The doctrine of harmonious construction under Interpretation of statute
Osha updates
1.
2. AGENDA
• OSHA Update-Latest rulemaking and enforcement
• Surviving an OSHA inspection—Common questions, tips
• Injury/Illness recordkeeping—Trouble spots
• Training—Tips for improving training, OSHA requirements
• Most challenging OSHA issues—Common questions, tips
• Recap—Preparation, compliance & prevention
3. HAZCOM/GHS Compliance dates
• DECEMBER 1, 2013: Train employees on SDS/Labels
• June 1, 2015*: Chemical manufacturers must ship with compliant container labels/SDSs
• December 1, 2105: Distributors must ship under new system
• June 1, 2016: Employers must make any needed updating to their programs
*OSHA will allow some “good faith” exceptions on a case-by-case basis
4. GHS/HAZCOM Clarifications
Labeling
• NFPA/HMIS can still be used in-house
As long as employees are trained where to get more information, how the system works, etc.
• No exemption for content on small containers (except in-house)
• No size requirements for labels
• No blank pictograms allowed
• Red border required (except in-house)
• DOT Label still required for transport
OSHA and DOT may appear together, e.g., on drums
5. AUDIENCE QUESTION
Under the new GHS/HazCom rules, do employers have to ask the manufacturer for SDSs for
chemicals they last received 4 years ago (before the deadline) but still have on hand?
• Yes
• No
6. GHS/HAZCOM Clarifications
Safety Data Sheets
• Manufacturers don’t have to send new SDSs to previous customers who may still have inventory.
• New SDSs do not have to be provided for chemicals no longer produced.
• A red border is not required for pictograms on SDSs.
• A red border is not required for pictograms on SDSs.
• SDSs must be in English; they may also be kept in other languages.
7. Final Rule: Reporting incidents to OSHA
• Employers must now:
Call or submit online within 8 hours to report any fatality
Call or submit online within 24 hours to report any hospitalization, amputation, or loss of eye
• Reportable fatalities=Those occurring within 30 days of the work-related incident.
• Reportable hospitalizations, amputations, loss of eye=Those occurring within 24 hours of the
work-related incident.
8. Clarifications: Reporting Requirements
• Admission to Emergency Room does not count as “hospitalization”.
• Scheduled surgeries that require hospitalization do not require reporting if more than 24 hours from
time of incident.
• Temporary workers: Employer that provides day to day supervision should make the report.
9. Clarifications: Reporting Requirements
• Amputations do NOT require loss of bone
Includes fingertip amputations.
• Avulsions (skin torn away) do not have to be reported
Use physician’s diagnosis to distinguish between amputation and avulsion.
• Working definition: If it isn’t expected to grow back, it’s an amputation.
Likely will get differing opinions from various OSHA offices for the next few months.
10. What the incident report may trigger
• Guaranteed Onsite Inspection—For fatalities, 2 or more hospitalizations, emphasis programs,
workers under 18 years of age, imminent danger, and past history
• Possible onsite inspection—When tempt workers involved, government agency referral, VPP sites
• Rapid Response Investigation (Phone inquiry, follow-up letter)—No evidence of trend or imminent
danger, no emphasis-area, good faith
11. Making the call to OSHA
Do say:
• That you’ve done a root cause analysis
• What you plan to do/have done to control the hazard
Don’t say:
• “It was the worker’s fault.”
• “The worker was careless.”
12. Confined Spaces for Construction
• Effective 8/3/15
Partial enforcement delay until October 2, 2014
• Similar protections to General Industry Rule
Multi-employer worksites
Continuous monitoring
Suspension and reinstatement of the permit
• Training that the worker understands.
13. Definition of “construction work”
• Defined in 1910.12
“construction, alteration, and/or repair, including painting and decorating”.
• Must also factor in complexity and scale of the project.
• See the following letters of interpretation:
11/18/2003
2/1/1999
5/11/1999
8/11/1994
14. Walking Working Surfaces (fall protection)
• Final rule projected: Late 2015
Proposed rule was published:5/24/2010
• A complete redo of 1910 Subpart D
Current rules go back to the 1970s
Only provide for guardrails
Don’t address many types of work surfaces
15. Walking Working Surfaces (continued)
• Will still use the “4-foot” trigger
Adds additional requirements for skylights, dockboards, runways, fixed ladders, outdoor advertising
(billboards), stairways, floor holes, etc.
