SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
Separation of Powers Review
Federalist #51 	“Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.  The interest of the man must be connected with the constitutional rights of the place.  It may be a reflection on human nature that such devices should be necessary to control the abuses of government.  But what is government itself but the greatest of all reflections on human nature?  If men were angels, no government would be necessary.  If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.” --James Madison (Publius), Federalist #51
Separation of Powers The division of powers among several institutions that must cooperate in decision or policy-making The allocation of constitutional authority to each of the three branches of government With different responsibilities Different powers Different constituencies, which makes them accountable to different groups of people Different terms of service
Distribution of Power Founders assumed that the Legislative Branch is most powerful. ,[object Object]
The other branches depend on Congress for much of their authority.Today– many think of the Executive Branch has having the most power. ,[object Object]
Increasing powers of the president
Increasing legislative influence of the White House.,[object Object]
Fig. 2.2
FEDERALISM
Types of power arrangements Unitary governments Confederation governments Federal governments
Federalism and the American Founding 	The balance of power between the central government and the states was at the heart of the constitutional struggle between the Federalists and the Antifederalists.
Federalism and the American Founding 	Although the Federalists won the struggle over ratification, the federal balance of power remained contested and paradoxical throughout American history and was at the heart of struggles throughout American history such as: 	1. the ability of states to “nullify” federal laws; 	2. the Civil War; 	3. the power of the central government in the New Deal; 	4. the “rights” of states vs. the rights of citizens in the Civil Rights Movement.
Federalism and the American Founding 	“[If] the people should in the future become more partial to the federal than to the State governments … the people ought not surely to be precluded from giving most of their confidence where they may discover it to be most due.” --James Madison (Publius) Federalist #46
National Government Powers Expressed powers collect taxes coin money  declare war Implied powers The “necessary and proper” powers the national government from their implication in the Constitution State Government Powers Reserved powers “police powers” (the powers to regulate the health, safety, and morals of its citizens) 10th Amendment
	10th Amendment 	“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”
Stages of Federalism There have  been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789                                 1937                     1960            1970           1990 “DUAL 						           FEDERALISM”
Stages of Federalism There have  been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789                                 1937                     1960            1970           1990 “DUAL                  II. “COOPERATIVE                                          FEDERALISM”          FEDERALISM”
Fig. 3.2 top
Stages of Federalism There have  been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789                                 1937                     1960            1970           1990 I. “DUAL                  II. “COOPERATIVE    III. “REGULATED   FEDERALISM”           FEDERALISM”           FEDERALISM

More Related Content

What's hot

Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016WestCal Academy
 
Political philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and Leaders
Political philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and LeadersPolitical philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and Leaders
Political philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and Leadersfreealan
 
Abernathy2e full ppt02_edited
Abernathy2e full ppt02_editedAbernathy2e full ppt02_edited
Abernathy2e full ppt02_editedJohn Seymour
 
Hist 2111 final powerpoint
Hist 2111 final powerpointHist 2111 final powerpoint
Hist 2111 final powerpointParisa Lynn
 
PO 101 Political Culture
PO 101 Political Culture PO 101 Political Culture
PO 101 Political Culture atrantham
 
POL 205 Political Culture
POL 205 Political Culture POL 205 Political Culture
POL 205 Political Culture Austin Trantham
 
Chapter 5 and 6: The United States Constitution
Chapter 5 and 6: The United States ConstitutionChapter 5 and 6: The United States Constitution
Chapter 5 and 6: The United States Constitutionphillipgrogers
 
WORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE
WORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCEWORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE
WORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCEFaHaD .H. NooR
 
10th Grade History Chapter 2
10th Grade History Chapter 210th Grade History Chapter 2
10th Grade History Chapter 2Bigcountry54
 
Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2
Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2
Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2MGP1978
 
The Triumph of the Jeffersonians
The Triumph of the JeffersoniansThe Triumph of the Jeffersonians
The Triumph of the JeffersoniansTom Richey
 
PO 101 American Founding and Constitution
PO 101 American Founding and Constitution PO 101 American Founding and Constitution
PO 101 American Founding and Constitution atrantham
 
Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016WestCal Academy
 
Sovereignity and human rights
Sovereignity and human rightsSovereignity and human rights
Sovereignity and human rightsMoses Mbanje
 
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4John Paul Tabakian
 
The American Revolution 2
The American Revolution 2The American Revolution 2
The American Revolution 2Cory Schiefer
 
