“The burden of mental
disorders, such as depression
and anxiety, fall
disproportionately on women of
childbearing and childrearing
age.”
Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 2007
Rates of severe mental illness similar between
men and women, but differences in diagnoses,
age of onset, course.
 Rates of Major Depression and Dysthymia are
about twice as high for women as for men
 Prevalence rates for most Anxiety Disorders
(panic disorder, agoraphobia, specific phobia,
GAD, PTSD) are 2-3x higher in women
(exceptions are OCD and social phobia: rates
are =)
 Bipolar Disorder – Type I rates = in men and
women, Type II women > men
› More mixed episodes, rapid cycling
› Later age of onset, more depressive episodes
 Schizophrenia – Lifetime prevalence = in men and
women.
› Women have later age of onset (25-35) with bimodal
distribution
› Higher premorbid functioning and social functioning
› More “benign” course
 Eating Disorders – Anorexia Nervosa 95% female;
Bulimia 80% female
 Substance Abuse : Men 2-4 x more likely to
have dx of substance abuse or dependence
› Women with affective illness more vulnerable
 Personality Disorders:
› Women > Men in Borderline, Histrionic (?)
› Men > Women in Antisocial, Narcissistic,
Obsessive-Compulsive
0
5
10
15
20
25
MDE DD SAD PMDD BPD
Female
Male
 Biologic Vulnerability
 Reproductive Events
 Psychosocial Factors
 Gender based violence (rape, sexual abuse,
domestic violence)
 Socioeconomic status
 Caregiving responsibilities, multiple roles
 Menstrual Cycle
 Infertility
 Pregnancy
 Postpartum Period
 Menopausal Transition/Perimenopause
 Hormonal Therapies
 Higher incidence of MDD in women starting at
puberty, less marked post-menopause
 Suicidal behavior may be more common in low
estrogen states
 5% rate of PMDD
 Rates of postpartum admissions and psychosis
elevated immediately after childbirth
 Perimenopausal mood d/o’s vs. post-
menopause
Kessler et al, 1993 (National Comorbidity Survey)
Fig. 1. Phases of the menstrual cycle positively correlated with suicide attempts and
changes in oestrogen concentration during the cycle. * Denotes studies where results were
statistically significant. Saunders et al, 2006
 Estrogen
 Progesterone
 FSH
 LH
 Testosterone
 HCG
 Prolactin
E2
PROG 
MAO / COMT
E2  MAO & COMT -  5HT
PROG  MAO & COMT -  SHT
MAO: Monoamine Oxidase
COMT: Catechol-O-Methyl
Transferase
5HT: Serotonin
TRYP
5HT Re-uptake Site
5HT
Estroge
n
Psychological Symptoms
 Depression
 Anger, Irritability
 Affective lability
 Anxiety
 Sensitivity to rejection
 Poor concentration
 Sense of feeling
overwhelmed
 Social withdrawal
Physical Symptoms
 Lethargy or fatigue
 Sleep disturbance
(usually hypersomnia)
 Appetite disturbance
(usually increased)
 Abdominal bloating
 Breast tenderness
 Muscle aches, joint pain
 Swelling of extremities
 Affects 3-8% of menstruating women
 Symptoms begin during Luteal Phase,
resolve completely with onset of menses
 ≥5 symptoms in most cycles
 Marked decrease in social or occupational
functioning
 Distinguish from underlying mood disorder
(no symptoms Follicular Phase)
 Abnormal serotonin neurotransmission?
 Lifestyle interventions, exercise
 Calcium, Vit B6, Magnesium, Vit E
 Herbal remedies (chasteberry)
 Psychotherapy
 SSRI’s (fluoxetine, paroxetine, sertraline)
› Immediate effect
› Intermittent vs. continuous dosing
 Hormonal therapies
 Increased risk for first episode depression
during menopausal transition
 Lower risk for first episode depression in
post-menopausal women
 Women with a history of depression remain
at risk for future episodes
 Estrogen replacement effective for mild
symptoms, but not Major Depression
Is pregnancy a time of emotional
wellbeing for women?