Proposal did not address “rolling stock” issue
New PPE section added for personal fall protection systems (e.g. lanyard and harness)
• Inspection requirement
“Regular and periodic”
• Training requirement
“Training must be understandable”
16. Walking Working Surfaces (continued)
• Mezzanine, floor load ratings
Would no longer have to be posted
• Ladder requirements consolidated
• Scaffolding to refer to Construction regulations
• More detail on dockboards
17. Electronic reporting of injury/illness information
New Electronic System
• Will require employers to submit records to OSHA
Sites with 250+ employees to submit detailed data quarterly
Proposal did not address “rolling stock” issue
Sites with 20+ employees in high-hazard industries to submit summary data annually
• Data will be made public
• Will be used to target enforcement
• State Plan OSHA’s would have to follow
Likely one system run by Federal OSHA
18. How will the electronic system work?
• Employers with either
Go to an OSHA website and manually enter the information in a secure form, OR
Go to the website and submit a batch file
• No reminders or notifications will be sent
• No impact on BLS annual survey—that will still happen
• BUT, annual OSHA survey will be replaced.
• Be aware of a couple of regulatory alternatives
Corporate-wide reporting
Changing the reporting threshold
19. How much time does OSHA have to issue a citation for an injury recordkeeping violation from the
time the violation occurred?
1. One month
2. Sixty days
3. Six months
4. Five years
20. Duty to keep accurate records
• Proposed rule would allow OSHA to cite employers for recordkeeping violations within the 5-year
retention period, so long as they do so within 6 months of discovery
Result of a court case that OSHA lost
Rule would clarify that recordkeeping obligations are “continual”
21. Chemical/substances rules
• PSM (Process Safety Management of highly hazardous chemicals)
New coverage definition— “one percent rule”
Possible changes to atmospheric tank and oil/gas exemptions, as well as reactives
• Silica in construction and general industry—will lower PEL
• Beryllium—Lowered PEL
23. Temporary Workers
• OSHA has issued several recent citations to HOST employees
Lack of site-specific training
• Ordered inspectors to start focusing on issue, capturing data
Aggressive enforcement so far, several hundred inspections
Both employers and staffing agents are being cited
• Focus on injury/illness recordkeeping—whoever provides “day-to-day supervision” must record:
An employer is performing day-to-day supervision when that employer controls conditions presenting
potential hazards and directs the worker’s activities around, and exposure to, those hazards
In most cases, the host employer provides this supervision.
24. Who has temporary worker responsibility?
• Chemical-specific training—Host
• Foundational training—Staffing agency
• PPE selection, provision, enforcement—Host*
• Reporting serious incidents—Whoever provides day-to-day supervision
Host can contract out to provide PPE, etc. BUT, if they don’t, host can be responsible.
25. Corporate-Wide Enforcement
• Tougher on repeat violations at other locations
“When a company is cited at one of its locations, it has the responsibility to improved and construct
similar violations at all its plants.”—OSHA area director
• Spring-boarding from one location to another
• Press releases naming company-wide history
• Pushing corporate-wide citation settlement agreements
27. Who is targeted?
• Fatality/hospitalization reports
• Referrals from other agencies
• Complaints
• National, regional, local emphasis programs
Hazard-based (e.g. Heat, combustible dust, hexavalent chromium)
Equipment-based (e.g. residential construction, auto parts suppliers)
• Site-Specific-Targeting Program
• Follow-up from prior inspection
• Plain-view
28. Key points to get through an inspection
• Prepare ahead of time
Safety programs, audits, training, mock inspections, OSHA inspection team
• Employers do have a right to request a warrant
BUT, it is fairly easy for OSHA to get a warrant
• Ask for time
• Negotiate the scope—sometimes an inspector would rather limit the inspection than deal with
a refusal/warrant
• Get senior management and legal involved
Particularly in fatality/catastrophe investigations
• Be polite, but formal
29. Key points to get
through an
inspection
• Take photographs during the walkthrough
Different angles
• Don’t volunteer documents. Keep a log of all items
given to the inspector
BUT, it is fairly easy for OSHA to get a warrant
• Don’t let inspector wander unsupervised
Take most direct route, if it’s up to you.
30. Key points to get through an inspection
• Don’t interfere with employee interviews
If possible, ask inspector to schedule all interviews ahead of time.
• Correct hazards while the inspector is there (but don’t admit to violation)
If CSHO seems concerned about something, try to address it before the end of the day (e.g. “this is
how we comply with that, even though this….”)