Foundations of Government
Foundations of GovernmentFoundations of Government
Foundations of Governmentengdkyl
 

What's hot (20)

Tabakian Pols 5 PP3 Fall 2014
Tabakian Pols 5 PP3 Fall 2014Tabakian Pols 5 PP3 Fall 2014
Tabakian Pols 5 PP3 Fall 2014
 
Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 3 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
 
Political philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and Leaders
Political philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and LeadersPolitical philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and Leaders
Political philosophy behind Constitution, Federalist Papers, and Leaders
 
Abernathy2e full ppt02_edited
Abernathy2e full ppt02_editedAbernathy2e full ppt02_edited
Abernathy2e full ppt02_edited
 
Hist 2111 final powerpoint
Hist 2111 final powerpointHist 2111 final powerpoint
Hist 2111 final powerpoint
 
PO 101 Political Culture
PO 101 Political Culture PO 101 Political Culture
PO 101 Political Culture
 
POL 205 Political Culture
POL 205 Political Culture POL 205 Political Culture
POL 205 Political Culture
 
Chapter 5 and 6: The United States Constitution
Chapter 5 and 6: The United States ConstitutionChapter 5 and 6: The United States Constitution
Chapter 5 and 6: The United States Constitution
 
WORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE
WORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCEWORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE
WORLD ORDER AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE
 
10th Grade History Chapter 2
10th Grade History Chapter 210th Grade History Chapter 2
10th Grade History Chapter 2
 
Founding Principles
Founding PrinciplesFounding Principles
Founding Principles
 
Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2
Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2
Mp contemporary american and exceptionalism 1 2
 
The Triumph of the Jeffersonians
The Triumph of the JeffersoniansThe Triumph of the Jeffersonians
The Triumph of the Jeffersonians
 
PO 101 American Founding and Constitution
PO 101 American Founding and Constitution PO 101 American Founding and Constitution
PO 101 American Founding and Constitution
 
Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 2 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
 
Dictatorship
DictatorshipDictatorship
Dictatorship
 
Sovereignity and human rights
Sovereignity and human rightsSovereignity and human rights
Sovereignity and human rights
 
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #4
 
The American Revolution 2
The American Revolution 2The American Revolution 2
The American Revolution 2
 
Foundations of Government
Foundations of GovernmentFoundations of Government
Foundations of Government
 

Similar to Chapt 3

History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docxHistory Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docxsimonithomas47935
 
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docxHistory Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docxpooleavelina
 
252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx
252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx
252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docxtamicawaysmith
 
1787 Compromise And Federalist Ch2
1787 Compromise And Federalist Ch21787 Compromise And Federalist Ch2
1787 Compromise And Federalist Ch2lafenix
 
Early American Government
Early American GovernmentEarly American Government
Early American Governmentdficker
 
I need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdf
I need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdfI need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdf
I need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdfarvindarora20042013
 
Constitution and federalism
Constitution and federalismConstitution and federalism
Constitution and federalismjonathanmpowell
 
Gov't foundations ii
Gov't foundations iiGov't foundations ii
Gov't foundations iiMolly Lynde
 
Federalist papers lesson plan student copy
Federalist papers lesson plan student copyFederalist papers lesson plan student copy
Federalist papers lesson plan student copyBlake Harris
 
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10John Paul Tabakian
 

Similar to Chapt 3 (13)

History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docxHistory Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
 
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docxHistory Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
History Week 4Classmate response #1What issues did the new go.docx
 
Federalists Essays
Federalists EssaysFederalists Essays
Federalists Essays
 
252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx
252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx
252018 3. Federalism U.S. v. The States, Topic Overview.docx
 
Jurisdiction: Acting Like States
Jurisdiction: Acting Like StatesJurisdiction: Acting Like States
Jurisdiction: Acting Like States
 
1787 Compromise And Federalist Ch2
1787 Compromise And Federalist Ch21787 Compromise And Federalist Ch2
1787 Compromise And Federalist Ch2
 
Early American Government
Early American GovernmentEarly American Government
Early American Government
 
I need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdf
I need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdfI need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdf
I need help answering these Summarize Madison’s central arguments i.pdf
 
Constitution and federalism
Constitution and federalismConstitution and federalism
Constitution and federalism
 
Gov't foundations ii
Gov't foundations iiGov't foundations ii
Gov't foundations ii
 
