Peer reviews should provide feedback to a peer on the criteria expected in the paper. The
Week 8 Feedback Form
can be downloaded from the Appendices section of the course guide by clicking the link
here
. Follow these instructions:
For Online Students:
Choose a classmate's paper from the "Easy Drop off/Pick up Zone" discussion thread in the course shell.
Obtain the Peer Review Feedback Form from the course shell.
Comment on all criteria, noting strengths and / or areas for improvement on the feedback form.
Provide completed Peer Review Feedback Form by posting it to the same "Easy Drop off/Pick up Zone" discussion thread AND submitting it to the Peer Review Assignment link above.
Appendix A: Peer Review Feedback Form 2
Reviewer’s Name: _
Date: __
Writer’s Assigned #: _
Course:____
Section:__
Assignment
4:
PersuasivePaper
Part
2:
Solution
and Advantages
Peer
reviews
should
provide
feedback
toapeeronthe
criteria
expectedinthe
paper.
Followthese
instructions:
1)
Receive
aclassmate’spaper
from
your
professor(inclass
if
on-ground;
by
e-mail
if
online).
2)
Copy
thePeerReviewFeedback
Form
from
the
Appendix.
3)
Comment
on
allcriteria,notingstrengths
and
/
or
areasforimprovement
on
thefeedbackform.
4)
Provide
completedPeerReviewFeedback
Form
and
classmate’s
paperto
your
professor.
Note
:
On-groundstudents
should
submit
the
feedbackform
and
papertotheprofessorduringthe
class
meetingin
which
thepaper
is
reviewed;
online
students
should
submit
the
feedback
form
and
paper
totheprofessorviatheAssignmentTab
in
thecourseshell.
Criteria
+ Strengths
Comments < Areas for Improvement
Part 1
1. Revise,
using
feedback
from
the
professor
and
classmates,
your
Persuasive
PaperPart I- A
Problem
Exists.
Part 2
2.
Included
a
defensible,
relevant
thesis
statement
clearly
in
the
first
paragraph.
3.
Explain
a
detailed,
viable
solution
that
supports
your
thesis.
This
should
be
one
or
two
(1-2)
paragraphs.
4. State,
explain,
and
support
the
first
advantage
(economic,
social,
political,
environmental,
social,
equitable,
ethical/moral,
etc.)
to
your
solution.
This
should
be
one
or
two
(1-2)
paragraphs.
5. State,
explain,
and
support
the
second
advantage
(economic,
social,
political,
environmental,
social,
equitable,
ethical/moral,
etc.)
to
your
solution.
This
should
be
one
or
two
(1-2)
paragraphs.
6.
State, explain, and support the third (and fourth if desired) advantage (economic, social, political, environment, social, equitable, ethical/moral, etc.) to your solution. This should be one or two (1-2) paragraphs.
7. Use effective transitional words, phrases, and sentences.
8.
Provide
a
concluding
paragraph
/transitional
paragraph
that
summarizes
the
proposed
solution
and
its
advantages.
9. Develop a coherently structured paper with an introduction, body, and conclusion.
10. Use one or more rhetorical strategies (ethos, logos, pathos) to explain advantages.
11. Support
advantage
cla.
Peer reviews should provide feedback to a peer on the .docx
1. Peer reviews should provide feedback to a peer on the criteria
expected in the paper. The
Week 8 Feedback Form
can be downloaded from the Appendices section of the course
guide by clicking the link
here
. Follow these instructions:
For Online Students:
Choose a classmate's paper from the "Easy Drop off/Pick up
Zone" discussion thread in the course shell.
Obtain the Peer Review Feedback Form from the course shell.
Comment on all criteria, noting strengths and / or areas for
improvement on the feedback form.
Provide completed Peer Review Feedback Form by posting it to
the same "Easy Drop off/Pick up Zone" discussion thread AND
submitting it to the Peer Review Assignment link above.
Appendix A: Peer Review Feedback Form 2
Reviewer’s Name: _
Date: __
Writer’s Assigned #: _
Course:____
Section:__
11. (1-2)
paragraphs.
6.
State, explain, and support the third (and fourth if desired)
advantage (economic, social, political, environment, social,
equitable, ethical/moral, etc.) to your solution. This should be
one or two (1-2) paragraphs.
7. Use effective transitional words, phrases, and sentences.
8.
Provide
a
concluding
paragraph
/transitional
paragraph
that
12. summarizes
the
proposed
solution
and
its
advantages.
9. Develop a coherently structured paper with an introduction,
body, and conclusion.
10. Use one or more rhetorical strategies (ethos, logos, pathos)
to explain advantages.
