How Letters of Credit Work  NACM Oregon/CMA Business Credit Learning Center Webinar May 21, 2009 Buddy Baker, Head of Trade Services Sales Fifth Third Bank [email_address] (847) 830-3038 If you can read this, your settings are not optimal for printing this presentation and will draw certain graphics incorrectly.  Please re-print using the “Color” setting, even if printing using a black & white printer. (…and Why They Sometimes Don’t)
NOTE: This set of slides contains animation and “builds” designed to be viewed in Slide Show mode.  Please switch to Slide Show mode.  Printing the slides may produce partially obstructed slides and slides with missing elements.  If your desire is to review the presentation on paper, when in the print dialog, choose “Print range: Custom Show: Handouts” and check “Print hidden slides.”  Choose the “Color” setting, even if printing in black & white.
Walter (Buddy) Baker   Walter (Buddy) Baker has over 30 years of experience in international trade finance. In May 2009 he joined Fifth Third Bank as the head of their Trade Services Sales team. Prior to Fifth Third, Buddy worked for Atradius Trade Credit Insurance, ABN AMRO Bank, Bank of America, Wachovia Bank, and The First National Bank of Chicago. Buddy is a recognized expert in trade finance and author of numerous magazine articles and the books  Users’ Handbook to Documentary Credits under UCP600 ,  Documentary Payments & Short-Term Trade Finance , and  The Regulatory Environment of Letters of Credit and Trade Finance . He owns the consulting firm Global Trade Risk Management Strategies, which specializes in educational training, and makes frequent presentations for national associations of exporters, importers, bankers and lawyers.  Mr. Baker serves as a member-at-large of the National Letter of Credit Committee of the International Financial Services Association and is actively involved in establishing national and worldwide standard practices for LCs, such as the recent revision of the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (referred to as UCP600), the official ICC guide for examining letter of credit documents, called the International Standard Banking Practices for the Examination of Documents under Documentary Credits, the eUCP supplement to the UCP dealing with electronic documents, the International Standby Practices, and Article 5 of the Uniform Commercial Code. He acts as an advisor to the Wolfsberg Group, an international group that includes most of the largest banks in the world whose purpose is to set standards for combating money laundering, and to the Institute for International Banking Law and Practice.  Buddy also serves on the Advisory Council of the Finance Credit and International Business Association (FCIB), a multinational association of export credit managers.  Buddy earned his undergraduate degree at Yale University and his MBA at Northwestern.  He can be reached at (847) 830-3038 or  [email_address] .
How L/Cs  Are Supposed to Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
When Might a Letter of Credit Drawing Not Be Paid? Expired L/C Discrepancies Political or economic event Fraud/injunction L/C issued during bankruptcy preference period, covering pre-existing debt Insolvent bank, liquidated May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
What Is a Letter of Credit? An assurance of payment? A guarantee? A security interest? Conditional or unconditional? May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker A letter of credit is a bank’s own engagement to make payment of a specified amount upon presentation of specified documents
Definition Letter of Credit   an undertaking, usually on the part of a bank and at the request of one of the bank’s customers, to pay a named beneficiary a specified amount of money (or to deliver an item of value) if the beneficiary presents documents in accordance with the terms and conditions specified in the letter of credit. May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Uses of Letters of Credit Intended means of payment for goods Secondary means of payment for goods (if buyer fails to pay directly) Bid bond (seller is applicant) Performance bond/warranty (seller is applicant) Advance payment guarantee (seller is applicant) Loan repayment Direct loan repayment (bond enhancement) etc., etc., etc. May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Contract Buyer’s Bank Letter of Credit Application
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Contract Buyer’s Bank Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit 3 parties 3 independent contracts
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit Principles of Letters of Credit: Independent  and Documentary Goods Documents
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Letter of Credit Goods Payment
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Letter of Credit Goods Documents Payment Debit
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Goods
Risk Mitigation Techniques May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 1. It may be possible for the applicant to obtain a court injunction to stop payment of a non-negotiable L/C. 7. A receivable in a foreign currency made be sold, including the remaining currency fluctuation risk.  8.   FX exposure depends on the currency of the credit.
