This document provides a summary of Navah Hopkins' presentation at the Utah Digital Marketing Collective on unlocking ROI from any budget. The presentation covered:
1) Questions to ask clients to establish a performance baseline, such as which parts of the business are most valuable and if leads are equal.
2) Common causes of poor performance related to inadequate budgets, including wasted spend, budgets not aligned with campaign structures, and losing impression share to rank.
3) Strategies for getting the most out of an existing budget, including adjusting bids and targets, prioritizing high-value areas, and exploring alternative platforms like Bing.
4) Signs an account is performing well and winning, and questions
12. #UTAHDMC
WE HAVE AN INCREDIBLE LINEUP!
• 3 KEYNOTES
• 15 PRESENTATIONS
• 2 TRACKS
• SWAG & FOOD
• FANOCRACY BOOK TO FIRST
400 PAID ATTENDEES
•WORKSHOP DAY ON 27TH
22. WORKFRONT, LEHI
SEO Manager
‣ Lead SEO initiatives
‣ Run technical and on-site audits to optimize and improve
site performance
‣ 3-5 years managing SEO (prefer some experience in
B2B/SaaS)
‣ Experience using web analytics (Google Analytics, Adobe
Analytics) - SEO software (SEMRush, Ahrefs, Moz, etc.) -
SEO crawling software (ScreamingFrog, DeepCrawl, etc.)
‣ https://www.workfront.com/job/2069695
#UTAHDMC
23. MATIX LABS, BOUNTIFUL
Senior Google Ads/Paid Search
Specialist
‣ Minimum of 3 years experience running Google Ads in
the ecommerce space (Search/Shopping/YouTube)
‣ Prefer past agency experience
‣ Need to be comfortable on the phone with clients
‣ Unique compensation model, base salary plus monthly
commissions earned on every client you manage.
‣ Salary: $70,000.00 to $100,000.00 /year
‣ https://www.indeed.com/job/senior-google-adspaid-
search-specialist-63583e08f996ad99
#UTAHDMC
24. RETAILSPHERE.COM, SLC
Sales Leader
‣ Implementing sales strategy, build and maintain
infrastructure, and overse the team’s daily performance.
‣ Proven track record of recruiting, training, ramping and
managing entry to mid level successful inside sales reps
to sell SaaS product(s)
‣ Experience with HubSpot Sales CRM ideal
‣ Experience selling or working within the real estate or
“prop tech” industries NOT required but a plus
‣ https://retailsphere.com/Careers/Sales-Leader-7
#UTAHDMC
25. RETAILSPHERE.COM, SLC
Inside Sales Manager
‣ As a proven seller.
‣ Be a highly money-motivated, quota busting selling
machine.
‣ Experience with all aspects of inside sales.
‣ A natural salesperson, with experience selling
subscription tech products in a b-to-b environment.
‣ Detail oriented with outstanding follow up skills
‣ https://retailsphere.com/Careers/Inside-Sales-
Manager-9
#UTAHDMC
26. AUTOMILE, PLEASANT GROVE
Digital Marketing Manager
‣ Responsible for build out, personalization, and
optimization of digital campaigns.
‣ Managing $100k+ in monthly ad spend.
‣ Executing campaigns and lead management programs.
‣ 3+ years in a digital marketing with experience across
multiple channels (Google, Facebook, etc.)
‣ Track record of launching successful marketing
campaigns that drive qualified leads
‣ https://automile.com/career/digital_marketing_manager
#UTAHDMC
27. UTAHDMC.ORG/JOB-BOARD
PUT YOUR JOB IN FRONT OF OUR AUDIENCE!
‣ EMAILED TO 4500+ CONTACT DATABASE
‣ SHARED ON TWITTER, FACEBOOK AND SLACK
‣ ANNOUNCED AT MONTHLY EVENT
QUESTIONS? EMAIL AJ@UTAHDMC.ORG
#UTAHDMC
29. KYLE SHURTZ
DOUBLING DOWN ON PPC: HOW TO
INFORM YOUR OTHER MARKETING
CHANNELS WITH PPC DATA
VP OF PERFORMANCE MARKETING
AVALAUNCH MEDIA
SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
TONIGHTS 1ST PRESENTER:
#UTAHDMC
31. Avalaunch Media is a full-service marketing agency based in Salt Lake City, Utah. For more than 15 years, we’ve been
passionate about marketing and producing tangible results for clients. We’re inspired by devising and executing marketing
strategies that launch our clients and earn their trust.