11. Support
advantage
claims
with
at
least
14. and the chosen one
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to show you that possibly
through proper taxation and implementation the government
could help set up some sort of healthcare system for those who
are effected by alcohol and smoking related illness, through
either direct access or secondhand means.
(Did double spacing so as to separate abstract from actual paper
for page number purposes).
Throughout the many years of service I have committed to a top
pharmacy in the nation, I have spoken to many people regarding
their use of cigarettes and alcohol. Why do they smoke/drink?
What kind do they like? Their favorite time of day to smoke?
Just to ring the amount of smoking to their attention to help
raise awareness of smoking, to no avail for the most part. Over
the years I have noticed the toll these have taken on my
everyday customers, from the mental dependence on the two to
the physical detriments that it can cause. More and more I see
customers come in to get medication to treat the ailments that
15. these vices could cause. Paying out of pocket on some
medication costing a lot, often I found myself asking myself the
question “What if we taxed the two too and use the money on
programs that will help the population deal with whatever issue
they may need help with?”
When nearly 1 out of every five people you know will
develop some smoking-related disease (Jamal, 2015) wouldn’t
you want them to have some support system to help the recover
or rehabilitate the issue that would be present? From personal
experience I have seen the hardship such a detrimental disease
could have on one person body and pocketbook. I am sure you
know someone who may be suffering from the symptom that
these diseases can cause. Then for the alcohol related side you
have 30 percent of eligible drinkers don’t drink at all, another
30 percent drinks less than one per week. As for the opposite
end, the top 10 percent of drinkers consume an average of 74
drinks a week (Ingraham, 2014). These binge drinking, or even
just moderate drinking over time, can cause serious health
effects like cirrhosis, which can cause your liver to fail. It is the
leading cause (1 in 3) for liver transplants in the United States
(Singal, 2013).
Another issue that comes with large consumptions of anything
(tobacco or alcohol) can lead to a mental dependence on it
called “Addiction.” Addiction to Alcohol and tobacco is pretty
common amongst those who consume them. This addiction can
16. be fierce when trying to get over them; some people can shirk it
like no problem while others go through the fire and back
(because of the detox they may come from the ability not have
them no more). These are treated with programs that are
designed to help the individual overcome the nasty addiction.
One of the biggest programs set up to help combat alcohol
addiction is AA (Alcohol Anonymous). This group (based on
the book published in 1939) was specifically created to help
those who have had a bad experience due to the addiction or
who are having a hard time beating the addiction on their own.
They use a 12 step process which focuses on the individual with
a strong support system; they typically are non-professional
everyday persons like us who are trying to help people help
themselves as well as working on themselves too.
Nicotine is treated mainly by oneself, or with the help
(encouragement) of others. Some people have the ability to go
cold turkey and not have a problem with it. Though for some it
is a much harder task to accomplish, for some it takes the push
of others to get them to quit, but for many, they have to seek
further help to quit. The help usually received is a talk with the
doctor and knowledge about the smoking cessation options
(nicotine gum, nicotine lozenges/patches). If they feel like
further help may be needed than there is help in the form of
behavioral therapy. (C, 2015)
Another issue that comes to mind of selling alcohol and tobacco
17. is why are we selling things that harm our customers, not in the
immediate but the long term, how is that okay? Selling
something that harms your customer is just bad business and not
to mention morally wrong. You want your customers to come
back, healthy, not to mention alive.
Over the six years of customer service experience, I have had
the time to look into the things that have intrigued me. Taxes
have always intrigued me because we don’t know the exact
percentage we are paying in taxes with every transaction, for
instance, did you know that when cigarettes were first
introduced they were only taxed at .8 cents, then again this was
back in 1864 (Fontinelle, 2009). It is currently taxed at roughly
$1.01. These have been known to cause cancer and other severe
health defects in both the smokers and those around the smoker
through secondhand smoke. Alcohol has been the drink of man
for decades, and that too is taxed based upon type (spirit, wine,
and beer). My state adopted the spirit tax in 1935 (CA). The
current tax being $3.30 per gallon of spirits (Alcohol rate,
2006). Why can’t we increase this, if any a little, to help pay for
the rising medical cost?
(ADVANTAGES) Raising the taxes could help benefits
numerous people in both first-hand manners and then again in
an offhand type of way. The three ways in which I believe we
could help people are:
18. 1.
Raising taxes on them to help pay for the increasing medical
expenses: Throughout the years the cost of everything is slowly
but surely increasing, this includes the cost of medical services
and equipment/materials. The biggest cause for the reason of a
91% increase in the cost of medical care is was an increase in
the cost of the prescription medications, cost increase of
medical devices and the increase of the care upon hospital visit.