A Typical Export L/C May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Prepared MAR08/07  14:21 KEY:  SWIN 9603000708914700 SEQ NO: 960308500050 RECEIVED FROM: ABN AMRO BANK N.V., SINGAPORE BRANCH SINGAPORE Authentication: CORRECT : 1 :basic header : F 01 LASLUS44BXXX  1448  170261 : 2 :application  : 0 700 1519 968300 ABNASCSCAXXX  2456 743J92 960308 0709 N message type : 700-Issue of Documentary Credit N-Normal Message : 4 :message text :  :27 :sequence of total : 1/1 :40A:applicable rules : UCP600 :20 :doc credit  number : L960477 :31C:date of issue : 070308 :31D:date/place of expiry : 070430 IN U.S.A. :50 :applicant : ABC COMPANY   21 ANY STREET   SINGAPORE  659539 :59 :beneficiary : XYZ COMPANY   52 ANY STREET   GREENWOOD, IN  48182   USA :32B:currency/amount : USD10,000.00 :41D:available with…by… : ANY BANK   BY NEGOTIATION :42C:drafts at : SIGHT :42D:drawee : ABN AMRO BANK N.V., SINGAPORE BRANCH :43P:partial shipments : NOT ALLOWED :43T:transshipment : ALLOWED :44A:place of taking in charge/dispatch from…/ place of receipt : METROPOLIS, IN :44B:place of final destination/for transportation to…/ place of delivery  : SINGAPORE :44E:port of loading/ airport of departure : USA PORT :44F:port of discharge/ airport of destination : SINGAPORE :44C:latest date of shipment : 070415 :45A:description of goods : 1 (ONE) UNIT - PORTABLE CHILLER, MODEL : MX-7, SAYR 415/   50 AS PER APPLICANT’S P/O NO. 2075 FOB USA PORT :46A:documents required : ++ BENEFICIARY’S SIGNED COMMERCIAL INVOICE IN ONE ORIGINAL AND    THREE COPIES    ++ FULL SET ORIGINAL CLEAN ON BOARD PORT TO PORT BILLS OF LADING    AND ONE N.N. COPY MADE OUT TO ORDER OF SHIPPER   BLANK ENDORSED MARKED FREIGHT COLLECT AND NOTIFY APPLICANT   INDICATING THIS CREDIT NUMBER.   ++CERTIFICATE OF USA ORIGIN IN ONE ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY ISSUED    BY BENEFICIARY/CHAMBER OF COMMERCE    ++ PACKING LIST IN ONE ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY :47A:additional conditions : +ALL DOCUMENTS MUST BE DISPATCHED TO US IN ONE LOT BY   REGISTERED AIRMAIL + INSURANCE WILL BE COVERED BY APPLICANT :71B:charges : ALL BANK CHARGES AND COMMISSIONS OUTSIDE SINGAPORE INCLUDING    REIMBURSEMENT CHARGES ARE FOR BENEFICIARY’S ACCOUNT :49 :confirmation instructions : WITHOUT :53A:reimbursing bank : ABN AMRO BANK N.V.   NEW YORK, NY :78 :instr to nominated bank : REIMBURSEMENT : PLEASE REIMBURSE YOURSELVES TO THE DEBIT   OF OUR ACCOUNT WITH ABN AMRO BANK NV, NEW YORK, UNDER TESTED    TELEX ADVICE TO US.  A DISCREPANCY FEE OF USD40.00 (OR ITS    EQUIVALENT) SHALL BE DEDUCTED FROM THE REIMBURSEMENT CLAIM/    PROCEEDS UPON EACH PRESENTATION OF DISCREPANT DOCUMENTS AND THE    LEVY OF THE DISCREPANCY FEE DOES NOT IN ANY WAY ALTER THE TERMS   AND CONDITIONS OF THIS CREDIT.
