Research for Human Services
Michael R. Perkins, MSW, LCSW, Contributing Editor
This edition is adapted from a Psychology research text originally produced in 2010 by a publisher who has
requested that they not receive attribution, with some material from Principles of Sociological Inquiry –
Qualitative and Quantitative Methods by Amy Blackstone, University of Maine. Both published under this
license:
Conditions of Use
FIGURE 1 IS THE SYMBOL FOR CREATIVE COMMONS LICENSE THIS WORK IS RELEASED UNDER.
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike
CC BY-NC-SA
This work is a derivative that is also published under that license which states:
You are free to:
Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material
The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms if you follow the license terms.
The terms of the license are:
Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes
were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the
licensor endorses you or your use.
NonCommercial — You may not use the material for commercial purposes.
ShareAlike — If you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you must distribute your
contributions under the same license as the original.
You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that restrict others from doing anything the
license permits.
Notices:
You do not have to comply with the license for elements of the material in the book which are in the public
domain or where your use is permitted by an applicable exception or limitation.
No warranties are given.
The license may not give you all of the permissions necessary for your intended use. For example, other
rights such as publicity, privacy, or moral rights may limit how you use the material.
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/us/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
Forward
About This Book
I did not write this book. I did contribute, rewrote parts of it, created some original material, and added
sections. My role is rather amorphous. Such is the nature of an open source project like this. An open
source project such as this, (when it is done properly) takes on a life of its own - which is exactly what it is
supposed to do. I did adapt, edit, and transform the original works (primarily an introductory text on
research for Psychology students along with some material from an introductory text on research for
Sociology students) into a text for Human Services majors. This book is based on those .
Research for Human Services Michael R. Perkins, MSW, LCS.docx
1. Research for Human Services
Michael R. Perkins, MSW, LCSW, Contributing Editor
This edition is adapted from a Psychology research text
originally produced in 2010 by a publisher who has
requested that they not receive attribution, with some material
from Principles of Sociological Inquiry –
Qualitative and Quantitative Methods by Amy Blackstone,
University of Maine. Both published under this
license:
Conditions of Use
FIGURE 1 IS THE SYMBOL FOR CREATIVE COMMONS
LICENSE THIS WORK IS RELEASED UNDER.
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike
CC BY-NC-SA
This work is a derivative that is also published under that
license which states:
You are free to:
— copy and redistribute the material in any medium or
format
— remix, transform, and build upon the material
2. The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms if you follow the
license terms.
The terms of the license are:
— You must give appropriate credit, provide a
link to the license, and indicate if changes
were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in
any way that suggests the
licensor endorses you or your use.
— You may not use the material for
commercial purposes.
areAlike — If you remix, transform, or build upon the
material, you must distribute your
contributions under the same license as the original.
You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that
restrict others from doing anything the
license permits.
Notices:
You do not have to comply with the license for elements of the
material in the book which are in the public
domain or where your use is permitted by an applicable
exception or limitation.
No warranties are given.
The license may not give you all of the permissions necessary
for your intended use. For example, other
rights such as publicity, privacy, or moral rights may limit how
you use the material.
4. The changes I have made reflect my own view of the research
process, and what I think undergraduate
students in Human Services need to know. It reflects an
approach developed during my first career as a
Human Service practitioner, and the twenty years following that
teaching an introductory research class in
Social Work and Human Services. It also reflects my forays
into qualitative and quantitative research over
the past three decades. To that end the focus has been shifted to
Human Services, and there is much less
emphasis on statistics. The emphasis on this text is to assist
students into becoming better consumers of
quality research, rather than producers of it. I think the latter is
more appropriate for graduate work, or a
more advanced class specifically designed to accomplish that
purpose.
Open Source
Earlier I mentioned open source, so what is it exactly? Probably
the best place to explore the concept is
www.opensource.org . They define open source software (even
though in this case it applies to a book) in
terms of the license granted:
The license shall not restrict any party from selling or giving
away the software as a component of
an aggregate software distribution containing programs from
several different sources. The license
shall not require a royalty or other fee for such sale.
Notice it says software, which is where the open source concept
originated, and most notably with the
development of the Linux operating system which was
developed using that model. However, the same
concept has been adapted for other creative endeavors including
the written word. This book is open
5. source and released into the wild under a generous creative
commons license. For more information on the
philosophy and approach of open Source please see The
Cathedral and the Bazaar by Eric Steven
Raymond (available to read online).
I am a devoted proponent of open source efforts such as Linux,
Libre Office, and the growing number of
textbooks that are being made available free to the public.
And finally, many thanks to Rebecca Whitworth who has joined
me in this project, and who made, and
continues to make, many contributions.
Sincerely,
Michael R. Perkins, MSW LCSW
http://www.opensource.org/
Table of Contents
Conditions of Use
...............................................................................................
.......................................... 1
Forward
...............................................................................................
............................................................. 2
About This Book
...............................................................................................
............................................ 2
Open Source
...............................................................................................
6. .............................................. 2
Table of Contents
...............................................................................................
.............................................. 3
Preface
...............................................................................................
............................................................... I
Relevance, Balance, and Accessibility
...............................................................................................
.......... 1
Introduction: Human Services
...............................................................................................
.......................... 2
What is Human Services?
...............................................................................................
............................. 2
A Brief History of Human Services
...............................................................................................
................ 2
Origins of Human Services in Deinstitutionalization
.................................................................................... 3
.Chapter 1: Science in the Social Sciences
...............................................................................................
...... 5
Who talks more?
...............................................................................................
............................................ 6
7. 1.1 Understanding Science
...............................................................................................
........................... 6
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
......................... 6
Science & Human Services
...............................................................................................
....................... 6
Empirically Based Research
...............................................................................................
