EFert EPS at Rs1.9). The above-mentioned one-off dampened Engro Corp's earnings for the said period, however, the company remained glued to its history by offering DPS of Rs2/sh. Tweaking assumptions to have value fine-tuned Keeping in view the recent gas curtailment scenario and lower than contracted level of supply to EnVen, we have done few changes in the price assumption of Urea, gas levels that we expect EnVen to enjoy, Urea production figures and offtake numbers. Currently, ENGRO’s USD1.2bn plant is receiving 80mmcfd gas supply from SNGP, while another 20 mmcfd additional supply is being provided by the Mari network. As a result, the plant is producing 3,500 tons of urea per day, against name-plate capacity of 3,850 tons (~91% capacity utilization). ENGRO CROP 1HCY11 RESULT REVIEW (Rs mn) 1HCY11 YoY 2QCY11 QoQ Net Sales 46,084 37% 24,236 44% Gross Profit 13,041 40% 6,916 50% Gross Margin 28.3% 140bps 28.5% 50bps Admin Cost 1,359 36% 744 31% Selling and Distribution Cost 3,184 17% 1,636 19% Other Operating Income 599 -3% 255 -47% Other Operating Charges 734 29% 456 0% EBIT 8,363 49% 4,333 61% Finance Cost 3,674 96% 2,501 131% Share of Income from JV 239 -8% 120 -6% Profit After Tax 3,316 4% 1,274 -8% EPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 8.43 3.24 DPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 2.00 2.00 Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research Engro Gross Margins 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% 55% 60% 65% CY05A CY07A CY09A CY11E CY13F CY15F Company Discripation Engro Corporation is one of the leading Pakistani business conglomerates. Having had undergone an employee led buyout in 1992. Currently Dawood Hercules holds 32% stake in the company. Engro has expanded its businesses phenomenally in the past two decades. As a holding company its subsidiaries include: Subsidiary Stake *Engro Fertilizers Ltd 100% *Engro Foods Ltd 90% *Engro Eximp Pvt Ltd 100% *Avanceon Ltd 100% *Engro PowerGen Ltd 100% *Engro Polymers Chem Ltd 56% *Engro Vopak Ltd 50% Bloomberg Code ENGRO PK No. of Shares 339.28mn Avg Daily Vol (1-Yr) 2.09mn Sh Last Closing Rs142.42 Target Price (Dec-11) Rs251.00 Upside Potential 86.1% Dividend Yield (CY12) 5.61% Total Return (CY12) 91.71% Return in CY10 5.75% Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
  • 24. 22InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research We expect EnVen's capacity utilization to be at 77.5% for CY12 (down because we expect capacity utilization to be at 65% during 1QCY12 and 4QCY12), owing to gas outages during winter season. We assume the production and offtake to be at ~1070k tons form new plant, total offtake is expected to be at 1.9mn tons. This is our long term production assumption as well. On cost front, we expect fuel gas cost per mmbtu to increase by 2.5% and feed gas cost per mmbtu to increase by 5.25% ( on old plant), both increasing biannually. In order to fight this increase in costs, we have assumed ENGRO to raise price of its Urea by 4% annually. Fertilizer business stability very important for Engro Corp Engro Fertilizer is currently the bread and butter for the whole Engro Corp (bottomline contribution of average 70%), and is going to be so in future as well due to the attractive margins the company earns on its fertilizer (Urea) sales. However, with acute gas supply shortages, production of Engro Fertilizer has painted a different picture from what was expected prior to new capacity coming online. Going forward, we expect gas supply situation to gradually improve (as Kunal Pasaki field is expected to add 50-100mmcfd to Sui network). This expected better supply with current level of product prices makes Engro Fertilizer an attractive subsidiary of the conglomerate. Ferlizer business holds largest share in Corp’s value Engro Corp’s profitability and value share break up graph shows 5-year average forecasted profitability of Corp’s existing subsidiaries coupled with their individual value contribution to conglomerate’s target price. In this regard, Engro Fertilizer leads the way in both the profitability and valuation departments with average 70% and 63% share respectively. Source: NFDC, InvestCap Research - 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 