The document discusses theories and strategies related to investing, including modern portfolio theory, behavioral finance theories, and secular stock market cycles. It notes opportunities to improve upon traditional strategic asset allocation models by combining them with tactical allocation approaches. This would involve adjusting allocations between asset classes in response to changing market conditions to better protect from downside losses. The lessons learned are that markets are riskier than traditional models assume, with fat tails and potential for secular bear markets, so portfolios need strategies to manage severe downturns.
Momentum, Mean Reversion, Martingales, and Model Value are prevalent disasters in financial Industrial technology. All segments of this caterpillar in your garden are destroying your net wealth eating your lettuce on a summer day.
More contented mooing for 15 to 20% IRR p.a.
StockTakers ABC-ZsTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Nice market mooing for 6.03 to 17.78% p.a. StockTaker helps small investors grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
More contented mooing for 4% to 10% in a month.
StockTakers ABC-ZsTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
More contented mooing for 4% to 10% in a month.
StockTakers ABC-ZsTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Momentum, Mean Reversion, Martingales, and Model Value are prevalent disasters in financial Industrial technology. All segments of this caterpillar in your garden are destroying your net wealth eating your lettuce on a summer day.
More contented mooing for 15 to 20% IRR p.a.
StockTakers ABC-ZsTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Nice market mooing for 6.03 to 17.78% p.a. StockTaker helps small investors grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
More contented mooing for 4% to 10% in a month.
StockTakers ABC-ZsTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
More contented mooing for 4% to 10% in a month.
StockTakers ABC-ZsTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Awesome Penny Stocks specialize in finding hidden gems in the OTC, they find companies with new and exciting visions and help spotlight these companies. They hope you enjoy with their website.
How to Lock in Profits on Every Trade - Presented by Dr. Richard M. Smith TradeStops
www.tradestops.com
How to Lock in Profits on Every Trade - Presented by Dr. Richard M. Smith
Learn the single most important reason that individual investors lose money.
Learn the proven mathematical formula to make bigger and faster gains on every trade you make.
Learn what trailing stops are and how they work.
Learn how to make a plan for tracking your stocks to sell at just the right time.
View case studies of this process in action and the amazing results.
Deep Value and the Aquirer's Multiple by Tobias Carlisle for QuantCon 2016Quantopian
How to beat The Little Book That Beats The Market: An exploration of the deep value investment strategy. This talk will combines engaging anecdotes with industry research to illustrate the principles and reasoning behind a counterintuitive investment strategy.
Very contented mooing from those TSX Newbies - 8.24% in 3 months.
StockTakers WHYNOTtsxBUBBYTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Investors have lost trillions. Advisors have lost the respect and confidence of their clients and their practices have suffered from declining AUM and client outflows. Traditional models have failed.
Hybrid Portfolio Theory provides an alternative to advisors and investors that want to safeguard their portfolio from unexpected negative black swan events, while positioning for the opportunity to benefit from positive asymmetrical outcomes.
Awesome Penny Stocks specialize in finding hidden gems in the OTC, they find companies with new and exciting visions and help spotlight these companies. They hope you enjoy with their website.
How to Lock in Profits on Every Trade - Presented by Dr. Richard M. Smith TradeStops
www.tradestops.com
How to Lock in Profits on Every Trade - Presented by Dr. Richard M. Smith
Learn the single most important reason that individual investors lose money.
Learn the proven mathematical formula to make bigger and faster gains on every trade you make.
Learn what trailing stops are and how they work.
Learn how to make a plan for tracking your stocks to sell at just the right time.
View case studies of this process in action and the amazing results.
Deep Value and the Aquirer's Multiple by Tobias Carlisle for QuantCon 2016Quantopian
How to beat The Little Book That Beats The Market: An exploration of the deep value investment strategy. This talk will combines engaging anecdotes with industry research to illustrate the principles and reasoning behind a counterintuitive investment strategy.
Very contented mooing from those TSX Newbies - 8.24% in 3 months.
StockTakers WHYNOTtsxBUBBYTM gives small investors means to grow their wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves.