...................... 7
The Emergence of Science and the Scientific Method
................................................................................ 7
Features of Science
...............................................................................................
................................... 7
1. Systematic
Empiricism..............................................................................
............................................ 7
2. The Scientific Approach
...............................................................................................
........................ 8
3. Public Knowledge
......................................................................................... ......
.................................. 8
8. Publication is an essential feature of science for two
reasons:................................................................ 9
Science Versus Pseudoscience
...............................................................................................
.................... 9
Karl Popper
...............................................................................................
.............................................. 10
The Skeptic’s Dictionary
...............................................................................................
.......................... 10
1.2 Scientific Research in the Human Services
..................................................................................... .... 12
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
....................... 12
A Model of Scientific Research
...............................................................................................
................ 12
Who Conducts Scientific Research?
...............................................................................................
....... 13
The Broader Purposes of Scientific Research in the Human
Services .................................................. 13
Two Categories: Basic and Applied Research
9. ...................................................................................... 13
Summary
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 14
1.3 Science and Common Sense
...............................................................................................
................ 15
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 15
Can We Rely on Common
Sense?....................................................................................
..................... 15
Some Great Myths
...............................................................................................
................................... 15
How Could We Be So Wrong?
...............................................................................................
................ 15
Practice:
...............................................................................................
................................................... 16
1.4 Science and Human Services Practice
...............................................................................................
. 18
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
10. ....................... 18
Empirically Supported Treatments
...............................................................................................
.......... 18
Discussion:
...............................................................................................
............................................... 19
Chapter 2: Getting Started in Research
...............................................................................................
......... 20
2.1 Basic Concepts
...............................................................................................
...................................... 20
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
....................... 20
Variables
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 20
Sampling and Measurement
.......................................................................................... .....
....................... 21
Statistical Relationships Between Variables
..............................................................................................
21
Single Variable
...............................................................................................
11. ......................................... 21
Statistical Relationship Between Multiple Variables
............................................................................... 22
Differences Between Groups
...............................................................................................
................... 22
Correlations Between Quantitative Variables
......................................................................................... 23
Scatterplots
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 23
Pearson’s r
......................................................................................... ......
................................................... 24
Independent and Dependent Variables
...............................................................................................
... 25
Correlation and Causation
...............................................................................................
........................... 25
Directionality Problem
...............................................................................................
.............................. 26
Third-Variable Problem
...............................................................................................
............................ 26
12. “Lots of Candy Could Lead to Violence”
...............................................................................................
.. 26
Experiment
...............................................................................................
................................................... 26
Practice
...............................................................................................
.................................................... 27
2.2 Generating Good Research Questions
...............................................................................................
...... 27
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
....................... 27
Finding Inspiration
...............................................................................................
....................................... 28
Informal Observations
...............................................................................................
.............................. 28
Practical Problems
...............................................................................................
................................... 28
Previous Research
...............................................................................................
13. .................................. 28
Generating Empirically Testable Research Questions
.......................................................................... 28
Evaluating Research Questions
...............................................................................................
.................. 29
Interestingness........................................................................
................................................................ 29
Does it fill a gap?
...............................................................................................
..................................... 30
Feasibility
...............................................................................................
................................................. 30
Types of Studies in the
Literature................................................................................
............................... 30
Summary
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 31
Practice:
...............................................................................................
................................................... 31
2.3 Reviewing the Research Literature
...............................................................................................
....... 31
14. LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
....................... 31
What Is the Research
Literature?..............................................................................
................................. 32
Professional Journals
...............................................................................................
.............................. 32
Peer Review
...............................................................................................
............................................. 33
Scholarly Books
...............................................................................................
....................................... 33
Literature Search Strategies
...............................................................................................
.................... 33
Using Other Search Techniques
...............................................................................................
............. 34
What to Search For
...............................................................................................
..................................... 34
Newer Work
...............................................................................................
............................................. 34
15. Reviews of the Topic and Meta-analysis
...............................................................................................
. 34
Practice:
...............................................................................................
................................................... 35
Chapter 3: Research Ethics
...............................................................................................
........................... 36
3.1 Moral Foundations of Ethical Research
......................................................................................... ......
.... 36
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 36
A Framework for Thinking About Research Ethics
................................................................................ 36
Moral Principles to Consider and Who Research Affects:
..................................................................... 37
Ethical Principles
...............................................................................................
......................................... 37
Weighing Risks Against Benefits
...............................................................................................
............. 37
The Milgram Study on Obedience
...............................................................................................
16. ............... 37
Was It Worth It?
...............................................................................................
....................................... 38
Acting Responsibly and With Integrity
...............................................................................................
..... 38
Seeking Justice: The Tuskegee Experiment
.......................................................................................... 38
“They Were Betrayed”
...............................................................................................
............................. 39
Respecting People’s Rights and Dignity
...............................................................................................
. 39
Unavoidable Ethical Conflict
...............................................................................................
.................... 39
Practice:
...............................................................................................
....................................................... 40
3.2 From Principles to Ethics Codes
.................................................................................. .............
............... 40
17. LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 40
Historical Overview
...............................................................................................
...................................... 41
Ethics
Codes......................................................................................
......................................................... 41
Research Ethics and Human Services
...............................................................................................
........... 42
Other Social Science Ethical Codes
.................................................................................... ...........
........... 42
Research Ethics & Social Work
...............................................................................................
............... 42
Practice
...............................................................................................
........................................................ 42
Discussion
...............................................................................................
................................................... 42
3.3 Putting Ethics into Practice
...............................................................................................
....................... 43
18. LEARNING OBJECTIVES
........................................................................................ .......
........................... 43
Know and Accept Your Ethical Responsibilities
......................................................................................... 43
Identify and Minimize Risks
...............................................................................................
......................... 43
Identify and Minimize Deception
...............................................................................................