CY11F CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15F CY16F CY17F CY18F CY19F CY20F 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Total Offtake EnVen Production Capacity Utilization EnVen(000 tons) Long term offtake and EnVen production - 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2009A 2010A 2011E 2012F 2013F 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% Urea Production Urea Sales Capacity Utilization Engro production and sales (000 tons) Eximp 7% Polymer 2% Power 4% Vopak 9% Avanceon 1% Food 14% Fertilizer 70% Profit Contributors ` Fertilizer 63% Food 14% Avanceon 1% Vopak 6% Power 4% Polymer 3% Eximp 11% Value Contributors ` Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
  • 25. 23InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research As far as profitability and value contribution by other subsidiaries are concerned: • 3% is contributed by Engro Foods towards valuation and 7% towards profitability • Plagued Engro Polymer has 4% share in valuation, while contributes 2% in corp’s profit • Engro Power enjoys valuation share of 11% and its profitability participation is at 4%. • Trading concern, Eximp has participation of 14% and 7% is towards profitability • Vopak and Avanceon have contribution of 6% and 1% respectively. Their contribution towards profitability is at 9% and 1% respectively. Decreasing interest rates to benefit Engro the most With expected cut in the discount rate in up coming monitory policies of the central bank, ENGRO's PKR denominated debt servicing should experience contraction due to falling KIBOR, as a result of discount rate cut. We have run a sensitivity, providing different scenarios at different interest levels and their impact on ENGRO’s Target Price. The table above highlights the relativity of financial leverage of Engro Corp with interest rate volatility. In this regard, 50bps rate cut would increase the target price of the company by 6%. In CY12 we expect policy rate to shed 100-150bps, which should lead to increase in the target price of ENGRO by 10-15%. IMPACT OF INTEREST RATE CHANGE ON ENGRO Interest rate decline Target Price Change Base case (Rs/sh) 265 - 50bps 281 6% 100bps 291 10% 150bps 306 15% 200bps 322 22% Source: Company Reports, InvestCap Research
  • 26. 24InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Outlook and Recommendation Better expected profits from the Engro subsidiaries such as Engro Fertilizer, Engro PowerGen, Engro Foods, and Engro Eximp (though not as much as previous year’s), are expected to do their bit to offset the expected profitability loss of the much plagued subsidiary, Engro Polymer and Chemicals Limited. We expect Engro Corp to turn the tide and once again prove as to why it has been and still continues to be Pakistan's premier company as far as profitability growth is concerned. We iterate a 'Buy on the scrip with Jun-12 Target Price of Rs265/share, which offers a massive upside potential of ~92%. At current levels, the company is trading at CY12F and CY13F PE of 2.70x and 2.51x respectively. ENGRO VALUATION BREAK UP (Rs mn) CY11E CY12F CY13F CY14F CY15-20F Terminal Fertilier (20,304) 16,283 9,049 4,331 127,914 142,605 Foods (4,172) (1,256) 460 1,083 24,646 79,818 Polymer (1,415) (805) (211) 52 13,833 23,378 Power (Div) 674 735 762 812 4,339 1,130 Eximp (Div) 959 1,689 2,041 1,781 11,286 13,956 Avanceon - 10 77 99 949 1224 Vopak (Div) 505 602 686 765 6,923 9,280 Engro Corp Aggregate FCFF* (SoTP) (26,101) 15,564 9,553 5,522 189,890 271,287 WACC 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% 14.2% Discounted FCFF (SoTP) (24,965) 16,011 9,593 5,438 56,401 56,425 Total Firm Value* 104,262 Number of shares 393mn Jun-12 Target Price (SoTP) (Rs) 265 *Adjusted cashflows for Corp’s shares in the subsidiaries as well as for their leverage and cash balances VALUATION CRITERIA Risk free 14.5% Risk Premium 7% Terminal growth 5% -1 49 99 149 199 249 Jan- 06 Sep- 06 May- 07 Jan- 08 Sep- 08 May- 09 Jan- 10 Sep- 10 May- 11 ENGRO PE Bands 3x 5x 10x 15x 20x (Rs bn)
