In May 2013, a group of user experience (UX) designers traveled to Vancouver, B.C. at their own expense to do something that has never been done before: use design thinking principles to invent new ways to "educate the heart".
Partnering with the Dalai Lama Center, leading scientists, school district officials, teachers, parents and students, the designers took on two challenges...
1. Seek ways to embed the "teaching of the heart" into interactions that take place between children and adults
2. Investigate what the school system could do to embed social and emotional learning into the relationships between student and student, child and child
The designers that presented to the Dalai Lama Center, education experts and other stakeholders included...
Davide Casali (@folletto)
Marie-Claire Dean (@missmcj)
Carolyn Chandler (@chanan)
Patrick DiMichele (@theparanoids)
Lee-Sean Huang (@leesean)
Wil Kristin (@wilkristin)
Jason Kunesh (@jdkunesh)
Emily Luke (@emilyeatskale)
Greg Melander (@gregmelander)
Dan Saimo (@dansaimo)
Judy Siegel (@gqjudy)
Brian Winters (@bwinters)
The crew of instigators...
Jason Ulaszek (@ux4good)
Jeff Leitner (@insightlabs)
Chris Kelly (@dalailamacenter)
Andrew Benedict-Nelson (@benedictnelson)
Howell Malham (@howellmalham)
Jim Jacoby (@jjacoby)
Brad Smith (@webvisions)
Yarrow Kraner (@hatchexperience)
4. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
INTRODUCTION
A ‘heartfelt’ thank you!
4
5. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
INTRODUCTION
The Designers
Brian Winters
Jason Kunesh
Emily Luke
Marie-Claire Dean
Greg Melander
Davide Casali
Lee-Sean Huang
Patrick DiMichele
Judy Siegel
Wil Kristin
Dan Saimo
Carolyn Chandler
5
6. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
INTRODUCTION
The Instigators
Jason Ulaszek
Jeff Leitner
Chris Kelly
Andrew Benedict-Nelson
Howell Malham
Jim Jacoby
Brad Smith
Yarrow Kraner
6
7. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
INTRODUCTION
Our Challenge
• Seek ways to embed the "teaching of the heart"
into interactions that take place between
children and adults
• Investigate what the school system could do to
embed social and emotional learning into the
relationships between student and student, child
and child
7
8. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
INTRODUCTION
Our Process
• Day 1: Research and immersion
• Day 2: Research and immersion
• Day 3: Synthesis
• Day 4: Presentation and discussion
8
9. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
INTRODUCTION
By the Numbers...
• 30+ interviews with DLC members, school administrators,
teachers, conference attendees and students
• 200+ hours of primary and secondary research
• 1,000s of Post-Its, sketches and visioning documents
• Dozens of ideas for building traction in the community
• 4 kindergarten sing-alongs (yes, really)
• 32 karaoke songs observed (sympathy, not empathy)
• Full compliment of feelings (oddly, no crying)
9
45. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
REFLECTION
Re-shape the challenge
• How to embed social and emotional learning into
children's school experience.
• We re-organized the two teams into one team
during synthesis to share insights, then split into
pairs to tackle each part of the challenge.
45
47. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
REFLECTION
Stories
• Stories translate data into meaning
• Parents tell their story, not outcome
data. Empower them
• Stories must transmit data and
emotion
47
49. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
REFLECTION
Design Principles
• Be empathetic with the people you’re
trying to convince
• Don’t feed the trolls, build your community
• Establish a controlled, neutral vocabulary
for mindful social emotional outreach
• Find low cost solutions that build on
available infrastructure
49
51. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
REFLECTION
Building awareness & action
• Activate your influencers to activate your
message
• Identify community champions and give
them actionable information
• Invite policy makers to the movement, but
give parents the baton
• Massive scale comes from 1 on 1 human
interactions
51
55. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
REFLECTION
Constraints framework
55
Now
Root
Easy
Analog
Free
Single
Local
Future
Leaf
Hard
Digital
Expensive
Many
Global
60. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
REFLECTION
Validation framework
• Develop baselines using current metrics
• Difficulty & importance
• Depth: enrich experience of existing programs
• Breadth: Expand the breadth of the Mindful
Education movement
• Use these vectors to help choose your first
projects
60
62. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
Brand Values
"In the Snake Sutra, the Buddha also tells us that the
Dharma is a raft we can use to cross the river and get
to the other shore. But after we have crossed the
river, if we continue to carry the raft on our
shoulders, that would be foolish. "The raft is not the
shore." He said: "Bhikkhus, I have told you many
times the importance of knowing when it is time to
let go of a raft and not hold onto it unnecessarily."
62
63. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
Brand Values
Scale means relinquishing control.