................. 44
Weigh the Risks Against the Benefits
...............................................................................................
......... 45
Create Informed Consent and Debriefing Procedures
............................................................................... 45
Get Approval
...............................................................................................
................................................ 46
Follow Through
................................................................................ ...............
............................................ 46
Discussion
...............................................................................................
................................................... 47
Practice
...............................................................................................
19. ........................................................ 47
Chapter 4: Theory
...............................................................................................
........................................... 48
4.1 Phenomena and Theories
...............................................................................................
......................... 49
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 49
Phenomena
...............................................................................................
................................................. 49
Some Famous Phenomena from Psychology
............................................................................................
49
What Is a Theory?
...............................................................................................
........................................... 50
What Are Theories For?
...............................................................................................
.............................. 51
Organization
...............................................................................................
................................................ 51
Occam’s Razor & Parsimony
...............................................................................................
20. ...................... 52
Prediction
...............................................................................................
..................................................... 52
Generation of New Research
...............................................................................................
...................... 53
Multiple Theories: Competing and Complementary
.................................................................................. 53
Example of Competing Theories: Where Do Multiple
Personalities Come From? .................................... 53
Practice
...............................................................................................
........................................................ 54
Discussion:
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 54
4.2 The Variety of Theories
...............................................................................................
............................... 55
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 55
Formality
22. ...............................................................................................
........... 58
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 58
Theory Testing and Revision
...............................................................................................
....................... 58
Hypothetical-Deductive method
...............................................................................................
............... 59
Constructing or Choosing a Theory
...............................................................................................
............ 59
Deriving A Hypotheses
...............................................................................................
................................ 60
Evaluating and Revising Theories
...............................................................................................
............... 60
Incorporating Theory into Your Practice
...............................................................................................
...... 61
Incorporating Theory into Practice
...............................................................................................
.............. 62
Practice:
23. ...............................................................................................
....................................................... 62
Chapter 5:
Measurement...........................................................................
.................................................... 64
Do You Feel You Are a Person of Worth?
...............................................................................................
.. 64
5.1 Understanding Clinical Measurement
...............................................................................................
... 66
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
....................... 66
What Is Measurement?
...............................................................................................
............................... 66
Constructs
...............................................................................................
.................................................... 66
Aspects of the Human Personality: The Big Five
.................................................................................. 67
Operational Definitions
...............................................................................................
................................ 68
24. Converging Operations
...............................................................................................
............................ 68
Levels of Measurement
...............................................................................................
............................... 69
Nominal Level
...............................................................................................
.......................................... 69
Ordinal Level
...............................................................................................
............................................ 69
Interval Level
...............................................................................................
............................................ 69
Ratio Level
...............................................................................................
............................................... 69
Practice
...............................................................................................
........................................................ 71
5.2 Reliability and Validity of Measurement
...............................................................................................
71
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 71
31. ...............................................................................................
....................... 94
Experimenter Gender as an Extraneous Variable
..................................................................................... 95
Experimenter Expectancy Effect
...............................................................................................
................. 95
Record Keeping
...............................................................................................
........................................... 96
Pilot Testing
...............................................................................................
................................................. 96
Practice
...............................................................................................
........................................................ 97
Discussion
...............................................................................................
................................................... 97
Chapter 7: Nonexperimental Research
...............................................................................................
.......... 98
7.1 Overview of Nonexperimental Research
............................................................................. ................
98
32. LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
........................... 98
What Is Nonexperimental Research?
...............................................................................................
......... 98
When to Use Nonexperimental Research
...............................................................................................
... 99
Types of Nonexperimental Research
...............................................................................................
.......... 99
Nonexperiments
...............................................................................................
........................................ 100
Correlational and Quasi-Experimental Research
................................................................................. 100
Qualitative Research
...............................................................................................
............................. 100
Internal Validity Revisited
...............................................................................................
.......................... 100
Discussion
...............................................................................................
................................................. 101
33. 7.2 Correlational Research
...............................................................................................
........................... 102
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
......................... 102
What Is Correlational Research?
...............................................................................................
.............. 102
Misconceptions about Correlational Research
........................................................................................ 102
Data Collection in Correlational Research
...............................................................................................
103
Naturalistic Observation
...............................................................................................
............................ 104
The Question of What will be Observed
...............................................................................................
.... 104
Coding Data
...............................................................................................
........................................... 105
Archival Data
...............................................................................................
............................................. 105
Content Analysis
34. ....................................................................................... ........
.................................... 105
Summary:
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 106
Discussion
...............................................................................................
................................................. 106
7.3 Quasi-Experimental Research
...............................................................................................
................ 107
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
......................... 107
Nonequivalent Groups Design
...............................................................................................
.................. 107
Pretest-Posttest Design
...............................................................................................
............................. 108
Regression to the
Mean......................................................................................
.................................. 108
Spontaneous Remission
...............................................................................................
........................ 108
Does Psychotherapy Work?
35. ...............................................................................................
...................... 108
Interrupted Time Series Design
..................................................................................... ..........
................. 109
Combination Designs
...............................................................................................
................................ 110
Quasi-Experimental Research
...............................................................................................
.................. 111
7.4 Qualitative Research
...............................................................................................
............................... 112
What Is Qualitative Research?
...............................................................................................
.................. 112
Characteristics of Quantitative Research Methods
.............................................................................. 112
Characteristics of Qualitative Methods
...............................................................................................
.. 113
Origins of Qualitative Research
...............................................................................................
................. 113
36. The Purpose of Qualitative Research
...............................................................................................
....... 113
Weaknesses of Quantitative Research are Strengths of
Qualitative Research .................................. 114
Thick Description
...............................................................................................
................................... 114
Data Collection and Analysis in Qualitative Research
............................................................................. 114
Interviews
...............................................................................................
