Subsurface Placement - Opportunities And Considerations - Trey Colley, from the 2018 Conservation Tillage and Technology Conference, March 6 - 7, Ada, OH, USA.
More presentations at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZBwPfKdlk4SB63zZy16kyA
2. 2
Trey Colley
Graduate Research Assistant
Department of Food, Agricultural,
and Biological Engineering
Originally from AL.
Passion for ag technologies,
data, profitability.
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
About me:
3. 3
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
Did you place any nutrients
subsurface in 2017?
a) Yes
b) No
6. 6
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
Which method of water loss has
greater nutrient concentrations?
a) Overland Runoff
b) Sub-surface Drainage
7. 7
Food, Agricultural and Biological
Engineering
Modes of Action for Nutrient Losses
1. Overland Runoff
1. Exposed Particles
2. Stratified Soil Erosion
2. Sub-surface Drainage
1. Macropore Movement
2. Drainage
Overland Higher P concentrations
Sub-surface Higher total loads
(Pease et al., 2018)
9. 9
Food, Agricultural and Biological
Engineering
1. Overland Runoff
• Particles
• Stratification
• Placing MAP below the soil surface
reduced losses by 98%
(Smith et al., 2016)
10. 10
Food, Agricultural and Biological
Engineering
1. Overland Runoff
• Particles
• Stratification
0-2 in
6-8 in
2-6 in
*Percent of total
sample P
Core Depth
(inches)
57%
29%
14%
11. 11
Food, Agricultural and Biological
Engineering
Sub-surface Movement
(Williams et al., 2017)
Macropores Drainage
(Lindsay Pease, USDA-ARS)
16. 16
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
1. Ground Engaging Implement
Precise Placement
2. Fertilizer Applicator
Accurate Metering
Accurate Distribution
Sub-surface Equipment Set-up
1 2
17. 17
C. High Speed with
Injection
15% or less disturbance
B. Zone Mixing with
Fertilizer Injection
A. Deep Rip and
Placement
40% or less disturbance
1. Ground Engaging Implement – Surface Tillage
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
18. 18
C. High Speed with
Injection
B. Zone Mixing with
Fertilizer Injection
A. Deep Rip and
Placement
1. Ground Engaging Implement – Sub-surface Disturbance
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
19. 19
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
Which equipment style is most
suitable for use on your farm today?
a) Deep Rip and Placement
b) Zone Mixing
c) Injection Placement
d) Broadcast and Incorporate
27. 27
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
Planting Depth
Seedbed Preparation – Case Study
No-Till 8” Strip-Till
28. 28
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
• Placement that benefits early
growth, strong roots
• In some instances, yield
increases have been shown
1. Nutrient Uptake
8 in
6 in
V5
P
29. 29
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
• Ride Quality
• Optimal Emergence
• Downforce control helps
2. Planter Performance
31. 31
Food, Agricultural, and Biological
Engineering
What are the biggest barriers to sub-
surface adoption on your farm?
a) Time
b) Equipment Limitations
c) Added cost of application
d) Other
32. 32
Implementation
• Time
• Field capacity
• Equipment limitations
• Increased application cost
Field Operations
1. Till
2. Fertilize
3. Incorporate
4. Plant
5. Manage
6. Harvest
1. Sub-surface placement
2. Plant
3. Manage
4. Harvest
33. 33
Take-a-ways
• Sub-surface equipment getting more popular
• Many tools available, not all suitable for your farm
• Opportunities for implementation today
• Many innovations to come
35. 35
Questions?
Trey Colley
Ohio State Precision Ag Program
(205) 213-8519
Colley.65@osu.edu
Follow along:
Twitter: @OhioStatePA
Facebook: @OhiostatePA
Editor's Notes
We know we have some issues, how can we as producers make a difference? Lot’s of finger pointing that goes around.
Note the sediment losses
Removes the potential for particles to be washed off – 98% reduction in DRP at agricultural outlets
Stratification – highly concentrated soils moved off site
Removes the potential for particles to be washed off – 98% reduction in DRP at agricultural outlets
Stratification – highly concentrated soils moved off site
Removes the potential for particles to be washed off – 98% reduction in DRP at agricultural outlets
Stratification – highly concentrated soils moved off site
Mean dissolved reactive P (DRP) concentration for the broadcast, inject, and till treatments
Installed lysimeter under a 1 m2 square of soil to test the effect of sub-surface placement on drainage quality
Also, traditional drainage through soil profile – least concentrated of the drainages
Spreader applications in long-term no till can build stratified soils
Till Fertilize Plant Spray Harvest
Make sub-surface work for your farm.
Consider your current nutrient plan, see how you can work it in.
Why are you interested in sub-surface application?
Sub-surface is difficult to implement: takes patience, and an all-in approach
Have some degree of customization
Determines final placement, not only influence on placement put primary driver in how fert is distributed.
Ensures that right rate/blend arrives at the opening on implement – Rate
Distribution – rate/placement
Precision nutrient management.
Rate checks, important to understand that these units are putting out accurate rates
When applying in blend, do a simple check on blend quality
Most systems are capable of making and holdling rate throughout, but check row by row variations.
Challenge you to think about what your resulting seedbed environment looks like after this operation.
No-Till vs ST – 2017 WARS
Soil compaction impedes root growth at 200 PSI (Red)
Planting at 1.75” Look at environment seed is starting it’s life in
Fertilizer placement
No-till, top 0-3” of soil, induces stratification
Strip-till, primed for optimal growth nutrients ready for uptake
Root growth/health
Pushing sub-surface placement – WLEB nutrient concerns, greater FUE
Planter performance, emergence, single pass savings
Reducing compaction, shatter zone
Pushing sub-surface placement – WLEB nutrient concerns, greater FUE
Planter performance, emergence, single pass savings
Reducing compaction, shatter zone
Compaction levels from the downforce study
Demo day, learned a lot about the unit
Nutrient management becoming more of a focus in agriculture across the board.
Sub-surface offers a toolset to accomplish responsible nutrient management.
Tools coming out that enable better placement, operation dependent.
Lot’s of opportunities for adoption outside of strictly “sub-surface placement”
Will be exciting to see innovations and how these products evolve.
Looking forward to a good year:
A few issues during the fall
VRT field was first one up, was behind at harvest and missed window.
Looking forward to a good year:
A few issues during the fall
VRT field was first one up, was behind at harvest and missed window.