Full online slides: https://dalgaaf.github.io/openstack-summit-barcelona/ Presentation held on the OpenStack Summit 2016 in Barcelona. Abstract: If it comes to OpenStack there is always the question: vanilla or a distribution. You have the agony of choice, it will highly depend on your use case and organization. This presentation will not only highlight differences and similarities between these choices but also between the major OpenStack distributions. We will take a look behind the curtain of the OpenStack products. What should you know about the offerings? Is there anything you may should evaluate before you choose a solution? There is more to take a look at than only the OpenStack product itself if you include also e.g. KVM and Ceph. What about the base distributions and support? This talk will cover besides Vanilla also RedHat, SUSE, Ubuntu/Canonical, and Mirantis OpenStack.

1. VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLAVANILLA
or
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONS
DISTRIBUTIONSDISTRIBUTIONS
How do they differentiate ?
danny.al-gaaf@bisect.de

2. What means
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLA
VANILLAVANILLA
in this context?

3. UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAM
UPSTREAMUPSTREAM
without
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGES
PRIVAT CHANGESPRIVAT CHANGES
from VCS or released packages

4. Sounds
GREAT
GREAT
GREAT
GREAT
GREAT
GREAT
GREAT
GREAT
GREATGREAT
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?
RIGHT?RIGHT?

5. Lets take a look

6. 111111
Know your
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!
REQUIREMENTS!REQUIREMENTS!

7. May consider
topics
like

8. Which software do you need ?
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGESTORAGE
Ceph
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OSBASE OS
Kernel/Hypervisor/...

9. Which specific
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTS
COMPONENTSCOMPONENTS
OpenStack projects
and
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURESFEATURES
CephFS, SDN, Hypervisor, API versions ...

10. Operational requirements
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CD
CI/CDCI/CD
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATION
AUTOMATIONAUTOMATION
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT
Release Cycles, Update/Upgrade
SLAs
SUPPORTSUPPORTSUPPORTSUPPORTSUPPORTSUPPORT

11. But also
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCY
COST & EFFICENCYCOST & EFFICENCY
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICS
LEGAL TOPICSLEGAL TOPICS

12. 222222
Your
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATIONORGANIZATION

13. Even with full automation

14. You absolutely need
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCED
EXPERIENCEDEXPERIENCED
Operators
but also very likely
Developers

15. You may also need to change
the mindset of people
and adapt processes.

16. 333333
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITYCOMMUNITY

17. How do you get
bugs fixed
or
missing features
upstream implemented?

18. Participate in the
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITY
COMMUNITYCOMMUNITY
Report your bugs and missing features!
Give feedback!
Review!

19. But what then?
Open source developers do either:
what they are interested in
or
what they are payed for.

20. Therefore
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:
BE PREPARED:BE PREPARED:
At the end you may
fix or implement it!

21. With this in mind,
let's take a
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOK
DEEPER LOOKDEEPER LOOK

23. Core Services: Higly mature and widely adopted.

24. Optional Services:
Lower level of maturity and adoption!
BARBICAN
Key Management
CEILOMETER
Telemetry
DESIGNATE
DNS Service
FUEL
Deployment/Management
HEAT
Orchestration
HORIZON
Dashboard
Ironic
Bare-Metal Provisioning
MAGNUM
Containers
MANILA
Shared Filesystems
MISTRAL
Workflow Service
MURANO
Application Catalog
SAHARA
Elastic Map Reduce
TROVE
Database

25. What about Automation?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?
Write your own?Write your own?
Sure!
If you prefer the epic fail!

26. What does the
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?OPENSTACK COMMUNITY?
Ansible, Puppet, Chef.

27. But what about
Fuel and Juju?

28. May an option if you use
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTIS
MIRANTISMIRANTIS
Fuel
or
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICAL
CANONICALCANONICAL
Juju
96% of the code is from one company

29. But even then:
The community code may not fit your needs.
It may takes quite some time to make it work.
You may stuck with a release longer than expected.
Very likely means:
Lot of extra work for you!

31. Most mature:
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBDRBD
block storage
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGWRADOSGW
Swift/S3 oject store

32. Less mature:
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFSCephFS

33. What about Automation?
First: Check above!
Then choose from
ceph-deploy
or
Ansible, Puppet, Chef

34. What are the
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
ALTERNATIVESALTERNATIVES
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?
TO VANILLA ?TO VANILLA ?