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Goods
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller NominatedBank Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments Debit L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Debit Letter of Credit Goods Payment
How  International  Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Contract Nominated Bank Docu- ments Goods Debit Documents Payment Pay-  ment Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation L/C Advising Bank L/C Docu- ments
How  Confirmed  Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Docu- ments Pay-  ment Goods Contract Confirming Bank L/C L/C Debit Documents Payment Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments
Risk Mitigation Techniques May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Standby L/Cs  and Guarantees May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
What Is a  Standby  Letter of Credit? Standby Letter of Credit   as opposed to a commercial letter of credit, a letter of credit that does not cover the direct purchase of merchandise, so called because it is often intended to be drawn on only when the applicant for whom it is issued fails to perform an obligation.  Standby letters of credit are based on the underlying principle of letters of credit that payment is made against presentation of documents–whatever documents the applicant, beneficiary, and issuing bank may agree to, not necessarily documents evidencing shipment of goods. May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Characteristics of Standby L/Cs Similar to guarantees but independent in nature Documentary Not meant to be drawn on (generally) May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Letter of Credit Application Goods
How  Standby  Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Applicant Applicant’s Bank Beneficiary Contract Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit Documents Documents Payment Debit Payment
Risk Mitigation Techniques May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 2. Preferential payment risk exists unless the standby is properly worded. 3. Country risks are covered if the L/C is confirmed by a “developed-world” bank.
Risk Mitigation Techniques Guarantees Independent/demand guarantee  Accessory/contract guarantee, surety bond May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Standby L/Cs vs. Guarantees & Bonds May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Standby L/C Demand Guarantee Accessory/Contract Guarantee,  Surety Bond Independent & payable  against documents Independent & payable  against documents Specified amount Specified amount Payable upon occurrence  of specified event Amount of damages  (usually with a maximum) Specified expiry Usually has a specified expiry Expiry event Rules: UCP or ISP  (and UCC5 in the U.S.) Rules: URDG, ISP,  or local law Rules: Local law
Risk Mitigation Techniques May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 4. Country risks are covered if the guarantee is a ‘local guarantee’. 5. If the principal repudiates the contract, the guarantor may do the same.
Risk Mitigation Techniques May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 4. Country risks are covered if the guarantee is a ‘local guarantee’. 5. If the principal repudiates the contract, the guarantor may do the same. Be sure you know  which kind   of guarantee  you’re dealing with
Rules and Regulations to Be Aware Of The Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (“UCP”) The Uniform Commercial Code, Article 5 International Standard Banking Practice for the Examination of Documents under Documentary Credits (“ISBP”) The eUCP  The International Standby Practices (“ISP98”) The Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees The Incoterms Antiboycott regulations OFAC sanctions May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Real-World  Letter of Credit Mechanics May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
How Letters of Credit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Goods
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments Debit L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Seller Contract Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Seller Contract L/C Appli- cation Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank L/C L/C
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Advising Bank Seller Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C Buyer’s Bank Reimbursing Bank Reimbursement Authorization
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C Reimbursement Authorization Seller Freight Forwarder  L/C
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C Reimbursement Authorization Seller Freight Forwarder  Nominated Bank L/C & Documents Goods Goods
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Reimbursement Authorization Goods Goods Nominated Bank Reimbursement Claim Documents
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Reimbursement Authorization Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Reimbursement
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Reimbursement Authorization Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Nominated Bank Payment Seller’s Bank Payment Reimbursement
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Docu- ments Debit
How Letters of Credit Work: Reality  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder  Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Debit
