1. Using Enterprise Architecture
to harmonise national
legislation

2. Agenda
• Project Background
• Project Approach
• Realisation
• Some observations

3. Directive 2006/123/EC (“Service Directive”)
aims to
• modernise and simplify Member States'
regulatory frameworks
• lift barriers to the functioning of the
Internal Market for services.
The Project Driver

4. Directive 2006/123/EC (“Services Directive”)
aims to
• modernise and simplify Member States'
regulatory frameworks
• lift barriers to the functioning of the
Internal Market for services.
The Project Driver
• harmonisation of legislation
• simplification of the administrative
procedures
• modernisation of administrative services

5. Main stakeholders
Authorities
(Public Service Providers)
• Ministries
• Municipalities
• Government Agencies
• Chambers
• ….
Service Providers
• Companies
• Craftsmen
• Lawyers, engineers, architects
• Other freelancers
• …

6. Public Service
Provider
Public Service
Provider
Услуга
в обхвата на
DIR2006/123
Услуга
в обхвата на
DIR2006/123
SERVICE
in the scope of
DIR2006/123
license
------------
------------
Public Service
Provider
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
NACE: Nomenclature statistique des Activités économiques dans la CE
DIRECTIVE
2006 / 123
National
Law
§

7. • Project Background
• Project Approach
• Realisation
• Some observations
Agenda

8. The toolset
Use MS Office
Create RDBMS
based app
• web access
• user management
• security
• ….
Use repository-
based EA tool

9. Service Categorisation Viewpoint
Public Service Viewpoint
Administrative Procedure Viewpoint
Business Process ViewpointThe meta-model

10. Service Categorisation Viewpoint
Public Service Viewpoint
Administrative Procedure Viewpoint
Business Process Viewpoint

11. • Weekly cycle
• In case of recurring patterns of misfit
• Elaboration of application (adapt interpretation rules)
• Modification of modelling conventions
In the remaining cases:
• Change of meta-model
Impact analysis
Regression tests
Adaptations
changes
time

12. Public Service
Provider
Public Service
Provider
Услуга
в обхвата на
DIR2006/123
Услуга
в обхвата на
DIR2006/123
SERVICE
in the scope of
DIR2006/123
section
division
group
class
license
------------
------------
Public Service
Provider
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
NACE: Nomenclature statistique des Activités économiques dans la CE
NACE

13. • Project Background
• Project Approach
• Realisation
• Some observations
Agenda

14. NACE

15. Registration of a retail site
Registration of a site for public use
Registration under VAT Act
sector
division
group
class

16. Registration of a retail site
Registration of a site for public use
Registration under VAT Act
Identified private
services and their
relations to economic
activities and public
services

17. Registration of a retail site
Registration of a site for public use
Registration under VAT Act

18. Registration of
ECS
One-tier
system
Two-tier
system
Founder is а
legal entity
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law
Founder is legal
entity, member of
BoD
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law,
member of BoD
Cash
contribution
Contribution
in kind
Corporeal right
over immovables
or vehicles
Receivables
Registration of European
Cooperative Society

19. Registration of
ECS
One-tier
system
Two-tier
system
Founder is а
legal entity
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law
Founder is legal
entity, member of
BoD
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law,
member of BoD
Cash
contribution
Contribution
in kind
Corporeal right
over immovables
or vehicles
Receivables

20. Registration of
ECS
One-tier
system
Two-tier
system
Founder is а
legal entity
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law
Founder is legal
entity, member of
BoD
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law,
member of BoD
Cash
contribution
Contribution
in kind
Corporeal right
over immovables
or vehicles
Receivables
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
Scenario 4
….
Scenario N
Registration of European
Cooperative Society
Scenario 5

21. Process improvement
AS-IS TO-BEsimplification
compliance
e-Government

22. Process improvement
AS-IS TO-BEsimplification
compliance
e-Government
New capabilities
needed

23. • Having many documented elements connected
allowed for extracting important information
(outside the scope of the project but with
minimal effort)
• Example:
• Report on the needed Government-to-Government
(G2G) services
Additional benefits

24. "When certain circumstances are certified by
another authority in the territory of the Republic of
Bulgaria, the competent authority may not require
proof by the service supplier, but is obliged to
gather them directly from that authority."
The Act for Activities Related to Provision of Services, Art 11, Par 5
Legal grounds

25. Discovery of
needed G2G
services

26. Discovery of
needed G2G
services

27. • Project Background
• Project Approach
• Realisation
• Some observations
Agenda

28. Load balance
cognitiveload
work load
Modellers
Method designers
Legal consultantsClient
Report writers
Programmers

29. Load Balance
work load
Modellers
Method designers
Legal consultantsClient
Report writers
Programmers
Registration of
ECS
One-tier
system
Two-tier
system
Founder is а
legal entity
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law
Founder is legal
entity, member of
BoD
Founding entity
not incorporated
under BG law,
member of BoD
Cash
contribution
Contribution
in kind
Corporeal right
over immovables
or vehicles
Receivables
cognitiveload

30. • The team
• 4 part time
• 5 full-time
• 7 locations
• Project
• Duration: 6 months
• Scope:
290 Public services
50 Public service Providers
1400 legal requirements
Some numbers

31. • More information about this case, and from a
different angle, is available in the book
• (Chapter 10)
• http://www.igi-global.com/book/enterprise-architecture-
connected-government/62630