The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in Dental Clinic (The Silent Hazard)

The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in
Dental Clinic
(The Silent Hazard)
Ass. Prof. Dr. Ameer Hamdi Al-Ameedee
Department of Operative Dentistry,
College of Dentistry / University of Babylon, Babil, Iraq.
dent.ameer.Hamdi@uobabylon.edu.iq

International research concluded
“ Mercury from restorations constitutes the largest non occupational
source of mercury in the general population, being greater than all
environmental sources combined.”
W.H.O. environmental health criteria
Inorganic mercury 1991.

 Mercury is a heavy, silvery-white liquid metal known as quick silver, and its
the only common metal which is liquid at ordinary temperatures.
 A fair conductor of electricity, and poor conductor of heat if compared with
other metals.
Introduction
Gasper JD, Aiken GR, Ryan JN. A critical review of three methods used for the measurement of mercury (Hg 2+)-
dissolved organic matter stability constants. Applied Geochemistry. 2007 Aug 31;22(8):1583-97.
 Mercury (Hg) is a naturally occurring metal and exists in three forms:
elemental (metallic), inorganic, and organic. The form of mercury greatly
influences mercury’s distribution within the body and its health effects.

 Mercury with atomic number 80 a standard atomic weight of 200.59. The
amount of mercury in dental amalgam may be specified as alloy – mercury
ratio=1:1.
 The name comes from Greek name, hydrargyrum, which means "hydr-"
water and "argyros" silver to reflect its shiny surface, it has a silvery tinge
and it, as a liquid, flows quickly .
 It alloys easily with many metals, such as gold, silver, and tin, these alloys
are called amalgams.
Introduction
Phillip’s science of dental materials south east edition 2015

 Mercury was a well-known metal in the ancient time in China, India, and Egypt.
 1500 BC : Found in Egyptian tombs. It was used to prolong life, heal fractures, and
maintain generally good health.
 500 BC : Ancient Greeks-ointments. Ancient Egyptians and Romans- cosmetics
Maya civilization-began making amalgams
History
Gasper JD, Aiken GR, Ryan JN. A critical review of three methods used for the measurement of mercury (Hg 2+)-
dissolved organic matter stability constants. Applied Geochemistry. 2007 Aug 31;22(8):1583-97.

 1 AD :The Roman scholar Pliny described mercury poisoning as a disease of
slaves because mines contaminated by mercury vapour were considered too
unhealthy for Roman citizens.
 659AD Amalgam -- First used by Chinese. There is a mention of silver mercury
paste by Sukung in the Chinese medic
History
Schaefer JK. Biogeochemistry: Better living through mercury. Nature Geoscience. 2016 Jan 18.

 1816:Aguste Taveau of Paris developed was probably the first dental amalgam
by using filings from silver coins mixed with mercury.
 1833:Crawcour brothers brought dental amalgam to the US.
 1900 : Introduction of copper amalgams.
 1956 : Minamata disease officially acknowledged .
History

 2013 The final mercury treaty session took place in Geneva. Treaty requested
countries to phase down the use of dental amalgam.
 2016 The European Union (E.U.), with 28 member nations declared , will
prohibit the use of dental amalgam in children under 16 and in pregnant and
breastfeeding women effective from July 1, 2018.
History
Gasper JD, Aiken GR, Ryan JN. A critical review of three methods used for the measurement of mercury (Hg 2+)-dissolved
organic matter stability constants. Applied Geochemistry. 2007 Aug 31;22(8):1583-97.

Lyman SN, Jaffe DA. Formation and fate of oxidized mercury in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. Nature Geoscience. 2012 Feb
1;5(2):114-7.
 Mercury is a compound that can be found naturally in the environment as metal form,
mercury salts or as organic mercury compounds. Found mainly in cinnabar ore (HgS).
Also present as an impurity in many other minerals, in particular
the non-ferrous metals, and in fossil fuels, coal.
Mercury in the environment
Cinnabar ore
 Easily vaporize in room temperature into an odorless, colorless
vapor that can easily inhaled.

Elemental mercury
Is a shiny, silver-white liquid (quicksilver) primarily obtained from the refining of
mercuric sulfide in cinnabar ore. Elemental mercury usually used in school
science lab and used in dental amalgams, easily vaporizes at room temperature to
an invisible, odorless toxic gas referred to as elemental mercury vapor..
ATSDR. 1999. Toxicological profile for Mercury, 1999. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. Atlanta (GA). Available at http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp46.html

Inorganic mercury
Compounds, or mercury salts, are formed when mercury combines with
other elements such as chlorine (e.g., mercuric chloride), sulfur, or oxygen.
Its exist in two oxidative states— mercurous (+1) and oxide mercuric (+2).
Mercury salts are highly toxic and corrosive, white in color except
cinnabar (Red), enters body through mouth and skin from disinfectant and
fungicide.
ATSDR. 1999. Toxicological profile for Mercury, 1999. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. Atlanta (GA). Available at http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp46.html