............................................... 114
Focus Groups
...............................................................................................
........................................ 114
Participant Observation
.................................................................................. .............
......................... 114
Data Analysis in Quantitative Research
...............................................................................................
.... 115
Grounded Theory
...............................................................................................
................................... 115
Grounded Research in Action
37. ...............................................................................................
............... 115
Five Themes of Postpartum Depression
..............................................................................................
116
The Quantitative-Qualitative “Debate”
...............................................................................................
....... 116
Mixed Methods and Triangulation
...............................................................................................
......... 116
Discussion
...............................................................................................
................................................. 117
Chapter 8: Survey Research
...............................................................................................
......................... 118
Why Survey Research?
...............................................................................................
............................. 118
General Social Survey
...............................................................................................
............................... 118
8.1 Survey Research: What Is It and When Should It Be Used?
............................................................ 118
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
38. ......................... 118
Surveys are a Quantitative Method
...............................................................................................
........... 119
Exercise
............................................................................... ................
..................................................... 119
8.2 Pros and Cons of Survey Research
...............................................................................................
........ 119
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
......................... 119
Strengths of Survey Method
...............................................................................................
.................. 119
Versatility
...............................................................................................
................................................... 120
Weaknesses of Survey Method
...............................................................................................
................. 120
Validity & Surveys
...............................................................................................
.................................. 121
Exercises
...............................................................................................
39. ................................................... 121
8.3 Types of Surveys
...............................................................................................
..................................... 121
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
......................... 121
Cross-Sectional and Longitudinal Surveys
..............................................................................................
121
Cross-Sectional Research
...............................................................................................
..................... 122
One Problem with Cross-Sectional Surveys
........................................................................................ 122
Longitudinal Surveys
...............................................................................................
................................. 122
Trend Survey
...............................................................................................
......................................... 122
Panel Surveys
...............................................................................................
........................................ 123
42. Open-Ended Questions
...............................................................................................
......................... 133
Fence Sitting and Floating
...............................................................................................
......................... 133
Fence Setting
...............................................................................................
......................................... 133
Floating
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 133
Using a Matrix
...............................................................................................
............................................ 133
Designing Questionnaires
...............................................................................................
......................... 135
Order of Questions: It Does Matter
...............................................................................................
...... 136
Questions of Time
...............................................................................................
..................................... 136
Pretesting & Time to Complete
44. Managing, Sorting, and Ordering Your Data
........................................................................................ 140
Using Statistical Software
...............................................................................................
.......................... 140
Excel and Open Source Options
...............................................................................................
........... 140
PSPP.......................................................................................
.............................................................. 140
Libre Office and Calc
...............................................................................................
............................. 140
R
.......................................................................................... .....
............................................................. 140
Specialty Commercial Software Options
..............................................................................................
141
Identifying Patterns
...............................................................................................
.................................... 141
Frequency Distribution
...............................................................................................
............................... 141
Measures of Central Tendency
45. ...............................................................................................
................. 142
The Three Measures of Central Tendency
..............................................................................................
142
Mode
...............................................................................................
...................................................... 142
Median
...............................................................................................
................................................... 142
Mean
...............................................................................................
...................................................... 142
Bivariate Analysis
...............................................................................................
...................................... 143
Contingency Tables
...............................................................................................
............................... 143
Collapsing Categories
...............................................................................................
............................ 144
Conventions
...............................................................................................
........................................... 144
Multivariate Analysis
47. ...................................... 146
Conventions for Frequency Distribution Tables
................................................................................... 147
Histograms
...............................................................................................
................................................. 148
Distribution Shapes
...............................................................................................
................................... 149
Symmetrical or Skewed
...............................................................................................
............................. 149
Outlier
...............................................................................................
.................................................... 151
Measures of Central Tendency and Variability
........................................................................................ 151
Central Tendency
...............................................................................................
.................................. 151
Mean
...............................................................................................
...................................................... 151
Median
...............................................................................................
................................................... 151
48. MODE
...............................................................................................
.................................................... 151
Bimodal
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 152
Measures of Variability
............................................................................. ..................
.......................... 152
Standard Deviation
...............................................................................................
................................ 153
Computing the Standard Deviation
...............................................................................................
....... 154
N or N-1?
...............................................................................................
............................................... 154
Simple Standard Deviation Problem: Step by Step
............................................................................. 154
The Standard Deviation in More Detail
............................................................................................ ...
. 155
Percentile Ranks and z Scores
...............................................................................................
................. 155
Percentile Rank
49. ................................................................................ ...............
..................................... 156
Commonly Used Terms for Specific Percentiles
.................................................................................. 156
Some Examples
...............................................................................................
..................................... 156
Z Score
...............................................................................................
.................................................. 157
Online Descriptive Statistics
...............................................................................................
...................... 157
Use of Spreadsheets for Data Management
............................................................................................
158
Summary
...............................................................................................
................................................... 158
Practice
...............................................................................................
...................................................... 159
9.2 Describing Statistical Relationships
...............................................................................................
........ 159
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
...............................................................................................
50. ......................... 159
Differences Between Groups or Conditions
.............................................................................................
159
Cohen’s d
...............................................................................................
................................................... 160
Sex Differences Expressed as Cohen’s d
............................................................................................
161
Correlations Between Quantitative Variables
..........................................................................................
161
Nonlinear Relationship
...............................................................................................
........................... 165
Limited or Restricted Range
...............................................................................................
.................. 165
Chapter 10: Single-Subject Research Designs
..........................................................................................
168
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
.......................................................................................... .....
......................... 168
51. The Single-Subject Design
...............................................................................................
........................ 168
Single-Subject Design Conventions
...............................................................................................
.......... 168
The X and Y Axis
...............................................................................................
................................... 169
AB Design
...............................................................................................