 Pregnancy is NOT protective against psychiatric
illness
 Rates of Major Depression during pregnancy
10-15% Anxiety disorders may be higher.
 High rate of relapse when antidepressant
medications are stopped during pregnancy
(~50-70%)
 Pregnant Bipolar women have same risk for
relapse off meds as non-pregnant Bipolar
women. Post partum risk 4x higher.
 Past history of depression
 Poor overall health
 Greater alcohol use
 Smoking
 Being unmarried
 Unemployment
 Lower education level
Level of suffering – for mom and partner
Decreased ability to care for herself and the
pregnancy – suicide risk in severe cases
Increased risk for pre-term delivery,
preeclampsia, and low birth weight
Higher rates of smoking, alcohol and substance
use
Risk of post-partum depression, negative effects
on child and family
Non-Pharmacologic Treatments:
 Psychotherapy
 Light Therapy
 Omega-3 Fatty Acids
 Psychosocial supports
Psychotropic Medications in Pregnancy – are
they safe?
 No Psychotropics are FDA-approved for use
during pregnancy
 All medications cross the placenta
 Principals of management: maximize non-
medication options, minimize exposure to
meds and to depression
 Teratogenesis
› No increase in overall rate of fetal malformations
› Some evidence linking inc risk of rare defects (i.e.
paroxetine and cardiac malformations)
 Pregnancy Outcomes
› Mixed evidence on birth weight, early pregnancy loss,
preterm labor (depression effects?)
 Neonatal Toxicity
› Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome
› Persistent Pulmonary Hypertension of the Newborn
 Long-term effects
› No evidence to date of long-term developmental effects in
children exposed in utero
“Baby
Blues”
Postpartum
Depression
Postpartum
Psychosis
Y axis: Rates of psychiatric hospitalization
X axis: Years pre- and post- childbirth
“When I delivered the placenta, I felt like I fell off
a cliff.”
 Occurs in 50-85% of women
 Characterized by mood lability, tearfulness,
anxiety and irritability
 Symptoms peak at day 4-5
 May last a few hours to several days
 Symptoms do not interfere with functioning
 Reassurance rather than treatment
 If symptoms persist > 2 weeks, patient should
be evaluated for a more serious mood disorder
 Occurs in 1-2 per 1000 women
 Onset 24hrs – 3 weeks postpartum
 Rapid mood swings, insomnia, obsessive thoughts
 Delusions, hallucinations, impaired reality testing.
Delusions involving infant are common
 Shifting mental status , disorientation, confusion,
disorganized behavior
 High risk of suicide and/or infanticide
 Psychiatric emergency – needs evaluation immediately
 Differential: medical causes of delirium, PPD, SCZ
 >70% appears to be a presentation of bipolar disorder.
Bipolar women at very high risk of PPP
 Estimates of prevalence between 10-15%
 Risk factors:
› Prior episodes depression or anxiety, including
during pregnancy
› Marital discord
› Unwanted or unplanned pregnancy
› Infant medical problems
› Lack of social support
› Low socioeconomic status
 Differential: anemia, diabetes, thyroid
Symptoms:
• Depressed mood
• Tearfulness
• Loss of interest in usual activities
• Feelings of guilt
• feelings of worthlessness or incompetence
• Fatigue
• Sleep disturbance
• Change in appetite
• Poor concentration
• Suicidal thoughts
 Milder cases overlap with normal feelings in the
postpartum period – i.e. fatigue, altered sleep,
appetite, energy
 Hopelessness, worthlessness, suicidal ideation
are not normal in the postpartum period
 Comorbid anxiety with obsessional thoughts
about the baby is common
› Important to distinguish from psychosis
 Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale
› 10-item self-rating scale measuring mood, anxiety
and SI
 Psychotherapy: IPT, CBT, Supportive,
Psychodynamic, Couples, Group
 Improved social supports
 Help with infant care
 Light therapy
 Medications: SSRI’s, Tricyclics,
Benzodiazepines for comorbid anxiety
 All psychotropic medications are secreted into
breast milk
 Concentrations in breast milk vary widely
 Peak concentrations are attained at 6-8 hours
 Infant toxicity depends on exposure and hepatic
metabolism
 Relationship between infant serum
concentrations and infant physiology, behavior
and development is unknown
 Carefully monitor breast fed infants
 Mood and Anxiety disorders disproportionately affect
women of reproductive age
 Times of hormonal change may be periods of particular
vulnerability
 Many women are reluctant to seek treatment, diagnoses
often missed
 Treatment of psychiatric illness is complicated by
potential pregnancy, pregnancy, postpartum issues
 Risks and benefits of both treatment and non-treatment
must be carefully considered

women_2011b.PPT women mental health and education

  • 2.
