SlideShare a Scribd company logo
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u
Warped Dark Sectors
Flip Tanedo
23 March 2021
Continuum mediators
work with


Sylvain Fichet


Philippe Brax


Lexi Costantino


Kuntal Pal


Ian Chaffey
1906.02199


1910.02972


2002.12335


2102.05674
WARPED DARK SECTORS
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
Dark sector
2
Renormalizable


(or low-dimension)


portal interaction
one or two particles in
the narrow width limit
e.g. kinetic mixing,


operator with |H|2,


neutrino portal…
stable
Dark matter
Standard


Model
Mediator
Strength of coupling
controls abundance,
self-interactions
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
3
Renormalizable


(or low-dimension)


portal interaction
Continuum (or tower)
of states beyond the
narrow-width limit
e.g. kinetic mixing,


operator with |H|2,


neutrino portal…
stable
Dark matter
Standard


Model
Mediator
e.g. near-conformal sector,
“unparticles,” extra dimension…
beyond “particle” mediators
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
Warped Dark Sector: AdS Realization
4D dark matter, bulk mediators, new phenomena
• 5D mediator encodes Kaluza–Klein
tower (spectrum)


• Narrow width approximation breaks
down at large KK number
4
BULK
MEDIATOR
UV
BRANE
IR
BRANE
Dark matter
Standard


Model Mediator
“warping, but no attempt to address hierarchy”
5D mediator is dual to


near-conformal sector
1906.02199, 1910.02972, 2002.12335, 2102.05674
• spacelike: non-integer power potentials


• timelike: “soft bomb” cascade decays
Examples of phenomenology
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
Katz, Reece, Sajjad 1509.03628


“continuum mediated DM-baryon scattering”


Contino, Max, Mishra 2012.08537 “searching for elusive dark sectors”


Rizzo et al. 1801.08525, 1804.03560, 1805.08150, 2006.06858


“extra dimensions are dark”


Buyukdag, Dienes, Gherghetta, Thomas 1912.10588


“partially composite dynamical dark matter”


Bernal, Donini, Folgado, Ruis 2004.14403


“KK FIMP dark matter in warped extra dimensions”


McDonald, von Harling 1203.6646


“secluded DM coupled to a hidden CFT”


Gherghetta, von Harling 1002.2967 “a warped model of DM”


McDonald, Morrissey 1002.3361, 1010.5999


“low-energy probes of a warped extra dimension”
5
Summary of prior work
Apologies for incompleteness, please let me know of major omissions
=
1906.02199: “Warped Dark Sector”


FT, Fichet, Brax


1910.02972: “Exotic spin-dependent forces”


FT, Costantino, Fichet


2002.12335: “EFT in AdS: Continuum Regime,
Soft Bombs, …” FT, Costantino, Fichet


2102.05674: “Continuum mediated self-
interacting dark matter” FT, Chaffey, Fichet


2011.06603: “Opacity from Loops in AdS”


Costantino, Fichet


1905.05779: “Opacity and EFT” Fichet


See also: explicit RS models, explicit CFT models, unparticle mediators, hidden valley, quantum critical Higgs …
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
Bulk Mediator: propagator
Mixed position-momentum space
6
function for z > z0 is
(z, z0
< z) =
i⇡R
2
✓
zz0
R2
◆2
JyUV(pz0) JyIR(pz)
f
Jy(p)
(4.3)
m the method of variations, Appendix B, using the solutions to the homogeneous
u(z) = z2
J↵(pz) v(z) = z2
Y↵(pz) , (4.4)
The propagator depends on boundary functions e
J and e
Y , which are boundary
the homogeneous solutions:
e
JUV
↵ ⌘ BUV
u(z) z=R
= ( mUV + @z) u(z)|z=R (4.5)
e
JIR
↵ ⌘ w3
BIR
u(z) z=R0 = w3
(wmIR + @z) u(z) z=R0 , (4.6)
e
Jy’s are combinations of Bessel functions; poles match KK sum
Bulk self-interaction shifts
momentum into complex plane.


Higher KK modes have larger


widths (as expected) and mix
Re
Im
Fichet 1905.05779 ,Section 5: Dressed Propagator; quantitative results: Fichet & Costantino 2011.06603
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
Continuum-Mediated Self-Interactions
“Discretuum” Mediators from a Kaluza–Klein Tower
Closed form 5D brane-to-brane propagator matches in
fi
nite tower
of Kaluza–Klein modes: produces non-integer power-law
Cha
ff
ey, Fichet, Tanedo: 2102.05674 7
Kaluza–Klein representation. One may use the KK representation of the free
3.15) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5); this amounts to iden
xchange of a 5D bulk scalar with the sum of t-channel diagrams with each KK m
= + + + · · ·
The spectral distribution is Disc⇢
⇥
Gp
⇢(z, z0
)
⇤
=
P
n fn(z)fn(z0
)2⇡ (p2
m2
n),
potential is an infinite sum of Yukawa potentials from each KK mode:
V (r) =
1
4⇡
2
k
X
n
fn(z0)2 e mnr
r
.
While this KK representation of V is exact, it requires knowledge of the entire s
potential is exponentially suppressed at long distances,
V (r) /
⇣m1
k
⌘1 2↵ 1
kr2
e m1r
. (5.21)
2↵, r) takes the place of the e mr
Yukawa factor that encodes the mass
mediator scenario. In turn, this mass gap is a key ingredient for cutting o↵
nge dark forces.
e to check the behavior in the gapless limit µ ! 0. The large, spacelike
ximation of the propagator (5.15) is exact in this limit and potential can
tly. We recover the gapless limit in (5.19) the gapless limit is recovered by
ving
Vgapless(r) =
2
2⇡3/2
(3/2 ↵)
(1 ↵)
1
r
✓
1
kr
◆2 2↵
, (5.22)
result from [17]. The power law behavior obtained matches the proposed
th the AdS/CFT identification = 2 ↵.
al, ↵ = 1
rameter ↵ = 1 and with generic IR brane mass parameter bIR ⇠ O(1),
ghter than the scale µ. The suppression relative to µ is the kinetic factor
2
in (5.13). This is in contrast to the ↵ < 1 case. The spectral integral
(3.15) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5); this amounts to iden
exchange of a 5D bulk scalar with the sum of t-channel diagrams with each KK m
= + + + · · ·
The spectral distribution is Disc⇢
⇥
Gp
⇢(z, z0
)
⇤
=
P
n fn(z)fn(z0
)2⇡ (p2
m2
n),
potential is an infinite sum of Yukawa potentials from each KK mode:
V (r) =
1
4⇡
2
k
X
n
fn(z0)2 e mnr
r
.
While this KK representation of V is exact, it requires knowledge of the entire s
KK masses and wavefunctions.
Canonical representation. One may alternatively use the canonical repres
the propagator (3.13) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5). In th
uza–Klein representation. One may use the KK representation of the free pro
5) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5); this amounts to identif
hange of a 5D bulk scalar with the sum of t-channel diagrams with each KK mo
= + + + · · ·
spectral distribution is Disc⇢
⇥
Gp
⇢(z, z0
)
⇤
=
P
n fn(z)fn(z0
)2⇡ (p2
m2
n), so
ential is an infinite sum of Yukawa potentials from each KK mode:
V (r) =
1
4⇡
2
k
X
n
fn(z0)2 e mnr
r
.
le this KK representation of V is exact, it requires knowledge of the entire spe
In practice: mass gap from IR brane
Ian Cha
ff
ey
Our 5D EFT contains isolated degrees of freedom localized on a brane. In a realistic theory
with gravity, localized 4D fields are special modes from 5D bulk fields and are necessarily
accompanied by a spectrum of KK modes [32]. We assume an appropriate limit where the
observable e↵ects of these modes are negligible.
3.3 Model Parameters
For the purposes of studying novel, continuum-mediated dark matter self-interactions, we
restrict the parameters presented in the 5D model in Section 3.1. The AdS curvature, k,
corresponds to the cuto↵ of the theory, as described in Section 3.2. To ensure that the cuto↵
of the theory is beyond the experimental reach of the Large Hadron Collider to detect, e.g.,
Kaluza–Klein gravitons, we set k to be
k = 10 TeV . (3.9)
This sets the position of the UV brane zUV = k 1
and the upper bound on all other dimen-
sionful parameters in the theory. The AdS curvature is much smaller than the Planck scale,
in the spirit of ‘little Randall–Sundrum’ models [33].
The mediator mass, M is related to the dimension of the continuum mediator operator
and is conveniently described by the dimensionless parameter ↵,
↵2
⌘ 4 +
M2
k2
= (2 )2
. (3.10)
The range of ↵ corresponds to the branch of AdS/CFT (see details in Appendix A) and
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
8
Figure 2: Absolute potential |V (r)| plotted to validate the cont
Cha
ff
ey, Fichet, Tanedo: 2102.05674
5D Green’s function
Large spacelike


momentum asymptotic
Many KK modes
trust
green
line
trust
red
line
Sum of many KK modes
reproduces a fractional
power potential.