Because You Can.
Accredited investors can Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Investors have lost trillions. Advisors have lost the respect and confidence of their clients and their practices have suffered from declining AUM and client outflows. Traditional models have failed.
Hybrid Portfolio Theory provides an alternative to advisors and investors that want to safeguard their portfolio from unexpected negative black swan events, while positioning for the opportunity to benefit from positive asymmetrical outcomes.
Lovely mooing herd for 14.54-19.56% pa.
StockTakers BlackSwanTrading-Solo 50K TM allows small investors to grow their own wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves with our 'likeables'.
Because You Can.
Accredited Investors Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
StockTakers Hark, FESTIVUS mooing herds 14.44-18.50% pa.
BlackSwanTrading-Solo 50K TM helps small investors grow their own wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves with our 'likeables'.
Because You Can.
Accredited Investors Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
FESTIVUS Hark, the mooing herds for 14.39-18.12% pa.
StockTakers BlackSwanTrading-Solo 50K TM allows small investors to grow their own wealth with our Risk Price driven 'likeables'.
Enjoy another slice of our Risk Price method to earn investment income for yourselves with our 'likeables'.
Because You Can.
Accredited Investors Buy A Slice of StockTakers 12% Bond to earn investment income by leaving that work to us.
Because We Do.
Abstract
The idea of an Efficient Market first came from the French mathematician Louis Bachelier in 1900: « The theory of speculation ».
Bachelier argued that there is no useful information in past stock prices that can help predicting future prices and proposed a theory for financial options’ valuation based on Fourier’s law and Brownian’s motions (time series).
Bachelier’s work get popular in the 60s during the computer’s era.
In 1965, Eugene Fama published a dissertation arguing for the random walk hypothesis (Stock market’s prices evolve randomly: prices cannot be predicted using past data).
In 1970, Fama published a review of the theory and empirical evidences
The EMH (Efficient Market Hypothesis): Financial markets are efficient at processing information. Consequently, the prices of securities is a correct representation of all information available at any time.
Weak:
Not possible to earn superior profits (risk adjusted) based on the knowledge of past prices and returns.
Semi-strong:
Not possible to earn superior profits using all information publicly available.
Strong:
Not possible to earn superior profit using all publicly and inside information.
The CAPM describes the relationship between market risks and expected return for a security i (also called cost of equity), E(Re_i):
Re_i = Rf – Bi(Rm – Rf)
With:
Rf = Risk free rate (typically government bond rate)
Rm = Expected return for the whole market
Bi = The volatility risk of the security i compared to the whole market
(Rm – Rf) is consequently the market risk premium
According to the EMH, for a well-diversified portfolio, expected returns can only reflect those of the market as a whole. Consequently, in the CAPM formula, It would involves that for a diversified-enough portfolio: β = 1 so Re = Rm
Investors want to value companies before making investment decisions.
A typical way to do so is to use the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) method:
See also: Prospect theory, disposition effect, heuristic, framing, mental accounting, Home bias, representativeness, conservatism, availability, greater fool theory, self attribution theory, anchoring, ambiguity aversion, winner's curse, managerial miscalibration and misconception, Equity premium puzzle, market anomalies, excess volatility, Bubbles, herding, limited liabilities, Fama French three 3 factors model.
In the world of the commodity futures markets, no subject generates more interest and questions than spread trading. A spread combines both a long and a short position put on at the same time in related futures contracts.
StockTakers continues our charity to small investors of our proprietary information, because we can, and prove it! Patience and slow trading, relaxed even, our risk averse method wins over the longer term. These public portfolios run by our methods prove you can keep your capital safe, liquid and make exceptional AlphaSmart gains as we do prove, because we can, and so, you can too!
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook
1. Fake Markets: How Artificial Money Flows Kill Data Dependency, Affect Market Functioning and Change the Structure of the Market
Hard data ceased to be a driver for markets, valuation metrics for bonds and equities which held valid for over a century are now deemed secondary. Narratives and money flows trump hard data, overwhelmingly.