• If you’re going to contest…do it within writing and within the required period (15 WORKING days
Federal)
• Take advantage of the informal conference process
32. Recording Criteria
To be recordable an injury/illness must meet OSHA’s criteria*
1. Work-related*
2. New case, and
3. Meet one of the recording criteria:
a. Medical treatment beyond first aid; days away, lost time, transfer, loss of consciousness; significant
injury/illness; OR death
• Only record under most serious outcomes
If injury only has 1 lost day, but 40 restricted days, check the day-away column (but record day counts
for both)
33. 1. Work-related
OSHA considers a case to be work-related if:
• Work environment caused or contributed to condition or significantly aggravated pre-existing
condition.
Work-related is presumed in employer locations (geographic presumption)
Travel for work generally considered work-related except once checked into a hotel, or if on a
personal detour.
BUT, there is a specific set of exceptions!
34. Exceptions to being “Work-Related”
1. Present as a member of the general public
2. Signs and symptoms that merely surface at work but are from non-work exposure/event
3. Voluntary participation in wellness or recreation activities
4. Eating, drinking, or preparing food/drink
5. Personal tasks outside of assigned hours
35. Exceptions to being “Work-Related”
6. Personal grooming, self-medication, or self-inflicted
7. Motor vehicle accident in parking lot during commute
8. Common cold or flu
9. Mental illness
36. Audience Poll--
An employee slams his finger into a car door in the parking lot while getting out of his car to come
to work. Medical treatment is provided.
Is this recordable?
1. Yes
2. No
37. New Case
What makes a case a new case?
No previous injury to the body part
OR
Completely recovered from the previous injury
38. Meet the General Recording Criteria
• General criteria: medical treatment beyond first aid; days away, restriction, transfer; death;
loss of consciousness; or significant injury or illness (broken bone, punctured ear drum)
• Specific criteria: contaminated sharps, hearing loss, tuberculosis, medical removal
39. First Aid
• First aid is not recordable
• There is a defined list of what is considered first aid for recordkeeping
14 First-Aid treatments
• If it’s not on the list, it’s medical treatment!
40. Exclusive List of First Aid Treatments
1. Nonprescription medication at
nonprescription strength
2. Cleaning, flushing, or soaking wounds on
the surface of the skin.
3. Cleaning, flushing, or soaking wounds on
surface of the skin
4. Wound coverings
5. Hot or cold therapy
6. Non-rigid means of support
7. Temporary immobilization devices
8. Drilling a fingernail or toenail, or draining a
blister
9. Eye patches
10.Removing foreign bodies from the eye using
only irrigation or cotton swab
11. Removing splinters or foreign material from
areas other than the eye by irrigation,
tweezers, cotton swabs, or other simple
means.
12.Finger guards
13.Massages
14.Drinking fluids for relief of heat stress
41. Exceptions to Medical Treatment
Any treatment beyond first-aid. EXCEPT
Diagnostic procedures, e.g. x-rays
Counseling
Massage
42. Lost work days
• Begin counting days on the day after the injury occurred or the illness began.
• Count calendar days, not scheduled days
May include weekends, vacations, holidays
• E.g. off Wed to Wed, would be 8 lost days, even if employee NOT scheduled on weekend
Count what physician recommends, even if employee ignores
• Partial days off are counted as restricted days
• Can cap at 180 days
If both lost days and restricted, must be at least 1 day listed for both, e.g., 180 lost days, 1 day
restricted
43. Recordable or not?
1. Employee trips over own feet in office—lost time?
2. Employee trips over printer cords in a home office?
3. Employee finds tick embedded, is prescribed antibiotics?
4. Two employees get into a fight in the company parking lot, medical care needed?
5. Employee punches wall after bad review, breaking hand?
6. Employee passes out during a blood draw for an OSHA-required medical surveillance program (lead)?
7. Employee loses consciousness at work due to diabetic issue, falls and breaks arm?
8. Employee gets insect bite at hotel while on business trip?
9. Employee gets insect bite on airplane while on work trip?
10.Employee self-administers Epi-pen for bee sting at work?
11. Though voluntary, employee is paid to participate in an offsite community service project during
normal working hours, injured while clearing debris?
Editor's Notes
New Rule (24 hour rule)
Contracted workers are not reportable because you are not directly supervising them (e.g. Janitorial service).
If it doesn’t grow back, it’s an amputation.
According to an OSHA report, 2,644 worker amputations were reported in 2015.