Problems with Confirming Banks The Confirming Bank is chosen by the Issuing Bank The Confirming Bank has a monopoly position The Confirming Bank may be an affiliate of the Issuing Bank The Confirming Bank can be enjoined from making payment # May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Replacing Confirmation Negotiation of documents without recourse Often referred to as “silent confirmation” Allows you to present all your L/Cs to your own bank for payment Can request payment without recourse if documents comply with L/C requirements Immediate availability of funds May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
How  Confirmed  Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Docu- ments Pay-  ment Buyer Seller Goods Debit Documents Payment Docu- ments Contract Confirming Bank L/C L/C Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation
How  Silent Confirmation  Works May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer A ‘silent confirmation’ is a commitment, issued in advance by the nominated bank, to purchase compliant documents without recourse Seller Goods Contract Debit Documents Payment Pay-  ment Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments Commit- ment L/C Advising Bank L/C Nominated Bank L/C Docu- ments
Risk Mitigation Techniques May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Usance Letters of Credit Time drafts vs. deferred payment Significance of whom drafts are drawn on: obligations of the drawee fixing maturity Discounting accepted drafts L/C re-financing vs. time drafts Effect of “discount charges for Buyer” clause May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
An Extended  Look at Standby L/Cs May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Using Standby L/Cs in Trade Transactions Credit line back-up  Bid bonds Performance bonds Warranty/retention money Advance payment guarantees May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Why Was the ISP Created? Continuing problem with lawsuits involving standbys UCP reflects commercial L/C practice standby practice sometimes differs (e.g., Articles 36 (Force Majeure), 32 (Instalment Drawings), 14c (Late Presentation), & 38   (Transfers)) many standby practices are not covered in the UCP Sometimes UCP is unclear (or wrong) URDG too vague May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
UCP vs. ISP UCP assumes applicants want to pay ISP assumes applicants don’t want to pay ISP is more liberal re document examination ISP is more liberal re time allowed to present UCP is more concerned about originality of documents ISP contains a few rules that are just missing from the UCP ISP contains standby-specific rules (that no one wanted to put in the UCP) Transfers work differently May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
UCP vs. ISP May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker The ISP is designed for standbys UCP600 ISP98 Intended Use: L/Cs whose primary purpose is to serve as a means to exchange control of goods for payment. L/Cs whose primary purpose is to provide credit assurance Assumption 1: The documents have a time value The documents have no intrinsic value Assumption 2: Applicants want to pay Applicants don’t want to pay
UCP vs. ISP  May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker UCP600 ISP98 Force majeure L/C expires nonetheless Expiry extended 30 days after bank re-opens Consistency of documents Data in documents must not conflict Documents need not be consistent Time allowed for dishonor 5 banking days <4 days = reasonable >7 days = unreasonable Original documents  “ In __ copies” means one original of each document “ Copies” means copies Transport documents Extensive, detailed requirements Treated like “other” documents Disposition of documents Strict requirements No requirements Deemed acceptance of amendments If documents comply  w/ amended terms If documents will not comply w/o amendment Transfer One time but multiple partial transfers allowed Multiple times but always in entirety
Standby L/C Loopholes Court injunctions Bankruptcy of the applicant Before receiving payment/performance from applicant Within 90 days of receiving payment Within 90 days of receiving L/C did the debt exist at the time the L/C was issued? bank secured or unsecured when L/C was issued? May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Standby L/C Loopholes (cont’d) Insolvency of the issuing bank The FDIC will disaffirm all undrawn L/Cs If the bank is sold, you will be made whole If the bank is liquidated, you will have a ratable claim Abusive drawings May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
Recap: When Might a Letter of Credit Drawing Not Be Paid? Expired L/C Discrepancies Political or economic event Fraud/injunction L/C issued during bankruptcy preference period, covering pre-existing debt Insolvent bank, liquidated May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
 

How Letters of Credit Work

  • 1.
    How Letters ofCredit Work NACM Oregon/CMA Business Credit Learning Center Webinar May 21, 2009 Buddy Baker, Head of Trade Services Sales Fifth Third Bank [email_address] (847) 830-3038 If you can read this, your settings are not optimal for printing this presentation and will draw certain graphics incorrectly. Please re-print using the “Color” setting, even if printing using a black & white printer. (…and Why They Sometimes Don’t)
  • 2.