n.b. KK picture is
consistent as long as
you’re within the
effective theory (do not
probe beyond heaviest
KK mode)
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
9
Figure 7: Velocity dependence of the thermally averaged transfer cross section. The parameters are
chosen to be reasonably fit astronomical data. A benchmark 4D self-interacting dark matter model
Self-Interaction Phenomenology
New parameter: Bulk mass/Scaling Dimension
bulk


mass
Cha
ff
ey, Fichet, FT: 2102.05674; Visible matter long-range forces: 1910.02972 FT, Costantino, Fichet
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
10
AdS5 as an effective field theory
Fichet: 1905.05779; Brax, Fichet, Tanedo: 1906.02199; Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335
ENERGY
SCALE
5D
fl
at (scales shorter than curvature)
5D theory breaks down
5D warped
4D EFT with contact interactions
many KK modes
few KK modes
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
11
Timelike momenta
High Kaluza–Klein modes have larger widths that merge into a continuum rather
than a sequence of discrete Breit–Wigner resonances.
4D Narrow width approximation breaks down (due to interactions)
See also Dynamical Dark Matter realization, Brooks, Dienes et al. 1610.04112, 1912.10588  
one-“particle” states
Re
Im
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
12
AdS5 as an effective field theory
ENERGY
SCALE
What happens at Λμ/k ?
Fichet: 1905.05779; Brax, Fichet, Tanedo: 1906.02199; Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335
5D
fl
at (scales shorter than curvature)
5D theory breaks down
5D warped
4D EFT with contact interactions
RS2-like theory (one brane)


Continuum states
RS1-like (two branes)


Discrete KK modes
IR brane “decouples”
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
Bulk cascades from self-interactions
Timelike mediators falling into the IR: soft bombs
But high-mass states have a large
width (continuum), so narrow width
approximation fails. Cascades are
exponentially suppressed.
See Knapen et al. 1612.00850, Cesarotti et al. 2009.08981, Hofman & Maldacena 0803.1467
13
Bulk interactions


cause decays into
lighter KK modes


Large ’t Hooft coupling


(contrast to QCD)


“soft bomb” event


Lexi Costantino
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
So what? Annihilation Rate
Speculations for a neat application
Bulk interaction controls the breakdown of the
narrow width approximation.

Additional control over dark matter annihilation
rate, separate from Yukawa coupling.

e.g. typical self-interacting dark matter cross section
is too large for thermal freeze out
14
cascade controlled


by bulk interaction
coupling to


dark matter
suppress on-shell (timelike)…
…keep off-shell (spacelike)
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
15
Lots to explore
• Cosmological Bounds

Early universe phase transition (see, e.g.
1910.10160), light particle bounds

• Stellar cooling bounds

If high-momentum mediator production
is suppressed, could this relax bounds?
Finite temperature: AdS-Schwarzschild


• Spin-1 mediator

Work with Kuntal Pal; see also recent
work by Rizzo et al. (e.g. 1801.08525)
Very much a work in progress
Brax, Fichet, Tanedo (1906.02199)
FIMP? See also


Bernal et al.


2004.14403
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
16
Conclusion
• 5D model for a continuum
mediator (dual to near CFT sector)

• Narrow width approximation
breaks down

• Non-integer potential

• Novel handle to play with dark
sector phenomenology
Warped dark sector
Brax, Fichet, Tanedo (1906.02199)
FIMP? See also


Bernal et al.


2004.14403
Similar to: Randall–Sundrum, CFT, unparticles,
hidden valley, quantum critical Higgs… if we
ignore the Hierarchy Problem/Higgs, focus on
phenomenology of the continuum regime.
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS
Looking forward to chatting in person soon
Thanks Chanda, Regina, Djuna,


Nausheen, and Tien-Tien!
Sylvain Lexi Ian
Im
age: Flip
Tanedo
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
18
Extra Slides in case of discussion
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
19
Mixed position–momentum propagator
where p2
is the norm of the Minkowski four-momentum. One may use the method of variations to
obtain the propagator with respect to the homogeneous solutions, see Appendix B:
G(z, z0
) =
i⇡
2R3
h
e
JUV
↵ z2
<Y↵(pz<) e
Y UV
↵ z2
<J↵(pz<)
i h
e
JIR
↵ z2
>Y↵(pz>) e
Y IR
↵ z2
>J↵(pz>)
i
e
JUV
↵
e
Y IR
↵
e
Y UV
↵
e
JIR
↵
, (3.9
3
Also see: https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/143601 and references therein.
4
unction for z > z0 is
(z, z0
< z) =
i⇡R
2
✓
zz0
R2
◆2
JyUV(pz0) JyIR(pz)
f
Jy(p)
(4.3)
the method of variations, Appendix B, using the solutions to the homogeneous
z> ⌘ max(z, z0
). The e
Y and e
J are shorthand for the boundary operator
solutions, for example:
e
JUV
↵ ⌘ BUV
⇥
z2
J↵(pz)
⇤
z=R
. (3.10)
e boundary conditions:
+ UV (R) = 0 BIR
(z) = ↵IR
0
(R0
) + IR (R0
) = 0 . (3.11)
of motion on the boundaries. This, in turn, depends on the Lagrangian
ecomposition
osition is
perturbing about a stable vacuum because AdS provides a positive contribu
3.1 Bulk Equation of Motion
To derive the equation of motion, we may integrate the kinetic term by part
p
g|@ |2
= @M
p
g ⇤
gMN
@N
⇤
@M
p
ggMN
@N
The bulk equation of motion is
O = @M
p
ggMN
@N
p
gM2
= 0 .
In RS the di↵erential operator maps onto:
O =
✓
R
z
◆3
"
@2
z
3
z
@z + p2
✓
R
z
◆2
M2
#
.
The integration by parts with respect to @z generates surface terms at R0
an
Z R0 Z
p
Z
p p
Solution to homogeneous equation
Boundary equation of motion


Acting on homogeneous solution
e.g. solution by method of variations
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
20
UV brane IR brane
elementary composite
~conformal
A dual description of a conformal sector
A slice of AdS5
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
21
The RS1 model
electroweak hierarchy
Randall & Sundrum hep-ph/9905221
Higgs Boson
IR brane-localized
Top quark
IR brane leaning
electron
UV brane leaning
composite
elementary
TeV-1
MPl-1
only a few


KK modes relevant
Zero mode pro
fi
les
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
22
Warped Dark Sector
Brax, Fichet, Tanedo: 1906.02199
UV brane
IR brane
standard


model
mediator
Goal is not the hierarchy
many KK modes!
e.g.
dark matter:


either brane
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
23
Cutoff is position–dependent
EFT perspective: higher-order interaction dominates for momenta of this order:
c.f. RS1 solution to the hierarchy problem
Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335
Alternatively, for
fi
xed