VPP=Voluntary Protection Program; The Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) recognize employers and workers in the private industry and federal agencies who have implemented effective safety and health management systems and maintain injury and illness rates below national Bureau of Labor Statistics averages for their respective industries. In VPP, management, labor, and OSHA work cooperatively and proactively to prevent fatalities, injuries, and illnesses through a system focused on: hazard prevention and control; worksite analysis; training; and management commitment and worker involvement. To participate, employers must submit an application to OSHA and undergo a rigorous onsite evaluation by a team of safety and health professionals. Union support is required for applicants represented by a bargaining unit. VPP participants are re-evaluated every three to five years to remain in the programs. VPP participants are exempt from OSHA programmed inspections while they maintain their VPP status.
Let them know that you have been proactive about this particular problem, that you are making documentation & are addressing this proactively.
Confined spaces - such as manholes, crawl spaces, and tanks - are not designed for continuous occupancy and are difficult to exit in the event of an emergency. People working in confined spaces face life-threatening hazards including toxic substances, electrocutions, explosions, and asphyxiation.
Construction workers often perform tasks in confined spaces - work areas that (1) are large enough for an employee to enter, (2) have limited means of entry or exit, and (3) are not designed for continuous occupancy. These spaces can present physical and atmospheric hazards that can be prevented if addressed prior to entering the space to perform work.
OSHA's regulations define "construction work" as "construction, alteration, and/or repair, including painting and decorating.“ They further provide that OSHA's construction industry standards apply "to every employment and place of employment of every employee engaged in construction work."
Falls from heights and on the same level (a working surface) are among the leading causes of serious work-related injuries and deaths. OSHA has issued a final rule on Walking-Working Surfaces and Personal Fall Protection Systems to better protect workers in general industry from these hazards by updating and clarifying standards and adding training and inspection requirements.
The rule affects a wide range of workers, from painters to warehouse workers. It does not change construction or agricultural standards.
The rule incorporates advances in technology, industry best practices, and national consensus standards to provide effective and cost-efficient worker protection. Specifically, it updates general industry standards addressing slip, trip, and fall hazards, and adds requirements for personal fall protection systems.
OSHA estimates that these changes will prevent 29 fatalities and 5,842 lost-workday injuries every year.
Benefits to Employers
The rule benefits employers by providing greater flexibility in choosing a fall protection system. For example, it eliminates the existing mandate to use guardrails as a primary fall protection method and allows employers to choose from accepted fall protection systems they believe will work best in a particular situation - an approach that has been successful in the construction industry since 1994. In addition, employers will be able to use non-conventional fall protection in certain situations, such as designated areas on low-slope roofs.
Ladder inspection
How many ladders do we have? Visuals
Checklist
As much as possible, OSHA aligned fall protection requirements for general industry with those for construction, easing compliance for employers who perform both types of activities. For example, the final rule replaces the outdated general industry scaffold standards with a requirement that employers comply with OSHA's construction scaffold standards.
Timeline
Most of the rule will become effective January 17, 2017, 60 days after publication in the Federal Register, but some provisions have delayed effective dates, including:
Ensuring exposed workers are trained on fall hazards (May 17, 2017),
Ensuring workers who use equipment covered by the final rule are trained (May 17, 2017),
Inspecting and certifying permanent anchorages for rope descent systems (November 20, 2017),
Installing personal fall arrest or ladder safety systems on new fixed ladders over 24 feet and on replacement ladders/ladder sections, including fixed ladders on outdoor advertising structures (November 19, 2018),
Ensuring existing fixed ladders over 24 feet, including those on outdoor advertising structures, are equipped with a cage, well, personal fall arrest system, or ladder safety system (November 19, 2018), and
Replacing cages and wells (used as fall protection) with ladder safety or personal fall arrest systems on all fixed ladders over 24 feet (November 18, 2036).
OSHA has an entire set of rules on Walking/Working Surfaces. A strange name for an apparently simple topic: making sure you don’t fall down, fall through, slip, or trip. Do you have a mezzanine, or any other elevated area where you have to go? Preventing you from falling down can be as simple as installing guard rails on a mezzanine. You can put those in yourself, if you can safely use a hammer and nails. They have to be substantial enough to hold someone who falls against them. But you can build a guard rail, with a midrail and a toeboard (to keep things from falling on people below) out of standard 2 x 4 construction lumber and posts eight feet apart.
Provisions call for employers to electronically submit injury and illness data that they already record.
Why is OSHA issuing this rule?