Organic mercury
Compounds are formed when inorganic mercury is methylated or
combines with organic agents. The most important organic form of mercury in
terms of human exposure is methylmercury, is formed by anaerobic
methylation of inorganic mercury by microorganisms in sediments. The
primary source of human exposure to mercury is through the consumption of
fish and shellfish containing methylmercury.
FDA, 2006. Mercury in Drug and Biologic Products. US Food and Drug Administration, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. <
http://www.fda.gov/cder/fdama/mercury300.html>

Other forms of organic mercury
May be found in outdated fungicides, antiseptics, and disinfectants. Most of
these uses have been discontinued, however, small amounts of these compounds
may still be found in some medicines.
FDA, 2006. Mercury in Drug and Biologic Products. US Food and Drug Administration, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. <
http://www.fda.gov/cder/fdama/mercury300.html>

Composition of amalgam
 50% Mercury
 35% Silver
 13% Tin
 2% Copper and Zinc
Amalgam most commonly refers to:
 Amalgam (chemistry), mercury alloy.
 Amalgam (dentistry), an alloy that consists chiefly of silver mixed with mercury
and variable amounts of other metals and is used as a dental filling.
 Bonded amalgam, used in dentistry.

 γ1 forms first and then γ2.
 Alloy is mixed with mercury in the ratio of 1:1.
 Mercury is insufficient to completely consume the alloy particles.
 γ1 - Dominant phase – 54-56%.
 Unreacted γ - 27- 35%.
 γ2 - 11-13%

 Easily crosses blood brain barrier and can enter breast milk.
 Potent neurotoxin.
 Neurological effects - tremors , mood swings, irritability, excessive shyness.
 Very high exposure can cause kidney effects, respiratory failure and death.
Risks
 Birth defects.
 Impairment of vision, speech, walking.

Mercury exposure in dental clinic.
Sturdevant's Art and Science of Operative Dentistry South east edition 2013

In 1845, American Society of Dental Surgeons condemned the use of all filling
material other than gold as toxic, thereby igniting. The society went further and
requested members to sign a pledge refusing to use amalgam.
The amalgam controversy-an evidence based analysis ; JADA,Vol.132,march 2001
In mid 1920's a German dentist, Professor A. Stock. He claimed to have evidence
showing that mercury could be absorbed from dental amalgam, which leads to
serious health problems. He also expressed concerns over health of dentists,
stating that nearly all dentists had excess mercury in their urine.

Remarkably, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has separately
approved the mercury and the alloy powder for dental use; but the amalgam
mixture has never been approved as a dental device.
The amalgam controversy-an evidence based analysis ; JADA,Vol.132,march 2001
In 1980 primarily through the seminars and writings of Dr. Huggins. He was
convinced that mercury released from dental amalgam was responsible for
human diseases affecting the cardiovascular system and nervous system.
Also stated that patients claimed recoveries from multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s
disease and other diseases as a result of removing their dental amalgam fillings.

Due to the health effects of mercury exposure, industrial and commercial uses are
regulated in many countries. The World Health Organization (WHO), Occupational Safety
and Health Administration (OSHA), and National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health (NIOSH) all treat mercury as an occupational hazard, and have established
specific occupational exposure limits. Environmental releases and disposal of mercury
are regulated in the U.S. primarily by the United States Environmental Protection Agency.

Amounts of Mercury released
 Trituration : 1-2 μg
 Placement of restorations : 6-8 μg
 Dry Polishing : 44μg
 Wet Polishing : 2.4 μg
 Removal of restorations using water spray and high volume suction : 1.5 - 2μg
 Additional evacuation for 1 minute to remove amalgam dust : 1.5 – 2 μg

Mercury management
 Spills of triturated materials are collected with vacuum aspirator.
 Vapor releases must be cleared by airflow system of room.
 During intra oral placement and condensation procedure rubber dam can be
used to isolate patient and high vacuum evacuation is used.

 Storages location should be near a vent that exhaust air out of the building.
 Before use : Store in a plastic container with threaded cover
 Scrap amalgam, from condensation is stored under water , glycine or spent x
ray fixer and tightly capped jar.
Mercury management

ADA Recommendations for dental mercury
hygiene.
 Train all personnel regarding mercury handling and hazards.
 Make them aware of the potential sources of mercury vapor in the clinic.
 Work in well ventilated spaces with an exhaust.
 Replace air conditioning filters periodically.
 Monitor the dental clinic atmosphere for mercury vapor.

 Design work area properly, and the floor covering should be nonabsorbent,
seamless and easy to clean.
 Use precapsulated alloys.
 Use amalgamator with completely enclosed arm.
 Avoid skin contact with mercury or freshly prepared amalgam.
 Re-cap single use capsules after use if possible.
hygiene.