  • 27. 25InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research ENGRO’S INCOME STATEMENTS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Net Sales 58,152 79,976 97,950 129,253 142,713 Cost of Sales 44,658 59,702 65,606 80,469 91,044 Gross Profit 13,494 20,274 32,344 48,783 51,668 Selling Distribution 6,215 8,290 7,410 8,319 8,870 Other Income 390 897 728 914 1,035 Other Operating Charges 844 958 1,323 2,004 2,232 Finance Cost 2,222 4,201 6,409 10,273 8,532 Share of Income from JV 459 555 555 662 754 Profit before Tax 5,062 8,277 18,485 29,763 33,824 Taxation 1,343 1,836 6,470 8,917 11,308 Profit after tax 3,719 6,441 12,015 20,846 22,516 Attributable to Equity Holders 3,807 6,790 12,071 20,754 22,275 Attributable to Minority Interest -88 -349 -56 92 241 3,719 6,441 12,015 20,846 22,516 EPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 9.7 17.26 30.69 52.77 56.64 DPS (Rs) @ 393mn shares 6.0 6.0 6.0 8.0 8.0 ENGRO FERTILIZER CASH FLOWS (Rs mn) CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Cashflow from Operations 9,244 (14,611) 14,544 18,598 21,765 Cashflow from Investments (38,840) (14,695) (23,427) 9,354 (1,678) Cashflow from Financing 28,274 24,280 (9,813) (13,064) (12,789) Net Cash Inflow/Outflow (1,322) (5,026) (18,696) 14,888 7,298 Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research Financial Highlights
  • 28. 26InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research ENGRO KEY RATIOS CY09A CY10A CY11E CY12F CY13F Liquidity ratios Current Ratio 1.07 2.06 0.46 1.05 1.05 Quick Ratio 0.34 1.73 0.05 0.56 0.58 Coverage ratios Time Interest Earned 3.28 2.85 3.89 3.94 5.02 Profitablity margins Gross margin 23% 25% 33% 38% 36% EBITDA margins 12% 13% 25% 33% 30% Net profit margins 6% 8% 12% 16% 16% Growth Sales 42% 38% 22% 32% 10% EBITDA growth 0% 48% 139% 74% 1% Net profit growth -12% 73% 87% 73% 8% General ratios PBV 1.45 1.37 1.37 0.95 0.72 Payout ratio 21% 12% 7% 4% 4% Dividend Yield 1% 1% 1% 1% 1% PE 14.71 8.25 4.64 2.70 2.51 Source:Company Reports, InvestCap Research Key Ratios
  • 29. 27InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research Notes:
  • 30. 28InvestCap Research October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR 2011 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research
  • 31. October 2011 FERTILIZER SECTOR CY11 A Publication of InvestCap Research Pakistan Research MONEY MARKET DESK (92-21) 3520 8751, 3520 8757, 3520 8767 Naeem Ul Hassan Nadeem Dar Mehmood Qureshi Asif Hussain Nasir Suria EQUITY SALES DESK (92-21) 3520 8727, 3520 8735, 3520 8730-31 Shahrukh Naqvi Noureen Moin Khan Nabeel Jafar Owais Imam Abdul Samad Tariq Irfan Ali Muhammad RESEARCH (92-21) 111 111 097 (8634) Khurram Schehzad Economy, Strategy and Oil Farhan Bashir Khan Economy, EP, Refineries and Telecom Asad Siddiqui Fertilizers, Chemicals, Banks and Construction Abdul Azeem Automobile, Gas Distribution, Power and Textiles Mazhar A. Sabir Mutual Funds and Insurance Yawar uz Zaman FMCGs, Paper Board and Construction Rao Aamir Ali Database Manager Asim Abbas Research Distribution FOREIGN EXCHANGE DESK (92-21)3520 8778-87 Raheel Abbass Atif Ali Naheed Fatima Qazi Owais Zain Jafri Zeeshan Atique Hammad Rasheed COMMODITY SALES DESK (92-21)3521 35226-28 Ali Kazmi Shoaib Memon Shoaib Machiara CORPORATE FINANCE (92-21)3521 35226-28 AsherSaeed Salman Shahab Kiran Javed
  • 32. This report is for information purposes only and we are not soliciting any action based upon it. The material is based on information we believe to be reliable but we do not guarantee that it is accurate and complete. Invest Capital Markets Limited will not be responsible for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or statement herein or for any omission. This report or any part of it may not be reproduced or published without prior permission. www.investcapital.com InvestCapital Markets Limited Karachi Head Office C3C, 12th Lane, Ittehad Commercial Area, Khayaban-e-Ittehad, Phase- II Ext, DHA, Karachi, Telephone + 92 (21) 111 111 097 Fax + 92 (21) 3531 3885 Email info@investcapital.com Islamabad Office 301, Muhammad Gulistan Khan House 82E, Blue Area, Fazal-e-Haq Road, Islamabad Telephone + 92 (51) 3282 5904 Fax: +92 (51) 3227 5202 Peshawar Office 1st Floor, State Life Building 34 - The Mall, Peshawar Cantt. Telephone +92 (91) 3527 6025-28 Fax +92 (91) 3527 3683 Lahore Office 16A, Main Gulberg ,Near MCB Tower, Lahore Telephone +92 (42) 35776701-08 Fax +92 (42) 3577 6710