Energy Management and the
Evolution of Intelligent Motor
Control and Drives
Craig Resnick
Research Director
ARC Advisory G...
2
© ARC Advisory Group
Energy Management and the Evolution of
Intelligent Motor Control and Drives
• Intelligent motor con...
3
© ARC Advisory Group
Energy Management and the Evolution of
Intelligent Motor Control and Drives
• This session will add...
4
© ARC Advisory Group
Energy Management and the Evolution of
Intelligent Motor Control and Drives
• Users of electrical p...
5
© ARC Advisory Group
Energy Management and the Evolution of
Intelligent Motor Control and Drives
• ARC conducted a best ...
6
© ARC Advisory Group
Are you an end user of Electrical Systems (ES), OEM, or
Systems Integrator?
 A vast majority of th...
7
© ARC Advisory Group
What is your industry?
 Industry split between refining, petrochemical,
chemical, and power genera...
8
© ARC Advisory Group
What region are you in?
 North America dominated the respondents,
indicating that this is a bigger...
9
© ARC Advisory Group
Approximately, how many industrial plants/facilities does
your company operate that contain electri...
10
© ARC Advisory Group
When a new Electrical System/Equipment is installed in a
facility, what to you expect the operable...
11
© ARC Advisory Group
Approximately, what is the average age of
installed Electrical Systems in your Company?
 65 perce...
12
© ARC Advisory Group
Do you consider the supplier's published obsolescence date, the date which
repair of components & ...
13
© ARC Advisory Group
Have you utilized electrical equipment or systems beyond
the supplier's stated obsolescence date? ...
14
© ARC Advisory Group
Do you use a standard lifecycle criteria
when accepting new Electrical Equipment?
 A surprising n...
15
© ARC Advisory Group
Indicate the practices you use for justification for
upgrade projects for your Electrical Equipmen...
16
© ARC Advisory Group
Do you have an Electrical System Lifecycle
Management Policy?
 Somewhat surprising how many of th...
17
© ARC Advisory Group
Which of the following is most likely to trigger upgrade
planning for your Electrical Equipment/Sy...
18
© ARC Advisory Group
Do you conduct System/Equipment
condition assessment before the upgrade?
 Conducting a Systems/Eq...
19
© ARC Advisory Group
Considering that a typical Electrical System is made up of multiple layers or
subsystems with diff...
20
© ARC Advisory Group
Survey Conclusions
• The sizeable and rapidly aging installed base must be
upgraded, but managemen...
Thank You
For more information, contact the author at
cresnick@arcweb.com or visit our web pages at
www.arcweb.com
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives @ ARC's 2011 Industry Forum

692 views

Published on


Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives @ ARC's 2011 Industry Forum by Craig Resnick.
Intelligent motor control & drives once provided a safe, flexible & centralized means to control & protect motors
•Today, these devices have evolved to ‘smart’ energy managers that bring advances ranging from complex drive systems to basic control of fan or pump motors
•In high demand where uptime & equipment reliability are critical, in applications where even a short period of downtime can prove extremely costly & damaging
•These devices perform critical protective & troubleshooting functions & detailed diagnostics to help improve productivity & minimize downtime

Published in: Technology, Business
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives @ ARC's 2011 Industry Forum