.............................................. 169
The ABA Design
...............................................................................................
........................................ 169
ABAB Design
...............................................................................................
......................................... 170
Multiple-Treatment Reversal Design
...............................................................................................
..... 171
Potential Problems with the Reversal Design
..........................................................................................
171
Multiple Baseline Design
...............................................................................................
....................... 171
52. Other Single-Subject Designs
...............................................................................................
............... 172
Data Analysis in Single-Subject Research
...............................................................................................
172
Visual Inspection
............................................................................................. ..
.................................... 172
Statistical Analysis
...............................................................................................
..................................... 173
Christopher: A Case History
...............................................................................................
...................... 173
Summary
...............................................................................................
................................................... 174
Practice
...............................................................................................
...................................................... 174
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES pg. I
Preface
The research methods course, or something very much like it, is
inevitably required in the Human Services
curriculum. And for good reason. While the importance of
53. understanding research methods is usually clear
to students who intend to pursue an advanced degree, I’ve long
thought that those of us who teach
research methods could do a better job of demonstrating to all
of our students the relevance of what it is
that we’re teaching. Why should students want what this class
has to offer? That question is especially
relevant for undergraduate students.
As someone who has used both qualitative and quantitative
methods, I appreciate the need not only for
students to understand the relevance of research methods for
themselves, but also for them to understand
the relevance of both qualitative and quantitative techniques.
Also, as a teacher I have learned that
students will not get much from sources they perceive to be
overly boring, too full of jargon, or overly
technical. Altogether, my experiences as a student, researcher,
and teacher shape the three overriding
objectives of this text: relevance, balance, and accessibility.
Relevance, Balance, and Accessibility
This text emphasizes the relevance of research methods for the
everyday lives of its readers:
undergraduate students. The book describes how research
methodology is useful for students in the
multiple roles they fill:
citizens in a society where findings from
social research shape our laws, policies, and public life; and
connections to these roles throughout and
directly within the main text of the book rather than their being
relegated to boxes.
54. Using a variety of examples, this text also aims to provide
balanced coverage of qualitative and quantitative
approaches. We’ll also cover some of the debates regarding the
values and purposes of qualitative and
quantitative research. In addition, we’ll discuss the strengths
and weaknesses of both approaches.
One of the most important goals of this text is to introduce you
to the core principles of social research in a
way that is straightforward and keeps you engaged. As such, the
text reflects an emphasis on research
being accessible and readable.
In summary? Above all, the purpose of this textbook is to help
you to become a more critical thinker, who
can identify, implement, evaluate, and communicate best
practices (from high quality and reliable sources)
in your personal and professional life. One of the key marks of
the educated person.
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES
pg. 2
Introduction: Human Services
It is appropriate for us, no matter which Human Services class
we are in at the moment, to review the
definition of Human Services and our history as a profession.
One of the better definitions of Human
Services, can be found on Wikipedia:
What is Human Services?
55. Human services is an interdisciplinary field with the objective
of meeting human needs through an
applied knowledge base, focusing on prevention as well as
remediation of problems, and
maintaining a commitment to improving the overall quality of
life of service populations. The
process involves the study of social technologies (practice
methods, models, and theories), service
technologies (programs, organizations, and systems), and
scientific innovations that are designed
to ameliorate problems and enhance the quality of life of
individuals, families and communities to
improve the delivery of service with better coordination,
accessibility and accountability.[1] The
mission of human services is to promote a practice that involves
simultaneously working at all
levels of society (whole-person approach) in the process of
promoting the autonomy of individuals
or groups, making informal or formal human services systems
more efficient and effective, and
advocating for positive social change within society.
Human services practitioners strive to advance the autonomy of
service users through civic
engagement, education, health promotion and social change at
all levels of society. Practitioners
also engage in advocating so human systems remain accessible,
integrated, efficient and effective.
Human services academic programs can be readily found in
colleges and universities, which award
degrees at the associate, baccalaureate, and graduate levels.
Human services programs exist in
countries all around the world. Retrieved from:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_services
on 11 July 2017.
56. After defining Human Services, the same page provides a brief
history:
A Brief History of Human Services
Human services has its roots in charitable activities of religious
and civic organizations that date
back to the Colonial period. However, the academic discipline
of human services did not start until
the 1960s [during the deinstitutionalization movement]. At that
time, a group of college academics
started the new human services movement and began to promote
the adoption of a new ideology
about human service delivery and professionalism among
traditional helping disciplines. [2] The
movement's major goal was to make service delivery more
efficient, effective, and humane. The
other goals dealt with the reeducation of traditional helping
professionals (interprofessional
education), to have a greater appreciation of the individual as a
whole person (humanistic
psychology) and to be accountable to the communities they
serve (postmodernism). Furthermore,
professionals would learn to take responsibility at all levels of
government, use systems
approaches to consider human problems, and be involved in
progressive social change.
Traditional academic programs such as education, nursing,
social work, law and medicine were
resistant to the new human services movement's ideology
because it appeared to challenge their
professional status. Changing the traditional concept of
professionalism involved rethinking
consumer control and the distribution of power. The new
57. movement also called on human service
professionals to work for social change.[3] It was proposed that
the reduction of the monopolistic
control of professionals could result in democratization of
knowledge and would lead to
professionals advocating on behalf of clients and communities
against professional
establishments.[4] The movement also hoped that human service
delivery systems would become
integrated, comprehensive, and more accessible, which would
make them more humane for
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES
pg. 3
service users.[5][6] Ultimately, the resistance from traditional
helping professions served as the
impetus for a group of educators in higher education to start the
new academic discipline of human
services. Retrieved from:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_services
on 11 July 2017.
Origins of Human Services in Deinstitutionalization
A glaring omission of the history, as outlined in Wikipedia, is
why Human Services began in the first place.