    “The burden ofmental disorders, such as depression and anxiety, fall disproportionately on women of childbearing and childrearing age.” Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 2007
  • 3.
    Rates of severemental illness similar between men and women, but differences in diagnoses, age of onset, course.  Rates of Major Depression and Dysthymia are about twice as high for women as for men  Prevalence rates for most Anxiety Disorders (panic disorder, agoraphobia, specific phobia, GAD, PTSD) are 2-3x higher in women (exceptions are OCD and social phobia: rates are =)
  • 4.
     Bipolar Disorder– Type I rates = in men and women, Type II women > men › More mixed episodes, rapid cycling › Later age of onset, more depressive episodes  Schizophrenia – Lifetime prevalence = in men and women. › Women have later age of onset (25-35) with bimodal distribution › Higher premorbid functioning and social functioning › More “benign” course  Eating Disorders – Anorexia Nervosa 95% female; Bulimia 80% female
  • 5.
     Substance Abuse: Men 2-4 x more likely to have dx of substance abuse or dependence › Women with affective illness more vulnerable  Personality Disorders: › Women > Men in Borderline, Histrionic (?) › Men > Women in Antisocial, Narcissistic, Obsessive-Compulsive
  • 6.
    0 5 10 15 20 25 MDE DD SADPMDD BPD Female Male
  • 7.
     Biologic Vulnerability Reproductive Events  Psychosocial Factors
  • 8.
     Gender basedviolence (rape, sexual abuse, domestic violence)  Socioeconomic status  Caregiving responsibilities, multiple roles
  • 9.
     Menstrual Cycle Infertility  Pregnancy  Postpartum Period  Menopausal Transition/Perimenopause  Hormonal Therapies
  • 10.
     Higher incidenceof MDD in women starting at puberty, less marked post-menopause  Suicidal behavior may be more common in low estrogen states  5% rate of PMDD  Rates of postpartum admissions and psychosis elevated immediately after childbirth  Perimenopausal mood d/o’s vs. post- menopause
  • 11.
    Kessler et al,1993 (National Comorbidity Survey)
  • 12.
    Fig. 1. Phasesof the menstrual cycle positively correlated with suicide attempts and changes in oestrogen concentration during the cycle. * Denotes studies where results were statistically significant. Saunders et al, 2006
  • 14.
     Estrogen  Progesterone FSH  LH  Testosterone  HCG  Prolactin
  • 15.
    E2 PROG  MAO /COMT E2  MAO & COMT -  5HT PROG  MAO & COMT -  SHT MAO: Monoamine Oxidase COMT: Catechol-O-Methyl Transferase 5HT: Serotonin TRYP 5HT Re-uptake Site 5HT Estroge n
  • 17.
    Psychological Symptoms  Depression Anger, Irritability  Affective lability  Anxiety  Sensitivity to rejection  Poor concentration  Sense of feeling overwhelmed  Social withdrawal Physical Symptoms  Lethargy or fatigue  Sleep disturbance (usually hypersomnia)  Appetite disturbance (usually increased)  Abdominal bloating  Breast tenderness  Muscle aches, joint pain  Swelling of extremities
  • 18.