35. Select a
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTIONDISTRIBUTION

36. Leaves one question:
What is the
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFRERED
PREFREREDPREFRERED
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTIONDISTRIBUTION
of your organization?

38. 111111
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK

39. Red Hat
Red Hat
Red Hat
Red Hat
Red Hat
Red Hat
Red Hat
Red Hat
Red HatRed Hat
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9
OpenStack Platform 9OpenStack Platform 9
with
based on
RHEL 7.2

40. KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNELKERNEL
3.10-based
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISORHYPERVISOR
KVM
ESX (vCenter)
Docker (OpenShift)

41. Deployment
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOROSP DIRECTOR
TripleO and Ansible
or
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACK
PACKSTACKPACKSTACK

42. OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORTOPENSTACK SUPPORT
All Core Services plus
BARBICAN
Key Management
CEILOMETER
Telemetry
DESIGNATE
DNS Service
FUEL
Deployment/Management
HEAT
Orchestration
HORIZON
Dashboard
Ironic
Bare-Metal Provisioning
MAGNUM
Containers
MANILA
Shared Filesystems
MISTRAL
Workflow Service
MURANO
Application Catalog
SAHARA
Elastic Map Reduce
TEMPEST
Integration Test Suite
TROVE
Database
Technical Preview
Supported
Unsupported

43. LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLELIFE CYCLE
New downstream version with
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream releaseevery upstream release
Next:
Newton, end of 2016, RHEL 7.3

44. Additionally recommended
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOR
OSP DIRECTOROSP DIRECTOR
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITE
SATELLITESATELLITE
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMS
CLOUDFORMSCLOUDFORMS

45. SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORTSUPPORT
Two phases:
1 year
1 year
1 year
1 year
1 year
1 year
1 year
1 year
1 year1 year
Full support (till August 2017)
2 years
2 years
2 years
2 years
2 years
2 years
2 years
2 years
2 years2 years
No feature backport, installer updates, new partner additions and certification
(till August 2019)

46. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
per machine and per-socket-pair
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:DEPENDING ON:
running RHEL guests or not
support for business hours or 24x7
special SLAs

47. 222222
CEPHCEPHCEPHCEPHCEPHCEPH

48. Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0Red Hat Ceph Storage 2.0
based on
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWELJEWEL
RHEL 7.2 or Ubuntu 16.04

49. Deployment via
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLE
ANSIBLEANSIBLE
or
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLE
RH STORAGE CONSOLERH STORAGE CONSOLE

50. CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFSCephFS
Tech preview in RHCS 2.0
Support planed for Q1/2017

51. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
Yearly subscriptions
based on:
raw capacity with node limit
Also available:
pre-production subscriptions

53. 111111
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK

54. SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSESUSE
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7
OpenStack Cloud 7OpenStack Cloud 7
with
based on
SLES 12 SP2

55. KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNELKERNEL
4.4-based
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISORHYPERVISOR
KVM, Xen
Hyper-V, VMWare vSphere
IBM z/VM
Docker

56. Deployment
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBARCROWBAR
(v4.0)
and
CHEFCHEFCHEFCHEFCHEFCHEF
(v10)

57. OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORTOPENSTACK SUPPORT
All Core Services plus
BARBICAN
Key Management
CEILOMETER
Telemetry
DESIGNATE
DNS Service
FUEL
Deployment/Management
HEAT
Orchestration
HORIZON
Dashboard
Ironic
Bare-Metal Provisioning
MAGNUM
Containers
MANILA
Shared Filesystems
MISTRAL
Workflow Service
MURANO
Application Catalog
SAHARA
Elastic Map Reduce
TEMPEST
Integration Test Suite
TROVE
Database
Technical Preview
Supported
Unsupported

58. LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLELIFE CYCLE
New downstream version with
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream release
every 2nd upstream releaseevery 2nd upstream release
Next:
P-release

59. Additionally recommended
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIO
SUSE STUDIOSUSE STUDIO
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGER
SUSE MANAGERSUSE MANAGER
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSION
SLES HA EXTENSIONSLES HA EXTENSION
(for KVM/Xen compute nodes)

60. SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORTSUPPORT
at least
27 months
27 months
27 months
27 months
27 months
27 months
27 months
27 months
27 months27 months
after GA

61. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
control node
admin node
compute node, per-socket-pair (SLES)
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:DEPENDING ON:
12x5 or 24x7
special SLAs

62. 222222
CEPHCEPHCEPHCEPHCEPHCEPH

63. SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
SUSE Enterprise Storage 3SUSE Enterprise Storage 3
based on
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWELJEWEL
with
Calamari

64. Deployment via
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBAR
CROWBARCROWBAR
or
SALT
SALT
SALT
SALT
SALT
SALT
SALT
SALT
SALTSALT
(tech preview)

65. FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURES
FEATURESFEATURES
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFS
CephFSCephFS
Tech preview in v3
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSI
iSCSIiSCSI
to connect Windows and VMWare

66. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
per node
Basis subscription:
with 4 OSDs, 3/5 MONs, Admin/Deploy node
priority support included

67. 333333
MOREMOREMOREMOREMOREMORE

68. You should know:
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSE
SUSESUSE
Is the only distro
which does not charge for
development of upstream features
if you agree on it!
All included in the subscription!

70. 111111
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK

71. Mirantis
Mirantis
Mirantis
Mirantis
Mirantis
Mirantis
Mirantis
Mirantis
MirantisMirantis
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9
OpenStack 9OpenStack 9
with

72. Mirantis is the
ONLY
ONLY
ONLY
ONLY
ONLY
ONLY
ONLY
ONLY
ONLYONLY
distribution
not maintaining an own
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OS
BASE OSBASE OS

73. CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODES
CONTROLLER NODESCONTROLLER NODES
Ubuntu 14.04 (next 16.04)
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODES
COMPUTE NODESCOMPUTE NODES
Ubuntu 14.04 (next 16.04)
RHEL 7.x
Oracle Linux 7.x
SUSE Enterprise Linux

74. KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNELKERNEL
depends on Base OS
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISORHYPERVISOR
KVM
Xen via plugin
VMWare vSphere

75. Deployment
via
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUELFUEL

76. OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORTOPENSTACK SUPPORT
All Core Services plus
BARBICAN
Key Management
CEILOMETER
Telemetry
DESIGNATE
DNS Service
FUEL
Deployment/Management
HEAT
Orchestration
HORIZON
Dashboard
Ironic
Bare-Metal Provisioning
MAGNUM
Containers
MANILA
Shared Filesystems
MISTRAL
Workflow Service
MURANO
Application Catalog
SAHARA
Elastic Map Reduce
TEMPEST
Integration Test Suite
TROVE
Database
Technical Preview
Supported
Unsupported

77. LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLELIFE CYCLE
New downstream version with
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream releaseevery upstream release
within 1-6 months
Next:
MOS 10 (Newton, H1/2017)

78. Additionally recommended
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
MIRANTIS STACKLIGHTMIRANTIS STACKLIGHT
and
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOG
PARTNER CATALOGPARTNER CATALOG
(Billing, LBaaS, DBaaS, SDN, Storage)

79. SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORTSUPPORT
Each release for
3 years
3 years
3 years
3 years
3 years
3 years
3 years
3 years
3 years3 years

80. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
per machine (Ubuntu)
per-socket-pair (RHEL)
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:DEPENDING ON:
8x5
24x7
Proactive

81. 222222
CEPHCEPHCEPHCEPHCEPHCEPH

82. Part of
MOS
MOS
MOS
MOS
MOS
MOS
MOS
MOS
MOSMOS
based on
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMER
HAMMERHAMMER
and
UBUNTUUBUNTUUBUNTUUBUNTUUBUNTUUBUNTU

83. Deployment via
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUEL
FUELFUEL
plugin

84. Only
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBD
RBDRBD
and
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGW
RADOSGWRADOSGW
supported

85. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
Subscription
based on:
gross capacity

87. 111111
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK

88. UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTU
UBUNTUUBUNTU
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK
with
based on
Ubuntu 16.04 LTS

89. KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNELKERNEL
4.4-based
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISOR
HYPERVISORHYPERVISOR
KVM
Hyper-V
LXD

90. Let's get one thing out of the way!
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK"CANONICAL" OPENSTACK
(enterprise version)
≠
≠
≠
≠
≠
≠
≠
≠
≠≠
UBUNTU OPENSTACKUBUNTU OPENSTACKUBUNTU OPENSTACKUBUNTU OPENSTACKUBUNTU OPENSTACKUBUNTU OPENSTACK
(community version)