 Use high volume evacuation while finishing or removing amalgam.
 Salvage and store all scrap amalgam.
 Dispose amalgam scrap and mercury contaminated items as per applicable
regulations.
 Clean up spilled mercury using trap bottles, tape or freshly mixed amalgam.
 Do not use household vacuum cleaner.
 Remove professional clothing before leaving the workplace.
hygiene.

Management of mercury spills
In case of an accidental mercury spill (regardless of size),
 Never use a vacuum cleaner to clean up the mercury.
 Never use household cleaning products to clean up the spill, particularly
those containing ammonia or chlorine.
 Never allow mercury to go down the drain.
 Never use a broom or a paintbrush to clean up the mercury.
 Never allow people whose shoes may be contaminated with mercury to walk
around.
Dental mercury hygiene recommendation. J am Dent Assoc 2003;134:1498.

 Amount of exposure.
 Length of exposure.
 Length of mercury accumulation in body.
 Amount of accumulated mercury.
 Overall health of the patient ( for detoxification).
Toxic effect of Mercury depend on:

Procedure:
Put on the Personal Protective Equipment which is provided in the kit.
 Using the scoop collect the amalgam or mercury waste.
 If it is mercury droplets use the syringe to pick up as many globules, then place
the full syringe in the waste container (provided in the kit).
 Open the container which contains calcium hydroxide and sulphur.
 Tip out onto the spillage area, close the center of the spillage.
 Using the scoop mix the powders with the spilt amalgam or mercury (which you
could not pick up).
 The powder may start to go grey as the mercury is absorbed.
Mercury spillage kit
Spill kits are essential for the management of mercury spills and breakages.
Baughman TA. Elemental mercury spills. Environmental health perspectives. 2006 Feb 1:147-52.

 Brush the contaminated powder into the scoop and place in the waste
container.
 Close the lid on the waste container or sealable bag.
 Dispose of the Personal Protective Equipment in the waste container .
 Label the waste container or bag with ‘hazardous waste sign.
 Contact the licensed waste carrier company you use to remove the hazardous
waste.
 Cleanup of large mercury spills requires experienced environmental personnel.
Mercury spillage kit
Baughman TA. Elemental mercury spills. Environmental health perspectives. 2006 Feb 1:147-52.

Alternatives to Dental Amalgam
 Composite Resin Dental Flling Materials.
 Glass Ionomer Filling.
FDA. "Dental Amalgam" Retrieved 3 April 2014

Effects of Mercury toxicity on the body
Allergy, Contact dermatitis represent the most likely physiologic side effect to
dental amalgam, an alternative material (e.g. Composite or ceramic) must be used.
Phillip’s science of dental materials south east edition 2015 Bernhoft RA. Mercury toxicity and treatment: a review of the literature.
Journal of environmental and public health. 2011 Dec 22;2012
Release of mercury induced an acute reaction which resulted in erythematous
lesions, severe burning and itchy sensation and difficulty in breathing
Bernhoft RA. Mercury toxicity and treatment: a review of the literature. Journal of environmental and public health. 2011 Dec 22;2012.
 The toxic effects of mercury depend on its chemical form and the route of
exposure.

 Ivoclar cention Ivoclar cention

Laboratory Tests
Urine test:A urinary mercury concentration of less than four micrograms per liter
(μg/L) would be considered within the background range.
Wilhelm M, Müller F, Idel H. Biological monitoring of mercury vapour exposure by scalp hair analysis in comparison to blood and urine.
Toxicology letters. 1996 Nov 30;88(1):221-
6

Blood test
 Blood level greater than 10 mcg/L indicates an unusual level of exposure for
someone who does not regularly work with mercury.
 Amount present will decrease by half about every 3 days as the mercury
moves into organs such as the brain and kidneys. Therefore, blood testing
must be done within days of suspected exposure

Inhalation of mercury vapors causes:
Chemical pneumonia, Pulmonary oedema, Gingivostomatitis, Increased salivation.
CNS symptoms like: Ataxia, Restriction of field of vision, Delerium, Polyneuropathy.
Symptomatic patients who have experienced acute high-dose elemental mercury
inhalation exposure should receive supportive care and be monitored for development
of acute pneumonitis and pulmonary edema in a hospital setting.
Hall JL. Cellular mechanisms for heavy metal detoxification and tolerance. Journal of experimental botany. 2009 Jan 1;53(366):1-1.
Mercury can be inhaled and absorbed through the skin and mucousmembranes,
so containers of mercury should be securely sealed to avoid spills and
evaporation.