    NOTE: This setof slides contains animation and “builds” designed to be viewed in Slide Show mode. Please switch to Slide Show mode. Printing the slides may produce partially obstructed slides and slides with missing elements. If your desire is to review the presentation on paper, when in the print dialog, choose “Print range: Custom Show: Handouts” and check “Print hidden slides.” Choose the “Color” setting, even if printing in black & white.
  • 3.
    Walter (Buddy) Baker Walter (Buddy) Baker has over 30 years of experience in international trade finance. In May 2009 he joined Fifth Third Bank as the head of their Trade Services Sales team. Prior to Fifth Third, Buddy worked for Atradius Trade Credit Insurance, ABN AMRO Bank, Bank of America, Wachovia Bank, and The First National Bank of Chicago. Buddy is a recognized expert in trade finance and author of numerous magazine articles and the books Users’ Handbook to Documentary Credits under UCP600 , Documentary Payments & Short-Term Trade Finance , and The Regulatory Environment of Letters of Credit and Trade Finance . He owns the consulting firm Global Trade Risk Management Strategies, which specializes in educational training, and makes frequent presentations for national associations of exporters, importers, bankers and lawyers. Mr. Baker serves as a member-at-large of the National Letter of Credit Committee of the International Financial Services Association and is actively involved in establishing national and worldwide standard practices for LCs, such as the recent revision of the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (referred to as UCP600), the official ICC guide for examining letter of credit documents, called the International Standard Banking Practices for the Examination of Documents under Documentary Credits, the eUCP supplement to the UCP dealing with electronic documents, the International Standby Practices, and Article 5 of the Uniform Commercial Code. He acts as an advisor to the Wolfsberg Group, an international group that includes most of the largest banks in the world whose purpose is to set standards for combating money laundering, and to the Institute for International Banking Law and Practice. Buddy also serves on the Advisory Council of the Finance Credit and International Business Association (FCIB), a multinational association of export credit managers. Buddy earned his undergraduate degree at Yale University and his MBA at Northwestern. He can be reached at (847) 830-3038 or [email_address] .
  • 4.
    How L/Cs Are Supposed to Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 5.
    When Might aLetter of Credit Drawing Not Be Paid? Expired L/C Discrepancies Political or economic event Fraud/injunction L/C issued during bankruptcy preference period, covering pre-existing debt Insolvent bank, liquidated May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 6.
    What Is aLetter of Credit? An assurance of payment? A guarantee? A security interest? Conditional or unconditional? May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker A letter of credit is a bank’s own engagement to make payment of a specified amount upon presentation of specified documents
  • 7.
    Definition Letter ofCredit an undertaking, usually on the part of a bank and at the request of one of the bank’s customers, to pay a named beneficiary a specified amount of money (or to deliver an item of value) if the beneficiary presents documents in accordance with the terms and conditions specified in the letter of credit. May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 8.
    Uses of Lettersof Credit Intended means of payment for goods Secondary means of payment for goods (if buyer fails to pay directly) Bid bond (seller is applicant) Performance bond/warranty (seller is applicant) Advance payment guarantee (seller is applicant) Loan repayment Direct loan repayment (bond enhancement) etc., etc., etc. May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 9.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Contract Buyer’s Bank Letter of Credit Application
  • 10.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Contract Buyer’s Bank Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit
  • 11.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit 3 parties 3 independent contracts
  • 12.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit Principles of Letters of Credit: Independent and Documentary Goods Documents
  • 13.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Letter of Credit Goods Payment
  • 14.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Letter of Credit Goods Documents Payment Debit
  • 15.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Goods
  • 16.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 1. It may be possible for the applicant to obtain a court injunction to stop payment of a non-negotiable L/C. 7. A receivable in a foreign currency made be sold, including the remaining currency fluctuation risk. 8. FX exposure depends on the currency of the credit.
  • 17.
