Paper presented at "Spatial Variation in Energy Use, Attitudes and Behaviours: Implications for Smart Grids and Energy Demand", Policy Studies Institute, Friday, 7 February 2014, London, United Kingdom
Interactive Powerpoint_How to Master effective communication
Small Area Estimation as a tool for thinking about spatial variation in energy demand
1. Small Area Estimation as a tool for thinking about
spatial variation in energy demand
Dr Ben Anderson
Sustainable Energy Research Centre
University of Southampton
@dataknut
Spatial Variation in Energy Use, Attitudes and Behaviours:
Implications for Smart Grids and Energy Demand
Policy Studies Institute, London: 7 February 2014
2. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Contents
What & Why
How?
Results
– Overall consumption
– Consumption inequalities
Conclusions & future Directions
@dataknut
2
3. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Contents
What & Why
How?
?
Results
– Overall consumption
– Consumption inequalities
Conclusions & future Directions
@dataknut
3
4. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Digression: Geography
Southampton (UK)
@dataknut
4
5. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Digression: What‟s a small area?
In this case…
– English Lower Layer
Super Output Areas
– Census 200/2011
LSOAs
– c. 630 households each
– 148 in Southampton City
@dataknut
5
6. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
What & Why
Basically we want something for nothing
– Small area estimates of energy demand
– Without a bespoke energy census
Why?
–
–
–
–
@dataknut
Infrastructure planning
Energy efficiency intervention analysis
Energy inequality analysis
Politics!
6
7. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
The problem:
Small area summaries exist
But they are aggregates
– Or averages
– Or profiled
And we want a micro-level simulation model to
assess the socio-economic and spatial impact of
Price changes
Incentive changes
‘Efficiency’ interventions
Changes in ‘energy habits’ (appliances & practices)
Socio-demographic change
@dataknut
7
8. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
What can we do?
A bespoke energy census
– ££££££££££££££££££££
@dataknut
8
9. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
What can we do?
A bespoke energy census
– ££££££££££££££££££££
A large sample energy survey covering all
LSOAs
– ££££££££££
@dataknut
9
10. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
What can we do?
A bespoke energy census
– ££££££££££££££££££££
A large sample energy survey covering all LSOAs
– ££££££££££
Small Area Estimation
– Take existing area level data
– Take (ideally) an existing large n survey
– Combine £
@dataknut
10
11. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Small Area Estimation
Econometric approaches
Income, income deprivation,
income inequality
smoking prevalence,
obesity,
consumption expenditure,
CO2, water…
– Well known
– Multi-level Models
– Usually requires census microdata for anything other
Innovation Network:
than means
“Evaluating and improving small area
estimation methods”
Re-weighting (and other) approaches
– Increasingly http://eprints.ncrm.ac.uk/3210/
well known
– 'Spatial microsimulation'
– Does not require census microdata
@dataknut
11
12. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Contents
What & Why
Estimation
How?
Results
– Overall consumption
– Consumption inequalities
Conclusions & Future Directions
@dataknut
12
13. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Data
Data
– Living Costs and Food Survey 2008-2010
Consumption proxies (reported energy expenditure)
– Census 2001 (2011)
Projection/forecasting
– Projected ‘surveys’ -> 2021
– Projected ‘census’ -> 2021
So far…
@dataknut
13
14. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Conceptually…
LSOA census ‘constraint’ tables
Survey data cases
If Region = 1
LSOA 1.1
(Region1)
If Region = 2
@dataknut
Weights
LSOA 2.1
(Region2)
Iterative Proportional Fitting
Ballas et al (2005)
14
15. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Key First Job:
Choose your constraints
Census data
Survey data
You may have little choice
@dataknut
15
16. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Key First Job:
LSOA census ‘constraint’ tables
The constraints
– Selected by stepwise regression
Expenditure
Number of persons
Employment Status
Accommodation type
Number of earners
Age of HRP
Age of HRP
Employment Status
Most important
Share of expenditure
Composition
Number of rooms
Number of children
Least important
R sq
@dataknut
Ethnicity (non-white)
0.136
0.01
16
17. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
„Iterative Proportional Fitting‟
Well known!
Deming and Stephan 1940
– Fienberg 1970; Wong 1992
A way of iteratively adjusting statistical tables
– To give known margins (row/column totals)
– ‘Raking’
In this case
– Create weights for each case so LSOA totals ‘fit’
constraints
– Weighting ‘down’
@dataknut
17
18. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Internal Validation methods
Use of constraints to re-create the Census
tables
Difference = Absolute Error
–
–
Total Absolute Error (TAE) = sum of all
errors
Standardised AE = TAE/(n persons x n
constraint categories)
Smith et al:
–
SAE of less than 20% and ideally less
than 10%
–
Consumption
Mean SAE
p90
Ethnicity
2.18%
3.05%
Number of children
0.11%
0.22%
Number of rooms
0.05%
0.10%
Employment status
(HRP)
0.88%
1.22%
Age (HRP)
0.34%
0.75%
Tenure
0.07%
0.14%
Accomodation type
0.21%
0.51%
Number of persons
0.00%
0.00%
in 90% of the areas is desirable.
@dataknut
18
19. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Preliminary results: Electricity
Mean weekly
household £
Modelled
Census 2001
LC&F Survey 20082010
@dataknut
19
20. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Validation: Electricity
Mean weekly
household £
Observed @LSOA
–
DECC 2010
Spearman: 0.317
@dataknut
20
21. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Preliminary results: Electricity
Total weekly household £
Modelled
Census 2001
LC&F Survey 2008-2010
@dataknut
21
22. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Validation: Electricity
Total weekly household £
Observed @LSOA
–
DECC 2010
Spearman: 0.509
@dataknut
22
23. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
What is causing the error?
Heating!
–
@dataknut
2011 data
23
24. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
What is causing the error?
Housing growth
Combined:
–
–
@dataknut
Heating = 60%
Growth = 5%
24
25. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Consumption inequality
Area level gini
£ mean spend
R = -0.413
–
@dataknut
(p < 0.001)
25
26. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Consumption inequality
Area level gini
Index of Multiple
Deprivation 2010
–
Income score
R = 0.463
–
@dataknut
(p < 0.001)
26
27. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
My big worry
Data quality
Source: SPRG/ARCC-Water Survey, 2011
www.sprg.ac.uk
@dataknut
27
28. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Contents
What & Why
How?
Results
– Overall consumption
– Consumption inequalities
Conclusions & Future Directions
@dataknut
28
29. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Conclusions
Outliers and errors are informative
Reported consumption data
– Could be dangerous
Census 2011 central heating
– Critical new constraint
@dataknut
29
30. Small Area Estimates of Electricity Consumption
Future directions
Update for 2011 data
Census projection 1981 -> 2021
Use measured energy consumption
– New survey data?
Contact:
– b.anderson@soton.ac.uk
@dataknut
30
Editor's Notes
Data from SPRG linked water demand survey2 implications:Error in the estimates (spurious correlation with constraints)Error in any policy microsimulation