  1. 1. Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives Craig Resnick Research Director ARC Advisory Group cresnick@arcweb.com
  2. 2. 2 © ARC Advisory Group Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives • Intelligent motor control & drives once provided a safe, flexible & centralized means to control & protect motors • Today, these devices have evolved to ‘smart’ energy managers that bring advances ranging from complex drive systems to basic control of fan or pump motors • In high demand where uptime & equipment reliability are critical, in applications where even a short period of downtime can prove extremely costly & damaging • These devices perform critical protective & troubleshooting functions & detailed diagnostics to help improve productivity & minimize downtime
  3. 3. 3 © ARC Advisory Group Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives • This session will address advances in intelligent motor control and drives technology • How devices leverage real-time monitoring & integration into plant-wide networks • Session is designed for end users, equipment suppliers, and engineering service firms • Those interested in Motor Control, Drives and Energy Management Success Stories, as well as all types of Electrical Power Systems
  4. 4. 4 © ARC Advisory Group Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives • Users of electrical power systems have struggled with the issue of determining when the useful lives of their systems are over • Since these systems are crucial to the success of operations from so many aspects, having a strategy based on best practices is essential • Modern electrical power systems are comprised of many components that each have different life expectancies, ranging from 5-50 years
  5. 5. 5 © ARC Advisory Group Energy Management and the Evolution of Intelligent Motor Control and Drives • ARC conducted a best practices web survey for electrical power systems that have extended their life far beyond the original expectation • Final results of web survey is based on 131 responses from end users, OEMs, & SIs • The purpose of the survey is to determine the current state of the market is & how it relates to electrical power systems best practices
  6. 6. 6 © ARC Advisory Group Are you an end user of Electrical Systems (ES), OEM, or Systems Integrator?  A vast majority of the comments came from end users, demonstrating that the subject of Electrical Power Systems Lifecycle Management is getting quite a bit of attention at the plant level and visibility with upper management
  7. 7. 7 © ARC Advisory Group What is your industry?  Industry split between refining, petrochemical, chemical, and power generation, which will provide a good representation of a similar scale of businesses and operations with common issues and challenges  Other industries represented include cement & glass, upstream oil & gas, automotive, and aerospace
  8. 8. 8 © ARC Advisory Group What region are you in?  North America dominated the respondents, indicating that this is a bigger issue for older, established plants and not yet on the priority lists of newer plants in developing countries, especially in China and Eastern Europe
  9. 9. 9 © ARC Advisory Group Approximately, how many industrial plants/facilities does your company operate that contain electric power systems?  Interesting that the companies with the most plants had the most interest in this survey, but the issues also strongly resonated with companies with a single plant as well as the mid-size companies with 11-20 plants
  10. 10. 10 © ARC Advisory Group When a new Electrical System/Equipment is installed in a facility, what to you expect the operable lifecycle of the system and equipment/components to be?  Transformers had by far the longest lifecycle expectation (>40 years), followed by Switchgear and Motor Control Centers. Uninterruptable Power Systems and Variable Speed Drives had the shortest lifecycle expectations (<15 years)
  11. 11. 11 © ARC Advisory Group Approximately, what is the average age of installed Electrical Systems in your Company?  65 percent of the respondent's installed systems were between the ages on 11 and 30 years old, demonstrating that this is the time period where lifecycle management is most prevalent on the plant’s priority lists
  12. 12. 12 © ARC Advisory Group Do you consider the supplier's published obsolescence date, the date which repair of components & technical support is no longer offered by the supplier, to be the date an electrical system or equipment is considered obsolete?  A mixed opinion regarding published obsolescence dates, with some companies feeling that if the secondary market and third parties can support the product, as well as their own inventory of parts and components, then the product is not considered obsolete
  13. 13. 13 © ARC Advisory Group Have you utilized electrical equipment or systems beyond the supplier's stated obsolescence date? If yes, how long?  Virtually all respondents use their electrical equipment beyond the stated obsolescence date, with the majority exceeding that date by between 1-5, 5-10, and over 10 years, with the feeling that the obsolescence date is supplier - biased towards shortening product lifecycle
  14. 14. 14 © ARC Advisory Group Do you use a standard lifecycle criteria when accepting new Electrical Equipment?  A surprising number of companies had no standard lifecycle criteria when accepting new equipment, and many others just relied on the minimum MTBF/MTTR information provided by the suppliers as the standard lifecycle criteria
  15. 15. 15 © ARC Advisory Group Indicate the practices you use for justification for upgrade projects for your Electrical Equipment/Systems  Practices for upgrade justification varied somewhat evenly between Lost Production, Failure Costs, and Failure Frequency, with Improved Performance and Obsolescence slightly behind. However, Amortized Costs were virtually not a significant end of life factor at all
  16. 16. 16 © ARC Advisory Group Do you have an Electrical System Lifecycle Management Policy?  Somewhat surprising how many of the respondent’s companies had no official electrical system lifecycle management policy, relying on the individual opinions of plant personnel for decision making criteria
  17. 17. 17 © ARC Advisory Group Which of the following is most likely to trigger upgrade planning for your Electrical Equipment/Systems?  The most common factor to trigger upgrade planning is lost production, because it gets the most attention of the plant personnel and visibility of management, making it easier to financially justify getting capital funds approved
  18. 18. 18 © ARC Advisory Group Do you conduct System/Equipment condition assessment before the upgrade?  Conducting a Systems/Equipment condition assessment before an upgrade is an essential step, especially to take advantage of the scheduled downtime by upgrading all that needs to be done to best prevent potential future unscheduled downtime incidents
  19. 19. 19 © ARC Advisory Group Considering that a typical Electrical System is made up of multiple layers or subsystems with different life expectancies, would you or have you planned on wholesale migration to a new Electrical System or would you do in phases  Strong response that any Electrical Systems migration would be performed in phases, in a scalable fashion, designed to minimize any lost production time, regardless of the number of layers, subsystems, or different equipment life cycles of the existing systems
  20. 20. 20 © ARC Advisory Group Survey Conclusions • The sizeable and rapidly aging installed base must be upgraded, but management will only approve projects that have specific beneficial econometrics • For justification & approval to upgrade electrical power systems, with scarce CAPEX funds, emphasize the costs of lost production, the cost of failure, energy savings ROI • Getting justification based simply on upgrading to the latest version is not a successful strategy, or even trying to use argument regarding equipment obsolescence • Leverage the success stories from Woodard and Curran & MGM Resorts International to help you with the justification needed to upgrade MCCs and Drives
  21. 21. Thank You For more information, contact the author at cresnick@arcweb.com or visit our web pages at www.arcweb.com

×