4-momentum p, this is


a limit on the distance z


from the UV brane
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
24
Cascade Recursion Relation
Trick: replace KK sum with discontinuity across spectral representation
MN =
Z R0
R
du AN (u)fn(u) , (12.3)
AN (u) corresponds to the blob in the blob diagrams above. The decay rate is thus
N =
2M0
N 1
X
fin.
X
n
Z
d N (2⇡)4
Z R0
R
du AN (u)fn(u)
Z R0
R
du0
AN (u0
)⇤
fn(u0
)⇤
. (12.4)
hat we have written
N
X
fin.
=
N 1
X
fin.
X
n
, (12.5)
s ‘figurative’ notation to mean that we’ve explicitly separated the sum over the kk modes fn of
ernal state we’ve singled out. The power of this observation is that we may use the integral trick
to replace the kk sum with a spectral integral with respect to the discontinuity of the propagator
the real line:
N
X
n=n0
fn(z)fn(z0
)A(m2
n; z, z0
) =
1
2⇡
Z m2
N
m2
n0
d⇢ A(⇢; z, z0
) Disc⇢
h
p
⇢(z, z0
)
i
. (12.6)
33
1
N
X
fin.
=
N 1
X
fin.
X
n
, (12
which is ‘figurative’ notation to mean that we’ve explicitly separated the sum over the kk modes fn
the external state we’ve singled out. The power of this observation is that we may use the integral tr
(10.5) to replace the kk sum with a spectral integral with respect to the discontinuity of the propaga
across the real line:
N
X
n=n0
fn(z)fn(z0
)A(m2
n; z, z0
) =
1
2⇡
Z m2
N
m2
n0
d⇢ A(⇢; z, z0
) Disc⇢
h
p
⇢(z, z0
)
i
. (12
33
X(z, z0
) =
N
X
n=n0
fn(z)fn(z0
)A(m2
n; z, z0
) .
We can convert the sum over kk wavefunctions into a contour integral over the magnitude of
momentum:
X(z, z0
) =
1
2⇡
I
C
d⇢ Gp
⇢(z, z0
)A(⇢; z, z0
) .
The contour C is a series of counter-clockwise loops around the n0 through Nth poles. This is man
true with the kk decomposition of G(z, z0), but the real power is that one may replace it with t
position-space propagator. Furthermore, one may deform the series of loops into a single counter-cloc
contour that encloses the desired poles:
=)
29
Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
25
Cascade Recursion Relation
See also, e.g. treatment of unstable particles in (review): Phys.Part.Nucl. 45 (2014), Kuksa “Unstable States in QFT”
cascade decay composed of 1 ! 2 branchings coming from a
an initial state is
⇧N |MN |2
⌘
1
2M0
Z
(2⇡)4
d N |MN |2
, (12.1)
factor and M0 is the [would-be] mass of the initial excitation.
spect to d N , the phase space element defined in the pdg that
e these cascades, my collaborators Sylvain and Lexi developed
that relates an N-final state cascade to an (N + 1)-final state
ombs
n 5 of [7]. Assume a cascade decay composed of 1 ! 2 branchings coming from a
. The decay rate for an initial state is
N =
1
2M0
Z
d⇧N |MN |2
⌘
1
2M0
Z
(2⇡)4
d N |MN |2
, (12.1)
propriate phase space factor and M0 is the [would-be] mass of the initial excitation.
write this out with respect to d N , the phase space element defined in the pdg that
In order to investigate these cascades, my collaborators Sylvain and Lexi developed
te recursion relation that relates an N-final state cascade to an (N + 1)-final state
cascade:
The decay rate for an N-final state cascade is
N =
1
2M0
N
X
fin.
Z
d N (2⇡)4
|MN |2
,
where d N is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conservin
The sum is over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient sh
write an N particle amplitude for a particular final state with respect to its ‘last’ vertex at
ay rate for an N-final state cascade is
N =
1
2M0
N
X
fin.
Z
d N (2⇡)4
|MN |2
, (12.2)
N is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conserving -function.
m is over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient shorthand is to
N particle amplitude for a particular final state with respect to its ‘last’ vertex at z = u,:
MN =
Z R0
R
du AN (u)fn(u) , (12.3)
N (u) corresponds to the blob in the blob diagrams above. The decay rate is thus
N =
2M0
N 1
X
fin.
X
n
Z
d N (2⇡)4
Z R0
R
du AN (u)fn(u)
Z R0
R
du0
AN (u0
)⇤
fn(u0
)⇤
. (12.4)
at we have written
N
X
fin.
=
N 1
X
fin.
X
n
, (12.5)
‘figurative’ notation to mean that we’ve explicitly separated the sum over the kk modes fn of
he decay rate for an N-final state cascade is
N =
1
2M0
N
X
fin.
Z
d N (2⇡)4
|MN |2
,
here d N is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conserving
he sum is over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient shor
ite an N particle amplitude for a particular final state with respect to its ‘last’ vertex at z
MN =
Z R0
R
du AN (u)fn(u) ,
here AN (u) corresponds to the blob in the blob diagrams above. The decay rate is thus
Z Z Z
Distinguishable


Final states
1
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
26
Cascade Recursion Relation
rate for an N-final state cascade is
N =
1
2M0
N
X
fin.
Z
d N (2⇡)4
|MN |2
, (12.
is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conserving -functio
s over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient shorthand is
at in the propagators we have written p = p
p2 .15 For a scalar decay there is no angular
nce in the two-body rate. We thus have
R
d⌦mn = 4⇡ so that
N+1 =
2
2M0
N 1
X
fin.
Z
d N
Z
dp2
m dp2
n
Z
d2
u d2
v
Z
dq2
1/2(q2, p2
1, p2
2)
64⇡4q2
A(u)A(u0
)⇤
⇥
✓
R2
vv0
◆5
q(u, v) q(u0
, v0
)⇤
Discp2
m
⇥
pm (v, v0
)
⇤
Discp2
n
⇥
pn (v, v0
)
⇤
. (12.16)
AdS/CFT
that the continua tend to decay near kinematic threshold. The cascades gives rise to soft spherical
final states, in accordance with former results from both gravity and CFT sides.
Integrating over p2
1, p2
2, v, and v0
, we have
PM+1 =C↵
X
FS(M 1)
(2⇡)4
Z
d M
Z
dq2
k
⇣q
k
⌘2↵
Z
du
Z
du0
IM (u) I⇤
M (u0
)(ku)2+↵
(ku0
)2+↵
, (5.11)
where the constant prefactor is
C↵ =
84(1 ↵) 2
↵4⇡4k
✓
(1 ↵) sin(⇡↵)
(1 + ↵)
◆2 |(2 + 3↵)4↵
(↵ + 2) (1 ↵)
(1+↵)
ei↵⇡
|2
(2 + 3↵)2(2 + ↵)2(1 + ↵)2
. (5.12)
One may replace the dq2
in favor of a sum over the continuum of KK final states by applying (5.5).
This yields a recursion relation
PM+1 = r
Z X
FS(M)
Z
du IM (u)fn(u)
2
(2⇡)4
d n = r PM . (5.13)
The fact that one obtains a simple relation is a consequence of the integrand having a specific
momentum dependence and is nontrivial. This relation is clearly useful since it can be used to
give an estimate of a total rate with arbitrary number of legs.
The recursion coefficient r is given by
r ⌘
2
k
1
10241+↵
1
2⇡3↵3
|(2 + 3↵)4↵
(2 + ↵) (1 ↵)
(1+↵)
ei↵⇡
|2
(2 + 3↵)2(2 + ↵)2(1 + ↵)2
!
(1 ↵) sin(⇡↵)
(1 + ↵)
. (5.14)
Even for the strongly coupled case, 2
⇠ `5k, this coefficient is much smaller than one.
small
Källén triangle function
f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16
27
Cascade exponential suppression
Opacity at work
ENERGY
SCALE
5D warped continuum
RS2-like theory (one brane)


Continuum states
5D warped KK regime
RS1-like (two branes)


Discrete KK modes
27
Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335

More Related Content

What's hot

Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2
Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2
Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2
Claudio Attaccalite
 
Binping xiao superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency field
Binping xiao   superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency fieldBinping xiao   superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency field
Binping xiao superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency field
thinfilmsworkshop
 