Deinstitutionalization was a government policy that moved
mental health patients out of state-run
psychiatric hospitals into federally funded community mental
health centers. At least that was the theory. It
58. began in the 1960s due to a number of coalescing factors, but
largely as a cost saving measure. The
process of deinstitutionalization was always underfunded and,
as we shall see later, understaffed. The
result is that many people ended up homeless, or without
services that would help them cope in society.
Deinstitutionalization can still be seen in the criminal justice
system where persons with severe mental
health issues who run afoul of the law end up incarcerated. It is
a major problem in prisons and jails
throughout the country.
As institutions were closed thousands of their inmates were
released, many with no place to go, into
overwhelming societies ability to care for them [7]. It was
supposed to be a way to improve treatment of the
mentally ill, and other persons warehoused in total institutions
including children, while cutting
government expenditures. A total institution is a place where
people exist, cut off from mainstream society
living together enclosed in a formally administered existence.
The movement gained new force after the
1972 exposure of the horrible conditions under which children
were warehoused in a now defunct institution
called Willowbrook [8], as well as a flurry of court action
which has continued over time exemplified by the
Olmstead v. L.C. finding [9], which was itself an outgrowth of
the Americans with Disabilities Act.
In the mid-1960s a literal flood of persons was released with no
place to go. This was a class of people
who were ill equipped for a number of reasons to fend for
themselves, who quickly overran existing
services, and created a severe shortage of personnel trained to
work with them using more modern,
humane, and effective interventions. The profession was
59. created to fill that gap.
1.Herzberg, Judith T. (2015). Foundations in human services
practice: A generalist perspective on
individual, agency, and community (1st ed.). Boston: Pearson.
ISBN 9780205858255. OCLC 881181908
2. Chenault, Joann; Burnford, Fran (1978). Human services
professional education: Future directions. New
York: McGraw-Hill. ISBN 9780070107328. OCLC 3650238.
3. Dumont, M (1970). "The changing face of professionalism".
Social Policy. 1: 26–31.
4. Reiff, R. (1970). "Community psychology, community mental
health and social needs: The need for a
body of knowledge in community psychology". In Iscoe, Ira;
Spielberger, Charles D. Community
psychology: Perspectives in training and research. New York:
Appleton. pp. 1–. ISBN 9780390477712.
OCLC 92432.
5. Agranoff, R. (1974). "Human services administration: Service
delivery, service integration, and training".
In Mikulecky, Thomas J. Human services integration: a report
of a special project conducted by the
American Society for Public Administration. Washington, DC:
American Society for Public Administration.
pp. 42–51. OCLC 918115.
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES
pg. 4
60. 6. Baker, F (June 1974). "From community mental health to
human service ideology". American Journal of
Public Health. 64 (6): 576–581. PMC 1775477 Freely
accessible. PMID 4829069.
doi:10.2105/ajph.64.6.576.
7. Michael J. Dear, Jennifer R. Wolch (1987) Landscapes of
Despair: From Deinstitutionalization to
Homelessness (Human Geography) Hardcover, Princeton
University Press.
8. Rivera, Geraldo (1972). Willowbrook: A Report on How it is
and Why it Doesn’t Have to Be That Way.
New York: Random House. ISBN 0-394-71844-5.
9. Olmstead v. L.C., 527 U.S. 581 (1999): a United States
Supreme Court case regarding discrimination
against people with mental disabilities. The court ruled that
under the Americans with Disabilities Act,
persons with mental disabilities have a right to live in the
community rather than in institutions if "the State's
treatment professionals have determined that community
placement is appropriate, the transfer from
institutional care to a less restrictive setting is not opposed by
the affected individual, and the placement
can be reasonably accommodated, taking into account the
resources available to the State and the needs
of others with mental disabilities."
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES pg. 5
Chapter 1: Science in the Social Sciences
61. Science is the attempt to make the chaotic diversity of our
sense-experience correspond to a logically
uniform system of thought.
— Albert Einstein
Truth is not created. It is discovered. Science is an organized
attempt to discover truth.
First of all, which science are we talking about? There are three
main categories.
1. Natural sciences: the study of natural phenomena (including
cosmological, geological,
chemical, and biological factors of the universe)
2. Formal sciences: the study of mathematics and logic, which
use an a priori, as opposed to
factual, methodology)
3. Social sciences: the study of human behavior and societies.
From: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Branches_of_science
Einstein was a theoretical physicist which seems to fall mostly
into the formal sciences. He did not like
things that were, or at least seemed, unpredictable. Einstein
was very much bothered by chaos, and tried
to find a way to predict, what might in the end, be
unpredictable.
The social sciences are what we are interested in for this class,
and in particular how that knowledge can be
applied to help systems of all sizes (micro, mezzo, and macro).
In other words, Human Services is looking
to apply the methods and findings from social science to
62. improve the lives of people as individuals, in groups
such as families, and in the larger social context of
communities. However, all sciences have much in
common. For example, chaos theory is a branch of
mathematics, which is itself a science, that deals with
conditions where prediction is not possible. [1]
Chaotic diversity not only describes things on the
quantum level (which is what Einstein was
interested in), but also the human condition.
Chaos theory with its origins in mathematics has
implications when working with people that has
only recently been realized [2] [3]. Like Einstein,
we in the Human Services dislike chaos. We want
to find ways of explaining, possibly even
predicting, and preventing human misery.
So, what is Einstein’s message? Einstein is
telling us that we have a rich and imaginative
sensory capability that provides us with a vast
way of experiencing and interpreting our world.
However, from an evolutionary standpoint, it is
built for survival in the heat of the moment, rather
than the cool calculation of empirical analysis
which is by design a longer process. Things like
intuition and instinct are certainly useful. But, we
SYSTEMS THEORY – SYSTEMS ARE USUALLY MADE UP
OF SMALLER COMPONENTS THAT “FIT” INSIDE
THE LARGER ONES.