Our team consists of successful business owners, attorneys, MBAs, and professionals with years of experience in the public
and private sectors. We operate from experience and focus on creating sustainable and long-term marketing success.
32.
33. Kyle is the VP of Performance Marketing at Avalaunch Media and leverages top media channels,
industry best practices, and a few “wild bets” to create powerful campaigns. Kyle’s team of paid
media marketers and marketing automation specialists know how to ask the right questions.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51. KYLE SHURTZ
DOUBLING DOWN ON PPC: HOW TO
INFORM YOUR OTHER MARKETING
CHANNELS WITH PPC DATA
VP OF PERFORMANCE MARKETING
AVALAUNCH MEDIA
SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
THANK YOU
#UTAHDMC
53. NAVAH HOPKINS
UNLOCKING ROI OUT OF ANY
BUDGET
DIRECTOR OF PAID MEDIA
HENNESSEY DIGITAL
BOSTON, MA
TONIGHTS 2ND PRESENTER:
#UTAHDMC
54. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Unlocking ROI In Any Budget
By: Navah Hopkins
55. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
I am a bounty hunter of happiness and profit
(& a Star Wars nerd)
56. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Am focused on the business metrics
of my stakeholders (clients).
• Know when to invest and when to
hold back.
• Live for the thrill of winning for my
stakeholders.
This means I:
57. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Talking Money is Hard – Talking Profit is Easy
58. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
By the end of this session, each of you will have the tools to be a fellow bounty hunter of happiness and profit
59. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
What We’ll Be Covering
➔ Baseline/Questions to Ask
➔ Poor Performance Caused by
Lack of Budget
➔ Can’t Spend the Budget
➔ Account is Winning
➔ Casestudy
Navah Hopkins
Director of Paid Media
61. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Before We Can Begin Hunting, We Need to Do
Some Reconnaissance
62. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Are All Parts of the Business Equal, or Are Some
Worth More?
63. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Are There Hubs of High-Value Customers, or Are
They Truly Spread Out?
64. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Are Phone and Website Leads Equal? Do Conversion
Rates and Auction Prices Align?
65. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Impression Share
• Auction Price
• Conversion Rate/Value
Three Trails Good Hunters
Follow:
66. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Most Advertisers Struggle to Achieve 50%+ of Available Impressions
Based on
2973
accounts
with at least
$.01 in
search
spend
Average
impression
share is 47%
67. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Search Auction Prices Vary by Industry – don’t bring a blaster to a
68. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
If You Know You Have An Easier Time Winning on Mobile/Desktop, Don’t Be Afraid to Focus There
Mobile:
4.39% CTR
$34.79 CPA
69. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
✓Location Targets
✓Duplicate Keywords
✓Structure of the Campaign
✓Match-types of keywords
✓Bidding strategies
Raising Budget is a Last Resort
– Check the Following First:
70. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Poor Performance Caused by Lack of Budget
72. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
If there’s a hint of wasted spend, it
can be hard to convince clients to
open up budget.
73. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Here’s the problem: a budget that isn’t aligned with the structure it’s asked to support will always be wasted spend
74. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Can your budget support 10 “top of page clicks”?
76. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
If Not, Assess if You Can Get The Traffic With Different Search Ideas
77. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Check The Search Terms For The Real Heroes!
3% cheaper &
perfect
conversion
rate!
78. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Broad Keywords Can Drag Your Budget into Unintended Auctions
162%
More
Than
Average
79. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
If they’re all too high, find out if clients can live
without that Traffic
80. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Use extensions to communicate
valuable ideas without paying a
premium.
• Bid adjustments can focus the budget.
• Lumping strategic initiatives together
can cause all to fail.
Not all profit centers are
equal:
81. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Daily Budgets Needed For AT LEAST One Lead Based on 2019 Average CPC
Monthly
budget will be
30.4 X daily
budget
82. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Bing’s Auction Prices Can Be More Forgiving
83. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Starting Bing Is As Easy As Setting Up An Auto-Import
84. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Be transparent about industry costs
and whether budget expectations are
realistic.