    A Typical ExportL/C May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Prepared MAR08/07 14:21 KEY: SWIN 9603000708914700 SEQ NO: 960308500050 RECEIVED FROM: ABN AMRO BANK N.V., SINGAPORE BRANCH SINGAPORE Authentication: CORRECT : 1 :basic header : F 01 LASLUS44BXXX 1448 170261 : 2 :application : 0 700 1519 968300 ABNASCSCAXXX 2456 743J92 960308 0709 N message type : 700-Issue of Documentary Credit N-Normal Message : 4 :message text : :27 :sequence of total : 1/1 :40A:applicable rules : UCP600 :20 :doc credit number : L960477 :31C:date of issue : 070308 :31D:date/place of expiry : 070430 IN U.S.A. :50 :applicant : ABC COMPANY 21 ANY STREET SINGAPORE 659539 :59 :beneficiary : XYZ COMPANY 52 ANY STREET GREENWOOD, IN 48182 USA :32B:currency/amount : USD10,000.00 :41D:available with…by… : ANY BANK BY NEGOTIATION :42C:drafts at : SIGHT :42D:drawee : ABN AMRO BANK N.V., SINGAPORE BRANCH :43P:partial shipments : NOT ALLOWED :43T:transshipment : ALLOWED :44A:place of taking in charge/dispatch from…/ place of receipt : METROPOLIS, IN :44B:place of final destination/for transportation to…/ place of delivery : SINGAPORE :44E:port of loading/ airport of departure : USA PORT :44F:port of discharge/ airport of destination : SINGAPORE :44C:latest date of shipment : 070415 :45A:description of goods : 1 (ONE) UNIT - PORTABLE CHILLER, MODEL : MX-7, SAYR 415/ 50 AS PER APPLICANT’S P/O NO. 2075 FOB USA PORT :46A:documents required : ++ BENEFICIARY’S SIGNED COMMERCIAL INVOICE IN ONE ORIGINAL AND THREE COPIES ++ FULL SET ORIGINAL CLEAN ON BOARD PORT TO PORT BILLS OF LADING AND ONE N.N. COPY MADE OUT TO ORDER OF SHIPPER BLANK ENDORSED MARKED FREIGHT COLLECT AND NOTIFY APPLICANT INDICATING THIS CREDIT NUMBER. ++CERTIFICATE OF USA ORIGIN IN ONE ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY ISSUED BY BENEFICIARY/CHAMBER OF COMMERCE ++ PACKING LIST IN ONE ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY :47A:additional conditions : +ALL DOCUMENTS MUST BE DISPATCHED TO US IN ONE LOT BY REGISTERED AIRMAIL + INSURANCE WILL BE COVERED BY APPLICANT :71B:charges : ALL BANK CHARGES AND COMMISSIONS OUTSIDE SINGAPORE INCLUDING REIMBURSEMENT CHARGES ARE FOR BENEFICIARY’S ACCOUNT :49 :confirmation instructions : WITHOUT :53A:reimbursing bank : ABN AMRO BANK N.V. NEW YORK, NY :78 :instr to nominated bank : REIMBURSEMENT : PLEASE REIMBURSE YOURSELVES TO THE DEBIT OF OUR ACCOUNT WITH ABN AMRO BANK NV, NEW YORK, UNDER TESTED TELEX ADVICE TO US. A DISCREPANCY FEE OF USD40.00 (OR ITS EQUIVALENT) SHALL BE DEDUCTED FROM THE REIMBURSEMENT CLAIM/ PROCEEDS UPON EACH PRESENTATION OF DISCREPANT DOCUMENTS AND THE LEVY OF THE DISCREPANCY FEE DOES NOT IN ANY WAY ALTER THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS CREDIT.
  • 18.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Goods
  • 19.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller NominatedBank Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments Debit L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim
  • 20.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Debit Letter of Credit Goods Payment
  • 21.
    How International Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Contract Nominated Bank Docu- ments Goods Debit Documents Payment Pay- ment Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation L/C Advising Bank L/C Docu- ments
  • 22.
    How Confirmed Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Seller Docu- ments Pay- ment Goods Contract Confirming Bank L/C L/C Debit Documents Payment Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments
  • 23.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 24.
    Standby L/Cs and Guarantees May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 25.