     Affects 3-8%of menstruating women  Symptoms begin during Luteal Phase, resolve completely with onset of menses  ≥5 symptoms in most cycles  Marked decrease in social or occupational functioning  Distinguish from underlying mood disorder (no symptoms Follicular Phase)  Abnormal serotonin neurotransmission?
  • 19.
     Lifestyle interventions,exercise  Calcium, Vit B6, Magnesium, Vit E  Herbal remedies (chasteberry)  Psychotherapy  SSRI’s (fluoxetine, paroxetine, sertraline) › Immediate effect › Intermittent vs. continuous dosing  Hormonal therapies
  • 20.
     Increased riskfor first episode depression during menopausal transition  Lower risk for first episode depression in post-menopausal women  Women with a history of depression remain at risk for future episodes  Estrogen replacement effective for mild symptoms, but not Major Depression
  • 22.
    Is pregnancy atime of emotional wellbeing for women?
  • 24.
     Pregnancy isNOT protective against psychiatric illness  Rates of Major Depression during pregnancy 10-15% Anxiety disorders may be higher.  High rate of relapse when antidepressant medications are stopped during pregnancy (~50-70%)  Pregnant Bipolar women have same risk for relapse off meds as non-pregnant Bipolar women. Post partum risk 4x higher.
  • 25.
     Past historyof depression  Poor overall health  Greater alcohol use  Smoking  Being unmarried  Unemployment  Lower education level
  • 26.
    Level of suffering– for mom and partner Decreased ability to care for herself and the pregnancy – suicide risk in severe cases Increased risk for pre-term delivery, preeclampsia, and low birth weight Higher rates of smoking, alcohol and substance use Risk of post-partum depression, negative effects on child and family
  • 27.
    Non-Pharmacologic Treatments:  Psychotherapy Light Therapy  Omega-3 Fatty Acids  Psychosocial supports
  • 28.
    Psychotropic Medications inPregnancy – are they safe?  No Psychotropics are FDA-approved for use during pregnancy  All medications cross the placenta  Principals of management: maximize non- medication options, minimize exposure to meds and to depression
  • 29.
     Teratogenesis › Noincrease in overall rate of fetal malformations › Some evidence linking inc risk of rare defects (i.e. paroxetine and cardiac malformations)  Pregnancy Outcomes › Mixed evidence on birth weight, early pregnancy loss, preterm labor (depression effects?)  Neonatal Toxicity › Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome › Persistent Pulmonary Hypertension of the Newborn  Long-term effects › No evidence to date of long-term developmental effects in children exposed in utero
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Y axis: Ratesof psychiatric hospitalization X axis: Years pre- and post- childbirth
  • 32.
    “When I deliveredthe placenta, I felt like I fell off a cliff.”
  • 33.
     Occurs in50-85% of women  Characterized by mood lability, tearfulness, anxiety and irritability  Symptoms peak at day 4-5  May last a few hours to several days  Symptoms do not interfere with functioning  Reassurance rather than treatment  If symptoms persist > 2 weeks, patient should be evaluated for a more serious mood disorder
  • 34.
     Occurs in1-2 per 1000 women  Onset 24hrs – 3 weeks postpartum  Rapid mood swings, insomnia, obsessive thoughts  Delusions, hallucinations, impaired reality testing. Delusions involving infant are common  Shifting mental status , disorientation, confusion, disorganized behavior  High risk of suicide and/or infanticide  Psychiatric emergency – needs evaluation immediately  Differential: medical causes of delirium, PPD, SCZ  >70% appears to be a presentation of bipolar disorder. Bipolar women at very high risk of PPP
  • 35.
     Estimates ofprevalence between 10-15%  Risk factors: › Prior episodes depression or anxiety, including during pregnancy › Marital discord › Unwanted or unplanned pregnancy › Infant medical problems › Lack of social support › Low socioeconomic status  Differential: anemia, diabetes, thyroid
  • 36.
    Symptoms: • Depressed mood •Tearfulness • Loss of interest in usual activities • Feelings of guilt • feelings of worthlessness or incompetence • Fatigue • Sleep disturbance • Change in appetite • Poor concentration • Suicidal thoughts
  • 37.