Semiconductor Assignment Help
Semiconductor Assignment HelpSemiconductor Assignment Help
Semiconductor Assignment Help
Edu Assignment Help
 
CH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 Assignment
CH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 AssignmentCH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 Assignment
CH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 Assignment
semihypocrite
 
972 B3102005 Xray3
972 B3102005 Xray3972 B3102005 Xray3
972 B3102005 Xray3praying1
 
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment Help Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistics Assignment Help
 
Search for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron collider
Search for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron colliderSearch for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron collider
Search for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron colliderSérgio Sacani
 
ppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devices
ppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devicesppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devices
ppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devices
Yuvraj Singh
 
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment HelpStatistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistics Assignment Help
 
Part VIII - The Standard Model
Part VIII - The Standard ModelPart VIII - The Standard Model
Part VIII - The Standard Model
Maurice R. TREMBLAY
 
NANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
NANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum MechanicsNANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
NANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
University of California, San Diego
 
Exact Exchange in Density Functional Theory
Exact Exchange in Density Functional TheoryExact Exchange in Density Functional Theory
Exact Exchange in Density Functional Theory
ABDERRAHMANE REGGAD
 
statistical physics assignment help
statistical physics assignment helpstatistical physics assignment help
statistical physics assignment help
Statistics Homework Helper
 
Electron wave function of first 3 states
Electron wave function of first 3 statesElectron wave function of first 3 states
Electron wave function of first 3 states
vijayakumar sivaji
 
Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1
Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1
Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1Sérgio Sacani
 
Two efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersion
Two efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersionTwo efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersion
Two efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersion
Takeshi Nishimatsu
 
Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686
Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686
Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686
Edmund Christian Herenz
 
Electromagnetic Homework Help
Electromagnetic Homework HelpElectromagnetic Homework Help
Electromagnetic Homework Help
Edu Assignment Help
 
GPS satellite power output at earth
GPS satellite power output at earthGPS satellite power output at earth
GPS satellite power output at earth
Pei-Che Chang
 

What's hot (20)

Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2
Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2
Theoretical Spectroscopy Lectures: real-time approach 2
 
Binping xiao superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency field
Binping xiao   superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency fieldBinping xiao   superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency field
Binping xiao superconducting surface impedance under radiofrequency field
 
Semiconductor Assignment Help
Semiconductor Assignment HelpSemiconductor Assignment Help
Semiconductor Assignment Help
 
CH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 Assignment
CH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 AssignmentCH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 Assignment
CH EN 3453 Heat Transfer 2014 Fall Utah Homework HW 10 Assignment
 
972 B3102005 Xray3
972 B3102005 Xray3972 B3102005 Xray3
972 B3102005 Xray3
 
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment Help Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
 
Search for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron collider
Search for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron colliderSearch for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron collider
Search for microscopic black hole signatures at the large hadron collider
 
ppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devices
ppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devicesppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devices
ppt on the Solar cells understanding semiconductor devices
 
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment HelpStatistical Physics Assignment Help
Statistical Physics Assignment Help
 
Part VIII - The Standard Model
Part VIII - The Standard ModelPart VIII - The Standard Model
Part VIII - The Standard Model
 
NANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
NANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum MechanicsNANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
NANO266 - Lecture 1 - Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
 
Exact Exchange in Density Functional Theory
Exact Exchange in Density Functional TheoryExact Exchange in Density Functional Theory
Exact Exchange in Density Functional Theory
 
statistical physics assignment help
statistical physics assignment helpstatistical physics assignment help
statistical physics assignment help
 
Electron wave function of first 3 states
Electron wave function of first 3 statesElectron wave function of first 3 states
Electron wave function of first 3 states
 
Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1
Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1
Puzzling accretion onto_a_black_hole_in_the_ultraluminous_x_ray_source_m101_ulx1
 
Two efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersion
Two efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersionTwo efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersion
Two efficient algorithms for drawing accurate and beautiful phonon dispersion
 
DIAS
DIASDIAS
DIAS
 
Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686
Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686
Are Young Galaxies Visible? - Partridge & Peebles 1967, ApJ 147, 686
 
Electromagnetic Homework Help
Electromagnetic Homework HelpElectromagnetic Homework Help
Electromagnetic Homework Help
 
GPS satellite power output at earth
GPS satellite power output at earthGPS satellite power output at earth
GPS satellite power output at earth
 

Similar to Warped Dark Sector

Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...
Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...
Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...
SEENET-MTP
 
"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic
"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic
"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic
SEENET-MTP
 
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3
SEENET-MTP
 
Article 1st
Article 1stArticle 1st
Andreev levels
Andreev levelsAndreev levels
Andreev levels
Manuel Morgado
 
TMD PDF in SIDIS
TMD PDF in SIDISTMD PDF in SIDIS
TMD PDF in SIDIS
Francesca Giordano
 
N. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark Energy
N. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark EnergyN. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark Energy
N. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark Energy
SEENET-MTP
 
Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)
Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)
Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)
Marcel Schmittfull
 
Theoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theory
Theoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theoryTheoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theory
Theoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theory
ABDERRAHMANE REGGAD
 
Xu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdf
Xu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdfXu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdf
Xu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdfgrssieee
 
electron positron production of dark sector particles
electron positron production of dark sector particleselectron positron production of dark sector particles
electron positron production of dark sector particles
Flip Tanedo
 
Q.M.pptx
Q.M.pptxQ.M.pptx
Q.M.pptx
mustafaalasady8
 
E. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after Planck
E. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after PlanckE. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after Planck
E. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after Planck
SEENET-MTP
 
2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...
2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...
2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...Guilherme Tosi
 
Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)
Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)
Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)Roberto Anglani
 
Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...
Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...
Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...
ijma
 

Similar to Warped Dark Sector (20)

Serie de dyson
Serie de dysonSerie de dyson
Serie de dyson
 
Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...
Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...
Sergey Sibiryakov "Galactic rotation curves vs. ultra-light dark matter: Impl...
 
"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic
"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic
"Warm tachyon matter" - N. Bilic
 
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 2/3
 
Ch9
Ch9Ch9
Ch9
 
Article 1st
Article 1stArticle 1st
Article 1st
 
Andreev levels
Andreev levelsAndreev levels
Andreev levels
 
TMD PDF in SIDIS
TMD PDF in SIDISTMD PDF in SIDIS
TMD PDF in SIDIS
 
N. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark Energy
N. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark EnergyN. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark Energy
N. Bilic - Supersymmetric Dark Energy
 
Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)
Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)
Large-scale structure non-Gaussianities with modal methods (Ascona)
 
Instantons in 1D QM
Instantons in 1D QMInstantons in 1D QM
Instantons in 1D QM
 
Theoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theory
Theoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theoryTheoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theory
Theoretical picture: magnetic impurities, Zener model, mean-field theory
 
Xu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdf
Xu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdfXu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdf
Xu_IGARSS11_snow_f.pdf
 
electron positron production of dark sector particles
electron positron production of dark sector particleselectron positron production of dark sector particles
electron positron production of dark sector particles
 
Q.M.pptx
Q.M.pptxQ.M.pptx
Q.M.pptx
 
E. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after Planck
E. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after PlanckE. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after Planck
E. Sefusatti, Tests of the Initial Conditions of the Universe after Planck
 
2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...
2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...
2012 NComms - Geometrically-locked vortex lattices in semiconductor quantum f...
 
Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)
Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)
Collective modes of CFL phase of QCD (QCD@Work 2010)
 
OCT FD 1.5
OCT FD 1.5 OCT FD 1.5
OCT FD 1.5
 
Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...
Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...
Mimo radar detection in compound gaussian clutter using orthogonal discrete f...
 