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES pg. 6
can add science to our toolbox which is what this text is about.
63. With the tool of science, we can explore our
world, social and physical, in a way which allows us to test our
assumptions and theories about the way
things are. Science helps us to increase our rational
understanding of the totality of the world we live in.
We have had some success. Science can not only give us
theories about how people act, it can also test
our assumptions as we will see in the following example of
social science at work.
Who talks more?
Many people believe that women tend to talk more than men—
with some even suggesting that this
difference has a biological basis. One widely cited estimate was
that women spoke 20,000 words per day
on average and men only 7,000. This claim seemed plausible,
but was it true? A group of psychologists led
by Matias Mehl decided to find out. How did they check? They
used a literature review, a powerful tool we
will discuss in depth later on in the text. When they checked
the literature to see if anyone had actually
tried to count the daily number of words spoken by women and
men, no one had. All they found were
theories and assumptions, many of them culturally derived
based on stereotypical beliefs about gender
rather than any real science. The researchers conducted a study
of their own in which a sample of 369
female and male college students wore audio recorders while
they went about their day. The result? The
women spoke an average of 16,215 words per day and the men
spoke an average of 15,669 which was a
difference of just under one percent. It was an extremely small
difference that could easily be explained by
chance. In an article in the journal Science, these researchers
summed up their findings as follows: “We
therefore conclude, on the basis of available empirical evidence,
64. that the widespread and highly publicized
stereotype about female talkativeness is unfounded” (Mehl,
Vazire, Ramirez-Esparza, Slatcher, &
Pennebaker, 2007, p. 82) [4]. Sometimes what we think is true,
just isn’t so.
In this case, we had a working assumption about the way things
are. However, when that theory was
tested it turned out not to be true. What we believe about
people, and how they behave, is fundamental to
effectively working with our clients. This example shows how
what we believe individually or collectively
can sometimes be wrong. Sometimes what we believe is
inaccurate or incomplete. We should keep in
mind that as professionals, whenever possible, we should act
according to the best information that we
have at hand. This means we need to be informed as to what
science has empirically indicated.
[1] Oestreicher C. (2007), Dialogues Clinical Neuroscience.
2007;9(3):279-89.
[2] Chamberlain L. (Editor), Butz, M. (Editor), (1998). Clinical
Chaos: A Therapist's Guide To Non-Linear
Dynamics And Therapeutic Change 1st Edition, Routeledge.
[3] Eenwyk, J, (2012), Clinical Chaos, Inner City Books.
[4] Mehl, M. R., Vazire, S., Ramirez-Esparza, N., Slatcher, R.
B., & Pennebaker, J. W. (2007). Are women
really more talkative than men? Science, 317, 82.
1.1 Understanding Science
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
65. eudoscience and give some examples.
Science & Human Services
Human Services is not a science but a profession, and an
evolving one at that. As such it is
interdisciplinary, drawing not just on our profession’s research,
but also that of our good colleagues in such
diverse disciplines as social work, anthropology, sociology,
education, criminal justice, education, and
nursing to name just a few. Some of those disciplines are
considered to be social sciences, and some like
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES pg. 7
Human Services, are considered to be professions. However,
we are all engaged in research to find the
best possible methods for helping improve the human condition
on practical terms. That is not to say that
Human Service professionals do not engage in the research
process, because we do. Human Services
practice should be based on empirically based information.
That means practice should be research based
whenever possible.
Empirically Based Research
Empirically based practice is considered best practice.
Whenever possible, Human Service practitioners
should strive to use only those techniques, methods, and
approaches in the helping process that are
empirically derived.
66. Empirically based practice means using quality research from
peer reviewed sources in your professional
practice. Professional journals, online databases, and
continuing education, are all ways that we can keep
informed as to what is happening in our field. It also means
assessing the results of your practice, and
doing so in an ethical way. In summary, empirically based
research is the application of empirically derived
best practices into your everyday practice. That is, we have a
moral imperative to use science.
The Emergence of Science and the Scientific Method
The Oxford Dictionaries Online defines the scientific method as
"a method or procedure that has
characterized natural science since the 17th century, consisting
in systematic observation, measurement,
and experiment, and the formulation, testing, and modification
of hypotheses1" Since then, the method has
expanded from the natural sciences into the social sciences to
including such disciplines as anthropology,
sociology, psychology, psychology and such professions as
social work and Human Services.
Francis Bacon (1561-1626) is considered to be the first person
to have conceptualized the scientific
method, but he did so under the influence of other great minds
such as his contemporary Galileo (1564-
1642), and those who came before him such as Copernicus
(1473-1543). But the list goes back even
67. further to the likes of Plato, Socrates, and Aristotle, and even
further back as our ancestors struggled to
make this world (which is such an unpredictable and dangerous
place where disasters still seem like
random happenstance) into a more tolerable and predictable
place to dwell. This led to the ability to make
fire, create shelter, and of course finding something to eat. The
rise of technologies was, in their own time,
no less miraculous to them then than time travel would be to us
now. Otherwise we lived brutish and short
lives. Knowledge was gained slowly but accumulated over the
years, handed down person-to-person
through an oral tradition. The invention of writing and then
printing sped up the process as it became
possible to transmit knowledge across time and space. The
scientific method was just one innovation but
we will focus on it now as it forms the foundation for all
modern research.
We have a legal, moral, and ethical, responsibility to our
profession, ourselves, society, and certainly our
clients to do just that. What are the implications? While not all
Human Service practitioners are engaged
in research, all Human Service practitioners are consumers of
research in their personal and professional
lives. Research is based on a scientific approach to knowledge.
What are the modern features of science?