     Milder casesoverlap with normal feelings in the postpartum period – i.e. fatigue, altered sleep, appetite, energy  Hopelessness, worthlessness, suicidal ideation are not normal in the postpartum period  Comorbid anxiety with obsessional thoughts about the baby is common › Important to distinguish from psychosis  Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale › 10-item self-rating scale measuring mood, anxiety and SI
  • 38.
     Psychotherapy: IPT,CBT, Supportive, Psychodynamic, Couples, Group  Improved social supports  Help with infant care  Light therapy  Medications: SSRI’s, Tricyclics, Benzodiazepines for comorbid anxiety
  • 39.
     All psychotropicmedications are secreted into breast milk  Concentrations in breast milk vary widely  Peak concentrations are attained at 6-8 hours  Infant toxicity depends on exposure and hepatic metabolism  Relationship between infant serum concentrations and infant physiology, behavior and development is unknown  Carefully monitor breast fed infants
  • 40.
     Mood andAnxiety disorders disproportionately affect women of reproductive age  Times of hormonal change may be periods of particular vulnerability  Many women are reluctant to seek treatment, diagnoses often missed  Treatment of psychiatric illness is complicated by potential pregnancy, pregnancy, postpartum issues  Risks and benefits of both treatment and non-treatment must be carefully considered

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Curiosity about why this is What does this tell us about the differences between men and women? What does this tell us about affective and anxiety disorders? Responsibility to our women patients to understand the effects of these illness and our treatments of them not only on the patients, but on their unborn children and their families.
  • #12 DSM III categorization of MDE – 12-month prevalance. Hazard rate data by age. Hazard rates diverge starting at age 10-14. Data in the 50-54 range based on small n, so not reliable, though ? Perimenopause effect? Overall women are 1.7 x more likely to report a lifetime episode of MDE. Prior to menarche, rates in boys and girls similar
  • #13 Systematic review of studies looking at suicidal behavior and menstrual cycle. ? Findings (some + some -) though felt that better methods led to more correlation. Trend toward low-estrogen states being more correlated.
  • #14 Relative risk of admission 90d after childbirth = 4 Computer linkage of obstetric and psychiatric record systems made it possible to identify all women resident in the city of Edinburgh who had given birth to live or stillborn children in 1971-7 and to study (a) the distribution of psychiatric admissions relative to the time of childbirth and (b) the correlates of psychiatric admission in the first 90 days after childbirth. Having a first baby, being unmarried and undergoing Cesarean section were all associated with an increased risk of admission; twin births, perinatal death and maternal age were not. It is difficult to account for these and other established relationships purely in psychological or purely in somatic terms, suggesting that influences of both kinds are probably involved in the genesis of puerperal disorders.
  • #17 Progesterone levels in mid-luteal phase abt 5ng/dl. By the third trimester of pregnancy abt 175
  • #19 PMS abt 75%
  • #20 PMS abt 75%
  • #21 PMS abt 75%
  • #22 PMS abt 75%
  • #27 Where there is illness there is risk. Depression may impact a woman’s ability to care for herself and the pregnancy (i.e. insufficient weight gain, poor nutrition, insufficient pre-natal care). Risk of suicide in severe cases (though on a population basis, rates of suicide during pregnancy are relatively lower than the general population). There is evidence to suggest that maternal depression increases the risk for pre-term delivery, preeclampsia, and low birth weight [1-7].  This may be due to maternal neuroendocrine changes associated with depression, although the exact mechanisms are unclear  [8-11]. There are higher rates of smoking, alcohol and substance use in depressed pregnant women as compared to nondepressed pregnant women. In addition, the level of suffering of untreated depression has an impact not only on the mother and the unborn fetus but on the family unit, with potentially adverse effects for young children in the home - including behavioral, cognitive and emotional problems and psychiatric diagnoses. [25,39] Severity and length of post-partum depressions in mothers has been associated with less language and cognitive development in children. [25]