Ingestion of Mercury
The signs and symptoms start immediately after swallowing the mercury:
 Hot burning pain in mouth, stomach and abdomen.
 Stools are blood stained , urine is suppressed and scanty,contain blood and
albumin is accompanied by necrosis of renal tubules and damage to the
glomeruli.
Houston MC. Role of mercury toxicity in hypertension, cardiovascular disease, and stroke. The Journal of Clinical Hypertension.
2011 Aug 1;13(8):621-7.

 Hoarseness of voice.
 Difficulty in breathing
 Acrid metallic taste in mouth.
 Feeling of constriction or choking of throat.
 Pulse is quick small and irregular.
 Thrombocytopenia and bone marrow depression.
2011 Aug 1;13(8):621-7.
Ingestion of Mercury

Chronic Mercury Poisoning/ Hydrargyrism
 Workers may get poisoned due to vapors or dust.
 When small doses are taken for prolonged time or used as ointment for long
period.
 The signs and symptoms of chronic mercury start at a blood level 100 mg/ml.
 Patient is symptomatic at daily urinary excretion more than 300 mg/ml
2011 Aug 1;13(8):621-7.

Hydrargyrism/ Signs and symptoms
 Excessive salivation with swollen and painful salivary glands.
 Foul smelling breathing, inflamed and ulcerated gums with brownish blue line
and loosening of teeth.
 Mercura lentis: A brownish reflex from the anterior lens capsule
of both the eyes is seen when observed in slit lamp in person
exposed to mercury vapors for some years. It is bilateral and has
no effect on the visual acuity.

Houston MC. Role of mercury toxicity in hypertension, cardiovascular disease, and stroke. The Journal of Clinical Hypertension. 2011 Aug
1;13(8):621-7.
Oral cavity problems
 Inflammation of the mouth.
 Loss of bone around teeth.
 Ulcerated gums and other areas in the mouth.
 Darkening of gums.
 Taste of metal.
 Bleeding gums.

Acrodynia (Pink disease)
 There is generalized rashes over the body.
 Results from chronic exposure to mercury in any forms.
 Erythematous, eczematous (watery and weeping) popular type of skin lesion.
 Mostly in the hands and feet accompanied with thickening of skin.
Tunnessen WW, McMahon KJ, Baser M. Acrodynia: exposure to mercury from fluorescent light bulbs. Pediatrics. 1987 May
1;79(5):786-9.

Hunter-Russell syndrome
 The term Hunter-Russell syndrome derives from a study of mercury poisoning among
workers in a seed packing factory in England in the late 1930s who breathed methyl
mercury that was being used as a seed disinfectant and preservative.
 Syndrome is characterized by paresthesia, visual field constriction, ataxia, impaired
hearing, and speech impairment.
Tokuomi H, Kinoshita Y, Teramoto J, Imanishi K. Hunter-Russell syndrome. Nihon rinsho.Japanese journal of clinical medicine. 2004
Dec;35:518-9.

Erethism
(Mad hatter disease, or mad hatter syndrome)
 In 19th century, inorganic mercury in the form of mercuric nitrate was commonly
used in the production of hats.
 It caused a slow release of volatile free mercury.
 Erethism commonly characterized by behavioral changes such as irritability, low
self-confidence, depression, apathy, shyness and timidity.
 In some extreme cases delirium personality changes and memory loss occur.
Waldron HA (2003). "Did the Mad Hatter have mercury poisoning?" British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition). 287
(6409): doi:10.1136/bmj .287.6409.1961. PMC 1550196. PMID 6418283. FDA. "Dental Amalgam" Retrieved 3 April 2014

Analyzing Hair
 Hair analysis primarily measures organic (methyl) mercury exposure only and is not
useful for assessing recent exposures.
 In cases of occupational exposure to mercury vapour, hair is an useful tool for
monitoring external exposure.
 Hair may be used as an indicator of internal uptake
of mercury provided that it was not externally
exposed to mercury vapour.
Wilhelm M, Müller F, Idel H. Biological monitoring of mercury vapour exposure by scalp hair analysis in comparison to blood and urine.
Toxicology letters. 1996 Nov . 88:30(1) 221-6

Conclusion
Mercury and its compounds are toxic and should be handled with care.
Mercury is treated by most international bodies as a hazard and toxic compound.
The organomercury compounds and Mercury crosses the blood-brain barrier to
cause nervous breakdown, tremors and suicidal tendency.
It use for some medicinal, electrical and cosmetic purpose have been banned in
some countries around in the world.
Mercury poison can be treated with Chelating therapy.
Soil and sediments can be decontaminated by phytoremediation.

The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in Dental Clinic (The Silent Hazard)

The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in Dental Clinic (The Silent Hazard)

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (20)

Similar to The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in Dental Clinic (The Silent Hazard)

Similar to The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in Dental Clinic (The Silent Hazard) (20)

More from Ameer Al-Ameedee

More from Ameer Al-Ameedee (16)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

The Safety Use of Mercury Restoration in Dental Clinic (The Silent Hazard)