More from Flip Tanedo

Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?
Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?
Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?
Flip Tanedo
 
Communicating Science Effectively
Communicating Science EffectivelyCommunicating Science Effectively
Communicating Science Effectively
Flip Tanedo
 
Sustainable HEP
Sustainable HEPSustainable HEP
Sustainable HEP
Flip Tanedo
 
Explainer Videos
Explainer VideosExplainer Videos
Explainer Videos
Flip Tanedo
 
Equity as an Early Career Academic
Equity as an Early Career AcademicEquity as an Early Career Academic
Equity as an Early Career Academic
Flip Tanedo
 
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited Opinions
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited OpinionsDiversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited Opinions
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited Opinions
Flip Tanedo
 
Snowmass: Theory and the Cosmic Frontier
Snowmass: Theory and the Cosmic FrontierSnowmass: Theory and the Cosmic Frontier
Snowmass: Theory and the Cosmic Frontier
Flip Tanedo
 
Popular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physics
Popular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physicsPopular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physics
Popular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physics
Flip Tanedo
 
Little Particles in a Big Universe
Little Particles in a Big UniverseLittle Particles in a Big Universe
Little Particles in a Big Universe
Flip Tanedo
 
Non-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics Teaching
Non-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics TeachingNon-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics Teaching
Non-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics Teaching
Flip Tanedo
 
How to hep-ph
How to hep-phHow to hep-ph
How to hep-ph
Flip Tanedo
 
Attending to Diversity in the Physics Classroom
Attending to Diversity in the Physics ClassroomAttending to Diversity in the Physics Classroom
Attending to Diversity in the Physics Classroom
Flip Tanedo
 
The Invisible Universe and You
The Invisible Universe and YouThe Invisible Universe and You
The Invisible Universe and You
Flip Tanedo
 
Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?
Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?
Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?
Flip Tanedo
 
the ñ in my name
the ñ in my namethe ñ in my name
the ñ in my name
Flip Tanedo
 
Figuring It Out
Figuring It OutFiguring It Out
Figuring It Out
Flip Tanedo
 
P39: the secret syllabus
P39: the secret syllabusP39: the secret syllabus
P39: the secret syllabus
Flip Tanedo
 
P39: How to Fail as a Physics Major
P39: How to Fail as a Physics MajorP39: How to Fail as a Physics Major
P39: How to Fail as a Physics Major
Flip Tanedo
 
P39: How To F Up Your Academic Career
P39: How To F Up Your Academic CareerP39: How To F Up Your Academic Career
P39: How To F Up Your Academic Career
Flip Tanedo
 
P39: I have no idea
P39: I have no ideaP39: I have no idea
P39: I have no idea
Flip Tanedo
 

More from Flip Tanedo (20)

Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?
Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?
Why Haven't We Discovered Dark Matter?
 
Communicating Science Effectively
Communicating Science EffectivelyCommunicating Science Effectively
Communicating Science Effectively
 
Sustainable HEP
Sustainable HEPSustainable HEP
Sustainable HEP
 
Explainer Videos
Explainer VideosExplainer Videos
Explainer Videos
 
Equity as an Early Career Academic
Equity as an Early Career AcademicEquity as an Early Career Academic
Equity as an Early Career Academic
 
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited Opinions
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited OpinionsDiversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited Opinions
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: Perspectives and Unsolicited Opinions
 
Snowmass: Theory and the Cosmic Frontier
Snowmass: Theory and the Cosmic FrontierSnowmass: Theory and the Cosmic Frontier
Snowmass: Theory and the Cosmic Frontier
 
Popular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physics
Popular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physicsPopular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physics
Popular Book Discussions: a platform for equity in physics
 
Little Particles in a Big Universe
Little Particles in a Big UniverseLittle Particles in a Big Universe
Little Particles in a Big Universe
 
Non-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics Teaching
Non-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics TeachingNon-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics Teaching
Non-Traditional Assessment and Inclusivity in Physics Teaching
 
How to hep-ph
How to hep-phHow to hep-ph
How to hep-ph
 
Attending to Diversity in the Physics Classroom
Attending to Diversity in the Physics ClassroomAttending to Diversity in the Physics Classroom
Attending to Diversity in the Physics Classroom
 
The Invisible Universe and You
The Invisible Universe and YouThe Invisible Universe and You
The Invisible Universe and You
 
Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?
Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?
Whatever happened to the WIMP of tomorrow?
 
the ñ in my name
the ñ in my namethe ñ in my name
the ñ in my name
 
Figuring It Out
Figuring It OutFiguring It Out
Figuring It Out
 
P39: the secret syllabus
P39: the secret syllabusP39: the secret syllabus
P39: the secret syllabus
 
P39: How to Fail as a Physics Major
P39: How to Fail as a Physics MajorP39: How to Fail as a Physics Major
P39: How to Fail as a Physics Major
 
P39: How To F Up Your Academic Career
P39: How To F Up Your Academic CareerP39: How To F Up Your Academic Career
P39: How To F Up Your Academic Career
 
P39: I have no idea
P39: I have no ideaP39: I have no idea
P39: I have no idea
 

Recently uploaded

platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptxplatelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
muralinath2
 
Red blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptx
Red blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptxRed blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptx
Red blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptx
muralinath2
 
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlandsRichard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard Gill
 
Oedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptx
Oedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptxOedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptx
Oedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptx
muralinath2
 
Deep Software Variability and Frictionless Reproducibility
Deep Software Variability and Frictionless ReproducibilityDeep Software Variability and Frictionless Reproducibility
Deep Software Variability and Frictionless Reproducibility
University of Rennes, INSA Rennes, Inria/IRISA, CNRS
 
Mudde & Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...
Mudde &  Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...Mudde &  Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...
Mudde & Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...
frank0071
 
Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...
Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...
Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...
University of Maribor
 
THEMATIC APPERCEPTION TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...
THEMATIC  APPERCEPTION  TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...THEMATIC  APPERCEPTION  TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...
THEMATIC APPERCEPTION TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...
Abdul Wali Khan University Mardan,kP,Pakistan
 
BREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptx
BREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptxBREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptx
BREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptx
RASHMI M G
 
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensiveLateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
silvermistyshot
 
Toxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and Arsenic
Toxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and ArsenicToxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and Arsenic
Toxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and Arsenic
sanjana502982
 
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWSOrion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Columbia Weather Systems
 
DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...
DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...
DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...
Wasswaderrick3
 
DMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdf
DMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdfDMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdf
DMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdf
fafyfskhan251kmf
 
Leaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdf
Leaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdfLeaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdf
Leaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdf
RenuJangid3
 
Phenomics assisted breeding in crop improvement
Phenomics assisted breeding in crop improvementPhenomics assisted breeding in crop improvement
Phenomics assisted breeding in crop improvement
IshaGoswami9
 
Shallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptx
Shallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptxShallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptx
Shallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptx
Gokturk Mehmet Dilci
 
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technologyNutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Lokesh Patil
 
What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.
What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.
What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.
moosaasad1975
 
Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...
Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...
Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...
Ana Luísa Pinho
 

Recently uploaded (20)

platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptxplatelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
 
Red blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptx
Red blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptxRed blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptx
Red blood cells- genesis-maturation.pptx
 
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlandsRichard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
 
Oedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptx
Oedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptxOedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptx
Oedema_types_causes_pathophysiology.pptx
 
Deep Software Variability and Frictionless Reproducibility
Deep Software Variability and Frictionless ReproducibilityDeep Software Variability and Frictionless Reproducibility
Deep Software Variability and Frictionless Reproducibility
 
Mudde & Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...
Mudde &  Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...Mudde &  Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...
Mudde & Rovira Kaltwasser. - Populism in Europe and the Americas - Threat Or...
 
Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...
Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...
Remote Sensing and Computational, Evolutionary, Supercomputing, and Intellige...
 
THEMATIC APPERCEPTION TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...
THEMATIC  APPERCEPTION  TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...THEMATIC  APPERCEPTION  TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...
THEMATIC APPERCEPTION TEST(TAT) cognitive abilities, creativity, and critic...
 
BREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptx
BREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptxBREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptx
BREEDING METHODS FOR DISEASE RESISTANCE.pptx
 
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensiveLateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
 
Toxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and Arsenic
Toxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and ArsenicToxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and Arsenic
Toxic effects of heavy metals : Lead and Arsenic
 
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWSOrion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
 
DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...
DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...
DERIVATION OF MODIFIED BERNOULLI EQUATION WITH VISCOUS EFFECTS AND TERMINAL V...
 
DMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdf
DMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdfDMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdf
DMARDs Pharmacolgy Pharm D 5th Semester.pdf
 
Leaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdf
Leaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdfLeaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdf
Leaf Initiation, Growth and Differentiation.pdf
 
Phenomics assisted breeding in crop improvement
Phenomics assisted breeding in crop improvementPhenomics assisted breeding in crop improvement
Phenomics assisted breeding in crop improvement
 
Shallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptx
Shallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptxShallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptx
Shallowest Oil Discovery of Turkiye.pptx
 
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technologyNutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
 
What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.
What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.
What is greenhouse gasses and how many gasses are there to affect the Earth.
 
Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...
Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...
Deep Behavioral Phenotyping in Systems Neuroscience for Functional Atlasing a...
 

Warped Dark Sector

  • 1. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u Warped Dark Sectors Flip Tanedo 23 March 2021 Continuum mediators work with Sylvain Fichet Philippe Brax Lexi Costantino Kuntal Pal Ian Chaffey 1906.02199 
 1910.02972 
 2002.12335 
 2102.05674 WARPED DARK SECTORS
  • 2. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 Dark sector 2 Renormalizable 
 (or low-dimension) 
 portal interaction one or two particles in the narrow width limit e.g. kinetic mixing, 
 operator with |H|2, 
 neutrino portal… stable Dark matter Standard 
 Model Mediator Strength of coupling controls abundance, self-interactions
  • 3. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 3 Renormalizable 
 (or low-dimension) 
 portal interaction Continuum (or tower) of states beyond the narrow-width limit e.g. kinetic mixing, 
 operator with |H|2, 
 neutrino portal… stable Dark matter Standard 
 Model Mediator e.g. near-conformal sector, “unparticles,” extra dimension… beyond “particle” mediators
  • 4. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 Warped Dark Sector: AdS Realization 4D dark matter, bulk mediators, new phenomena • 5D mediator encodes Kaluza–Klein tower (spectrum) • Narrow width approximation breaks down at large KK number 4 BULK MEDIATOR UV BRANE IR BRANE Dark matter Standard 
 Model Mediator “warping, but no attempt to address hierarchy” 5D mediator is dual to near-conformal sector 1906.02199, 1910.02972, 2002.12335, 2102.05674 • spacelike: non-integer power potentials • timelike: “soft bomb” cascade decays Examples of phenomenology
  • 5. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 Katz, Reece, Sajjad 1509.03628 
 “continuum mediated DM-baryon scattering” Contino, Max, Mishra 2012.08537 “searching for elusive dark sectors” Rizzo et al. 1801.08525, 1804.03560, 1805.08150, 2006.06858 
 “extra dimensions are dark” Buyukdag, Dienes, Gherghetta, Thomas 1912.10588 
 “partially composite dynamical dark matter” Bernal, Donini, Folgado, Ruis 2004.14403 
 “KK FIMP dark matter in warped extra dimensions” McDonald, von Harling 1203.6646 
 “secluded DM coupled to a hidden CFT” Gherghetta, von Harling 1002.2967 “a warped model of DM” McDonald, Morrissey 1002.3361, 1010.5999 
 “low-energy probes of a warped extra dimension” 5 Summary of prior work Apologies for incompleteness, please let me know of major omissions = 1906.02199: “Warped Dark Sector” 
 FT, Fichet, Brax 1910.02972: “Exotic spin-dependent forces” 
 FT, Costantino, Fichet 2002.12335: “EFT in AdS: Continuum Regime, Soft Bombs, …” FT, Costantino, Fichet 2102.05674: “Continuum mediated self- interacting dark matter” FT, Chaffey, Fichet 2011.06603: “Opacity from Loops in AdS” 
 Costantino, Fichet 1905.05779: “Opacity and EFT” Fichet 
 See also: explicit RS models, explicit CFT models, unparticle mediators, hidden valley, quantum critical Higgs …
  • 6. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 Bulk Mediator: propagator Mixed position-momentum space 6 function for z > z0 is (z, z0 < z) = i⇡R 2 ✓ zz0 R2 ◆2 JyUV(pz0) JyIR(pz) f Jy(p) (4.3) m the method of variations, Appendix B, using the solutions to the homogeneous u(z) = z2 J↵(pz) v(z) = z2 Y↵(pz) , (4.4) The propagator depends on boundary functions e J and e Y , which are boundary the homogeneous solutions: e JUV ↵ ⌘ BUV u(z) z=R = ( mUV + @z) u(z)|z=R (4.5) e JIR ↵ ⌘ w3 BIR u(z) z=R0 = w3 (wmIR + @z) u(z) z=R0 , (4.6) e Jy’s are combinations of Bessel functions; poles match KK sum Bulk self-interaction shifts momentum into complex plane. Higher KK modes have larger 
 widths (as expected) and mix Re Im Fichet 1905.05779 ,Section 5: Dressed Propagator; quantitative results: Fichet & Costantino 2011.06603
  • 7. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 Continuum-Mediated Self-Interactions “Discretuum” Mediators from a Kaluza–Klein Tower Closed form 5D brane-to-brane propagator matches in fi nite tower of Kaluza–Klein modes: produces non-integer power-law Cha ff ey, Fichet, Tanedo: 2102.05674 7 Kaluza–Klein representation. One may use the KK representation of the free 3.15) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5); this amounts to iden xchange of a 5D bulk scalar with the sum of t-channel diagrams with each KK m = + + + · · · The spectral distribution is Disc⇢ ⇥ Gp ⇢(z, z0 ) ⇤ = P n fn(z)fn(z0 )2⇡ (p2 m2 n), potential is an infinite sum of Yukawa potentials from each KK mode: V (r) = 1 4⇡ 2 k X n fn(z0)2 e mnr r . While this KK representation of V is exact, it requires knowledge of the entire s potential is exponentially suppressed at long distances, V (r) / ⇣m1 k ⌘1 2↵ 1 kr2 e m1r . (5.21) 2↵, r) takes the place of the e mr Yukawa factor that encodes the mass mediator scenario. In turn, this mass gap is a key ingredient for cutting o↵ nge dark forces. e to check the behavior in the gapless limit µ ! 0. The large, spacelike ximation of the propagator (5.15) is exact in this limit and potential can tly. We recover the gapless limit in (5.19) the gapless limit is recovered by ving Vgapless(r) = 2 2⇡3/2 (3/2 ↵) (1 ↵) 1 r ✓ 1 kr ◆2 2↵ , (5.22) result from [17]. The power law behavior obtained matches the proposed th the AdS/CFT identification = 2 ↵. al, ↵ = 1 rameter ↵ = 1 and with generic IR brane mass parameter bIR ⇠ O(1), ghter than the scale µ. The suppression relative to µ is the kinetic factor 2 in (5.13). This is in contrast to the ↵ < 1 case. The spectral integral (3.15) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5); this amounts to iden exchange of a 5D bulk scalar with the sum of t-channel diagrams with each KK m = + + + · · · The spectral distribution is Disc⇢ ⇥ Gp ⇢(z, z0 ) ⇤ = P n fn(z)fn(z0 )2⇡ (p2 m2 n), potential is an infinite sum of Yukawa potentials from each KK mode: V (r) = 1 4⇡ 2 k X n fn(z0)2 e mnr r . While this KK representation of V is exact, it requires knowledge of the entire s KK masses and wavefunctions. Canonical representation. One may alternatively use the canonical repres the propagator (3.13) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5). In th uza–Klein representation. One may use the KK representation of the free pro 5) in the spectral representation of the potential (5.5); this amounts to identif hange of a 5D bulk scalar with the sum of t-channel diagrams with each KK mo = + + + · · · spectral distribution is Disc⇢ ⇥ Gp ⇢(z, z0 ) ⇤ = P n fn(z)fn(z0 )2⇡ (p2 m2 n), so ential is an infinite sum of Yukawa potentials from each KK mode: V (r) = 1 4⇡ 2 k X n fn(z0)2 e mnr r . le this KK representation of V is exact, it requires knowledge of the entire spe In practice: mass gap from IR brane Ian Cha ff ey Our 5D EFT contains isolated degrees of freedom localized on a brane. In a realistic theory with gravity, localized 4D fields are special modes from 5D bulk fields and are necessarily accompanied by a spectrum of KK modes [32]. We assume an appropriate limit where the observable e↵ects of these modes are negligible. 