Federalist papers lesson plan student copy
Federalist papers lesson plan student copyFederalist papers lesson plan student copy
Federalist papers lesson plan student copy
 
Essay On Federalism
Essay On FederalismEssay On Federalism
Essay On Federalism
 
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10
Political Science 1 - Introduction To Political Science - Power Point #10
 

More from Emily Neff-Sharum (17)

Lecture 11 13 women president
Lecture 11 13 women presidentLecture 11 13 women president
Lecture 11 13 women president
 
Lecture women president
Lecture women presidentLecture women president
Lecture women president
 
Women congress
Women congressWomen congress
Women congress
 
WP Lecture1 introduction
WP Lecture1 introductionWP Lecture1 introduction
WP Lecture1 introduction
 
17 courts online
17 courts online17 courts online
17 courts online
 
Chapt 13 media
Chapt 13 mediaChapt 13 media
Chapt 13 media
 
Chapt 12 interest groups
Chapt 12 interest groupsChapt 12 interest groups
Chapt 12 interest groups
 
Political parties
Political partiesPolitical parties
Political parties
 
Public opinion
Public opinionPublic opinion
Public opinion
 
Public opinion
Public opinionPublic opinion
Public opinion
 
Elections
ElectionsElections
Elections
 
Bureaucracy
BureaucracyBureaucracy
Bureaucracy
 
Presidency ii
Presidency iiPresidency ii
Presidency ii
 
Presidency i
Presidency iPresidency i
Presidency i
 
Chapt 4
Chapt 4Chapt 4
Chapt 4
 
Chapt 2
Chapt 2Chapt 2
Chapt 2
 
Chapt 1
Chapt 1Chapt 1
Chapt 1
 

Chapt 3

  • 2. Federalist #51 “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition. The interest of the man must be connected with the constitutional rights of the place. It may be a reflection on human nature that such devices should be necessary to control the abuses of government. But what is government itself but the greatest of all reflections on human nature? If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.” --James Madison (Publius), Federalist #51
  • 3. Separation of Powers The division of powers among several institutions that must cooperate in decision or policy-making The allocation of constitutional authority to each of the three branches of government With different responsibilities Different powers Different constituencies, which makes them accountable to different groups of people Different terms of service
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6. Increasing powers of the president
  • 7.
  • 10. Types of power arrangements Unitary governments Confederation governments Federal governments
  • 11. Federalism and the American Founding The balance of power between the central government and the states was at the heart of the constitutional struggle between the Federalists and the Antifederalists.
  • 12. Federalism and the American Founding Although the Federalists won the struggle over ratification, the federal balance of power remained contested and paradoxical throughout American history and was at the heart of struggles throughout American history such as: 1. the ability of states to “nullify” federal laws; 2. the Civil War; 3. the power of the central government in the New Deal; 4. the “rights” of states vs. the rights of citizens in the Civil Rights Movement.
  • 13. Federalism and the American Founding “[If] the people should in the future become more partial to the federal than to the State governments … the people ought not surely to be precluded from giving most of their confidence where they may discover it to be most due.” --James Madison (Publius) Federalist #46
  • 14. National Government Powers Expressed powers collect taxes coin money declare war Implied powers The “necessary and proper” powers the national government from their implication in the Constitution State Government Powers Reserved powers “police powers” (the powers to regulate the health, safety, and morals of its citizens) 10th Amendment
  • 15. 10th Amendment “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”
  • 16. Stages of Federalism There have been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789 1937 1960 1970 1990 “DUAL FEDERALISM”
  • 17. Stages of Federalism There have been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789 1937 1960 1970 1990 “DUAL II. “COOPERATIVE FEDERALISM” FEDERALISM”
  • 19. Stages of Federalism There have been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789 1937 1960 1970 1990 I. “DUAL II. “COOPERATIVE III. “REGULATED FEDERALISM” FEDERALISM” FEDERALISM
  • 20.
  • 21. Stages of Federalism There have been FOUR STAGES OF FEDERALISM throughout American history. 1789 1937 1960 1970 1990 I. “DUAL II. “COOPERATIVE III. “REGULATED IV. “NEW FEDERALISM” FEDERALISM” FEDERALISM FEDERALISM”
  • 22. State to State Relationships Full Faith and Credit Privileges and Immunities Extradition

Editor's Notes

  1. Bobby Knight…. When his team is playing in Puerto Rico, he hit a ref when blowing up about a call… P.R. asks for extradition– but Indiana refuses.