68. Features of Science
The modern scientific approach has three fundamental features
(Stanovich, 2010):
1. Systematic Empiricism
The first feature is systematic empiricism. Empiricism refers to
learning based on observation. Scientists
learn about the natural and social world systematically, by
carefully planning, making, recording, and
1 "scientific method", Oxford Dictionaries: British and World
English, 2017, retrieved 7 Nov 2017
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES
pg. 8
analyzing observations of it. A lot of what we learn and what
we might know (that may or may not be true)
is actually acquired haphazardly. As we will see, logical
reasoning, and even creativity, play important roles
in science, but scientists are unique in their insistence on
checking ideas about the way the world seems to
be, against more systematic observations. That is, using the
practice of science rather than tradition,
superstition, guessing, or any number of other ways we have of
knowing. Notice, for example, that Mehl
and his colleagues did not trust other people’s stereotypes or
even their own informal observations.
Instead, they systematically recorded, counted, and compared
the number of words spoken by a large
sample of women and men. Furthermore, when their systematic
observations turned out to conflict with
people’s stereotypes, they trusted their systematic observations.
69. 2. The Scientific Approach
Following logically from the first feature is the second feature
which is the scientific approach. It is
concerned with empirical questions. These are questions about
the way the world actually is rather than
what we think it might be, and are answered by systematic
observation. The question of whether women
talk more than men was a simple question that could be
empirically answered but just counting. Either
women really do talk more than men or they do not, and this can
be determined by systematically
observing how much women and men actually talk.
There are many interesting and extremely important questions
that are not empirically testable and that
science cannot answer. Among them are questions about
values—whether things are good or bad, just or
unjust, or beautiful or ugly, and how the world ought to be.
Although the question of whether a stereotype
is accurate or inaccurate is an empirically testable one that
science can answer, the question of whether it
is wrong for people to hold to inaccurate stereotypes is not.
Similarly, the question of whether criminal
behavior has a genetic component is an empirical question, but
the question of what should be done with
people who commit crimes is not. Questions about permitting
the death penalty, abortion, or the
legalization of marijuana are ultimately moral rather than
scientific issues. It is especially important for
researchers in Human Services to be mindful of this distinction.
3. Public Knowledge
The third feature of science is that it creates public knowledge.
After asking their empirical questions,
making their systematic observations, and drawing their
conclusions, scientists publish their work. This
70. usually means writing an article for publication in a
professional journal, in which they put their research
question in the context of previous research, describe in detail
the methods they used to answer their
question, and clearly present their results and conclusions.
These are the kind of articles you use for your
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES
pg. 9
research papers, and the kinds of articles that should be
informing your practice with clients. Earlier we
discussed how we progressed from an oral tradition, to the
written word, and then to printing. We noted
that the venerable art of printing allowed for knowledge to be
transferable through time and space. It was
more reliable, durable, and transportable. Knowledge was
spread far and wide. We have now come to the
digital age, maybe even past it, which has exponentially
increased the growth of knowledge as well as the
speed it is created and disseminated. While this is generally
considered progress, we will soon discuss new
problems which have arisen because of new communication
technologies such as social media, and
massive online databases. One thing that has not
changed is that knowledge dies if it is not passed on, and
now that is through publication in whatever form be it,
print or digital.
Publication is an essential feature of science for
two reasons:
1. Science is a social process—a large scale
collaboration among many researchers distributed across
71. both time and space. Our current scientific knowledge of
most topics is based on many different studies conducted
by many different researchers who have shared their
work with each other over the years.
2. Publication allows science to be self-correcting.
Individual scientists understand that despite their best
efforts, their methods can be flawed and their
conclusions incorrect.
Publication allows others in the scientific community to
detect and correct these errors so that, over time,
scientific knowledge increasingly reflects the way the
world actually is. If the findings of a research study
cannot be reproduced elsewhere, then there is a problem
with the original study. The ability of scientist to replicate
what others do is how scientific findings are ultimately
verified.
Science Versus Pseudoscience
Pseudoscience refers to activities and beliefs that are claimed to
be scientific by their proponents—and
may appear to be scientific at first glance—but are not.
Consider the theory of biorhythms (not to be
confused with sleep cycles or other biological cycles that do
have a scientific basis). The idea is that
people’s physical, intellectual, and emotional abilities run in
cycles that begin when they are born and
continue until they die. The physical cycle has a period of 23
days, the intellectual cycle a period of 33
days, and the emotional cycle a period of 28 days. So, for
example, if you had the option of when to
schedule an exam, you would want to schedule it for a time
when your intellectual cycle will be at a high
point. The theory of biorhythms has been around for more than
100 years, and you can find numerous
popular books and websites about biorhythms, often containing
72. impressive and scientific-sounding terms
like sinusoidal wave and bioelectricity. The problem with
biorhythms, however, is that there is no good
reason to think they exist (Hines, 1998).
A set of beliefs or activities can be said to be pseudoscientific if
adherents claim or imply that it is scientific
but it lacks one or more of the three features of science. It
might lack systematic empiricism. Either there is
no relevant scientific research or, as in the case of biorhythms,
there is relevant scientific research but it is
ignored. It might also lack public knowledge. People who
promote the beliefs or activities might claim to
have conducted scientific research but never publish that
research in a way that allows others to evaluate
it.
WOOD CUT OF AN EARLY PRINTING PRESS. 1
IN THE PUBLIC DOMAIN:
HTTPS://COMMONS.WIKIMEDIA.ORG/WIKI/FILE:PRINTER
_IN_1568-
CE.PNG
RESEARCH FOR HUMAN SERVICES
pg. 10
Karl Popper
A set of beliefs and activities might also be pseudoscientific
because it does not address empirical questions.
The philosopher Karl Popper was especially concerned
with this idea (Popper, 2002). He argued more specifically