‘Fake Markets’ are defined as markets where the magnitude and duration of artificial flows from global Central Banks or passive investment vehicles have managed to overwhelm and narcotize data-dependency and macro factors. A stuporous state of durable, un-volatile over-valuation, arrested activity, unconsciousness produced by the influence of artificial money flows.
- Passive Flows: The Prehistoric Elephant In The Room
- ETFs Are Taking Over Markets
- The Impact of Passive Investors on Active Investors: the Induction Trap
- How Narratives Evolve To Cover For Fake Markets
- Defendit Numerus: There is Safety in Numbers
- What Could We Get Wrong
2. Be Short, Be Patient, Be Ready
Markets driven by Central Banks, passive investment vehicles and retail investors are unfit to price any premium for any risk. If we are right and this is indeed a bubble (both in equity and in bonds), it will eventually bust; it is only a matter of time. The higher it goes, the higher it can go, as more swathes of private investors are pulled in. The more violently it can subsequently bust.
The risk of a combined bust of equity and bonds is a plausible one. It matters all the more as 90%+ of investors still work under the basic framework of a balanced portfolio, exposed in different proportions to equity and bonds, both long. That includes risk parity funds, a leveraged version of balanced portfolio. That includes alternative risk premia funds, a nice commercial disguise for a mostly long-only beta risk, where premia is extracted from record rich markets that made those premia tautologically minuscule.
Today we are covering the most impact full ideas I have discovered since taking a closer look at asset allocation following the mkt downturns in the fall of ’08 and this past spring. We are going to look at 1)theory and strategy, 2)fat tails and fractals, 3) a secular market perspective and then I’ll show you the opportunities available to improve and protect a typical moderate aggressive strategic allocation portfolio of 70% equities and 30% debt.
3 The first rationale theory tied to the bell curve and market efficiency originated in 1900 in a paper called Theory of Speculation by Louis Bachelier. The paper analyzed changes in French bonds and was not considered to be a monumental work but it did receive “honorable mention” by the University of Paris. Little did Bachelier know that his theory on uncertainty would be picked up 52 yrs later by Harry Markowitz in his paper on Security Selection and Modern Portfolio Theory. Later Bachelier’s theory on probability, chance, and “fair game” would be resurrected in 1956 by MIT student Paul A. Samuelson in his thesis on option pricing. Sharpe then developed the Equilibrium Theory and CAPM. Then came Eugene Fama with his theories on the random walk of securities and the inclusion of information into security prices. Later came Fischer Black and Merton Scholes with their landmark theory on pricing options. Much of this work with the exception of Black & Scholes, has culminated in popular models and applications such as strategic asset allocation where as we know the primary risk and return focus is std dev and relative returns. From the book Unexpected Returns, Ed Easterling does a masterful job of describing SAA as a sailing approach to investing which does well during secular bull markets.
3 The main industry dialogue is the controversy surrounding CAPM, MPT and Strategic Asset Allocation derived from the harsh reality that the theory and strategy have been turned on it’s head as a consequence of market meltdowns and what some are identifying as a secular bear in equities that started in 2000. For example, our moderate plus clients with an expected time horizon of 10 years have experienced lower returns and much higher risk compared to their more conservative peers.
3 For advisors, the primary discourse today lies in the dilemma caused by an increase in correlations across asset classes during the equity market meltdowns of ’08 and ‘09. While it is true that alternatives do act like good diversifiers and reduce standard deviation over long holding periods, the reality is they proved to be of no help in the fall of ’08 when all asset classes moved down in tandem. As you can see the largest int’l bond, precious metals, bond and commodities funds had enormous spikes in their 12 month correlations. We’ll see later how Sallie Krawcheck head of BOA/Merrill’s advisors succinctly frames the new asset allocation paradigm which get’s to the heart of the correlation and drawdown issue.
3 While it may be commonly thought that treasuries would be a safe haven when equities experience drawdowns of 10% or more, these stats prove otherwise. The reality is that using a 12 mo equity/treasury correlation trigger of zero and 0.20 or below for 36 mo correlations then since ’26 you would have been wrong 38% and 42% of the time respectively for draw downs of 10% or more.