    What Is a Standby Letter of Credit? Standby Letter of Credit as opposed to a commercial letter of credit, a letter of credit that does not cover the direct purchase of merchandise, so called because it is often intended to be drawn on only when the applicant for whom it is issued fails to perform an obligation. Standby letters of credit are based on the underlying principle of letters of credit that payment is made against presentation of documents–whatever documents the applicant, beneficiary, and issuing bank may agree to, not necessarily documents evidencing shipment of goods. May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 26.
    Characteristics of StandbyL/Cs Similar to guarantees but independent in nature Documentary Not meant to be drawn on (generally) May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 27.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Letter of Credit Application Goods
  • 28.
    How Standby Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Applicant Applicant’s Bank Beneficiary Contract Letter of Credit Application Letter of Credit Documents Documents Payment Debit Payment
  • 29.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 2. Preferential payment risk exists unless the standby is properly worded. 3. Country risks are covered if the L/C is confirmed by a “developed-world” bank.
  • 30.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesGuarantees Independent/demand guarantee Accessory/contract guarantee, surety bond May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 31.
    Standby L/Cs vs.Guarantees & Bonds May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Standby L/C Demand Guarantee Accessory/Contract Guarantee, Surety Bond Independent & payable against documents Independent & payable against documents Specified amount Specified amount Payable upon occurrence of specified event Amount of damages (usually with a maximum) Specified expiry Usually has a specified expiry Expiry event Rules: UCP or ISP (and UCC5 in the U.S.) Rules: URDG, ISP, or local law Rules: Local law
  • 32.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 4. Country risks are covered if the guarantee is a ‘local guarantee’. 5. If the principal repudiates the contract, the guarantor may do the same.
  • 33.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker 4. Country risks are covered if the guarantee is a ‘local guarantee’. 5. If the principal repudiates the contract, the guarantor may do the same. Be sure you know which kind of guarantee you’re dealing with
  • 34.
    Rules and Regulationsto Be Aware Of The Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (“UCP”) The Uniform Commercial Code, Article 5 International Standard Banking Practice for the Examination of Documents under Documentary Credits (“ISBP”) The eUCP The International Standby Practices (“ISP98”) The Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees The Incoterms Antiboycott regulations OFAC sanctions May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 35.
    Real-World Letterof Credit Mechanics May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 36.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Theory May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer Buyer’s Bank Seller Contract Letter of Credit Application Documents Documents Payment Debit Letter of Credit Goods
  • 37.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments Debit L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim
  • 38.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Seller Contract Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation
  • 39.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Seller Contract L/C Appli- cation Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank L/C L/C
  • 40.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Advising Bank Seller Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C Buyer’s Bank Reimbursing Bank Reimbursement Authorization
  • 41.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C Reimbursement Authorization Seller Freight Forwarder L/C
  • 42.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C Reimbursement Authorization Seller Freight Forwarder Nominated Bank L/C & Documents Goods Goods
  • 43.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Reimbursement Authorization Goods Goods Nominated Bank Reimbursement Claim Documents
  • 44.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Reimbursement Authorization Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Reimbursement
  • 45.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Reimbursement Authorization Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Nominated Bank Payment Seller’s Bank Payment Reimbursement
  • 46.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Docu- ments Debit
  • 47.
    How Letters ofCredit Work: Reality May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Foreign Buyer Buyer’s Bank Advising Bank Seller’s Bank Seller Nominated Bank Freight Forwarder Reimbursing Bank Contract L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments L/C L/C L/C L/C & Documents Documents Payment Payment Reimbursement Authorization Reimbursement Goods Goods Reimbursement Claim Debit
  • 48.
    Problems with ConfirmingBanks The Confirming Bank is chosen by the Issuing Bank The Confirming Bank has a monopoly position The Confirming Bank may be an affiliate of the Issuing Bank The Confirming Bank can be enjoined from making payment # May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 49.
    Replacing Confirmation Negotiationof documents without recourse Often referred to as “silent confirmation” Allows you to present all your L/Cs to your own bank for payment Can request payment without recourse if documents comply with L/C requirements Immediate availability of funds May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 50.