63
64. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
Brand Values
Teach mindfulness by being mindful, not preaching
mindfulness. Appeal to emotion to tell the story of
the importance of emotional education.
64
65. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
Brand Values
Both branding and mindfulness are exercises in
subtraction, removing clutter to get to foundational
truths.
65
66. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
How?
Use language and terms that appeal to broad or
global audiences; avoid trigger words that can
impact the implementation of the tools, programs
and products.
66
67. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013 67
You teach who you are.
- Maria LeRose
68. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
How?
Implement using the tools and resources that you
have. Don't try to create new policy frameworks.
68
69. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
BRAND VALUES
How?
To achieve your goals, the messaging platform
needs to take a neutral, secular focus.
69
91. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
Toolbox Intention & Goals
• Deliver information to help people better
understand the benefits of mindfulness.
• Centralize resources to help people easily infuse
mindfulness into their lives and classrooms.
• Facilitate sharing to help people find and use
ideas and activities that encourage mindfulness.
• Jumpstart conversations to help people
introduce mindfulness within their community.
• Foster engagement to move people from
awareness, to implementation to advocacy to
evangelism.
92. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
Inside the Toolbox
• Activities
• How-to Guides
• Dialogue
• Community
• Support
93. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
Toolbox Shapes and Sizes
Poster Website Mobile Hand-out
96. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
Meet Teacher Tamara
Background and context:
• Tamara has witnessed the benefits of
mindfulness in the classrooms of her
peers and would like to learn more.
• Her goal is to learn the basics and find
quick and easy ways to experiment.
• Tamara doesn’t have much time to take
away from the classroom to implement
a program.
• She needs to see how mindfulness can
fit into her existing approach.
• If she gets positive results, she’ll be
back to learn and explore more.
97. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
Teacher Tamara can:
• Learn about the benefits of
mindfulness in a friendly and
accessible way; Read stories
about its impact.
• Utilize teacher, how-to and
implementation guides
explaining process, concepts
and intended outcomes.
• Find classroom activities
organized by categories of
the Heart & Mind Index.
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
1. Gathering Information
98. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
Get Along with Others
Compassionate and Kind
Peaceful
Secure and Calm
Attentive and Engaged
99. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
Comment
Pretend to be an animal.
Be an animal for a minute. Then, sit down
and be still for a few moments. Breathe in
and then release letting out an “Ahhh...”
Suggested Duration: 2-3 Minutes
Suggested Frequency: Weekly
Suggested Age: 4-8
100. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
BRAIN BREAK
Pretend to be an
animal.
101. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
Teacher Tamara can:
• Find exercises and
inspirations suggested by
peers and practitioners.
• Provide feedback and
testimonials on the
exercises she incorporates.
• Contribute her own
experiences and ideas.
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
2. Explore content, engage peers.
103. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
HEART-SHAPED TOOLBOX
3. Tell stories, spread the word.
Teacher Tamara can create
talking points intended to:
• Engage inquisitive parents
• Support peer teachers
• Advocate to administrators
109. VANCOUVER, B.C. | MAY 9-12, 2013
COMMUNITY ALLIES
Small commitments, big results
• People have a strong drive to appear consistent
in their behaviors.
• Once they’ve agreed to something, they’re more
willing to commit to new things in line with it.
• In a 1987 study participants were asked, “Are you
voting tomorrow?” 100% said yes. About 87% of
them did, compared to 61% of those not asked.
122. MEASUREMENT
Can help us be mindful.
By making the unseen visible and actionable.
Data can help us make better decisions.
123. GOAL
The goal of measurement is to
be more aware of what is going
on so we can take appropriate
actions for kids and this
program. In other words, we
need to create a feedback loop.
124. CONSIDERATIONS
Easy – easy and natural ways to
capture the data
Trusted – authoritative &
accurate
Privacy – use the data to help
not hurt. At some point
anonymous & private
125. MEASURE WHAT?
Students
1. Heart & Mind Index (Clyde Hertzman)
2. Effectiveness of the Program for kids education
What else should we measure for…?
Teachers
Parents
Schools
Communities
126. THE FEEDBACK LOOP
CHECK IN
AWARENESS
LEARN Student
Teacher Parents
School
Community
Awareness,
Support,
Value
Funding
128. THE PITCH
Problem
Students have a habit of negative thoughts and
poor grades.
Solution – The Motivator
What if there was an easy way to capture the pulse
of students and Direct resources to help the
problems
Outcome
Happier more educated children contributing to
society in a meaningful way.
141. Policy Media Business /
Professions
Research
Social /
Cultural Influences
Neighbourhood
Community
Parents Children
and
Youth
Educators
Parent
and
Child
Parent
and
Educator
Child
and
Educator
The Socially
and Emotionally
Capable
Young
Person