3 Watson Wyatt recently re-defined risk management. They now believe risk mgmt must identify risks beyond normal distributions and 2 std deviations.
More on the current state of asset allocation…here’s Ren Cheng, the developer and former CIO of the Fidelity Freedom funds cracking open MPT, the bell curve and emphasizing that fat tails now need to be considered more often than previously… Lynette DeWitt, research director of subadvisory markets and lifecycle funds for Financial Research Corporation (FRC) comments here on the fate of target-date funds…
3 David Blitzer from S&P comments here on the disconnect of the normal distribution bell curve and investment results during the financial crisis. Next we are going to look at theories derived from observation or what David Blitzer defines as “reality.”
3 After the carnage of the market meltdown, I decided to take a hard look at strategic asset allocation. I discovered that there is a wealth of “irrational” theories out there that are at the heart of some very successful market timing, trend following and hedge strategies. One of the oldest is the Elliott Wave Principle which was developed by Ralph N. Elliott in the late 30s who discovered through observation while studying the Dow that equity prices move in a repetitious pattern with “comprehensive exactitude.” Later on Benoit Mandelbrot who began studying income changes while working at IBM came across price data on cotton and observed that changes in cotton prices follow an imitation pattern much like the patterns found in nature. He also discovered that security price changes that fall outside of the traditional 2 std dev bell curve can be quite large and can have a devasting impact on a portfolio. Eventually Mandelbrot developed Fractal Geometry and the term Fat Tails was coined. Behavioral Economics was first developed in the 70s with 2 theories developed from observations that investors react more to price and direction irrespective of fundamentals and investors consider losses to be more painful than gains of equal nominal amounts. Then in ’78, Robert Prechter, a market technician using the Elliott Wave Principle, started making equity market calls that led to a super cycle bull market call just before the ’82 secular bull began. Prechter has since theorized that changes in equity prices proceed changes in social moods with his theory of Socionomics. All these theories can be found in use in one form or another among the following strategies of market timing/technical analysis, trend following, tactical asset allocation and hedging. All these strategies which aim to protect or mitigate drawdowns and loss of principal fall into what Easterling defines as a rowing approach to investing which are appropriate during secular bear markets.
These 4 books have had the most influence on my investment perspective with respect to fat tail risk. The first one written by former MIT professor Charles Kindleberger provides detail on what happens when a mania, panic, and crash occurs all of which mirrors the run-up in equities thru 2000 and then thru ’07 and it’s subsequent downturn. The second one was written by U. of Maryland professor, Carmen Reinhart and Harvard professor, Ken Rogoff. It does what Kindleberger’s does but in addition to narrative it also supplies the numbers surrounding financial crisis’. The third one written by Yale professor Benoit Mandelbrot centers on the fundamental risks associated with Modern Portfolio Theory and the use of the bell curve in financial modeling and engineering. The last one relates to the problems associated with humans when it comes to protecting ourselves against what Taleb defines as a black swan or an unforeseen event. The sales rank is indicated to highlight how widely read the subject of financial risk has become among readers.
Here is what professor Kindleberger discovered…
While much of the narrative on financial crises found in the Reinhart & Rogoff book is similar to what professor Kindleberger details in his book…Reinhart & Rogoff back-up their narratives with cold hard data across both developed and emerging economies. Here are 3 main points to recognize.
Professor Mandelbrot discovered… His main point is… “ We have been mis-measuring risk.” “ The odds of financial ruin in a free, global-market economy have been grossly underestimated.” “ The deepest and most realistic finance book ever published.” Nassim Nicholas Taleb on B. Mandelbrot’s The Misbehavior of Markets
RN Elliott discovered a 5 wave followed by 3 wave fractal with 11 alternative patterns in observing changes in the Dow. Considered to be the granddaddy of technical analysis, the most recent completion of a triple zig zag from the March lows is said to be the completion of wave 2 up. Wave 3 down according to the EWI people will be of historic proportions.