    How Confirmed Letters of Credit Work May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Docu- ments Pay- ment Buyer Seller Goods Debit Documents Payment Docu- ments Contract Confirming Bank L/C L/C Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation
  • 51.
    How SilentConfirmation Works May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker Buyer A ‘silent confirmation’ is a commitment, issued in advance by the nominated bank, to purchase compliant documents without recourse Seller Goods Contract Debit Documents Payment Pay- ment Buyer’s Bank L/C Appli- cation Docu- ments Commit- ment L/C Advising Bank L/C Nominated Bank L/C Docu- ments
  • 52.
    Risk Mitigation TechniquesMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 53.
    Usance Letters ofCredit Time drafts vs. deferred payment Significance of whom drafts are drawn on: obligations of the drawee fixing maturity Discounting accepted drafts L/C re-financing vs. time drafts Effect of “discount charges for Buyer” clause May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 54.
    An Extended Look at Standby L/Cs May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 55.
    Using Standby L/Csin Trade Transactions Credit line back-up Bid bonds Performance bonds Warranty/retention money Advance payment guarantees May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 56.
    Why Was theISP Created? Continuing problem with lawsuits involving standbys UCP reflects commercial L/C practice standby practice sometimes differs (e.g., Articles 36 (Force Majeure), 32 (Instalment Drawings), 14c (Late Presentation), & 38   (Transfers)) many standby practices are not covered in the UCP Sometimes UCP is unclear (or wrong) URDG too vague May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 57.
    UCP vs. ISPUCP assumes applicants want to pay ISP assumes applicants don’t want to pay ISP is more liberal re document examination ISP is more liberal re time allowed to present UCP is more concerned about originality of documents ISP contains a few rules that are just missing from the UCP ISP contains standby-specific rules (that no one wanted to put in the UCP) Transfers work differently May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 58.
    UCP vs. ISPMay 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker The ISP is designed for standbys UCP600 ISP98 Intended Use: L/Cs whose primary purpose is to serve as a means to exchange control of goods for payment. L/Cs whose primary purpose is to provide credit assurance Assumption 1: The documents have a time value The documents have no intrinsic value Assumption 2: Applicants want to pay Applicants don’t want to pay
  • 59.
    UCP vs. ISP May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker UCP600 ISP98 Force majeure L/C expires nonetheless Expiry extended 30 days after bank re-opens Consistency of documents Data in documents must not conflict Documents need not be consistent Time allowed for dishonor 5 banking days <4 days = reasonable >7 days = unreasonable Original documents “ In __ copies” means one original of each document “ Copies” means copies Transport documents Extensive, detailed requirements Treated like “other” documents Disposition of documents Strict requirements No requirements Deemed acceptance of amendments If documents comply w/ amended terms If documents will not comply w/o amendment Transfer One time but multiple partial transfers allowed Multiple times but always in entirety
  • 60.
    Standby L/C LoopholesCourt injunctions Bankruptcy of the applicant Before receiving payment/performance from applicant Within 90 days of receiving payment Within 90 days of receiving L/C did the debt exist at the time the L/C was issued? bank secured or unsecured when L/C was issued? May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 61.
    Standby L/C Loopholes(cont’d) Insolvency of the issuing bank The FDIC will disaffirm all undrawn L/Cs If the bank is sold, you will be made whole If the bank is liquidated, you will have a ratable claim Abusive drawings May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 62.
    Recap: When Mighta Letter of Credit Drawing Not Be Paid? Expired L/C Discrepancies Political or economic event Fraud/injunction L/C issued during bankruptcy preference period, covering pre-existing debt Insolvent bank, liquidated May 21, 2009 – BCLC – How L/Cs Work – Buddy Baker
  • 63.

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Additional handouts: L/C cycle diagrams, export L/C sample, L/C Instructions template, ISP vs UCP, standby L/C sample
  • #18 Refer to handout
  • #57 1