More than 16 million are living with a smoking-related disease,
which costs a total of $300 Billion each year, $170 billion is
used for direct medical related health problems for adults, with
another $5.6 billion being used for secondhand smoke
purposes.
According to research a 10 % increase in overall price decreases
smoking by 3 to 5 percent (C, 2016).
2.
Tax revenue used elsewhere: Roughly the US government get 30
million (federally) in money off of taxes from the current tax. If
we increased the taxes, the money could not only be used in the
programs you open it up with, but also on other much-needed
programs that could help people in other health aspects, such as
mental, or disability health. Just a 5 percent increase could help
lower the number of smokers (which will lower overall cost of
19. medical expenses because of less smokers) as well raising an
additional 1.5 million which could go to great lengths to help
these non-profit originations, which just barely scrape by.
3.
Raising taxes passive effect: Through raising taxes, studies have
proven that it can help reduce the number of smokers or alcohol
abusers. Within the nation. We can check this out by the simple
conclusion on if the revenue is declining on the taxes then they
must not be buying them as much, so that is why the revenue is
declining (Cole, 2015).
4.
(Critical thinking making connections, please review professor)-
Raising the taxes will help the poor save money in an offhand
way. By raising the taxes it would have a more profound
outcome on the poor since they will still be buying them (if they
can) and they literally have a limited budget, when compared to
someone more well off, the .$25 to $.50 extra per pack will
eventually add up to a sum in which they could not afford to
smoke till the next pay day and then it will continue to go that
way, while compared to the more well off person who could
afford it would continue with their addiction or habit.
Here is where they may benefit (depending upon outlook)
because they would have to stop smoking due to financial
20. reasons, their health will/ may get better because of health
reasons for not smoking, the general overall health should
improve, and on top of that since they would not be able to
afford their cigarettes they may be able to use that money on
improving their lives (Remler,2004).
5.
Add the tax to road tickets- We could add a small tax on all
tickets served and call it a “public service tax.” This may work
because of the fact that it would be a further deterrent to all the
people who frequently break the laws of the road. And by
paying the ticket. they are contributing to something that would
better someone else life.
All of the above health detriments should be reason enough
alone to want to help your friends if not just the random person
who may not be able to afford the healthcare needed for the
treatments of smoking and alcohol-related illness, and if
somehow the revenue gets ahead we can place extra tax revenue
not being spent on these programs and put it towards other
public healthcare programs so as to help with whatever is facing
society today. I feel programs like these are essential to our
society to show that we care for each other.
From the way I see it according to the math and the layout
possibilities, this is very much possible. The profound use of
monies obtained through these taxes could be the edge many
21. people need to stop drinking (or at least consume less) due to
awareness and group that can help them work through their
drinking issues.
I feel like this isn’t about a question of if a tax should be added
to the two products in question, but rather should we apply a tax
on something that isn’t healthy for you so as to help those who
become unhealthy from it later? This shouldn’t be a hard
question since it “should” be human nature to want to help
people out, but that is found very rarely today, this will provide
us the opportunity to give back with a little effort from us, and
if the customers don’t want to help pay the tax then they just
don’t have to buy the product.
22. References
Stone, L. (2014, August 5). When Did Your State Adopt Its Tax
on Distilled Spirits? Retrieved August 05, 2016, from
http://taxfoundation.org/blog/when-did-your-state-adopt-its-tax-
distilled-spirits
Alcohol Rates 2000-2010, 2013-2015. (2006, December 07).
Retrieved August 05, 2016, from
http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/alcohol-rates-2000-
2010-2013-2015
Cole, A. (2015, May 8). Federal Tobacco Tax Revenues are
declining. Retrieved August 05, 2016, from
http://taxfoundation.org/blog/federal-tobacco-tax-revenues-are-
declining
Jamal, A. (2015, November 13). Current Cigarette Smoking
Among Adults — United States, 2005–2014. Retrieved August
06, 2016, from
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6444a2.htm?
s_cid=mm6444a2_w
Singal, A. (2013, March 13). Using PubMed. Retrieved August
06, 2016, from
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?cmd=search
C, C. D. (2015). Quitting Smoking. Retrieved August 21, 2016,
from
23. http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/cessatio
n/quitting/
C, C. D. (2016, July 18). Economic Facts About U.S. Tobacco
Production and Use. Retrieved August 21, 2016, from
http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/economi
cs/econ_facts/
Remler, D. K. (2004, February). Poor Smokers, Poor Quitters,
and Cigarette Tax Regressivity. Retrieved August 21, 2016,
from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1448232/