3.3 Model Parameters For the purposes of studying novel, continuum-mediated dark matter self-interactions, we restrict the parameters presented in the 5D model in Section 3.1. The AdS curvature, k, corresponds to the cuto↵ of the theory, as described in Section 3.2. To ensure that the cuto↵ of the theory is beyond the experimental reach of the Large Hadron Collider to detect, e.g., Kaluza–Klein gravitons, we set k to be k = 10 TeV . (3.9) This sets the position of the UV brane zUV = k 1 and the upper bound on all other dimen- sionful parameters in the theory. The AdS curvature is much smaller than the Planck scale, in the spirit of ‘little Randall–Sundrum’ models [33]. The mediator mass, M is related to the dimension of the continuum mediator operator and is conveniently described by the dimensionless parameter ↵, ↵2 ⌘ 4 + M2 k2 = (2 )2 . (3.10) The range of ↵ corresponds to the branch of AdS/CFT (see details in Appendix A) and
  • 8. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 8 Figure 2: Absolute potential |V (r)| plotted to validate the cont Cha ff ey, Fichet, Tanedo: 2102.05674 5D Green’s function Large spacelike 
 momentum asymptotic Many KK modes trust green line trust red line Sum of many KK modes reproduces a fractional power potential. n.b. KK picture is consistent as long as you’re within the effective theory (do not probe beyond heaviest KK mode)
  • 9. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 9 Figure 7: Velocity dependence of the thermally averaged transfer cross section. The parameters are chosen to be reasonably fit astronomical data. A benchmark 4D self-interacting dark matter model Self-Interaction Phenomenology New parameter: Bulk mass/Scaling Dimension bulk mass Cha ff ey, Fichet, FT: 2102.05674; Visible matter long-range forces: 1910.02972 FT, Costantino, Fichet
  • 10. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 10 AdS5 as an effective field theory Fichet: 1905.05779; Brax, Fichet, Tanedo: 1906.02199; Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335 ENERGY SCALE 5D fl at (scales shorter than curvature) 5D theory breaks down 5D warped 4D EFT with contact interactions many KK modes few KK modes
  • 11. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 11 Timelike momenta High Kaluza–Klein modes have larger widths that merge into a continuum rather than a sequence of discrete Breit–Wigner resonances. 4D Narrow width approximation breaks down (due to interactions) See also Dynamical Dark Matter realization, Brooks, Dienes et al. 1610.04112, 1912.10588   one-“particle” states Re Im
  • 12. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 12 AdS5 as an effective field theory ENERGY SCALE What happens at Λμ/k ? Fichet: 1905.05779; Brax, Fichet, Tanedo: 1906.02199; Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335 5D fl at (scales shorter than curvature) 5D theory breaks down 5D warped 4D EFT with contact interactions RS2-like theory (one brane) Continuum states RS1-like (two branes) Discrete KK modes IR brane “decouples”
  • 13. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 Bulk cascades from self-interactions Timelike mediators falling into the IR: soft bombs But high-mass states have a large width (continuum), so narrow width approximation fails. Cascades are exponentially suppressed. See Knapen et al. 1612.00850, Cesarotti et al. 2009.08981, Hofman & Maldacena 0803.1467 13 Bulk interactions cause decays into lighter KK modes Large ’t Hooft coupling 
 (contrast to QCD) “soft bomb” event Lexi Costantino
  • 14. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 So what? Annihilation Rate Speculations for a neat application Bulk interaction controls the breakdown of the narrow width approximation. Additional control over dark matter annihilation rate, separate from Yukawa coupling. e.g. typical self-interacting dark matter cross section is too large for thermal freeze out 14 cascade controlled 
 by bulk interaction coupling to 
 dark matter suppress on-shell (timelike)… …keep off-shell (spacelike)
  • 15. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 15 Lots to explore • Cosmological Bounds
 Early universe phase transition (see, e.g. 1910.10160), light particle bounds • Stellar cooling bounds
 If high-momentum mediator production is suppressed, could this relax bounds? Finite temperature: AdS-Schwarzschild • Spin-1 mediator
 Work with Kuntal Pal; see also recent work by Rizzo et al. (e.g. 1801.08525) Very much a work in progress Brax, Fichet, Tanedo (1906.02199) FIMP? See also 
 Bernal et al. 
 2004.14403
  • 16. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 16 Conclusion • 5D model for a continuum mediator (dual to near CFT sector) • Narrow width approximation breaks down • Non-integer potential • Novel handle to play with dark sector phenomenology Warped dark sector Brax, Fichet, Tanedo (1906.02199) FIMP? See also 
 Bernal et al. 
 2004.14403 Similar to: Randall–Sundrum, CFT, unparticles, hidden valley, quantum critical Higgs… if we ignore the Hierarchy Problem/Higgs, focus on phenomenology of the continuum regime.
  • 17. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS Looking forward to chatting in person soon Thanks Chanda, Regina, Djuna, Nausheen, and Tien-Tien! Sylvain Lexi Ian Im age: Flip Tanedo
  • 18. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 18 Extra Slides in case of discussion
  • 19. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 19 Mixed position–momentum propagator where p2 is the norm of the Minkowski four-momentum. One may use the method of variations to obtain the propagator with respect to the homogeneous solutions, see Appendix B: G(z, z0 ) = i⇡ 2R3 h e JUV ↵ z2 <Y↵(pz<) e Y UV ↵ z2 <J↵(pz<) i h e JIR ↵ z2 >Y↵(pz>) e Y IR ↵ z2 >J↵(pz>) i e JUV ↵ e Y IR ↵ e Y UV ↵ e JIR ↵ , (3.9 3 Also see: https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/143601 and references therein. 4 unction for z > z0 is (z, z0 < z) = i⇡R 2 ✓ zz0 R2 ◆2 JyUV(pz0) JyIR(pz) f Jy(p) (4.3) the method of variations, Appendix B, using the solutions to the homogeneous z> ⌘ max(z, z0 ). The e Y and e J are shorthand for the boundary operator solutions, for example: e JUV ↵ ⌘ BUV ⇥ z2 J↵(pz) ⇤ z=R . (3.10) e boundary conditions: + UV (R) = 0 BIR (z) = ↵IR 0 (R0 ) + IR (R0 ) = 0 . (3.11) of motion on the boundaries. This, in turn, depends on the Lagrangian ecomposition osition is perturbing about a stable vacuum because AdS provides a positive contribu 3.1 Bulk Equation of Motion To derive the equation of motion, we may integrate the kinetic term by part p g|@ |2 = @M p g ⇤ gMN @N ⇤ @M p ggMN @N The bulk equation of motion is O = @M p ggMN @N p gM2 = 0 . In RS the di↵erential operator maps onto: O = ✓ R z ◆3 " @2 z 3 z @z + p2 ✓ R z ◆2 M2 # . The integration by parts with respect to @z generates surface terms at R0 an Z R0 Z p Z p p Solution to homogeneous equation Boundary equation of motion Acting on homogeneous solution e.g. solution by method of variations
  • 20. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 20 UV brane IR brane elementary composite ~conformal A dual description of a conformal sector A slice of AdS5