This simple change in OSHA’s rulemaking requirements will improve safety for workers across the country. One important reason stems from our understanding of human behavior and motivation. Behavioral economics tells us that making injury information publicly available will “nudge” employers to focus on safety. And, as we have seen in many examples, more attention to safety will save the lives and limbs of many workers, and will ultimately help the employer’s bottom line as well. Finally, this regulation will improve the accuracy of this data by ensuring that workers will not fear retaliation for reporting injuries or illnesses.
The new rule, which takes effect Jan. 1, 2017, requires certain employers to electronically submit injury and illness data that they are already required to record on their onsite OSHA Injury and Illness forms. Analysis of this data will enable OSHA to use its enforcement and compliance assistance resources more efficiently. Some of the data will also be posted to the OSHA website. OSHA believes that public disclosure will encourage employers to improve workplace safety and provide valuable information to workers, job seekers, customers, researchers and the general public. The amount of data submitted will vary depending on the size of company and type of industry.
Answer: five years
OSHA’s June 5, 2015 memorandum abandoned that decades old “commercial grade” standard, and substituted in what is being referred to as the “1% rule.” As the name suggests, rather than counting for PSM-coverage purposes only those mixtures made up of 99% of an Appendix A chemical, OSHA would now count Appendix A chemicals in mixtures when they make up only one percent or more of a chemical mixture. OSHA reasoned that a set trigger of one percent is more appropriate because it will result in consistent application and will account for the hazardous characteristics of chemicals at low levels. Only the weight of the covered chemical, not the total of the mixture, is counted, and it does not count the weight of chemicals in portions of the process where partial pressure of the chemical in vapor space under handling or storage conditions is less than or equal to ten millimeters of mercury (https://oshadefensereport.com/2016/08/03/osha-settles-legal-challenge-to-process-safety-management-chemical-mixtures-enforcement-memo/).
To ensure that there is a clear understanding of each employer's role in protecting employees, OSHA recommends that the temporary staffing agency and the host employer set out their respective responsibilities for compliance with applicable OSHA standards in their contract. Including such terms in a contract will ensure that each employer complies with all relevant regulatory requirements, thereby avoiding confusion as to the employer's obligations.
*Unless company & temp agency has made a contract (must be put in writing).
While the extent of responsibility under the law of staffing agencies and host employers is dependent on the specific facts of each case, staffing agencies and host employers are jointly responsible for maintaining a safe work environment for temporary workers - including, for example, ensuring that OSHA's training, hazard communication, and recordkeeping requirements are fulfilled.
The most significant trend impacting employers with multiple locations is OSHA’s recent fascination with Follow-up Inspections and Repeat citations. OSHA characterizes citations as Other Than Serious (OTS), Serious, Willful, or Repeat. The maximum penalty for OTS and Serious citations is only $7,000 per violation, but for Willful and Repeat violations, OSHA can issue penalties up to $70,000 per violation. By actively pursuing more Repeat violations, OSHA is issuing much higher penalties.
OSHA issues “Repeat” violations when an employer has been cited in the past for a substantially similar violation (generally, a citation issued under the same standard for the same violation condition).
60% of OSHA inspections are programmed. The other 40% are complaints, triggers (e.g. accidents).
OSHA cannot inspect all 7 million workplaces it covers each year. The agency seeks to focus its inspection resources on the most hazardous workplaces in the following order of priority:
Imminent danger situations
Severe injuries and illnesses—employers must report
Worker Complaints—allegations of hazards or violations also receive a high priority. Employees may request anonymity when they file complaints.
Referrals of hazards from other federal, state or local agencies, individuals, organizations or the media receive consideration for inspection.
Targeted inspections—inspections aimed at specific high-hazard industries or individual workplaces that have experienced high rates of injuries and illnesses also receive priority.
Follow-up inspections
We do have a right to request a warrant, but expect OSHA to come back with guns blazing.
You can ask for them to come back another day to give you some time.
Don’t offer more information than what is being asked for.
*No relationship to worker’s compensation
*No relationship to worker’s compensation
1. For example, working and shopping at the same place.
No matter how much your boss drives you crazy…mental illness isn’t work-related, technically-speaking
The employee's injuries are recordable. While the employee parking lot is part of the work environment, injuries occurring there are not work-related if they meet the exception, which are injuries caused by motor vehicle accidents occurring on the company parking lot while the employee is commuting to and from work. In the case in question, the employee‘s injury resulted from a motor vehicle accident in the company parking lot while the employee was commuting.
Recordable
Recordable
Recordable
Recordable
Recordable
Recordable
Not Recordable
Not Recordable
Recordable
Recordable
Not Recordable