• Offer options that work within the
requested budget.
• Give realistic timelines for growth
When crafting marketing
budgets/assessing clients:
86. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
It can be intimidating to ask for more budget, when
you’re struggling to spend existing budget.
87. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Your Campaign is Likely Losing Impression Share to Rank
88. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Too many targets
• Bids and auction prices not aligned
• Search volume isn’t there for
“important” keywords
Here are the most common
culprits:
89. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
There’s only so
many signals a
budget can
accommodate
90. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Targeting 5+ locations without bid adjustments can cause budget allocation issues
91. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Different Locations Have Different Auction Prices, Search Patterns, & Time Zones
92. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Number of ad groups can also choke a budget: 5-7 is the golden ratio!
60% of
impressions
Budget will
only go to
“winners”
instead of
everything
93. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Bid to budget ratio is only part of the equation: if the bids are too low, you
94. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
While it is true Google can up to double your
budget, you can’t bank on it delivering premium
volume if you’re consistently under bidding
95. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Search volume is an important mechanic in account health
96. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Google’s not going to waste its time or your money on pages
97. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
But those pages may be important to clients
98. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Turn important low volume keywords into
site links/callouts
• Make a low budget “experiment” campaign
to house these ideas
• Ask the client if they’d be open to content
marketing being responsible for those
ideas.
Here are three easy
solutions:
100. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Congratulations! You’ve vanquished your enemies
and achieved profit!
101. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
But we’re bounty hunters of profit and happiness…
there’s always more to be had
102. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Can your client handle more leads or are
they at capacity?
• Is this seasonal – should we invest now, or
hold for next season?
• Should the budget go to existing initiatives,
or would you rather expand to new
platforms/parts of the business?
Before we continue:
103. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Here is what I look for in a winning campaign
Consistently
above 75%
impression
share!
Campaign live for at least three months
104. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Important: Never dump large amounts of money into a winning campaign all at once!
105. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Gradually increase budget by 10-15% each week
over a month
106. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
A great way to expand is to layer in display!
In-market display
ad with affinity
content!
107. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Display Average CPC’s Are Cheaper – Build Your Perfect Audience to Be Picked Up By Search Remarketing
10%
conversion
rate vs 4%
conversion
rate
108. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Display Can Bring Users Your Branded and Remarketing Search Campaigns are Poised to Pick-up
$500
Monthly
Budget
168550
Monthly
Impressions
701
Monthly
Clicks
*Average monthly budget, impressions and clicks across 4000
accounts (no budget over $50 and no budget under $1)
109. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
Don’t Forget About Facebook!
26% Of Clicks Result In A
Conversion (Spark Central)
110. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Average CPC is $1.72, but this is
determined by how many folks click
on your ad!
• Now that budgets are campaign level
choices, be sure you’re choosing the
right objective for how you judge ROI!
• 19% of time spent on mobile is on
Facebook.
Facebook Budgets
111. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
By running campaigns on other networks, you can expand your Google market:
112. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
New Campaigns Are Expensive – the
first 1-2 months of a campaign will be
about data acquisition
116. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Quality of leads
• Return on ad spend
• Volume of leads (as long as quality isn’t
impacted)
• Year over year growth
• Growing the value of a customer
Clients will care about:
117. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
If we want to grow the budget, we need to speak their language
119. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• $2,700 monthly costs
• Conversions weren’t tracking
properly
• Struggling to get enough business
to justify keeping staff
Before We Found Each Other,
Marketing Their Business Was Stressful
121. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Built trust by identifying and eliminating wasted
spend brought in by broad terms and
tangential searches.
• Focused budgets by geos served and replicated
winning structure across those areas.
• Layered in display to educate markets on why
their approach to training works.
How did we achieve victory?
129. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
“Dog Training” Just As Broad – Worse Quality
130. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
• Paused dubious “dog trainer” in
favor of long-tail broad.
• Removed extra numbers
• Used “borrowed” budget to
invest in educational display
So We:
131. | #UtahDMC @navahf @HennesseyDgtl
We Were Able To Unlock Profit In One Month!