  • 21. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 21 The RS1 model electroweak hierarchy Randall & Sundrum hep-ph/9905221 Higgs Boson IR brane-localized Top quark IR brane leaning electron UV brane leaning composite elementary TeV-1 MPl-1 only a few KK modes relevant Zero mode pro fi les
  • 22. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 22 Warped Dark Sector Brax, Fichet, Tanedo: 1906.02199 UV brane IR brane standard model mediator Goal is not the hierarchy many KK modes! e.g. dark matter: either brane
  • 23. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 23 Cutoff is position–dependent EFT perspective: higher-order interaction dominates for momenta of this order: c.f. RS1 solution to the hierarchy problem Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335 Alternatively, for fi xed 4-momentum p, this is a limit on the distance z from the UV brane
  • 24. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 24 Cascade Recursion Relation Trick: replace KK sum with discontinuity across spectral representation MN = Z R0 R du AN (u)fn(u) , (12.3) AN (u) corresponds to the blob in the blob diagrams above. The decay rate is thus N = 2M0 N 1 X fin. X n Z d N (2⇡)4 Z R0 R du AN (u)fn(u) Z R0 R du0 AN (u0 )⇤ fn(u0 )⇤ . (12.4) hat we have written N X fin. = N 1 X fin. X n , (12.5) s ‘figurative’ notation to mean that we’ve explicitly separated the sum over the kk modes fn of ernal state we’ve singled out. The power of this observation is that we may use the integral trick to replace the kk sum with a spectral integral with respect to the discontinuity of the propagator the real line: N X n=n0 fn(z)fn(z0 )A(m2 n; z, z0 ) = 1 2⇡ Z m2 N m2 n0 d⇢ A(⇢; z, z0 ) Disc⇢ h p ⇢(z, z0 ) i . (12.6) 33 1 N X fin. = N 1 X fin. X n , (12 which is ‘figurative’ notation to mean that we’ve explicitly separated the sum over the kk modes fn the external state we’ve singled out. The power of this observation is that we may use the integral tr (10.5) to replace the kk sum with a spectral integral with respect to the discontinuity of the propaga across the real line: N X n=n0 fn(z)fn(z0 )A(m2 n; z, z0 ) = 1 2⇡ Z m2 N m2 n0 d⇢ A(⇢; z, z0 ) Disc⇢ h p ⇢(z, z0 ) i . (12 33 X(z, z0 ) = N X n=n0 fn(z)fn(z0 )A(m2 n; z, z0 ) . We can convert the sum over kk wavefunctions into a contour integral over the magnitude of momentum: X(z, z0 ) = 1 2⇡ I C d⇢ Gp ⇢(z, z0 )A(⇢; z, z0 ) . The contour C is a series of counter-clockwise loops around the n0 through Nth poles. This is man true with the kk decomposition of G(z, z0), but the real power is that one may replace it with t position-space propagator. Furthermore, one may deform the series of loops into a single counter-cloc contour that encloses the desired poles: =) 29 Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335
  • 25. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 25 Cascade Recursion Relation See also, e.g. treatment of unstable particles in (review): Phys.Part.Nucl. 45 (2014), Kuksa “Unstable States in QFT” cascade decay composed of 1 ! 2 branchings coming from a an initial state is ⇧N |MN |2 ⌘ 1 2M0 Z (2⇡)4 d N |MN |2 , (12.1) factor and M0 is the [would-be] mass of the initial excitation. spect to d N , the phase space element defined in the pdg that e these cascades, my collaborators Sylvain and Lexi developed that relates an N-final state cascade to an (N + 1)-final state ombs n 5 of [7]. Assume a cascade decay composed of 1 ! 2 branchings coming from a . The decay rate for an initial state is N = 1 2M0 Z d⇧N |MN |2 ⌘ 1 2M0 Z (2⇡)4 d N |MN |2 , (12.1) propriate phase space factor and M0 is the [would-be] mass of the initial excitation. write this out with respect to d N , the phase space element defined in the pdg that In order to investigate these cascades, my collaborators Sylvain and Lexi developed te recursion relation that relates an N-final state cascade to an (N + 1)-final state cascade: The decay rate for an N-final state cascade is N = 1 2M0 N X fin. Z d N (2⇡)4 |MN |2 , where d N is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conservin The sum is over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient sh write an N particle amplitude for a particular final state with respect to its ‘last’ vertex at ay rate for an N-final state cascade is N = 1 2M0 N X fin. Z d N (2⇡)4 |MN |2 , (12.2) N is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conserving -function. m is over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient shorthand is to N particle amplitude for a particular final state with respect to its ‘last’ vertex at z = u,: MN = Z R0 R du AN (u)fn(u) , (12.3) N (u) corresponds to the blob in the blob diagrams above. The decay rate is thus N = 2M0 N 1 X fin. X n Z d N (2⇡)4 Z R0 R du AN (u)fn(u) Z R0 R du0 AN (u0 )⇤ fn(u0 )⇤ . (12.4) at we have written N X fin. = N 1 X fin. X n , (12.5) ‘figurative’ notation to mean that we’ve explicitly separated the sum over the kk modes fn of he decay rate for an N-final state cascade is N = 1 2M0 N X fin. Z d N (2⇡)4 |MN |2 , here d N is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conserving he sum is over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient shor ite an N particle amplitude for a particular final state with respect to its ‘last’ vertex at z MN = Z R0 R du AN (u)fn(u) , here AN (u) corresponds to the blob in the blob diagrams above. The decay rate is thus Z Z Z Distinguishable Final states 1
  • 26. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 26 Cascade Recursion Relation rate for an N-final state cascade is N = 1 2M0 N X fin. Z d N (2⇡)4 |MN |2 , (12. is the N-body phase space factor that contains the overall momentum-conserving -functio s over the distinguishable configurations of the N final states. A convenient shorthand is at in the propagators we have written p = p p2 .15 For a scalar decay there is no angular nce in the two-body rate. We thus have R d⌦mn = 4⇡ so that N+1 = 2 2M0 N 1 X fin. Z d N Z dp2 m dp2 n Z d2 u d2 v Z dq2 1/2(q2, p2 1, p2 2) 64⇡4q2 A(u)A(u0 )⇤ ⇥ ✓ R2 vv0 ◆5 q(u, v) q(u0 , v0 )⇤ Discp2 m ⇥ pm (v, v0 ) ⇤ Discp2 n ⇥ pn (v, v0 ) ⇤ . (12.16) AdS/CFT that the continua tend to decay near kinematic threshold. The cascades gives rise to soft spherical final states, in accordance with former results from both gravity and CFT sides. Integrating over p2 1, p2 2, v, and v0 , we have PM+1 =C↵ X FS(M 1) (2⇡)4 Z d M Z dq2 k ⇣q k ⌘2↵ Z du Z du0 IM (u) I⇤ M (u0 )(ku)2+↵ (ku0 )2+↵ , (5.11) where the constant prefactor is C↵ = 84(1 ↵) 2 ↵4⇡4k ✓ (1 ↵) sin(⇡↵) (1 + ↵) ◆2 |(2 + 3↵)4↵ (↵ + 2) (1 ↵) (1+↵) ei↵⇡ |2 (2 + 3↵)2(2 + ↵)2(1 + ↵)2 . (5.12) One may replace the dq2 in favor of a sum over the continuum of KK final states by applying (5.5). This yields a recursion relation PM+1 = r Z X FS(M) Z du IM (u)fn(u) 2 (2⇡)4 d n = r PM . (5.13) The fact that one obtains a simple relation is a consequence of the integrand having a specific momentum dependence and is nontrivial. This relation is clearly useful since it can be used to give an estimate of a total rate with arbitrary number of legs. The recursion coefficient r is given by r ⌘ 2 k 1 10241+↵ 1 2⇡3↵3 |(2 + 3↵)4↵ (2 + ↵) (1 ↵) (1+↵) ei↵⇡ |2 (2 + 3↵)2(2 + ↵)2(1 + ↵)2 ! (1 ↵) sin(⇡↵) (1 + ↵) . (5.14) Even for the strongly coupled case, 2 ⇠ `5k, this coefficient is much smaller than one. small Källén triangle function
  • 27. f l i p . t a n e d o @ u c r. e d u WARPED DARK SECTORS 16 27 Cascade exponential suppression Opacity at work ENERGY SCALE 5D warped continuum RS2-like theory (one brane) Continuum states 5D warped KK regime RS1-like (two branes) Discrete KK modes 27 Costantino, Fichet, Tanedo: 2002.12335