Taleb defines Black Swans in his widely regarded book on risk… He outlines how humans suffer from…
I find that these definitions on secular market cycles are as good as any.
In July ’09, I started to explore whether others believed we were in a Secular Bear Market. Here are some notable views. More than anything else I believe it is profound to see that all of these market participants have a technical and secular viewpoint. Note: Elliott Wave International accurately predicted the start of a secular bear 10 years ago.
Using a moderate aggressive allocation example of 70% equities and 30% debt, we’ll now look at how we can utilize some simple allocation approaches to guard against primary and secular bear mkts and to add alpha during bull mkts.
There’s plenty of existing research on how to enhance strategic asset allocation performance…however I’ve identified what I think are the best papers and factors to enhance performance. The 1 st set of papers are focused on improving performance by avoiding losses. The 1 st paper identifies the 10 month moving avg of the S&P 500 as the premier trend following factor to identify a change in a primary market cycle. We already know about the VIX however the other CBOE index that is used as a contrarian factor for measuring market extremes is the Put/Call Ratio. This factor is used typically as a secondary factor for making market timing decisions. The 2 nd set of papers focus on adding alpha. The 1 st paper identifies the real fed funds rate as a factor that can be used to overweight small/mid caps. This factor is attributable to the “Don’t Fight The Fed” rationale that was coined by Marty Zweig many years ago when he wrote his best selling book Winning on Wall Street. The book Style Investing written by the former CIO of Merrill Lynch outlines a growth value approach to equity investing. In addition to the book on style investing I discovered a paper which details how earnings growth mirrors equity returns and supports the use of “Growth At A Reasonable Price” or what is called GARP. The last paper supports using GDP for making country allocation decisions.
To measure the effectiveness of these factors in a portfolio I compared tactical allocations within a 70% equity 30% debt strategy against a strategic allocation of 70/30. For all the factors, the tactical allocations to equities was capped at 70%. What I found most appealing was the loss avoidance factors increased returns but also reduced risk and increased sharpe while the alpha factors enhanced return with small increases in risk.
While dynamic asset allocation is commonly confused with tactical, for our purposes I will consider an example of our current strategic approach with small and tactical adjustments.
Specifically, the dynamic example shifts 15% from equities to debt when all 3 loss avoidance factors are triggered. Outlined in chapter 10 of Unexpected Returns, Professor Easterling details how the need to become defensive during market downturns and describes the asset allocation approach during this period as a rowing approach.
Here’s a more granular view in which the allocation becomes defensive when the 3 rowing factors are triggered and then becomes more opportunistic when the one sailing factor, the real fed funds rate, turns negative. So when the rowing triggers are off and the real fed funds rate turns negative the small/mid cap allocation is increased from 10% to 20%. The rationale behind a lower strategic allocation to small/mid cap is to improve risk adjusted returns…historically the modest increase in return with small/mid caps is not supported by the increase in standard deviation…large caps simply have better risk adjusted returns.
Utilizing both rowing and sailing factors…below is the variation among a dynamic, strategic and 100% equities allocation over a period which includes a secular bull mkt thru July 2000 and a subsequent bear since. With a focus on ending wealth value and mitigating loss…you’ll notice the benefit of the dynamic portfolio over pure strategic and an all equity portfolio is substantial. Additionally you’ll notice significant improvements in the return and sharpe.
The dynamic portfolio outperformed strategic in this bull period by over 117 bps.
And as expected dynamic outperforms strategic in the bear period by 178 bps.
Here are the rolling return comparisons…
The key to maintaining a high Morningstar rating is primarily protecting to the downside and secondarily capturing the upside.
Sallie Krawcheck head of the BOA/Merrill retail brokerage sales force sets the bar for how her advisors and clients will now approach asset allocation…I thought it was interesting that she identified both standard deviation, the primary risk of strategic asset allocation and draw downs, the primary risk associated with dynamic and tactical asset allocation as part of the asset allocation equation.
Here we have the heads of distribution at the 4 largest broker-dealers recently spelling out what their advisors want. Followed by Strategic Insight’s summary of what product innovation means.