91. While probably most
Community Developers
using Ubuntu, make use of
DevStack, Puppet, Ansible, Chef
the enterprise version uses
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaS
JuJu and MaaSJuJu and MaaS

92. OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORT
OPENSTACK SUPPORTOPENSTACK SUPPORT
All Core Services plus
BARBICAN
Key Management
CEILOMETER
Telemetry
DESIGNATE
DNS Service
FUEL
Deployment/Management
HEAT
Orchestration
HORIZON
Dashboard
Ironic
Bare-Metal Provisioning
MAGNUM
Containers
MANILA
Shared Filesystems
MISTRAL
Workflow Service
MURANO
Application Catalog
SAHARA
Elastic Map Reduce
TEMPEST
Integration Test Suite
TROVE
Database
Technical Preview
Supported
Unsupported

93. LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLELIFE CYCLE
New downstream version with
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream release
every upstream releaseevery upstream release

94. Additionally recommended
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPELANDSCAPE
for
system management, security compliance and audit

95. SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORTSUPPORT
5 years
5 years
5 years
5 years
5 years
5 years
5 years
5 years
5 years5 years
For versions released with LTS
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years
1,5 years1,5 years
For 3 following versions (e.g. N, O, P)
3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years
OpenStack release of next LTS in former version

96. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
node/year
VM/hour
OpenStack regions (S/M/L)
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:
DEPENDING ON:DEPENDING ON:
support for business hours, 24x7, managed

97. 222222
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPHCEPH

98. UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGE
UBUNTU ADVANTAGEUBUNTU ADVANTAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGE
STORAGESTORAGE
based on
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWEL
JEWELJEWEL
with
Ubuntu Performance Dashboard

99. PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICING
PRICINGPRICING
Subscription
based on:
used capacity

100. 333333
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUES
POTENTIAL ISSUESPOTENTIAL ISSUES

101. LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPE
LANDSCAPELANDSCAPE
and
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCE
UBUNTU PERFORMANCEUBUNTU PERFORMANCE
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARD
DASHBOARDDASHBOARD
(for Ceph)
have a
non Open Source license

102. KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNELKERNEL
At least
controversial
integration of
ZFSZFSZFSZFSZFSZFS
in 16.04

104. How to assess
if a distro can provide
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORTSUPPORT
for your project?

105. MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?
MARKETING?MARKETING?
Just Kidding!
Rhetorical question!

106. If you are lucky:
The experience of
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELF
YOURSELFYOURSELF
or
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODY
SOMEBODYSOMEBODY
you know

107. If you have time and ressources:
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATION
EVALUATIONEVALUATION
PoC
PoC
PoC
PoC
PoC
PoC
PoC
PoC
PoCPoC
Before you stuck with one!

108. Another may helpful indicator:
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICS
SOME STATISTICSSOME STATISTICS
on recent project
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONS
CONTRIBUTIONSCONTRIBUTIONS
of the distributions

109. OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACK
OPENSTACKOPENSTACK

110. COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORECOMMITS TO OPENSTACK CORE

111. COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
COMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONALCOMMITS TO OPENSTACK OPTIONAL
Barbican, Ceilometer, Designate, Heat, Horizon, Ironic, Magnum, Manila, Murano, Sahara, Trove

112. REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
REVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONALREVIEWS IN CORE AND OPTIONAL

113. BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
BUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONALBUGFIX RATIO IN CORE AND OPTIONAL
resolved vs. reported bugs in %

114. COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION
COMMITS TO DOCUMENTATIONCOMMITS TO DOCUMENTATION

115. CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPH
CEPHCEPH

116. COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITSCOMMITS
ceph.git, 2016/10/20

117. KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNEL
KERNELKERNEL

118. CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETS
CHANGESETSCHANGESETS
source: linux.git, gitdm with 4.4 data set, 2016/10/20

119. CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
CHANGESETS IN STABLE TREECHANGESETS IN STABLE TREE
source: linux-stable.git, gitdm with 4.4 data set, 2016/10/20

120. KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRT
KVM/LIBVIRTKVM/LIBVIRT

121. COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITS
COMMITSCOMMITS
libvirt/qemu git, 2016/10/20

122. Trademarks or registered trademarks used in this presentation are the property
of their respective owners.

123. https://dalgaaf.github.io/openstack-summit-barcelona